I've owned Ferraris and own 3 Porsches now including a 997.2 GT3. My Alfa QV is my favorite car. And it drives like a Mercedes on bad California roads whereas an M3 would cause loose fillings in my teeth. I'm at 3 years, and it still inspires me. Why they don't compare them on ROADS where they are driven 99% of the time is baffling. I don't live on a track. I live in Los Angeles, the land of potholes.
Why you watch stupid reviews which is all about "how I feel" and one dude obviously struggling with keeping car on the road. Go to car center and request a test drive 🤣 im not as fancy as you tho. I only own 1 Porsche and BMW X7
I own the Giulia Ti Sport (Veloce) and it is an absolute blissful experience every time I drive her. Going on three years with not so much as a hiccup. It is a brilliant machine. Easily the best, most fun sports-sedan on the planet by a considerable margin.
@@leok7193 This is true but judging a car only on specs is not very wise and it gives you only one perspective. This BMW is a great car that is certain, however for some of us Alfa has something that BMW will never have and that is why in general Giulia is such a great car, objectively and subjectively.
I have owned an Alfa QV for three years now and i think its the most balanced and complete car I have ever owned or driven. Still years ahead of competition despite being 4 years old.
how is it reliability wise? as I really want to give it a go, but scared the reliability might not be there... how has yours been for the past 3 years? Thanks in advance!
@@JuliansCarChannel pretty good to hear that, seems like that problem of alfas having issues has gone, was it a brand new or second hand purchase, used market is looking very tempting
Very good review. Consistency instead of appearance. BMW is a great car, better interior quality and more gadgets....no discussion on that. The Alfa is more refined under the "skin" with a double wishbone suspension, rear slip differential and with a carbon-fiber propeller shaft. It is unbelivable that after 5 years this Alfa still competent and competitive on the market....what a machine!
wait, it is still on the road past year 5? Car and Driver crucified it after their 4 year long term test. considering some bavarians still deliver at the 20 year mark, tough to pass the Alfa its reliability issues.
@@firstname7780 Have you ever owned a BMW ? RELIABILITY ???? M 3 Subframe Cracks M 5 Rod Bearing Failures Vanos failures across the board Fuel Pump Failures across the board and now you have to deal with "The Grille" !!!!! FORZA ALFA BABY !!!! THE KING IS BACK !!!!
@@hassanger8128 The problem with your reply is it can be used against any decision any journalist makes about any car which you disagree with. It dismisses points it doesn't address them.
Proud 2019 qv owner here, vesuvio grey, 16k miles on the clock. Had 3 m3s before my qv. Loved them. This QV though, is something else. What a machine. Just insane. Best car I have ever owned, an absolute blast to drive but also so comfortable and balanced. I never thought I'd like a car more than my last dct e92 m3.
Very nice review. The Giulia is definitely a better car in my opinion, which will become a classic, like the BMW E46. Looking at the 2 cars together in this video you immediately see the differences..The M3 is a tuned 3 series while the Giulia QV was developed from zero with the purpose of being a sport car. All vents and dams are functional. BMW clearly tried to copy some of the Giulia's aesthetic features (see the shape of the rear spoiler, the Montreal green color, the carbon bucket seats, the new bigger paddle shift)..but it was impossible to achieve top driving dynamics starting from a normal 3 series.
Ok so what you’re saying is that a standard giulia doesn’t exist and that the qv version is a besboke model that doesn’t share anything with the normal car 🤨🤨🤨 COTA YLE XoarXXar? :))
@@nikashushanashvili8100 No Nika, i am not saying this. I mean that the standard Giulia was developed after the Giulia QV, which was developed from scratch by the same engineer who worked on the 458, with the purpose of creating a proper sport car with 4 doors. So the normal Giulia is a scaled down version of the QV, but sharing the same steering, chassis, carbon fiber driveshaft and extensive use of aluminum, which makes the normal car a reference in the category for driving dynamics and weight. That said i believe that the normal BMW 3 series is a better package than the normal Giulia, because in buying a normal saloon the parameters of valuation are different, and a fancy cabin, top class infotainment, laser led lights, virtual dashboard and so on are much more important in this segment.
Except the regular 3 series has better driving dynamics than the regular giulia and the M3 has always had better handling/ driving dynamics as well as better daily capabilities than the Giulia QV You can’t even get the Giulia with a manual in the main target market USA, such a shame
Ditch those pirelli corsas on the Alfa and get yourself the Michelin MP4s tyres which are now available in the correct size for the rear. 👍🏼 Much better tyre for UK climate
@@stephenlongfield8492 yeah they are certainly a great tyre by all accounts too. I would have gone down that route if the ps4s wasn't available in the correct size. 👍🏼
I bought a late 2017 Alfa Guilia QF from new and was blown away by how good it was. I had it for 2 years, swapped to Winter tyres October-March and had an absolute ball You find after a little while with the car that you can modulate the brakes with no problem. My only gripes were no split fold rear seat and no Apple CarPlay, but the Alfa (TomTom) system was fine - both sorted now. To be honest, I just had a smile on my face every time I drove it. Give one a test drive and if you can find some pennies down the back of a sofa, just go out and get one. It is hard to define, but this car has soul. A 6 star car :D
I agree. I'd take the QV, though with the optional carbon racing seats, carbon ceramic breaks & titanium exhaust to save a bit more weight & get a bit more breaking consistency on the track
Except it's not that great of an engine (having driven it). It felt like I had almost no power until about 5k rpm and with redline around 7k you're constantly shifting if you're going through curves, but that's what you get with 30 psi boost, which feels like a ticking time bomb (BMW does 19 psi). I'm sure the actual Ferrari engine is better, probably wider power band, higher redline, and more power down low before turbo kicks in, but QV engine is not one to drool over
@@leok7193 you keep spouting this utter garbage. I’ve owned both and that it just absolutely not the case. The Alfa engine is far superior to the f80/2 engine, the whole car is far superior so please stop being a fan bot
@@peterszendrei they are expensive for a reason And the trio always says they would take the Ferrari over any other supercar so it probably means something
I'm guessing it's love despite all shortcomings, but I am glad you're enjoying it. I've been enjoying F82 for the last year. Put in my order after I saw what was going to happen with the grille on the new one lol
After all this time, the M3 still cannot dethrone the mighty Alfa! Job well done to all the engineers at Alfa for creating the ultimate driving machine, still to this day!
@@davissilvestrs1996 The Nurburgring proved otherwise which measures handling braking etc. I highly doubt the new M3 will beat 7:32 since it is also heavier than the QV.
@@davissilvestrs1996 That might be true, but I’m comparing sedan to sedan, so a 2017 QV ran 7:32 and a 2018 M3 CS ran a 7:38. I’m sure the new platform M4 should be quicker than the 7:32 though. Have the new M3/M4 been tested at the Nring yet for official times? Either way, all are very fast sedans/coupes.
@@chasinglimits M3 CS lap time was done by Sport Auto magazine while the Giulia lap time was done by Alfa Romeo factory team, not comparable When you look at other track times (on Fastestlaps) the M3 CS is way quicker, Giulia can be compared to the normal M3 or M3 Competition looking at comparison tests and lap times. Also keep in mind the old gen M3 had a 70hp disadvantage vs the Alfa
@@fulviovalenziano4579 I don't know about girly things like dresses that are made in Italy, but if two clothes like Armani and another cost the same and the Armani sells 20 times more than the other (which is the case with the 3er that sells 20 more times than the Giulia) then the Armani is better looking
And now wait for the Giulia Quadri MKII with new interiors, revised front and back and digital cokpit, expected for end of the year.Ah and yes...more power😉
@@hassanger8128 and @VIB33 I'll bet you two loved the nauseating Bangle E60 5 Series and E65 7-Series too. BMW has been making pig-ugly cars for twenty years now, so there must be a lot of customers with bad taste, bad eyesight or both.
I hope bmw get belted in these reviews I’d love a fully revised LCI Weight reduction New face And a return to form I don’t want to know an m3 as a super saloon but rather a sports car
@@arnoldmbuthia2687 and yet here I am, buying BMWs for the last 15 years, including M3s and a 440. And I fully agree with the OP and will not get another one until Dukec is gone and BMW redesign this POS.
@@arnoldmbuthia2687 No, trolls make decisions @ BMW, how do you think they came up with M in the 1st place & have been expanding for 60 years? M3 now same size as perfect classic E39 M5, but with 100+ hp "too heavy". These repeat owner whingers don't realize they've aged themselves out of M market, maybe they can enjoy nice small-grilled M340i. Or retire to their walkers & keyboards.
@@harriz17 BMW scored few times when it comes to design, for me personally it was 1974 CSL, E46, and maybe F80, but the last one is very young so we will see how good it will look in a decade or two. This M3/4 design is not very nice even without this grill. But the grill is simply unacceptable. Having Alfa next to this car is really a joke.
1. Who else skipped the M3 and fast forward to 8:07 to see the Alfa Romeo? 2. In case you didn't know, that diffuser on the M3 is fake.... same goes to the pumping engine-sound-in-the-cabin! 3. I've said this before: AR Q all day long 365 days!!!!! The AR has soul! where the M3 is like a naked kid running all scared and stressed out looking for a hideout!!
@@mikealanzo "M3 is like a naked kid running all scared and stressed out looking for a hideout!!" giga fanboy, implying the m3 dont have soul like yeah, it dont get much more fanboy^ shut ur mouth if u don't got actuall meaningful comments xD
Why are we "glossing over the nose" of the BMW ? Why not address the ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM ? That freaking thing is HIDEOUS !!! FORZA ALFA BABY !!!! THE KING IS BACK !!!!!
These 2 have their days numbered so no matter which one you prefer, can we just agree that they are some of the best relatively attainable cars on sale today? So maybe instead of arguing, as petrol-heads, we should appreciate and buy them while we still can...
That's why you don't have this kind of money. The people who do (most likely smart people), will buy the M3. We all know the M3 will be a sales success. Sorry.
Don't be so sure about the BMW being better built! Total pain in the arse after 50K miles. Total. I've had three over the years, one recent, and - never again.
Have 2 BMWs (one is a classic mint E30 320i) and a MINI as daily driver, so I'm obviously devoted to the brand. But woud buy the Giulia in a heartbeat.
@@saidalas7763 😍🤣🤣🤣 sorry man ,the quadrigfolio is way prettier, buck tooth ratbeaver hybrid grills don't look good,if they had left normal kidney grilles on it, it would have given the alfa a run for its money looks wise, but sorry not this monstrosity, worst looking m car ever!
really like the new M3, but I think it now makes most sense as a xDrive version in a space the M5 once was in. A fun, very fast and competent daily. But it leaves plenty of room for the M2. I hope it stays considerably cheaper, lighter and more of an enthusiasts sports car.
@@johncreedon1833 get your eyes checked. Seriously, there's no way a person with functioning eyes sees tha Alfa as the better looking car, unless he's a fanboy. Ask your non car people firends, your gf or faimly members who they think is the better looking car. 101% sure they'll say the BMW, which is nothing more but reflecting the sales numbers
☘️☘️☘️ I've had mine for 6 months. An amazing machine. I didn't buy it for the infotainment. I bought it for the engine, chassis, exhaust, and SOUL. 🇮🇹
Love the Alfa - BMW have completely lost the plot and M3 occupies the same space that the M5 did - bloated luxo barge. Being back the tidy lightweight M3 saloon!!
It is nice to see That most of the comments are in favor of the alfa, but still no one is buying it. Don't get me wrong I'm an alfa fan, expecially the onld ones, but I'm just noticing that everyone loves the Giulia but very few buy it, and it is sad because if sells don't go the right way this would probably be the last alfa sedan. Then alfa will reduce to sell boring suv.
@@emanuelemasella5312 always Maserati. bmws are for babies GARBAGE AND FULL OF POVERTY THE INTERIOR IS TRASH and has fake ass claims on the internet EMBARRASSING HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
These stoopid Alfa fanboys are not petrolheads, they can't even appreciate the manual of the BMW All they want is ugly triangular grills. But don't worry, actual buyers (people who are smart to have that kind of money, not lazy weirdos on YT comments bashing BMW) will prefer the M3 which will be evident from the sales numbers
As the owner of an Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio I have been petitioning BMW to change the rodent teeth on the front of the new M 3 / M 4 as they are always in my rear view mirror and they are making me nauseous while driving.....they told me they are working on it...
The problem is that m2 is already heavy car... Maybe you can't feel it but even on these shots the car looks very heavy. Over 1700kg in m3... Wgere are we going?!!! Alfa all the way
@@ma3kc i was an owner of F10 M5 and weight was killing this car. The point is on the one hand we are going with downsizing yet we are adding tons and we put extreme loads on the engine.
@@saidalas7763 You know nothing about what I can or cannot afford. Please abstain yourself from talking about what you don’t now, because I own more than one Alfa Romeo!! I am not a teenager like you, young lad. If you prefer the BMW, it’s your choice. I would never write that you have bad taste. I also own BMW’s. This shows how childish you are.
I don't like the fact that BMW made the M3's body wider, but kept the rear doors untouched. The wide body behind the rear doors looks incredibly forced, and I am sorry that the accountants won and the designers lost. Don't buy this car, it was created by penny pinchers.
Bmws break like no one’s Business, lost faith in them ages ago.had 4 used ones and never had a great experience really.they are fun cars but they cost to Much to fix and they deprecate to much.then again I’m not a rich man, so I shouldn’t be driving one anyway.
Great video! The only thing that annoys me is that you used the standard Giulia in the interior B-roll. The other thing are different size rims. It's purely estetic, and it makes the car look stupid imo. Porsche and Merc does it too and I personally hate it.
A nice comparison - I liked it. But we look at your channel worldwide. So can you please work out how to speak more clearly? The middle calm bit was fine but even I had to replay some bits, especially your conclusions at the end (and I'm a Brit - admittedly ex-pat for many years ;o) ).
I thank you BMW for improving the depreciation on my F80 M3 zCP. I chose my M3 zCP over the Alfa 4 years ago this month! I liked both cars but honestly thought the M3 is one of the best looking sedans on the road. Luckily I have no buyer's remorse after seeing the G80. To each their own. I love cars and have no problem with people choosing one brand over another. If you can afford any of the cars in this class you'll have fun!
I got a GQ recently and although I’ve owned many cars and bikes, it is by far the most complete package of them all. Beauty, power but like James Bond it can put on dress clothes for the casino. It is basically a Ferrari sedan. Instant classic. I would recommend buying one before it’s too late.
These track comparisons are really pointless when the cars are equipped with different tires...even you say that alfas corsas suck in the wet/cold, but by the end you totally forget that and declare the m3 a better track car...with no lap time whatso ever taken into account. Btw, what is the M3s Ring time ? Surely it must be better than Alfas, since you say its the better track car...
Alfa has hard plastic ? BMW doesn’t ? I had the chance to check other bmw ‘s and all had hard plastic in the lower part of the doors .,.... Infotainment is more intuitive ? I’d like to see how. The real challenge to develop a sport car is engine, chassis, steering and brakes. And Alfa does it at the best .
I've owned Ferraris and own 3 Porsches now including a 997.2 GT3. My Alfa QV is my favorite car. And it drives like a Mercedes on bad California roads whereas an M3 would cause loose fillings in my teeth. I'm at 3 years, and it still inspires me. Why they don't compare them on ROADS where they are driven 99% of the time is baffling. I don't live on a track. I live in Los Angeles, the land of potholes.
Have you tried the new M3s? I've been driving one daily for the past few weeks and it is very comfortable in comfort mode...
Why you watch stupid reviews which is all about "how I feel" and one dude obviously struggling with keeping car on the road. Go to car center and request a test drive 🤣 im not as fancy as you tho. I only own 1 Porsche and BMW X7
Haha true!
I believe New Orleans may hold the record for potholes on the road... Its ridiculous
I owned Bugatti and 3 Koenigsegg now including Pagani Hyura. My M3 Competition is my favorite car. And it drives like BMW......
I own the Giulia Ti Sport (Veloce) and it is an absolute blissful experience every time I drive her. Going on three years with not so much as a hiccup. It is a brilliant machine. Easily the best, most fun sports-sedan on the planet by a considerable margin.
Maybe the best you've driven, but not even close to being easily the best....
@@leok7193 This is true but judging a car only on specs is not very wise and it gives you only one perspective. This BMW is a great car that is certain, however for some of us Alfa has something that BMW will never have and that is why in general Giulia is such a great car, objectively and subjectively.
How many days did you sleep at the shop?
I have it too for almost an year now. I totally agree with you, but I do have one complaint and that's the turning circle. Could be better.
@@hassanger8128 one sleep over in the city - once a year. It’s called a service. 😂
I have owned an Alfa QV for three years now and i think its the most balanced and complete car I have ever owned or driven. Still years ahead of competition despite being 4 years old.
how is it reliability wise? as I really want to give it a go, but scared the reliability might not be there... how has yours been for the past 3 years? Thanks in advance!
@@MotorDynasty we have owned one (my2019) for nearly 2 years now, never had any problems with it.
@@MotorDynasty no problems brother we love ours !!!
I've never owned one but I've heard people saying that if your getting an Alfa it's almost always better to lease it.
@@JuliansCarChannel pretty good to hear that, seems like that problem of alfas having issues has gone, was it a brand new or second hand purchase, used market is looking very tempting
Very good review. Consistency instead of appearance. BMW is a great car, better interior quality and more gadgets....no discussion on that. The Alfa is more refined under the "skin" with a double wishbone suspension, rear slip differential and with a carbon-fiber propeller shaft. It is unbelivable that after 5 years this Alfa still competent and competitive on the market....what a machine!
you hit the nail right on the head my friend...wow!
wait, it is still on the road past year 5? Car and Driver crucified it after their 4 year long term test. considering some bavarians still deliver at the 20 year mark, tough to pass the Alfa its reliability issues.
@@firstname7780 Have you ever owned a BMW ? RELIABILITY ????
M 3 Subframe Cracks
M 5 Rod Bearing Failures
Vanos failures across the board
Fuel Pump Failures across the board
and now you have to deal with "The Grille" !!!!!
FORZA ALFA BABY !!!!
THE KING IS BACK !!!!
@@jamesterakazis6624 go drive your Panda it's itali
an.
Forza Alfa, simply the best. Love my QV ☘️🤙🏼
the M3 looks way better
Doesn't i brake 247?
@@saidalas7763 the bmw looks like a beaver
@@saidalas7763 😐😐😐😐😐Looks are arguably this generation of M3's bad side
@@krzysiu5145 the worst looking BMW - ever!
The Alfa is actually in it's 5th year of production so it's getting old, which makes it even more impressive you two still prefer it.
They are two paid journalists
Give them E46 M3 and they will adore that too :) They are just too old to understand the new M
Exact. Alfa 5th !!!
@@hassanger8128 The problem with your reply is it can be used against any decision any journalist makes about any car which you disagree with. It dismisses points it doesn't address them.
@@ma3kc Well...yes because the E46 is probably the best M car in recent decades.
Proud 2019 qv owner here, vesuvio grey, 16k miles on the clock. Had 3 m3s before my qv. Loved them. This QV though, is something else. What a machine. Just insane. Best car I have ever owned, an absolute blast to drive but also so comfortable and balanced. I never thought I'd like a car more than my last dct e92 m3.
Sweet review! Nicely explained.👍🏼 That expression on James face while explaining the Giulia's sound track!❤️
Very nice review. The Giulia is definitely a better car in my opinion, which will become a classic, like the BMW E46. Looking at the 2 cars together in this video you immediately see the differences..The M3 is a tuned 3 series while the Giulia QV was developed from zero with the purpose of being a sport car. All vents and dams are functional. BMW clearly tried to copy some of the Giulia's aesthetic features (see the shape of the rear spoiler, the Montreal green color, the carbon bucket seats, the new bigger paddle shift)..but it was impossible to achieve top driving dynamics starting from a normal 3 series.
totally agree - ALfa QV - real car, bmw m3 - fake car :)
Ok so what you’re saying is that a standard giulia doesn’t exist and that the qv version is a besboke model that doesn’t share anything with the normal car 🤨🤨🤨 COTA YLE XoarXXar? :))
@@nikashushanashvili8100 No Nika, i am not saying this. I mean that the standard Giulia was developed after the Giulia QV, which was developed from scratch by the same engineer who worked on the 458, with the purpose of creating a proper sport car with 4 doors. So the normal Giulia is a scaled down version of the QV, but sharing the same steering, chassis, carbon fiber driveshaft and extensive use of aluminum, which makes the normal car a reference in the category for driving dynamics and weight. That said i believe that the normal BMW 3 series is a better package than the normal Giulia, because in buying a normal saloon the parameters of valuation are different, and a fancy cabin, top class infotainment, laser led lights, virtual dashboard and so on are much more important in this segment.
@@MrGiamma84 bang on! That’s also why the regular Giulia has a carbon prop shaft 👍
Except the regular 3 series has better driving dynamics than the regular giulia and the M3 has always had better handling/ driving dynamics as well as better daily capabilities than the Giulia QV
You can’t even get the Giulia with a manual in the main target market USA, such a shame
100% spot on. Alfa Romeo QF will be a future collectable, it's just THAT good even after 5 years.
Ditch those pirelli corsas on the Alfa and get yourself the Michelin MP4s tyres which are now available in the correct size for the rear. 👍🏼 Much better tyre for UK climate
Are they? Fantastic! I had to go for SuperSports when my Corsas wore out.
@@OldManOnTrak yeah I had those supersports before too. 👍🏼
@@azamchaudhri Goodyear Supersports are utterly fantastic too, i actually find them better than the PS4S in a few places 👍
@@stephenlongfield8492 yeah they are certainly a great tyre by all accounts too. I would have gone down that route if the ps4s wasn't available in the correct size. 👍🏼
I went for the the Goodyear F1SS. Awesome tyres and available in OEM sizes.
James expression while driving the Giulia says it all! There is no build quality or infotainment screen that makes you smile like that
Infotainment. How old are you? 13? Cars are about engines, chassis, suspensions, steering and brakes.
@@alexantonoglou3080 ask to bmw if the inforainment save your ass
@@alexantonoglou3080 εισαι και ελληνας, BMW wins, Αλφα ειναι ασχημη
@@saidalas7763 You must be joking...
@@alexantonoglou3080 you must be a fanboy
I'd take the Alfa, what a stunning car. Despite the fact I love older BMWs and actually own one, I can't stand that 3 series front grille.
So how you can stand the ugly triangular grill? No taste is the answer
@@saidalas7763 🤣🤣🤣
@@Nexus.Achiles it's funny huh?
Why don't you visit the opthalmologist?
@@saidalas7763 TOOL !!! BMW APOLOGISTS UNITE....THE M 3 GRILLE IS HIDEOUS....THE SCUDETTO IS ICONIC !!!
@@saidalas7763 YOU ARE BEING MURDERED TOOL....JUST GO AWAY !!!!!
I bought a late 2017 Alfa Guilia QF from new and was blown away by how good it was. I had it for 2 years, swapped to Winter tyres October-March and had an absolute ball You find after a little while with the car that you can modulate the brakes with no problem. My only gripes were no split fold rear seat and no Apple CarPlay, but the Alfa (TomTom) system was fine - both sorted now. To be honest, I just had a smile on my face every time I drove it. Give one a test drive and if you can find some pennies down the back of a sofa, just go out and get one. It is hard to define, but this car has soul. A 6 star car :D
souls are imaginary bs that religous sheep believe are real.
Alfa Romeo fanboys revealed
I'd take an Alfa over capibara all day long
I agree. I'd take the QV, though with the optional carbon racing seats, carbon ceramic breaks & titanium exhaust to save a bit more weight & get a bit more breaking consistency on the track
This is the perfect comparison I wanted to see. Will be buying an alfa quadrifoglio within the next 2 months :)
Can you give me a lift?
I’ve just bought my Quadrifoglio, you won’t be disappointed. I’d recommend a cheeky remap too as 600bhp is very pleasant 😆👍
@@stephenlongfield8492 congrats!
@@davidpeters6536 I would!
❤️🍀
The is the test I always wanted to see..thank you!
Seeing how the new M just came out for comparisons, I'm sorry you had to wait so long. Lol
The alfa as a engine made by ferrari and thats enough for me (if i had the age /the money to drive it lol)
Ferrari trash made in luxory robe with high price tag...
Except it's not that great of an engine (having driven it). It felt like I had almost no power until about 5k rpm and with redline around 7k you're constantly shifting if you're going through curves, but that's what you get with 30 psi boost, which feels like a ticking time bomb (BMW does 19 psi).
I'm sure the actual Ferrari engine is better, probably wider power band, higher redline, and more power down low before turbo kicks in, but QV engine is not one to drool over
@Catholic Firefighter you are right. I’m not fan of audi either:)
@@leok7193 you keep spouting this utter garbage. I’ve owned both and that it just absolutely not the case.
The Alfa engine is far superior to the f80/2 engine, the whole car is far superior so please stop being a fan bot
@@peterszendrei they are expensive for a reason
And the trio always says they would take the Ferrari over any other supercar so it probably means something
Thanks, guys. I chose my QV over an F80 M3 2 years ago, and I'm really pleased to hear you agree with my decision. I too love my car.
I'm guessing it's love despite all shortcomings, but I am glad you're enjoying it. I've been enjoying F82 for the last year. Put in my order after I saw what was going to happen with the grille on the new one lol
@@leok7193 You mean that you don't love your wife, cause she has shortcomings? Or the BMW doesn't have those?
What about reliability? Some people say that is not good, I don't believe it, what do yo think?
Still in the garage LOL
@@abnerphilipe mine has been super reliable.
Alfa Romeo any day !!!! ♥️♥️♥️
And those plastics are fine !! They clean much better than the other garbage!
Alfa everyday and twice on a Sunday....
no.
After all this time, the M3 still cannot dethrone the mighty Alfa! Job well done to all the engineers at Alfa for creating the ultimate driving machine, still to this day!
Alfa struggled to match the last gen F80 M3 in terms of handling and driving dynamics. The new M3 utterly destroys the Giulia
@@davissilvestrs1996 The Nurburgring proved otherwise which measures handling braking etc. I highly doubt the new M3 will beat 7:32 since it is also heavier than the QV.
@@chasinglimits M4 GTS which is based on the 2011 F30 chassis did 7:27, G80 is way more capable than the 10 year old F series bmws.
@@davissilvestrs1996 That might be true, but I’m comparing sedan to sedan, so a 2017 QV ran 7:32 and a 2018 M3 CS ran a 7:38. I’m sure the new platform M4 should be quicker than the 7:32 though. Have the new M3/M4 been tested at the Nring yet for official times? Either way, all are very fast sedans/coupes.
@@chasinglimits M3 CS lap time was done by Sport Auto magazine while the Giulia lap time was done by Alfa Romeo factory team, not comparable
When you look at other track times (on Fastestlaps) the M3 CS is way quicker, Giulia can be compared to the normal M3 or M3 Competition looking at comparison tests and lap times. Also keep in mind the old gen M3 had a 70hp disadvantage vs the Alfa
Good lord, the Beemer is fugly. Am sure it’s a riot to drive though. But I’d go with the Alfa, in the reddest of reds.
Go get your eyes checked. The M3 looks way better than the tringular grill on wheels
@@saidalas7763 you should get checked. Comparing this BMW against the Alfa is like comparing a Gaultier dress against and Armani
@@fulviovalenziano4579 I don't know about girly things like dresses that are made in Italy, but if two clothes like Armani and another cost the same and the Armani sells 20 times more than the other (which is the case with the 3er that sells 20 more times than the Giulia) then the Armani is better looking
@@saidalas7763 TOOL !!! YOU'RE GETTING SLAUGHTERED IN THE COMMENTS DAWG !!!!
@@saidalas7763 SALES equal TOOLS DRINKING THE GERMAN KOOL AID !!!!
I'm waiting for this showdown, and I'm glad you guys did it.
ALFA for the WIN!!!!💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
Alfa Romeo: lighter, higher top speed and more beautifully designed!
And now wait for the Giulia Quadri MKII with new interiors, revised front and back and digital cokpit, expected for end of the year.Ah and yes...more power😉
It just had the interior facelift. I doubt it will happen that soon. More like 2025.
@Kinky Streets I hope you change that ugly profile pic
One Giulia for me, thank you.
said an Italian. Your opinion doesn't mean much, next.
@@saidalas7763 THE TOOL IS TROLLING ONCE AGAIN !!!!!
@@jamesterakazis6624 the FOOL is back to annoy us once again!!!
Obviously people need to buy the car that makes them smile........ Avanti.....
Awesome review on these cars, I agree the Alfa is still the king!
Alfa romeo is STUNNING 🏆👑💎🇮🇹
it's ugly
Sad to see bmw charging 85/90k for a car that looks like a dyslexic mammoth.
What does a dyslexic anything look like? You can’t tell.
I love its new looks
It is gorgeous
@@hassanger8128 and @VIB33 I'll bet you two loved the nauseating Bangle E60 5 Series and E65 7-Series too. BMW has been making pig-ugly cars for twenty years now, so there must be a lot of customers with bad taste, bad eyesight or both.
Alfa Romeo ❤❤❤
The Alfa is the best saloon on the planet.
Said nobody ever
@@kells77 "said nobody ever" 🤓🤓
Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio best😍
I hope bmw get belted in these reviews
I’d love a fully revised LCI
Weight reduction
New face
And a return to form
I don’t want to know an m3 as a super saloon but rather a sports car
M2 CS.
🤣 you fail to realise the target market doesn't live in the comments section of a video
@@arnoldmbuthia2687 and yet here I am, buying BMWs for the last 15 years, including M3s and a 440. And I fully agree with the OP and will not get another one until Dukec is gone and BMW redesign this POS.
@@arnoldmbuthia2687 No, trolls make decisions @ BMW, how do you think they came up with M in the 1st place & have been expanding for 60 years? M3 now same size as perfect classic E39 M5, but with 100+ hp "too heavy". These repeat owner whingers don't realize they've aged themselves out of M market, maybe they can enjoy nice small-grilled M340i. Or retire to their walkers & keyboards.
Yet, it will break another record in sales numbers
Thank you for another great review Matt.
Great video! My choice is the Alfa too ❤️
Alfa is a thing of a beauty compared cu bmw and a much more character automobil.
Now go wear your glasses
Aaah the same Alfa in the Piston Heads vid. What a work horse
BMW M3 IS THE NEW FIAT MULTIPLA
Multipla had an intelligent although not very pretty design. This BMW is simply asinine.
@@BojanBojovic besides the front the overall design of the car is good, the Multipla just looks bland and ugly (just like every minivan)
@@harriz17 As I said, Multipla has a good reason for that design while this ugly BMW is simply asinine without reason.
@@BojanBojovic oh I get what you mean now, yes that's true, don't why they just didn't stick with the normal 3 series grill
@@harriz17 BMW scored few times when it comes to design, for me personally it was 1974 CSL, E46, and maybe F80, but the last one is very young so we will see how good it will look in a decade or two. This M3/4 design is not very nice even without this grill. But the grill is simply unacceptable. Having Alfa next to this car is really a joke.
I just fast forwarded to Alfa review and closed the video before the final take between BMW and Alfa. Heart and mind, both goes for Alfa.
1. Who else skipped the M3 and fast forward to 8:07 to see the Alfa Romeo?
2. In case you didn't know, that diffuser on the M3 is fake.... same goes to the pumping engine-sound-in-the-cabin!
3. I've said this before: AR Q all day long 365 days!!!!!
The AR has soul! where the M3 is like a naked kid running all scared and stressed out looking for a hideout!!
thats the most fanboy thing u could have written, cringe
Nah
@@Fearzzy Fanboy!?!?! You high??? I just said that the AR has soul, something all car lovers happen to agree with!
@@mikealanzo "M3 is like a naked kid running all scared and stressed out looking for a hideout!!" giga fanboy, implying the m3 dont have soul like yeah, it dont get much more fanboy^ shut ur mouth if u don't got actuall meaningful comments xD
@@Fearzzy oh no!!!! A keyboard warrior!!!! What is I gonna do now?!?!??!
The BMW looks like it has already had a front end crash.
The Giulia looks exactly the same as the standard Giulia, hate it or love it the BMW certainly gets the more looks
Broooo...that M3 looks so much better than the Alfa let’s be honest
I’m getting used to those buck tooth grills.. I think in person the BMW will look sick!!
I looks like a decoupled train carriage
@@minimead368 It looks very Star Wars. Like the front was cut off with a light sabre.
Why are we "glossing over the nose" of the BMW ? Why not address the ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM ? That freaking thing is HIDEOUS !!!
FORZA ALFA BABY !!!!
THE KING IS BACK !!!!!
Nice video guys. Keep them coming !
Great vid Autocar
These 2 have their days numbered so no matter which one you prefer, can we just agree that they are some of the best relatively attainable cars on sale today? So maybe instead of arguing, as petrol-heads, we should appreciate and buy them while we still can...
9:12 that rear tire was saying help meeeee
After 5 years, the Alfa is still the sportiest. The sound of the m3 no :(
Good stuff. For my money it would be the Alfa every time.
That's why you don't have this kind of money. The people who do (most likely smart people), will buy the M3. We all know the M3 will be a sales success.
Sorry.
Tell that to O A ....THE TOOL !!!!
@@jamesterakazis6624 tell that to James Terakazis.. the FOOL!!
Love my Giulia (even though it's only the Veloce) feels light and balanced, but I know the Bmw will be better built and hold it's money
Don't be so sure about the BMW being better built! Total pain in the arse after 50K miles. Total. I've had three over the years, one recent, and - never again.
Have 2 BMWs (one is a classic mint E30 320i) and a MINI as daily driver, so I'm obviously devoted to the brand. But woud buy the Giulia in a heartbeat.
the voice of honesty and reason...the BMW is slower, heavier and FUGLY !!!
@@jamesterakazis6624 it's faster, better looking, and won't break down every mile
Just putting the BMW with this grill next to the QV is a murder by itself .... Alfa anyway !
GRILLE DAWG ....
@@jamesterakazis6624 the Alfa is ugly.
Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio
Prettier, faster and better 😉👍👍
@@jrgensenbo2999 said no one with half a brain or more
Only one car here is a masterpiece. The other is just a beemer.
Very silly silly comment
@@DaleSteel thx
Great review, the Alfa is my choice too. Besides, that M3 is seriously odd looking if not ugly.
haahahahah, the M3 looks way better
@@saidalas7763 STFU ...YOU'RE GETTING DESTROYED TOOL
@@jamesterakazis6624 no you fanboy
@@saidalas7763 😍🤣🤣🤣 sorry man ,the quadrigfolio is way prettier, buck tooth ratbeaver hybrid grills don't look good,if they had left normal kidney grilles on it, it would have given the alfa a run for its money looks wise, but sorry not this monstrosity, worst looking m car ever!
@@conoconnor4375 eww the alfa is so fugly. gimme that mean m3 with carbon fiber roof and snarling nostrils. u take the expired marshmallow.
Alfa Romeo is king well done Alfa Romeo
BMW is king
I love my 2019 QV, it’s faster than my California and NA2 NSX.
Winner is Alfa Romeo Giulia 🇮🇹 🏆👑💎🚘
really like the new M3, but I think it now makes most sense as a xDrive version in a space the M5 once was in. A fun, very fast and competent daily. But it leaves plenty of room for the M2. I hope it stays considerably cheaper, lighter and more of an enthusiasts sports car.
Dude...HELGA IS GETTING BIGGER AND FATTER !!!
Alfa all day💪🍀🇮🇹
Brilliant review. 2 top men. Alfa all day for me also. And I am a 3 time m3 owner
why would you want the uglier car?
@@saidalas7763 anybody blessed with the gift of sight will agree the new M3 is possible the ugliest m car ever made.
@@johncreedon1833 and that's confirmed from the sales?
You are just a fanboy.
Get your eyes checked
@@saidalas7763 a fan boy ? I have been driving M3's for the last 9 years. Still have one. And your calling me an Alfa fan boy 🤔🤣🤣🤣
@@johncreedon1833 get your eyes checked.
Seriously, there's no way a person with functioning eyes sees tha Alfa as the better looking car, unless he's a fanboy.
Ask your non car people firends, your gf or faimly members who they think is the better looking car.
101% sure they'll say the BMW, which is nothing more but reflecting the sales numbers
☘️☘️☘️ I've had mine for 6 months. An amazing machine. I didn't buy it for the infotainment. I bought it for the engine, chassis, exhaust, and SOUL. 🇮🇹
Alfa Romeo all day and all night baby.
Been waiting for this match-up, let me proceed to watch......
Giulia is King for me ......and it has the Bonus of not looking like Hitlers moustach
No, just bad rhinoplasty.
So what is the M3s Ring time ? Surely it must be better than Alfas, since you say its the better track car...
Love the Alfa - BMW have completely lost the plot and M3 occupies the same space that the M5 did - bloated luxo barge. Being back the tidy lightweight M3 saloon!!
Lost the plot, sounds funny from you boy, and no not the same space go check yourself before talking nonsense.
Get an m2 then. This is miles faster than that and all your old m3s.
*bring
Yes I agree
@@jaruslavnguyen4777 everybody does see through your soft ass🤣🤣
It is nice to see That most of the comments are in favor of the alfa, but still no one is buying it. Don't get me wrong I'm an alfa fan, expecially the onld ones, but I'm just noticing that everyone loves the Giulia but very few buy it, and it is sad because if sells don't go the right way this would probably be the last alfa sedan. Then alfa will reduce to sell boring suv.
Alfa all day every day, no comparison
If Alfa Romeo pulls out of the American Market it will be a national tragedy
beauty is in the eye of the beholder!!!
The driver.
Bmw m3 for boys, Alfa Romeo for man
Alfa Romeo for baby* .
Do M4 Competition or M5 Cs against the Giulia 😉. Always BMW🚀
@@emanuelemasella5312 bruh put them shits against the Maserati trofeo HAHAHAHHA the Maserati wins
@@emanuelemasella5312 always Maserati. bmws are for babies GARBAGE AND FULL OF POVERTY THE INTERIOR IS TRASH and has fake ass claims on the internet EMBARRASSING HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
@@mdegaming1706 the Audi Rs7 is more performance than the Trofeo. Then the sporty style, Maserati dreams of
@@mdegaming1706 bro calm down, however they are tastes eh
BMW confirmed a M3 wagon and that in itself is a big win.
These stoopid Alfa fanboys are not petrolheads, they can't even appreciate the manual of the BMW
All they want is ugly triangular grills.
But don't worry, actual buyers (people who are smart to have that kind of money, not lazy weirdos on YT comments bashing BMW) will prefer the M3 which will be evident from the sales numbers
Love every Alfa
Did anyone really have any question which car they were gonna pick? The Alfa is one of the GOATs of the sedan world.
the goat that no one buys
I traded my m2 in for one two years ago and it was the best decision I’ve ever made
@@Tatamo1989 because it's ugly
GOATs?
haha little kid, it looks 2/10
As the owner of an Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio I have been petitioning BMW to change the rodent teeth on the front of the new
M 3 / M 4 as they are always in my rear view mirror and they are making me nauseous while driving.....they told me they are working on it...
Alfa has better styling, soul plus a Ferrari derived engine so... a Giulia for me!
🤣. They look pretty similar. The m3 is faster, better quality, and will work
@@arnoldmbuthia2687 Alfas work pretty damn good as well. Been an owner for 4 years and they seem to work more so than BMWs ;)
@@arnoldmbuthia2687 lol, you are really trying to tell us that BMW is a reliable car brand? Give me a break!
@G MG you mean, German engine sounds over the speakers instead of Ferrari sounds out of the exhaust?
@G MG Lol, you just absolutely don't know anything about cars. That's a Ferrari V6 in the Giulia.
Super-duper video 👍
What would be REALLY good is a comparison review between the new M3 and an Alpina B3...
Alfa QV still the best sport sedan even bmw has a new M3 model
Aged >= 40 loves Giulia Quadrifoglio style
Aged < 40 loves M3 style
not really i own ah qv and i love it my age is 25
The problem is that m2 is already heavy car... Maybe you can't feel it but even on these shots the car looks very heavy. Over 1700kg in m3... Wgere are we going?!!! Alfa all the way
Then try M5 F90 with almost 2000kg...
@@ma3kc i was an owner of F10 M5 and weight was killing this car. The point is on the one hand we are going with downsizing yet we are adding tons and we put extreme loads on the engine.
M3 weighs 1705 kg, Alfa weighs 1695 kg. So that’s a difference of 10 kg
The thing is they are comparing a 5 year old car to one that has finally caught up with them
BMW had Alfa in its sights when it revised the Bimmer
BUT FAILED MISERABLY !!!
Easy choice for me: the Alfa 🍀
you can't afford a fiat anyway + your taste is bad
@@saidalas7763 You know nothing about what I can or cannot afford. Please abstain yourself from talking about what you don’t now, because I own more than one Alfa Romeo!! I am not a teenager like you, young lad. If you prefer the BMW, it’s your choice. I would never write that you have bad taste. I also own BMW’s. This shows how childish you are.
@@ruisantos8291 I am not a teen. Just a young adult with good taste in cars, unlike you
@@saidalas7763 Jesus. I’m not wasting my time with you. Have a good life. Pfff...
@@ruisantos8291 ok -religious sheep- kid
BMW playing catchup even after so many years. They even tried to copy the look of Alpha with the lights and grille.
The answer to any multi-choice question where one option is Alfa Romeo, is always Alfa Romeo.
I don't like the fact that BMW made the M3's body wider, but kept the rear doors untouched. The wide body behind the rear doors looks incredibly forced, and I am sorry that the accountants won and the designers lost. Don't buy this car, it was created by penny pinchers.
Bmws break like no one’s Business, lost faith in them ages ago.had 4 used ones and never had a great experience really.they are fun cars but they cost to
Much to fix and they deprecate to much.then again I’m not a rich man, so I shouldn’t be driving one anyway.
Great video!
The only thing that annoys me is that you used the standard Giulia in the interior B-roll.
The other thing are different size rims. It's purely estetic, and it makes the car look stupid imo. Porsche and Merc does it too and I personally hate it.
Still stay Alfa Romeo for life
What about the new "face" of bmw?
Does exist in English a word like "un-lookble"?
Alfa 🍀 Over the Top for me
you have terrible taste
A nice comparison - I liked it. But we look at your channel worldwide. So can you please work out how to speak more clearly? The middle calm bit was fine but even I had to replay some bits, especially your conclusions at the end (and I'm a Brit - admittedly ex-pat for many years ;o) ).
I thank you BMW for improving the depreciation on my F80 M3 zCP. I chose my M3 zCP over the Alfa 4 years ago this month! I liked both cars but honestly thought the M3 is one of the best looking sedans on the road. Luckily I have no buyer's remorse after seeing the G80. To each their own. I love cars and have no problem with people choosing one brand over another. If you can afford any of the cars in this class you'll have fun!
Your m3 is still a mass produced car that will depreciate like a tank
Typically SMUG BMW elitist attitude you have.....
I got a GQ recently and although I’ve owned many cars and bikes, it is by far the most complete package of them all. Beauty, power but like James Bond it can put on dress clothes for the casino. It is basically a Ferrari sedan. Instant classic. I would recommend buying one before it’s too late.
Alfa 👌
These track comparisons are really pointless when the cars are equipped with different tires...even you say that alfas corsas suck in the wet/cold, but by the end you totally forget that and declare the m3 a better track car...with no lap time whatso ever taken into account. Btw, what is the M3s Ring time ? Surely it must be better than Alfas, since you say its the better track car...
Alfa has hard plastic ? BMW doesn’t ? I had the chance to check other bmw ‘s and all had hard plastic in the lower part of the doors .,....
Infotainment is more intuitive ? I’d like to see how. The real challenge to develop a sport car is engine, chassis, steering and brakes. And Alfa does it at the best .
Please stop talking. Alfa is hard plastic, point......
@@pasma1983 come on show me where it is....I'll show you where is all the crap on BMW