Society of the Snow: History vs. Hollywood
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 фев 2024
- How accurate is Society of the Snow directed by J.A. Bayona? In this video that contains real footage, the Society of the Snow true story is compared to the Netflix movie about the Andes plane crash, which involved Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 on October 13, 1972. Of the 45 people on board, 19 were members of a rugby team on their way to Santiago, Chile for an exhibition match.
In this fact-check, we explore the Andes crash movie's biggest inaccuracies, as well as what it gets right, including the Society of the Snow crash scene. We look at the actions of the survivors of the crash, including how the movie's narrator, Numa Turcatti, sustained the injury to his leg, which doesn't line up with the true story. Also examined is the avalanche and Society of the Snow's ending, specifically the rescue of the survivors, which was significantly more difficult in real life.
To learn more about the fact vs. fiction in this Netflix Andes plane crash movie, read our article, "Society of the Snow: History vs. Hollywood", which further fact-checks the film. www.historyvshollywood.com/re...
I wouldn't say Society of the Snow is a "Hollywood" movie. The director is Spanish, the actors are all Uruguayan and Argentine. "Alive" is a Hollywood movie.
Exactly what I thought.
Exactamente pero es gringo entonces para ellos todo gira al rededor de Hollywood
He means, real life vs made up. How much of it is historically accurate vs made up by Hollywood. Or non fiction vs fiction.
Also Spanish actors.
Alive was much much better.
Thank God Hollywood had nothing to do with this film.
This movie is not a Hollywood movie. It was nominated for the best foreign film for the Oscars just so you know.
Roberto Canessa was the doctor at the end, Carlitos Paez played his father calling out the names twice.
And Nando Parrado is the one that opens the door in the airport to the actor that portrays him
There are like 8 survivors playing cameos
I noticed how every survivor cameo is in relation to themselves Roberto is treating himself nando opens the door for he’s family and paez is reading the names of his friends and himself and is playing his father
Not Hollywood. An spanish Movie !!! Very proud of that. 🇪🇸🇪🇸
is not a Hollywood movie
USians: see movie
USians: must be hollywood because no other person ever makes movies
This movie is everything and the real story absolutely inspiring!!👏🏻🙌♥️
You guys… calm down. Obviously it’s a Spanish movie, but Hollywood vs History is the name of the CHANNEL. He literally just means film/cinema in general. 🤦🏼♀️
Exactly. Thank you.
Haley Marry me?
Reportedly there are some scenes that were shot but deleted from the final cut. Two of them depict actual events:
• During the hike to the plane's tail, a blizzard hits the group and Roy Harley tells the others to leave him behind. Nando becomes aggressive and harshly convinces him to return to the fuselage. This is depicted in Alive.
• Carlos Valeta was ejected from the plane as it skidded down the slope but didn't die immediately. Injured and in shock, he started walking and didn't hear the other survivors calling his name (the shouting can be heard in the background during the scene with the pilot). He fell into a snowdrift and died of asphyxiation. His body was found on the 63rd day.
i think ultimately, the choices Bayona made for this film were the correct ones. Frank Marshall and Kathleen Kennedy largely made the film they wanted to make, not the one that should have been made. The survivors said that film did not resemble anything of what they went through, and most of the survivors and the families of that dead refused to allow their names to be used because of how really bad that film turned out. It's best not do discuss the 1976 film "Survive" as it was clearly exploiting the tragedy with very shoddy effects such as powdered snow. And again with that film none of the real names were used. I am hoping Bayona releases a longer cut of the film.
I like how they called out the names and age as they died.
Yeah, survivors have told Society of the Snow is highly accurate, unlike other movies about the tragedy. That is why all the survivors and family of the ones who died gave permission to use the actual names of everybody in the movie.
The 93 film never had permission to use the names of the dead to begin with so it had nothing to do with the quality of the film. Parrado was a technical advisor on the film and many of the survivors visited the set. The main complaint was that Alive focused too much on Nando and didnt depict the team effort as much as it could have. The new film is arguably better, but it could be just as truly stated that it focuses too much on Turcatti. I enjoyed both films. Both leave a lot of details out and change some situations for dramatic purposes. The Strauch cousins certainly get their due in the newer film but Carlitos has less of a part. Alive did a better job of depicting the injuries suffered by the survivors. Society does a better job of depicting the bleakness and hardship of their ordeal but this is due more so to the style of the directing and cinematography than to any factual errors present in the 93 film. Clunky dialog aside Alive doesnt merit the disdain many seem to want to heap on it. Just my opinion of course.
It's a Spanish movie with Uruguayan actors
Esta pelicula esta fundamentada en:la fe ,la lucha por vivir,el amor por el projimo,la solidaridad ,el amor por la familia es decir todo lo que el holiwood actual odia,imposible ganar un oscar
"Society of the Snow" is not a hollywood movie, "Alive" was. Please change the title.
In the movie I think the flight engineer only appeared once but in real life he survived up until the avalanche
Yeah and from what I’ve read there’s no proof at all that he was anything like the character he was portrayed as being in the 1993 movie Alive.
In that film he was shown as being a selfish creep who was no help to anyone and acted like some kind of nutter. It showed him snatch a coat that had been put over a young girl to try to keep her a bit more comfortable because she had been so seriously injured from the crash.
Until one of the young guys notice and threatened him not to touch it again and he put it back over the girl.
I watched another documentary comparing the two films and the narrator said he’d researched it and couldn’t find a single thing about this having happened or anything about the engineer being an asshole the way he is in that film🤷🏻♀️
I just thought how angry and hurt you’d be if this wasn’t true and had just been added for effect
if you are a family member of this man😕
The mechanic does appear up to the avalanche in STOS, he just blends in with the rest of the guys in the background
voy a decir algo que solo los que hablan español van a entender: las generaciones de cristal de hoy, se morirían de un ataque de ansiedad el primer dia, y no llegarían a los 20 días sin que el 90% estén fríos bajo la nieve.
Total!
😂🤣 👏 👏
De hecho fue mi primer pensamiento al terminar la película, los chicos de hoy día no habrían sobrevivido. 😢😢
La generacion de cristal no existe.
En todas Las generaciones hay gente chillona
wow! no more life complaints for me
Por suerte La sociedad de la nieve no fue tocada por Hooliwood
Read the book Alive! It goes into great detail and is absolutely heartbreaking. When they experience the avalanche that kills 8 and leaves only 19 remaining, its crushing!
According to US Americans everything is either Hollywood or Bollywood :)))
Society of Snow gave the "deserved respect" to survivors and deceased much much better than the Hollywood made Alive! I wasn't surprised that all team are local actors (Uruguayan, Argentinian) and Spanish.
Society of Snow abbreviate as (SOS).. i don't know if this was intentional but quite impactful!
Not all Americans
Hollywood? It’s a Spanish movie.
La película no es de Hollywood, por eso costó tanto realizarla.
The best story ever.
amazing movie--the effort put into the movie to make it accurate is so diligently done. I also feel Society of the Snow has a leg up due to having better technology and resources for make it possible to shoot up where the actual crash took place (in comparison to the Ethan Hawk movie, where drones wasn't possible)
If surviving the airplane accident was not enough, the plane had to crash on the most magnificent inhospitable place on earth! Cordilheira dos Andes! That is really a very profound moment in their lives, the fact they were considered dead to the authorities and their families but since they hade one another as part of a team that was already entrusted thru the sport, and the fact they were all young .
It seems is a lot lessons to learn from this horrific experience. They survived avalanche and 72 days off constant knowing they needed to try to cross that super scary cordilheira / Montain ! Wow !! They really deserve to be Alive 🙏💕🦋
Roy Harley cluched while the avalache hit the plane. Roy and Carlitos were the only one that weren't buried in the snow. He managed to pull himself free then he pulled Carlitos free. After the avalanche Roy broke the window
"Survive!" Mexican Exploitation
"Alive" Hollywood Movie
"Society..." A Spanish Movie
I absolutely loved this movie! They did a very good job! I picked up on the cameos and most of the mistakes almost immediately. The mistakes do not take away from the movie at all
Hollywood movie? Are you kidding?
not hollywood. its a spanish movie
Actually the movie is American. It's like saying that Jurassic World is a Spanish movie just because the director is Spanish.
@matiasdanielgamon3996 no lol. it's literally made in Spanish, with Uruguayan and Argentinian actors. nothing about the director. Even then the producers and the director are all Spanish. the only American association it has is being released on Netflix with English dub. American movies don't get nominated at oscars for "best INTERNATIONAL feature film"
@@matiasdanielgamon3996 is not a movie from Hollywood studio
@@matiasdanielgamon3996no, it is not american, in fact they did this movie bc Hollywood did it before ant it was all wrong and super Hollywood and USA like
@@matiasdanielgamon3996Is american because the tragedy was in America 😂
Can you show pictures of the people who died in the Avalanche
ruclips.net/video/KSUBUqMQah0/видео.htmlsi=1k1yA1qXlGLbrQxs
Everyone commenting about his use of Hollywood.
It’s his branding. it’d be stupid to change for one video, we all understand what it means. 🤣
We don’t understand which is why we are upset
I’m with Sheila. This is NOT a Hollywood film.
Está película es tal y cuál cómo fue en la realidad....no está exagerada a extremo Hollywood..fue así..aquí los uruguayos lo sabemos lo vivimos ..
In alive they name Marcelo Antonio for some reason
Because, unlike SOTS, Alive as a project didn’t have the approval of the families of the victims
you pronounce Juan as One
😂 😂😂
Society Of The Snow is NOT a Hollywood film.
Why did the co pilot have a gun with him tho
It was an Air Force plane.
not really a hollywood movie
NGL. Cannibalism is always on the table when SHTF.
@@rosinamariacaviglia5022 Nice try, but go sit down now. The reason that science uses a different term is to categorize cannibalism into different categories, i.e. ritualistic use vs. survival measures.
@@rosinamariacaviglia5022 Sorry, it's called English, where words have definition and meaning. Learn more of it.
@@rosinamariacaviglia5022 Crack a book before ya go!
I'm calm. Tho, if I was calmer, I'd be asking about your anthropophagous interests. @@rosinamariacaviglia5022
And are you liking your own replies? How pathetic@@rosinamariacaviglia5022
Thats really disappointing. The true story is better