@@mo_shiota1637 Herrschende Klassen geben ihre Macht nicht freiwillig auf. Jeder Versuch eine neue Gesellschaftsform zu etablieren braucht autoritäre Mittel. Egal ob durch Gewehrläufe in einer Revolution oder durch Enteignungskampagnen der Treuhand während der Wiedervereinigung. Autoritarismus ist ein essentieller Bestandteil jeder politischen Entscheidung denn die Entscheidungen müssen gewaltsam umgesetzt werden. Es braucht daher Autorität in irgendeiner Form.
What the actual.... anti-GDR communist German song. So it's a song about struggle against both regimes. I bet there's something right-wing like this...
@@danielescalantedemedeiros. oh, that was one of these most mematic parties We had one in Poland, it was called Komunistyczna Partia Polski (Communist Party of Poland)
It promotes a socialist council republic (probably following the teachings of Liebknecht and Luxemburg during the November Revolution) nothing right wing
Hört sich schön patriotisch an. Allerdings stört mich der Klassenkampf. Besser finde ich ein Soziales und Demokratischen Deutsches Kaiserreich mit einer staatlich gelenkten Sozialen Marktwirtschaft. Eine Mischung aus Skandinavien und Titoismus. Sozialistisches Deutschland aber mit Marktwirtschaft, Demokratie und einem Kaiser wie in Skandinavien die Monarchie ist.
@@AnhaltMapping ich meine jetzt keine Monarchie mit Absolutismus, sondern wie sie in Dänemark, Schweden und Norwegen erfolgreich praktiziert wird. Der Kaiser soll Repräsentant sein und nicht das Land alleine regieren.
@@felixtheredfox1778 The proletariat is supposed to win the conquest of state power and hasten the abolition of class via internationalism and the centralization of all production into public property: Proletarian Revolution - Solution of the contradictions. The proletariat seizes the public power, and by means of this transforms the socialized means of production, slipping from the hands of the bourgeoisie, into public property. By this act, the proletariat frees the means of production from the character of capital they have thus far borne, and gives their socialized character complete freedom to work itself out. Socialized production upon a predetermined plan becomes henceforth possible. The development of production makes the existence of different classes of society thenceforth an anachronism. In proportion as anarchy in social production vanishes, the political authority of the State dies out. Man, at last the master of his own form of social organization, becomes at the same time the lord over Nature, his own master - free. - Engels | Socialism: Utopian & Scientific
It might sound strange, but when I don't listen to the words... I see this just as a pro-FRG song. Probably because it contains this spirit of freedom present in West Germany and its music. When I listen to this song and let my imagination flow, I imagine... evening of a cloudy day in a gorgeous Wannsee. Sitting on a terrace of one of those big and beautiful houses you can find there. Enjoying freedom and richness of this place. Going nearby Glienicker Brücke, looking at Potsdam and whispering "Germany, you shall free yourself"
@@Gdanbo72I understand But at the same time, imagine the KPD/ML members singing it in Esst Germany, where they knew "Ami, Go Home"... must have been weird
![Das Lied von der Rationalisierung - KPD/ML [West German Communist Song] [+English Translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AAj3KAZjuAA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Das Lied von der Rationalisierung - KPD/ML [West German Communist Song] [+English Translation]](/img/tr.png)
![Rotes Antikriegstagslied - KPD/ML [West German Communist Song] [+English Translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fNh5CtipVio/mqdefault.jpg)
Das war jetzt wirklich etwas, mit dem ich ganz ehrlich nicht gerechnet habe. Ein kommunistisches Lied, das sich auch kritisch gegen die DDR richtet 🧐
Ich habe das auch absolut nicht erwartet
Maoisten
@@redElim maoismus ist allerdings auch nicht weniger autoritär
@@mo_shiota1637 Herrschende Klassen geben ihre Macht nicht freiwillig auf. Jeder Versuch eine neue Gesellschaftsform zu etablieren braucht autoritäre Mittel. Egal ob durch Gewehrläufe in einer Revolution oder durch Enteignungskampagnen der Treuhand während der Wiedervereinigung. Autoritarismus ist ein essentieller Bestandteil jeder politischen Entscheidung denn die Entscheidungen müssen gewaltsam umgesetzt werden. Es braucht daher Autorität in irgendeiner Form.
I was surprised too...
The melody is from "Go home, ami!"
The melody is from "God save Ireland"
@@BartlomiejDmowski Go on home,British Soldiers go on home*
@@thisisabandonedgosomewhereelse Go on home, British soldiers is a completely different song
@@BartlomiejDmowski The melody is from "Tramp, Tramp, Tramp!"
"Jesus Loves the Little Children" also uses this melody
Tolles Lied ❤
go home ami tune
Ami, Go Home?
What the actual.... anti-GDR communist German song. So it's a song about struggle against both regimes. I bet there's something right-wing like this...
Is from the KPD(ML) I think
@@danielescalantedemedeiros. oh, that was one of these most mematic parties
We had one in Poland, it was called Komunistyczna Partia Polski (Communist Party of Poland)
Its an anti-revisionist anti social imperialist song
It promotes a socialist council republic (probably following the teachings of Liebknecht and Luxemburg during the November Revolution) nothing right wing
@@dlegion9378 I mean that there must be some other anti-FRG and anti-GDR German song. But a right-wing one
ultras -_-
Kooommt sagt es allen weeiiiiteeerr!🎶
Based und Franco Freda pilled
Can you make the ww1 for K.U.K
👌
Hört sich schön patriotisch an. Allerdings stört mich der Klassenkampf. Besser finde ich ein Soziales und Demokratischen Deutsches Kaiserreich mit einer staatlich gelenkten Sozialen Marktwirtschaft. Eine Mischung aus Skandinavien und Titoismus. Sozialistisches Deutschland aber mit Marktwirtschaft, Demokratie und einem Kaiser wie in Skandinavien die Monarchie ist.
Interessante Vorstellung. Jedoch wäre ich eher gegen die Rückkehr zur Monarchie. :)
@@AnhaltMapping ich meine jetzt keine Monarchie mit Absolutismus, sondern wie sie in Dänemark, Schweden und Norwegen erfolgreich praktiziert wird. Der Kaiser soll Repräsentant sein und nicht das Land alleine regieren.
💀💀 Diese Idee muss aus einer Nervenheilanstalt kommen. Lang lebe die Revolution und der Klassenkampf :)
Absolut Basiert
liebe es und eine frage
hast du discord
Ja, habe ich.
@@AnhaltMapping super
If it wasn’t for the statism this would be a fantastic song
statism? like... the desire for a unified state? that's the whole point of the song, can't really say "it'd be good except for that" lol...
@@RyRy2057 no statism as in being in favour of the existence of a state, state in this case referring to the ruling classes monopoly on power.
no... nah.. it really just is a fantastic song ;)
@@felixtheredfox1778 The proletariat is supposed to win the conquest of state power and hasten the abolition of class via internationalism and the centralization of all production into public property:
Proletarian Revolution - Solution of the contradictions. The proletariat seizes the public power, and by means of this transforms the socialized means of production, slipping from the hands of the bourgeoisie, into public property. By this act, the proletariat frees the means of production from the character of capital they have thus far borne, and gives their socialized character complete freedom to work itself out. Socialized production upon a predetermined plan becomes henceforth possible. The development of production makes the existence of different classes of society thenceforth an anachronism. In proportion as anarchy in social production vanishes, the political authority of the State dies out. Man, at last the master of his own form of social organization, becomes at the same time the lord over Nature, his own master - free.
- Engels | Socialism: Utopian & Scientific
It might sound strange, but when I don't listen to the words... I see this just as a pro-FRG song. Probably because it contains this spirit of freedom present in West Germany and its music.
When I listen to this song and let my imagination flow, I imagine... evening of a cloudy day in a gorgeous Wannsee. Sitting on a terrace of one of those big and beautiful houses you can find there. Enjoying freedom and richness of this place. Going nearby Glienicker Brücke, looking at Potsdam and whispering "Germany, you shall free yourself"
It is a mix of socialism,democratic and nationalism
wierd since the melody is of an east german anti-American song "Ami, go home"
@@Gdanbo72 wrong. It can be also found in American song "Tram Tram Tram" and Irish song "God save Ireland", neither is communist and both are older
@@BartlomiejDmowski yeah but you get what i mean
@@Gdanbo72I understand
But at the same time, imagine the KPD/ML members singing it in Esst Germany, where they knew "Ami, Go Home"... must have been weird