I'm currently reading the book and I have exactly the same feelings about it as you do. It is the first time when the main characters annoy me a lot (mostly Albus and Harry). However, I really like Scorpius and Draco. In my opinion there is no magic atmosphere in this book like in the previous ones. I don't feel like I'm reading a Harry Potter book. For me the real Harry Potter ended with the words "All was well". P.S. I kind of ship Albus and Scorpius 😂
Right? Everytime the two had a scene I was like "and now kiss!" I honestly expected them to be gay, maybe that is why the whole script reminded me of the Simon Snow fanfic in fangirl...
lol there is one thing everybody agrees on with the cursed child and that's that Scorpious was gold like how can you hate or not like him. I personally really loved this book but I agree that the book has some problems. I don't really count it as a part of the original series but it's still hp for me
This review has earned you a subscriber! Thank you for your honesty. I was beginning to wonder if I was one of the few Harry Potter fans who absolutely despised this script. I agree with everything you said and I really hated what they did with some of our beloved characters. As much as I love Harry Potter, I'm not going to be one of those fans who is so blinded by my love and obsession for this series that I am not able to see the MAJOR flaws in this entire script. The plot was very unrealistic and so overused and there were too many things that made no sense. None of the characters were anything like how they had been portrayed in the first 7 books (it has nothing to do with them being stressed adults). The ONLY things I appreciated about this story is the different side to Malfoy, and his son. Great review and I am simply going to pretend that this book doesn't exist (which really hurts me to say).
I think the main problem is, is that people are judging a script as if it is a book! of course we aren't going to get the same feels as a full fledged novel, but JK Rowling wanted all to be able to have in sight to this story, incase you can't make it to a play. and personally I don't think you cant judge a character based on a script, the lines are half of what's going on. also to judge the characters we fell in love with against the Harry Potter series to be isn't fair... they are adults now with children we should expect them to no be that same characters we parted with after Deathly Hallows.
I have to disagree, there are other plays that are often read instead of seen performed (Shakespeare, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest & 12 Angry Men Come to Mind) and you can still get a sense of the characters through reading it. The plot itself also is influenced by what the actors bring to the table, but it's the same regardless of if it's read or seen.
Your points are valid, it is a script and some people treat it like a book. HOWEVER, I think that plot and writing determine whether a movie, book, play, or anything that involves writing, is good. HP&CC is a script, yes, but the dialog and writing was awful, and the plot had holes in it that I can't see being dismissed just because it's a script. There are many script reads (Shakespeare, did I spell that right? XD), where the plot and writing is creative and really well done, so you feel like you're part of the story, even though you're not seeing it on a stage. Also, in the book (I won't include spoilers incase you haven't read it...), Albus says the line "I wish you weren't my father" and Harry replies with "Sometimes I wish you weren't my son" and that bothers me. They are adults now so they're out of character, but I think HARRy, of all people, would try his hardest to be kind to his children (After the dursleys...), and even if he did feel that way, he wouldn't say it out loud.
I haven't read it but wouldn't that taking it out of context, because if you really thought it through...I would understand where they're coming from saying those words to each other...If I was Harry Potter, I'd wish that my kids didn't have the famous Harry Potter for a father either, same as if you were the son or daughter of the famous Harry Potter and people had a lot of expectations for you, I'd want to say "I wish you weren't my father" too. Just my view...I feel kind of bad that people aren't having good reviews, I wasn't expecting it to be written like a book either, they said it would be the script...surely it can't be that bad, since it is a play and they worked hard on it, they wouldn't write like shit; they're professionals. I'll keep my hope up for my copy, I really hope I don't get it and I start to read it and have all these negative comments destroy it...It's really your opinion, honestly but I do feel like they wouldn't write a shit script and then publish it. Are we reading them "He said this" and then have an action of the stage actor moving or something... Is it the type of script actors would recieve with their names and stuff... I don't know...I do think that Harry shouldn't be as distant to his children as he appeared to be in the photos on Pottermore...
No one seems to be remembering that this was not made to be released as a book, it was made to be performed as a play so much of its charm comes from its stage fx. This book was simply released as a consolation to those who couldn't get down to London for the play.
I think since it's a play, no one really can go in it thinking that this is the "new Harry Potter book". And it's a script, so it's kinda like the movies, you only get sort of glimpse of the greatness, when in the books you get the deeper meaning behind things. If it had been a book I think it would have been very different, but since it's build for the stage it is kinda weird reading it like a book. don't know if this make any sense. Would have loved to read more of Scorpius and Albus in school though, being the outcast and all that.
THANK YOU! I don't understand all the negativity for Cursed Child when it really was a good play about events that happened after the original series. Everyone seems to be judging it the same way they would judge a novel. :/
I loved this play, but I can totally understand why it wasn't for everyone. I think one thing most positive and negative reviewers can agree on, is that it will probably be phenomenal on stage. I really hope I get to see it sometime as I'm desperate to see how it all comes together on stage. Great review :)
Finally a spoiler free review!!! Have been debating on whether to buy this book because it is not written by J.K Rowling and now I think I will get it, but will keep my expectations very low. Thanks for posting this!!
The mark of a well-written play is when it doesn't need an actor to bring the character to life. So, if you didn't think the characters weren't developed enough and would be better when it is acted out, maybe the writing just isn't good. Maybe the play is lacking, while relying too heavily on someone else to bring the characters to life. The writing should bring a character to life, even in a play, it shouldn't all be left to the actors.
I loved your review Hailey. I have not read it and don't plan to because of everything you said (not that you influenced me but because those were my thoughts/predictions for the book). I was never excited for this book because HP ended where it should have ended and nothing should ever be aded. It's perfect the way it is, or better, was.
Has there been any word of whether there will be a recording of the two plays made available for purchase to the public? I don't care if it's not live, I just want to see it.
To be honest I don't think they should have even released it as a book, they should have just made sure to make the play accessible, take it on tour, have shows across the globe, film the play! Most people find reading play difficult, I'm a drama student and I read plays all the time and I struggle. There's no way you can get the same Harry Potter vibe reading a play that watching the magic on stage
In really glad you reviewed this because I've been debating buying it.... I'm half and half, at this point and I've heard several people agree with what you've had to say about this. I may buy it at some point but I'm just kinda iffy about it.
I just have to totally agree. I hoped for something different. Till the last moment I hoped that the spoilers were fake due to all the #keepthesecrets situation. I knew it was meant to be different, but not like that. It really felt like a fan fiction and not because of the lack of description but because of the characters attitude, their motivation and poor interaction. There were just a couple of great things: - The space given to Malfoy family (I loved Draco & Scorpius) - Snape moments (even though he seemed out of character sometimes) - Hagrid moment - The possibility to fill the gaps left between the lines thanks to our imagination
I heard people say that the writting of JK Rowling just changed in the new format but a couple of days before reading the cursed child (finished it today) I read the fantastic beasts screenplay and you can definetly see the difference in the two sorts of writting as the fantastic beasts screenplay was written by JK Rowling and you definetly saw that
I just finished it and I kind of enjoyed it ! I agree on the points you made about the writing style, of course it doesn't even come close to a HP book. But I think all these issues about the writing were indeed due to the play script format, it really doesn't allow description and info dumps. And yes it was corny at times. But as for the characters, I thought some of it made sense. Maybe Harry wasn't exactly like Harry, but he's like 40 years old here, he's probably changed, and he's struggling with a rebellious kid. I think all parents make wrong decisions when they try to protect their kids. And as he said in the book, he didn't have a father (or a mother), so he really has to learn it all by himself. I enjoyed the plot even if it was a bit predictable, but I would've liked to know more about the different "realities", if you know what I mean. But again, you can't really give a ton of information in a play script. Also I thought it was kind of random that it all started because of Cedric. I think I enjoyed because I watched your review first and therefore I went into it without seeing it as "the official 8th book of the series" ! I think it's the only way you can enjoy it because let's be honest, the ending was perfect. Few, sorry, had to talk about it xD
I have read all of the Harry Potter books and I love them!! I don't have high expectations for this book and I don't want to read it unless it is worth it! I don't want it to take away from the love that I have for the original series:) so my question is: do think that it is worth reading??
Finally someone who doesn't worship this book! I thought I was the only one. I agree with absolutely everything you said. The characters were pretty flat and they didn't act like the characters in the original series. The story was flawed and clichéd and everything was messed up! Over all it just didn't feel like Harry Potter. If there was a way to unread this book/script, I would do it!
Wonderful review~! To be honest when I first saw people starting to post reviews I thought that just because it's Harry Potter most people would not be completely honest about what they thought about it. I had high expectations for this book and have been waiting to read it since it was first announced. My feelings and opinions are much the same as yours especially in regards to the characters. I feel like this is one of those stories where it's best in it's original format which is on stage. Even though it is a play, it just doesn't translate well on paper. If it was translated into an actual novel then yes it would be just as good as seeing the play, but with just the script book it's a big let down. For me the only redeeming quality is Scorpius. He's so adorable and I'm so happy we now have some one in Slytherin who's not evil and out to destroy the world/murder all muggles.
I completely agree with your issues, especially with the characters. They don't seem like themselves. I was especially disappointed with Hermoines decisions because she was always my favorite of the three because of her thoughtfulness.
I personally ended up enjoying it but you definitely brought up some great points. There were definitely some times that it felt like a fanfiction a bit. Great review and points for being honest for sure!
I personally agree with many of your points, especially about the predictable plot. However, I did like the portrayal of Harry in it. I think showing that parenthood changed Harry, and that he actually does have some flaws as a character really made me see him as more than a one-dimensional character in the book. I also think that the the writers were trying to give some fan service and that is why it comes of as a bit of a fanfiction (especially at the bit where it reveals Delphi's parenthood). But overall, I liked it, possibly because I was so in love with the world before, but I bet it is amazing on stage.
I'd give this video 1,000 thumbs up if i could. I was thinking the exact same things about it as you. (Attention, spoiler) I find that the character who acted NOTHING like he would've is Snape. Honestly, he used to be so mysterious and all, but after knowing his secret, there was just no way to let him live on. Even if it was in a different version.
I really agree with you here, the characters didn´t feel like the characters we know and love! I would really love to see the play, just to compare it to the script and see if my opinions change!
Great review! I personally really enjoyed it but I can see what you mean in your review. Love that you explained your 'disappointment' so well. Also Scorpius was definitely the best haha, and agreed on Draco! I was a bit disappointed in Ron as well, I agree it felt like he was filling in for Fred which was so unnecessary...
I didn't know how to put my thoughts and feelings into words, but now I don't have to because you've done it for me. Everything you said was exactly how I feel about it
I bought this on my kindle because I was really excited when I heard about it but I'm so hesitant to read it… I'm a huuuge HP fan and I don't want to be disappointed ^^ the fact that it's in a play script format is kind of strange to me
I really do agree on Ron. His character is way more than the "funny guy", he is kindhearted (something which is seen but I felt it wasn't shown in the right way) and brave. Something that many ppl have said is that Harry didn't fit into his character, personally I think he actually did, whilst some actions were a little bit over the top I wasn't surprised at all by how he evolved as an adult. I also liked how Hermione was really shown as a strong woman. There are definitely some bits I didn't like about this, but some that I really did enjoy and that I really wish to see in real. Tbh I wasn't really looking forward to reading the actual story and the adventure, I just wanted a glimpse of the magical wizarding world of Hp, and that is what I got :)
tbh what dissapoints me the most was Rose. I mean, she could've been more of a jokester character on top of all the acedemic success. And maybe a little less superficial. She's not only Hermione's but Ron's kid as well...
I loved this book, mainly because I like plays, and I managed to read it and "separate" it from the other books as I was reading.. It was a 5 out of 5 stars for me. But, again... I like plays and I didn't read it with the ideia that this is a sequel of the other books.
I really enjoyed reading this, but there are so many flaws. I really like wat they did with loads of the characters, but when reading it I just glossed over the plotholes, hoping that it will be glossed over in the play. Loads of people complain that the characters where OOC, and I agree, but I also think that the characters have grown up. Harry, Hermione, Draco and Ron aren't the same as when they were 18, so I think that people need to accept that they're not going to be the same. I still think though, that if you're going to change the original characters completely they should explain why. Like, Harry wouldn't be that mean to his son, it didn't make sense, I would accept it if they gave the reason... but... I mean, I still loved it though.
I enjoyed reading it, it was hard to put down. But the plot, the dialogue, everything... it just felt very off. I'm kind of baffled JK okayed this plot, and if this truly is canon, I hope Fantastic Beasts can undo what people find to be its mistakes. This probably is better left as a play, its nice to get the script and all, but maybe it should have been released in book form after the play found more success worldwide, the timing could be the issue. Different things work better on different mediums.
I was very disappointed when I read this book. I wish I had seen this review before reading it. Your words are so true. The characters did seem to be a lot different. I felt Harry was so mean and rude. I loved Draco's character too 😃 I like your review. You were completely honest about the book. And I'm totally in love with your bookland , Hailey❤ Bring up with more review videos 😊😊
Love the honest review! I think a lot of people kind of overhyped it and said it was better than it actually was - also just recently discovered your RUclips last week and think you're wonderful!!
New Subscriber! This was a very critical review of the Cursed Child, which was very similar to my own opinion. But I subscribed because the way you explain it, your personality, and everything else. Can't wait to watch more from your channel. 💛 Edit: Scorpius was my only favorite character. Draco had some good development and seemed like himself. EVERYONE ELSE WAS OUT OF CHARACTER. Even McGonnagal and some other established characters (I won't say who) that reappeared. That was what probably disappointed me the most. Oh and the obvious elephant in the room that made the whole book very underwhelming since it was all going to be changed anyway. I would love to see the play since I've heard it is very good. But yeah, this playbook wasn't very fun to read for the most part.
YOU NAILED THE CHARACTER REVIEW SO PERFECTLY. They aren't the same. Ginny seems so submissive. She's not the sarcastic, witty, FUNNY Ginny we all new. Harry really disappointed me. Hermione wasn't the same. We didnt get to see much of James or Lily. We didn't get to hear about the other characters; Hagrid, Luna, The Weasleys. So disappointed.
I read this book before watching your review and I am surprised how well this video displays my own opinion. I think, that it is rather inspired by the HP musicals (AVPM,AVPS,AVPSY) than by the actual series and if I look at it like that, I definitely see the play in a better light :)
So many characters were out of character. I hated it when the movies turned Ron into just comic relief, when he's actually so much more than that. But in this play it's not just Ron, but there were so many characters who acted nothing like they would in the books. I agree with what lots of people are saying, it comes across as a very mediocre fanfiction by a writer who has a slight idea of what the characters are like.
Personally I loved the script. It was such a throwback to my childhood. I just can't say a bad thing about it. I just think it's a great story about fathers and their sons. I also love how we got to see Draco now that he's not being influenced by his father (and the terrible thing him and Scorpius had to go through)
The number one thing wrong with it was the 'villain' of the play just wouldn't have existed. It's explained away in an instant if you're a Harry Potter fan. So disappointing
I enjoyed it for the most part. I think it had several flaws and that it needed to be a novel instead of a play so that things could be explained instead of thrown at us. The bare bones of the story are good, but it needs a lot of development. Also Ron needs more love.
Thank you for the review and your honesty. I wasn't going to read it anyway, but now I'm certain. I was so glad to see J.K.Rowling develop her capacity and writing style in non-Harry-Potter books, so I don't want to associate her name with this fan fiction,in which I feel she didn't even participate that much
My personal opinion, while I didn't love the book, I did like it. And I just wanted to throw a few counterarguments against yours. Feel free to counter argue against my counterarguments... Wow that was redundant.. Haha. Firstly, I think Harry's character was represented correctly in this play. Harry, while brave and caring, is no stranger to outbursts that hurt people. While what he said is a bit far fetched, I think it's still plausible being how over emotional Harry can be, which I also can see in Albus Severus. While I personally hated Albus Severus, his character is just like Harry. Very socially awkward, random outbursts of anger, and I feel like he is the main child of Harry and Ginny that actually fits Harry. With Hermione, I agree that her character was a bit... Off. Though, while Hermione is very organized, and plans everything out, there are times that she does things without thinking and it bites here (ex, calling the Werewolf in PoA). Tho I agree about Ron. Haha. He was off
i really hated this book so much... the trolley witch scene just shows everything that's wrong with it tbh. it makes no sense and really the plot is a bit awful. i thought albus was really irritating and scorpius was the only good thing about reading it. i didn't even want to finish it.
I'm glad to see someone actually discuss this book negatively. I'm halfway through it and I'm struggling to finish it.cause it's just so bad. the only thing I'm enjoying is Scorpious.
I was really confused about buying the book or not(especially when it was translated to my language) because I was afraid that it would be differenτ.Thank you for solving those problems and I hope your other videos are like this one,if yes, then you have a very interesting channel that you should not give up. :D
umm in movieflames delphi diggory theory delphis hair looks like yours and shes beautiful so you might just be her...... im joking youre awesome. i have the same feelings about Harry Potter and the cursed child plus this line i hate it 'harry : i wish you werent my son. to albus me : harry would never say that. and theres too many plots
The book was okay but it would be better in novel form rather than a script. However I would definitely see the play. I agree with nearly everything you say
Yes yes yes so much love for you right now I was hoping this would be a negative review simply because I'm so disappointed with the book and need someone else to share my feelings of resentment!!
I agree with everything you said!! the characterisations were so bad and when i read this i had tears streaming down my face i was laughing so hard at how ridiculous the plot was. having said that i did get to see the show and it was honestly one of the most amazing experiences of my life. the plot was still awful but the staging, music and special effects were so amazing that it didnt even matter!!
I really liked this one. My imagenation works wonders though. And since I had already read plays before, I knew what to expect. I missed descriptions in a couple of places though and there is a huge plothole in the story (to keep it as spoilerfree a possible: it has to do with wands)
I agree with pretty much all of this! I was so disappointed with how they portrayed the characters. I hated what they did with Ron's character. Scorpius was amazing though, and the only smart character in the whole play. I think on stage this would be great, as a book... no
Omg best review. I agree with you 100%. You says everything that I thought. Also did everyone else hate what they did to the trolley witch? I thought that was ridiculous. Not in keeping with Harry Potter at all. It was more like from a supernatural tv series (and I love those but I didn't want that done in Harry Potter)
I agree that the story is weak and it does feel like fan fiction, but for me the dialogue was actually quite good/entertaining, i think jack thorne did a good job with it
why the disepointment it wasn't realistic. yhe just like harry killing a basilisk in his 2nd year. it's just a small story. it's like fanficition but then with a nice cover and a lot of fans coming together to talk about it. I loved it because I expected bad writing because it's a play I expected a mhe story because it's a sub story and it wasn't written by Rowling. but because of this I enjoyed to have a new story and some new characters in my harry potter mind. keep up the good work I love your videos and hello from the Netherlands :)
I loved the book, I loved the feeling of coming home and I loved certain lines which are very quotable. But besides that I cant see the book as the ultimative future, because I have different opinions on character developments (e.g. I ship scorpius with Lily Luna). I see the book as a Fanfiction and JKR just helped out with details anyways. Besides she said a movie wouldn't suit the storyline at all and therefore they wont do a movie out of it and I definitely agree with her. But I would loooove to see the movie in my country (Germany), because I'm not able go to London to see it.
I disagree with just about everything you said! BUT! Everyone has the right to their opinion and I appreciate your honest review. I LOVED this book and I hope one day I can see it live! But anyways love your reviews. Just disagree (:!
I totally agree with your review😂the book/script was kinda a let down. It was understandably different from the other books but it didn't feel right. Anyways, I love your videos!!💜
Hey Hailey! i'm a new subscriber and i could'nt help but notice the huge collection of books in the background and was wondering if you have ever read The Fault in our Stars by Jhon Green?
I'm currently reading the book and I have exactly the same feelings about it as you do. It is the first time when the main characters annoy me a lot (mostly Albus and Harry). However, I really like Scorpius and Draco. In my opinion there is no magic atmosphere in this book like in the previous ones. I don't feel like I'm reading a Harry Potter book. For me the real Harry Potter ended with the words "All was well".
P.S. I kind of ship Albus and Scorpius 😂
Right? Everytime the two had a scene I was like "and now kiss!"
I honestly expected them to be gay, maybe that is why the whole script reminded me of the Simon Snow fanfic in fangirl...
Harry Potter good book s
lol there is one thing everybody agrees on with the cursed child and that's that Scorpious was gold like how can you hate or not like him. I personally really loved this book but I agree that the book has some problems. I don't really count it as a part of the original series but it's still hp for me
This review has earned you a subscriber! Thank you for your honesty. I was beginning to wonder if I was one of the few Harry Potter fans who absolutely despised this script. I agree with everything you said and I really hated what they did with some of our beloved characters. As much as I love Harry Potter, I'm not going to be one of those fans who is so blinded by my love and obsession for this series that I am not able to see the MAJOR flaws in this entire script. The plot was very unrealistic and so overused and there were too many things that made no sense. None of the characters were anything like how they had been portrayed in the first 7 books (it has nothing to do with them being stressed adults). The ONLY things I appreciated about this story is the different side to Malfoy, and his son. Great review and I am simply going to pretend that this book doesn't exist (which really hurts me to say).
imSarahSnitch and Mercy'sBookishMusing gave really well discussed reviews as to why they were not a fan of this book.
Just remember: Fred rhymes with dead
💔
WHY.
Well damn
Thanks. It's not needed. 😭😭😭😭😭😭
Ella Gilbert he would think that was funny😭😭😭
I think the main problem is, is that people are judging a script as if it is a book! of course we aren't going to get the same feels as a full fledged novel, but JK Rowling wanted all to be able to have in sight to this story, incase you can't make it to a play. and personally I don't think you cant judge a character based on a script, the lines are half of what's going on. also to judge the characters we fell in love with against the Harry Potter series to be isn't fair... they are adults now with children we should expect them to no be that same characters we parted with after Deathly Hallows.
Exactly.
Preach 🙌🏽
I have to disagree, there are other plays that are often read instead of seen performed (Shakespeare, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest & 12 Angry Men Come to Mind) and you can still get a sense of the characters through reading it. The plot itself also is influenced by what the actors bring to the table, but it's the same regardless of if it's read or seen.
Your points are valid, it is a script and some people treat it like a book. HOWEVER, I think that plot and writing determine whether a movie, book, play, or anything that involves writing, is good. HP&CC is a script, yes, but the dialog and writing was awful, and the plot had holes in it that I can't see being dismissed just because it's a script. There are many script reads (Shakespeare, did I spell that right? XD), where the plot and writing is creative and really well done, so you feel like you're part of the story, even though you're not seeing it on a stage. Also, in the book (I won't include spoilers incase you haven't read it...), Albus says the line "I wish you weren't my father" and Harry replies with "Sometimes I wish you weren't my son" and that bothers me. They are adults now so they're out of character, but I think HARRy, of all people, would try his hardest to be kind to his children (After the dursleys...), and even if he did feel that way, he wouldn't say it out loud.
I haven't read it but wouldn't that taking it out of context, because if you really thought it through...I would understand where they're coming from saying those words to each other...If I was Harry Potter, I'd wish that my kids didn't have the famous Harry Potter for a father either, same as if you were the son or daughter of the famous Harry Potter and people had a lot of expectations for you, I'd want to say "I wish you weren't my father" too. Just my view...I feel kind of bad that people aren't having good reviews, I wasn't expecting it to be written like a book either, they said it would be the script...surely it can't be that bad, since it is a play and they worked hard on it, they wouldn't write like shit; they're professionals. I'll keep my hope up for my copy, I really hope I don't get it and I start to read it and have all these negative comments destroy it...It's really your opinion, honestly but I do feel like they wouldn't write a shit script and then publish it.
Are we reading them "He said this" and then have an action of the stage actor moving or something... Is it the type of script actors would recieve with their names and stuff... I don't know...I do think that Harry shouldn't be as distant to his children as he appeared to be in the photos on Pottermore...
No one seems to be remembering that this was not made to be released as a book, it was made to be performed as a play so much of its charm comes from its stage fx. This book was simply released as a consolation to those who couldn't get down to London for the play.
I think since it's a play, no one really can go in it thinking that this is the "new Harry Potter book". And it's a script, so it's kinda like the movies, you only get sort of glimpse of the greatness, when in the books you get the deeper meaning behind things. If it had been a book I think it would have been very different, but since it's build for the stage it is kinda weird reading it like a book. don't know if this make any sense. Would have loved to read more of Scorpius and Albus in school though, being the outcast and all that.
THANK YOU! I don't understand all the negativity for Cursed Child when it really was a good play about events that happened after the original series. Everyone seems to be judging it the same way they would judge a novel. :/
I loved this play, but I can totally understand why it wasn't for everyone. I think one thing most positive and negative reviewers can agree on, is that it will probably be phenomenal on stage. I really hope I get to see it sometime as I'm desperate to see how it all comes together on stage. Great review :)
Thank you for stating your differing opinion in a civil and friendly manner. :)
I loved this personally I thought it was so good and I cried like 5 times while reading it
That's awesome!! Glad you enjoyed it!
Me too! It was like coming home in a way, I am so glad to see that someone liked the script as well
I totally agree
Same here😭
Same same :')
I discovered this channel today and I've been having a marathon since that...hope it will bring me back to reading more😁💕
I haven't bought the book yet and I think I am now going to wait for a lonnnnnggg time to read the book.
AHHH! I'm here so early! I'm loving all these videos from Hailey today
💗💗💗💗
YESSS!!! Ron was such a letdown, I was appalled by their depiction of him :/
i love how honest is ur review. I totaly don't think of it as a continuation of the HP series so I wouldn't be let down.
Finally a spoiler free review!!! Have been debating on whether to buy this book because it is not written by J.K Rowling and now I think I will get it, but will keep my expectations very low. Thanks for posting this!!
Fred died. Not George
I had a 50/50 chance, I knew I'd be wrong.
+Hails Hearts Nyc
I get mixed up on them too! 😁 I agree with your video a lot. Especially about Ron and the way the characters acted..
+Hails Hearts Nyc I remember it by thinking the twin who survived was the one who lost his ear, which was George. So Fred died.
+Emily Janet
Same!
I read the first page and i cant believe you didn't mention how horrible it was reading in not standardized book form
The mark of a well-written play is when it doesn't need an actor to bring the character to life. So, if you didn't think the characters weren't developed enough and would be better when it is acted out, maybe the writing just isn't good. Maybe the play is lacking, while relying too heavily on someone else to bring the characters to life. The writing should bring a character to life, even in a play, it shouldn't all be left to the actors.
I loved your review Hailey. I have not read it and don't plan to because of everything you said (not that you influenced me but because those were my thoughts/predictions for the book). I was never excited for this book because HP ended where it should have ended and nothing should ever be aded. It's perfect the way it is, or better, was.
I love your hair 😍 and I like the way u review books. So organized.
Has there been any word of whether there will be a recording of the two plays made available for purchase to the public? I don't care if it's not live, I just want to see it.
To be honest I don't think they should have even released it as a book, they should have just made sure to make the play accessible, take it on tour, have shows across the globe, film the play! Most people find reading play difficult, I'm a drama student and I read plays all the time and I struggle. There's no way you can get the same Harry Potter vibe reading a play that watching the magic on stage
I enjoyed reading this but I do feel like there were some things that were off....
In really glad you reviewed this because I've been debating buying it.... I'm half and half, at this point and I've heard several people agree with what you've had to say about this. I may buy it at some point but I'm just kinda iffy about it.
I just have to totally agree. I hoped for something different. Till the last moment I hoped that the spoilers were fake due to all the #keepthesecrets situation. I knew it was meant to be different, but not like that. It really felt like a fan fiction and not because of the lack of description but because of the characters attitude, their motivation and poor interaction. There were just a couple of great things:
- The space given to Malfoy family (I loved Draco & Scorpius)
- Snape moments (even though he seemed out of character sometimes)
- Hagrid moment
- The possibility to fill the gaps left between the lines thanks to our imagination
I heard people say that the writting of JK Rowling just changed in the new format but a couple of days before reading the cursed child (finished it today) I read the fantastic beasts screenplay and you can definetly see the difference in the two sorts of writting as the fantastic beasts screenplay was written by JK Rowling and you definetly saw that
Can I also say that I hate the fact that Ron runs the joke shop in this book? He's an auror like Harry. Did I make that up?
I just finished it and I kind of enjoyed it ! I agree on the points you made about the writing style, of course it doesn't even come close to a HP book. But I think all these issues about the writing were indeed due to the play script format, it really doesn't allow description and info dumps. And yes it was corny at times. But as for the characters, I thought some of it made sense. Maybe Harry wasn't exactly like Harry, but he's like 40 years old here, he's probably changed, and he's struggling with a rebellious kid. I think all parents make wrong decisions when they try to protect their kids. And as he said in the book, he didn't have a father (or a mother), so he really has to learn it all by himself. I enjoyed the plot even if it was a bit predictable, but I would've liked to know more about the different "realities", if you know what I mean. But again, you can't really give a ton of information in a play script. Also I thought it was kind of random that it all started because of Cedric.
I think I enjoyed because I watched your review first and therefore I went into it without seeing it as "the official 8th book of the series" ! I think it's the only way you can enjoy it because let's be honest, the ending was perfect.
Few, sorry, had to talk about it xD
I have read all of the Harry Potter books and I love them!! I don't have high expectations for this book and I don't want to read it unless it is worth it! I don't want it to take away from the love that I have for the original series:) so my question is: do think that it is worth reading??
Finally someone who doesn't worship this book! I thought I was the only one.
I agree with absolutely everything you said. The characters were pretty flat and they didn't act like the characters in the original series. The story was flawed and clichéd and everything was messed up! Over all it just didn't feel like Harry Potter. If there was a way to unread this book/script, I would do it!
Wonderful review~! To be honest when I first saw people starting to post reviews I thought that just because it's Harry Potter most people would not be completely honest about what they thought about it. I had high expectations for this book and have been waiting to read it since it was first announced. My feelings and opinions are much the same as yours especially in regards to the characters. I feel like this is one of those stories where it's best in it's original format which is on stage. Even though it is a play, it just doesn't translate well on paper. If it was translated into an actual novel then yes it would be just as good as seeing the play, but with just the script book it's a big let down. For me the only redeeming quality is Scorpius. He's so adorable and I'm so happy we now have some one in Slytherin who's not evil and out to destroy the world/murder all muggles.
I completely agree with your issues, especially with the characters. They don't seem like themselves. I was especially disappointed with Hermoines decisions because she was always my favorite of the three because of her thoughtfulness.
I personally ended up enjoying it but you definitely brought up some great points. There were definitely some times that it felt like a fanfiction a bit. Great review and points for being honest for sure!
I personally agree with many of your points, especially about the predictable plot. However, I did like the portrayal of Harry in it. I think showing that parenthood changed Harry, and that he actually does have some flaws as a character really made me see him as more than a one-dimensional character in the book. I also think that the the writers were trying to give some fan service and that is why it comes of as a bit of a fanfiction (especially at the bit where it reveals Delphi's parenthood). But overall, I liked it, possibly because I was so in love with the world before, but I bet it is amazing on stage.
I'd give this video 1,000 thumbs up if i could. I was thinking the exact same things about it as you. (Attention, spoiler) I find that the character who acted NOTHING like he would've is Snape. Honestly, he used to be so mysterious and all, but after knowing his secret, there was just no way to let him live on. Even if it was in a different version.
What book or series would you recommend after reading the Harry Potter series?
I think it's just that the older people notice stuff like that when they read as to children who just read it
loved ur little intro!!
I really agree with you here, the characters didn´t feel like the characters we know and love! I would really love to see the play, just to compare it to the script and see if my opinions change!
SERIOUSLY WTF WAS WRONG WITH RON
aNd what happened to harry !!
How can you be best friends with Hary Potter and not be brave?
Great review! I personally really enjoyed it but I can see what you mean in your review. Love that you explained your 'disappointment' so well. Also Scorpius was definitely the best haha, and agreed on Draco! I was a bit disappointed in Ron as well, I agree it felt like he was filling in for Fred which was so unnecessary...
I didn't know how to put my thoughts and feelings into words, but now I don't have to because you've done it for me. Everything you said was exactly how I feel about it
Does the book has pics on it?
No, it's a script.
How ToMake Nop
I bought this on my kindle because I was really excited when I heard about it but I'm so hesitant to read it… I'm a huuuge HP fan and I don't want to be disappointed ^^ the fact that it's in a play script format is kind of strange to me
I haven't brought it yet because I agree with you that the script format is strange which Is why I'm hesitant to buy it
I really do agree on Ron. His character is way more than the "funny guy", he is kindhearted (something which is seen but I felt it wasn't shown in the right way) and brave. Something that many ppl have said is that Harry didn't fit into his character, personally I think he actually did, whilst some actions were a little bit over the top I wasn't surprised at all by how he evolved as an adult. I also liked how Hermione was really shown as a strong woman.
There are definitely some bits I didn't like about this, but some that I really did enjoy and that I really wish to see in real.
Tbh I wasn't really looking forward to reading the actual story and the adventure, I just wanted a glimpse of the magical wizarding world of Hp, and that is what I got :)
tbh what dissapoints me the most was Rose. I mean, she could've been more of a jokester character on top of all the acedemic success. And maybe a little less superficial. She's not only Hermione's but Ron's kid as well...
I totally agree. I feel like this book is not a JK Rowling book. Its sorta plain and stiff at some times. It would work much better as a play.
I loved this book, mainly because I like plays, and I managed to read it and "separate" it from the other books as I was reading.. It was a 5 out of 5 stars for me. But, again... I like plays and I didn't read it with the ideia that this is a sequel of the other books.
I really enjoyed reading this, but there are so many flaws. I really like wat they did with loads of the characters, but when reading it I just glossed over the plotholes, hoping that it will be glossed over in the play.
Loads of people complain that the characters where OOC, and I agree, but I also think that the characters have grown up. Harry, Hermione, Draco and Ron aren't the same as when they were 18, so I think that people need to accept that they're not going to be the same.
I still think though, that if you're going to change the original characters completely they should explain why.
Like, Harry wouldn't be that mean to his son, it didn't make sense, I would accept it if they gave the reason... but...
I mean, I still loved it though.
I enjoyed reading it, it was hard to put down. But the plot, the dialogue, everything... it just felt very off. I'm kind of baffled JK okayed this plot, and if this truly is canon, I hope Fantastic Beasts can undo what people find to be its mistakes. This probably is better left as a play, its nice to get the script and all, but maybe it should have been released in book form after the play found more success worldwide, the timing could be the issue. Different things work better on different mediums.
I was very disappointed when I read this book. I wish I had seen this review before reading it. Your words are so true. The characters did seem to be a lot different. I felt Harry was so mean and rude. I loved Draco's character too 😃 I like your review. You were completely honest about the book. And I'm totally in love with your bookland , Hailey❤ Bring up with more review videos 😊😊
Love the honest review! I think a lot of people kind of overhyped it and said it was better than it actually was - also just recently discovered your RUclips last week and think you're wonderful!!
New Subscriber! This was a very critical review of the Cursed Child, which was very similar to my own opinion. But I subscribed because the way you explain it, your personality, and everything else. Can't wait to watch more from your channel. 💛
Edit: Scorpius was my only favorite character. Draco had some good development and seemed like himself. EVERYONE ELSE WAS OUT OF CHARACTER. Even McGonnagal and some other established characters (I won't say who) that reappeared. That was what probably disappointed me the most.
Oh and the obvious elephant in the room that made the whole book very underwhelming since it was all going to be changed anyway.
I would love to see the play since I've heard it is very good. But yeah, this playbook wasn't very fun to read for the most part.
YOU NAILED THE CHARACTER REVIEW SO PERFECTLY. They aren't the same. Ginny seems so submissive. She's not the sarcastic, witty, FUNNY Ginny we all new. Harry really disappointed me. Hermione wasn't the same. We didnt get to see much of James or Lily. We didn't get to hear about the other characters; Hagrid, Luna, The Weasleys. So disappointed.
you need to see the play. You say the characters aren't the same but remember it's 20+ years later
I read this book before watching your review and I am surprised how well this video displays my own opinion. I think, that it is rather inspired by the HP musicals (AVPM,AVPS,AVPSY) than by the actual series and if I look at it like that, I definitely see the play in a better light :)
Aw I'm sorry you didn't like it :( I definitely agree that Scorpius was the best character in this play. He was definitely the highlight for me!
Plot twist: harry was like that because his scar didn't pain for 19 years, and this actually meant that all was not good
So many characters were out of character. I hated it when the movies turned Ron into just comic relief, when he's actually so much more than that. But in this play it's not just Ron, but there were so many characters who acted nothing like they would in the books. I agree with what lots of people are saying, it comes across as a very mediocre fanfiction by a writer who has a slight idea of what the characters are like.
"You need an actor to bring him to life" she says then says how an actual performance would make it better. It was a play before it was a book.
Personally I loved the script. It was such a throwback to my childhood. I just can't say a bad thing about it. I just think it's a great story about fathers and their sons. I also love how we got to see Draco now that he's not being influenced by his father (and the terrible thing him and Scorpius had to go through)
The number one thing wrong with it was the 'villain' of the play just wouldn't have existed. It's explained away in an instant if you're a Harry Potter fan. So disappointing
I enjoyed it for the most part. I think it had several flaws and that it needed to be a novel instead of a play so that things could be explained instead of thrown at us. The bare bones of the story are good, but it needs a lot of development. Also Ron needs more love.
Thank you for the review and your honesty. I wasn't going to read it anyway, but now I'm certain. I was so glad to see J.K.Rowling develop her capacity and writing style in non-Harry-Potter books, so I don't want to associate her name with this fan fiction,in which I feel she didn't even participate that much
Is Teddy Lupin in it?
How often have we the opportunity to hear a book review from such a beautiful countenance? And so expressive with a pleasant voice? Thank you!
My personal opinion, while I didn't love the book, I did like it. And I just wanted to throw a few counterarguments against yours. Feel free to counter argue against my counterarguments... Wow that was redundant.. Haha. Firstly, I think Harry's character was represented correctly in this play. Harry, while brave and caring, is no stranger to outbursts that hurt people. While what he said is a bit far fetched, I think it's still plausible being how over emotional Harry can be, which I also can see in Albus Severus. While I personally hated Albus Severus, his character is just like Harry. Very socially awkward, random outbursts of anger, and I feel like he is the main child of Harry and Ginny that actually fits Harry. With Hermione, I agree that her character was a bit... Off. Though, while Hermione is very organized, and plans everything out, there are times that she does things without thinking and it bites here (ex, calling the Werewolf in PoA). Tho I agree about Ron. Haha. He was off
Cursed Child was Back to the Future 2 and Doctor Who mashed together with the Harry Potter world and characters
i really hated this book so much... the trolley witch scene just shows everything that's wrong with it tbh. it makes no sense and really the plot is a bit awful. i thought albus was really irritating and scorpius was the only good thing about reading it. i didn't even want to finish it.
Pretty bummed out:( I was quite excited to read this but it doesn't sound good
I'm glad to see someone actually discuss this book negatively. I'm halfway through it and I'm struggling to finish it.cause it's just so bad. the only thing I'm enjoying is Scorpious.
I was really confused about buying the book or not(especially when it was translated to my language) because I was afraid that it would be differenτ.Thank you for solving those problems and I hope your other videos are like this one,if yes, then you have a very interesting channel that you should not give up. :D
Great review, I haven't read this because i'm waiting to finish reading the series for the first time...
I ABSOLUTELY agree with you. I wrote a review of my own and I even used the same words you used in this video.
umm in movieflames delphi diggory theory delphis hair looks like yours and shes beautiful so you might just be her...... im joking youre awesome. i have the same feelings about Harry Potter and the cursed child plus this line i hate it 'harry : i wish you werent my son. to albus
me : harry would never say that.
and theres too many plots
wow! I love your honest raw review.
I totally agree with you Hailey...
The book was okay but it would be better in novel form rather than a script. However I would definitely see the play. I agree with nearly everything you say
Yes yes yes so much love for you right now I was hoping this would be a negative review simply because I'm so disappointed with the book and need someone else to share my feelings of resentment!!
I agree with everything you said!! the characterisations were so bad and when i read this i had tears streaming down my face i was laughing so hard at how ridiculous the plot was. having said that i did get to see the show and it was honestly one of the most amazing experiences of my life. the plot was still awful but the staging, music and special effects were so amazing that it didnt even matter!!
I really liked this one. My imagenation works wonders though. And since I had already read plays before, I knew what to expect. I missed descriptions in a couple of places though and there is a huge plothole in the story (to keep it as spoilerfree a possible: it has to do with wands)
I agree with pretty much all of this! I was so disappointed with how they portrayed the characters. I hated what they did with Ron's character. Scorpius was amazing though, and the only smart character in the whole play. I think on stage this would be great, as a book... no
Omg best review. I agree with you 100%. You says everything that I thought. Also did everyone else hate what they did to the trolley witch? I thought that was ridiculous. Not in keeping with Harry Potter at all. It was more like from a supernatural tv series (and I love those but I didn't want that done in Harry Potter)
*said*
I'm kinda scared to start reading incase it ruins my views on the characters and I'll never be able to see them in the same way
Ikr
You just turned my thoughts into words, for real, this is exactly how I feel about the book.
I agree that the story is weak and it does feel like fan fiction, but for me the dialogue was actually quite good/entertaining, i think jack thorne did a good job with it
Oh my, I just found your channel and cannot stop watching. I fell in love. You're so beautiful inside and out. Thanks for making my day brighter.
The ad before this video was the Cursed Child ad ❤️
I love your bookshelf I wish I had one in my room
My thoughts and opinions match yours perfectly. It makes me sad the way Harry acted above anything else.
Hmm, I would have to rethink if I want to read it.
thank you for this very honest review cause I was looking forward to read it but now I know it would just annoy me to see the characters like that
Ive only just recently found your channel and ive been binge watching your videos. Ahhh i love them!! ❤️🙌🏻
why the disepointment it wasn't realistic. yhe just like harry killing a basilisk in his 2nd year. it's just a small story. it's like fanficition but then with a nice cover and a lot of fans coming together to talk about it. I loved it because I expected bad writing because it's a play I expected a mhe story because it's a sub story and it wasn't written by Rowling. but because of this I enjoyed to have a new story and some new characters in my harry potter mind. keep up the good work I love your videos and hello from the Netherlands :)
I loved the book, I loved the feeling of coming home and I loved certain lines which are very quotable. But besides that I cant see the book as the ultimative future, because I have different opinions on character developments (e.g. I ship scorpius with Lily Luna). I see the book as a Fanfiction and JKR just helped out with details anyways. Besides she said a movie wouldn't suit the storyline at all and therefore they wont do a movie out of it and I definitely agree with her. But I would loooove to see the movie in my country (Germany), because I'm not able go to London to see it.
the play, not the movie* 😂
preach ! same for me ! thanks for that review !
I disagree with just about everything you said! BUT! Everyone has the right to their opinion and I appreciate your honest review. I LOVED this book and I hope one day I can see it live! But anyways love your reviews. Just disagree (:!
I totally agree with your review😂the book/script was kinda a let down. It was understandably different from the other books but it didn't feel right. Anyways, I love your videos!!💜
I agree with you on a lot of points and disagree on others. However, I loved this review and how honest you were.
i think it was Fred who died
Hey Hailey! i'm a new subscriber and i could'nt help but notice the huge collection of books in the background and was wondering if you have ever read The Fault in our Stars by Jhon Green?