Annette Harvey: Murder Victim Told Me I Was Being Brainwashed
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- Defendant Annette Harvey concluded direct-examination detailing her mental health issues, saying that victim Robin Leonard accused her of being "brainwashed" by her own husband.
#CourtTV What do YOU think?
MORE HERE: www.courttv.co...
#annetteharvey
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.co...
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.co...
FOLLOW THE CASE: Facebook / courttv Twitter/X / courttv Instagram / courttvnetwork TikTok / courttvlive RUclips / courttv
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.co...
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.co...
#CourtTV Learn more about Annette Harvey here: www.courttv.com/news/tn-v-annette-harvey-murder-between-mothers-trial/?
Why is this lawyer leading every question and prosecutor isnt objecting??
Agreed
Why do I feel like I'm watching a court case from the 70s
😂😂😂😂
@WhitneyMerten-hb3tc what do you mean?
@@TinyRanterI thought it was Tennessee?
I think it’s that trendy dress and hairstyle 😅
@@leslievasquez2645
It was Tennessee. She specifically talks about TBI, which is the Tennessee Bureau of Investigations.
with a mental illness myself I don't like how she's blaming her friend just my opinion
She knows what she did and she’s totally externalizing blame on her supposed bff. This is what a person with a personality would do. She has a clear secondary mental illness (cluster b, antisocial personality disorder) which is evident throughout the trial. She needs prison. This woman is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt and in my opinion is suffering from a severe personality disorder. She staged everything thinking she can outsmart ppl with her antics. Not me! Can’t fool me!😊
In her terrified state of mind, she shouldn't have the children. They shouldn't be around that.
Wasn't that why they were with her friend(s)?
Wait until you hear her on cross. Her go to answer was I don't remember. I got tired of hearing it so I stopped watching. So pathetic. What a waste of taxpayer money on this basket case
Where is the cross? I can't find it.
Where is cross???
Annette Harvey received life in prison for murdering Robin!!
"No it wasn't impounded it was taken a lot, what do you call those big old lots?" Impound lots.
This is the strangest format of questioning I’ve ever seen.
Leading questions by defence attorney. Thank God she was found guilty.
They love to call them 'track' phones, when we all know them as burner phones to get away with crimes.
Lawyer isn’t listening obviously.
Keeps asking the same questions.
Talk about leading questions!! But no one is objecting...
Why is he allowed to lead in direct examination. This is not cross.
I don't know much about this case. In my opinion I think this unusual cross examination is bc they believe she was having a mental breakdown or temporary insane! I find it's ridiculous what it takes to be legally insane or suffering an acute mental breakdown in the 🇺🇸 Courts. Even people who have been legally insane although the offender doesn't agree when they are asked if they knew right from wrong & they answer yes.With that said in most cases you're charged anyway bc you said yes & receive treatment then deemed okay to go to trial & then convicted & sent away for life! I remember watching a TV Documentary where the inmates wanted this young man out of their pod telling the prison guards he needs to be in a Mental Hospital he doesn't belong here. They we're scared of what he might do bc he didn't like taking his meds & they can't force him too either. They've been attacked luckily he's not a big guy rather skinny but he was that disturbed. Being in prison didn't bother him he didn't seem to grasp reality. Some ppl belong in a locked down Mental Hospital where there is a 3 or 4 Tier system getting them on proper medications & seeing professionals, group meetings very strict conditions. It can take 10 years or longer too to get them well before they go out with an escort for a couple of hours to see how they do bc some are scared to leave. Then it takes another 6 months or longer until they are prepared to live with another person in an assisted living apartment & gain employment. Some will never get out usually due to severe trauma as a child. The police & authorities know where they are & once out the hospital has an open door policy & number if they have any difficulties or concerns. They keep prisoners in the 🇺🇸 who are to violent serving Life Sentences instead of bring back the death penalty & spend the money on hospitals for those who need it. They need to teach prisoners a Trade so when they do get out they can find work if they really want to take advantage of their 2nd chance. Sorry for the rant! Prisons shouldn't be privatized either & no one selling weed should be locked away in prison & I don't smoke weed. Ontario, 🇨🇦 🐾
It’s just strategy. They’re banking on a not guilty by reason of insanity. Verdict. Bad strategy IMO.
Lol just posted same
Her husband stated she had changed after the visit in Tennessee, that the ride back home was the strangest. Just my opinion but she had untreated mental disorder , became extremely paranoid , thinking she was followed, feeling husband was going to unalive her. Then on top of untreated mental disorder she is drinking, and smoking pot both can alter the thinking . Can’t wait to hear from the psychologist , hopefully she had mental evaluation. I’d like to hear more about this alcohol and substance use , since she has portrayed herself as woman of faith with the Pastor as the one to get advice from and follow his advice. She’s clearly manipulative and takes no accountability , blamed the victim, the pastor, and paranoia.
Exactly!
I don’t think they called a mental health expert. Tennessee is different: if you use a diminished capacity or mental health/insanity defense you actually can’t use an expert to prove it.
Well, Annette Harvey got life in prison where she belongs!! Robin, the murder victim had custody of Annette’s children because Annette was a horrible mother!! Robin did many things to help others!!
@@daddyboy3546So you can just say I'm mentally ill & no psych evaluation? That doesnt sound legal. 1. You have to provide evidence of your defense claim otherwise it's just 'he said, she said'. 2. Mental incapacity means you had no ability to use reason & logic, so you go to a psych unit not a prison.
Seems she was simply totally jealous of Robyn imo.
Robin was her best friend since middle school
I'm just catching up on this trial, but if seems very strange. I don't think it was that she was jealous of Robyn, I think she definitely had some sort of mental break from stress.
@@theropesofrenovation9352that means she couldn’t be envious of her more accomplished friend while her own life is a mess, no career, no purpose in life!
Well, I think you’re on to something there. They went to school together, Robin was successful in her career, owned her house. This hot mess was none of those things.
@@theropesofrenovation9352so whats your point exactly?!? You’ve never been jealous of a friend before?!? I know I have been!!! And when you read up on the facts there was a lot for her to be jealous of!!!!
What a sorry excuse for a human being! 😢😢😢
The bruises don't help the accused. They show that Robin, the victim fought for her life when the accused attacked her.
Do these people have an aversion to seeking help when things dont seem quite right?
From having had a bi polar co worker, getting them to admit they're spiralling down if off meds is very hard. When I visited them in the psych unit they often hid her meds in yoghurt, because they developed the delusion that the meds were 'poison'.
I made it up ... I dont think I was lying. which is it love? This woman has watched too many cartoons.
She is very manipulative - doesn't think before she is saying something, for example about the phone.....how did she knew she had medicine to pic up? She had been very occupied several days, she had no phone, allegedly. To remember what you only want to remember, to not remember the horrible she did is a total lie. Calculated, evil, entitled, know at all - pretending to cry on key is very telling to me. Is it the prosecutor or the defense attorney who is questioning her here? I have only seen the defense asking questions. Nobody who calling out her lies. OMG she is so fake - sociopath!
I think Annette wants to appear mentally fragile or insane so she won’t have the book thrown at her. I see malice.
So do I.
She is lying. She recalls everything in great detail except the stabbing. Bullshit
@@hautefemme49 Exactly. I agree. Selective amnesia.
I think they’re going to throw the book at her anyway!!!
I just heard of this case today and have been listening to her testimony and Alexander’s testimony and read some articles about the case. What I wonder is why the defense did not have a medical professional testify to back her diagnosis?
Seems to me that would be extremely important and why I think she will have the book thrown at her HARD!
If you’re going to plead diminished capacity you better have a professional back you and not just expect the jury to take yours and others words for your bad behavior.
Does anyone know if the entire trial is posted somewhere. I can only find Alexander, Annette’s testimony and opening statements.
It’s weird how she keeps having to correct him and I understand what she says the first time.
I wondered if anyone was noticing that,he is not listening, just waiting for his turn to speak and interrupts her and speaks over her and finish her sentences
Why wouldn't robin kept doors locked when her son told her not to let her in
I am just coming across this case this morning and so far I forming the opinion that there was some issues on all sides here , this Lady was terrified and the dead Lady wasn't the right person to assist her , they shared a childhood and possibly unhealed trauma.
I don’t get this attorneys approach. He acts like he doesn’t know what happened or what she’s going to say. Maybe I’m missing some strategy here…🤷🏼♀️
I feel horrible for everyone involved in this case. In my opinion this lady definitely had a major psychotic break down, and belongs in a mental health institution, not a prison.
just terrible case.
I agree, she was going through hell .
Is this a defense lawyer?
If he is..he's awful..
Between his constant sighing and not listening to his own witnesses answers..he needs to CARE...mmho
This is her lawyer.
A selective memory on parade! The mind boggles at this farce. She gives so many detailed answers, and then does the "I don't remember" routine about the stabbing. I'm not buying the convenience of her "mental illness". And even so, having a mental illness does NOT preclude the ability to know right from wrong. I hope they throw the book at her.
RIP, Robin.
Actually I can buy that. I think many of us have a point that if something clicks, we could do the most outrageous things and not remember doing it. Many people have said that they don’t remember doing things even though they did it. I think your minds shuts down to the point you lose all control, so it’s very possible she didn’t remember the incident
@@SteveJones-gz3ndit's also very possible that she's lying 🤥
@@margaretlumley1648 , I never said she wasn’t, but there have been times where I gotten so angry that I could kill someone but I probably wouldn’t remember doing it. No one knows for sure what happened and I’m sure it was traumatic for her. I mean, I don’t think she would kill he best friend for no reason
@@SteveJones-gz3ndnot violently murdering someone the way she did. She is faking the selective amnesia 🙄🙄
@@SteveJones-gz3ndlol 🤦🏽♀️
She certainly knows how to spin a yarn. Everything goes about her she wants all the attention.
She had a psychotic break down. Everyone missed it.
I didn't. I've seen this. I was in college and an acquaintance do this. I didn't know to call anyone at the time and he died. I still feel bad about this.
@@theropesofrenovation9352 …. I meant everyone in her life
@@doneldamacdonnell8602 True
@@theropesofrenovation9352 …. Forgive yourself. You are not at fault.
I agree. IMO she had some kind of Paranoid Scizophrenia or Schizoid Affctive Disorder.
Guilty in all points- verdict: life without parole. Trial finished.
SPOILER ALERT gee thanks for that
why I cannot find all the days of videos for this trial? I just found bits and pieces
I’m having same issue - so weird just bits and pieces. Can’t find her cross or the states’s closing arguments that started in Friday 🤷🏼♀️
I’ve watched just bits & pcs of testimony too. Guess there was no coverage of complete trial. Found opening statements then few testimony people, then verdict! Ugh!
My mother who is now 87, has severe mental illness. I can remember from the age of 8 that my mother wasn't okay. It was so confusing because she was okay one day and the next, she was someone else. She has paranoid schizophrenia with manic depression and anxiety. Im 51 now. I have depression and anxiety. I have forgiven her because she didn't chose this. But the 1 thing my mom did that this woman didn't do was continually seeking out mental health treatment. She went to the psych ward many times because she knew she needed to be treated because she would stop her medication when she started feeling better because she thought she would be okay. She severely abused me and my sister. We hoped it would get better as time went on but her patterns always seem to come back. She would drink alcohol and smoke cigarettes alot when she was going into her mental state. It doesn't however give her any right or any excuse if she killed me, myself or my dad. We can't justify her mental illness on murder because this women knew she wasn't well. She didn't follow up with mental health treatment. She doesn't get a pass for killing anyone. Im glad the jury wasn't persuaded by her excuses. She even laughed at times. She seems very with it now so she fully understands her illness and didn't get help for herself. She's a poor excuse for those who don't have the option of mental health. She is disgusting how she is trying to garner sympathy from everyone. When my mom was in her psychosis, she can not remember her actions fully because her brain doesn't know how to fully come to terms that she was so cruel but she always made sure she sought help to keep herself in check. She deliberately is using her mental state as an excuse for murder. Glad she's locked up forever.
Don’t like this woman. Too smooth with the mouth. Doesn’t sound like she has a mental problem now
These women criminals looks extremely different than the original pic before jail
Oh no she didnt...Yada yada? Come on lady.
Super convenient what she does as doesn’t remember (listen to her cross examination). I guess I understand the defense strategy because there is no other full defense beyond insanity but I’m sorry, I’m not buying it for a second.
I sure would like to see the rest of the trial where is it???
This lawyer is so empathetic and professional . Good man🙏⭐️
He’s asking leading questions! Not sure why prosecutor is not objecting. The fake tears and quivering, selective amnesia are most aggravating to me.
Was there a cross examination by the prosecution?
She remembers before & after this horrific attack in vivid details It might be a mental illness... But IMO it's very selective during the attack. Her ability to cry & get over it is exceptional. Tears are for herself, there's no empathy here
Does anyone know if the entire trial is posted somewhere. I can only find Alexander, Annette’s testimony and opening statements.
I don’t think court tv or any true crime played whole trial. Only got bits of testimony too, opening statements.
@@lesare6509 thank you for responding. I was wishing we could view the entire trial. Maybe someday….
This wemon is clearly mental very sad story and i pray for the victims family so heartbreaking
This lady is a froot loop,god bless her soul
This defense attorney is screwing up on the days something awful. I think by this point Robin was scared of her, because of the way she was acting. Robin should've called the cops told them what was going on and had her forcefully admitted to the phyche ward. My uncle had paranoid schizophrenia and other mental health issues he couldn't stand loud voices either. He took his medicine and so he didn't get to the point of not being able to tell fiction from reality.
My heart aches for this woman. Delusional disorder is like having your brain hijacked. So sad for the victim and their family. 😢
Just wow! 😮
So she's medicated now right?
I’ve seen a few videos of testimony & I’m not sure why there is no mention of what Annette has been diagnosed with, she must have been treated for awhile by a psychiatric doctor or a few because she now realizes it was all not real, her husband wasn’t after her, etc. I guess the incident happened awhile ago for her to now be out of the psychotic episode. It was kinda weird she thought her husband was after her but depositing money for her! I really don’t think she deserves prison for life, really should be given help & be in a mental place for a few years, based on looking at her past life & upbrining. Just my opinion.
She was on drugs she’s affected
Why this glass shield??🙈
Still up from when installed during Covid
Hi
I'm unfamiliar with this case but just began to watch and already I can say with confidence this is a case of the white trash collection album lol
Disgusting..
No, it's not. She's mentally ill. Grow the hell up
There's not much diversity in court t.v ..
And just how??? That is so dumb.
lol? Diversity? We've had everything-we have the rap case, we've got stuff like this, we had the woman who tortured her autistic son, we've had Dan Markel killed by wife's family....Montgomery....What else? Pretty diverse tbh!
@@ir9567 I was just going through the videos of Court TV and all I see is White people Court cases ..
@@lilamayoral1031do you want to see more black defendants? I assure you there’s a lot of those. The most of any group in fact. But the white people crimes are juicier.
@@kathismith7441 yes Court TV looks like the average cover of People's magazine...
How did Annette get the wound on her head in her mugshot? Did someone hit her with a baseball bat? Was it self inflicted??
Sounds like she had a marijuana psychosis. Guilty.
Annette’s my name. I see this name everywhere