How is China's Belt and Road initiative transforming Mongolia? | The New Silk Road | Full Episode
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 окт 2019
- The China-Mongolia-Russia economic corridor is one of six key corridors on the Belt and Road initiative. Travel to Mongolia to discover spectacular new infrastructure projects.
EP 1: Where China meets Russia • Where China meets Russ...
EP 3: China's New Silk Road in Uzbekistan • How will China's Belt ...
EP 4: Growing alliance between China and Russia • Russia and China’s Spe...
The New Silk Road playlist here: • China's New Silk Road
For more on our long-form documentaries, head to CNA Insider: / cnainsider
=============
China, Mongolia, Uzbekistan and Russia were once strong allies in the Cold War. Now, rapid transformation is happening in these countries, some of whom are still struggling to emerge from their communist past.
How will the Belt and Road Initiative impact Mongolia and integrate it into China’s masterplan for the 21st century? How will the Stan countries go from land-locked to land-linked countries? What is the nature of the new strategic partnership between Russia and China?
CNA's award-winning documentary series returns, uncovering developments on China's Belt and Road Initiative, along the China-Russia economic corridor.
=============
#CNA #CNADocumentaries #NewSilkRoad #China #Russia #Mongolia
Subscribe to our channel here: cna.asia/youtubesub
Subscribe to our news service on Telegram: t.me/cnalatest
Follow us:
CNA: cna.asia
CNA Lifestyle: www.cnalifestyle.com
Facebook: / channelnewsasia
Instagram: / channelnewsasia
Twitter: / channelnewsasia
This is real documentary, not propaganda by the US & Europe that paints anything Chinese as bad.
These people are extremely sceptical of China. Are you blind
@@stevenobinator2229 its sarcasm
lol
@@stevenobinator2229 Being skeptical equals being propaganda?
@@stevenobinator2229 Compare to what most western corporate media say about China and BRI, even relatively neutral reports like that are considered overwhelmingly positive. Image the negative campaign against China by western corporate media. China is not ruled by big corporations, for corporation media that is being despicably evil.
@@joseph_wei Quote: "China is not ruled by big corporations, for corporation media that is being despicably evil." True, in China corporations are ruled by the CCP, which in and of itself is despicably evil.
@Rainhard Quote: "Europe should embrace the developement of Asia. In fact Italy joint the Belt Road project 9 months ago."
And look where it got Italy now. High number of Coronavirus cases. The same goes for Spain, which also has close ties to China. Bavaria also.
China withheld important information for over 6 weeks or so. Europe should not trust China. Infact it should distance herself from China.
BTW I am Chinese and I live in Europe.
Long Live the One Belt One Road initiatives & Cooperation. May all participating countries and her people prosper ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Fun facts:
1. There are more ethnic mongols in Inner Mongolia than Outer Mongolia
2. Inner Mongolia's GDP per capita is 3 times higher than that of Outer Mongolia.
inner mongolia: 6 millions, outer mongolia: 2.3 million
@@philippok18 When he talk about inner mongolia it is include Mongolians and non Mongolians.
Michael Mai than he should say 25 million. It’s a total population of this province
I think the problem for Mongolia economy is on man management. in Inner side they have more advance and educated so they can provide better man management that in not significantly will improve economy. Times now for Mongolia and China gov make an agreement of scholarship for Mongolian to study in China.
@@philippok18 stop ur bs, inner mongolia of china has 6 million mongols, outer mongolia only has 2.3 millions,, 6 millions are all mongols, it is different number for total population in inner mongolia which is 250 millions, while outer mongolia, 2.3 million is total population including some kazak people,
this young man tells an amazing story of the hardships people face in Mongolia. Life over there is a incredible journey of endangerment where only the fittest can survive. Yet, the do it day in and day out.
Quite neutral report, not like the west media only report one side story.
Infoworld most of the films are pro - China
@@powercomm if someone is helping build shit in your country in exchange for money or oil or minerals or gold... or just alliance........ what would you call that? debt trap? invasion?
in the white world, you call that.
in other worlds, they call it common sense alliance and business exchanges.
in the white people's world, you call that WHEN YOU DO THAT, you say it's helping allies.
@@swishywishy3490 Those country don't even have "shit" lol
The older videos on BRI from a couple years ago are anti-China. Maybe becoz now Singapore officially support BRI.
@@pomodoro385 Because the Chinese let the Singaporean to build cities in China that why this video has little positive about China. However the reporter said that the mining field was nationalized from the Chinese, he is wrong, the Mongolian nationalized their mining field from the Aussie and the British mining companies, like Rio Tinto and BHP Group.
Went to Mongolia this year, from what I heard from the more educated locals, on one hand their gov brows money from n working with China, on the other hand, keeps feeding anti- China sentiment amongst ordinary ppl n told them that their problems r caused by the Chinese. Talking about two-faced! My general impression of Mongolia is a nation still very much hold onto their Genghis Khan area glory.
most interestingly is that more ethnic Mongols live in China than live in the country of Mongolia
@@Amidat pretty sure this is incorrect
@v x Yes and the descendants of Genghis Khan made Beijing the capital of China...
@@blee04524 well you are wrong... so you aren't sure
@@Amidat nah. at this point theyre no longer mongols. just like americans are no longer british.
I been following CNA's BRI series for awhile. Its very informative and I really enjoy it. Most countries involved expressed their optimism and are on the up and up. Mongolia's vast barren landscape, education system and extreme temperatures will be its biggest challenge.
Ok, I don't get it. This so called debt trap. This docu from what I could infer, China didn't force Mongolia to borrow billions from them. it was Mongolia's govt decision. You borrow that much, of course your interest would be just as much. Banks don't lend as some gd samaritans, so do countries. Mongolia could have approached western led organisation like the World bank or even Russia, Why not? And since western countries are so concerned, why not show some action, lend the same to these so called "debt tap" countries instead of just criticising. Criticism without some remedya ction is like empty vessels making the most noise to me.
you'd imagine if the interest rate were so high then many other countries would be lining up to undercut the rate given to Mongolia and still make good returns...🙊 Someone crooked at the top is getting kickbacks
@@ldsiverling except the interest rates are extremely low considering the credit ratings of the countries they are lent to. Some are 2-3% for countries with a BBB- rating. The reason now one else is lending to them is actually because you can't beat the Chinese offer and there is nothing to undercut.
The west dont lend , they civilised and just took the resources as per history.
When you lend money to someone who you know can’t pay you back, you are a PREDATOR.
@@SuperTonyony should just invade them and take their resources instead, so civilised.
Your Silkroad series is Awesome. Singapore's Journalism standard is very high.
Go Mongolia! Your country is beautiful and I love You! Greetings from PORTUGAL
come on seriously if Mongolia "don't need" china they can just do it on their own and survive can they? you need the money but you blame the chinese kinda ridiculous to me
By beating up foreignor constrction workers. Probably leaving in a ger is good for them.
It's frightening to live on the doorstep of a superpower. You want to be strong and independent, but you know that if push came to shove, it's all over. It's also hard to embrace a technological industrial future when you're defined by a glorious pastoral legacy and so many of your people are still connected to that life. Mongolia has a challenging path ahead of itself no matter which way it walks.
Since they r friendly with the Russians, what better enemy u can find than China?
They like money but don't like debt. Everybody pays interests for the bank loans, does that mean everyone is debt-trapped by banks? ridiculous
Chinese and Russian policy in Mongolia is blackmail and extortion aka threats of tariffs and extra red tape. If you think these loans are taken without duress I have a bridge to sell you.
What the world needs to do is all countries should be working together to make it a one world to help out each other
@gerald Powell that’s exactly the idea behind China’s BRI a global network of trade, commerce, business, industry, resources. Free of external military and government intervention, coups, threats, sanctions, wars.
This is what BRICS is working on. It’s the US doing everything to try and stop it including using wars to create fractures and division
I'm a Chinese and I live Mongolian people and culture. greeting to our great neighbor
the silk road will give benefit to the nation as a whole.
The ecological spirit of Mongolians is admirable and commendable, it is strikingly powerfully charged just as is Xi Jinping's thought on a green ecological society where nature is a supremely invaluable asset.
If Mongolia and China unite their ecological will, there's no telling what lush nature and ecological benefits could be gained. China's efforts to control the desert have been successful and they are willing to share their experiences with Mongolia as I believe they have.
Mining is a dirty business but China's commitment to nature is self evident and soon the Artificial intelligence, ecological solutions and 5G development, etc will solve many of the downsides of mining in Mongolia as they have in China.
Long live the friendship between the Great Nations of 🇲🇳Mongolia, 🇨🇳China and 🇷🇺Russia!
❤🇨🇳 China🇨🇳❤🇲🇳Mongolia🇲🇳❤🇷🇺Russia 🇷🇺❤
The mining is vital to both economies. Don't be fooled, Mongolia would absolutely collapse without the mining. They would be forced to take on ever increasing debts, or see their citizens die from starvation.
@@nosignal7156 Mongolia got 60 millions of livestock and other millions died from Climate change. Mongolia still got animals for foods. Mining won't dry not that easy. If it does that the economy will have a problems. Mongolia is still got cashmere to sell.
Just a few tips correct the mistake in this Documentaries. First, the Yuan dynasty is between 1271 to 1368, not in the 11th century. Another is, the silk road starts from the Han dynasty, not the yuan dynasty.
Ze David wenn a Reporter without history educated
Ya, silk road startwd in Han dynasty and trade with the Rome empire. Kublai Khan conquered the whole China but didn't last for over 100 years.
The Mongols in Republic of Mongolia is pathetic to whine all the time, and they are not civilized in history, and the silk road has nothing to do with them.
@@boonseow8338 It's easy to understand. They do have abilities to destroy, yet they do not have abilities to construct.
@@guo7043 Let's give people a little time to adjust!
I thought Mongolians had their own script, like in China where Inner Mongolians write Mongolian in a top-down traditional script, you can see it along the characters of the Lingua Franca of China, Mandarin.
In Inner Mongolia Genghis Khan is a big deal also, there's a festival honouring a symbolic mausoleum. This province is the legacy still remaining of the Yuan Dynasty where their accession to China came after conquering China, today they live in peace along eachother.
❤🇨🇳 China🇨🇳❤🇲🇳Mongolia🇲🇳❤🇷🇺Russia 🇷🇺❤
Yes, Mongolians have their own script, written top-down in each line, and the lines go from the left to the right in the text.
They lost their own script during the Soviet reign, and never went back to pick it up, while the funny thing is that the Mongolian Chinese residing in the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region in the PRC can still write and are encouraged to preserve the Mongolian script, so people often can see the Mongolian script in hanging scrolls and plaques in their houses inside the PRC.
@@resnica3557 because outer moangolia, most of so called mongols are not real mongols, they are kahhalla mongols, their ancestors were tugus tribes who were captive of mongol army, they were called " old slaves" , technically they are not mongols, they just joined mongols as POW, and later adopted mongol culture , and yes, only mongols using mongol script are all in china, there are 5.9 million mongols there, while outer mongolia only has 2.5 millions
@@xinyiquan666 I'm sorry, I'm rather not that well acquainted with the history, I do know the Song Dynasty went south where artistic depictions of nature reached an unparalleled hight of technique, beauty and delicacy.
I have as well heard there are more ethnic Mongols in the PRC rather than in Mongolia.
❤🇲🇳 Mongolia🇲🇳❤🇨🇳China🇨🇳❤ 🇷🇺Russia🇷🇺❤
Res Nica
Encouraged?!? 5 yuan transferred to your account, good post. I am sure your credit score has gone up, you pinko red freak.
@@xinyiquan666 inner mongols are not mongols. theyre chinese pretending to be mongols. like americans who pretends to be british.
Just want to mention
Yuan dynasty only last 89 years in China
And China resisted the Mongolians much longer than the Europe did.
@Hello World then get off youtube a byproduct of civilisation
I can watch your documentary a million times and won't get tired. Simply incredible
Thank you for your support! Have you checked out the New Silk Road playlist? ruclips.net/p/PLbnMTcZEga8RRyTMl4pIAXjQNqsV1xVPM
@@channelnewsasia was looking for this
to many ads
Very interesting point to blame China and bri for their environmental damage. But it's largely the failure of their environmental policy.
In fact their environment was worsening well before the bri existed, it's not just mining but also overgrazing. This theory can be backed up by publicly available satellite images, while the Inner Mongolia has similar climate to them, it looks greener. More than ten years ago, there were already reports of starving wolves crossed the border to China just to find food.
Also many sandstorm in northern China (and north east Asia in general) are originated in Outer Mongolia. In this sense, China has incentives to improve outermongol environment.
In the video, the crews drove hours away from the mines on the grassland with no roads to met the herdswoman. She claimed she (and her family, maybe a small family) owns over 1,000 sheep and goats. The animals were eating on the grassland with no grass. This might be an evidence of unsustainable overgrazing.
Talking about their anti china sentiment. Hatred is just a human design flaw. It's in fact the soviet who suppressed them in the early 20th century. But it turned out they fell in love with soviet. Looked at their language, it's completely "romanized", while the actual mongol is better preserved in china.
Your comment is very neutral and rings completely true, I thank you for your putting into words this valuable information.
China is very demonised around the world, an extremely unwarranted depiction. And it's such a sorrowful shame, since the Chinese have such enormously good will and have shown themselves very efficient in development with many different programs that could help the very people that would like to put down China.
Long live the friendship between the Great Nations of 🇲🇳Mongolia, 🇨🇳China and 🇷🇺Russia!
❤🇲🇳Mongolia🇲🇳❤🇨🇳China🇨🇳❤🇷🇺 Russia🇷🇺❤
Another point on overgrazing, the video said those herders didn't engage in the economy and were self sufficient, how many thousands of heads of cattle could you need for a self sufficient family? Seems very needlessly detrimental to the environment, reminds me of the now gone Rapanui in Easter Island.
Marcus-Aerilius Maximus yes yes yes everyone must be ccp troll while he is talking in logic and show evidence to support what he said. However at same time what you can said is repeat and repeat again MUST BE CCP TROLL. Plz don’t reply cause I must be some kind of CCP bot, lol
Yao Zheng this is very bias comment. Remember this land is in a different climate so it’s ecosystem is different.
You said their is no grass, but if there is no grass how did they manage to feed 1.5k cattle’s and those cattle look healthy.the wolves probably died because the normad took all there desired food not because of shortage of grass.
Your video/ documentary is informative and helpful. Your questions are unbiased and relevant.
I appreciate the research you do before taking on this project and all of your other projects.
Calm in your approach.
MUCH appreciated and Thank You.
❤🇨🇳 China🇨🇳❤🇲🇳Mongolia🇲🇳❤🇷🇺Russia 🇷🇺❤
How do you do it? Some of the best reporting. Great job bringing to us more information about Mongolia and its culture than I have learned in 40 years.
If you grew up on Western media it is amazingly interesting when you watch content from around the world. They are much more nuanced with layers of culture, history, and lessons. As opposed to Western media where everything is good or bad, no room for anything else.
Thank you for this unbiased documentary.
God Bless Mongolia 🇲🇳👍👍
God will not bless the Nazis and barbarians
Good for China and Mongolia cooperation... 👍👍
At the time of Genghis Khan, China had split into 3 separate Kingdoms for about 300 years. Genghis Khan united 2 of the Kingdoms, and made Beijing the Capital. The rest of China was united by his grandson, Kubla Khan, who built a precursor of the Forbidden City, and re-opened the Silk Road Trade with Europe. The Mongols had also conquered Russia, where they remained for about 350 years.
The Russian Prince Trubetskoy wrote in the 1920's:
"Our task is to create a completely new culture, our own culture, which will not resemble European civilization ... when Russia ceases to be a distorted reflection of European civilization ... when she becomes once again herself -- Russia-Eurasia -- the conscious heir to and bearer of the great legacy of Genghis Khan".
As a Han Chinese I admit that Mongolians had many contributions for China in history, for example Tibet and Xinjiang first firmly controlled by central government was by Mongolians efforts
@@jackytang3683
Now,
FREE TIBET
FREE SOUTH MONGOLIA .
Inner Mongolia belongs to Mongolia . China is occupying inner Mongolia .
@@MM-br3gt the whole world belongs to Mongolia during Great Khan's time 🤣🤣🤣
Tibetans, Taiwanese, Uyghurs, Manchus and Mongolians are all mandated by heaven to be Chinese. Nobody can go against the will of heaven! Mongolia shall one day be reunited with their motherland China! It is the wish of 1.4 billion people
eh, as a Chinese, I'd prefer Mongolia to stay independent, less burden on China, while at the same time China will forever be the only viable trading partner.
mongolia can also be a buffer between Russia and China. relations are good at the moment, but you never know, having a neutral country in between is a good thing.
tibetan are chinese by blood, they are sino -tibetan people from same ancestors, there is no taiwanese in world they are all ethnic chinese from mainland china, taiwanese refer to people from a place like new yorker, not a ethnic word, manchus are also han chinese, 80% of manchus 8 banner system were made up with han chinese , while today, so called manchus are fake ethnic group in china, they are all han chinese , the real so called 20% manchus all dies off and merge into han chinese,
@@obsidianstatue 不能同意更多。
You’re still using marijuana?
we may be weak but we will never accept it
Such an informative presentation. Kudos to you - looking forward to more informative videos.
Wow! The band " The Hu" is amazing I will download all their songs they are awesome! Greetings from PORTUGAL
There's something slippery about the discussion of how Mongolia was partitioned, the Soviet Union is mentioned at 5:00 here, long before it existed! If Imperial Russia and then the Whites (anti Communist Russian forces) supported Mongolia that's a different story! At that time it was Imperial China, too! SO it was just one empire against another!
In order to get the Soviets to fight Japan - the west promised them they could get Outer Mongolia from China. The Nationalist Chinese balked but couldn't do anything. When the communists got into power they agreed to give up Outer Mongolia and then later Outer Manchuria. That's why if you read the constitution originally of the Republic of China in Taiwan - they still claimed those parts as part of China and didn't recognize the communists giving up those areas.
The Great Wall was built to protect against North Asian nations, of which the Mongols were one group of many. The first Great Wall protected against the Xiongnu; the last Great Wall protected against the Jurchens/Manchus. It's also a pretty enlightening piece of symbolism. Though the wall was built to keep the North Asian nations out, most of the North Asian people found their way into China and were eventually sinicized.
其实最后一道长城是为了抵抗蒙古人，因为最后一次大规模修建长城是明朝，为了对抗北元，瓦剌和鞑靼，而对抗女真的是山海关附近的关锦防线，另外长城的作用不是为了挡住游牧民族，长城是一种军事哨所，每个节点驻扎少量军队，而城墙起到了高速公路的作用，另外就是，长城在早期并不是防御性质的，而是军队出击草原的前进基地。
Great video. Very uplifting!
I like that stories from both side is told. Bravo
Really enjoyed your interview, photography and the easy flow and balanced way that all the interactions followed.
I Learned about aspects of modern Mongolian society and the dilemma facing its people. I’m very impressed by their leaders ability to collaborate successfully with the Chinese people despite the challenges and different interests amongst Mongolians.
♦️♦️♦️
I always imagine that the Chinese government can now be friendly to Mongolia, but I bet they don't take their eyes off them either! They had to take nomads seriously for generations, I somehow think they didn't entirely forget.
All positive steps, exploring opportunities .
This is informative reporting. Western reporting tends to just emphasize on the existence of objectors and corruption, as if that justifies a negative view of China.
Beautiful landscape 👍👍👍
Hard life for the coal drivers- admire them for putting up with harsh conditions
Can't be made.more interesting, purely fascinating
حفظهم الله و بارك فيهم و حقق كل أمنياتهم في الخير و فرج الله على أخواننا في بورما و الأيغور و كل البلدان المسلمة
Excellent documentary!
China being a great country, it should help the surrounding countries from extreme poverty by peace and cooperation economically.
A VERY GOOD DOCUMENTARY FILM
Nice documentary. I watched all from the start, episode 1. One thing I am struggling you to have in your future docus: please flash on screen unfamiliar and local terms (i.e. local names and places). Hope this helps.
The reason why some Mongolians hate China is obvious. For example, China donated buildings for free. However, the Chinese government does not publicize, the Mongolian government does not publicize, and even the posters of “China donations” are not posted on the periphery of the building. Then the Mongolian people took it for granted that it was the money from the Mongolian government to invite Chinese workers to build buildings. Originally, the Mongols did not like China very much, but for the Chinese, it was nothing.
Without the warmongers, the world would be a much better place for ordinary people. Nationality and borders created by the rich and powerful people who want to control their people and the week neighbors. It is all dramatic. One world government without the border is coming, so people can share the wealth without war that benefits the rich nations.
As an Inner Mongolian, I hope Mongolia can rejoin with China and as rich as us.
Where is our brothers ? Where is bravely Uyghurs ? Where is warlike Innmongols ? Where is cruel Manchurians ? Where is our brothers ? What happened to them ? hiding and slow genocide ? Where is these ancient warlike nations ?
If Innermongolians and Manchurians were in china they would kill every han chinese. InnerMongolians and Manchurians did not have much more coward than little hong kong people. Innermongolia and Manchurians were respectful nations. Why chinese don't do genocide in hong kong ? Why ? Have you ever heard Tibet, Xinjiang ? What is beijing waiting for ? Why don't kill hong kongs ? china never mercy to another nations. But why do not the chinese do what they do in Tibet and Xinjiang ?
God bless Mongolia from hazara Mongol in Afghanistan any country who harms my forefathers land we will destroyed them. Long live Mongolia.
Should have use HU's metal music as background cover.
Just subscribed what a great channel
At 19:30 you can clearly see wind turbines in the background it may be the worlds largest coal mine but they are not monsters.
If you want to be developed/rich you need to obtain loan for financing the capital. Chinese new silk roads bring "the idea of one world".
Nice documentary
This is all very interesting and exciting, but I definitely have questions. My main concern is focused on the truck drivers from the mine. What happens to them when the railroad finally reaches the mine? Do they no longer have to work, or don't have to work as much, because now the mine is more profitable and the profits will be used to elevate the lives of workers? Are there plans to use the truck drivers elsewhere on other development projects? Or...is this going to be a disaster for a large group of workers that are soon to be jobless and without support even though there's more wealth than ever being created (I'm American, and this is definitely what would happen in the US)?
It would be better for the truck drivers to be trained in other jobs where they could work in safer environment. Life is a learning journey where everyone has to learn to change and adapt.
@@jennylee1802 Of course, but is there explicit policy to bring a positive outcome from this disruption? I'm not asking out of hostility. I'm just interested in working class lives and really all I know about BRI is from this series.
@@aaronlund2110 you are a kind person, but let these people work on their next phase of their lives. It could be for the better . Have you read the book, 'Who move my cheese?' 🌈
They need land bridge to allow wildlife crossing.
A balanced view. Thank you.
الله يحقق أمنية كل إنسان في قلبه خير و يحب الخير للناس
Everyone will benefit from this project.
Good presentations
Like the last scene so much 😃
礦工待遇不錯，乍一看以為是歐美
修公路妨礙放牧，神奇的理論
修公路会找地理环境好的地方，而这些地方恰恰也是人会居住的地方。
大量重型卡车来来往往，会带来空气污染；要是粉尘多的话，还会改变局部环境。
@@changshingeng 卡车效率太低了，大型的矿就用铁轨运输了
The take away I've gotten from this series is that central Asia is damn that they do and damn that they don't
things I don't understand, why is Tenmujin such a celebrated character, but Adolf Hitler isn't.
I asked exactly the same question during high school days, and of course, no teachers ever ventured to offer any response, let alone answers. After some years, I thought of this one of the possibilities, which is most likely to be the reason, that Tenmujin slaughtered much more people (including many instances of genocides of entire tribes, entire states, and so on. One typical example of genocide of the entire city state took place where modern day Uzbekistan is) and trashed and/or scorched much more cities, farm lands and fields, and states, and occupied the territories long enough than Adolf Hitler had ever been able to.
Because people now don't have clear image of the far past.
Oh shit, I just realized Tenmujin=铁木真，it is brain spinning whether Chinese should view yuan dynasty a great time of China or an miserable period of occupation
Simple, history is written by victor.
Genghis Khan did not exterminate people on racial grounds like Hitler did. Many of those attacked by Genghis Khan had killed the envoys he sent to them.
I LOVE THE INTRO xD
Me too ☺️
Good job.
@ 45:17 ... The narrator says ¨This is Mongolian biggest band at the moment¨. He is wrong...
THE HU is the best band IN THE WORLD!
So climate change has caused serious negative impact in this part of the world. Thanks for the informative report.
Go tell that to the Native Americans, who lose their way of life and many of their people got killed to build America.
Native American's get monthly pay checks from the government. Does China do the same?
I think the chinese have a goal. They are better off with neighbours, and other countries, who are well enough to do good business, and therefore dont need 800 military posts to keep the world in order.
I hope regulations start to help nature. Every country goes through this. Learn and modify, moderate.
Learn to understand that the welfare of the people,.. comes first before the welfare of some possums and a few endangered bunny rabbits etc !!
🖐️😄😄😻😂😂👆
Uhh quick correction. Soviet Union could not have helped Mongols gain independence in 1911, because 'Soviet Union' didn't even exists yet.
Imperial Russia was the one whom helped Mongols in this instance.
BRAVO 👏 CHINA 🇨🇳 REVIVING THE LAND OF CHENGIZ KHAN 👍
My view about countries along the Silk Road Initiative, there is always a group of people who insists on building and financing by their own people but they didn't realize that they should have "know how, finance and technology" because for the last 50-60 years, they didn't build anything at all. Observing those bikers with expensive big motorcycles and attires means they are doing pretty well, I suspected Western countries stirred the situation to damage the relationship with China.
"Exactly". The Western Anglo countries have all way use there "Divide and Rule" strategies back in there colonial day and still today.
"debt trap" is a convenient "excuse" to use when you dont want to pay up u see.. cus God forbidden ...that lenders, banks, treasury bills, bonds and mortgage actually exist in this world.
Why have you missed the flagship project of BRI called China Pakistan economic corridor. We want documentary on that too
HU cares? Sadly you didn't go to the inside Mongolia so you can find answers all those issues how to make them right, but anyway very good Episode and great job!
When the west constantly demonize China of debt traps, they should in turn play the angelic role of offering much needed money and credits for poor countries to develop themselves out of poverty. If they are unable or unwilling to borrow these poorer countries money, they should just stay out of other people's business. We are talking about feeding people and their livelihood here.
Exactly. All talk no help
“While Europeans exploit China 🇨🇳 (Or so they think) 🇨🇳 Spreads the wealth while buying up all of Europe - Cash! 🌺 💰 🙌🏻👏🙌🏻👏
Yes
Great work
Please upload video in Hindi dubbed
Whole series of The New Silk Road
This is a great documentary. The band music, sound interesting, but looks alike American biker gangs.
39:41 oh wow
As long no countries force their values or beliefs onto other countries, most people would welcome the change. Whatever conflict is are things we don't understand and fear of being forced into this 'inhumane values'
Different cultures, different ways of acting. Indians are always shouting and become emotional. Chinese are more calm and calculating.
why China should help Mongolia economy?
Because you’re her step mother.
At around 6:35 he said there are 8 countries being in the debt trap pf china, which are those besides mongolia?
So free capitalism didn't work in Mongolia. They have to turn into state owned operation for mining.
Lol
History is often surreal. In the case of Han-Mongolian relation history is really bizarre. The most powerful Mongolians in the 13th century has become a tiny speck in comparison to 1.4 billion non-Mongolian Chinese, mostly Hans.
Han policy has always been assimilated and destroy native cultures. Do you really think that all those people are actually Han?
@@RemoveChink It is simply social progress of a country to promote assimilation; native cultures will not be intact.
The Hawaiian culture is destroyed by the US but Hawaiians should and will be happy about the demise of their integral culture. It is simply joy to assimilate and become a part of the social mainstream; elders' insistence on otherwise not withstanding. Daniel Akaka sponsored the Akaka Bill in 2000 to aim to preserve the Hawaiian culture, but the US Senate cited the American "tradition of assimilation" as it rejected the Akaka Bill. I support the US Senate's decison in rejecting the Akaka Bill: ethnic cultures are a hindrance to human happiness.
Ethnic cultures have no value; their demise simply indicates human happiness in minorities fully integrating into society. Assimilation is the best for any countries, although some considerations should wisely be given to the mindset of elders within minority populations.
The more I observe the more I realize that China's minority police has been quite progressive. The best policy is to promote assimilation subtly while mollifying the mindset of elders within minority groups. China's policy is rather apt, thus.
Chinese government is prosecuting, torturing, jailed, murder, religious people in china.
@@s.humble1732 Falsehood.
the nomad way will soon be gone via modern progress.
"medium reports by Quartz"
I just vomited a little
in the next winter my mom is going to take me to the mountains to sled on the snow
You cannot get rich by herding. Unless you have a big market like China so they can sell the meat and dairy products inside the country. It is difficult to balance the Development and prosevation.
a funny thing is : the GDP of Outer Mongolia equals to a small city's GDP of Inner Mongolia
Andy Lee sorry. Maybe there are many chinese state companies operates for gdp. Gdp is just a number. Instead of gdp there are many measures are used to determine who is happy, for instance human right and happiness. In addition all of companies around the world are struggling against chinese state companies or supported companies in every market if you know.
@@temkatemka1230 Wow yes I can be happy when I am dirt poor, without water, internet or gas, but have a vote.
@@eternalelysium4944 i have 2 prius,decent internet,apartment but i consider myself poor. that should tell u mongolia like ukraine has massive shadow economy
@@QWERTY-gp8fd ?? Do not speak for the entire country
@@eternalelysium4944 who are to u say i cant speak for my country?
we have different way to value wealth. i dont have horse nor ger outside countryside.
hence im poor. cars and decent internet? everyone in mongolia can afford it.
Feel bad for the guy and his animals that would be a very very depressing and difficult situation to deal with
Is it possible to protect environment as well as have development, such that people can choose their lifestyle ?
World: Summer and may is here!!!!!
Mongolia: Wait it's summer during may?
Mongolia needs China for everything cause they are landlocked, so without China, Mongolia would have a hard time.
China needs Mongolia for it's natutal resources. If China cant get the resources from Mongolia then the consumers globally will have to pay more for the products they buy. Also decreasing the output of Chinese factories.
All in all, Mongolia cant do much without China. Whereas, China will have some difficulty if trade with Mongolia stops but they can always get the resources from other part of the world.
@CNA, and the host of this episode,
At 04:00 min or so, "... that mongols rule all of China and that lasted for over 100 years...."
It is ERRONEOUS. Mongols ruled China for 99 years, when the last Mongolian Emperor was driven out of China.
Go do your study a bit more, if no other causes led to such erroneous statement.
Films and narratives do not necessarily make a documentary. More often than not, they make noise and nuisance at their best, while tactless and insidious propaganda when deliberate and covert planting of misleading information to incite the worse elements of human nature is intended and orchestrated.
87 years, officially, and actual time of controlling is only 45 years, after 45 years yuan dynasty lost control of most part of china because people rising up against yuan govertment, in addtion, in that 45 years, only 11 years mongols controlled whole china, because after yuan founded in beijing, they spent another 34 year to attack south song dynasty in south part of china
@@xinyiquan666 , actually Han chinese have never ruled Mongolia as whole (because nowadays they rule Inner Mongolia.) Both Mongolia and China were parts of Qing dynasty, which ruled by Manchu people. It's same thing as Ukraine and Baltic states were the parts of USSR. Mongolia declared its independence from Qing in December 29, 1911 and in January 1, 1912. Mongolia got its independence from Qing before Chinese did. Therefore, do your study more, before teach others!
14:01 Did the opening of the LV store back in 2010.. Since then, I believe they have been going backward in their economy
Being nationalist and only talk and scream, without the capability to build country. What good does it bring to society?
interesting documentary, but too many ads make it unwatchable