It's still funny that they used Sera's background vocals. If they could do that then they should have invited her. The performance clearly felt incomplete without her.
@@healtheworldforabetterplace she was invited but she reject it because she think the rest of member who stay until the end (disbandment) are more deserve to do the performance. she said it on her youtube channel.
no kidding sera's presence is very strong in dolls so them performing dolls without sera felt really weird :(((( but the 2021 version was still enjoyable
I know that Sera are important for Dolls, as well as for NineMuses.. But I think the production team will try to invite all as possible as they can, but no by forcing idols😅 (You may watch some interviews with idols, JaeJae wouldn't be forcing idols to do things that they don't want to) But for this event, I think they are get in touch with one of the members ( like for After School, JaeJae said that she contacted Juyeon first and Juyeon contact other members) So it might be members problem,or Sera doesn't want to come, or some agency/company don't want Sera to stand on stage with other members?🤔 Btw, i think all of them including MMTG team and also idols already do their best for everything 💕
@@qingiee5693 Sera herself said she wouldn't have minded being part of it but she simply was not invited and wasn't aware. They left her out on purpose.
@@Vulpix298 omg.. but I think might be some problem inside the team, or they decide not to invite Sera, not MMTG🥺 As MMTG are trying to get those group, they are contact to one of the members from each group and ask them to invite others member 😅
@@chairelectric I think Lee Sem was referring more to Euaerin, not Hyuna (I could be wrong). Lee Sem seems to be hurt by it and rightfully so. Dolls was arguably the defining song of 9MUSES and Lee Sem probably wanted to be there to perform that song. There probably was a communication problem among all the members, and maybe the other 9MUSES members weren't thinking properly of telling her the song was Dolls. I'm not standing up for the members who performed because I do think they were wrong in not telling her. However, you can see by Sera's response of completely supporting the performance and her saying of how they all agreed that the latest members of 9MUSES would perform the song that this issue seems to be a personal issue of Lee Sem and the other members (and that's fine btw she has every right to feel this way).
When there's a school batch reunion but not all were attended due to 'inner problems' they say. I could embrace how Sera, Lee Sem, Eunji and others feel abt it....
In addition to sharing the sentiments of not having Sera around, I'm also sad not to have my 9Muses bias Sungah around. Dolls was Sungah's debut song and her addition was what made 9Muses nine again.
I am sure sera would have liked to join in, but she couldn’t -the relationship between their company Star Kingdom and Sera by the end of her contract was awful - they wouldn’t have let her : ( nor would she want to go back to work with the company and suffer more
@@lilappletreeundertheroof3749 yes recently they had a reunion along with after school and 2PM. Hyuna was on charge of inviting members but she only invited members from Hurt Locker era up to join. Lee Sem was so angry that she posted about their bad relationship drama all over the internet.
Confirmation they used Sera’s vocals. Surely a phone call to Sera with an invite would have been a better way to go instead of using a backing track. Sojin’s vocals were just to soft to go over Sera’s. Rather sad when Sera did a reaction to the performance and could hear herself. Learn from After School - straight up sing!
i love the new members and everything, but when they first came out I did feel like the company tried to match sera's image when choosing new members and that always rubbed me the wrong way. I still love this reunion but the old line up has a place in my heart
even though we are all probably disappointed that not all the members were invited to this let's not look over the members that did a good job during the reunion performance 😩
I’m only a casual listener, but it irked me that they used Sera’s bg vocals. If y’all wanted her vocals in the performance wouldn’t it have made sense that she’d be a part of this too? Hyuna messed up in this one.
Thanks for making this video. I like both OT8 & OT9 so this is quite interesting to watch. I will take the fact that they used Sera’s vocals in the last verse as a tribute to her.
interesting comparison.. the mixes are clearly different, despite the different vocal arrangements.. I'm guessing part of it is one's a concert with no audience (to speak of), and one's on a music show, etc also, yeah I really miss Sera, Eunji, and Lee Sem from that lineup .. .Also, I wish they had kept some nostalgic outfits the same way After School did
Sera does have an amazing voice, but if she had been onstage all of the focus would have been on her and her history instead of 9Muses as a whole. This reunion series for all the groups was meant to be fun for them and their fandoms not to rehash any past pain or drama. I actually thought the reunion version visuals were far superior. Without exception each woman is more beautiful and more confident now and they looked stunning in classic and timeless all white suits.
lmao what are you talking about? lmao of course if they want perfom dolls at least they should inform sera, leesem, & eunji who were part of the group during dolls era. you’re going too far to talk about ‘to be fun’ even visual of the member. you didn’t even get the point lmao
at first, I thought that HyunA didn't invited LeeSem to join the reunion. maybe their relationship is as bad as LeeSem revealed. but I've watched a vid of Sera and HyunA enjoy singing Dolls at an event themselves. so not inviting Sera might be the decision of the company. Star Empire you are fishy
Personally, I don't think Star Empire had nothing to do with this. Hyuna and Sera just aren't on good grounds but that's just life, we can't all be friends forever.
@@milkyyy4443 my comment saying that lee sem and hyuna' relationship is not good but Sera and Hyuna's relationship is. And dont forget that they use Sera's background vocal without asking for her permission. Star empire had something to do with it
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
It's still funny that they used Sera's background vocals. If they could do that then they should have invited her. The performance clearly felt incomplete without her.
Yup and they sang together in Sera's part in the second chorus too
@@linhttm58 why she was not invited?
@@healtheworldforabetterplace she was invited but she reject it because she think the rest of member who stay until the end (disbandment) are more deserve to do the performance. she said it on her youtube channel.
@@ikychoi1605 sorry I didn’t understand her korean
@@ikychoi1605 she wasn't invited tho
sera presence is a must for every dolls perf and this is the proof
@@kwangya_king she was kicked by the company who knows maybe she and Hyemi will be the "start-to-end duo"
@@kwangya_king She was kicked by the company in 2014
Sera was definitely needed and missed for this reunion
Tehy did not erase her voice just got me like 🤌🏻☠️
exactly
no kidding sera's presence is very strong in dolls so them performing dolls without sera felt really weird :(((( but the 2021 version was still enjoyable
Whoever was in charged of the invitation, I hope you know you pissed off a lot of people and the majority of the fandom for not inviting Sera.
I know that Sera are important for Dolls, as well as for NineMuses..
But I think the production team will try to invite all as possible as they can, but no by forcing idols😅
(You may watch some interviews with idols, JaeJae wouldn't be forcing idols to do things that they don't want to)
But for this event, I think they are get in touch with one of the members ( like for After School, JaeJae said that she contacted Juyeon first and Juyeon contact other members)
So it might be members problem,or Sera doesn't want to come, or some agency/company don't want Sera to stand on stage with other members?🤔
Btw, i think all of them including MMTG team and also idols already do their best for everything 💕
@@qingiee5693 Sera herself said she wouldn't have minded being part of it but she simply was not invited and wasn't aware. They left her out on purpose.
@@Vulpix298 omg.. but I think might be some problem inside the team, or they decide not to invite Sera, not MMTG🥺
As MMTG are trying to get those group, they are contact to one of the members from each group and ask them to invite others member 😅
it was actually hyuna who invited and arranged the reunion
I wish Sem, Eunji and Sera were invited even if it was just to watch the performance like JaeJae and Minhyuk..
They should have invited Sera, Eunji and LeeSem.......
Do you blame the girls or the producers? hmm
@@kaioshinn_ its hyuna's fault, not the producers
@@rebeccablackvirus975 why hyuna fault?
@@alondraleos1017 Lee Sem posted about it, you can search it up.
@@chairelectric I think Lee Sem was referring more to Euaerin, not Hyuna (I could be wrong). Lee Sem seems to be hurt by it and rightfully so. Dolls was arguably the defining song of 9MUSES and Lee Sem probably wanted to be there to perform that song. There probably was a communication problem among all the members, and maybe the other 9MUSES members weren't thinking properly of telling her the song was Dolls. I'm not standing up for the members who performed because I do think they were wrong in not telling her. However, you can see by Sera's response of completely supporting the performance and her saying of how they all agreed that the latest members of 9MUSES would perform the song that this issue seems to be a personal issue of Lee Sem and the other members (and that's fine btw she has every right to feel this way).
When there's a school batch reunion but not all were attended due to 'inner problems' they say. I could embrace how Sera, Lee Sem, Eunji and others feel abt it....
In addition to sharing the sentiments of not having Sera around, I'm also sad not to have my 9Muses bias Sungah around. Dolls was Sungah's debut song and her addition was what made 9Muses nine again.
sungah's husky voice
Wish Hyuna would've invited Sera, Lee Seem and Eunji to the reunion instead of leaving them out 🙄
yes yes ;_;
I am sure sera would have liked to join in, but she couldn’t -the relationship between their company Star Kingdom and Sera by the end of her contract was awful - they wouldn’t have let her : ( nor would she want to go back to work with the company and suffer more
@@papillonaire she stated that she wouldn't have minded but that she was simply not invited. If she was invited she would've joined
@@SM-wf4ki for real??? I didnt really know nine muses back then, i just know them now and i dont understand what happened but they did a reunion?
@@lilappletreeundertheroof3749 yes recently they had a reunion along with after school and 2PM. Hyuna was on charge of inviting members but she only invited members from Hurt Locker era up to join. Lee Sem was so angry that she posted about their bad relationship drama all over the internet.
Confirmation they used Sera’s vocals. Surely a phone call to Sera with an invite would have been a better way to go instead of using a backing track. Sojin’s vocals were just to soft to go over Sera’s. Rather sad when Sera did a reaction to the performance and could hear herself. Learn from After School - straight up sing!
Imagine promoting this song with your girls and you don’t get asked to come back to reunite with this song.
Sera ❤️ LeeSem ❤️ Eunji ❤️
2:28 QUEEN ERIN SNAPPED
They still used sera voice 😂😂 and her reaction to that was hilarious
2:18 my everything in life THEY LOOK SO HAPPY
I wonder why nobody appreciate how Hyemi actually be the strongest backbone of the group...
For real, she was the most stable vocalist in there
The real underrated member of Nine Muses. She worked really hard for this group.
i love the new members and everything, but when they first came out I did feel like the company tried to match sera's image when choosing new members and that always rubbed me the wrong way. I still love this reunion but the old line up has a place in my heart
I really miss 2013 formation
seras presence was the key to dolls :/
Would have been better to have the original Dolls lineup!
They released 5 singles and 1 full album.
They deserved to be here.
@@iampause but she/he said "the original *dolls* line-up", not the original nine muses line-up
even though we are all probably disappointed that not all the members were invited to this let's not look over the members that did a good job during the reunion performance 😩
Erin's rap still slaps... Although I wish Eunji would have been there too :(
I’m only a casual listener, but it irked me that they used Sera’s bg vocals. If y’all wanted her vocals in the performance wouldn’t it have made sense that she’d be a part of this too? Hyuna messed up in this one.
Agree, we can't blame Lee Sem for being resentful to Hyuna. It is all making sense to me now.
Thanks for making this video. I like both OT8 & OT9 so this is quite interesting to watch. I will take the fact that they used Sera’s vocals in the last verse as a tribute to her.
interesting comparison.. the mixes are clearly different, despite the different vocal arrangements.. I'm guessing part of it is one's a concert with no audience (to speak of), and one's on a music show, etc
also, yeah I really miss Sera, Eunji, and Lee Sem from that lineup .. .Also, I wish they had kept some nostalgic outfits the same way After School did
9muses is back in may 2023 ❤
They used the same base from 2013 with sera’s vocals
Me encanta esta canción!!
편집 칭찬...
Sera does have an amazing voice, but if she had been onstage all of the focus would have been on her and her history instead of 9Muses as a whole. This reunion series for all the groups was meant to be fun for them and their fandoms not to rehash any past pain or drama. I actually thought the reunion version visuals were far superior. Without exception each woman is more beautiful and more confident now and they looked stunning in classic and timeless all white suits.
lmao what are you talking about? lmao of course if they want perfom dolls at least they should inform sera, leesem, & eunji who were part of the group during dolls era. you’re going too far to talk about ‘to be fun’ even visual of the member. you didn’t even get the point lmao
I just only know sera and kyungri in nine muses
Bc vocals sera 🥴🥴 in the high note
Lee Saem should've been invited by hyuna :
Always pretty
Minha 😍😍
Powerful 🔥
Wow
So good
2021?? They disbanded though???
they performed recently in this show called mmtg in case u have missed it
at first, I thought that HyunA didn't invited LeeSem to join the reunion. maybe their relationship is as bad as LeeSem revealed.
but I've watched a vid of Sera and HyunA enjoy singing Dolls at an event themselves. so not inviting Sera might be the decision of the company. Star Empire you are fishy
Personally, I don't think Star Empire had nothing to do with this. Hyuna and Sera just aren't on good grounds but that's just life, we can't all be friends forever.
@@milkyyy4443 my comment saying that lee sem and hyuna' relationship is not good but Sera and Hyuna's relationship is. And dont forget that they use Sera's background vocal without asking for her permission. Star empire had something to do with it
@@elijahpham8048 Yeah, i guess to some extent
Gilda gireul ppaldari
Jjuk jjuk ppang ppang!!!
Sojin & Keumjoo forever. ♡
Well too bad they have no impact to the group
@@nakyumleftnips8633 The way Sera, Lee Sem and Eunji were serving it during their prime was just amazing. Nobody can ever replace them.
@@nakyumleftnips8633 the slander 💀
@@nakyumleftnips8633HELP
@@nakyumleftnips8633bl fan talking hell no
Original is better
Giving ng Sera lines to Sojin is kind of disrespectful 😅
イセムとセラが居ないのがダメだわ。ソンアと、ウンジは別にだけど