Rappers React To Rammstein "Pussy"!!! (Live From Maddison Square Garden)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 155

  • @tosa2522
    @tosa2522 Год назад +50

    What an honor for the MSG that Rammstein performed there.

  • @philippwerd8433
    @philippwerd8433 Год назад +47

    See them live 2 times the last two years!! What should i say , a great experience , best live performance ever!! love it

    • @CapitanDePlai
      @CapitanDePlai Год назад +2

      Can't wait to see them again next year!

  • @Djcimofficial
    @Djcimofficial Год назад +47

    This was the first time seeing Rammstein and this was one of the best concerts I have ever went to.

    • @AKayfabe
      @AKayfabe Год назад +1

      I think that Rammstein, Iron Maiden, and Tool are always the best 3 to see live.

    • @s.n.9952
      @s.n.9952 Год назад +2

      ​@@AKayfabe Ich sah 2022 Rammstein und Iron Maiden kurz hintereinander im Stadion ,,Ullevi" in Göteborg (SE) .
      Die legendären ,,Iron Maiden " , (zusammen mit ,,Metallica" ) Band meiner Jugend , waren im Vergleich zu Rammstein auf dem Niveau einer (sehr guten) Vorband . Alle diese Ikonen der Rockgeschichte , habe zu Recht den Status den sie sich erarbeitet haben und verdienen den höchsten Respekt!
      Live sind ,,Rammstein '' jedoch ein ganz eigenes Level!
      Der Entertainmentfactor ist absolut unerreicht!
      Entschuldigung das ich deutsch schreibe ! Mein englisch ist zu schlecht !
      Regards!
      Ps. Ich sah Rammsteins StadiumTour auch in 2019 und 2023. Jedes Mal eine Steigerung. Die werden immer noch besser !

  • @Litsntei_
    @Litsntei_ Год назад +23

    This concert at Madison Square Garden was sold out in 20 !!! Minutes and yes for their stadium tour for the band's 30th anniversary next summer, some concerts are already sold out, so they have added more dates. Thanks for your Reaction

    • @mikek9297
      @mikek9297 11 месяцев назад +1

      Rammstein tickets be like that. Gotta click quick.

  • @Mellovesrammstein
    @Mellovesrammstein Год назад +26

    I have seen Rammstein 17 times now, and off to Austria and Spain (from the UK) to see them next year. Appreciate you reacting!! Love your videos very much ❤

    • @AKayfabe
      @AKayfabe Год назад +4

      if they come back to Minneapolis I’ll go see them, they were here in 2022. They tour Europe more often than N America though.
      They were here in 1999 long ago. I met them back then. Flake didn’t speak much English, Richard invited me to their party. They are great people.
      I have been listening to them since they began in the 90s

    • @s.n.9952
      @s.n.9952 Год назад +1

      I have Feuerzone-Tickets to St.Antonio and Barcelona ( and Marseille)
      See You !🤘❤️‍🔥🤘❤️‍🔥🤘❤️‍🔥🤘❤️‍🔥🤘❤️‍🔥🤘❤️‍🔥

    • @isuckatguitar6252
      @isuckatguitar6252 Год назад +1

      I'll be seeing them in Barcelona and Copenhagen! 🥳🥳🥳 Will just be my 2nd & 3rd time cause I live in Asia😅

  • @jezza117
    @jezza117 Год назад +27

    you are by some margin my favorite reactors and for Rappers you totally get Rammstein, considering metal is not your bag, well done dudes, enjoyed this and hopefully we see 'Pussy' back on their tour next year

    • @christof2122
      @christof2122 11 месяцев назад +1

      I can't wait to see them again....

    • @asdasd-rp9hx
      @asdasd-rp9hx 4 месяца назад

      this is the best reaction video. first time on this channel and the energy and vibe is so good

  • @chrisbadgrampacarpenter8052
    @chrisbadgrampacarpenter8052 Год назад +12

    Definitely gotta do more live rammstein absolutely amazing live great reaction guys 😂

  • @sentatyn5207
    @sentatyn5207 Год назад +9

    I got to know them in June 2023 , fell in love with this Band and have my first Concerts in Vienna in July, this was the best Concert I ever ever seen in my age over 60 . ITs really fantastic!! And they all 6 have so much Charisma, even every of them a little bit different - and all together, playing now for 30 Years together!! They music brought so much Energy in my Life! I like your reaction very much! By the way Flake = Christian Lorenz had written two books which are great with his humor :-) and all words of all Songs are written by Till Lindemann!!

  • @arlandjonesiii7512
    @arlandjonesiii7512 Год назад +16

    Please do more Rammstein, they are so deep....

  • @jasonjtd79dunne88
    @jasonjtd79dunne88 Год назад +5

    I worked at that concert. Was their first US show in 10 years at the time i loved getting to see the bits I saw live. But had to walk from my beer cart to see it down the hall side stage.

  • @savemepunk3191
    @savemepunk3191 Год назад +3

    Saw them live at Gillette Stadium last September (2022) and this was one of the highlights of the show... I was about 8 rows from the stage... and it's like a bubble/foam... and then confetti gets stuck to you! Everyone was high fiving and vibing... its was the best live show I've ever been too!

  • @KenBober
    @KenBober Год назад +16

    Damn Christian is a legend. Makes me want to send them some genuine New England salt water taffy. And some other New England treats.

  • @donaldligon9418
    @donaldligon9418 Год назад +4

    After watching yall's reaction I was laughing so hard. You two really get into the videos. Keep up the great work yall.

  • @KattMurr
    @KattMurr Год назад +4

    Even though I live in New York, the only time I went to Madison Square Garden was in the 90's and it was for a Grateful Dead Show...fun times! I was only able to see Rammstein once when they were part of the Pledge of Allegiance Tour along with Slipknot and System of a Down. They were incredible!!! I was unable to see them last year when they came here. I didn't have a working car and they played in both Massachusetts and New Jersey, which either venue was not that far. Hopefully next time they come to America I will be able to see them. I have a newer car, so transportation won't be an issue...

  • @jessiefarmer6979
    @jessiefarmer6979 Год назад +9

    Next rammstein song do buck duch live in France 2013 there's others but do this one great band

  • @AKayfabe
    @AKayfabe Год назад +5

    Rammstein don’t tour the US or North America often enough. But when they do they are hugely popular. Have you guys ever reacted to Bloodywood? If not, you should! Also they don’t cause people any grief for reacting to their music, they are really nice guys. I met them a couple years ago.

  • @paulhaire3982
    @paulhaire3982 Год назад +9

    I want to see them in concert. I saw Tool in concert Friday.

    • @AKayfabe
      @AKayfabe Год назад

      Tool are amazing live now! I saw Tool first in 1995, at First Ave in Minneapolis which isn’t a large venue, but it is famous. the show was very straightforward no light show, nothing fancy, but amazing. I saw them this last time again and it was a huge lightshow, and a huge venue. I’m glad I got to see them early on, and now again. I saw Bloodywood too. I think this channel should react to Bloodywood. Rammstein are my favorite band, but Till has a solo album out just this month too now.

  • @arnodobler1096
    @arnodobler1096 Год назад +7

    On US TV they called it the Foam Cannon😂😂

  • @jessiefarmer6979
    @jessiefarmer6979 Год назад +3

    Finally I suggested this a few times

  • @Litsntei_
    @Litsntei_ Год назад +5

    Maybe you both make Rammstein Reaction to
    "Haifisch" Official Video and Live
    "ZickZack" Official Video
    "Radio" Official Video
    "Bück dich" live Montral 2012
    "Wollt ihr das Bett in Flammen sehen" live in Paris
    "Weisses Fleisch!" the same Concert in Madison Square Garden
    "Benzin" Official Video and live in Madison Square Garden
    "Mein Teil" Official Video

  • @victorstefanovsky6902
    @victorstefanovsky6902 Год назад +1

    Keyboardist Kristian “Flake” Lorenz is the main songwriter with guitarist Kruspe. Lindemann writes the lyrics.

  • @xxxxxx-gm1fp
    @xxxxxx-gm1fp Год назад

    You really are among the top 3 who respond to Rammstein!!! Keep up the good work and especially with RAMMS+EiN! 🤘

  • @TrojanSalesmen1
    @TrojanSalesmen1 7 месяцев назад

    Lucky I have gotten to see them Twice in the States,, so Far the have taken up both number 1 and number 2 for the BEST concerts EVER!

  • @mattboselli1099
    @mattboselli1099 Год назад +4

    Great reaction by two dudes that really care about the genre and thank you for watching the p word with us it really means a lot great video great song and I'm so glad all the allegations have acquitted with these guys because these guys are nothing but looking for move forward to more reactions

    • @fast_mattw8059
      @fast_mattw8059 Год назад

      What if they react to THE PUSSYCAT DOLLS? Can they say it then? Lmao

  • @srenjohansen1592
    @srenjohansen1592 Год назад +3

    I hope you will reach to Dicke Titten by Rammstein. Its gonna make you cry of laughter

  • @txmale1977
    @txmale1977 Год назад +3

    Hollywood 6, love the Janis shirt. I actually graduated from the same high school as she did

  • @HammeredReactions
    @HammeredReactions Год назад

    Saw these guys in Gothenburg and was probably the best concert I’ve ever been to

  • @River_Foster
    @River_Foster Год назад

    Best reaction from this performance I've seen yall are epic

  • @dimitrasotirakoglou2553
    @dimitrasotirakoglou2553 Год назад +7

    I love them ❤😅😅

  • @chriscb8353
    @chriscb8353 Год назад +3

    The sold out this concert at MSG in only 20 minutes. No more tickets available after 20 min starting the ticket presale

    • @chriscb8353
      @chriscb8353 Год назад +1

      By the way it is me Christian. And it always a pleasure to make people laughing in this strange world. I am glad you liked it!

  • @sterling8298
    @sterling8298 Год назад +2

    This band rules.💪🤘🤘🤘🤘💯💯💯 And for them to get to play Madison Square gardens in New York, that's saying something. Cause Madison Square gardens doesn't just let anybody play there.
    I hope I get to see this band live 1 day.😊

  • @tiffanyabell9070
    @tiffanyabell9070 Год назад +1

    Ramm-sht-i-n. Is how you say it.❤❤😊 i also saved a few peices of the confetti from the cannon! Lol

  • @PalleRasmussen
    @PalleRasmussen Год назад

    I was at Ullevi 29-07 last year, in the Feuerzone. Nothing compares to it, especially after "Pussy". All your senses as well as your brain gets kicked around during that. It is extreme; like a really good shaq actually. You are left exhausted and happy. This band is beyond description.
    Iggy Pop said about is; "They handed me earplugs and said 'you will need this'. I was like 'naaah'. I put in the earplugs and I was still too loud, my hole body was shaking."

  • @eldeano9964
    @eldeano9964 Год назад +2

    Yeah, the only place to see the uncensored music video version of this song, is an adult site.

  • @kristiinaaaltonen9652
    @kristiinaaaltonen9652 Год назад

    Great reaction👍. What can i say, it was amazing to get painted by Till this year in Helsinki. Loved it🔥 I hope next summer i can get same treatment in CPH 😉

  • @mjrtaurus2714
    @mjrtaurus2714 Год назад

    All the confetti after the foam. I've heard of getting tarred and feathered, but that crowd got frosted and sprinkled.

  • @jessiefarmer6979
    @jessiefarmer6979 Год назад +1

    This is why i suggested this song multiple times cause what he rides on for the crowd 😂

  • @gennyreese420
    @gennyreese420 Год назад +1

    They are truly one of a kind, that was probably the craziest thing I’ve seen a band do, and I’ve seen Marilyn Manson slice his hand and splay blood all over the crowd, but yeah, that was something lol!…
    Polar opposite band from Germany is Trio…new wave we loved in the 80’s…Da da da and Anna are their best known songs ✌💚✨ something in the very beginning of this song made me think of them, not just the German connection lol it’s totally pop tho, nothing like this at all.
    Also, when I was a teenager we used to be able to get Toffifee here, I remember liking it…we called it toffee Fay 😹…very cool gift box, so nice!

  • @isuckatguitar6252
    @isuckatguitar6252 Год назад

    Got tkts to see them in Europe next summer!!! Wooohoooo! Firezone here I come! Apparently tkts sold out at Madison Square garden in 20-30 mins! They just put tkts on sale in Europe for summer 2024 and places like Dresden are sold out 4 dates in a row already 🤯 Oh the P. canon is much BIGGER now! 😂

  • @ShanLH5
    @ShanLH5 Год назад +10

    So romantic 🥰

    • @kristaspecht
      @kristaspecht Год назад +1

      🤣🤣🤣right shan??? Lol

    • @kristaspecht
      @kristaspecht Год назад +1

      Morning fellas! That was friggin great! Hahaha! The audience loved it! Glad y'all got to try some German candies! That's awesome too! Lol. Very Kool❤️🤓🤘

    • @gennyreese420
      @gennyreese420 Год назад +2

      Truer words were never written 😹😹✨

    • @ShanLH5
      @ShanLH5 Год назад +1

      @@kristaspecht 🤣🤣🤣

    • @ShanLH5
      @ShanLH5 Год назад +3

      @@gennyreese420 those lyrics just touched my heart lol 💕

  • @ItsJimmyTheCat
    @ItsJimmyTheCat 7 месяцев назад

    i love your reactions! more of this please! new subscriber here!

  • @conjunctivius8552
    @conjunctivius8552 Год назад

    It's always sooo delicious when your minds get blown away by Rammstein😊

  • @DM-rc4yu
    @DM-rc4yu Год назад

    This is the definition of a fun song.

  • @bema1908
    @bema1908 Год назад +4

    There's also an uncensored music video of this song, definitely not suitable for RUclips. :D

    • @txmale1977
      @txmale1977 Год назад

      Oh yea, I remember when it came out, you had to go to a pron site to view it.

  • @fineflavour4493
    @fineflavour4493 Год назад +1

    You guys really need to see the uncensored official video of that song. pro tipp: you won't find it on youtube ;)

  • @srenjohansen1592
    @srenjohansen1592 Год назад +2

    You should also react to this song from this years tour. Although it was removed from
    the setlist halfway in the tour due to allegations towards Till. The D… is bigger on way more foam. I saw the twice in Denmark this year and was in second row. I was pretty foamed😂

  • @MRHEEL-ys2rq
    @MRHEEL-ys2rq 4 месяца назад

    Trash Talkers, seeing as you definitely like reacting to Rammsteins live shows and they are definitely awesome, maybe sometime react to a song from their Sehnschuct album they usually play at their shows called "Stripped" its their cover of the Depeche Mode song which quite honestly you cant go wrong with either version, but would love to see you guys do that one, thanks😊

  • @jurgenkreitz4059
    @jurgenkreitz4059 Год назад +2

    Hey
    the name from the keyborder is FLAKE Lorenz

  • @SilencerUK
    @SilencerUK Год назад

    Now go see if you can find the unedited video version, certainly not suitable for youtube but just for your own veiwing pleasure.

  • @JohnWayne-vf5bs
    @JohnWayne-vf5bs Год назад +4

    The German industrial Giants

  • @dimitri9262
    @dimitri9262 Год назад

    now see for Benzin live at MSG ;). I'm happy because I'm going to see Rammstein at San Sebastian stadium in June next year ;)

  • @superkamialyssa9406
    @superkamialyssa9406 Год назад +5

    The correct pronunciation of this bands name is "raam-shtine"

    • @superkamialyssa9406
      @superkamialyssa9406 Год назад +1

      Side note: toffiffe is sold in America at both Walmart and Aldi stores

  • @Mister__Jey
    @Mister__Jey Год назад

    20:17 the firezone Tickets cost usually 130 to 150 nowadays

  • @michelleponzio
    @michelleponzio Год назад

    I love Till's antics❤❤!!

  • @nordicbynature2775
    @nordicbynature2775 8 месяцев назад

    Moin from Germany 😊
    Yes they sold out within
    23 MINUTES after anounced😂
    I see them live again in july in Germany...exidet like every time❤🔥🤘😎

  • @Kyuss-Unida
    @Kyuss-Unida Месяц назад

    Very underrated song of Rammstein.

  • @zanderalex2463
    @zanderalex2463 Год назад +3

    The Keyboarders Nickname is "Flake".

    • @txmale1977
      @txmale1977 Год назад +1

      Christian "Flake" Lorenz

  • @IgYel
    @IgYel 6 месяцев назад

    The video actually starts at the mid.. nice)

  • @stefanstark9825
    @stefanstark9825 Год назад +2

    21:48 Hello, I think your reaction is great, you should check out the song 'Los',

  • @als81940
    @als81940 Год назад

    You should watch their videos...especially the older ones. They really play around with the keyboard player in those!

  • @christof2122
    @christof2122 11 месяцев назад

    It is not really the end of the show, they came back few minutes later and finish the show with Engel.
    Fun fact: Christian Lorenz is the only member of the group who never respond "yes" when they create rammstein, he just came to the studio and play because at first he didn't know what the hell he was doing in a metal band. But we can say that without a keyboard rammstein is not the rammstein we like.

  • @sterling8298
    @sterling8298 Год назад +2

    I eat croissants all the time but I put them in the air fryer.😊

  • @Twigaroni
    @Twigaroni Год назад

    In the US that candy is spelled, "Toffifay," and both it and the German spelling are pronounced the same, "Toffee-fay." It's yummy!

  • @n0wi153
    @n0wi153 Год назад +1

    Luv the Mutter TShirt

  • @munkemis
    @munkemis Год назад +3

    Smokey is right in his pronunciation. it's Ramm-Stein, not Ramm-Stien

  • @ragepunx9342
    @ragepunx9342 Год назад

    want a good one watch the performance of engal at the same gig as the keyboardest is cutting shapes on a treadmill while playing the keyb
    oard while til is wearing wings that shoot fire

  • @ModoTronic666
    @ModoTronic666 Год назад

    The keyboardist goes by the nickname Flake (flah-kay). I'm not sure what exactly it means but I know that much.

  • @hugogeerts201
    @hugogeerts201 Год назад

    I was lucky to get some tickets for next year here in the Nederlans

    • @chriscb8353
      @chriscb8353 Год назад

      I have some available for Gelsenkirchen?

  • @waschberserker
    @waschberserker 21 день назад

    First of all, Janis Joplin and Rammstein t-shirts? Perfect XD This was a very entertaining reaction, and I genuinely enjoyed watching it. However, the song, despite its humorous appeal, tackles a serious topic: sex tourism. Specifically, it highlights the issue of German men traveling to Eastern Europe for this purpose (though it’s not limited to this region; German men also travel to Thailand and other locations). The line 'I can't get laid in Germany' alludes to this issue, which is a serious problem, not only from a moral standpoint. 👍

  • @VicGrimes
    @VicGrimes Год назад +1

    for the name, think about a beer stein. you dont call it beer steen, you call it beer styne. Or listen to their song Rammstein.

  • @donaldligon9418
    @donaldligon9418 Год назад

    You should really checkout Lindemann. Tills solo career is just as crazy.

  • @pauloaraujo3824
    @pauloaraujo3824 Год назад +1

    FANTÁSTICO

  • @txmale1977
    @txmale1977 Год назад

    Guys, you should do Fish on, Steh Auf or really any of the songs Til did under the name Lindemann. The album Skills with Pills is all in English and a lot of the songs are sexual in nature

  • @backstabbedmetal
    @backstabbedmetal Год назад

    Saw them live, they played this last, had soap/foam everywhere lol

  • @chriscb8353
    @chriscb8353 Год назад

    you still must react to the shirts you have :-) "Mutter" and "Zeit". Zeit I recommend the official video, but Mutter live.

  • @TheDukeOfPannekoeken
    @TheDukeOfPannekoeken 6 месяцев назад

    I love you guys 😂😂

  • @ROBOTRIX_eu
    @ROBOTRIX_eu Год назад +1

  • @Steffe
    @Steffe Год назад +1

    I just ate a Swedish semla. It would be tricky to send some to you, so I guess you will have to take my word for it when I say that it was very tasty.

  • @dadjeans391
    @dadjeans391 Год назад

    I would still like to see Ex-mortis by Ice Nine Kills on here!

  • @sterling8298
    @sterling8298 Год назад +1

    Yall should check out the band Memphis may fire.😊

  • @starwraithe
    @starwraithe Год назад

    Saw them in Los Angeles last year at the Memorial Coliseum, I was in the Fire Zone, the foam is basically just suds(some of it got into my mouth and it tasted soapy, lol somehow that sounds just wrong ha ha)also the 'dick cannon' looks a lot different from the one from this show, as always great reaction to R+ by you both

  • @lindasalaki9404
    @lindasalaki9404 Год назад

    That was funny as hell 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @user-nr2cs2rq7h
    @user-nr2cs2rq7h Год назад

    In German,if it is EI;pronounce it as I.
    If it is IE; pronounce it as E❤

  • @Connorjwebb123
    @Connorjwebb123 Год назад

    Love it 😂

  • @user-ti2ko7ex3h
    @user-ti2ko7ex3h 8 месяцев назад

    Your question to beginning: Was the Medison Square Garden sold out ?? The MSG was sold out in 30 min. 😎😎😎

  • @notbadbros7814
    @notbadbros7814 9 месяцев назад

    no official music video? ah, nvm wrong website for that...

  • @amadeusitchon
    @amadeusitchon 11 месяцев назад

    It wasn't IF they sold it out. It was HOW LONG before it was sold out.

  • @chrishoskavich2435
    @chrishoskavich2435 Год назад +2

    Schokolade = chocolate

  • @sterling8298
    @sterling8298 Год назад +1

    The people in the front row i feel like got a $500 seat if they were only a $100.

  • @pittsburghgrower
    @pittsburghgrower Год назад

    He face painted the entire crowd.. hilarious

  • @sterling8298
    @sterling8298 Год назад +1

    Could you imagine if today you could get a brand new car for $825? It would be like we were all living in a Twilight Zone if that happened.

  • @FroschimBrunnen
    @FroschimBrunnen Год назад

    If you found this hilarious, you're gonna LOVE Bück dich 😅 (live from Montreal, Paris or Berlin)

  • @boubou230910
    @boubou230910 Год назад

    Next step, "Buck Dich" from Paris.....if you dare patreons....

  • @Tiisiphone
    @Tiisiphone Год назад +6

    I've seen this live, the c*m smelled like coconut!

    • @Pennywise-hn5qw
      @Pennywise-hn5qw Год назад +2

      Its a liquid of coconut vodka😅😅 like in the liveshow of Bück Dich❤❤😊

  • @PeturHinrik
    @PeturHinrik Год назад

    Puh-lease do Rammstein - Rammstein. That way there will be no question on how to pronounce the name

  • @tracyburd5166
    @tracyburd5166 Год назад

    Just subscribed to your Channel, yo you guys should check it out the band Stainded, "Something to Remind You" the live performance (Live at Mohegan Sun) on the night you guys do new metal, it's from 2011 are there just rock and not really new metal

  • @Gorerupted
    @Gorerupted 11 месяцев назад

    You know you now have to react the live version of Buck Dich... i dare you

  • @cornick115
    @cornick115 9 месяцев назад

    We sell those at my work in Michigan I’ll send you the same thing just spelt in English

  • @Nanda-1305
    @Nanda-1305 Год назад +1

    😂👍❤

  • @sonofthesea3298
    @sonofthesea3298 Год назад +2

    In theyr youth (this might be abit of a spoiler?) Till did a German song with similar lyrics to this,where he took it even further,by having what looked like an actual d**k he pulled out of his pants,and "showered people with". And that was not all he did...... i have always had an open mind,i let people be what they want to be and all that,but that performance became a tad too much for me. At a point it was funny,but then it turned into "come on man...."
    It seemed like they were much more provocative when they started out. Yes,they still try to open peoples minds and create some sort of controversy,but they are much more matured and "restrained" these days.
    I have always had Madonna as my favourite female solo artist,and she has done alot of vulgar,provocative stuff. Although she always had some serious plans for why she did what she did,she changed the industry around for the better,as well as saved many lifes in the process. When i saw Rammstein as super young,it was like they just provoced to create a name for themselfs. Well,in that specific performance that is. I know a few female reactors has been tricked into reacting to it,i dont know if those reactions are still up,but yeah.... it turned into some shocked faces alright.
    Overall i do agree though,these guys has always put on a show,and strangely enough they make a type of music,where it doesnt matter what language they perform in. I sort of questioned myself if my potential spoiler was really worth mentioning,but in all fairness. The cat was out of the bag already,with him riding on a mechanical shlongadong. And i havent revealed what they did during the entire performance. But you really need a stomach to digest it all,and a free mind. Thats all im saying
    Have you done Mein Herz Brennt? Thats my favourite song of theyrs alongside Ich Will (live) and Sonne (studio version/music video)

    • @txmale1977
      @txmale1977 Год назад

      They did Mein Herz Brennt, but it was the official video, wish they would do the piano version, it is so much more darker in tone