Yes, this collab isn't perfect, but no collab is. Nobody deserves to have their hard work insulted, and definitely shouldn't be told to never participate in or organize collaborations again. Without the opportunity to have these experiences, nobody would learn and improve. I'd like to congratulate all the participants, and the hosts for seeing this collab through and making it to release. You should be proud! Dispite what a lot of people may be saying, there are many creators here that I can see a lot of potential in for future works as they hopefully continue to learn and create more. I would like to encourage participants reading this to not be discouraged by the harsh words in the other comments. Of course, you can and should learn from their criticisms, but what's most important in my opinion is that If you have passion for this medium, then please don't let other people discourage you from creating your art. It's yours, and you shouldn't let people make it no longer fun for you anymore. I think that this collab is flawed, yes, but still something to be proud of and something that has value. The biggest critique I have that I haven't seen very many people mention is mostly with the medley, particularly the pacing and song choices. It feels like almost half the song choices seem to be re-treading ideas that have already been explored in other inmu/cookie medley collabs, like new years dreams. Additionally, the pacing and transitions between songs can be rough sometimes. Despite that however, I can see that everyone really did work with what they had when it came to their parts to the best of their abilities. Even if sometimes the knowledge of the source material can have some blank spots, I really don't think that that completely invalidates the work done here unlike what a lot of people seem to unfortunately be suggesting. Constructive criticism is a very important thing, but people need to remember that when you start getting disrespectful it can be really discouraging to creators, especially newcomers. I enjoyed watching this collab, and will be watching it again. My favorite parts are bbkkbkk, wario's gold mine, and unwelcome school! congrats to everyone who worked on this project.
the most coherent thing I've read here it may not be good for some, but that is their problem and it is respected. it is also not for them to start crying and making twitter or discord dramas
Easter still being included in things like this makes me feel really happy. It’s been almost 7 years since I helped edit everyone else’s work together for that, and I’m glad it still has some impact.
That was a super fun collab, great job! Edit: what's with all the hate? People acting like collabs should be the absolute most perfect thing ever or it sucks makes me think something's up
@@Hamburgagapeople are out here writing passages over an otoMAD collab lol. it's not really that deep honestly. people need to give criticism and move on instead of acting like this collab killed their whole family
@@Hamburgaga There's a big reason why I often don't release videos, it's because people like you often don't give good enough criticism to generally think things through and to be quite frank, you're not doing anything to help anyone either. People need to realize their mistakes better rather than being told what their mistake is and only that, they need to learn from their mistakes. You cannot progress until something is learned.
i enjoyed this collab! especially with the production issues i think it turned out pretty good. my favorite parts were jojo, voyage 1969, brain power, marshall maximizer, itte, and koronba. also the inclusion of sexting and cookie summer beach was unexpected. Thank you for the good weather!!
Excuse me for my poor English. I love this collab too! but why complainers demand high quality for a gay porn video and amateur voice drama 13 years ago?
In hindsight: I think collaborations like NYD or 音MAD x artist have severely skewed expectations of smaller collaborations like this one. Cookie☆ is a celebration of artistic creativity. And this collab excelled in that. I personally still enjoyed this one start to finish. But there’s something important to remember: cookie☆ is decreasing in popularity. It is not 2018 anymore. And many talented creators have moved on. A drop in quality and quantity is to be expected.
I think the collab varied in quality a lot throughout because of some of the creators not having enough experience, especially with the audio, but some parts were pretty good
Alright, jokes aside, I think this collab is overhated, I mean, even if how the hosting went poorly, some participants did gave on their entry, and whoever tried to do their best should be proud.
Nice collab, Fiiinally i see "sexting", "あさやけもゆうやけもないんだ", and "Say It" doing good use, And while some parts legit gives me some questions/doubts, some parts manage to get the job done. Now if you worked on the collab, i hope that you had an enjoyable experience, but keep in mind to get more skilled, more creative, get better.
These comments are the exact reason why YTPMVers don't get friends, let alone girlfriends. What is so bad about this collab? None of the entries are off-pitch, the visuals are S tier for what most of these people commenting "GRR BAD COLLAB" make. But obviously because it's not Octagon or Old Spice and it doesn't have the "big names" (who should move on instead of making these videos in their middle 20s) then it gets deleted. I'm LMAOing your lives!
Honestly as a ytpmver I just gave up interacting with most of the community this stuff is so embarrassing, I'm sorry to all the outsiders who don't get context for the unnecessary drama and bs that goes on. People take this shit too seriously, lol.
Meh collab. A couple parts were good, but not much to rave and love about. And I would have to agree with what Beazty said. The collab would have been better if someone else who knows what the source is truly capable of would have hosted it, the collab would have been better. 4.5/10.
なんで批判されてんのかなって思ったら単純にクオリティが低いからってこと？
待ってくださいよ！「みんなで作ろうぜー！」ってワイワイやったものにクオリティ求めるのはやめてくれよ……
そんなことしたら新人がとっつきにくくなって音MADの土壌が枯れちゃうだろ！
0:00 Crazy Noisy Bizarre Town
0:38 Sexting
1:09 ヴォヤージュ1969
1:49 神っぽいな
2:32 エゴロック
3:12 グッバイ宣言
3:44 フォニィ
4:12 夜に駆ける
4:42 HONEY-Q
5:35 B.B.K.K.B.K.K.
6:29 Brain Power
7:14 FUNKY SUMMER BEACH
8:08 サイハテギャラクシー
9:00 Banbado ~Piano Version~
9:23 Wario's Gold Mine
9:50 Unwelcome school
10:22 Marshall Maximizer
11:04 あさやけもゆうやけもないんだ
11:36 言って。
12:27 ENDING
訂正点ありましたらご報告下さい。
ありがとナス
Yes, this collab isn't perfect, but no collab is. Nobody deserves to have their hard work insulted, and definitely shouldn't be told to never participate in or organize collaborations again. Without the opportunity to have these experiences, nobody would learn and improve.
I'd like to congratulate all the participants, and the hosts for seeing this collab through and making it to release. You should be proud! Dispite what a lot of people may be saying, there are many creators here that I can see a lot of potential in for future works as they hopefully continue to learn and create more. I would like to encourage participants reading this to not be discouraged by the harsh words in the other comments. Of course, you can and should learn from their criticisms, but what's most important in my opinion is that If you have passion for this medium, then please don't let other people discourage you from creating your art. It's yours, and you shouldn't let people make it no longer fun for you anymore.
I think that this collab is flawed, yes, but still something to be proud of and something that has value. The biggest critique I have that I haven't seen very many people mention is mostly with the medley, particularly the pacing and song choices. It feels like almost half the song choices seem to be re-treading ideas that have already been explored in other inmu/cookie medley collabs, like new years dreams. Additionally, the pacing and transitions between songs can be rough sometimes. Despite that however, I can see that everyone really did work with what they had when it came to their parts to the best of their abilities. Even if sometimes the knowledge of the source material can have some blank spots, I really don't think that that completely invalidates the work done here unlike what a lot of people seem to unfortunately be suggesting.
Constructive criticism is a very important thing, but people need to remember that when you start getting disrespectful it can be really discouraging to creators, especially newcomers.
I enjoyed watching this collab, and will be watching it again. My favorite parts are bbkkbkk, wario's gold mine, and unwelcome school! congrats to everyone who worked on this project.
the most coherent thing I've read here
it may not be good for some, but that is their problem and it is respected.
it is also not for them to start crying and making twitter or discord dramas
i luv you bro
長文否定兄貴批判兄貴大好き
ンアーッ！文章がデカすぎます‼︎
ま、多少はね？(ホモ特有の掌返し)
現代っぽい編集とか簡単な編集が多いってのは新規参入がまだ続いているって意味でもあるのだ 良い世、来いよ
理解、
淫夢とクッキー☆は不滅はっきり分かんだね
@@Imperialism334 淫夢バッジは持っているかな？
そもそもクッキー☆界隈自体が技術力高すぎるんよな
ホモは欲張り、はっきりわかんだね
オススメ
1:47 神っぽいな
2:32エゴロック
2:53 エゴロック(一転構成)
3:13 グッバイ宣言
3:33 グッバイ宣言(サビ)
3:44 フォニィ
5:34 B.B.K.K.B.K.K
6:07 B.B.K.K.B.K.Kサビ
6:28 Brain power
6:53 Brain power (フラッシュ注意)
9:00 バンバード(サビ)
9:22 ワリオ鉱山
9:48 unwelcome school
11:34 言って。
9:22からのパートは ノコノコみさき ではなく ワリオこうざん だと思うゾ
@@Hoshikuzu40 あっ…そっかぁ
俺これ淫ク合作系で一番好きなのに
叩かれてんの？なんで？
こちとら作業用に聴きすぎて
覚えちまってるくらいなんだぞ
Easter still being included in things like this makes me feel really happy. It’s been almost 7 years since I helped edit everyone else’s work together for that, and I’m glad it still has some impact.
まずは13周年やってくれたことに感謝だよね
なんで海外兄貴からの評判が悪いんですかね？
普通にいいと思う(小並感)
ほならね？自分で作ってみろって話じゃないですか
そうだよ（便乗）
何が悪かったんですかねぇ…？
そうだよ
sodayo（一般通过中国人）
中国兄貴も仲間だぜ
That was a super fun collab, great job!
Edit: what's with all the hate? People acting like collabs should be the absolute most perfect thing ever or it sucks makes me think something's up
13年続いてんのマジ草
MGR姉貴大好きﾎﾝﾄﾆｱｺｶﾞﾚﾃﾙ
あさやけもゆうやけもないんだパートほんとすき
マジそれ
Gotta get popcorn... FOR THE COMMENTS LMAO
The funniest part about this is that majority of the people complaining dont do any better job either lmao
@@Hamburgagapeople are out here writing passages over an otoMAD collab lol. it's not really that deep honestly. people need to give criticism and move on instead of acting like this collab killed their whole family
😂
@@Hamburgaga There's a big reason why I often don't release videos, it's because people like you often don't give good enough criticism to generally think things through and to be quite frank, you're not doing anything to help anyone either. People need to realize their mistakes better rather than being told what their mistake is and only that, they need to learn from their mistakes. You cannot progress until something is learned.
@@BeaztyGay but people arent gonna listen anyway lol, its better to just focus on urself and the stuff u have control of
i enjoyed this collab! especially with the production issues i think it turned out pretty good. my favorite parts were jojo, voyage 1969, brain power, marshall maximizer, itte, and koronba. also the inclusion of sexting and cookie summer beach was unexpected. Thank you for the good weather!!
一番好きな合作MAD
Excuse me for my poor English. I love this collab too! but why complainers demand high quality for a gay porn video and amateur voice drama 13 years ago?
色んな国の人が協力してこんな大作作ってんの感動
まじ映像も音声も最高峰やろ
11:04あさやけ☆があるの最高ッスよ〜
1:48〜からのボカロパートすき
the marshall maximizer part is my fav, love who ever worked on it
クオリティ高杉ィ！
というか一人自分の国家建国してる人いて草
クッキー☆10thと11thのクオリティーが高すぎたから海外兄貴が「イマイチだな…」って苦言を呈してるんだと思う。俺も個人的に昔の方が選曲を含めて好きだしその気持ちわかるけど、ブチギレ必要はないでしょ。今回編集力はかなり高い。
玄人も新進気鋭もみんなで集まってひとつの作品を創り上げてくのが1番エモいってそれ一
てか海外ニキにもクッキー☆人気なのか〔困惑〕
6:38ここ感動したwww
pomping→天気で韻踏んでて気持ちええw
6:52音圧が足らん、あまりに綺麗
これでクオリティがどうとか言ってるやつ普段何見てんだよ！作ろうと思ったらとんでもない時間かかるぞ！
ク✩は永遠に紡がれる！
今年もやってくれたのまじでありがてぇ、ありがとナス
Интересно.
野球から始まったすごい技術！
これってコメント荒れてるのは海外の身内ネタなの？それとも評論家が増えすぎただけ？
年々技術が向上してるのがわかるのいいゾ〜これ
ニコニコもようつべも伸び悩んでて悲しいなぁ…
これからは俺達新世代が立たせてやる可能性濃い、濃くない？
あっ、おい待てい！
ビリビリは4万再生だゾ
はぇ～、すっごい再生されてる…
This is legend! ☆☆
神っぽいなめっちゃ好き！
ク☆が続いていくのはいいゾ〜コレ
Nunca perdí la fe
P.D.: Devuelvanme mi fe
c mamut
中 日 友 好 靠 曲 奇
The Easter part had me smiling the entire time it's so sweet
In hindsight: I think collaborations like NYD or 音MAD x artist have severely skewed expectations of smaller collaborations like this one. Cookie☆ is a celebration of artistic creativity. And this collab excelled in that. I personally still enjoyed this one start to finish.
But there’s something important to remember: cookie☆ is decreasing in popularity. It is not 2018 anymore. And many talented creators have moved on. A drop in quality and quantity is to be expected.
一 生 ネ ッ ト の 喋 る 笛
I think the collab varied in quality a lot throughout because of some of the creators not having enough experience, especially with the audio, but some parts were pretty good
海外でもクッキー⭐︎が普及してるのは考え深い
外国人がクッキー☆と淫夢認知してて誇らしいよ、俺
6:38 RIM一家好き
7:35 いいゾ〜これ
love this anime❤
野獣罠とANNYUI姉貴罠のところで家で1人なのに周りキョロキョロしちゃった😂毎回技術高いし面白いし、今年も楽しませてもらいました‼️
特地使用魔法来这里看非中国特供版……不得不说，把银梦本篇画面换成潮汕英豪传真的天才
really love あさやけもゆうやけもないんだ
これは名作
神っぽいな好きすぎると思ったらねこちゃん兄貴やんけ！
ANNYUI姉貴多い...多くない？
でもクオリティTKSGだからOKか
ていうかSNくんはよく協力してくれましたね...(0:17)
ヴォ野獣+1969点本当に好きすぎて絶頂しちゃった
すごい
★★★★★ クッキー☆大好き太郎
ニッコニコで見ましたわ、感動した。
Masterpiece
才能の無駄遣いやけどこれからも作ってくれ！
クッキー☆界隈は天才しかいないのか？
I liked it
DEEP♂DARK♂FANTASY
とりあえず、13周年おめでとうございます
13周年 祝 이거지~
Cool
❤
when is medley gonna gonna come out?
PART 4 COOKIE THE WORLD IS COMPLETE
why are likes disabled wut
one of the best videos i have ever watched i love cookie star
外国コメントしかなくて笑う
1:48
「神っぽいな」カッコ良すぎる！
7:14
マーシャルマキシマイザーの単品どこにあるのやら
淫スト版、まーだ時間かかりそうですかね〜？
Alright, jokes aside, I think this collab is overhated, I mean, even if how the hosting went poorly, some participants did gave on their entry, and whoever tried to do their best should be proud.
F adal tho
ベストを尽くせば結果は出せる(至言)
wow how is it hated? the song selection is goated and the visuals as good as they ever were. 11th medley stays my most favorite tho
あさやけパートすこなのだ
1:47
Я счастлив жить в одно время с создателями этого произведения
どうしてテスト前日に出すんだ(歓喜)
Cool collab
marvelous
Loved Wario's Goldmine
Leave
@@dsakn6884 ?
Stay
@@__-hx8gu 😊
just kiddng@@LeClusterFunk
昔よりクオリティーが少し低かったぐらいでキレちゃだめでしょ。
一段时间没回B站，现在中华兄贵技术力提升得好快啊
是的呢（讚賞）
最後的部分太棒了
810 Store
Malmen plofs company
世界レベル
I'm new here, why is there drama now, i don't understand
Same I don't get it
Amazing work!!!
中華兄貴大勝利☆
普通に東方を色々調べてたらこんな所来ちゃったけどなんだこれぇ…。ただ私は純粋に当方の二次創作を見たいだけという…()
私みたいに純粋に東方系を見に来たらク☆にたどり着いてしまった人はどのぐらいいるんだ…？(((
てかク☆の二次創作だけクオリティ高すぎ…えぇ…？これからも頑張ってください皆さん…。
あさやけもゆうやけもないんだ 好き 11:03
Nice collab, Fiiinally i see "sexting", "あさやけもゆうやけもないんだ", and "Say It" doing good use, And while some parts legit gives me some questions/doubts, some parts manage to get the job done. Now if you worked on the collab, i hope that you had an enjoyable experience, but keep in mind to get more skilled, more creative, get better.
These comments are the exact reason why YTPMVers don't get friends, let alone girlfriends.
What is so bad about this collab? None of the entries are off-pitch, the visuals are S tier for what most of these people commenting "GRR BAD COLLAB" make.
But obviously because it's not Octagon or Old Spice and it doesn't have the "big names" (who should move on instead of making these videos in their middle 20s) then it gets deleted.
I'm LMAOing your lives!
Lack of inmu
mcafee antivirus
Honestly as a ytpmver I just gave up interacting with most of the community this stuff is so embarrassing, I'm sorry to all the outsiders who don't get context for the unnecessary drama and bs that goes on. People take this shit too seriously, lol.
Epic
yattaze
残念な部分が少しあるけど、クッキーの新しい合作を見ることができて嬉しい！ 皆さんお疲れ様でした
何があったんだ？
探してた
9:00
8:00 lol
😱🙈🔥🔥🔥🔥!!!🙉😭😭!!
中2でこの動画に出会えて感謝
堕ちたのか…
@@zako_bottomああ、
Meh collab. A couple parts were good, but not much to rave and love about. And I would have to agree with what Beazty said. The collab would have been better if someone else who knows what the source is truly capable of would have hosted it, the collab would have been better. 4.5/10.
Oh we surely missed you being a participant, your part would have made eeveeerything sooooo much better
最高だ
確かに先の淫ク☆madと比べてクオリティは下がってますよ...
けど100点満点を維持するのは困難だから多少はね？
13年経っても続いてる方が可笑しいんよな....
야수선배랑 뽀뽀하고싶다
やっと来てくれたか