Just proves that Dylan Alexander has the best and most informative content for the afl draft pick, maybe the tigz need to pick him up as the national recruiter lol
Guys Tigers don't need a key defender @10, we have gibcus balta young miller and blight. Even if next years key fwd prospects are good we'll still need 2 key forwards. So we'll take Shanahan or Armstrong this year and then take the best key fwd next year
Yes, agree, Tigers have plenty of good defenders, they just need to play together more & develop their system. Don't understand people urging them to take a key defender when it'd be better in the longer term to get a key forward to develop.
a great demonstration of why the tigers are probably better off not trading, they will get 2 of those elite group of mids and keep those other first round picks for where the best talls will be
As they touched on, Jagga likely gets taken earlier if Norf trade down with another team, but that still leaves us with Reid, and id personally much rather Lalor and Reid + another over Lalor and FOS. I love Jagga a bit too much, but if we aren't gonna pick him at 2, then we dont need said pick
it's hard to know which players are going to slide but there will be some. What I will say is I would be happy with either Smith, Langford or Smillie at our pick 6. I think Sam Lalor is firming as the number 1 pick.
Great video as a Richmond supporter I don’t think they are interested going in defenders because we’ve already got Gibcus,Brown,Balta,Broad,Miller,Blight,Trezise and Smith. I think they are going for Mids and small forwards.
Love your content lads. Can’t seem to find much info on Murphy Reid’s athletic profile as he missed the combine. Do you know anything about his speed/endurance?
Hey mate! Reid doesn’t have a lot athletically! He’s more a footy IQ guy, think Sheezal, Steele Sidebottom type. He’s one that feels like he’s playing in slow motion while everything around him is chaotic. Super creative by hand too!
@@DylanAlexanderFollowsDraft Problem is Tigers need speed and skill. For me Lalor and Jagga fit that if they stay 1/6 and if they had 1/2 they prob go Lalor and FOS based on upside and FOS performance as a bottom ager over this year injury issues. I like M/Reed as he just finds the footy everywhere but I think Jagga is a better accumulator and Extractor. Although the tigers could use all 3 or even Lalor/Jagga/Langford but unfortunately they spent too much on Hopper and Toronto. Toronto is a good inside mid until he needs to dispose of the footy and hit a target over 15m away. Hopper the jury is out as he can't stay on the park but his disposal is also woeful but he can play the defensive stopper role at clearance. Prestia just doesn't have enough in the tank and his disposal is also woeful. Injuries have killed his explosiveness. Tigers need help everywhere.
Good but not great. Poss would trade up for FOS if this was the outcome. (Hate to see Carlton with this pick.) If Armstrong got through to 10 would take that first. Possibly Shanahan may be at 18. I would personally go for hybrid needs - Allen and Hotton at 10&11. Power and speed plus class and poise. Hotton is that Edwards/Bolton type.
You guys mention how St Kilda's midfield is too one-paced/lacks speed, but then you also select 2 blokes in Reid and Langford who do not have the required explosive/burst/acceleration traits to fix that critical issue??? Guys like Bo Allan and Travaglia (who could easily have the same HB-to-midfielder trajectory that Young and Day had) are way better suited for St Kilda's needs
Atrocious from a Richmond POV. They don't need key backs, or rebounding flankers. They need mids, pace, forwards. Backs are last on the list. For key backs they have Balta, Gibcus, Miller, Blight all 25 and under. Kositschke is probably better suited down back as well. For the Travaglia types they still have Vlastuin and Broad as well as young developing players Brown (a first-rounder) and Trezise. Banks is also best suited to half-back but might be developed as a winger. Kaleb Smith is a bit smaller but also a rebounder the club rates highly after a fantastic VFL season. If it worked out the way you have it, Richmond would possibly take Langford instead of Smith, then definitely two of Armstrong, Lindsay, Hotton or Allan instead of Trainor and Travaglia. Finally, there really is no point doing these if you're going to stick with North at 2 and give them Tauru. As you acknowledge yourselves, it won't happen. If you're going to mock the draft, mock the trade. We know it likely involves Richmond getting 2 and North getting 6 or 10, with other picks involved. So work from there.
They 100% need a rebounding defender with Rioli leaving. Agree with the forward. Pick 10 and 11 will be Travaglia and a key forward. They also do not need to trade for pick 2 as we will get 2 gun mids and pick 1 and 6.
@@JMar1011 They 100% don't need to draft a rebounding defender this year. They will go Lindsay before Travaglia as he's quicker, a better kick and a better mid option.
Love Lalor, Jagga, Trainor, and Travaglia. I also believe Richmond doesn't need to trade up as there will be a quality mid at 6. My only difference is i would take Lindsay, Berry, or Hotton at 10 or 11 as I believe Trainor could be available at pick 18 as he's been sliding lately.
@craftofthedraft they really need to, reports coming out that they will sell the farm to trade back which sounds weird lol but makes sense. Loading up in this draft makes more sense for north then using picks next year
Hopefully North get picks 6 and 12 from Richmond for pick 2 to increase our chances of getting Tobie. Would love to get him and James Barrat at the Eagles (for obvious reasons). Hopefully St Kilda trade out their 2nd top 10 pick as well as that would also help.
I don’t think Richmond should do a Deal with North for Pick 2 but if they do ? Then Lalor , O’Sullivan , Armstrong are 3 selections in the Top 10 THANKS! If Armstrong is gone then cash in on Lindsay , Hotton , Travagalia , Shanahan this is why I’m not a big fan of the Trade with North ? As someone good is going to Slide down to 6 to 12 range as much as I want O’Sullivan at the Tigers it means pick 6 and 20 we would lose could be Stars out of this Draft? Do we go with one Star in O’Sullivan or 2 Stars with picks 6 & 20 ? Pick 6 could be very important pick this year ? A lot of Clubs are interested in Lindsay and he will most likely be gone to Melbourne or St.Kilda at there picks but Richmond could jump them with getting Lindsey at pick 6 if Armstrong is gone ? And if Melbourne has not got Lindsay at 5 ? 🧐👀. 🏆17 🏆19 🏆20 🐅🐅🐅
Id hate it if the Saints take Reid and Langford. Centre bounce explosive, burst away, clearance, goal kicking Midfielders is the NEED. If Smillie is on the board at 7, draft him. Trade pick 8 to Richmond for 11 and 20. Whats the point of drafting a guy (langford) if he doesnt fit our needs in the midfield? Might as well trade down from 8 and STILL draft 2 more players in the first round. I really would consider a key position player at 8 if the saints keep it. Membrey, Campbell, Hayes and Battle, ALL key position players have left the club now, Id rather take Harry Armstrong (Key Forward), Tauru or Trainor (Key Back)at Pick 8, instead of another one-paced 20+ possession a game type mid.
That's another risky Horne Francis position. No way they overlook FOS or Jagga for Draper. Draper is a good prospect but that home factor is a bit of a dark spot at north.
jagga yes he is our future captain... very risky taking sam lolar he is injury prone we already have problems with hopper Prestia in the middle and lynch in the forward line is lolar a risk worth taking....
@@peterkay3440 I know Carlton are very keen on Draper and that's why they targetted pick 3 just before Adelaides pick. He will come to Carlton with the Camporeale twins who he knows well.
Given the clubs picking around that mark and if no trade from North (I'd trade it for multiple picks in the later first round and KPP talent) it's a possibility that it happens. Range is between Carlton's pick 3 and Richmond's current 6 pending possible pick swaps. Adelaide will be wooed by home grown talent in Draper, and the Dees can't go too wrong with Jagga, or Smilie/ Langford as taller mids either.
Ill burn arden st to the ground if they reach for a guy that was gonna get picked around late teens a month ago at 2. Draft best available if can't do a trade sliding back
Just proves that Dylan Alexander has the best and most informative content for the afl draft pick, maybe the tigz need to pick him up as the national recruiter lol
Guys Tigers don't need a key defender @10, we have gibcus balta young miller and blight. Even if next years key fwd prospects are good we'll still need 2 key forwards. So we'll take Shanahan or Armstrong this year and then take the best key fwd next year
I agree we need Mids and small forwards
Yes, agree, Tigers have plenty of good defenders, they just need to play together more & develop their system. Don't understand people urging them to take a key defender when it'd be better in the longer term to get a key forward to develop.
GIC and Balt are very injury prone
@@SuperBLUEIRIS So were Astbury & Grimes in the beginning. Tigers need a key forward more than a key defender. Forwards are harder to find & develop.
Subtract Miller from that list but I agree
Another key forward would be good to support Lefau, Baur going forward
a great demonstration of why the tigers are probably better off not trading, they will get 2 of those elite group of mids and keep those other first round picks for where the best talls will be
As they touched on, Jagga likely gets taken earlier if Norf trade down with another team, but that still leaves us with Reid, and id personally much rather Lalor and Reid + another over Lalor and FOS. I love Jagga a bit too much, but if we aren't gonna pick him at 2, then we dont need said pick
@DEADMEM3 yeah you are basically guaranteed someone good to go with Lalor, I wouldn't trade if I had the pick
it's hard to know which players are going to slide but there will be some.
What I will say is I would be happy with either Smith, Langford or Smillie at our pick 6.
I think Sam Lalor is firming as the number 1 pick.
Great video as a Richmond supporter I don’t think they are interested going in defenders because we’ve already got Gibcus,Brown,Balta,Broad,Miller,Blight,Trezise and Smith. I think they are going for Mids and small forwards.
Agree totally
Well done Boys!
Love your content lads. Can’t seem to find much info on Murphy Reid’s athletic profile as he missed the combine. Do you know anything about his speed/endurance?
Hey mate! Reid doesn’t have a lot athletically! He’s more a footy IQ guy, think Sheezal, Steele Sidebottom type. He’s one that feels like he’s playing in slow motion while everything around him is chaotic. Super creative by hand too!
@@DylanAlexanderFollowsDraft Problem is Tigers need speed and skill. For me Lalor and Jagga fit that if they stay 1/6 and if they had 1/2 they prob go Lalor and FOS based on upside and FOS performance as a bottom ager over this year injury issues. I like M/Reed as he just finds the footy everywhere but I think Jagga is a better accumulator and Extractor. Although the tigers could use all 3 or even Lalor/Jagga/Langford but unfortunately they spent too much on Hopper and Toronto. Toronto is a good inside mid until he needs to dispose of the footy and hit a target over 15m away. Hopper the jury is out as he can't stay on the park but his disposal is also woeful but he can play the defensive stopper role at clearance. Prestia just doesn't have enough in the tank and his disposal is also woeful. Injuries have killed his explosiveness. Tigers need help everywhere.
I think a kako bid will be in here
Good but not great. Poss would trade up for FOS if this was the outcome. (Hate to see Carlton with this pick.) If Armstrong got through to 10 would take that first. Possibly Shanahan may be at 18. I would personally go for hybrid needs - Allen and Hotton at 10&11. Power and speed plus class and poise. Hotton is that Edwards/Bolton type.
You guys mention how St Kilda's midfield is too one-paced/lacks speed, but then you also select 2 blokes in Reid and Langford who do not have the required explosive/burst/acceleration traits to fix that critical issue??? Guys like Bo Allan and Travaglia (who could easily have the same HB-to-midfielder trajectory that Young and Day had) are way better suited for St Kilda's needs
100% I think Josh Smilie falls to saints and Langford goes to Melb. I don’t think we go Reid. If he’s there we will trade back.
Say it louder for those in the back haha
Yes! We either trade to the North pick to get Draper/FOS or we sit and pick and go Travaglia and then maybe a Smillie/Langford
Atrocious from a Richmond POV. They don't need key backs, or rebounding flankers. They need mids, pace, forwards. Backs are last on the list. For key backs they have Balta, Gibcus, Miller, Blight all 25 and under. Kositschke is probably better suited down back as well. For the Travaglia types they still have Vlastuin and Broad as well as young developing players Brown (a first-rounder) and Trezise. Banks is also best suited to half-back but might be developed as a winger. Kaleb Smith is a bit smaller but also a rebounder the club rates highly after a fantastic VFL season.
If it worked out the way you have it, Richmond would possibly take Langford instead of Smith, then definitely two of Armstrong, Lindsay, Hotton or Allan instead of Trainor and Travaglia.
Finally, there really is no point doing these if you're going to stick with North at 2 and give them Tauru. As you acknowledge yourselves, it won't happen. If you're going to mock the draft, mock the trade. We know it likely involves Richmond getting 2 and North getting 6 or 10, with other picks involved. So work from there.
They 100% need a rebounding defender with Rioli leaving. Agree with the forward. Pick 10 and 11 will be Travaglia and a key forward. They also do not need to trade for pick 2 as we will get 2 gun mids and pick 1 and 6.
@@JMar1011 They 100% don't need to draft a rebounding defender this year. They will go Lindsay before Travaglia as he's quicker, a better kick and a better mid option.
As a Richmond supporter I would LOVE these picks
Love Lalor, Jagga, Trainor, and Travaglia. I also believe Richmond doesn't need to trade up as there will be a quality mid at 6. My only difference is i would take Lindsay, Berry, or Hotton at 10 or 11 as I believe Trainor could be available at pick 18 as he's been sliding lately.
I'd only trade up 10 and 18 or something like that for pick 2. If we can trade up without giving pick 6 then that would be good
I'll be incredibly disappointed if north take Tauru at pick 2
@@bomberwarren Very unlikely, they’ll probably split picks and still get him
@craftofthedraft they really need to, reports coming out that they will sell the farm to trade back which sounds weird lol but makes sense. Loading up in this draft makes more sense for north then using picks next year
Tiges exploring trading pick 10 to Port......
Darn. Missed Tobie Travaglia by one pick selection.
Hopefully North get picks 6 and 12 from Richmond for pick 2 to increase our chances of getting Tobie. Would love to get him and James Barrat at the Eagles (for obvious reasons). Hopefully St Kilda trade out their 2nd top 10 pick as well as that would also help.
I don’t think Richmond should do a Deal with North for Pick 2 but if they do ? Then Lalor , O’Sullivan , Armstrong are 3 selections in the Top 10 THANKS! If Armstrong is gone then cash in on Lindsay , Hotton , Travagalia , Shanahan this is why I’m not a big fan of the Trade with North ? As someone good is going to Slide down to 6 to 12 range as much as I want O’Sullivan at the Tigers it means pick 6 and 20 we would lose could be Stars out of this Draft? Do we go with one Star in O’Sullivan or 2 Stars with picks 6 & 20 ? Pick 6 could be very important pick this year ? A lot of Clubs are interested in Lindsay and he will most likely be gone to Melbourne or St.Kilda at there picks but Richmond could jump them with getting Lindsey at pick 6 if Armstrong is gone ? And if Melbourne has not got Lindsay at 5 ? 🧐👀. 🏆17 🏆19 🏆20 🐅🐅🐅
Id hate it if the Saints take Reid and Langford. Centre bounce explosive, burst away, clearance, goal kicking Midfielders is the NEED. If Smillie is on the board at 7, draft him. Trade pick 8 to Richmond for 11 and 20. Whats the point of drafting a guy (langford) if he doesnt fit our needs in the midfield? Might as well trade down from 8 and STILL draft 2 more players in the first round. I really would consider a key position player at 8 if the saints keep it. Membrey, Campbell, Hayes and Battle, ALL key position players have left the club now, Id rather take Harry Armstrong (Key Forward), Tauru or Trainor (Key Back)at Pick 8, instead of another one-paced 20+ possession a game type mid.
Saints would surely split pick 10 for 18,19 or 14,21.
Then get Hotton or Marshall with Whitlock
I’d take Lashcroft at pick 1 getting him pick 3 is a bargain for the Lions
Richmond take simile???
North won't be reaching for anyone if they keep pick 2. They'll pick best available even if it's a mid. Most likely Draper
That's another risky Horne Francis position. No way they overlook FOS or Jagga for Draper. Draper is a good prospect but that home factor is a bit of a dark spot at north.
jagga yes he is our future captain... very risky taking sam lolar he is injury prone we already have problems with hopper Prestia in the middle and lynch in the forward line is lolar a risk worth taking....
@@peterkay3440yeah not a fan of lolar but I have a feeling they will try and get Lolar and langford ...
Carlton will pick Draper
i hope so, he's a gun
Imagine Adelaide swap pick 4 to Richmond for 6 and say 20 who would Richmond take at 4 ?
No thanks, we need Draper.
Adelaide don't have the list spots for another draft pick. Can only see north trading down
@@peterkay3440 I know Carlton are very keen on Draper and that's why they targetted pick 3 just before Adelaides pick. He will come to Carlton with the Camporeale twins who he knows well.
smith at 8 will be highway robbery
Yeah not gonna happen
Given the clubs picking around that mark and if no trade from North (I'd trade it for multiple picks in the later first round and KPP talent) it's a possibility that it happens. Range is between Carlton's pick 3 and Richmond's current 6 pending possible pick swaps.
Adelaide will be wooed by home grown talent in Draper, and the Dees can't go too wrong with Jagga, or Smilie/ Langford as taller mids either.
We don’t need any tall defenders we need tall forwards and small forwards we lost Bolton Baker so we need to replace them
Ill burn arden st to the ground if they reach for a guy that was gonna get picked around late teens a month ago at 2. Draft best available if can't do a trade sliding back