Great video! Have you read Squirrelflight's Hope? That book includes a council of StarClan cats holding a trial to determine whether a cat can enter StarClan after death. In my opinion, the council was unfair to the cat on trial and made snap judgments based on their personal biases. Perhaps a larger, more diverse council would be more suitable for making StarClan judgments than the group in Squirrelflight's hope, but there is still danger in a council of fallible cats deciding the fates of the dead. A part of me thinks that if a good cat is unjustly sent to the Dark Forest, then they should have the strength of spirit to forge new spiritual hunting grounds, similar to how the fallen cats of the First Battle formed StarClan.
I actually haven't read Squirrelflight's hope yet, but that sounds super interesting! Also I completely agree with your other ideas, it would be cool to see an unfairly banished cat form their own StarClan-like afterlife, that could make a great idea for a fanfiction, or something similar!
That's what fans have to remember, Starclan isn't perfect, the Erin's never even said they were, their susceptible to mistake, and thats what makes them interesting to me, you'll have a difficult time predicting their actions.
The council idea is really good, tho very few cats knew about the Ashfur thing with the three and the fire, so they would have still voted for him to go to Starclan. But overall thats a really good idea!
Yeah it could be a mistake, however since the story team did publish an article about it on the official warrior cats website, in which they said it was intentional, I'm not really sure
To be honest, I think that the cats in star clan should send everyone to star clan even the cats who don’t believe in star clan. Why? Because it would be funny. Imagine that. Cloud tail doesn’t believe in starclan, dies, and then. "Where am I?" "In starclan." "That’s just a story for ki-" "Yeah shut up you’re one of us now." 💀💀💀
You gained a new sub, this was great explaining and editing! I loved your video on how long warriors would actually survive, and now this fortunately popped up on my fyp! Thanks for putting in your time to make this! ❤
So i’ve only ever read to Omen of the Stars. But that was YEARS ago. I’m on Power of Three right now. SO FAR, i’ve felt like Starclan & the Warrior code are 9/10 in judgement. - Cats in the dark forest are: Mapleshade, [who the heck ever trained Thistleclaw] Brokenstar, Tigerstar, Darkstripe, & Hawkfrost. Murderes, attempted murderes, and those with evil intentions. - Ashfur, i do feel belongs in the Dark Forest too. I’ve heard spoilers already about what he dose to Bramblestar. But yeah i BELIVE he conspired with Hawkfrost to trap Firestar, as well tried to kill ‘Squirrelflight’s kits’. YEAH the rest of his life he was a good warrior with good intentions. But he did act on his bad intentions to a murderous degree. - i do have 1 problem with the code. If the clans only internally breed. They’ll become crazy inbreed. I do think the solution is taking in outsiders like kitty pets and rouges. The worst thing is typically there made fun of. Because when clans mix, bad things happen. Wars and battles have been fought over mixed clan kits. Deaths. Some are outcast. Almost every relationship ends horribly with broken hearts and more. The only solution tends to be 1 leaving there clan for the other. But they typically have a conflicted heart of betrayal. It’s not a happy ending. - i also have a problem with how vaguely starclan treat the clans. They be like, “Dangers is in the moon. Beware the pebbles.” And just leave the baffled clan(s) to figure out WTF it means and rarely do they ever understand till ITS HAPPENING. I also dislike how they keep secrets that don’t matter to much like no one being able to find Cinderpelt’s spirit. Also how they just kinda bicker with Jaypaw and don’t ever give him his own dreams. I feel like if they didn’t act like a parent with no control they over there kid maybe Jaypaw would be a bit different. Not as pissy about EVERYTHING. But i do get Jaypaw is abusing his powers and being a complete ass. Ssssooo…. Yeah.
That would be helpful definitely But I do worry about companions from other clans like voting together and all the others following and that might happen that sounds like something Warrior cats would do love the video😃
I just wish they kept StarClan as how it was in Arc 1; wise and mysterious. So, whether a cat should go to StarClan or the Dark Forest should be as equally mysterious. But cats like Ashfur should have gone to the Dark Forest, just because of all the evil he did. Maybe it should be based on the intentions of the cat? But what if an evil cat thought his intentions were good. In my AU, I just keep it mysterious. But a council-ran judgement system like you mentioned would be good as well.
I've had it as my profile picture since before I decided to start making Warrior Cats videos, and I couldn't really find a good replacement, so I just stuck with it haha
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Great video! Have you read Squirrelflight's Hope? That book includes a council of StarClan cats holding a trial to determine whether a cat can enter StarClan after death. In my opinion, the council was unfair to the cat on trial and made snap judgments based on their personal biases. Perhaps a larger, more diverse council would be more suitable for making StarClan judgments than the group in Squirrelflight's hope, but there is still danger in a council of fallible cats deciding the fates of the dead. A part of me thinks that if a good cat is unjustly sent to the Dark Forest, then they should have the strength of spirit to forge new spiritual hunting grounds, similar to how the fallen cats of the First Battle formed StarClan.
I actually haven't read Squirrelflight's hope yet, but that sounds super interesting! Also I completely agree with your other ideas, it would be cool to see an unfairly banished cat form their own StarClan-like afterlife, that could make a great idea for a fanfiction, or something similar!
Honestly that trial pissed me off so bad I was absolutely disgusted by star clan
I really don't understand starclans judgement for cats that has it many issues and this video explains how to fix it better
That's what fans have to remember, Starclan isn't perfect, the Erin's never even said they were, their susceptible to mistake, and thats what makes them interesting to me, you'll have a difficult time predicting their actions.
The council idea is really good, tho very few cats knew about the Ashfur thing with the three and the fire, so they would have still voted for him to go to Starclan. But overall thats a really good idea!
I think that starclan can see everything and literally saw him trying to kill firestar, lionblaze, hollyleaf and jayfeather
I'm pretty sure frecklewish being in the dark forest according to the website was a mistake, bright guardian akira made a video about it.
Yeah it could be a mistake, however since the story team did publish an article about it on the official warrior cats website, in which they said it was intentional, I'm not really sure
To be honest, I think that the cats in star clan should send everyone to star clan even the cats who don’t believe in star clan. Why? Because it would be funny. Imagine that. Cloud tail doesn’t believe in starclan, dies, and then.
"Where am I?"
"In starclan."
"That’s just a story for ki-"
"Yeah shut up you’re one of us now."
💀💀💀
yea, so funny! But did he go to starclan yet, idk
@zeynepzahra5784 yay!!!
You gained a new sub, this was great explaining and editing! I loved your video on how long warriors would actually survive, and now this fortunately popped up on my fyp! Thanks for putting in your time to make this! ❤
Reading all your amazing comments and feedback makes it all worth it
So i’ve only ever read to Omen of the Stars. But that was YEARS ago. I’m on Power of Three right now. SO FAR, i’ve felt like Starclan & the Warrior code are 9/10 in judgement.
- Cats in the dark forest are: Mapleshade, [who the heck ever trained Thistleclaw] Brokenstar, Tigerstar, Darkstripe, & Hawkfrost. Murderes, attempted murderes, and those with evil intentions.
- Ashfur, i do feel belongs in the Dark Forest too. I’ve heard spoilers already about what he dose to Bramblestar. But yeah i BELIVE he conspired with Hawkfrost to trap Firestar, as well tried to kill ‘Squirrelflight’s kits’. YEAH the rest of his life he was a good warrior with good intentions. But he did act on his bad intentions to a murderous degree.
- i do have 1 problem with the code. If the clans only internally breed. They’ll become crazy inbreed. I do think the solution is taking in outsiders like kitty pets and rouges. The worst thing is typically there made fun of.
Because when clans mix, bad things happen. Wars and battles have been fought over mixed clan kits. Deaths. Some are outcast. Almost every relationship ends horribly with broken hearts and more. The only solution tends to be 1 leaving there clan for the other. But they typically have a conflicted heart of betrayal. It’s not a happy ending.
- i also have a problem with how vaguely starclan treat the clans. They be like, “Dangers is in the moon. Beware the pebbles.” And just leave the baffled clan(s) to figure out WTF it means and rarely do they ever understand till ITS HAPPENING.
I also dislike how they keep secrets that don’t matter to much like no one being able to find Cinderpelt’s spirit. Also how they just kinda bicker with Jaypaw and don’t ever give him his own dreams. I feel like if they didn’t act like a parent with no control they over there kid maybe Jaypaw would be a bit different. Not as pissy about EVERYTHING.
But i do get Jaypaw is abusing his powers and being a complete ass. Ssssooo…. Yeah.
That would be helpful definitely But I do worry about companions from other clans like voting together and all the others following and that might happen that sounds like something Warrior cats would do love the video😃
I think the council should be for everyone, even if it's obvious.
I was thinking of a set of rules similar to the warrior code
I just wish they kept StarClan as how it was in Arc 1; wise and mysterious. So, whether a cat should go to StarClan or the Dark Forest should be as equally mysterious. But cats like Ashfur should have gone to the Dark Forest, just because of all the evil he did. Maybe it should be based on the intentions of the cat? But what if an evil cat thought his intentions were good. In my AU, I just keep it mysterious. But a council-ran judgement system like you mentioned would be good as well.
I agree, star-clan is flawed but in my warrior cat rps we have a different 'religion' for the animals.
Star clan is just iredimable at this point
I like ur channel so can i ask why is ur profile pic photo from wings of fire even though ur not doing content on wings of fire
I've had it as my profile picture since before I decided to start making Warrior Cats videos, and I couldn't really find a good replacement, so I just stuck with it haha
Lol!
It would be nice if u try wings of fire content, im making it
@@Mayonnaise.mariyam That's a fun idea, but for now I think I'm mainly going to focus on Warrior Cats. Maybe eventually though!
@@perorbem hehe