her voice is the ordinary one. Nothing dynamic about it at all. Crackling at the high end with no punch at all. Boring really. That voice is a dime a dozen. Just because you shout over some one doesn't make you better. Sometimes it's the softer touches that rue the day. A lesson I doubt Carly could ever learn.
Country is the easiest to sing? I disagree with you on that brother... Country genre is one of the most complicated sing and play.. But I agree that Carly must've won..
@@aragornthexiv4187 This song was suited tens times better for her tone, of course she'll sound better (no to mention that she is a better singer than him, but not necessarily a better performer)
The thing is.. country is real, not about shaking your arse, or lip syncing. and I cannot stand the synthesized fake beat bs that passes for music these days. If the music doesn't get my attention in about 10 seconds... I don't care what the singing is.... it's not music.
This makes no sense.... I just realized she didn't win that season. I didn't know this tate guy existed at all. Till just now. And I could've done without that knowledge. "Nothing is true, everything is permitted." Basically they should make that the motto for this show.
You can see it in Spears face that it was over. She looked so sad. You can see Brit feel her pain. And you can see they both knew it was over. She was almost in tears poor thing. So young to feel this kind of pain.
I mean his voice is really good but it literally sounds like every other country singer. Carly had a very unique voice for her genre. She was also only 13 and he was way over 30 im guessing. She was a powerhouse for her age. A prodigy if you will. Not a fair competition at all. Country singers seem to always have the upper hand in these shows for some reason.
@doogleaelf Even if she was older, she objectively can sing it. It's not an unpopular opinion to think that she was a great singer. She struggled on some songs throughout the competition, like everyone else, but she did amazing with Hallelujah and this song. We can agree to disagree, I guess. But I think she sang it better, and country singers seem to have the upper hand in these competitions.
Na minha opinião, devido ao fato dela ser muito jovem, 14 anos se não me engano, eles viram que a carreira dela era muito promissora. Diferente da dele então, resolveram estender o prêmio pra ele, tendo em vista que ela tinha muito mais chances de fazer sucesso. É um palpite meu kkk mas nem se compara. O talento dela sequer pode ser comparado ao dele, ela está anos luz na frente dele. Também discordei muito do resultado na época!! Ainda discordo..
The best never wins because they don’t want to tie them up with all the winners conditions. She’s way better off coming runner up and free to record whatever, wherever, with or without whoever💃💃
CMON SRSLY? Carly obviously has a better singing voice. Tate only knows how to sing Country genre, which is easy. And who the fuck still listens to country genres nowadays? And if she lost becuz she wasn't 'powerful' enough, i would blame the judges. Like i mean... Its their first time performing.
Every week they competed Tate came in second to Carly, so how the F, did he win? He sounds like any other drunk karaoke singer trying to sing country. This season ended in a disgrace, shameful, if they're going to be doing this in future shows they should retire.
Well, I'm pretty sure that Carly might get more famous. Fifth Harmony got second and they are very famous worldwide now. And which company wants to work with Tate? He sings Country genre, I mean CMON its 2016! Sing some Pop dude.
ya but who is the real winner? everyone knows who she is and not him lol and she has recording contracts ;p once it comes down to 2 people there are no losers really..... look at the voice.... adam signed a *non winner* lol
This sums up the statesment “life isn’t fair”. When a guy who can’t sing and is so out of tune wins a talent competition against someone who can sing and sing better than most singers. “Life ain’t fair, baby. Yeehaw!”
Yes, I agree she should've won, but she was very young and I'm sure others knew her talent and the people knew she had a chance. Tate is just as good, and he's older, so he probably got the majority because he could handle it.
Kylie Marie i understand that but it doesn't have to depend on age, if so this is discrimination, everybody by any means whould be equal Also what in the world, carly rose for sure should have won
She cannot sing... music execs care about talent. not how young you are. Folks gotta stop being fooled by the age. Close your eyes and listen to the song... Everything else is just bs..
I think they just had him win because he had a family and was a lot older so this would be the best it for him, but she has a whole mega career in front of her
Carly's bloody amazing .. but listening to her sing this... n I remember how bloody good miley is. Another level. When she was more hannah and less nutcase...
He only won because country is supposedly America's music and they always go for the more popular genre and look of the artist and not the actual talent
Nunca vou superar Carly ter perdido pra ele, sei q o country lá é muito difundido, mas o talento dessa menina é assombroso, e essa música não ficou nada boa na voz dele!
Bro Tate is a good singer but there is no way he beat her with this finale battle she definitely should have won his voice is generic country and doesn’t really add “wow” factor her voice has so much range and it makes you feel the song it was rigged 100 percent
Um Tate sounds like me and my friends. She sounds like someone you'd pay to go a concert to hear. Every dad in America sings like Tate. You just squeeze your throat and then say the words somewhat musically and let the band do all the work
My dad couldn't sing like Tate. Nor can I or any of my friends. I think you're just crushing on Carly. She is amazing though. Here he is singing with no band. Only a guitar. Sounds great to me, for a country music singer. ruclips.net/video/8TbWAxgq1eE/видео.html
Carly should had won. Tate couldn’t hit those high notes, that’s why Carly did most of the song. Honestly in being fair , Carly should have won easily, but there’s a lesson to be learned here. LIFE isn’t always fair.
![Carly Rose Sonenclar - Final [03] (Legendado)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fZsN5J9SBSk/mqdefault.jpg)
![ARGENTINA vs. PERÚ [1-0] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 12](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xtI25ENDDSY/mqdefault.jpg)
He sounds like a good country singer. She sounds like a rare talent.
It’s so sad they gave it to him before her smfh country singers always gets the vote
OMG I'm still mad Carly didn't win
She tried harder and was better
her voice is the ordinary one. Nothing dynamic about it at all. Crackling at the high end with no punch at all. Boring really. That voice is a dime a dozen. Just because you shout over some one doesn't make you better. Sometimes it's the softer touches that rue the day. A lesson I doubt Carly could ever learn.
HOW did she not win?!
Him
THIS PROGRAM IS STILL
Jenni & Sammy who won?!
Emanuel Ray Tate Stevens did. He did not deserve to, Carly for sure has the better voice. And Carly tried so much more than Tate.
Her voice cracks like a 100 times she was to young at the time rates voice is more consistent.
I remember watching this with my dad, we were pissed when Tate won
OMG ME AND MY SISTER TOO 😭😭😭😭😭 We hated Tate, we cried, screamed, hit the TV and almost got depressed when she didn't win, f*ucking Tate Stevens!
Giovanni André why hate someone over a tv show and a democratic decision by the poeple? Very Sad, Tate seems nice
Why? Tate is hands down the better singer. Carly really can't sing worth a damn in my opinion.
@@doogleaelfdelulu
Carly is real winner .... i hate this stupid result
why you didnt vote at that time? they give you time right?
Hantono Shi how do you know she didn’t vote for her?🙄
She was awful singing Celine Diones My Heart will go on. Tate was average & they both sucked here.
Public voted, end of story
I would have liked her to sing this song alone :(
His voice is ordinary. Hers is extraordinary.
extraordinary boring and a dime a dozen. She has no range. BOOOORRRRRRIIIIINNNNNNNGGGGG
@@doogleaelfjealous af
She sounds way better!! She should have won the X factor ...
Delusional... where has her career gone from this show ... no where .... why ... she cannot sing.
Carly Rose Sonenclar deserved more to win x factor 2012. Anyway...
He was never competition for Carly.She is the real winer to me and to millions of people.
hey, look above the chest ok.
@@doogleaelfBro, she has 13 years old in this. Disgusting.
@@doogleaelfBro, she has 13 years old in this. Digusting.
@@Hatyso anyone thinking that bimbo can sing is disgusting. Dime a dozen voice. No range, crackles at the high end... boring.
Country is the easiest genre to sing! This guy proved it because he can't sing anything else. We all know she should have won!
Country is the easiest to sing? I disagree with you on that brother... Country genre is one of the most complicated sing and play.. But I agree that Carly must've won..
@@aragornthexiv4187 •
All I gotta sing is Howdy do boom easy.
@@aragornthexiv4187 This song was suited tens times better for her tone, of course she'll sound better (no to mention that she is a better singer than him, but not necessarily a better performer)
Yea try singing Carrie Underwood,Jennifer Nettles,Martina McBride,Leann Rimes,Ronnie DUnn,Alabama,Chris Stapleton.........
The thing is.. country is real, not about shaking your arse, or lip syncing. and I cannot stand the synthesized fake beat bs that passes for music these days. If the music doesn't get my attention in about 10 seconds... I don't care what the singing is.... it's not music.
I love this song!!! I loved Hanna Montana ever since I was just 4 years old! this song really speaks to me, its a part of me! I love you Carly!
This makes no sense.... I just realized she didn't win that season. I didn't know this tate guy existed at all. Till just now. And I could've done without that knowledge. "Nothing is true, everything is permitted." Basically they should make that the motto for this show.
Carly carries that song all the through the very end
Carries lt like the whooping cough. I enjoyed Tate singing it... Felt like fingernails across the chalkboard when carly opened her pie hole.
OH MYYYYY. why the actual heck did he win? There were so many better singers. Not trying to be a hater✌
I’m pretty sure it’s because the entire south of the USA voted for him
You can see it in Spears face that it was over. She looked so sad.
You can see Brit feel her pain. And you can see they both knew it was over. She was almost in tears poor thing. So young to feel this kind of pain.
Why are there so many comments saying she was robbed. I thought this was decided by public vote. Blame yourself America...
how come Carly isn´t in the media? i wan to see more of her work :O
She decided to finish school first and then concentrate on the singing career :) And she also performs on Broadway :)
cause she cannot sing.
Her and Laura murano look alike
Carly should've won!
wahwahwahwah
Two CRAZY Sisters you have to remember that the climb is supposed to be sung by a girl not a guy with a deep voice
I mean his voice is really good but it literally sounds like every other country singer. Carly had a very unique voice for her genre. She was also only 13 and he was way over 30 im guessing. She was a powerhouse for her age. A prodigy if you will. Not a fair competition at all. Country singers seem to always have the upper hand in these shows for some reason.
I'm sick of these teeny boppers getting points because of their age. She is a very average singer with no range. PERIOD.
I'm sick of this crap of extra points for age. Either you can sing it or you cannot. And Carly cannot.
@doogleaelf Even if she was older, she objectively can sing it. It's not an unpopular opinion to think that she was a great singer. She struggled on some songs throughout the competition, like everyone else, but she did amazing with Hallelujah and this song. We can agree to disagree, I guess. But I think she sang it better, and country singers seem to have the upper hand in these competitions.
Nothing is right in this world, Carly deserve to win, but.... That Tate is not even half on GREAT VOICE of Carly, 13 and "little Diva". Shame!!!
tissues?
The better singer won.
Eu nunca vou conseguir acreditar que ela perdeu cara!
Fizeram a podre com ela , afffffffff
Eu aceito até hoje , homiiii !!!!
ELLA ES LA REAL GANADORA
2018 and this is still the best battle
HOW DID SHE NOT WIN
simple. She has no talent.
Carly canta milhões de vezes mais e melhor que o seu concorrente, como é possível ela ter perdido
Na minha opinião, devido ao fato dela ser muito jovem, 14 anos se não me engano, eles viram que a carreira dela era muito promissora. Diferente da dele então, resolveram estender o prêmio pra ele, tendo em vista que ela tinha muito mais chances de fazer sucesso. É um palpite meu kkk mas nem se compara. O talento dela sequer pode ser comparado ao dele, ela está anos luz na frente dele. Também discordei muito do resultado na época!! Ainda discordo..
E também não justifica, ela deveria ter vencido!!
The best never wins because they don’t want to tie them up with all the winners conditions.
She’s way better off coming runner up and free to record whatever, wherever, with or without whoever💃💃
2023 e ate hj nao entendo como a carly rose nao ganho! 😢
Se ela tivesse ganhado estava aí até hj, esse cara nunca lançou uma música!
Carly Rose, was the program better and lost, these programs most often the best fall by the wayside, and good ends up winning
esse programa é pura armação o mundo Deseja Carly 🌹 ❤
She’s infinitely more talented than him but that said, they sound really good together. It was beautiful.
Hahahahahahaha are You freaking kidding me ? 😂😑
Omg why did tate win?
Oh my gosh hahahahaha 😂
CMON SRSLY?
Carly obviously has a better singing voice. Tate only knows how to sing Country genre, which is easy. And who the fuck still listens to country genres nowadays? And if she lost becuz she wasn't 'powerful' enough, i would blame the judges. Like i mean... Its their first time performing.
so the name , your just a sketch that can be erased
Do you know what else should be erased? Your grammar...
Sketch Boy a lot of people country is still one of the most selling genres of music.
THANK YOU
Every week they competed Tate came in second to Carly, so how the F, did he win? He sounds like any other drunk karaoke singer trying to sing country. This season ended in a disgrace, shameful, if they're going to be doing this in future shows they should retire.
Point of correction Carly always came 2nd when they competed
Well, I'm pretty sure that Carly might get more famous. Fifth Harmony got second and they are very famous worldwide now. And which company wants to work with Tate? He sings Country genre, I mean CMON its 2016! Sing some Pop dude.
You mean they got third? Carly got second
I thought she won... ?!?!?
Ela deveria ter ganhado, Todo mundo sabe.
5H and carly deserve the top 2
Strange result, she should have won ..
ya but who is the real winner? everyone knows who she is and not him lol and she has recording contracts ;p once it comes down to 2 people there are no losers really..... look at the voice.... adam signed a *non winner* lol
This was the last X-Factor season i watched and it was because some how this dude got the win over Carly. I still dont get it.
This sums up the statesment “life isn’t fair”.
When a guy who can’t sing and is so out of tune wins a talent competition against someone who can sing and sing better than most singers.
“Life ain’t fair, baby. Yeehaw!”
I love to listen to Tates deep voice.
tate won
proof democracy voting and people are failing to produce the best carlyrose was 1000 times better.
Carly merecia ter ganho!
She reminds me of Camila from 5 harmony !
Carly should have won, she is so amazing.
At the time, Tate had something special about him. Now that i look back at it. Theres no way Carly should have lost smh..🤦♂️
Carly should not of made it out of the 1st round. Very average voice in my opinion. No range whatsoever.
She SHOULD HAVE WON!! Blame the public.
Yes, I agree she should've won, but she was very young and I'm sure others knew her talent and the people knew she had a chance. Tate is just as good, and he's older, so he probably got the majority because he could handle it.
Kylie Marie i understand that but it doesn't have to depend on age, if so this is discrimination, everybody by any means whould be equal
Also what in the world, carly rose for sure should have won
As a musician/singer, I cannot believe she did not win..sad
Father and Daughter 👏🏻
Sad when the 13 year old girls voice is better and overpowers the older guys voice(the winner)
She sounds like Miley, but she has a stronger voice
What? I didn't know this before! Seriously? This thin, shaking, singing through the nose voice won??? This could only happen in the USA!
Carly is amazing
cara, ela deveria ter ganhando!!! 😭😭😭
Eu lembro de ter ficado muito p da vida... e quando recordo disso sinto a maior raiva.
The reason Tate won, he would've selled albums, etc. Carly is a really good singer, i'm surprised no signed her
She cannot sing... music execs care about talent. not how young you are. Folks gotta stop being fooled by the age. Close your eyes and listen to the song... Everything else is just bs..
Assisti aqui no Brasil essa temporada e torci desde o início para o Tate Stevens que foi o vencedor, mas nunca mais ouvi falar dele. O que aconteceu?
torci pra ele do início ao fim, acho que ele venceu no fim das contas por ela ter uma vida inteira pela frente.
Carly is clearly a far stronger vocalist than Tate! She should have definitely won!!
He was ok...but his vocal range seemed limited
Whos tate?! Oh the guy who won the xfactor and a 5 million record, and never used it, and he sounds really bad( just keeping it real)
wtf how did he win over her ..this confirm the problem between the judges and carly's family
I think they just had him win because he had a family and was a lot older so this would be the best it for him, but she has a whole mega career in front of her
1:03 - 1:07 ♥.
1:39 - 1:45 💛
Carly forever you’ll be the winner no go listen to her new song “birds and bees”
Am I the only one who really appreciates his voice?
Yes
It’s a nice voice, but she should have won
This song doesn’t do him justice, but his ”Tomorrow” was sensational
they really put two of them in a country song🙃guess who is a better fit?
CARLY SHOULDVE WON
One note billy Vs Angel of range
Don't they decide who wins by people voting and not the judges?!
it would’ve sounded so much better with her by herself
carly campeã do coração
Voz dele mais do mesmo ..essa menina era extraordinária infelizmente não ganhou foi bem injusto
Carly's bloody amazing .. but listening to her sing this... n I remember how bloody good miley is. Another level. When she was more hannah and less nutcase...
Joe McElderry owns this song and no one else comes close.
Torci para o Tate desde a hora que ele entrou. É o tipo de pessoa que tem uma aura diferente. Sou team Tate forever 💛
He only won because country is supposedly America's music and they always go for the more popular genre and look of the artist and not the actual talent
Nunca vou superar Carly ter perdido pra ele, sei q o country lá é muito difundido, mas o talento dessa menina é assombroso, e essa música não ficou nada boa na voz dele!
To this day I don't understand why this girl didn't win??? I wonder what she is doing today?? I haven't heard anything. 😕
Shitt this girl should be famous
this winner
Bro Tate is a good singer but there is no way he beat her with this finale battle she definitely should have won his voice is generic country and doesn’t really add “wow” factor her voice has so much range and it makes you feel the song it was rigged 100 percent
She sounded so much better then him
Tate was awesome! And so much more polished and ready to win this ,and he deserved it.
Lol stop now before you say another thing that is very ignorant and untrue.
Tate Stevens sucked and no one will ever believe he won the real winner is Carly or fifth harmony
Boo
how did this old man beat carly, she is the rightful winner
Carly or Beatrice should have won... And Beatrice should have had better songs to win
I thought the comments were exaggerating, then I saw the video and I also don't get how she didn't win. Like did he pull strings or something???
Um Tate sounds like me and my friends. She sounds like someone you'd pay to go a concert to hear. Every dad in America sings like Tate. You just squeeze your throat and then say the words somewhat musically and let the band do all the work
My dad couldn't sing like Tate. Nor can I or any of my friends. I think you're just crushing on Carly. She is amazing though.
Here he is singing with no band. Only a guitar. Sounds great to me, for a country music singer.
ruclips.net/video/8TbWAxgq1eE/видео.html
Watching this in 2018 and I’m so fucking mad
Carly should had won. Tate couldn’t hit those high notes, that’s why Carly did most of the song. Honestly in being fair , Carly should have won easily, but there’s a lesson to be learned here. LIFE isn’t always fair.
What? 2 sings well but Carly its better! Im shoked
carly
She was robbed
She’s carrying this song on her back btw
Estaba te arregladoooo
I see why he won, he sounds amazing, but holy shit she’s way better. He’s slightly harsher but because the song is country, he fits in better I guess
Tate also sings super good, for a boy is difficult to reach that notes
5H and Carly Lost to a OLD man? (He can sing lol)
He should of been eliminated!