that's why they the governor general is the representative of the king, why change if the system is not broken. it's been 25 years since the referendum and last 2023 the parliament have the opportunity to change the constitution unfortunately it did pursue.
Australia is a privileged and comfortable country why change the status quo. Monarchy is glamorous and republic is boring. The republic ego is unnecessary.
Thorpe is self serving and does not represent the aboriginal people. No there is not a growing sentiment to be a republic at all. The bias for being a republic is just that her bias, the speaker stating her view, not the view of the populace. One sided opinion from someone who wants a republic with a word salad stating opinion as fact. Australia has been disverse since the gold rush.
The argument of having a full time politician working for us instead does not stand. Politicians come and go. US doesn’t have a monarchy but I don’t see things being much better.
Oi Bloomberg! where was the other side of this debate? hmmmm why only show one side of the story? You really should have interviewed a Monarchist as well to balance out the "debate"
The United States kicked the British monarchy out a loooong time ago. I'm surprised that countries like Canada and Australia have taken so long to do the same.
No one here anyone wants as a president and the power that goes with it. A constitutional monarchy where the 'head' is outside politics has been just fine.
@@willow4587 Except you have a king and queen whose BORN into power. Not a good way to go about with that kind of government. That's why many countries who had a monarch got rid of them and prefer ELECTING a leadership and not from someone BORN into government.
@turbofanlover - That's because Canada and Australia are civilised nations. The US wanted out because they were told to stop purchasing and smuggling goods from nations the UK was at war with. Not to mention that whole free your slaves issue, that your constitution still keeps around. Actually read what the 13th amendment says. Americans are not a people anyone else should be imitating. And the US system of governance, is not something anyone should want to copy.
@@Ishmachiah Yeah, the United States is a complete disaster. LOL. ;) Oh, and I'm Canadian, by the way. And I don't see Canada as any more "civilized" than the mighty United States. But to each their own. :)
The biggest mistake Australia would make is to abolish its monarchy. Uncivilised behaviour like this from an excuse of a senator would be amplified by 1 thousand per cent.
How so? Its going to happen sooner or later. Many countries in recent years now have abolished their monarchy and switched over to Republic. And your king seems to be drawing protester more and more unlike Queen Elizabeth who hardly drew any kind of protesters. That should be say something right there.
King Charles III is NOT a Monarch from "another" country! He is the KING of Australia in his own right. When he was a young Prince, he spent a great deal of his youth living in Australia, going to school and living a relatively normal life. He has spent more time here than any other royal, including his mother the late Queen Elizabeth II - Esther you need to do your research before doing these interviews.
@@CheekyBird790 if you love to bow to spoiled sausage fingers then join the King cult and go live somewhere in the Woods. Dont Subject entire nations and people to your extreme ideologie.
There is no debate about becoming a Republic. You Yanks are doing a good job of demonstrating why our King and the Monarchy is a superior form of government. We are independent and welcome the visit of our King and his lovely Queen. I think the woman in the middle is talking about the role and responsibility of the Prime Minister and he doesn't give a rat's about ordinary citizens, just his new house for retirement. She's talking rubbish and does not represent most Australians.
Nope. Its your kings you had demonstrated why a monarch wasn't a good idea. Hence why many countries are now doing what we did over 200 years ago and abolish monarchy and have a leadership ELECTED not BORN.
Certainly, a republic followed by BRICS engagement could enhance trade relations. If Trump were to navigate these alliances, it could be quite beneficial. Moreover, it's crucial for individuals to release the past and acknowledge the need for global unity and progress. Observing recent world weather patterns and natural disasters, it's evident that numerous significant events are occurring concurrently.
Good Morning Majesty KING CHARLES III, in Australia huge support, excellent connection, Long live long live long live, beautiful documentary, all the congratulations, Thank you very much.
The Idea of a Kingdom is absolutely ridiculous today. England still believes they can own other Countries like Scotland and don't give them the right to choose what they want for their Future. Charles drive in a golden Carriage, don't pay Tax in England and believe that it is his Right. Pretty sure his Son will be the last King.
@@avayer849 Nothing lasts forever. And recently a few other countries have now abolished their monarchy and switched to Republic. Northern Ireland wants to split from the U.K. and rejoin Ireland which is a REPUBLIC country. Hmmm that should say something about your precious monarchy. Why continue to live in the past and paying extra taxes to someone who practically no longer have power like they used to. And if you paid attention in this video, 92% of Australians are open for a Republic. Days of monarch are over.
@@hhds113 'Nothing lasts forever' could be used for republics too. You're statistic is totally wrong, by the way. The latests poll in Australia showed support for a republic at 30%. Sounds like you have a chip on your should and, like many republicans seem to be, rather nasty.
How many times did Charles go to Epstein's island ?
$45 Trillion was taken from India by Britain over 200 years of rule
We value fairness: Aboriginals have left the chat.
that's why they the governor general is the representative of the king, why change if the system is not broken. it's been 25 years since the referendum and last 2023 the parliament have the opportunity to change the constitution unfortunately it did pursue.
Australia is a privileged and comfortable country why change the status quo. Monarchy is glamorous and republic is boring. The republic ego is unnecessary.
Thorpe is self serving and does not represent the aboriginal people. No there is not a growing sentiment to be a republic at all. The bias for being a republic is just that her bias, the speaker stating her view, not the view of the populace. One sided opinion from someone who wants a republic with a word salad stating opinion as fact. Australia has been disverse since the gold rush.
No, aboriginals don't see him as their king but a family of genocide
Britain killed 4 million Indians in Bengal in 1943 by imposing a famine
The argument of having a full time politician working for us instead does not stand. Politicians come and go. US doesn’t have a monarchy but I don’t see things being much better.
Name us any country who have a perfect government? None. Throughout human history all forms of government always has its flaws.
Oi Bloomberg! where was the other side of this debate? hmmmm why only show one side of the story? You really should have interviewed a Monarchist as well to balance out the "debate"
The United States kicked the British monarchy out a loooong time ago. I'm surprised that countries like Canada and Australia have taken so long to do the same.
No one here anyone wants as a president and the power that goes with it. A constitutional monarchy where the 'head' is outside politics has been just fine.
@@willow4587 Except you have a king and queen whose BORN into power. Not a good way to go about with that kind of government. That's why many countries who had a monarch got rid of them and prefer ELECTING a leadership and not from someone BORN into government.
Not sure the US republic is a great advertisement these days. Switzerland, perhaps, but it's a system not many countries would be able to follow.
@turbofanlover - That's because Canada and Australia are civilised nations. The US wanted out because they were told to stop purchasing and smuggling goods from nations the UK was at war with. Not to mention that whole free your slaves issue, that your constitution still keeps around. Actually read what the 13th amendment says.
Americans are not a people anyone else should be imitating. And the US system of governance, is not something anyone should want to copy.
@@Ishmachiah Yeah, the United States is a complete disaster. LOL. ;) Oh, and I'm Canadian, by the way. And I don't see Canada as any more "civilized" than the mighty United States. But to each their own. :)
"Democracy goes on a bit of a pause" bahaha
so true asuka
😮I didn't know that Australia was a part of the UK.😮
He has a ceremonial role though he’s not influencing Aussie policy at all
Of course not. But the media wants you to love the monarchy. Even though the role is purely ceremonial...
The biggest mistake Australia would make is to abolish its monarchy. Uncivilised behaviour like this from an excuse of a senator would be amplified by 1 thousand per cent.
How so? Its going to happen sooner or later. Many countries in recent years now have abolished their monarchy and switched over to Republic. And your king seems to be drawing protester more and more unlike Queen Elizabeth who hardly drew any kind of protesters. That should be say something right there.
King Charles III is NOT a Monarch from "another" country! He is the KING of Australia in his own right. When he was a young Prince, he spent a great deal of his youth living in Australia, going to school and living a relatively normal life. He has spent more time here than any other royal, including his mother the late Queen Elizabeth II - Esther you need to do your research before doing these interviews.
Royalists are Stockholm syndrome victims
He even had a girlfriend in Melbourne ....so people read the history...
@@CheekyBird790 get real the guy is german/transilvanian dont pretend hes british or Aussie.
@@akebouz Ancestry is a complicated matter but what's important is home is where your heart is, and Australia is one of the Kings homes!
@@CheekyBird790 if you love to bow to spoiled sausage fingers then join the King cult and go live somewhere in the Woods. Dont Subject entire nations and people to your extreme ideologie.
Monarchy the farewell tour is priceless, politics can f off
GOD SAVE THE KING! 🇦🇺
Showed up lookin like Captain Crunch. 😂
PRINCESS DIANA❤ (NO 2ND BEST)
There is no debate about becoming a Republic. You Yanks are doing a good job of demonstrating why our King and the Monarchy is a superior form of government. We are independent and welcome the visit of our King and his lovely Queen. I think the woman in the middle is talking about the role and responsibility of the Prime Minister and he doesn't give a rat's about ordinary citizens, just his new house for retirement. She's talking rubbish and does not represent most Australians.
Nope. Its your kings you had demonstrated why a monarch wasn't a good idea. Hence why many countries are now doing what we did over 200 years ago and abolish monarchy and have a leadership ELECTED not BORN.
@@hhds113 Still rather have a King than a president. .Do you know what your ex-president is doing to your rights?
Is this the republican debate the BBC is desperate to suggest does not exist?
Makes you wonder why, doesn't it?
The REPUBLIC OF AUSTRALIA SOUNDS RIGHT AND JUST. Little Charlie, what did you do to your late wife Diana?
Very interesting.
Your dream shall never die Alax
Stephen Benesch
You guys gave up your firearms, what are you going to do, throw big black dildos?
Certainly, a republic followed by BRICS engagement could enhance trade relations. If Trump were to navigate these alliances, it could be quite beneficial. Moreover, it's crucial for individuals to release the past and acknowledge the need for global unity and progress. Observing recent world weather patterns and natural disasters, it's evident that numerous significant events are occurring concurrently.
Long Live the Republic!
SHE AINT MY QUEEN
No fool. Queen Camilla is the King's wife not Queen Regnant. Her job is to love, care for, and keep the King happy.
Good Morning Majesty KING CHARLES III, in Australia huge support, excellent connection, Long live long live long live, beautiful documentary, all the congratulations, Thank you very much.
@@IsabelleMercier-r6w 🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
The Idea of a Kingdom is absolutely ridiculous today. England still believes they can own other Countries like Scotland and don't give them the right to choose what they want for their Future. Charles drive in a golden Carriage, don't pay Tax in England and believe that it is his Right. Pretty sure his Son will be the last King.
No it's not. I'm in Scandinavia and our monarchies are extremely popular and very relevant.
@@avayer849 Nothing lasts forever. And recently a few other countries have now abolished their monarchy and switched to Republic. Northern Ireland wants to split from the U.K. and rejoin Ireland which is a REPUBLIC country. Hmmm that should say something about your precious monarchy. Why continue to live in the past and paying extra taxes to someone who practically no longer have power like they used to. And if you paid attention in this video, 92% of Australians are open for a Republic. Days of monarch are over.
@@hhds113 'Nothing lasts forever' could be used for republics too. You're statistic is totally wrong, by the way. The latests poll in Australia showed support for a republic at 30%. Sounds like you have a chip on your should and, like many republicans seem to be, rather nasty.
LOOK FOR SLAVE TRADE ?
???