God fricking dammit its low quality rendering again Stay tuned if you want to help me get funds for a new computer! Clarifications: I gave different colors to the anarchist councils despite being loosely associated with the republican government because they were highly autonomous, and the republican government did not have effective control over those areas until it reached a certain point. However, in the textbox they are underneath the republican faction to indicate a somewhat de jure subservient relationship between the anarchist/leftist councils and the central government, but I gave them different colors because they were special in their own regard. Regarding the extent of control of the CNT-FAI in Catalonia, from what I've read so far, it appeared that they were the dominant force. There was collaboration with the central government through the Generalitat, as well as cooperation with the UGT, but they were the undisputed force in Catalonia and controlled almost every aspect of people's lives in the region. So, to make everything less complicated, I put them under the republican government but with a separate color. They "joined" the government as a way to avoid antagonizing the central government while still making their own decisions. For the Interprovincial Council of Santander, Palencia and Burgos (ICSPB in the video), I decided to put it in a lighter purple because out of all these councils this council stood out for being the least radical out of all the councils I've read.
@@DeliriumMaps I've read your sources and saw that you read an incredible amount of sources, and wrote so much notes. If you mind me asking, how do you manage to do all that in just a month?
what happened in the old days were a competitive and academic disaster. these damages to the public perception of history need to be fixed otherwise we will make exaggerations and simplifications of everything that we will distort history, i call jake mapping as joke mapping because of what he did to philippine history and it was a very disgraceful sight and it got personal, i almost had a stroke watching how he mutilated philippine history
Two of my great-grandfathers and one grandfather fought in that war. Only the latter came back home, the other two "disappeared", so we don't know the story. My grandfather became a general, and was ordered to cover the retreat of the republican army from Aragon and then Catalonia. He was eventually captured after defending a hill for days. He was sent to a prison camp and then to jail. Years after the war ended he was freed, his home was destroyed during the bombings so he rented a room, my grandmother was the one who rented it and they ended up marrying. He was routinely visited for years by the authorities to check if he was doing something suspicious. He died just days after the dictatorship ended.
Great video and research. Only one question about the basque country. Why did you mark Zarautz on the map but not Donostia/San Sebastián,the capital of the Guipuzkoa province? I find remarcable that you have put the excerpt of the francoist anthem lining up more or less with the Ebro battle, I don't know if it was intentional. Great work! ❤💛💜
I must congratulate you for the research and effort you’ve putted on that work, wich indeed must be recognised because that type of videos are not easy to make, you have added various important focuses of the war, like the Leon-Asturias guerrilla insurgency, and have clearly showed the progression on the takeover of Extremadura and portrayed the “Casado coup” (wich despite being crucial to understand the definitive surrender of the Spanish Republic is not showed on most of the videos portraying the Spanish Civil war). With that said, and because I have deeply studied this conflict, I must also point out some flaws in the portrayal of the situation made in this video: The most important one I think, is that the CNT-FAI, despite having a great influence and controling a lot of local Anti-fascist Militia Comitees, they did definitely not control all Catalonia, the region was administered from the beginning to the end of the war by the autonomous government of the “Generalitat de Catalunya” that was an integral part of the Spanish Republic, and despite the CNT acting on his own authority on many local comitees and having autonomy as an organitzation, they did not rebel against this government until May 1937, and the insurrection was mainly in the city of Barcelona, in the rest of Catalonia some local comitees (specially those controlled by the CNT-FAI itself or by the anti-stalinist marxist organitzation POUM) supported the insurrection, but most of them sided with the republican government. On the other hand, most regional comitees like the Madrid Defence Junta or the Valencia Executive Comitee were not independent from the republican government in any way, they were organisms within the Republican government aparatus created to better coordinate the war effort and the supression of those who were supportive of the military coup and the rebel faction, the same can be said of the inter-provincial council of Asturias and León until the 24th August 1937, when it declared it’s full sovereignty when their communications with the central government were cutted by the fascist forces (in that case showing the council as independent since its comformation avoided that to be properly showed). Regarding the Basque Government, it acted as an administrative autonomy just like the Generalitat government in Catalonia did, and was a part of the Spanish Republic as well. The Regional Defence Council of Aragon acted the facto as a separate entity, so in that case I think that the different color may be justified, but not in the other cases. To correct that without deminishing the amount of information that you represent, I think that the best option would be to represent the regional comitees with a light-purple tone, and if you want to represent the May 1937 clashes between the CNT-FAI and the republican government you can highlight Barcelona (also Madrid can be highlighted as the battle for Madrid lasted for most of the war). (As an idea, It would have also been interesting to portray the short-lived anti-Franco falangist uprising in Salamanca that ocurred between the 16th and 17th of April 1937). Pd: Sorry for bad english, I’m not a native speaker.
Also I may point out that even if Majorca became indeed a military base for italian troops (specially it’s airforcre) during the war, the political administration allways resided within the Spanish rebel military government, the change in color may seem like the italians occupied the island on their own and not to aid Franco (the foreign support or intervention can be showed in the legend).
on a lot of occasions, yes, but not entirely, there were fronts where towns are being contested and municipal borders no longer mattered in those circumstances
If Aside from the provinces, the video also remarked the borders of the regions that existed at the time (such as Old Castille for example) it would be unimprovable.
Gijón empezó siendo nacional, luego dejó de serlo porque las tropas nacionales de Gijón se replegaron a Oviedo que era la otra ciudad asturiana que ya habían liberado
Very good video, I agree with almost everything that has been put in the comments. My congratulations. However, the map and the name of the cities are after 1978. If in the future you make an improvement to this video, I suggest you add more details such as: number of troops or events (such as trading with the gold of the Bank of Spain, financing of both sides, both with credit, as well as with materials and resources.) It would be a very complete video, never before seen on the internet.
Very good video but if you wanted to put the anarchist control over Catalonia on the map you should have put the name of the official entity that grouped the Generalitat with the CNT-FAI which was the committee of anti-fascist militias
they lasted till ww2, forming the federation of guerrillas of galicia-leon (es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federaci%C3%B3n_de_Guerrillas_de_Le%C3%B3n-Galicia ), and there were a lot of other guerrilla groups that im too lazy to mention but they were everywhere around spain before, during and after ww2. these groups were only one of the factors that prevented franco from joining the axis. i have a friend that knows a lot more about these incidents (www.youtube.com/@pepitamapping)
I'm from Asturias, my grandma told me stories about these people, they called them "homes del monte" (mountain men) and she told me they'd steal money from the guarda civil and use it to pay for food, she told me that after the war they were very hungry and these mountain men shared food with her family and they let them sleep with the donkeys in exchange.
@@stephmod7434ill keep it confidential until my name starts appearing on wikipedia as everyone's favorite superstar, but its not history, history is a side quest to my general life, but perhaps the most colorful aspect and it gives me great joy
Could you make a video about the maquis and theyre uprisings? Its a episode of Spanish history that isnt often mentioned. By the way, you didnt include in your video the "Group of Guerrilla in the Levant and Aragon".es.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrupaci%C3%B3n_guerrillera_de_Levante_y_Arag%C3%B3n
i would say it's true last chance was to wait for the impending ww2, as was the plan of many republicans, to essentially connect the two conflicts and hope that the allies will land their forces in spain to open up a new front
Te ha faltado añadir el intento de desembarco republicano en la isla de Mallorca, ocuparon una pequeña parte de la isla hasta que reconocieron el fracaso y se retiraron
@@Jabiyt_90 No estoy a favor de la falange, pero no voy a recriminarte como hacen los WOKE, soy republicano por motivos de avanzar y que sea posible una unión Ibérica o Iberoamericana, odio cualquier partido de los que tienen el podio (PSOE, PP, VOX, Sumar y Podemos) todos son mentirosos, y los de Podemos los que más, las ideologías solo sirven para polarizar y enfrentar al pueblo, por eso yo no sigo ninguna política, sigo un concepto, concepto patriota, que patriota no es el que saca la bandera del poyo sino el que se preocupa por su pueblo, y estoy harto de la izquierda que desmorona la preciosa historia española, que vergüenza insultar a los antepasados que lucharon porque está mala gente viva y les insulte, quiero líderes, no políticos, Bukele es un líder, que además tiene un proyecto nacional, de lo que carece la política corrupta española.
@Nacionalista1939 No digo que no se hicieran cosas buenas bajo su mandato, más aún teniendo en cuenta la duración de este. Pero que también hubo muchas cosas malas, empezando porque su régimen se levantó sobre decenas de miles de muertos. Muchos de los que hoy llaman dictador a Pedro Sánchez, aplauden a Franco. En qué quedamos ¿tener un dictador es bueno o malo?
There was no Republican front, but Socialist. The Republic had already been established and well accepted by all Spaniards (save the Carlists oc, but they are the weirdos).
No, nationalists were against the republic. Only a minority (both from the left and right) really wanted a republic. It was the clash between the clerical fascism and the far-left (both communists and anarchists).
@@dieletztekavallerie395 Anycase you are pointing out the was no actual Republican front. However, during the war Franco did sign his documents "For the Republic". The decision of imposing a dictatorship was taken thereafter.
@@quentandilMore or less the most relevant leaders of the national/rebel side were neutral or republicans if we speak about the goverments form except the carlists. The FEJONS weren't monarchist but neather republicans they want to have a system based on the vertical syndicate. The CEDA is confising because they mix republicans and monarchists. A big percentage of the army before the coup was more republican than monarchist, etc. And, yes, part of the coup starts with part of then shouting "Viva la Republica" and using the three color flag before the unification
No tiene sentido que en el bando republicano se representen tantos bandos fragmebtados que controlan territorios, pues todos estavan bajo el control del gobierno de la republica, con la excepción de el país basco que habia recibido cierta autonomia, pero seguia siendo parte de la republica, y cataluña-aragón que estava bajo el control de las milicias de la CNT-FAI, pero de todas formas existia el gobierno de la generalitat, que al mismo tiempo tenia cierta autonomia también. Simplemente decir que no creo que esté bien representado así el bando republicano con lo de valencia, malaga, madrid, asturias, etc... 👎
@@Marcosespartano El control no era del gobierno de la república. Belarmino Tomás declaro la soberanía del consejo y formó su propio gobierno. No es que se separaran completamente claro, pero formaron su propio gobierno a isntancias del de la república.
Tanto el gobierno de la Generalitat, como el de País Vasco, CRDA, Asturias y demás, ejercieron su propia política de defensa, incluso teniendo sus propios ejércitos que no cumplían las órdenes del Gobierno Central, o las cumplían a su manera. Ocuparon oportunamente un vacío de poder. Si bien tampoco se puede decir que fueran plenamente independientes, claro.
![YoungBoy Never Broke Again - Sneaking [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1ILUps2zDFU/mqdefault.jpg)
God fricking dammit its low quality rendering again
Stay tuned if you want to help me get funds for a new computer!
Clarifications: I gave different colors to the anarchist councils despite being loosely associated with the republican government because they were highly autonomous, and the republican government did not have effective control over those areas until it reached a certain point. However, in the textbox they are underneath the republican faction to indicate a somewhat de jure subservient relationship between the anarchist/leftist councils and the central government, but I gave them different colors because they were special in their own regard.
Regarding the extent of control of the CNT-FAI in Catalonia, from what I've read so far, it appeared that they were the dominant force. There was collaboration with the central government through the Generalitat, as well as cooperation with the UGT, but they were the undisputed force in Catalonia and controlled almost every aspect of people's lives in the region. So, to make everything less complicated, I put them under the republican government but with a separate color. They "joined" the government as a way to avoid antagonizing the central government while still making their own decisions.
For the Interprovincial Council of Santander, Palencia and Burgos (ICSPB in the video), I decided to put it in a lighter purple because out of all these councils this council stood out for being the least radical out of all the councils I've read.
@@DeliriumMaps how much does a video take you on average?
@@AliAbedalrazek._. a month
@@DeliriumMaps I've read your sources and saw that you read an incredible amount of sources, and wrote so much notes. If you mind me asking, how do you manage to do all that in just a month?
ive got no idea either
it doesnt help the fact that i am in university
actually insane how every time you post a new front it gets crazier you are the best mapper out there
Both of you make good maps
I like how the mapping is improving, a new look at conflicts shown many times reveals the warring sides more widely
what happened in the old days were a competitive and academic disaster. these damages to the public perception of history need to be fixed otherwise we will make exaggerations and simplifications of everything that we will distort history, i call jake mapping as joke mapping because of what he did to philippine history and it was a very disgraceful sight and it got personal, i almost had a stroke watching how he mutilated philippine history
Dude schooled everyone else.
Franco or Delirium?
Two of my great-grandfathers and one grandfather fought in that war. Only the latter came back home, the other two "disappeared", so we don't know the story.
My grandfather became a general, and was ordered to cover the retreat of the republican army from Aragon and then Catalonia. He was eventually captured after defending a hill for days. He was sent to a prison camp and then to jail. Years after the war ended he was freed, his home was destroyed during the bombings so he rented a room, my grandmother was the one who rented it and they ended up marrying.
He was routinely visited for years by the authorities to check if he was doing something suspicious. He died just days after the dictatorship ended.
This quality content is completely unmatched in the mapping community. Crazy how you make maps this detailed.
As a Spanish person, this is the best video about our civil war I've ever seen. Good job!
>Repúblicano
@@xaropy ósea español, como el ha dicho.
Yo tmb diría que es el mejor mapa que he visto de la guerra, esta muy detallado.
@@Miguel-jr3gb communist republicans can't even be considered human beings, imagine Spaniards?
One of the best mapping videos I have ever seen. Thank you for your work.
Subscribed.
great video by the leading mapper of the mapping community!!!
Bro finally uploaded again salamat sa dios 🙏 (love your improvements in animation and wikipedia maps keep going!)
That's incredible mapping! You're really underrated!
brilliant work really
this deserves a million views
HEY LETS GOOO! This desperately needed an update. For a while, there was no sufficient video on it.
bro this is undereated so good job
Wow this is the best video I have ever seen on this topic!👍👍
After such a masterpiece is now clear that you are in the Mapping Olympus
Good work as always Kana ❤️
I like how this one shows all the factions during the war.
Dude you're way too underrated you should have 100k+ subs atlest
Spectacular quality
No sabía que podías escribir en español, bien hecho Kana 🐱
Quality work👍
I'm reading a book about the Spanish civil war so this is really interesting, well done
Well done, I liked!
Next time could you do Italian civil war? (1943-1945)
Anyways did subscribed from some time ago to this channel
ill have to see
Brilliant video!
Great video and research. Only one question about the basque country. Why did you mark Zarautz on the map but not Donostia/San Sebastián,the capital of the Guipuzkoa province?
I find remarcable that you have put the excerpt of the francoist anthem lining up more or less with the Ebro battle, I don't know if it was intentional.
Great work!
❤💛💜
ur right i shouldve put san sebastian 🤦♂️
@@DeliriumMapsno worries, it is very minor, and the work is outstanding
Very good video as always
I must congratulate you for the research and effort you’ve putted on that work, wich indeed must be recognised because that type of videos are not easy to make, you have added various important focuses of the war, like the Leon-Asturias guerrilla insurgency, and have clearly showed the progression on the takeover of Extremadura and portrayed the “Casado coup” (wich despite being crucial to understand the definitive surrender of the Spanish Republic is not showed on most of the videos portraying the Spanish Civil war). With that said, and because I have deeply studied this conflict, I must also point out some flaws in the portrayal of the situation made in this video: The most important one I think, is that the CNT-FAI, despite having a great influence and controling a lot of local Anti-fascist Militia Comitees, they did definitely not control all Catalonia, the region was administered from the beginning to the end of the war by the autonomous government of the “Generalitat de Catalunya” that was an integral part of the Spanish Republic, and despite the CNT acting on his own authority on many local comitees and having autonomy as an organitzation, they did not rebel against this government until May 1937, and the insurrection was mainly in the city of Barcelona, in the rest of Catalonia some local comitees (specially those controlled by the CNT-FAI itself or by the anti-stalinist marxist organitzation POUM) supported the insurrection, but most of them sided with the republican government. On the other hand, most regional comitees like the Madrid Defence Junta or the Valencia Executive Comitee were not independent from the republican government in any way, they were organisms within the Republican government aparatus created to better coordinate the war effort and the supression of those who were supportive of the military coup and the rebel faction, the same can be said of the inter-provincial council of Asturias and León until the 24th August 1937, when it declared it’s full sovereignty when their communications with the central government were cutted by the fascist forces (in that case showing the council as independent since its comformation avoided that to be properly showed). Regarding the Basque Government, it acted as an administrative autonomy just like the Generalitat government in Catalonia did, and was a part of the Spanish Republic as well. The Regional Defence Council of Aragon acted the facto as a separate entity, so in that case I think that the different color may be justified, but not in the other cases. To correct that without deminishing the amount of information that you represent, I think that the best option would be to represent the regional comitees with a light-purple tone, and if you want to represent the May 1937 clashes between the CNT-FAI and the republican government you can highlight Barcelona (also Madrid can be highlighted as the battle for Madrid lasted for most of the war). (As an idea, It would have also been interesting to portray the short-lived anti-Franco falangist uprising in Salamanca that ocurred between the 16th and 17th of April 1937).
Pd: Sorry for bad english, I’m not a native speaker.
Also I may point out that even if Majorca became indeed a military base for italian troops (specially it’s airforcre) during the war, the political administration allways resided within the Spanish rebel military government, the change in color may seem like the italians occupied the island on their own and not to aid Franco (the foreign support or intervention can be showed in the legend).
interesting take. i certainly could have made improvements on some aspects, thanks for your insights
Just perfect ! But I have a question to have the borders as detailed as that, did you use the municipal borders ?
on a lot of occasions, yes, but not entirely, there were fronts where towns are being contested and municipal borders no longer mattered in those circumstances
This level of editing is insane! I can see the exact day when my hometown was occupied by the NDJ! Awesome.
So, now we can think that memes about 'Modern Civil wars' are ivalid cuz they are always have been with too many sides
It's very good, I like reading about that war, it was like WW2 Prelude
If Aside from the provinces, the video also remarked the borders of the regions that existed at the time (such as Old Castille for example) it would be unimprovable.
And also: I officially subscribe
Eso no brindaría nada especial, las provincias eran las mismas que las actuales, aunque las regiones no lo fuesen
Great work 👏
damn , is incredibly detailed !
Gijón empezó siendo nacional, luego dejó de serlo porque las tropas nacionales de Gijón se replegaron a Oviedo que era la otra ciudad asturiana que ya habían liberado
How long did the communists last in the north of Spain after the war?
In some areas until the 1960s
they weren't exclusively communist, just antifascist
They weren't communist.
The level of detail here is insand
It just happened so fast at the beginning bro I had barely any time to react
Good video
Incredible mapping
so hoi4 depiction was accurate afterall
Very good video, I agree with almost everything that has been put in the comments. My congratulations. However, the map and the name of the cities are after 1978. If in the future you make an improvement to this video, I suggest you add more details such as: number of troops or events (such as trading with the gold of the Bank of Spain, financing of both sides, both with credit, as well as with materials and resources.)
It would be a very complete video, never before seen on the internet.
thank you for your feedback andcompliments. greatly appreciated. i plan to remake my old videos whenever practical
What if the Malaga Public Health Committee unified Spain?
¡Free healthcare for everyone! :D
very good maps
and kana too
love you
thanks
fall of purple
thank you for the much needed summary
muy detallado 10/10
impressive!
Very good video but if you wanted to put the anarchist control over Catalonia on the map you should have put the name of the official entity that grouped the Generalitat with the CNT-FAI which was the committee of anti-fascist militias
Certified GNS classic
Babe wake up Delirium maps posted
And what became of these Republican resistance in the holdouts around the regions of Galicia and Asturia-Leon?
they lasted till ww2, forming the federation of guerrillas of galicia-leon (es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federaci%C3%B3n_de_Guerrillas_de_Le%C3%B3n-Galicia ), and there were a lot of other guerrilla groups that im too lazy to mention but they were everywhere around spain before, during and after ww2. these groups were only one of the factors that prevented franco from joining the axis. i have a friend that knows a lot more about these incidents (www.youtube.com/@pepitamapping)
@@DeliriumMaps Kewl!
I'm from Asturias, my grandma told me stories about these people, they called them "homes del monte" (mountain men) and she told me they'd steal money from the guarda civil and use it to pay for food, she told me that after the war they were very hungry and these mountain men shared food with her family and they let them sleep with the donkeys in exchange.
I never knew Italy seized one of the Balaeric Island before
Can you make the Greek civil war? There arent any good videos about it...
ill have to see, i want to do every single thing but the darn university doesnt allow me to flap my butterfly wings out of the room!
@@DeliriumMaps what are you studying? History?
@@stephmod7434ill keep it confidential until my name starts appearing on wikipedia as everyone's favorite superstar, but its not history, history is a side quest to my general life, but perhaps the most colorful aspect and it gives me great joy
@@DeliriumMaps what then? Economics? Mechanism?
@@stephmod7434Most determined commenter
italy on mayorca is just false lol, and the maquis were mainly on aragon, catalonia and that zones not on leon and galicia (maybe a few)
Why did Italy occupy that one island?
roman empire larp (also as a base against france)
Maquis continued until 1950 decade.
Could you make a video about the maquis and theyre uprisings? Its a episode of Spanish history that isnt often mentioned.
By the way, you didnt include in your video the "Group of Guerrilla in the Levant and Aragon".es.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrupaci%C3%B3n_guerrillera_de_Levante_y_Arag%C3%B3n
🟥🟨🟪
This war started on my birthday😬
imagine celebrating ur birthday meanwhile all these people died! how dare you!
Who up spanishing they civil war
After Ebro, the republic was done for
i would say it's true last chance was to wait for the impending ww2, as was the plan of many republicans, to essentially connect the two conflicts and hope that the allies will land their forces in spain to open up a new front
Te ha faltado añadir el intento de desembarco republicano en la isla de Mallorca, ocuparon una pequeña parte de la isla hasta que reconocieron el fracaso y se retiraron
no i didnt my friend, its just too small but its there, try looking again
GLORIA ETERNA AL CAUDILLO DE ESPAÑA.
YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Arriba Espanha!
i love you
i love you too baby
These is what I was waiting for!!
🇪🇦❤️🔥 BTW, I'm republican
Nice, he improved a lot in mapping
Btw im Falangist❤
@@Jabiyt_90
No estoy a favor de la falange, pero no voy a recriminarte como hacen los WOKE, soy republicano por motivos de avanzar y que sea posible una unión Ibérica o Iberoamericana, odio cualquier partido de los que tienen el podio (PSOE, PP, VOX, Sumar y Podemos) todos son mentirosos, y los de Podemos los que más, las ideologías solo sirven para polarizar y enfrentar al pueblo, por eso yo no sigo ninguna política, sigo un concepto, concepto patriota, que patriota no es el que saca la bandera del poyo sino el que se preocupa por su pueblo, y estoy harto de la izquierda que desmorona la preciosa historia española, que vergüenza insultar a los antepasados que lucharon porque está mala gente viva y les insulte, quiero líderes, no políticos, Bukele es un líder, que además tiene un proyecto nacional, de lo que carece la política corrupta española.
@@Jabiyt_90 murderer
@@s3m1f64 tf, no! What do you mean ??wtf
@@Jabiyt_90 🟥🟨🟪
Divide et impera
Pro-Franco Fifth Columnist?
like pro-franco agents who defected
Que grande Francisco Franco
En realidad era muy bajito.
@Nacionalista1939 Sí, y nos salvó de una guerra civil.
@Nacionalista1939 No digo que no se hicieran cosas buenas bajo su mandato, más aún teniendo en cuenta la duración de este. Pero que también hubo muchas cosas malas, empezando porque su régimen se levantó sobre decenas de miles de muertos. Muchos de los que hoy llaman dictador a Pedro Sánchez, aplauden a Franco. En qué quedamos ¿tener un dictador es bueno o malo?
🟥🟨🟪🚩✊
There was no Republican front, but Socialist. The Republic had already been established and well accepted by all Spaniards (save the Carlists oc, but they are the weirdos).
No, nationalists were against the republic. Only a minority (both from the left and right) really wanted a republic. It was the clash between the clerical fascism and the far-left (both communists and anarchists).
@@dieletztekavallerie395 Anycase you are pointing out the was no actual Republican front. However, during the war Franco did sign his documents "For the Republic". The decision of imposing a dictatorship was taken thereafter.
@@quentandilMore or less the most relevant leaders of the national/rebel side were neutral or republicans if we speak about the goverments form except the carlists.
The FEJONS weren't monarchist but neather republicans they want to have a system based on the vertical syndicate.
The CEDA is confising because they mix republicans and monarchists.
A big percentage of the army before the coup was more republican than monarchist, etc.
And, yes, part of the coup starts with part of then shouting "Viva la Republica" and using the three color flag before the unification
No tiene sentido que en el bando republicano se representen tantos bandos fragmebtados que controlan territorios, pues todos estavan bajo el control del gobierno de la republica, con la excepción de el país basco que habia recibido cierta autonomia, pero seguia siendo parte de la republica, y cataluña-aragón que estava bajo el control de las milicias de la CNT-FAI, pero de todas formas existia el gobierno de la generalitat, que al mismo tiempo tenia cierta autonomia también.
Simplemente decir que no creo que esté bien representado así el bando republicano con lo de valencia, malaga, madrid, asturias, etc...
👎
El consejo de Asturias y León existió (es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consejo_Soberano_de_Asturias_y_Le%C3%B3n ) tal como muestra el mapa
@@fueyo2229Si, pero el control era del gobierno de la republica. No como podia pasar por ejemplo en cataluña, que si esta justificado.
@@Marcosespartano El control no era del gobierno de la república. Belarmino Tomás declaro la soberanía del consejo y formó su propio gobierno. No es que se separaran completamente claro, pero formaron su propio gobierno a isntancias del de la república.
Tanto el gobierno de la Generalitat, como el de País Vasco, CRDA, Asturias y demás, ejercieron su propia política de defensa, incluso teniendo sus propios ejércitos que no cumplían las órdenes del Gobierno Central, o las cumplían a su manera. Ocuparon oportunamente un vacío de poder. Si bien tampoco se puede decir que fueran plenamente independientes, claro.
As a Spaniard I can assure you that this is quite accurate. 🇪🇦⚔️🟥🟨🟪👀😢😢😢
El General Francisco Franco salvo a España del Comunismo. Gracias eternas
🇪🇦✝️