Greetings from Bhutan 🇧🇹 to both the brilliant minds out there , as it has been mind opening to know about the past incidents by China , and been blessed to have such a great country supporting us , May the two countries friendship bring millstones and be an exemplary for the world , long live the Bhutan 🇧🇹 and India 🇮🇳 friendship.
Bhutan did Hindu genocide do you remember it ? Where you forced hindus to flea bhutan you forcefully made hindu eat beef beated them do you remember anything ?
Sir Did you lived their when Hindu ko Target kiya ja raha tha ? Jab Hinduon ka narsamghar hua tha or bhagaya ja raha tha hinduon ko ? Hindu ye bat kaise bhul jate hain. Ki ye desh ne hinduon ke sath jo atya char kiya or india ne bhi un hindu Refuge ko apne desh mai lene se mana kr diya tha. @@gunnersshot
SIR. It was an outstanding conversation between you and Gen Hasnain. You have shown through maps & photographs that China has invested heavily in developing airfields, permanent fortified structures , villages, rail - road connectivity etc., close to the border. This is an extremely sparsely populated area with average height being 14000 above MSL. The only reason can be a sinister design towards India. We have no option other than maintaining extreme vigil along LOC. A multi pronged strategy encomposing minimising trade dependency as prior to 1991, increasing our global foot print as a responsible & reliable partner in manufacturing - supply chain, incrising our offensive capability seems to be the only option. Lastly we need to have a political continuity with respect towards such a policy. Regards.
Salute to our both brave brilliant veteran who is having birds eyes view's on our national integrity and national security. 🙏jai Hind. Fortunately I felt pride always by supporting and cooperating with our forces blindly by being a police officers. 🙏
Thank you. Generals. Succinct and informative. The rebalancing between the the Himalayan mountainous sector and the Maritime Indian Ocean sector is a strong message to China. Naval encounters in the Persian Gulf region is a projection of Indian naval power and we are learning on the fly. There would be other messages that I'm sure have already been given. That the initiative would not remain with them once hostilities break out, that their vulnerabilities would be exploited, that there would be bold and definitive Indian initiatives that will make them pay a price they would be unable to bear.
It is very pleasing to see and to listen our brave military veterans views regarding odds and evens and challenges of our national security. It should be enhance and quality wise. We must go in deep research to knows the faults line of Chinese so that we can combat the policy of Moutse tung that first counter attack and then self defense means Chinese has not made to commit mistakes means accept the hegemony of Chinese willingly or unwillingly. In past there were very bad images and reputation about our veterans that in Military there is also nepotism like cologium system of judiciary and they are Merry making and running dictatorship on the name of discipline in forces, but now things are going change which is very lucrative for nation And nationalist Jai Hind🙏
Very good discussion on the pivotal Role played by Bhutan in the East, very happy to have such a good bond between them and us and also for putting their faith in our shared destiny’s
Respected sirs, What a wonderful and thorough discussion on the NE frontier. Kudos to both of you sirs. Know for certain that Bharat is now safe at the frontiers and inside it . 👏👏👌👌🙏🙏
As a common citizen I appreciate this episode and explaining in layman terms all the thinking behind this think tank. Very nice and thank you for your sevice.
Being yr viewer on the episode for the first time....I really loved it coming from such great minds as two of u n especially the overall significance of the ap modis visit...Ap is a respected word used for elderly like ones father.....thank u for clarifying on chickens neck indian media has been rattling about.....infact it turns out to be like a 'Buffalo surrounded by a lion' scenario if the adversary tries to attack the chickens neck.....so thank u I don't need to worry about our neck anymore....jai bharat n jai Bhutan dosti
Love to our brothers and sisters of Bhutan. Holi’s Abhinandan. A really good analysis and reassuring. I am confidence in India’s ability. It is not the same India of 1862. Furthermore, any war with India, may likely be met on multiple flanks by other countries also intimidated by China. Not to mention the soft power of India is far more than that of China - that will squeeze China economically.
India🇮🇳, a third-rate country, does not deserve the attention of China, one of the five major countries. India is too weak. Let’s be the son of Russia and Britain👦
India🇮🇳, a third-rate country, does not deserve the attention of China, one of the five major countries. India is too weak. Let’s be the son of Russia and Britain👦
Amazing insights. Thank you sir. Is it possible for us to similarly apply reverse pressure by deploying troops at Pauhunri or nearby areas with the potential objective of looking down on and cutting off the chumbi valley?
Good Evening Gen Hasnain Sir and Gen Shankar, very impressed by the detailed analysis. I have following pts 1.we are talking of strategy and tactics. China is Plg Grand strategy by coming into India and ‘ threaten’ the Siliguri corridor and the plains of North India by coming through Bhutan and Nepal like the Manstein plan of second WW. If the neutrality of Bhutan and Nepal are brushed aside and he comes through that , we would be more than shocked. So let’s expect and plan something at that level. He has enough missiles ( conventional) to pulverise these countries into submission. So let’s plan on that and don’t get complacent. 2 Whatever May happen in the IOR , we can’t do anything unless there is a war declared between India and China. So again we can do nothing to his shipping lines in front of the international community. Whereas China is salami slicing on our Northern borders every day whether peace or war. So we need to be more than aggressive here and build up forces As far as IOR is concerned, we can only build up our capabilities. Our Navy is yet to face the PLNA unlike our Army who faces PLA on a daily basis. 3 As far as psy ops are concerned, we are a poor third rate unlike China. We need to work on that alongside Tibetans and those of Xinjiang. So Sir,we need to bring in our national policy to ensure that we as a nation are not surprised like 1962. We have to come out of 62 mentality and think of future scenarios. Rgds
Is it possible to have IOTO (indan Ocean Treaty Organization) with our increasing influence in Indian Ocean region ? Strategic lesson learnt from Chola empire's expansion in South East Asia for our current engagements in Central Asia region ?
According to the USA power index: True rankings of power in the world: Great Power only three: USA, China, Russia. six major powers : France, German, Japan,British, south Korean. middle powers: Canada,Italy,Australia,Brazil,Argentina, Mexico, Spanish. fourth tiers power: India, Pakistan, indonesia, Malaysia. Bangladesh. fifth tier power: the rest of the world. Indian often throw a rocket or a missile into outer space in the hope of lifting its ranking. which is amusing for the rest of world.
@@zengpang3177Great power?? 😂 PLA is too cowardly to even try a simple amphibious landing to take Kinmen island which is just 10 kilometers away from the mainland. Pathetic!
There must be one 50000 strong armed forces mixtures of both India and Bhutan which India must take care om within it's budget it will like building security wall around India. -jaihind har har mahadev mahadev.
.ore and more induan must visits Bhutan as tourism to lift Bhutan financial economically as well as enjoy nature's beuty which will bond both countries like anything prosper Bhutan and happiness in Bhutan is in the interest of both the countriesindia must help Bhutan in building school colleges hospitals infrastructures fir it's betterment which will bond like anything .-jaihind har har mahadev mahadev
Great Episode as Always by the Two Generals There was an Ad... Thumps Up "Taste the Thunder" On... General Ata sir's Voice... "Hear the THUNDER" I didn't understand much of Detailed Maps of Bhutan, Will listen them again.. As never saw such Detailed Maps of Bhutan before Please continue the Great Effort General sirs Pranam प्रणाम Gen Shankar sir Gen Ata sir
Compliments on very vivid military analysis on our borders with China and where we stand in defence of the same. The crucks of the matter appears to be "political continuity" with Bhutan, Nepal and Bangladesh ! We also should consider Maldives while thinking about the "political continuity" with "small, weak, India dependent" nation States, that surround our country ! Some diplomatic mistreatment is suspected to have resulted in Bhutan surprising India by opening direct dialogue with China on settlement of the border dispute with them, Bangladesh inching towards them for economic assistance, Nepal leaning on them for their essential supplies, like oil and gas etc, and Maldives "ordering us to evacuate" our soldiers out of their territory by a fixed time line ! Isn't our Diplomatic Corps making it difficult for our Defence Corps to secure our borders ??
Generals, Good morning. Excellent talk. But I feel we have mostly heard it with a defensive mindset. Can anything offensive be discussed to change our mindset. Regards.
Hello sir , Recently a national security editor , from The Print , Mr. Swami wrote an article on mercenaries being allowed in India . Would genuinely love to know your opinion on that article .
How about India and Bhutan likewise develop the boundary areas. People may protect the border by themselves as first line of defense. It is good news that India has tunnels being built and new facilities coming up on borders
Very informative initiative, thanks a lot for it !! I have a question related to India’s nuclear posture!! Can we go for a posture like when India is at war with one nation and during that, if any other country gets directly involved against us then we can have the option of exercising nuclear option ? Will it help us deal with TWO FRONTS SITUATION ? KINDLY REPLY if possible!! Thanks !!
We should not assume that PLA will take the same route for incursions which they took in 1962 . Gen can talk about the routes taken by PLA in 1962 but there is no need to discuss which are the passes and routes can be taken in future for incursions .
Firstly, in terms of maritime power projection, India does have a significant advantage over China due to its geographic position and naval capabilities. The Indian Navy has been expanding its fleet and enhancing its capabilities over the years, including aircraft carriers, submarines, and surface combatants. In a maritime conflict, India could potentially disrupt Chinese maritime trade routes and chokepoints, thereby exerting pressure on China's economy and military logistics. However, when it comes to the continental domain, particularly in the Himalayan region, China does possess significant logistical capabilities. China has invested heavily in infrastructure along its borders, including roads, railways, and airfields, which could facilitate the movement of troops, supplies, and equipment in mountainous terrain. Additionally, China's military modernization efforts have focused on enhancing its rapid deployment and sustainment capabilities, which could enable it to maintain a prolonged presence in the region. In contrast, while India has also been improving its infrastructure and logistics capabilities along the border with China, it may face challenges in sustaining a prolonged conflict in the Himalayan region. The rugged terrain, harsh weather conditions, and limited infrastructure pose logistical challenges for India's military operations. However, India has been working to address these challenges through initiatives such as the development of border infrastructure and the modernization of its armed forces. In terms of staying power, both countries have their strengths and weaknesses. China's centralized command structure and vast resources could allow it to sustain a prolonged conflict, but it also faces challenges such as potential supply chain disruptions and the risk of overextension. India, on the other hand, may face challenges in sustaining operations in both the maritime and continental domains simultaneously but could leverage its alliances and partnerships to mitigate these challenges. Ultimately, the outcome of a potential conflict would depend on various factors, including each country's military strategy, readiness, resilience, and ability to adapt to evolving circumstances. It's essential to remember that war is a complex and unpredictable endeavor, and any assessment of staying power should consider a wide range of factors and scenarios.
Indian Army must ensure that PLA never make incursion in any sector or surprise us in any sector . It has never made public how Indian Army was surprised in multiple sectors in 2020 . Why no head roled for the lapses .
Namskar General sir, can't we and Bhutanese occupy Chinese land in between zapurlung and passurlung (pls ignore spell) and force China to withdraw their Bhutanese land occupation ?
As a Bhutanese dont agree your analysis. 1949 treaty is reviewed. That's not what majority Bhutanese think and want. Bhutan does not hate or love india, neither china.
How a country is like can be judged by its average life expectancy, average education level, the proportion of women participating in the workforce, and their status, not by the media. China's indicators are far better than those of some countries, but those countries always describe China as a devil.😂
India has followed defensive posture all these while, and China is taking advantage of our actions the time has come for tit for tat. We have Tibet and Taiwan their weak points.
Funny. Speak about peace but being provocative to China. You lost your mind that makes China will always far behind China in every aspect of life. Be with it be realistic
King of Bhutan gave Moldy the highest award but prefer to work with China on its infrastructure. After the award Bhutan King told Moldy do not interfere with China Development. Why does the Podcaster accused China bullying Bhutan when the Kind seek help from China.?
I am not an expert. With all these discussions including where our artillery placed, where supplies are, where the staging area is and all that important sensitive information, aren’t you guys exposing the defense and offense plans of Bharat? Just curious!
Another excellent programme! I have a suggestion. Can we please stop referring to Tibet as China? Both of you referred to it as Tibet while speaking but the images say China. Thank you.
What if china uses air power to surpass Siliguri for entire an year , like Russia is doing in Ukraine , 😮 china need time of 6 months to build road if they captur Siliguri corridor after that they will put large size of troops
Tibet, Bhutan, Nepal, East Turkistan, Aksai Chin etc are closer to India than far east Main land China. But unfortunately we have made Chinese mindset as our big brother and they have been bullying and over powered these farther lands keeping India a mute spectator. Galwan also proved that our Army is clueless to handle mighty China, and got fooled with their mass troop movement at border.
India only exist after Brits colonization but being provocative. Indian just can not face the reality and the facts India is far far behind China. Less talk more work that what your need to do
Bhutan want develop only India out of the way , India cannot provide modernization investment stop others country help etc : Bhutan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Maldives why U India poor doesn't mean with follow Ur footsteps to poor as those countries
This is not a Hindi channel ... I will use the Hindi I know....otherwise I can start speaking in Tamil or Telugu....be within limits...or do not see this channel.
india will reduce geographically in future. China will decide which land is occupied and which is not occupied. Division of india has been decided. US will use u but not fight. u can do nothing except laughing.
You are being paranoid about China obsession instead of talking peace and seeking ameliorating solution of good neighbor. Please thank out of the box instead of everyone being obstinate.
It’s too little too late, Bhutan already given Docklam to China Sir, name of an ours neighbouring country who’s been happy with the Modi’s government and standing with India ? The modi’s foreign policy it’s the complete disaster for India.
Awesome discussion.....everyone missing this video is missing pure gold
PRS's podcasts need at least million followers, how can this be achieved ?
May be an edited version for popular and impatient audience and longer version for keener followers may be a good solution.
Greetings from Bhutan 🇧🇹 to both the brilliant minds out there , as it has been mind opening to know about the past incidents by China , and been blessed to have such a great country supporting us , May the two countries friendship bring millstones and be an exemplary for the world , long live the Bhutan 🇧🇹 and India 🇮🇳 friendship.
Thanks a lot to you and Bhutan. I have lived there and I love it.
Bhutan did Hindu genocide do you remember it ? Where you forced hindus to flea bhutan you forcefully made hindu eat beef beated them do you remember anything ?
Sir Did you lived their when Hindu ko Target kiya ja raha tha ? Jab Hinduon ka narsamghar hua tha or bhagaya ja raha tha hinduon ko ? Hindu ye bat kaise bhul jate hain. Ki ye desh ne hinduon ke sath jo atya char kiya or india ne bhi un hindu Refuge ko apne desh mai lene se mana kr diya tha. @@gunnersshot
SIR.
It was an outstanding conversation between you and Gen Hasnain.
You have shown through maps & photographs that China has invested heavily in developing airfields, permanent fortified structures , villages, rail - road connectivity etc., close to the border. This is an extremely sparsely populated area with average height being 14000 above MSL.
The only reason can be a sinister design towards India.
We have no option other than maintaining extreme vigil along LOC.
A multi pronged strategy encomposing minimising trade dependency as prior to 1991, increasing our global foot print as a responsible & reliable partner in manufacturing - supply chain, incrising our offensive capability seems to be the only option.
Lastly we need to have a political continuity with respect towards such a policy.
Regards.
Very informative sirs, we are very proud of our defence forces and our leader Modi
Salute to our both brave brilliant veteran who is having birds eyes view's on our national integrity and national security. 🙏jai Hind. Fortunately I felt pride always by supporting and cooperating with our forces blindly by being a police officers. 🙏
I wish long life of our brave brilliant and visionary veterans. Jai Hind
A masterclass on India's strategic counterbalances viz China's outrageous claims on Bhutan's Eastern and Western boundary.👌
Great analysis
Gen Ata Hasnain a luminary.
Thanks a lot for such an informative and thoughtful discussion, General Hasnain and General Shankar. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Fabulous episode. Gen. Ata Hasnain and Gen. PR Shankar, you both are wonderful communicators.
Enlightening, deeply insightful. Power to our fauj!
Thank you. Generals. Succinct and informative. The rebalancing between the the Himalayan mountainous sector and the Maritime Indian Ocean sector is a strong message to China. Naval encounters in the Persian Gulf region is a projection of Indian naval power and we are learning on the fly. There would be other messages that I'm sure have already been given. That the initiative would not remain with them once hostilities break out, that their vulnerabilities would be exploited, that there would be bold and definitive Indian initiatives that will make them pay a price they would be unable to bear.
It is very pleasing to see and to listen our brave military veterans views regarding odds and evens and challenges of our national security. It should be enhance and quality wise. We must go in deep research to knows the faults line of Chinese so that we can combat the policy of Moutse tung that first counter attack and then self defense means Chinese has not made to commit mistakes means accept the hegemony of Chinese willingly or unwillingly. In past there were very bad images and reputation about our veterans that in Military there is also nepotism like cologium system of judiciary and they are Merry making and running dictatorship on the name of discipline in forces, but now things are going change which is very lucrative for nation And nationalist Jai Hind🙏
Very good discussion on the pivotal Role played by Bhutan in the East, very happy to have such a good bond between them and us and also for putting their faith in our shared destiny’s
It is brilliant & brave discussion has insights. & required to secure our Nation'ssecurity . Joy Hind, JOY BHARAT.❤❤❤
Respected sirs,
What a wonderful and thorough discussion on the NE frontier. Kudos to both of you sirs. Know for certain that Bharat is now safe at the frontiers and inside it . 👏👏👌👌🙏🙏
Sir , No doubt it is one the best video made by you . Your intellect and energy is seen to be believed . God bless you . ❤
Superb sirs. I am loving these conversations
Very fascinating
Amazing episode
As a common citizen I appreciate this episode and explaining in layman terms all the thinking behind this think tank. Very nice and thank you for your sevice.
Our pleasure!
Great insights Sirs
Jai Hind
Being yr viewer on the episode for the first time....I really loved it coming from such great minds as two of u n especially the overall significance of the ap modis visit...Ap is a respected word used for elderly like ones father.....thank u for clarifying on chickens neck indian media has been rattling about.....infact it turns out to be like a 'Buffalo surrounded by a lion' scenario if the adversary tries to attack the chickens neck.....so thank u I don't need to worry about our neck anymore....jai bharat n jai Bhutan dosti
Thanks a lot
Daju...take care
Generation of huge appreciations and thanks to India 🇮🇳 government and people ❤. Pelden Drukpa Gyelo.
शुभ होली 🍨🎉🍹। जय हिन्द 🇮🇳
Excellent video
Glad you liked it
Jai hind sir
Brilliant analysis and highly educative. Thank you!!!
Our pleasure!
Love to our brothers and sisters of Bhutan.
Holi’s Abhinandan.
A really good analysis and reassuring. I am confidence in India’s ability. It is not the same India of 1862.
Furthermore, any war with India, may likely be met on multiple flanks by other countries also intimidated by China.
Not to mention the soft power of India is far more than that of China - that will squeeze China economically.
India🇮🇳, a third-rate country, does not deserve the attention of China, one of the five major countries. India is too weak. Let’s be the son of Russia and Britain👦
India🇮🇳, a third-rate country, does not deserve the attention of China, one of the five major countries. India is too weak. Let’s be the son of Russia and Britain👦
👍🙏
Namaskar 🙏💐
Thanks!
Thanks a lot for your generosity
Holi subhkamana
Amazing insights. Thank you sir. Is it possible for us to similarly apply reverse pressure by deploying troops at Pauhunri or nearby areas with the potential objective of looking down on and cutting off the chumbi valley?
Good Evening Gen Hasnain Sir and Gen Shankar, very impressed by the detailed analysis. I have following pts
1.we are talking of strategy and tactics. China is Plg Grand strategy by coming into India and ‘ threaten’ the Siliguri corridor and the plains of North India by coming through Bhutan and Nepal like the Manstein plan of second WW. If the neutrality of Bhutan and Nepal are brushed aside and he comes through that , we would be more than shocked. So let’s expect and plan something at that level. He has enough missiles ( conventional) to pulverise these countries into submission. So let’s plan on that and don’t get complacent.
2 Whatever May happen in the IOR , we can’t do anything unless there is a war declared between India and China. So again we can do nothing to his shipping lines in front of the international community. Whereas China is salami slicing on our Northern borders every day whether peace or war. So we need to be more than aggressive here and build up forces As far as IOR is concerned, we can only build up our capabilities. Our Navy is yet to face the PLNA unlike our Army who faces PLA on a daily basis.
3 As far as psy ops are concerned, we are a poor third rate unlike China. We need to work on that alongside Tibetans and those of Xinjiang.
So Sir,we need to bring in our national policy to ensure that we as a nation are not surprised like 1962. We have to come out of 62 mentality and think of future scenarios. Rgds
Will answer this on Sunday
Is it possible to have IOTO (indan Ocean Treaty Organization) with our increasing influence in Indian Ocean region ? Strategic lesson learnt from Chola empire's expansion in South East Asia for our current engagements in Central Asia region ?
According to the USA power index: True rankings of power in the world: Great Power only three: USA, China, Russia. six major powers : France, German, Japan,British, south Korean. middle powers: Canada,Italy,Australia,Brazil,Argentina, Mexico, Spanish. fourth tiers power: India, Pakistan, indonesia, Malaysia. Bangladesh. fifth tier power: the rest of the world. Indian often throw a rocket or a missile into outer space in the hope of lifting its ranking. which is amusing for the rest of world.
Then Hegemonic Western ambitions are better?? Once screwed by the British Indians never learn!
@@zengpang3177Great power?? 😂 PLA is too cowardly to even try a simple amphibious landing to take Kinmen island which is just 10 kilometers away from the mainland. Pathetic!
The Chinese bot!
There must be one 50000 strong armed forces mixtures of both India and Bhutan which India must take care om within it's budget it will like building security wall around India. -jaihind har har mahadev mahadev.
.ore and more induan must visits Bhutan as tourism to lift Bhutan financial economically as well as enjoy nature's beuty which will bond both countries like anything prosper Bhutan and happiness in Bhutan is in the interest of both the countriesindia must help Bhutan in building school colleges hospitals infrastructures fir it's betterment which will bond like anything .-jaihind har har mahadev mahadev
Great Episode as Always
by the
Two Generals
There was an Ad...
Thumps Up
"Taste the Thunder"
On...
General Ata sir's
Voice...
"Hear the THUNDER"
I didn't understand much of Detailed Maps of Bhutan,
Will listen them again..
As never saw such
Detailed Maps of Bhutan before
Please continue the Great Effort
General sirs
Pranam प्रणाम
Gen Shankar sir
Gen Ata sir
Very illuminating discussion indeed with graphic displays ,maps etc
Compliments on very vivid military analysis on our borders with China and where we stand in defence of the same.
The crucks of the matter appears to be "political continuity" with Bhutan, Nepal and Bangladesh ! We also should consider Maldives while thinking about the "political continuity" with "small, weak, India dependent" nation States, that surround our country !
Some diplomatic mistreatment is suspected to have resulted in Bhutan surprising India by opening direct dialogue with China on settlement of the border dispute with them, Bangladesh inching towards them for economic assistance, Nepal leaning on them for their essential supplies, like oil and gas etc, and Maldives "ordering us to evacuate" our soldiers out of their territory by a fixed time line !
Isn't our Diplomatic Corps making it difficult for our Defence Corps to secure our borders ??
China’s ambitions are never ending respected sirs.
Then Hegemonic Western ambitions are better?? Once screwed by the British Indians never learn!
HAPPY HOLI
Same to you too.
Generals, Good morning. Excellent talk. But I feel we have mostly heard it with a defensive mindset. Can anything offensive be discussed to change our mindset. Regards.
we will not discuss offensive actions due to security constraints
Bhutan and Arunchal are India’s two eyes. India will protect these with all her might from China
Hello sir ,
Recently a national security editor , from The Print , Mr. Swami wrote an article on mercenaries being allowed in India .
Would genuinely love to know your opinion on that article .
Hmm...long time no hear?
How about India and Bhutan likewise develop the boundary areas. People may protect the border by themselves as first line of defense. It is good news that India has tunnels being built and new facilities coming up on borders
Good idea.
Is Indian Ocean Treaty Organization of Central and South East Asian nations in coming future ?
will reply on Sunday . Question noted
Very informative initiative, thanks a lot for it !!
I have a question related to India’s nuclear posture!!
Can we go for a posture like when India is at war with one nation and during that, if any other country gets directly involved against us then we can have the option of exercising nuclear option ? Will it help us deal with TWO FRONTS SITUATION ?
KINDLY REPLY if possible!!
Thanks !!
Hmm…that’s the best reply…
Then Hegemonic Western ambitions are better?? Once screwed by the British Indians never learn!
Sir, what are war games and how are they conducted?
ask me on Sunday during open session.
Sirs... Please tell us..can we catch up Tibet !
hmm
Dont u agree that such issues..doklam n bhutan cant be kept lingering...need to take decisive action at some point of time ?
Rational discussion with China is moot. Overt aggression is probably what they understand
Then Hegemonic Western ambitions are better?? Once screwed by the British Indians never learn!
We should not assume that PLA will take the same route for incursions which they took in 1962 .
Gen can talk about the routes taken by PLA in 1962 but there is no need to discuss which are the passes and routes can be taken in future for incursions .
hmm....You must connect intentions of the Chinese with their claims. Other wise we will be dumb.
Great information ,gives lot of confidence. Jai Hind saab.
These border issues are instigated by CIA! Us Asians Hegemonic Western ambitions are better?? Once screwed by the British Indians never learn!
Firstly, in terms of maritime power projection, India does have a significant advantage over China due to its geographic position and naval capabilities. The Indian Navy has been expanding its fleet and enhancing its capabilities over the years, including aircraft carriers, submarines, and surface combatants. In a maritime conflict, India could potentially disrupt Chinese maritime trade routes and chokepoints, thereby exerting pressure on China's economy and military logistics.
However, when it comes to the continental domain, particularly in the Himalayan region, China does possess significant logistical capabilities. China has invested heavily in infrastructure along its borders, including roads, railways, and airfields, which could facilitate the movement of troops, supplies, and equipment in mountainous terrain. Additionally, China's military modernization efforts have focused on enhancing its rapid deployment and sustainment capabilities, which could enable it to maintain a prolonged presence in the region.
In contrast, while India has also been improving its infrastructure and logistics capabilities along the border with China, it may face challenges in sustaining a prolonged conflict in the Himalayan region. The rugged terrain, harsh weather conditions, and limited infrastructure pose logistical challenges for India's military operations. However, India has been working to address these challenges through initiatives such as the development of border infrastructure and the modernization of its armed forces.
In terms of staying power, both countries have their strengths and weaknesses. China's centralized command structure and vast resources could allow it to sustain a prolonged conflict, but it also faces challenges such as potential supply chain disruptions and the risk of overextension. India, on the other hand, may face challenges in sustaining operations in both the maritime and continental domains simultaneously but could leverage its alliances and partnerships to mitigate these challenges.
Ultimately, the outcome of a potential conflict would depend on various factors, including each country's military strategy, readiness, resilience, and ability to adapt to evolving circumstances. It's essential to remember that war is a complex and unpredictable endeavor, and any assessment of staying power should consider a wide range of factors and scenarios.
Thanks for your considered opinion
WHEN IN UNIFORM HAD NOT GUTS TO INFORM GOVT.
You think so ?
What is the outcome about Doklam. Did Modi succeed?
Indian Army must ensure that PLA never make incursion in any sector or surprise us in any sector . It has never made public how Indian Army was surprised in multiple sectors in 2020 . Why no head roled for the lapses .
Hmm
Hmm
These border issues are instigated by CIA! Us Asians Hegemonic Western ambitions are better?? Once screwed by the British Indians never learn!
PLA will fall in line only when their highways are strongly in our crosshairs
Its always men behind machines.
Namskar General sir, can't we and Bhutanese occupy Chinese land in between zapurlung and passurlung (pls ignore spell) and force China to withdraw their Bhutanese land occupation ?
No. They are all high Himalayan terrain
@@gunnersshot 🙏
Tibet’s land - no Chinese land in Chumbi valley
Sir please hundi me
As a Bhutanese dont agree your analysis. 1949 treaty is reviewed. That's not what majority Bhutanese think and want.
Bhutan does not hate or love india, neither china.
That is fine
Bha Rats want Bhutan become a state of india
How a country is like can be judged by its average life expectancy, average education level, the proportion of women participating in the workforce, and their status, not by the media.
China's indicators are far better than those of some countries, but those countries always describe China as a devil.😂
India has followed defensive posture all these while, and China is taking advantage of our actions the time has come for tit for tat. We have Tibet and Taiwan their weak points.
Exile Tibetans should be showcased in front of world and aided by india & USA for free Tibet ,Dalailama and Tibetans March forward restrict china
Funny. Speak about peace but being provocative to China. You lost your mind that makes China will always far behind China in every aspect of life. Be with it be realistic
King of Bhutan gave Moldy the highest award but prefer to work with China on its infrastructure. After the award Bhutan King told Moldy do not interfere with China Development. Why does the Podcaster accused China bullying Bhutan when the Kind seek help from China.?
You are from China
@@gunnersshot No, from West kashmir.
I am not an expert. With all these discussions including where our artillery placed, where supplies are, where the staging area is and all that important sensitive information, aren’t you guys exposing the defense and offense plans of Bharat? Just curious!
Don’t worry
Another excellent programme! I have a suggestion. Can we please stop referring to Tibet as China? Both of you referred to it as Tibet while speaking but the images say China. Thank you.
Are you doing RUclips policing?
@@gunnersshot haha. Absolutely not. This was a suggestion.
Return South Tibet,
Arunachal Pradesh
? To whom?
@@gunnersshot Dumb ?
What if china uses air power to surpass Siliguri for entire an year , like Russia is doing in Ukraine , 😮 china need time of 6 months to build road if they captur Siliguri corridor after that they will put large size of troops
They do not have the capacity
Genl saab pl. Choose it Tibet, not China🙏
Get lost
Bhutan chooses china and this makes endia angry saying bhutan belongs to endia .
Wong check your Dong! Its showing!
Tibet, Bhutan, Nepal, East Turkistan, Aksai Chin etc are closer to India than far east Main land China.
But unfortunately we have made Chinese mindset as our big brother and they have been bullying and over powered these farther lands keeping India a mute spectator.
Galwan also proved that our Army is clueless to handle mighty China, and got fooled with their mass troop movement at border.
hmm
India only exist after Brits colonization but being provocative. Indian just can not face the reality and the facts India is far far behind China. Less talk more work that what your need to do
You Tube unsubscribed me again from your channel
I do not know why.ask you tube if there is any algorithm for that. I will put Ina complaint though
How ahout internal foolishness ? .....
Modi’s Failed Economic Policies: Conversation w/Jayant Bhandari! Part 2
ruclips.net/video/AM52REUJt_M/видео.html
Hmm
HOW CAN INDIA RATTLE CHINA ?? WHAT PUSHBACK?? HOW ?
CHINA DID NOT LURE BHUTAN BUT BHUTAN IS IN LOVE WITH CHINA AND GETTING SICK OF INDIA
Hmm
Bhutan want develop only India out of the way , India cannot provide modernization investment stop others country help etc : Bhutan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Maldives why U India poor doesn't mean with follow Ur footsteps to poor as those countries
hmm
English channel unsubscribed kar Diya aaj
All the best
gentlemen to start with the word mubarak ho is islamic ... this is not a hindi word perhaps words like subh Holi or Abhinandanan
This is not a Hindi channel ... I will use the Hindi I know....otherwise I can start speaking in Tamil or Telugu....be within limits...or do not see this channel.
Talk like quarrelling.
Hmm
india will reduce geographically in future. China will decide which land is occupied and which is not occupied. Division of india has been decided. US will use u but not fight. u can do nothing except laughing.
Pakistan ka kya höga?
You are being paranoid about China obsession instead of talking peace and seeking ameliorating solution of good neighbor. Please thank out of the box instead of everyone being obstinate.
Hmm
It’s too little too late, Bhutan already given Docklam to China Sir, name of an ours neighbouring country who’s been happy with the Modi’s government and standing with India ? The modi’s foreign policy it’s the complete disaster for India.
in your dream
This is not a political channel
@@rahulbanerjee2363what do you mean in my dream? Tell me a name of the country which is happy with us?
These border issues are instigated by CIA! Us Asians Hegemonic Western ambitions are better?? Once screwed by the British Indians never learn!
@@markvelber8664you tell me how many country which are neighbour of china are happy with china , its is diplomacy .
I wish long life of our brave brilliant and visionary veterans. Jai Hind
Thanks a lot. Your blessings mean a lot to us.