I love all the scenes when the Doctor chooses the peaceful route. I don't think anyone else could truthfully say that they wouldn't shoot cobb under those circumstances. That's why the Doctor is so awesome. Because he can preach peace and act upon it.
guys the whole point of ten’s and later nine’s anti-gun/anti-genocide thing was because of their regrets with the time war. it’s not a lack of continuity, it’s specific to these particular incarnations of the doctor.
@@archiereilly419 They mean 9 in the later episodes of series 1. And although 9 never explicitly said about his no gun rule, it’s implied in Dalek and The Parting of the ways, when the Doctor realised killing the Dalek or the Dalek fleet makes him become dangerous and a vengeful man, like the Doctor of the time war
@@qt.pie.alfred894 No, the Doctor doesn't inherently hate guns. It's only the new fake Doctor that has a strict no gun policy. The Doctor has always been more of a pacifist and completely against unnecessary violence of any kind. However he is aware that at times, violence is necessary and cannot be avoided. For example the the fake Doctor, she despises guns and wont even let her companions have weaponry on them for self defence. 9, 10, 11 and 12 however weren't as strict on this sort of thing and were mostly fine with the use of guns in self defence. Just the Doctor himself didn't like using a gun because he didn't want to anticipate a violent situation. For example when he refused to take the gun from Wilf at first it wasn't because he was completely against guns. It was because especially in this situation he did not want to have to take someone's life. He took the gun because he realised that this time he simply might not have a choice, although he did take the first alternative he could.
@@rindoubaka1574 I never said he hated guns, and perhaps I could’ve been a bit clearer. That the no gun rule is for himself. The Doctor recognises that sometimes he has to kill or let the monster die because there is no other way. But the Doctor refuses to use a gun because it’s cowardly, he’d be tempted to kill anything that seemed like a threat and he refuses to become a soldier/warrior like he was in the time war. So when Tennants Doctor took the gun from Wilfred or when Capaldi’s Doctor took the gun off the time lord captain, it’s meant to symbolise the extreme choice that Doctor had to make. The Doctor title means to never be cruel and never be cowardly, and using a gun goes against that. So when he’s with unit for example, he’s okay if they use guns as a last resort but he’s not okay using a gun himself
@@Gutssssss666 I don't hate him by any stretch, but from a canonical perspective, he was quite brutal, especially near the end with The Time Lord Victorius
As a father of two daughters this scene hit me especially hard, harder than some of the more well known emotional scenes of tennents time as the doctor.
10 is amazing in the moments when that cheerful, easygoing facade slips and you remember that he's a being who's seen SO much and yet still CHOOSES to be good, EVEN when it's clear there's SO much darkness building in him
He was this close to making a step towards becoming like the master, killing an unarmed man. Of course, he still broke the laws of time to save Adelaide and her crew in the “Waters of Mars”, but murder was something else entirely
Duudes, duudes. The difference here is that the old general guy was no longer a threat, so killing him would be purely for vengeance, as opposed to all the villains he offed to stop yet more shit from happening; That, an he was deliberately trying to make an example here. He definitely has some overcompensation issues going on.
metalmugen when? Also, this is violence in vengeance, which would not save anyone. There's a massive difference between that and violence to save someone.
>Make the foundation of this society "A man who never would." "Oh god, Steve, take me to the hospital! I'm going to die soon!" "I'm a man who never would."
When the doctor pointed the gun at the guy's head, My immediate thought was " Hello, My name is the doctor. You killed my daughter. Prepare to die." lol
This was a seriously beautiful scene. I mean, I'm sure all of us wanted him to do it.. but then we're shown this instead, the Doctor's humanity and him setting an example. Slight problem though: Why does Martha know about regeneration? He came back to life once or twice with her but never actually regenerated with her obviously.
This is why Doctor Who is so amazing, The Doctor always has a genuine lesson. he reminds us who we are, and what we stand for. and he makes sure we stay true to that image.
At the moment, I don’t know how many years it has been since this moment. But this sentiment resonates right to the centre of my being. I looked it up tonight because, more than anything, I wish I could find a man that never would.... I think doctor who may have ruined me for the real world 😅
If there ever was a time, he would break his promise this was it, he has seen so much and feel so much pain for it, but the loss of a child, the other times he has felt a lost doesn't even come close to it
People just seem to forget this is his second daughter that’s probably why he cared for her so much when he’d known her a day he’s already had a kid and so just having one now he knows it’ll be great (context the first doctors first companion was his granddaughter meaning he had a kid already)
@@lochness5524Oh He wouldn't he does things 10 times worse. And then goes power-mad because that's his character, he gets progressively worse. He was a more human doctor and as such, he had our flaws
Brilliant scene. There's just no other way to put it. In addition, the score was timed ABSOLUTELY perfectly. The trumpet solo from 'The Doctor Forever' was the PERFECT line to use at 3:16.
“i never would. Have you got that I. Never. Would! When you start this new world, of Human and Hath. Remember that! MAKE THE FOUNDATION OF THIS SOCIETY, A MAN WHO NEVER WOULD!” This is why 10 is my favourite Doctor
The difference is when he's killed Daleks, or Cybermen, or Angels it has been done as a last resort so that he can save himself and those with him, where as in this scene it would be a cold blooded murder
So then he's not a cold blooded murderer. Except for with Daleks, but they'd kill everyone if left unchecked so they don't count. And the Cybermen, but death is honestly the only thing that'll stop them from converting people. And the Sileeee...Oh. The Silents were pretty much space confessional priests, so the Doctor made humankind genocidal towards them for the acts of a splinter group. Now I wanna know why Clara and every human born after the Apollo landing shown on screen didn't murder the Silents in Time of the Doctor.
That would be perfect if humanity stayed on earth, but they won't. Anyone in the universe who sees that clip will be compelled to kill innocent Silents on sight.
FullmetalHeart20 True... but I've never seen it, so it'll be more like a few killings here and there. But you do have a point. (But if it's just them, that basically the same as not genocide at all because... wait, what were we talking about again? Oh yeah, the Doctor has never actually committed genocide! Anybody know why those episodes in series 6 were missing so many parts?)
What is the name of the song played when The Doctor says "he never would." It has a strong brass section playing the melody and it has been played in other episodes (such as when Donna begs The Doctor to save someone in Pompeii)
This was probably incredibly easy for Tennant to act this scene, he was probably picturing his actual wife (jenny's actress) dying in his arms and the rage he would feel irl if the man was standing there
The first time I watched this episode it was around 4 am because that was the only time I had and so my roommate was sleeping in the other bed as I was sobbing uncontrollably into my pillow...yeah
Ten: Pacifist, forgiver. Also Ten: Condemns family of blood foreve with the fury of a time lord. lol but really, I think cos it was his daughter who wanted so much to learn from him, that he felt like he had to set the best example in her memory. A fatherly moment.
The 5th and 6th Doctors killed multiple Cybermen, the 7th manipulated Davros into destroying Skaro, the 3rd shot and killed a few Ogrons, and generally wasn’t opposed to violence (being the Doctor to introduce Venusian Aikido), and that’s just the classic Doctors. 9 teleported Cassandra back, and definitely knew what would happen (she didn’t actually die, but he didn’t know.), and even sticking just with 10, he killed the leader of the Sicorax within his first day. The Doctor is not the man who never would. At most, he’s the man who tries to find a better way.
Yeah, he shouldn't kill call because hes already defeted but. Don't go on this preachy ranch, and maybe punch The guy because every doctor deserves to punch an jurk you know as a treat
@@jobansand not really, remember that the woman who plays Jenny is actually the daughter of the man who played the 5th doctor. David Tennant, the man who played the tenth doctor, later married the woman who played Jenny. Therefore, the doctor married the doctor's daughter who was also the doctor's daughter.
Hi - wow, I forgot I'd posted this comment (doh). Actually, I don't know what I was thinking. I was in a bit of a bad mood I think. I agree with you now, especially after watching the Christmas special. I don't think the doctor does enjoy violence as a character, even if he is "like fire and ice and rage". He'll execute whole worlds if he thinks it's necessary, but I actually do agree that he doesn't enjoy it.
@Linkfanoftheyear What does that have to do with anything? That happened long before this. As I recall she was working with UNIT after she left the Doctor, they probably told her about it. Maybe not exactly WHAT Regeneration is, but enough that she could put the pieces together. 1) change of Face and Structure, 2) The Definition of Regeneration 3) THE MAN THAT IS THE DOCTOR!
The day she finally finds her dad/mum, the doctor will fill with a happiness she/her probably hadn’t felt since he found Rose. For once, the Doctor didn’t lose someone permanently
True enough, but every Doctor after the Eight has suffered through the Time War. If it was as horrible as he described, I imagine it would turn anybody off guns and violence if they weren't already off their rockers like the Master. And has any Doctor ever used a gun to kill in anger?
2:51 I’ve been waiting for this. “I never would” . The Wheel in Space: Doctor electrocutes a Cyberman to death . Day of the Daleks: Doctor goes around shooting Ogrons . Warriors of the Deep: Doctor releases poisonous gas killing all Silurians and Sea Devils in the underwater base . Remembrance of the Daleks: Doctor convinces he Supreme Dalek to kill itself . The Seeds of Death: Doctor messes up Ice Warriors transmissions leading the entire invasion fleet into the sun . Attack of the Cybermen: Doctor guns down 3 Cybermen at once . Horror of Fang Rock: Doctor totally blows up the Ruton with a laser light cannon . The Invasion of Time: Doctor shots the lead Sontaran . Remembrance of the Daleks again: Doctor uses the hand of Omega to freaking destroy Skaro . Genesis of the Daleks: when the Doctor blows up the incubation area at the end of part 6 . Earthshock: Doctor kills the Cyber Leader . And probably 10 other stories that I’m forgetting about
While I don't think they will ever have The Doctor fire a gun in violence, I do believe that we will eventually see him slowly but surely devolve into The Valeyard.
True true. But even though that could have happened, it won't be right. The fact that Jenny chose to protect her father no matter how bad the damage might be shows that she truly loved him as his daughter, even though The Doctor kept rejecting her as his daughter back then.
Hmm. Not sure he "gleefully" redirected those missiles, nor did Solomen launch them; however, it was a moment of unnecessary violence. I for one, thought it was an excellent scene: a more understated version of timelord victorious, showing how dangerous the Doctor is on his own, and how even he can give in to weakness. But, I guess, to each his own: I love the dark doctor, and see him as a dangerous character, even though I love him (every version of him) to bits
I never understood why Martha said there was no sign of regeneration. She’s never seen a time lord regenerate. She’s a human doctor; she has no idea how alien bodies function.
And that, kids, is how I met your mother.
DEAD LAUGHING
That was great
Fun fact: she's the fifth doctors daughter
Well yes but actually no
I love all the scenes when the Doctor chooses the peaceful route. I don't think anyone else could truthfully say that they wouldn't shoot cobb under those circumstances. That's why the Doctor is so awesome. Because he can preach peace and act upon it.
Even though he very much Would literally The previous season had him trapping people in internal tournament
Notice how no-one tries to stop him. They all stand there and allow it. Allow what they think is the Doctor about to execute a human being.
***** When you have enough authority people will act that way.
They know that the doctor would never kill, no matter how angry he gets, it's near enough his core belief
Because he'd be totally justified in pulling the trigger. But he didn't. And that's why it's powerful.
Is it ever a smart idea to try to stop the Doctor from doing anything?
@@nyreegraham7894 In all those years, did anyone ever read about anyone who managed to stop the Doctor?
guys the whole point of ten’s and later nine’s anti-gun/anti-genocide thing was because of their regrets with the time war. it’s not a lack of continuity, it’s specific to these particular incarnations of the doctor.
cat ✨ Awesome point, I really like this.
Apologies for sounding like a dick but 10 came after 9 and i don’t think 9 even mentioned not liking guns
@@archiereilly419 They mean 9 in the later episodes of series 1. And although 9 never explicitly said about his no gun rule, it’s implied in Dalek and The Parting of the ways, when the Doctor realised killing the Dalek or the Dalek fleet makes him become dangerous and a vengeful man, like the Doctor of the time war
@@qt.pie.alfred894 No, the Doctor doesn't inherently hate guns. It's only the new fake Doctor that has a strict no gun policy. The Doctor has always been more of a pacifist and completely against unnecessary violence of any kind. However he is aware that at times, violence is necessary and cannot be avoided. For example the the fake Doctor, she despises guns and wont even let her companions have weaponry on them for self defence. 9, 10, 11 and 12 however weren't as strict on this sort of thing and were mostly fine with the use of guns in self defence. Just the Doctor himself didn't like using a gun because he didn't want to anticipate a violent situation. For example when he refused to take the gun from Wilf at first it wasn't because he was completely against guns. It was because especially in this situation he did not want to have to take someone's life. He took the gun because he realised that this time he simply might not have a choice, although he did take the first alternative he could.
@@rindoubaka1574 I never said he hated guns, and perhaps I could’ve been a bit clearer. That the no gun rule is for himself. The Doctor recognises that sometimes he has to kill or let the monster die because there is no other way. But the Doctor refuses to use a gun because it’s cowardly, he’d be tempted to kill anything that seemed like a threat and he refuses to become a soldier/warrior like he was in the time war. So when Tennants Doctor took the gun from Wilfred or when Capaldi’s Doctor took the gun off the time lord captain, it’s meant to symbolise the extreme choice that Doctor had to make. The Doctor title means to never be cruel and never be cowardly, and using a gun goes against that. So when he’s with unit for example, he’s okay if they use guns as a last resort but he’s not okay using a gun himself
Love or hate Ten, you got to admit, his acting is top notch.
Who the fuck hates ten???
@@Gutssssss666 I don't hate him by any stretch, but from a canonical perspective, he was quite brutal, especially near the end with The Time Lord Victorius
Who the fuck hates ten?
@@nibncabc2737 Kinda makes sense really. Since he's still quite fresh from the Time War.
He’s the best
One of the lesser known moments of the 10th, but one of the greatest ones none the less. "I NEVER WOULD!"
As a father of two daughters this scene hit me especially hard, harder than some of the more well known emotional scenes of tennents time as the doctor.
10 is amazing in the moments when that cheerful, easygoing facade slips and you remember that he's a being who's seen SO much and yet still CHOOSES to be good, EVEN when it's clear there's SO much darkness building in him
You know, a part of me actually wanted me to see The Doctor pull the trigger
Same, but I think it suits his character a lot more this way
Hell naw. That's what I never understood. Evil people should never be given the gift of death. They should suffer.
I think he already had his share of killing in the great time war, he does have a pretty dark past after all.
He doesn't have to kill him, just shoot him where it wouldn't be fatal.
In this case i agree the man who killed the doctor's daughter shouldn't be killed to live and suffer for the rest of his day's
Did anyone else notice the way the music changed when he raises the gun? It was drumming.
Brilliant.
He was this close to making a step towards becoming like the master, killing an unarmed man. Of course, he still broke the laws of time to save Adelaide and her crew in the “Waters of Mars”, but murder was something else entirely
@@lochness5524 he was under the "Timelord victorious" delusion, so kinda of close to the Master also then
Duudes, duudes. The difference here is that the old general guy was no longer a threat, so killing him would be purely for vengeance, as opposed to all the villains he offed to stop yet more shit from happening; That, an he was deliberately trying to make an example here.
He definitely has some overcompensation issues going on.
"You Know for a man who abhors violence I take great satisfaction from doing that." - Third Doctor
A Doctor who always did.
Not always. Watch the video again! The better answer is sometimes. Just as all of us. No matter how great we say we are, we do everything sometimes.
Porterhouse the point is after seeing the horrors of the time war and meeting rose he changed to a man who never would
@@aerodblade1601 Except he totally did, even after the Time War.
metalmugen when? Also, this is violence in vengeance, which would not save anyone. There's a massive difference between that and violence to save someone.
>Make the foundation of this society "A man who never would."
"Oh god, Steve, take me to the hospital! I'm going to die soon!"
"I'm a man who never would."
NDSPCgamer is that a reference to another show?
@@jobansand It's a joke for this scene
the best thing is when in the end he throws away that gun with so much energy and fury
More in disgust
When the doctor pointed the gun at the guy's head, My immediate thought was " Hello, My name is the doctor. You killed my daughter. Prepare to die." lol
#princessbride
"STOP SAYING THAT!!!"
@@simonwelter6497 #thedoctorbride?
@@calamar1e320 HELLO, MY NAME IS THE DOCTOR YOU KILLED MY DAUGHTER PREPARE TO DIE
@@Maison05 *even faster/more energetically* HELLO! MY NAME IS THE DOCTOR! YOU KILLED MY DAUGHTER! PREPARE TO DIE!!
I just feel so light hearted every time I watch this. This is by far one of my most favorite speeches period.
When you see the Doctor point a gun at a defenceless man's head, *that* is when you know he's genuinely pissed off.
Can you hear them Doctor? The Drums?
Seeing the Day of the Doctor, you realize just how completely true his declaration is here.
This was a seriously beautiful scene. I mean, I'm sure all of us wanted him to do it.. but then we're shown this instead, the Doctor's humanity and him setting an example.
Slight problem though: Why does Martha know about regeneration? He came back to life once or twice with her but never actually regenerated with her obviously.
Hasn't he explained regeneration a few times
At this point she has been working for UNIT. Possible she has access to UNIT files on the Doctor, especially with how high ranking she is
Also... The Master regenerated in her season.
She was there when the Master Regenerated.
The Master regenerated when she was there, and Jack explained it to her in the episode afterwards.
Notice how, when The Doctor almost boils over with rage, you can hear The Drums...
This is why Doctor Who is so amazing, The Doctor always has a genuine lesson. he reminds us who we are, and what we stand for. and he makes sure we stay true to that image.
This is an literally Just words that he doesn't even Follow he's made people suffer faints worse than death for less
I adore the tonal shift at 1:36 where the Doctor's look of sadness changes to absolute, undying rage
At the moment, I don’t know how many years it has been since this moment. But this sentiment resonates right to the centre of my being. I looked it up tonight because, more than anything, I wish I could find a man that never would.... I think doctor who may have ruined me for the real world 😅
If there ever was a time, he would break his promise this was it, he has seen so much and feel so much pain for it, but the loss of a child, the other times he has felt a lost doesn't even come close to it
1:31 When the doctor does that face I cry instantly I swear-
People just seem to forget this is his second daughter that’s probably why he cared for her so much when he’d known her a day he’s already had a kid and so just having one now he knows it’ll be great (context the first doctors first companion was his granddaughter meaning he had a kid already)
Could've been a son too.
The real question when the doctor raises the gun; is if he’s trying to build the nerve to pull the trigger, or fight the urge to do so
Ten: "I never would."
Twelve when he tries to save Clara on Gallifrey: "I'mma pretend like I didn't hear that."
10 never would. He never specified wether he meant the Doctor as whole, or solely a specific version of him
Well he did it on gallifrey because of regeneration, the old guy in this was human so there'd be no chance of surviving.
@@lochness5524Oh He wouldn't he does things 10 times worse. And then goes power-mad because that's his character, he gets progressively worse.
He was a more human doctor and as such, he had our flaws
Brilliant scene. There's just no other way to put it. In addition, the score was timed ABSOLUTELY perfectly. The trumpet solo from 'The Doctor Forever' was the PERFECT line to use at 3:16.
“i never would. Have you got that I. Never. Would! When you start this new world, of Human and Hath. Remember that! MAKE THE FOUNDATION OF THIS SOCIETY, A MAN WHO NEVER WOULD!”
This is why 10 is my favourite Doctor
(Thinks back on what he's done to the Daleks, Silents, Weeping Angels, and various other baddies)
Yup. You're totally not a killer.
The difference is when he's killed Daleks, or Cybermen, or Angels it has been done as a last resort so that he can save himself and those with him, where as in this scene it would be a cold blooded murder
So then he's not a cold blooded murderer. Except for with Daleks, but they'd kill everyone if left unchecked so they don't count. And the Cybermen, but death is honestly the only thing that'll stop them from converting people. And the Sileeee...Oh. The Silents were pretty much space confessional priests, so the Doctor made humankind genocidal towards them for the acts of a splinter group.
Now I wanna know why Clara and every human born after the Apollo landing shown on screen didn't murder the Silents in Time of the Doctor.
The only ones on Earth were the splinter group. That's why they were on Earth.
That would be perfect if humanity stayed on earth, but they won't. Anyone in the universe who sees that clip will be compelled to kill innocent Silents on sight.
FullmetalHeart20 True... but I've never seen it, so it'll be more like a few killings here and there. But you do have a point. (But if it's just them, that basically the same as not genocide at all because... wait, what were we talking about again? Oh yeah, the Doctor has never actually committed genocide! Anybody know why those episodes in series 6 were missing so many parts?)
Probably because of that one episode before "Mercy," where he gleefully redirected those missiles to blow up the person who'd launched them.
This is just such a powerful moment... One of my all-time favorites from the Tennant era.
Thank you so much for uploading!
I love this scene so much :)
All I'm thinking of is of David tenants doctor scene saying "I never would, you got that I never would"
Wasn't she working for UNIT at this point? UNIT has known about regeneration for a long time now so she might have picked it up there.
I agree. Ten is really an inspiration.
What is the name of the song played when The Doctor says "he never would." It has a strong brass section playing the melody and it has been played in other episodes (such as when Donna begs The Doctor to save someone in Pompeii)
"The Doctor Forever".
For a moment you see the man who might've pulled the trigger
Corn on the Cobb didn't get his special sauce
This was probably incredibly easy for Tennant to act this scene, he was probably picturing his actual wife (jenny's actress) dying in his arms and the rage he would feel irl if the man was standing there
The best part of this scene, to me, is that he clearly thought about it. He thought HARD.
The first time I watched this episode it was around 4 am because that was the only time I had and so my roommate was sleeping in the other bed as I was sobbing uncontrollably into my pillow...yeah
It says something that no one even tried to stop him from pulling that trigger. I mean, sure, they looked dubious, but no one stopped him.
It was really chilling seeing how he held that gun to his head.
I'll always remember, Doctor!
david's acting as the doctor was just.... oof. you could see the anger. he truly brought the doctor to life
What? The Eleventh Doctor fired a gun exactly once and that was to destroy a gravity thingy to escape a horde of Weeping Angels.
Easy to forget that he was a father before and that he was technically responsible for the death of his children
A small glimpse into the time war, a flash back to number 9's rage
Ten: Pacifist, forgiver.
Also Ten: Condemns family of blood foreve with the fury of a time lord.
lol but really, I think cos it was his daughter who wanted so much to learn from him, that he felt like he had to set the best example in her memory. A fatherly moment.
The music here (chefs kiss) 😢 1:28
God I wish I knew the music from when he says “make the foundation of this society a man who never would”
i think this is one of those moments that really define the 10th doctor. This and when he realized that he was master over time in Waters of Mars.
David Tennant is such an amazing actor
When the doctor got married; the doctor gave his daughter away to her father who is the doctor. That’s a strange twist if I ever thought of one.
this is valid now more than ever
@Lopperopoly except that when Martha was told that the master regenerated she said "regenerated what does that mean"
Murry Gold is hands down the greatest composer of doctor who
The 5th and 6th Doctors killed multiple Cybermen, the 7th manipulated Davros into destroying Skaro, the 3rd shot and killed a few Ogrons, and generally wasn’t opposed to violence (being the Doctor to introduce Venusian Aikido), and that’s just the classic Doctors. 9 teleported Cassandra back, and definitely knew what would happen (she didn’t actually die, but he didn’t know.), and even sticking just with 10, he killed the leader of the Sicorax within his first day. The Doctor is not the man who never would. At most, he’s the man who tries to find a better way.
Yeah, he shouldn't kill call because hes already defeted but. Don't go on this preachy ranch,
and maybe punch The guy because every doctor deserves to punch an jurk you know as a treat
Hands up if it still made you so so sad for the Doctor.
I don’t think anyone would of blamed or judged 10 if he pulled the trigger
The tenth Doctor's best moment.
and then he married his daughter and had lots of sex and babies
Caine Luke Aury dude...
That's disgusting
@@jobansand not really, remember that the woman who plays Jenny is actually the daughter of the man who played the 5th doctor. David Tennant, the man who played the tenth doctor, later married the woman who played Jenny. Therefore, the doctor married the doctor's daughter who was also the doctor's daughter.
Incredible scene 👏🏻
Hi - wow, I forgot I'd posted this comment (doh). Actually, I don't know what I was thinking. I was in a bit of a bad mood I think. I agree with you now, especially after watching the Christmas special. I don't think the doctor does enjoy violence as a character, even if he is "like fire and ice and rage". He'll execute whole worlds if he thinks it's necessary, but I actually do agree that he doesn't enjoy it.
Did anyone hear the drums when the doctor was about to pull the trigger?
@Linkfanoftheyear What does that have to do with anything? That happened long before this. As I recall she was working with UNIT after she left the Doctor, they probably told her about it. Maybe not exactly WHAT Regeneration is, but enough that she could put the pieces together. 1) change of Face and Structure, 2) The Definition of Regeneration 3) THE MAN THAT IS THE DOCTOR!
Such an underrated scene
Hands up if you saw Jenny's death coming a mile away
Doctor: *does American Cup Song* I never would
What’s the music called when he says a man who never would
The day she finally finds her dad/mum, the doctor will fill with a happiness she/her probably hadn’t felt since he found Rose. For once, the Doctor didn’t lose someone permanently
yo imagine at the end when he tossed that gun it went off yo an hit the guy in the face
LOL
Is it me, or is the gun prop the exact same one the Doctor had to use in End of Time?(AKA Wilfred's Gun)
I always hoped she’d return. Have a story with her river and the doctor
Shots fired
What is the name of the soundtrack used in this one?
*Cut to the Fifth Doctor murdering a planet full of Daleks*
@MyRkAcc Yep. And it's also the gun that Captain Jack Harkness uses
I never would
Still crying over this in 2020? I am. #ValeDecem
2021 and I’m still crying
No Problem - Me TOO!
True enough, but every Doctor after the Eight has suffered through the Time War. If it was as horrible as he described, I imagine it would turn anybody off guns and violence if they weren't already off their rockers like the Master.
And has any Doctor ever used a gun to kill in anger?
I'm balling like a baby
Why didn't you just share some of his regeneration energy with heroh wait maybe that's cuz they haven't implemented that plot device in the series
What's the name of the song at the end? =/
Dr who fans: don't shoot, if you do you'll be no better then he is!
Americans: *Palpatine voice* Dew it.
And RIGHT AFTER he leaves, she heals and leaves the planet, wonder if she'll be seen again
she knows a time lord can regenerat because of what happened with the master
2:51 I’ve been waiting for this. “I never would”
. The Wheel in Space: Doctor electrocutes a Cyberman to death
. Day of the Daleks: Doctor goes around shooting Ogrons
. Warriors of the Deep: Doctor releases poisonous gas killing all Silurians and Sea Devils in the underwater base
. Remembrance of the Daleks: Doctor convinces he Supreme Dalek to kill itself
. The Seeds of Death: Doctor messes up Ice Warriors transmissions leading the entire invasion fleet into the sun
. Attack of the Cybermen: Doctor guns down 3 Cybermen at once
. Horror of Fang Rock: Doctor totally blows up the Ruton with a laser light cannon
. The Invasion of Time: Doctor shots the lead Sontaran
. Remembrance of the Daleks again: Doctor uses the hand of Omega to freaking destroy Skaro
. Genesis of the Daleks: when the Doctor blows up the incubation area at the end of part 6
. Earthshock: Doctor kills the Cyber Leader
. And probably 10 other stories that I’m forgetting about
Ok? He never would murder an unarmed and unthreatening man out of fury and a need for revenge, not really the same.
While I don't think they will ever have The Doctor fire a gun in violence, I do believe that we will eventually see him slowly but surely devolve into The Valeyard.
is it me or does 10 always rock dead people?
True true. But even though that could have happened, it won't be right. The fact that Jenny chose to protect her father no matter how bad the damage might be shows that she truly loved him as his daughter, even though The Doctor kept rejecting her as his daughter back then.
Hmm. Not sure he "gleefully" redirected those missiles, nor did Solomen launch them; however, it was a moment of unnecessary violence. I for one, thought it was an excellent scene: a more understated version of timelord victorious, showing how dangerous the Doctor is on his own, and how even he can give in to weakness. But, I guess, to each his own: I love the dark doctor, and see him as a dangerous character, even though I love him (every version of him) to bits
for a secon you can hear the drums
what is the name of the theme?
I never understood why Martha said there was no sign of regeneration. She’s never seen a time lord regenerate. She’s a human doctor; she has no idea how alien bodies function.
She saw the Master regenerate in Utopia.
@@liamturner4851 no she didn't, he was inside the TARDIS
@@scpromos9158 I’m a little late to this but in the Sound Of Drums Jack explains regeneration to Martha near the beginning of the episode.
What is this soundtrack on 2:55 ???
The doctor forever
Seven might have.
I always imagine as he throws the gun it going off and killing him anyway :L still BADASS.