This intrigued me. I never really thought about the fact that there were concept ideas for the first few. I knew Firey HAD to be one of the first. But Woody, Teardrop, Spongy and MATCH?! Like I said, this was interesting to learn and it honestly makes me love the characters even more now! Loved the video, Cary, keep up the great work! >:)
I was actually wondering about it so long. I was thinking that Match had a lot more of a connection to Firey initially, than it seems currently. 4:00 all this time, I thought this was the relationships visualization! Also, Firey being both the very first character created and the first BFDI winner is a very cool coincedence.
they have such big sister and little brother vibes in the comics... plus match was shown to be a very smart gal, like when she helped firey with the sudoku and when she won the spelling contest in TFI. there was also this school planner thingy i found in the bfdi google drive and some of the pages had comics and stuff on them, one of them was an IQ ranking and match was at the top with an IQ of 145, which means she qualifies as a genius. im kinda obsessed with smart match lol i wish she was more like that in the show
Fun fact, Rock Paper Scissors in Swedish (Sten, Sax, Påse) translates to ”Rock, Paper, Bag”, so the analogy of paper covers the rock works a lot better, as in the rock gets contained within the bag
Could you imagine an RPS game with ALL the BFDI, BFDIA and BFB characters? Black hole would probably be pretty overpowered, but it'd be quite fun and interesting.
4:53 BFDI has such a huge impact on my life, some of my own comic characters are based off of some of the contestants, along with the art style. And my main character (the one on my pfp) is based off of both Mario and Firey
Another reason is that most of them are gimmicks. If you think about it (in season 1 at least) firey is basically just a normal guy match is a gossip girl woody is scared teardrop doesn’t talk and spongy is fat
According to the bfdi character guide, Cary and Michael were thinking about making a reasonable rock paper scissors variant called water, fire, and sponge... and I'm pretty sure Woody and Match were the first 2 new characters in the firey comic strips they made......... I think :)
Match and Teardrop are literally one of my fav characters but they’re so underrated😭‼️ its actually crazy considering they were the first ones made as well🥲
Hm, truly this was interesting! This is indeed ambitious, I loved learning about this, this is really cool! This video was truly amazing Cary, thank you for this amazing video! Sincerely, One.
If I were woody I would climb through spongy, eat teardrop and create the universe and nickel. Then I would proceed to transend mortal understanding into a higher form existence. Then I would proceed to eat every single Venus-flytraps.
In the malaysian version of rock paper scissors, it's rock, water, bird. Rock sinks in water, water gets drank by the bird, and the rock kills the bird.
6:36 this reminds me of how i think in like 2016-2017 safeway changed their slogan from "Ingredients for Life" to "It's Just Better" i think i prefer dangerousway's slogan lmao
i had a version of rps i played with my mom where we'd play whatever we wanted and debate which one would win. like, pliers vs scissors, duck vs gun, knife vs suitcase, bee vs wall etc
everyone kind of knew that firey was probably one of the first characters created, but i actually didnt know that woody and teardrop were also one of the first characters created!
aw man, i took pride in my favorite character, match, being one of the original 5 contestants but now i know that there was an original three before her 😔😔 anyway we have similar senses of humor cary. this catalogue is a lot like the commercials i made in 6th grade for spelling homework. there was a selection of things we could do each week, and i tried a different one each time, but when i tried the commercial, it was so fun i decided to make one every week. i may actually have been influenced by bfdi, as 6th grade is when i discovered it and after writing my first commercial, my brother said it sounded like a yellow face commercial. anyway the type of humor here is similar to what i used, as well as the occasional dark joke (some of my employees never returned from their space mission...) but unlike you, whose prices are actually very low, i made mine rather expensive. probably influenced by the prices on yellow face's products. but my school account was recently deactivated so i lost all of these 😔 except for the 2 i turned into comics
My friend and I (Grade 5) are actually making comics about inanimate objects. Well, it was my friend's idea, he watched BFDI way before I did and he influenced me to watch it too, we both have watched every episode of each season by now. Back to the comic, my friend does the main episodes and I do the inbetweens. So, it's like he does Episode 1 and I do Episode 1 and 1/2. So yeah, that's about it. I'm still trying to find a way on how to animate these comics, kinda like BFDI but there isn't any battles or competitions, just some funny stuff.
1:25 the paper wraps around the rock (which is presumably round enough to not rip the paper) when i was in primary school when we did rock paper scissors the one that won would pretend to do the corresponding action on the other players hand, and i havent seen like anyone else play it like that but it made it a lot more clear how paper beat rock i think we also had this stupid version of rock paper scissors where you would just make something up on the spot. gun was iconic obviously, if you wanted to win instantly you would play blackhole, if you wanted to win against _blackhole_ you would play _whitehole_ which i dont think we were even too clear on the realness of but it _sounded_ like it would beat blackhole and that was enough for it to do so
When I was seven or eight, my first characters were Bill and Bob, but my very first Hudaon original-related thought was Macrower Goes To School, and Macrower himself wasn’t the first character. I created the Bird to the City character back in 2014, and also four kawaii characters who are an owl, lamb, frog and pirate pig (my pirate pig was the first character to be a reference). And before Alphabet Lore existed, I created characters who are the letter Sha, Deh, Yo, C cedilla, Tse and Omega (Ш Д Ё Ç Ц Ω). When I was twelve, my brother thought of animal versions of people and gave me the idea for Oscar Ostrich, the mascot of my channel. I created characters who are food in 2019 and 2020, and in 2022 and 2023, I created more animal versions of people. And here I am now, making series that I dreamt of making when I was little.
The fact that probably the most iconic corner of the internet's very first igniting spark was some 9-year-old being like "Hey, why _does_ paper beat rock?" is so funny and human to me.
You might not see this but i wanna ask, were there any characters you or Michael had considered for bfdi’s first season that ended up never going anywhere? Just a question I thought of watching this
I figured out about this "rock-paper-scissors" thing back when you showed old drawings where it was depicted who could "defeat" whom (or it was in the files, I don't remember)
i didn't know firey, teardrop, and spongy were based on rock paper scissors. this is a genuine good character designing technique 👀 edit: i still wonder if there were any bfdi/object show characters that existed in your mind before you made the firey comic that would be a good lore but it's still rly impossible to remember that X_X
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
The BFDI meta:
-Set things on fire
-Don't be flammable
Fr
“If you want to live a happy, fulfilling life… set things on fire!” ~ Pin
@@Hamburger8079”The flames will solve everything!”
There is also David
He wins every match up exept fire
Fire needs a nerf
Man, how bad of a nerf did Firey get
ah yes, the elements. fire, water, and of course, sponge
And WOOD
Where's earth? (Woody)
and wood
And Earth
and arson
the ONE foreshadow is insane
I cant believe it
It's actually crazy I'm so dumbfounded.
Imagine being the teacher who graded that assignment
"holy sh** why did he make a comic its only for making a fake catalog"
@@m30w13X3the teacher seeing cary with the bfdi plushes:💀
Little did they know they started an entire multiverse
0:12 “long before time had a name, there was, *the(se) five.”*
LONG BEFORE TIME HAD A NAME, THE FIRST SPINJITZU MASTER CREATED NINJAGO USING 4 ELEMENTAL WEAPONS
@@saboriineelong before time had a name…
STOP TALKING ABOUT THIS!
@@SiddharthSherpa-x2l 😢
This intrigued me. I never really thought about the fact that there were concept ideas for the first few. I knew Firey HAD to be one of the first. But Woody, Teardrop, Spongy and MATCH?! Like I said, this was interesting to learn and it honestly makes me love the characters even more now!
Loved the video, Cary, keep up the great work! >:)
Imagine if these five were the ONLY ones to compete in BFDI.
WOOWWW
AMAZINGGNGG
mist or beast?
Probably would be a point-based show then.
Can you do if my schizophrenic hallucinations were on BFB teams?
“I’m like, anti-impressed, I’m like, de-pressed- not depressed-“ Cary 2024
unimpressed, cary. the word is unimpressed.
Liy be like
Nah, that’s match
Where did he say it
@@KorbenD07 at 9:09
“I am fire! I can burn anyone as I wish!”
*TD appears*
@@AustinGoode591"E-Except you..."
E-except you
@@AustinGoode591e-except you…
@@AustinGoode591E-Except you....
I was actually wondering about it so long. I was thinking that Match had a lot more of a connection to Firey initially, than it seems currently.
4:00 all this time, I thought this was the relationships visualization! Also, Firey being both the very first character created and the first BFDI winner is a very cool coincedence.
BECAUSE THEY DOOO THEYRE DATIIING FATCH 1000% CANON
@@someoadamson9073Nuh uh
"uhhh, actually, pencil won total firey island which would be the first ever season
As a water, I can confirm firey can NOT burn anyone he wishes
as a fire, i confirm that teardrop does not burn but BOIL
@@voiky752as another fire, i confirm that spongy does not burn but DISINTEGRATES (start chain)
As oxygen I can confirm that fire can't burn every he wishes
I’m not even gonna be surprised when I look at the wiki page for Firey’s gallery and see Cary’s hand
hi
And teardrops
and spongys
5:59 I wouldn’t be surprised if the wiki editors changed it to “Dangerousway Catalogue” the millisecond he said that.
well i dont know when exactly it happened ofc but i checked it rn and its there
do these people even sleep lol
are those people real???
I love it how younger Cary was like: my paper scissors rock game will have elements! Fire, water and.....
*SPONGE*
Tbf, a sponge absorbs water way faster than grass! But not really an element when it immediately becomes *WET SPONGE*
I REALLY wish we could see more of Firey and Match interactions nowadays
fr, even with how they changed throughout the series they would still work with each other very well
Fr😭😭😭 they gave me childhood friend vibes
FR, I like both characters and seeing them interact would be interesting :)
Yeah, I used to ship them. I hope in Season 6 they can interact
they have such big sister and little brother vibes in the comics... plus match was shown to be a very smart gal, like when she helped firey with the sudoku and when she won the spelling contest in TFI. there was also this school planner thingy i found in the bfdi google drive and some of the pages had comics and stuff on them, one of them was an IQ ranking and match was at the top with an IQ of 145, which means she qualifies as a genius. im kinda obsessed with smart match lol i wish she was more like that in the show
Cary's creations with BFDI are great!
i like leafy
I like woody
Gosh.. bfdi’s history is so interesting. I’m also interested in rock paper scissors but I didn’t know you made a show out of it!
That's actually really cool, i love it when creator's characters line up with an irl story it's really interesting to me >:3
EARLY TO A CARY POST I HAVE WON!! also teardrop spotted im very happy and excited now cant wait to watch video
If rock paper scissors didn't exist, BFDI wouldn't exist
Petition for Nathon to be in the next BFDI season
Yes
signed
guys my friends brothers uncle works at jnj and they told me that in tpot episode 2763 nathon wins tpot!!!!!1! its really real trust me!!!!!11!1!
Pretty awesome how this just went from a simple fun game, to a successful series !
2:52 wow teardrop looked weird back then. Im glad the redesign looked a bit more like water!
It's scary how the wiki remembers more about Cary's childhood than he does for a few things
Real
Also Match is the first ever FreeSmarter to be made.
and pencil is the first freesmarter to win a season!
@@NylaaTheNeedleFan i was ab to ask when she won but then i remembered tfi exists... does that mean pencil is canonically rich??
@@shiny_crystal I mean, how else is she able to get the freesmart vans
@@Yoriya-real true, true
she’s so rich she got 2 vans and a rocket.
Fun fact, Rock Paper Scissors in Swedish (Sten, Sax, Påse) translates to ”Rock, Paper, Bag”, so the analogy of paper covers the rock works a lot better, as in the rock gets contained within the bag
This is so cool!! You were even a genius as a kid LOL. It’s nice to see my fav girly from my fav duo be one of the originals (Match ofc) :).
Cary, don't you know? Profiley was the first, not them!
Facts
how can the literal creator forget something like this smh 🤦
Bruh that's true🤓👆
Fr!!1!
here before Cary mentions this comment in another video
Match has been slaying for 16 years 💅💅💅
is it actually 16 years or only 14..
@@jordynn2763 She was created in comics in 2008
@@jordynn2763 Well, Match existen before BFDI even started, so yeah, it has been 16 years
Yes queen
HELL YEAHHH i love her so much
the fact we (probably) could've gotten grassy in bfdi if cary played pokemon
Could you imagine an RPS game with ALL the BFDI, BFDIA and BFB characters? Black hole would probably be pretty overpowered, but it'd be quite fun and interesting.
We already know that ain’t nobody using bubble😭
Get a life
@@Circle2947 that’s kinda unnecessary-
What about firey?
@@bealea1127 pretty sure he would easily destroy most of the cast
Except for opposites and metal contestants
4:53 BFDI has such a huge impact on my life, some of my own comic characters are based off of some of the contestants, along with the art style. And my main character (the one on my pfp) is based off of both Mario and Firey
I love how Cary forgot the word unimpressed and just went straight to depressed and anti-impressed.
It's so cool that Firey, Match, Teardrop, Woody and Spongy was based off Rock, Paper, Scissors.
Another reason is that most of them are gimmicks. If you think about it (in season 1 at least) firey is basically just a normal guy match is a gossip girl woody is scared teardrop doesn’t talk and spongy is fat
In post split, he is a normal guy
but in Bfdi bfdia and IDFB he is just dumb
a calm game caused a paradox in the Osc universe?
This is what I like!
According to the bfdi character guide, Cary and Michael were thinking about making a reasonable rock paper scissors variant called water, fire, and sponge... and I'm pretty sure Woody and Match were the first 2 new characters in the firey comic strips they made......... I think :)
Nope the order is:Firey, Woody,Teardrop,Match,Spongy
@@nimishasharma3430
Firey: I am fire!
Woody: Ahhh!
Firey: I can burn anyone as I wish!
*Teardrop Comes In*
Firey: Eugh except you!
i miss when match had more character then being pencils bestie
Match and Teardrop are literally one of my fav characters but they’re so underrated😭‼️ its actually crazy considering they were the first ones made as well🥲
Yes, match is underrated
But teardrop isn’t she’s probably one of the most popular characters in the show
I'm happy that Spongy is one of the first, he's my favorite bfdi character in the whole series!!! (tied with horrifying sludge of course)
I was scared you were not going to mention horrifying sludge for a second, like shes such a diva 💅🏾💅🏾
@@diwodisventurecamp so true
My favs are Marker, Spongy, TD, TB, Freesmart + Needlelingtin
The same, but mine includes TV, tying both of them together.
My favorite characters ever are Naily, woody, price tag, grassy, kind of ice cube, kind of remote, and yea. That’s it
Hm, truly this was interesting! This is indeed ambitious, I loved learning about this, this is really cool! This video was truly amazing Cary, thank you for this amazing video! Sincerely, One.
In an alternate universe we would've gotten Nathon instead of Battle For Dream Island
More backstories too the 2008 version of bfdi/ total firey island LETS GO
If I were woody I would climb through spongy, eat teardrop and create the universe and nickel. Then I would proceed to transend mortal understanding into a higher form existence. Then I would proceed to eat every single Venus-flytraps.
Real
Wow, that is relatable!
In the malaysian version of rock paper scissors, it's rock, water, bird. Rock sinks in water, water gets drank by the bird, and the rock kills the bird.
I already have my cast for object society, but this is definently a fun way to make characters.
How do you have more subscribers than me you don't even make videos
Absolutely none of my object shows have been successful
@@diogocaetano1REAL comments
And irl friends
It would be really cool if firey spongy and teardrop were the finalist🔥🧽💧
Firey is a bfdi icon
We have very similar minds Cary
When I was in 3rd grade I found the same rock paper scissors problem so I made fire ice water
Fire->ice->water->fire
I always loved how in Early bfdi match and firey were friends, it was neat
We need the Match and Fiery friendship once again
6:36 this reminds me of how i think in like 2016-2017 safeway changed their slogan from "Ingredients for Life" to "It's Just Better"
i think i prefer dangerousway's slogan lmao
The entire catalog is probably the inspiration for yellow face
i had a version of rps i played with my mom where we'd play whatever we wanted and debate which one would win. like, pliers vs scissors, duck vs gun, knife vs suitcase, bee vs wall etc
KNIFE VS SUITCASE FROM II217!>!?!?@@!?@!?@?!?!??
The third one was on purpose
@@cubechan1938 yeah
Glad Spongy is one of the original 5 💪
the sponge is the GOAT himself
🧽💪
Nah actually in the original 3
@@OfcourseJimmy000even in the original 3
Of course you are here
everyone kind of knew that firey was probably one of the first characters created, but i actually didnt know that woody and teardrop were also one of the first characters created!
7:56 HEAR ME OUT! ONE LIAM SMILE AND AIRY SPOTTED?
i was about to say that
aw man, i took pride in my favorite character, match, being one of the original 5 contestants but now i know that there was an original three before her 😔😔
anyway we have similar senses of humor cary. this catalogue is a lot like the commercials i made in 6th grade for spelling homework. there was a selection of things we could do each week, and i tried a different one each time, but when i tried the commercial, it was so fun i decided to make one every week. i may actually have been influenced by bfdi, as 6th grade is when i discovered it and after writing my first commercial, my brother said it sounded like a yellow face commercial. anyway the type of humor here is similar to what i used, as well as the occasional dark joke (some of my employees never returned from their space mission...) but unlike you, whose prices are actually very low, i made mine rather expensive. probably influenced by the prices on yellow face's products. but my school account was recently deactivated so i lost all of these 😔 except for the 2 i turned into comics
Im surprised and mindblown that cary still knows this from 16 years ago all in plot.
I think it’s interesting how close fire sponge water is to the fire water grass trio in Pokémon.
My friend and I (Grade 5) are actually making comics about inanimate objects. Well, it was my friend's idea, he watched BFDI way before I did and he influenced me to watch it too, we both have watched every episode of each season by now. Back to the comic, my friend does the main episodes and I do the inbetweens. So, it's like he does Episode 1 and I do Episode 1 and 1/2. So yeah, that's about it. I'm still trying to find a way on how to animate these comics, kinda like BFDI but there isn't any battles or competitions, just some funny stuff.
Can’t wait for Nathon to host BFDI season 6!
The hidden origins of Yellow Face and his strange products.
It would be so interesting to see these 5 interact with eachother more, especially firey and match
The fact two of these guys are my favorites (Spongy and Woody)
@CRRRAAAZZZZYYYY oh hey another spongy fan!!!
@@Mega-MSM us Spongy fans need to unite
@@CRRRAAAZZZZYYYY yes, there are too many spongy haters
Woody my GOAT
Spongy was and still is one of my favourites Team Spongy!!!!
1:02 e-exept you.
Teardrop is immune.
Spongy
7:31 is this what inspired Yellow Face?
Yay cary uploaded🔥🔥🔥🔥
the first character created won the first season.
He's like Makoto Naegi
I enjoy watching your videos and BFDI
This is what makes the characters special.
Their creations have a lot of science behind them.
Match being created first is kina ironic because Pencil overshadowes her
now im just curious what an object show with the Dangerousway Catalog items would look like
Bfb was so good they made fire a real thing
1:25 the paper wraps around the rock (which is presumably round enough to not rip the paper)
when i was in primary school when we did rock paper scissors the one that won would pretend to do the corresponding action on the other players hand, and i havent seen like anyone else play it like that but it made it a lot more clear how paper beat rock i think
we also had this stupid version of rock paper scissors where you would just make something up on the spot. gun was iconic obviously, if you wanted to win instantly you would play blackhole, if you wanted to win against _blackhole_ you would play _whitehole_ which i dont think we were even too clear on the realness of but it _sounded_ like it would beat blackhole and that was enough for it to do so
not cary confirming the exact name of the game he created as a kid by checking the bfdi wiki 💀
beefy die lore
Such dreamy island
island dreamy Such
dreamy Such island
If dreamy, then only island!
dreamy island such
"I thought these are funny but they're not" I think they're kinda funny tbh.
There were five nations : fire, water, wood, sponge and match
But it all changed when the fire nation attacked
Man, I really wish I lived in the Battle For Dust Island timeline
Didn't thought sponges were born before rocks,leaves and black holes
When I was seven or eight, my first characters were Bill and Bob, but my very first Hudaon original-related thought was Macrower Goes To School, and Macrower himself wasn’t the first character. I created the Bird to the City character back in 2014, and also four kawaii characters who are an owl, lamb, frog and pirate pig (my pirate pig was the first character to be a reference). And before Alphabet Lore existed, I created characters who are the letter Sha, Deh, Yo, C cedilla, Tse and Omega (Ш Д Ё Ç Ц Ω).
When I was twelve, my brother thought of animal versions of people and gave me the idea for Oscar Ostrich, the mascot of my channel. I created characters who are food in 2019 and 2020, and in 2022 and 2023, I created more animal versions of people. And here I am now, making series that I dreamt of making when I was little.
Teardrop…my beloved
my headcanon on why paper beats rock is because paper covers rock, suffocating it in the process
The fact that probably the most iconic corner of the internet's very first igniting spark was some 9-year-old being like "Hey, why _does_ paper beat rock?" is so funny and human to me.
You know that kind of makes sense.I love it 😊😊😊❤
1:25 glad im not the only one who thinks that, whenever I ask that, people say paper suffocates rock but rocks can't breathe...
no rock paper scissors = no bfdi
Nice!
(im still recovering from ii 17)
I still need to pay for treatment
You might not see this but i wanna ask, were there any characters you or Michael had considered for bfdi’s first season that ended up never going anywhere? Just a question I thought of watching this
The way that none of these guys are competing currently-
I figured out about this "rock-paper-scissors" thing back when you showed old drawings where it was depicted who could "defeat" whom (or it was in the files, I don't remember)
6:56 Is Nathon the same guy that starred in your Stagecast game 'Nate Jumps', which was remade as 'No Walking, No Problem'?
When I saw the selling for free I randomly got a flashback of my friend paying me after I gave him a uno reverse-
7:37 hfjone face before hfjone existed
the liam smile 😭
i didn't know firey, teardrop, and spongy were based on rock paper scissors. this is a genuine good character designing technique 👀
edit: i still wonder if there were any bfdi/object show characters that existed in your mind before you made the firey comic that would be a good lore but it's still rly impossible to remember that X_X
Nathon huh?
"Im highly offended" -NickLe
I read nation
This is so cute I love learning about old beefy die
Right at the start I noticed the rock, paper, scissors update and realized why they were the first