All the players featured on this channel are fantastic, but Ben is exceptional. I may not end up buying anything from you guys, but I'll keep up with the clicks and the likes so long as that dude is playing here.
Just because they're a bit buried in the description, A/B timestamps: Hard strumming 2:34 Jumbo 5:26 Dreadnought Gentle strumming 3:32 Jumbo 7:37 Dreadnought Single Line picking 4:24 Jumbo 8:35 Dreadnought
Nice explanation and examples. It took me close to 30 years to realize that jumbos were far more enjoyable to play than a boring dreadnought. I wish I’d have known earlier, but am now a proud jumbo player and songwriter.
Great video. I like both of these for different things. A long time ago I fell into Southern Jumbo’s. I really dig them. They are kind of blend of a few things and to me sit somewhere in between. Basically a J45 with slightly wider nut but still cool.
Went from a Jumbo to a dreadnought. The reason was because with the jumbo, chords sounded amazing, but for fingerpicked arpeggios, I felt like the notes were weak when I played them. Takes a lot of energy to get that body wood vibrating, lol. I may still want a J200, though. They’re my favorite acoustic guitars, but my use for a jumbo is limited right now. I can still get nice woody chords out of my dread. 😎
Yes a jumbo needs a lot of energie, and a bit more time too. Needs time to come in vibration. The juimbo changed my stile of playing guitar. At first, the only reason that giv´nt send it back, was the beaty. But by time, I learned how to play it. And now, I am absolut in love with it.
I bought my Epi J200 in 1995. The first thing I did was have it properly set up with bone nut and saddle, along with action and intonation set. This guitar is rarely out of tune, sounds and plays incredibly. Jamey Johnson famously plays his cut out version on every live performance I've ever seen him on.
I was looking at getting back to playing a guitar after neglecting it for about 35 years. I wasn't familiar with the 2, i think my experiences in past were with jumbo. After hearing the difference, i have to get the jumbo. thanks for sharing.
So, what I have learned by playing the guitar and busking on different instruments is this- dread is alrounder, and nice strummer, 000 is nice for fingerstyle and lead lines, grand auditorium style is good for recording. I have not yet played or owned a jumbo but it is what I would like to have one day, a big sound that leaves more space for vocals because of less mids.
I own a d18 and would say I definitely learn for a dreadnought over most styles of acoustics. But it might be tim I get a jumbo because that epiphone sounds fantastic!
Yes youre right. The dread is more for an allrouder, the Jumbo is special. And for me, it was not love at the first moment. It did need a lot of time, to find out how play it. But there was something in it, that didnt let me give up. It changed my stile of musik. And now, three years later, I cant leave my fingers on it. I remember the unboxing. This beauty, but at the sound, I missed something. But at the same the something in the sound touched me. The beginning of a true lovestorry. My Jumbo is a full solid Sigma SGJA-SG200 maple - stica spruce. I never played another Jumbo, so I have no comparsion to other Jumbos. At my Sigma, the picks and the strings make a big difference in sound. It likes wooden picks. Thanks for the job.
I want more Ben videos! Loved this. Got several dreadnoughts. no Jumbos. But really liked the base sound of the strumming on the Jumbo. "Honey I need just one more guitar, but it's an acoustic" 🙂
Curiously, back in the mid to late 70s, Paul Simon and John Denver were known to fingerpick on jumbos as well. I bought my Ibanez Concord jumbo guitar around this time. Still playing it...
I can't complain at missing the 5% discount, because I just got an incredible deal on a stunning B-stock Alvarez Masterworks MD70BG Bluegrass Dreadnought which arrived today. I've got to give a shout-out to the QC at Andertons, because I had to hunt to spot the faint marks that made it B-stock. I took it straight to rehearsal after unboxing it and we were blown away by how good it sounds. 😎
The funny thing being, I might’ve impulsively said that I leaned toward favoring the dreadnought style. I’m 5 foot 6 (1.70 m) at most, and I often feel dwarfed by the guitars I play. Then, I remind myself that I’ve got a pair of Guild acoustics, a single cut dreadnought 6-string and a full body jumbo 12-string. I’ve not let the size of the jumbo body get in the way of playing the 12-string.
To be perfectly honest with you the J200 sounded far more interesting and nuanced. Even with the single note lines. Not sure about how it sounded in the room cause I wasn't there, but based upon the way the mics picked up the two instruments I felt the dreadnaught sounded a bit dull.
And that is the way I and many others hear it too. Many experts comment that that the notes on a dreadnought come with many layers so they meld together and put out a sound which is all muddied together. Where as the articulation of chords is clearer on the jumbo. It all depends a little,on their application and what you want to achieve.
I find the dreadnought more versatile. Whether I want to strum or pick etc. it ticks most of the boxes. With the 200 you know what sound youre getting, that big boomy strum. Thought about getting one for years....might be time.
My preference is backwards from yours, but for a different reason. For chords i love the jumbo, for single notes and solos i prefer the dreadnaught. But im not thinking in a mix. Just a single guitar.
The dreadnought definitely sounded better to me overall. The Jumbo sounded good, but was a bit muddy through my speakers, and the dreadnought sounded bright and clear.
I bought a jumbo 12-string because the tension andaddedpressure on the guitar due to the fact it was supporti g q2 string adds so much addistress to the body, the Jumbo Hanes it much better. GYI
it is widely accepted that approximately 90% of a guitar's sound comes from its top (or soundboard). The top plays a crucial role in shaping the tonal quality and volume of the instrument.
on my opinion, jumbo guitar sound it's good for playing struming folk music. dreadnought it's more all around with you to play. for me sustain on jumbo guitar it's to long.
I had one of those epiphone Jumbo's, it was shite so I sold it. Sounded like a massive cardboard box with strings stretched over it. No character at all, the guitar equivalent of home brand trade emulsion paint, just a massive wash with zero character or definition. Dreadnought sounds better here, but I prefer a 000 Martin size.
I know the difference. Came here to watch Ben play
Totally! You should check out his band Smith & Brewer - they’ve got some albums and new single up on Spotify/streaming!
Me too.
I didn't know he had a band! Thanks for letting us know 👍
Yep there great ,and also play with a full band.
Same! 👍
All the players featured on this channel are fantastic, but Ben is exceptional. I may not end up buying anything from you guys, but I'll keep up with the clicks and the likes so long as that dude is playing here.
He’s got a duo called Smith & Brewer and they just dropped a new song. Lots of good guitar jams in the catalog.
The bass players slay me even more than the guitar players, I even bought a bass or two because of them!!
Nice one Ben. A very clear demonstration of the differences between jumbo and dreadnaught. Thank you. Excellent.
I bought a Jumbo not long ago and straight out of the box I was amazed by the sound tone and quality,I absolutely love it.
Just because they're a bit buried in the description, A/B timestamps:
Hard strumming
2:34 Jumbo
5:26 Dreadnought
Gentle strumming
3:32 Jumbo
7:37 Dreadnought
Single Line picking
4:24 Jumbo
8:35 Dreadnought
Nice explanation and examples. It took me close to 30 years to realize that jumbos were far more enjoyable to play than a boring dreadnought. I wish I’d have known earlier, but am now a proud jumbo player and songwriter.
That Jumbo epiphone is a real beauty 😍
Great video. I like both of these for different things. A long time ago I fell into Southern Jumbo’s. I really dig them. They are kind of blend of a few things and to me sit somewhere in between. Basically a J45 with slightly wider nut but still cool.
Went from a Jumbo to a dreadnought. The reason was because with the jumbo, chords sounded amazing, but for fingerpicked arpeggios, I felt like the notes were weak when I played them. Takes a lot of energy to get that body wood vibrating, lol.
I may still want a J200, though. They’re my favorite acoustic guitars, but my use for a jumbo is limited right now. I can still get nice woody chords out of my dread. 😎
Yes a jumbo needs a lot of energie, and a bit more time too. Needs time to come in vibration. The juimbo changed my stile of playing guitar.
At first, the only reason that giv´nt send it back, was the beaty. But by time, I learned how to play it. And now, I am absolut in love with it.
I bought my Epi J200 in 1995. The first thing I did was have it properly set up with bone nut and saddle, along with action and intonation set. This guitar is rarely out of tune, sounds and plays incredibly.
Jamey Johnson famously plays his cut out version on every live performance I've ever seen him on.
I was looking at getting back to playing a guitar after neglecting it for about 35 years. I wasn't familiar with the 2, i think my experiences in past were with jumbo. After hearing the difference, i have to get the jumbo. thanks for sharing.
I had always played dreadnoughts, but recently, I bought matching RainSong Jumbos… a 6 string and the last 12 string they made. Love them both!
I just got my first real guitar, a medium jumbo. I got the epiphone Texan inspired acoustic electric guitar , it came with medium strings and love it.
looks: jumbo over dread, sounds: i'll be happy with either of the them
So, what I have learned by playing the guitar and busking on different instruments is this- dread is alrounder, and nice strummer, 000 is nice for fingerstyle and lead lines, grand auditorium style is good for recording. I have not yet played or owned a jumbo but it is what I would like to have one day, a big sound that leaves more space for vocals because of less mids.
Good demo. I'll take the J200 as a strummer. I wish you had gone north of the sound hole a bit to show what they do mellowed a bit 🙃
I own a d18 and would say I definitely learn for a dreadnought over most styles of acoustics. But it might be tim I get a jumbo because that epiphone sounds fantastic!
Get the SJ-200, new model!
It's MUCH better, I have a review on my channel.
Yes youre right. The dread is more for an allrouder, the Jumbo is special. And for me, it was not love at the first moment. It did need a lot of time, to find out how play it. But there was something in it, that didnt let me give up. It changed my stile of musik. And now, three years later, I cant leave my fingers on it.
I remember the unboxing. This beauty, but at the sound, I missed something. But at the same the something in the sound touched me. The beginning of a true lovestorry.
My Jumbo is a full solid Sigma SGJA-SG200 maple - stica spruce. I never played another Jumbo, so I have no comparsion to other Jumbos. At my Sigma, the picks and the strings make a big difference in sound. It likes wooden picks.
Thanks for the job.
I want more Ben videos! Loved this. Got several dreadnoughts. no Jumbos. But really liked the base sound of the strumming on the Jumbo. "Honey I need just one more guitar, but it's an acoustic" 🙂
And if you feel this base sound in your stomach, during strumming your jumbo ... 🙂
Ben's playing is always stellar 👍
Yeah you are talking out of your hat .. I love the sound of the Jumbo.. In isolation it is amazing.. I love it so much I mix around it
Curiously, back in the mid to late 70s, Paul Simon and John Denver were known to fingerpick on jumbos as well. I bought my Ibanez Concord jumbo guitar around this time. Still playing it...
Still playing my Ibanez concord today too. What a beauty. Funny I always prefer the sound of the jumbo.
I can't complain at missing the 5% discount, because I just got an incredible deal on a stunning B-stock Alvarez Masterworks MD70BG Bluegrass Dreadnought which arrived today. I've got to give a shout-out to the QC at Andertons, because I had to hunt to spot the faint marks that made it B-stock. I took it straight to rehearsal after unboxing it and we were blown away by how good it sounds. 😎
So good 😊
If I was still playing classic rock, definitely the jumbo! As I get older and more folky, I'll stick with my 000!
Nice sum-up.
The funny thing being, I might’ve impulsively said that I leaned toward favoring the dreadnought style. I’m 5 foot 6 (1.70 m) at most, and I often feel dwarfed by the guitars I play. Then, I remind myself that I’ve got a pair of Guild acoustics, a single cut dreadnought 6-string and a full body jumbo 12-string. I’ve not let the size of the jumbo body get in the way of playing the 12-string.
Jumbo for the win!
Jumbos all day long! Great video.
Great playing btw. I really enjoyed the picking part on both guitars… I already own a cheap dreadnougt, so I take the jumbo 🤣
Alvarez all the way.
Personally I preferred the jumbo over the dreadnought. I really liked the sparkle from it.
To be perfectly honest with you the J200 sounded far more interesting and nuanced. Even with the single note lines. Not sure about how it sounded in the room cause I wasn't there, but based upon the way the mics picked up the two instruments I felt the dreadnaught sounded a bit dull.
And that is the way I and many others hear it too. Many experts comment that that the notes on a dreadnought come with many layers so they meld together and put out a sound which is all muddied together. Where as the articulation of chords is clearer on the jumbo. It all depends a little,on their application and what you want to achieve.
I find the dreadnought more versatile. Whether I want to strum or pick etc. it ticks most of the boxes. With the 200 you know what sound youre getting, that big boomy strum. Thought about getting one for years....might be time.
I think the epi is a strummer, and the dread is a picker, both excellent guitars.❤
Not crazy about the body size of a dreadnought or a jumbo...much prefer a parlor or a grand concert. These do sound terrific..very full !
Great playing
My preference is backwards from yours, but for a different reason. For chords i love the jumbo, for single notes and solos i prefer the dreadnaught. But im not thinking in a mix. Just a single guitar.
The dreadnought definitely sounded better to me overall. The Jumbo sounded good, but was a bit muddy through my speakers, and the dreadnought sounded bright and clear.
it's the other way around
Nylon all the time for me
enjoyed your vid thankyou
I bought a jumbo 12-string because the tension andaddedpressure on the guitar due to the fact it was supporti g q2 string adds so much addistress to the body, the Jumbo Hanes it much better. GYI
it is widely accepted that approximately 90% of a guitar's sound comes from its top (or soundboard). The top plays a crucial role in shaping the tonal quality and volume of the instrument.
dreadnought for me
If you can’t afford a Gibson Custom Shop or Standard SJ 200, they have Studio SJ 200 models that are priced lower, they are still great quality.
But they have no maple back and sides.
Wat,gaj,strings are on thos gitars?❤❤❤
Nylonstrings 🙂
I,think,both gitars,are mad,for slow,clasical,jazz,that incloods,lin,composishan,I-do'nt,own ether.❤❤❤
Dreadnought. No question.
Interesting
This is perfect to listen to while I lay slabs.
i started with Dreadnought and now I preferJumbo
The dred has more highs but also fills in the midrange that the jumbo doesn’t have. Both have plenty of bass.
I say dreadnought for the strum, jumbo for the finger Picking
on my opinion, jumbo guitar sound it's good for playing struming folk music. dreadnought it's more all around with you to play. for me sustain on jumbo guitar it's to long.
They both sownd abowt,the sam.
Ok… youre a legend on the guitar..
Afraid I prefer a smaller-bodied instrument. In a band setting you have to EQ all the muddy bass out of these big babies, anyhow.
To me both of these guitars sounded better when strummed softly
Neither....Parlor!
I don't think the Epiphone is a good example of a jumbo, since it sounds so drastically different from the Gibson sj-200.
Lots of treble on the jumbo...jangley
Jumbos jangles and dreadnoughts sparkle…
The jumbo is actually quieter
Oh no. Not Ben.
Jeans high and tight.
Wth
Just get a Guitarrón.
1000lbs is a little heavy for a guitar
Build one, than you think: How can they make it so cheap 🙂
@@martinspreiter8240maybe so…. But I still don’t want a Guitar that weighs 1000lbs. That is like a half a ton.
I had one of those epiphone Jumbo's, it was shite so I sold it. Sounded like a massive cardboard box with strings stretched over it. No character at all, the guitar equivalent of home brand trade emulsion paint, just a massive wash with zero character or definition. Dreadnought sounds better here, but I prefer a 000 Martin size.