Amazing documentary , it's sad that the local news channels in India are busy spreading religious propaganda while organisations from outside India are speaking about the real issues. I would've never known these problems exist in India if you never brought them to light, coz our news media will never cover these topics.
Spot on! If they don't divide and keep the people fighting over things such as religion and ethnicity and history, the government wouldn't get away with such atrocities.
No need to be so apologetic to western media my friend. I know that many of our ilk have been conditioned to think of ourselves as inferior when compared to the west still but you need to have a broader perspective of the world as it's changing rapidly everyday. If it wasn't for most of these factories producing generic medicine you will be at the mercy of western Pharma and paying much larger bills on your medicine and it's in these very factories that the vaccine for COVID too was created. They are two sides of the coin in all industries and they have only chosen to show the negative aspects of it.
EU wants India to sign in Free Trade Agreement. Indian government insisted that generic indian drugs also should be allowed in EU. Europeans fear that their pharmaceutical industry will be destroyed.
Its either pharma industry providing millions of jobs or millions starving because of poverty, if pharma industry is polluting then then waste water treatment plants can be setup and setting up of pharma city can be rigorously monitored but stopping an essential industry wrong for the economic future of the region therefore pharma city should be given go ahead for greater good of the people, I know the consequences are bad but it is what it is.
This is such a sad and scandalous state of affairs . My suggestion : the top investors, chairmen &/or presidents & top board members of these pharmaceuticals should be contractually forced to work a manual job in their Hyderabad plants at least once a year for a minimum of 3 days with no special treatment . They would have to drink the water and eat the food their local workers eat , maybe then we’d see faster & more real change rather than propaganda
Sure, if the region had imposed environment laws, the companies would have picked another place that does not. Who is to blame? The industry? We've seen such issues over the centuries over and over again, I conclude its simply us humans, being able to be horrible.
Jayesh Ranjan is not industrial minister, this is completely made with wrong information at ground level, need to review all the videos made by this channel, looks like paid video to blame the government, this is my opinion as a Hyderabadi
He's proud to be responsible for killing people! His grandchildren must be so proud, whilst they are coughing up who knows what. Assuming these children even exist with this level of pollution
I wonder why political leaders never discuss in Parliament & Legislative Assembly and act upon the fatal consequences of water pollution 😔😞😔😞 They bicker among themselves about the most inconsequential matters.
Amazing but how people will fight our all courpet burocrate and our courpet system we never fight because of unity of people kyonki her Lanka mai ek vibhishan Ho ta hai.but nice Approch to way of reporting ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Pollution doesn't mean plants and trees will die. if a land is contaminated by cadmium or selenium for example, many crops will still grow9rice or wheat) but the crop will contain excessive amounts of the pollutants which are very dangerous for humans and animals. The greenery around the river is full of these contaminants. If cattle eat these plants then they fall sick. the milk produced by the cattle will also contain excessive pollutants and will make people sick. Some pollutants cause excessive growth of harmful plants and algae which kills all the fish and other aquatic creatures.
I know a highly polluting chemical factory where surrounding rooftops of houses small trees grow on it. It was found that some pollutants accelerate plant growth. Just because something is growing doesn't mean it's good.
@@Error_-qz2zrMay be in your country but not in Hyderabad. That river MUSI used to be clean drinking water,polluted by many chemical industries not just pharma. Telangana Govt is corrupted and couldn't clean MUSI even after BILLIONS of Rupees spent. We have other water dams and sources.
No taxes and environment regs, gees put out a rat trap then be surprised you caught a few rats ie: factories with companies that will disappear in 50 years
I am from that city, the money generated by the industry never reaches the people. The politicians and industry owners keep all the money. The common people will suffer while the corrupt prosper.
@@mohit13reddyReally? To get that money, you need to work in that industry as someone's employee. There are lakhs of people working for that industry and get paid well. The profit is how an entrepreneur keeps expanding and increases his scope. He is entitled to his profit.
@@HA-rn2iu The employees are getting paid a salary, which might be generous but the these industries are so polluting, the land, air water is destroyed. Do we have to destroy the city and its people to earn profits? Can't they be less greedy and be careful with how they discharge the waste?. It is possible to do business and not harm the people and the land.
Pharma industry deserve much more respect people's are working solely because of passion to serve people so that even poor people can afford medicine, the money they get is nothing in terms of their education.
#artetvdocumentary 15:36 Jayesh Ranjan, IAS is the Principal Secretary, Ministry of Industries and Commerce, Telangana Government. He is not the minister. Refer: www.telangana.gov.in/departments/industries-and-commerce
Watch next 😮Myanmar: The Chin against the Junta I ARTE Documentary
ruclips.net/video/twbZ29ggt0U/видео.html
Amazing documentary , it's sad that the local news channels in India are busy spreading religious propaganda while organisations from outside India are speaking about the real issues. I would've never known these problems exist in India if you never brought them to light, coz our news media will never cover these topics.
That is what religion is for. To put people to sleep with their eyes open. And it's extremely successful.
Spot on!
If they don't divide and keep the people fighting over things such as religion and ethnicity and history, the government wouldn't get away with such atrocities.
No need to be so apologetic to western media my friend. I know that many of our ilk have been conditioned to think of ourselves as inferior when compared to the west still but you need to have a broader perspective of the world as it's changing rapidly everyday. If it wasn't for most of these factories producing generic medicine you will be at the mercy of western Pharma and paying much larger bills on your medicine and it's in these very factories that the vaccine for COVID too was created. They are two sides of the coin in all industries and they have only chosen to show the negative aspects of it.
Arte is quality 💯
India full POWER ZINDABAD 🇮🇳🎸
Amazing work by international organization local org should learn from this and work on real issue rather than spreading religious propaganda
I hope more people watch this
Feel free to share! ;)
EU wants India to sign in Free Trade Agreement. Indian government insisted that generic indian drugs also should be allowed in EU. Europeans fear that their pharmaceutical industry will be destroyed.
Yes, obviously 🤷🏾♂️
Its either pharma industry providing millions of jobs or millions starving because of poverty, if pharma industry is polluting then then waste water treatment plants can be setup and setting up of pharma city can be rigorously monitored but stopping an essential industry wrong for the economic future of the region therefore pharma city should be given go ahead for greater good of the people, I know the consequences are bad but it is what it is.
To, Saraswathi Kaluva: Please accept my respect for doing the right thing. You truly are God send!
*God sent
How ironic,treating numerous disease cause by drug with drugs.
Yea edgelord
This is such a sad and scandalous state of affairs . My suggestion : the top investors, chairmen &/or presidents & top board members of these pharmaceuticals should be contractually forced to work a manual job in their Hyderabad plants at least once a year for a minimum of 3 days with no special treatment . They would have to drink the water and eat the food their local workers eat , maybe then we’d see faster & more real change rather than propaganda
You dreaming 😂
In that case many top investors would end up living in slums 😅
Amazing documentary ,
Sure, if the region had imposed environment laws, the companies would have picked another place that does not. Who is to blame? The industry? We've seen such issues over the centuries over and over again, I conclude its simply us humans, being able to be horrible.
Greed brown envelopes corruption never mind fish nature money is god
Thanka Arte for eye opening documentary ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Jayesh Ranjan is not industrial minister, this is completely made with wrong information at ground level, need to review all the videos made by this channel, looks like paid video to blame the government, this is my opinion as a Hyderabadi
He's proud to be responsible for killing people! His grandchildren must be so proud, whilst they are coughing up who knows what. Assuming these children even exist with this level of pollution
As of today its the most loved real estate business buyers and sellers is Pharma City
Development without heed to ecology is more perilous
Great statement in regards to our modern social and economic systems. Nice job Mr Kumar, I agree with you.
Impossible to industrialize without affecting the environment. People can only be given compensation for the loss. The land is lost.
I wonder why political leaders never discuss in Parliament & Legislative Assembly and act upon the fatal consequences of water pollution 😔😞😔😞
They bicker among themselves about the most inconsequential matters.
Typical western propaganda to defame generic medicine industry of India😅😅
You are so lost my friend..nobody can save you anymore
Correct. Sane Indian.
Their operating revenues are in billions of dollars. Why can't they treat the toxic waste and make it less dangerous?
Amazing but how people will fight our all courpet burocrate and our courpet system we never fight because of unity of people kyonki her Lanka mai ek vibhishan Ho ta hai.but nice Approch to way of reporting ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Why is greenery growing alongside the polluted waterways?
Pollution doesn't mean plants and trees will die. if a land is contaminated by cadmium or selenium for example, many crops will still grow9rice or wheat) but the crop will contain excessive amounts of the pollutants which are very dangerous for humans and animals. The greenery around the river is full of these contaminants. If cattle eat these plants then they fall sick. the milk produced by the cattle will also contain excessive pollutants and will make people sick.
Some pollutants cause excessive growth of harmful plants and algae which kills all the fish and other aquatic creatures.
the same way people drink the water and dont die instantly life can take a lot of abuse
I know a highly polluting chemical factory where surrounding rooftops of houses small trees grow on it. It was found that some pollutants accelerate plant growth. Just because something is growing doesn't mean it's good.
@@Error_-qz2zrMay be in your country but not in Hyderabad. That river MUSI used to be clean drinking water,polluted by many chemical industries not just pharma.
Telangana Govt is corrupted and couldn't clean MUSI even after BILLIONS of Rupees spent.
We have other water dams and sources.
Those asthma inhalers were not that cheap…😢
Where is money there is polution,illnes ,and death.....Horible.
Same scenario takes place in poor countries or regions.
No taxes and environment regs, gees put out a rat trap then be surprised you caught a few rats ie: factories with companies that will disappear in 50 years
This is a catastrophe! I'm so sad when people are thinking only about money... :(
Europe propaganda
Why are u scare of others developing themselves?
Why ?
From west Africa
🦅
You cant be serious about that what you have written there. Have you even watched the documentary?
I am from that city, the money generated by the industry never reaches the people. The politicians and industry owners keep all the money. The common people will suffer while the corrupt prosper.
@@betul1411 go to sleep
@@mohit13reddyReally? To get that money, you need to work in that industry as someone's employee. There are lakhs of people working for that industry and get paid well. The profit is how an entrepreneur keeps expanding and increases his scope. He is entitled to his profit.
@@HA-rn2iu The employees are getting paid a salary, which might be generous but the these industries are so polluting, the land, air water is destroyed. Do we have to destroy the city and its people to earn profits? Can't they be less greedy and be careful with how they discharge the waste?. It is possible to do business and not harm the people and the land.
😢
Pharma industry deserve much more respect people's are working solely because of passion to serve people so that even poor people can afford medicine, the money they get is nothing in terms of their education.
Yes but the pharmaceutical industry is driven by money to be competitive and that has negative impacts on human and natural resources.
@@wadi5145 regulation is required but sometimes way much burden for new startup to grow . Balance between both should be made .
@@AbhishekTiwari-cn8jk that's also another problem
Propaganda channel
#artetvdocumentary
15:36 Jayesh Ranjan, IAS is the Principal Secretary, Ministry of Industries and Commerce, Telangana Government. He is not the minister.
Refer: www.telangana.gov.in/departments/industries-and-commerce