सर मेरे कई मित्र है जिनका धर्म तो मूसलमान है लेकिन वे भी विवाह करते समय अपनी ही जाति मे विवाह करते है ! तो इसका सीधा अर्थ यही निकलता है कि जाति व्यवस्था तो मूसलमानो मे भी व्यप्त है!
@@motorolaandroidone412 मूसलमान मूसलमान आपस मे भी तो शादियाँ नही करते वे भी तो जाति मे ही करते है मतलब अन्सारी केवल अन्सारी से ही शादी करता है, कुरेशी केवल कुरेशी से आदि
अगर किसी व्यक्ति ने अपना धर्म बदल लिया तो इससे उसका इतिहास,उसकी बायोग्रफी या उसका आर्थिक पिछड़ापन या उसके पूर्वज तो नहीं बदल जाते ! तो फिर धर्म के आधार पर दलित ईसाईयो और दलित मूसलमानो को आरक्षण से बहार क्यो रखा है ?
@@jaibheem9940 Islam mein cast k aadhar par reservation nahin hota hai, read Qur'an with translation jis language mein aapko suvidha ho aur dialogue na maaro, yahan reservation ki baat ho Rahi hai samjhe, uspar mene bola aur fact k saath age bhi boloonga.
सर अगर धर्म के आधार पर आरक्षण देना गैर संवैधानिक है तो धर्म पर आधारित नागरिकता कानून CAA कैसे संवैधानिक हो सकता है ? क्रपया इस पर भी एक वीडीयो बनाईए 🙏🙏🙏🙏
आरक्षण और नागरिकता दोनों अलग अलग चीज हैं, इनको तुलना नहीं करना चाहिए. आरक्षण देना खुद ही अलग अलग परिस्थितियों में सवैधानिक व असंवैधानिक होता है, उसी तरह नागरिकता देना भी एक बहुत समग्र विषय है... हर देश की अपनी नागरिकता नीति होती है, इसमें कुछ सही और गलत नहीं होता. जो विदेशी हैं, उनका पक्ष एवं अधिकार होता है नागरिकता नीति पर.. इससे देश के नागरिकों को समस्या नहीं होनी चाहिए.
@@AnupamEnosh आप बात समझे नही या समझना नही चाहते ? बात है धर्माधारित निर्योग्यता निर्धारण की.....मतलब यदी संविधान धर्म के आधार पर किसी को कुछ भी विशेषाधिकार (आरक्षणआदि) देने से निषिद्ध करता है तो वही संविधान केवल धर्म के आधार पर नागरिकता को सहा कैसे ठहरा सकता है?.... मतलब सही है तो दोनो सही है और अगर गलत है तो दोनो गलत है!
@@jaibheem9940 किसी विशिष्ट देश की नागरिकता की परिभाषा एवं नियम कायदे विदेशी के लिए अलग होते हैं, एवं उसमें जन्मे व्यक्ति के लिए अलग। और यह उस देश की नीतियों पर निर्भर करता है। इसे धर्म या किसी अलग पैमाने पर देना पूरी तरह से उस देश की नीतियों पर निर्भर करता है। उदाहरण के तौर पर अगर चावल की उपज हद से ज्यादा हो जाए कि रखने की जगह न हो, तो चावल अगर 30₹ किलो पर देश में बिक रहा है, और देश की सरकार उसे विदेशों में 25₹ पर बेच रही है स्टॉक खत्म करने के लिए, तो यह सीधे सीधे नीति निर्धारण पर आधारित हैं। इसका सही और गलत होने से कोई लेना देना नहीं है। नागरिकता सिर्फ विशिष्ट परिस्थिति में ही अधिकार है, वरन वह भी एक वरदान ही है जो भेंट में दी जाती है।
हिन्दू धर्म को गाली देकर जो लोग इस धर्म छोड़ गए, जो यह कहते हैं हिन्दू धर्म में जात पात है, इसलिए इसे छोड़ रहे हैं, फिर उन्हें कैसे हिन्दू धर्म के जात पात का लाभ मिलना चाहिए। यदि मुस्लिम के ऊची जाति के स्रोत का पता नहीं है तो हिन्दू के ऊची जाति के स्रोत के पुख्ता सबूत कैसे है?
Ideally both must be stopped. What was the practice before loud speaker as it creates more disturbance to the society. After all my friends ends at the nose of the other person
Its shameless statement by u. From, MOSQUE, WE MUSLIM OBEY ONLY AZAAN. NO GAYATHRI MANTHRA FROM IT. WE BELIEVE ONLY ONE GOD ONLY ALLAH. MAI LAATH MARTA HU AISI BEKAR RESERVATION KO JO DHARAM VIRODH JANE PAR ATI H.
Sir thank you aap ne bahut Achche se samjhaya... Or sbka right sbko mila chahiye.... Reservation cast ke base pr hai constitution me so Isse muslims or Christian jo Keval dharm k aadhar pr reservation se Bahar h unko samil kiya jaye....
It would go against the sacred preachings of Islam and Christianity to grant official recognition in India to the internal ideological, sectarian, racial or other such differences within those religious communities. The Constitution and different laws treat each of these religions as minorities and grants myriad special protections. If these communities wish to implement any affirmative action program for any of their sections, they have a constitutional right do so in their minority educational institutions, for which they should be encouraged. Incidentally, many occupation/avocation based groups of minorities already fall under the OBC lists.
गुरु जी पर छुआछूत भारत के obc के साथ तो हुआ नही फिर उनको obc आरक्षण क्यों । लेकिन obc में जो ज़मींदार जातियां हैं उनका भी एक बहोत बड़ा हाथ रहा है दलितों और आदिवासियों के साथ छुआछूत करने में । केवल जनसंख्या के आधार पर obc आरक्षण नही होना चाहिए।
@@jaibheem9940 to cast par kyun baat ho Rahi hai aur yeh minority ko bhi khatam kar dena chahiye, hum sab Indian hai, bas, minority k aadhar par bhi reservation nahin hona chahiye.
FAYZAN SAB AAP KI YEH TAQRIR BAHUT ACHCHI HAI AOR 100'/. SAHI HAI IS PAR IS MAOZU PAR MUSALSAL BAHAS JARI RAKHEN, I SE KARE KHAYR SAJHEN , BANARAS , U .P .
Forget it. No one dare to do it. SC Reservation is only rights of hindu SC. SC Reservation is given becz of caste. And according to muslim caste doesn't exist in their religion. So no question of giving SC reservation. And about discrimination. What about article 29 and 30? If they want SC reservation they have to revert or forget it.
Dear sir First I make clear that I m not against the demand of Muslim and Christian.But I have to say that Many people think that there is discrimination with the people otherthan Hindu,shikh and Buddhist because of condition in Constitution scheduled caste order 1950 But sir its not true.If we read the constitutional assembly debates, we will find that Minority committee had unanimously decided to give facilities to Sc and St only.Muslim and chrischhan leader of construction assembly were agreed and they denied reservation to their community.thererfore Muslim and christian are not considered as they himself declare that they have already taken reservation in British regime ,now they will be with mainstream Sir ,pl go through the constitunal debate on Minority committee . Rest I always appreciate your vedio.Great! Work sir Jaybhim Anil Vaidya Ex Judge Nashik
India 🇮🇳 is true secular country and equal rights to every religion why Dalit Muslims and Dalit Cristian not eligible for schedule cast reservations needs to amended article 341 and provide schedule cast reservations to Dalit Muslims and Dalit Cristian jai hind
No it is not advisable to give SC status to Muslims as Islam has no cast system and concept of untouchability. All Muslims are equal. Once a person accepts Islam, he becomes Muslim. All Muslims have to treat him as their brother or sister. There is no discrimination against such converted person in Islam. This is the beauty of Islam. Muslim scholars must object such act of Govt to give SC status to Muslims.
If they are giving reservation according to financially situation. That is Much better then casteism. So many people have upper caste but they are no financially strong.
Salute for the last line sir.... Moreover as a Muslim, I feel SC ST has more to do with just reservation and benefits...., They are an identity... They are a particular race with their own unique characteristics who only with the fear of discrimination are getting converted.... Just like Brahmins are unique, Muslims are unique so should be SC and ST..... They are the TRUE owners of this land.... And it's sad and unjust...that they're forced to choose either identify or respect... They deserve both....
Heartfelt thoughts from a Muslim from tamilnadu: There should be no caste among muslims like ST,SC,BC,OC shiek peer Ajlaf Asraf rowther lebbai mapillas etc nonsense! nonsense! 🤦♂️🤦♂️🙄 shame on my Muslim community😭 for discrimination.Some will say these are simply titles.If titles causes discrimination then they should be thrown away. "Muslim" is itself an identity.The oppression that we undergo today in India is a punishment from Allah for failing to fulfill the purpose of Islam.Nabi Muhammad (saw) was pelted with stones in Thaif city for preaching equality.Rich muslims should uplift the poor muslims that's why we have "Zakath".We can also uplift the poor non muslims thats why we have "sadaqah".For this we should have "Baithul maal" to manage the affairs of Muslims.If we had did this and shown True Islam in action today the majority people would have been with us.If we do that why we need reservations and all the dramas?. Now we are in a ugly situation where the BJP is taking about "Pasmanda muslims"🤦♂️.If someone comes to Islam he is just a Muslim .We should turn to Allah so he eases the country's situation.
Gharwapsi karlenge tab koi na koi tribe, caste mie waapsi hogi. Tab mil sakta hai. Boudh, Jain, Sikh, iss mitti se nikle majahab hai. Sanatan dharm ke ansh hai. Christians Muslims Farsi Afgani etc stc sab sharnarthi hai, migrated hai. Permenent residency aur citizen ship ho sakta hai. Jaisey... New Zealand mie Mouries aur Australia ke Aboriginals ki tarah lekin citizenship sab ko hai. Quota sirf moolnivasio ka hi hai.
@@motorolaandroidone412 Registan ke soil aur haryali se bhara soil ka fark jaanta hai? Dharm universal hai. majahab ek region ek tapke ke logo ke liye hota hai jismie convert hona padta hai. Ya uss majahab mie paida hona padta hai. Arya aur Asur ka fark pata hai? Paapi Adam jaat ke bacche aur Arya Eishwar ke baccho ka fark pata hai. Dharm aur majahab mie jo fark hota hai vahi fark soil, culture, heritage, region religion, language, food, way of life mie fark hota hai.
Religion ka moolwasi se kiya matlab. Reservation past ke discrimation ke basis pe milta hai., present condition pe nahin. Independent India me Constitution sub ko brabar manta hai. Ye flawed logic hai aapka. Mundir Masjid type argument hai
जहां औषधि तभी काम करे जब खून हो साफ़, क्यों केवल बालों मे हैं क्रीम लगाते समस्त राष्ट्रबीमारी का करना है जब उपचार दवा गहराई मे जा जड़ तक क्यों न पहुंचाते आचार्य, शिक्षक, पुजारी, योगी हो मौलवी या फिर कोई पंडित, प्रोफ़ेसर हो कि पादरी उल्लू ही हमे बचपन से हैं मिल कर बनाते और हम न्यापालिका के हैं चक्कर लगाते
Abdul kalam azhad ne musalmano main jo dalit hye unko SC reservetion dene ka virodh kiya constituent assembly main to isliye dalit muslim ya Christin ko sc reservetion nahi. Islam aur Christianity main jativad hi nahi hye koi bhi dalit musalman mulla,molvoli ya fir koi bhi bada majahabi audhe par ja sakta hye to uske saath bhedbhav hi khatm ho jata hyd to dalit muslim ya Christin ko reservetion ki jarurat nahi. Christin dalit bhi koi bhi bade pad par baith sakta hye Church main isliye dalit Christin ke saath bhi bhed bhav khatm to SC reservetion ki jarurat nahi Jab ki Hindu main dalit ke saath bhedbhav hota hye aur usko mandir main pravesh ki ya Hindu dharm ka sabse bada dharmik pas Shankarachary banne ki ijajat nahi hye isliye Hindu main daliton ke saath lagatar bhedbhav hota hye isliye Dalit ko Hindu hone par hi SC reservetion milta hye.
You're bro but it still exists among Muslims Untouchability nai baqi ounch neech sb Kuch exists 2ndly historically lower castes haven't benefited Tou sirf Hindu low cast q Maza lai Azad was a showboy of Congress stupid idiot
Some thing is hidden in this policy It' will be Alarming for danger zone Finally they will said Ghar wapsi Calculative game need to understand What's the actual plan behind this policy
Telangana me agar imam ke piche namaz na padhne ka faisla zaat ke based per tha to iski tahqeeq honi chahiye, hamare yahan sabzifarosh imaam aur qari rah chuke hain. Kisi KO koi problem nahi Hui. Aap KO Jo bataya gaya usper tahqeeq kijye.
Sir agar ya baat ha to sex ka adhar pr jo muslim woman ka satth discrimination ho rha ha us pr bhi baat kro ji jo 1 mard ko 4 shadi krna ki promision data ha or father ki property ma bhi muslim woman to equal right nhi milta. Or phir is pr bhi baat kra jo pura dash ma to educational instute ma to s.c obc reservation ha pr minority institutions ma nhi ha agar in ma bhi jaat paat ha to in instute s ma bhi s.c or obc reserveation ho is pr bhi apne rai degea tab to hma aap ka equality ka bhashan ka such pta chala ki aap kitna equility ka parkar ha ya vha pr kuter muslim ho jata ho
Why ? the bestest , greatest, last and final religion of peace claims that it has this wonderful effect of removing all human discrimination and binding all its followers under the holy universal blanket of ummah. Why would one so elevated by this bestest religion be discriminated against? If a dalit muslim claims he converted due to discrimination he faced as a Hindu and still faces discrimination as a Muslim isnt it proof that the best religion is no better than religion of old pagan idolaters and disbelievers? All these people want is to get benefits of reservation and still run their conversion shops. There is no way reservation would be given to converts. This would only incentivise conversion factories.
But that's exactly what Indian politicians, including Modi, are desperately trying to do. Provide incentives to Dalits to convert to C'ianity and I slam
@@mlg1279 I don't think so. Please listen to Abhijit Mitra Iyer's episode on Hinduism and a lot of your doubts will clear. Making a committee is a sure way and readymade aswer for not acting on something for years. Reservation is an incentive for Dalits to not join homogenizing cults and remain under the fold of Hinduism. There's a lot out there that we regular people don't understand and there's a lot propaganda artists like FM are actively trying to push. This is all about monopoly and control. The second Muslim majority or enough numbers to effect substantial changes are achieved, FM's love for constitution will disappear under the holy word of the final messanger. All this speak of constitution and its values is to fool and trap gullible idiots, especially upper caste Hindus. Reality and actual agenda are faaar more sinister and insidious.
अगर दलित क्रिस्चियन और दलित मुस्लिम को अगर अनुसूचित जाति में शामिल कर आरक्षण दिया जाएगा , तो क्या आपको नहीं लगता कि आरक्षण की जो प्रतिशत है उसको फिर जनसंख्या के अनुसार बढ़ाना चाहिए आपका इसमे क्या विचार है ? क्या सरकार ऐसा कर सकेगी ?
अगर हिन्दुओ की तरह मुसलिमो धर्म मे जाति आधार पर स्पृश्यता पाई जाती है तो ही उन्हे भी अनुसूचित जाति मे श्रेणी मे डाला जा सकता आखिर मुसलिम धर्म मे भी जाति आधार पर छुआछूत है लगता है यह केन्द्र सरकार कमिटी बनाकर साबित करेगी ।
O you who have believed, do not take your fathers or your brothers as friends if they have preferred disbelief over belief. And whoever does so among you - then it is those who are the wrongdoers. Quran 9:23
achcha nehi sahab Ghar wapsi karne me subidha hoga isliye e sab kiya ja raha hai constitution me minority ke jo subidha hai ohi manle to thik se desh chalega
आज हमारा समाज हर तरह से पिछड़ा हुआ है हर एक फील्ड में पीछे है मेरी केंद्रों सरकार से और राज्य सरकार से गुजारिश है कि हमारे समाज को विकसित और विकास करने में हमारी मदद करें
Ashraf vakil saheb aapne mana to sahi ke muslmano main jatiwad hai . Ashraf unche jati ke log Khule Aam jatiwad ka samarthan karte hain ! Ashraf log islam ka istemal apne fhyede ke liye karte hain ?
Shadi byah me zaat paat sirf better compatibility ke wajah se dekhi jati hai, iska dharm se koi lena dena nahi hai, shadi me zaat, dharm, gora Kala, mota patla, ameer ghareeb, padha likha anpadh, naukri wala, dhande pani wala sab kuch dekhte hain.
sir.... in Telangana almost all the converted Christians are availing benefits of Scheduled Caste by grabbing their reservations and upon that these converted people are showing lots of discrimination and humiliation towards original SC s... .. pathetically it's happening since many years...
Good for those who r really need of this reservation benifit.. This is meant for all Religions.. But kya minorities mai nahi aatey yeh log.. Like sikhs & others..
Odish pe agar ek sc christian ban goya to unko jati v christian aur dharm v christian RI likh deta hei aur sc benefit zero, aur sab log unko wohi sc hi mante hei
Jay Bheem, Jay Meem slogan is nullified by this video, scheduled cast will oppose such step, bcaz they will not share their right with new comers, more then 50 % reservation is prohibited l.
The simplest way to a prosperous India is... to provide all economically weaker citizens of the country with the benefit of education and skill learning at all levels and that too at Government subsidised cost... not only at government but private institutions as well... and for this purpose sufficient quota should be allocated based on biannual economic survey of the locality within a radius of 20 kilometres for non boarding schools and 50 kilometres for boarding institutions whether public or private... 🙏
Bandhu... the first step to innovation is learning of skills... and to learn skills you need to be literate... it is as simple as that... kya samjhe ❓ nahin samjhe ❓ 🙏
@@aniltuli5860 Education will not automatically bring prosperity. Why do you think we have an army of unemployed engineers in India?? So, your "simplest way" is not going to make India prosperous. It will only produce more educated unemployed. Kya samjhe??
Ever given a thought to... exporting (deployment) of human resources ( skilled experts) to improve the economy❓... this is one easy way when our country is not able to attract much foreign investments due to the prevent mass scale corruption even after the Chief Manager trying since the last 7+ years... Kya samjhe ❓ Agar ab bhi nahin samjhe... tou samjho ge bhi nahin... Thanks... Tropic closed... no further explanation required from your side or need to given from this side... 🙏
where is the question of caste in abrahamic religion ; then probably they must called hindu - dalit christian / muslim. Further it defeats the whole belief system of the religion ;
Islam mein Economic backwardness, handicapped aur mahila k aadhar par reservation hota hai. Masjid mein mahilaon k liye alag jagah hoti hai, handicapped persons k liye kursiyan hoti hai.
@@maaz87 India ka Islam aur baaki Islam Alag hai. Are bhai duniyavi lalach mein apni akhirat na bigado, deen seekho, samjho aur Amal karo. Allah hidayat de ya Mita de.
Yes Dalit Muslims & Christians should have included in the Schedule Cast.
No, Islam mein koi cast nahin hoti, Qur'an ko pdhi samjho.
आज आपने चैनल बनाने का हक़ अदा कर दिया ये मुद्दा बहुत अहम था 👌
Shame for those Muslim who believe in caste system
Muslim should enter Islam fully not partcily
Maam it is not a cast system but taking benifits of reservation
Lolz Khatoon ap kis duniya mein rehti hein
Bilkul sir Muslims ko st SC ka benifit milna chahie
Itna aasan nai. Hai aur na BJP ke under to bilkul nai
सर मेरे कई मित्र है जिनका धर्म तो मूसलमान है लेकिन वे भी विवाह करते समय अपनी ही जाति मे विवाह करते है ! तो इसका सीधा अर्थ यही निकलता है कि जाति व्यवस्था तो मूसलमानो मे भी व्यप्त है!
Agar bhaar karenghe tho love jihad ka. Case thopenghe na
@@motorolaandroidone412 मूसलमान मूसलमान आपस मे भी तो शादियाँ नही करते वे भी तो जाति मे ही करते है मतलब अन्सारी केवल अन्सारी से ही शादी करता है, कुरेशी केवल कुरेशी से आदि
@@jaibheem9940 karta hai bhai but kuch insan ki wajah se ap sab ko mat lelo
Islam mein cast k aadhar par reservation nahin hota hai, read Qur'an with translation jis language mein aapko suvidha ho.
@@roshanara4800 चुप करो तुम अशराफ ही जिम्मेदार हो इन सब चीजों के लिए
अगर किसी व्यक्ति ने अपना धर्म बदल लिया तो इससे उसका इतिहास,उसकी बायोग्रफी या उसका आर्थिक पिछड़ापन या उसके पूर्वज तो नहीं बदल जाते ! तो फिर धर्म के आधार पर दलित ईसाईयो और दलित मूसलमानो को आरक्षण से बहार क्यो रखा है ?
Correct 👍😇 bola aap ne
Kya koi muslim Mandir mein jaakar sajda karega.
@@motorolaandroidone412 thanks
@@roshanara4800 तू पाँच टाईम नमाज पढ़ता है क्या किसी मूसलमान की मस्जिद मे ? जो तू उनको मन्दिर मे ले जाकर सजदा करवाना चाहता है?
@@jaibheem9940 Islam mein cast k aadhar par reservation nahin hota hai, read Qur'an with translation jis language mein aapko suvidha ho aur dialogue na maaro, yahan reservation ki baat ho Rahi hai samjhe, uspar mene bola aur fact k saath age bhi boloonga.
आज आपने अपना हक़ अदा किया ऐसे ही आवाज उठाइये पसमांदा मुसलमानो के लिए
Thank you sir
Thankyou. You are always clear and info rmative.
Yes of course!
Good initiative by this govt
Equality and equity ... is must.
Thanks you sir
Sir 2018 me questions kiye the aaj aap se milgaya.
Excellent sir
सर अगर धर्म के आधार पर आरक्षण देना गैर संवैधानिक है तो धर्म पर आधारित नागरिकता कानून CAA कैसे संवैधानिक हो सकता है ? क्रपया इस पर भी एक वीडीयो बनाईए 🙏🙏🙏🙏
CAA is based on religious minorities.
आरक्षण और नागरिकता दोनों अलग अलग चीज हैं, इनको तुलना नहीं करना चाहिए. आरक्षण देना खुद ही अलग अलग परिस्थितियों में सवैधानिक व असंवैधानिक होता है, उसी तरह नागरिकता देना भी एक बहुत समग्र विषय है... हर देश की अपनी नागरिकता नीति होती है, इसमें कुछ सही और गलत नहीं होता. जो विदेशी हैं, उनका पक्ष एवं अधिकार होता है नागरिकता नीति पर.. इससे देश के नागरिकों को समस्या नहीं होनी चाहिए.
@@AnupamEnosh आप बात समझे नही या समझना नही चाहते ? बात है धर्माधारित निर्योग्यता निर्धारण की.....मतलब यदी संविधान धर्म के आधार पर किसी को कुछ भी विशेषाधिकार (आरक्षणआदि) देने से निषिद्ध करता है तो वही संविधान केवल धर्म के आधार पर नागरिकता को सहा कैसे ठहरा सकता है?.... मतलब सही है तो दोनो सही है और अगर गलत है तो दोनो गलत है!
@@jaibheem9940 किसी विशिष्ट देश की नागरिकता की परिभाषा एवं नियम कायदे विदेशी के लिए अलग होते हैं, एवं उसमें जन्मे व्यक्ति के लिए अलग। और यह उस देश की नीतियों पर निर्भर करता है। इसे धर्म या किसी अलग पैमाने पर देना पूरी तरह से उस देश की नीतियों पर निर्भर करता है।
उदाहरण के तौर पर अगर चावल की उपज हद से ज्यादा हो जाए कि रखने की जगह न हो, तो चावल अगर 30₹ किलो पर देश में बिक रहा है,
और देश की सरकार उसे विदेशों में 25₹ पर बेच रही है स्टॉक खत्म करने के लिए, तो यह सीधे सीधे नीति निर्धारण पर आधारित हैं। इसका सही और गलत होने से कोई लेना देना नहीं है। नागरिकता सिर्फ विशिष्ट परिस्थिति में ही अधिकार है, वरन वह भी एक वरदान ही है जो भेंट में दी जाती है।
@@jaibheem9940 काश तेरा जन्म पाकिस्तान में होता तो तुम्हारे घर की महिलाओ को पहले हिन्दूस्थान भेजने की कोशिश करता
Shandar
हिन्दू धर्म को गाली देकर जो लोग इस धर्म छोड़ गए, जो यह कहते हैं हिन्दू धर्म में जात पात है, इसलिए इसे छोड़ रहे हैं, फिर उन्हें कैसे हिन्दू धर्म के जात पात का लाभ मिलना चाहिए। यदि मुस्लिम के ऊची जाति के स्रोत का पता नहीं है तो हिन्दू के ऊची जाति के स्रोत के पुख्ता सबूत कैसे है?
VERY GOOD VIDEO 🇮🇳🌹🇮🇳
one of best videos SIR
VERY CONCISE AND VERY informative 👍👍👍❤
Excellence sir
Thanks a lot sir for your informative vedioes
Nice reporting 👍
Save Democracy, jai hind jai bharat
By playing Azaan from Temple and Gayatri Mantra from Mosque ...we can create super strong nation on this planet.
Agreed sir majority of Hindu 🕉 accept this but Muslims ☪️ community accept this?
Anil is right, never heard ISHWAR-ALLAH tero naam ....from MOSQUE
Ideally both must be stopped. What was the practice before loud speaker as it creates more disturbance to the society. After all my friends ends at the nose of the other person
allah will become so angry if it is done
Its shameless statement by u. From, MOSQUE, WE MUSLIM OBEY ONLY AZAAN. NO GAYATHRI MANTHRA FROM IT. WE BELIEVE ONLY ONE GOD ONLY ALLAH. MAI LAATH MARTA HU AISI BEKAR RESERVATION KO JO DHARAM VIRODH JANE PAR ATI H.
I think this is right.
Very very good JayBhim BSP DELHI
Sir thank you aap ne bahut Achche se samjhaya... Or sbka right sbko mila chahiye.... Reservation cast ke base pr hai constitution me so Isse muslims or Christian jo Keval dharm k aadhar pr reservation se Bahar h unko samil kiya jaye....
Thanks sir,
Myself Shamsuddin shaikh, petioner in supreme Court.
🙏
These time discrimination among Muslims are only by socioeconomic basis.
But the SC/ST classification is NOT on socioeconomic criteria, it is solely based on their caste and tribal status.
Very nice mustafa sir
It would go against the sacred
preachings of Islam and Christianity to grant official recognition in India to the internal ideological, sectarian, racial or other such differences within those religious communities. The Constitution and different laws treat each of these religions as minorities and grants myriad special protections. If these communities wish to implement any affirmative action program for any of their sections, they have a constitutional right do so in their minority educational institutions, for which they should be encouraged. Incidentally, many occupation/avocation based groups of minorities already fall under the OBC lists.
Ek dam sahi kaha sir...g Aapne🙏
Jab sarkari dept. Hi nahi hongay to reservation ka labh kya or kaisay kis tara diya jawega
Allah Aap ko salamat rakhe Aameen
A Muslim how can be a dalit? When there is no casteism in Islam.
Sahi kaha bhai aapne, kya aapne Qur'an padha hai.
Lolz tum bewaqof ho ya bnyy ho
गुरु जी पर छुआछूत भारत के obc के साथ तो हुआ नही फिर उनको obc आरक्षण क्यों ।
लेकिन obc में जो ज़मींदार जातियां हैं उनका भी एक बहोत बड़ा हाथ रहा है दलितों और आदिवासियों के साथ छुआछूत करने में ।
केवल जनसंख्या के आधार पर obc आरक्षण नही होना चाहिए।
Sahi kaha bhai, Islam mein cast k aadhar par koi reservation nahin hai.
ओबीसी आरक्षण आर्थिक आधार पर दिया गया है जैसे आपका ईडब्लयूएस आरक्षण है ठीक वैसे ही
@@jaibheem9940 to cast par kyun baat ho Rahi hai aur yeh minority ko bhi khatam kar dena chahiye, hum sab Indian hai, bas, minority k aadhar par bhi reservation nahin hona chahiye.
@@roshanara4800 बिल्कुल माइनोरेटी स्टेटस समाप्त करना चाहिए और दलित मूसलमानो और दलित ईसाईयो को भी आरक्षण का लाभ मिलना चाहिए !
@@jaibheem9940Islam mein dalit nahin hota hai, Islam mein castism nahin hai. Economic backwardness, handicapped aur mahila k aadhar par reservation hona chahiye.
Schedule agar rakhna hai to dharm ya zaat ke bajaye income ke base pe rakha Jaye. Kiyon ke ameeri ghareebi zaat dharm biradri dekh kar nahi hoti.
यदि सब मुसलमान बराबर हैं, तो उसमें SC/ST कहाँ से आ गए। और अगर सब बराबर नहीं है तो मुसलमान बना क्यों? हद है।
FAYZAN SAB AAP KI YEH TAQRIR BAHUT ACHCHI HAI AOR 100'/. SAHI HAI IS PAR IS MAOZU PAR MUSALSAL BAHAS JARI RAKHEN, I SE KARE KHAYR SAJHEN ,
BANARAS , U .P .
Good ser
Forget it. No one dare to do it. SC Reservation is only rights of hindu SC. SC Reservation is given becz of caste. And according to muslim caste doesn't exist in their religion. So no question of giving SC reservation. And about discrimination. What about article 29 and 30? If they want SC reservation they have to revert or forget it.
Agreed
We are all equal.
जय अरजाल ।कब मिलेगा अरजालों को अनुसूचित जाति का दर्जा?
Please acha mic Istal kariye
Dear sir
First I make clear that
I m not against the demand of Muslim and Christian.But I have to say that
Many people think that there is discrimination with the people otherthan Hindu,shikh and Buddhist because of condition in Constitution scheduled caste order 1950 But sir its not true.If we read the constitutional assembly debates, we will find that Minority committee had unanimously decided to give facilities to Sc and St only.Muslim and chrischhan leader of construction assembly were agreed and they denied reservation to their community.thererfore Muslim and christian are not considered as they himself declare that they have already taken reservation in British regime ,now they will be with mainstream
Sir ,pl go through the constitunal debate on Minority committee .
Rest I always appreciate your vedio.Great! Work sir
Jaybhim
Anil Vaidya
Ex Judge Nashik
India 🇮🇳 is true secular country and equal rights to every religion why Dalit Muslims and Dalit Cristian not eligible for schedule cast reservations needs to amended article 341 and provide schedule cast reservations to Dalit Muslims and Dalit Cristian jai hind
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻👌👌👌👌👌
No it is not advisable to give SC status to Muslims as Islam has no cast system and concept of untouchability. All Muslims are equal. Once a person accepts Islam, he becomes Muslim. All Muslims have to treat him as their brother or sister. There is no discrimination against such converted person in Islam. This is the beauty of Islam. Muslim scholars must object such act of Govt to give SC status to Muslims.
Your intentions are not right. People like you do not want the backward poor Muslim classes to develop and become equal to you
The "beauty" of I slam is evident in the MPLB rules which bars pasminda Mu-slims from marrying so-called "upper caste" Mus-lims
Phir ap Syed apny ap ko ouncha and chosen q smjhty ho Apni larki ki shadi ghair Syed sai q nai krty
@@mlg1279 MPLB ?
@@maaz87 Muslim personal law board
If they are giving reservation according to financially situation.
That is Much better then casteism.
So many people have upper caste but they are no financially strong.
Valid point
Aawaz sahi nahinaa Rahi hai sir
Indian 80-90% muslims were then Dalits , Buddhists etc.
And these muslims are patriotic beyond doubt .
Salute for the last line sir....
Moreover as a Muslim, I feel SC ST has more to do with just reservation and benefits...., They are an identity... They are a particular race with their own unique characteristics who only with the fear of discrimination are getting converted.... Just like Brahmins are unique, Muslims are unique so should be SC and ST..... They are the TRUE owners of this land.... And it's sad and unjust...that they're forced to choose either identify or respect... They deserve both....
Agar sangbidhan k Diya hua facilities chahiye to sariya ka birodh karo..kisi ek ko follow Karo..agar sariya chahiye to sangbidhan vul jao chacha
Heartfelt thoughts from a Muslim from tamilnadu:
There should be no caste among muslims like ST,SC,BC,OC shiek peer Ajlaf Asraf rowther lebbai mapillas etc nonsense! nonsense! 🤦♂️🤦♂️🙄 shame on my Muslim community😭 for discrimination.Some will say these are simply titles.If titles causes discrimination then they should be thrown away. "Muslim" is itself an identity.The oppression that we undergo today in India is a punishment from Allah for failing to fulfill the purpose of Islam.Nabi Muhammad (saw) was pelted with stones in Thaif city for preaching equality.Rich muslims should uplift the poor muslims that's why we have "Zakath".We can also uplift the poor non muslims thats why we have "sadaqah".For this we should have "Baithul maal" to manage the affairs of Muslims.If we had did this and shown True Islam in action today the majority people would have been with us.If we do that why we need reservations and all the dramas?. Now we are in a ugly situation where the BJP is taking about "Pasmanda muslims"🤦♂️.If someone comes to Islam he is just a Muslim .We should turn to Allah so he eases the country's situation.
Muslims are not SC..
Pasmanda is not a legal term.
It is used by some forward muslim of backward caste.
Not a single Islam converted SC asking for the reservation.
सर पसमांदा मसलों पर एक वीडियो बनाए।
Gharwapsi karlenge tab koi na koi tribe, caste mie waapsi hogi. Tab mil sakta hai.
Boudh, Jain, Sikh, iss mitti se nikle majahab hai. Sanatan dharm ke ansh hai.
Christians Muslims Farsi Afgani etc stc sab sharnarthi hai, migrated hai.
Permenent residency aur citizen ship ho sakta hai. Jaisey...
New Zealand mie Mouries aur Australia ke Aboriginals ki tarah lekin citizenship sab ko hai. Quota sirf moolnivasio ka hi hai.
Jara bata na konse mitti ke mineral se nikla hai dharam ???? Bolna soil me bhi varieties hai ???🤔
@@motorolaandroidone412 Registan ke soil aur haryali se bhara soil ka fark jaanta hai?
Dharm universal hai.
majahab ek region ek tapke ke logo ke liye hota hai jismie convert hona padta hai. Ya uss majahab mie paida hona padta hai.
Arya aur Asur ka fark pata hai?
Paapi Adam jaat ke bacche aur Arya Eishwar ke baccho ka fark pata hai.
Dharm aur majahab mie jo fark hota hai vahi fark soil, culture, heritage, region religion, language, food, way of life mie fark hota hai.
Religion ka moolwasi se kiya matlab. Reservation past ke discrimation ke basis pe milta hai., present condition pe nahin. Independent India me Constitution sub ko brabar manta hai. Ye flawed logic hai aapka. Mundir Masjid type argument hai
absolutely discrimination on the base religion
Then personal laws and minority benefits should be abolished, den we can talk abt equality.
जहां औषधि तभी काम करे जब खून हो साफ़,
क्यों केवल बालों मे हैं क्रीम लगाते
समस्त राष्ट्रबीमारी का करना है जब उपचार
दवा गहराई मे जा जड़ तक क्यों न पहुंचाते
आचार्य, शिक्षक, पुजारी, योगी हो मौलवी
या फिर कोई पंडित, प्रोफ़ेसर हो कि पादरी
उल्लू ही हमे बचपन से हैं मिल कर बनाते
और हम न्यापालिका के हैं चक्कर लगाते
Sir lease br law batayn
Kuch din pahle dhum dham se sant kabir ko yad kaya gaya.
Abdul kalam azhad ne musalmano main jo dalit hye unko SC reservetion dene ka virodh kiya constituent assembly main to isliye dalit muslim ya Christin ko sc reservetion nahi.
Islam aur Christianity main jativad hi nahi hye koi bhi dalit musalman mulla,molvoli ya fir koi bhi bada majahabi audhe par ja sakta hye to uske saath bhedbhav hi khatm ho jata hyd to dalit muslim ya Christin ko reservetion ki jarurat nahi.
Christin dalit bhi koi bhi bade pad par baith sakta hye Church main isliye dalit Christin ke saath bhi bhed bhav khatm to SC reservetion ki jarurat nahi
Jab ki Hindu main dalit ke saath bhedbhav hota hye aur usko mandir main pravesh ki ya Hindu dharm ka sabse bada dharmik pas Shankarachary banne ki ijajat nahi hye isliye Hindu main daliton ke saath lagatar bhedbhav hota hye isliye Dalit ko Hindu hone par hi SC reservetion milta hye.
Sahi kaha bhai, Islam mein cast k aadhar par reservation nahin hai.
You're bro but it still exists among Muslims Untouchability nai baqi ounch neech sb Kuch exists 2ndly historically lower castes haven't benefited Tou sirf Hindu low cast q Maza lai Azad was a showboy of Congress stupid idiot
Some thing is hidden in this policy
It' will be Alarming for danger zone
Finally they will said
Ghar wapsi
Calculative game need to understand
What's the actual plan behind this policy
तू जाहिलो वाली बातें कर रहा है!
Telangana me agar imam ke piche namaz na padhne ka faisla zaat ke based per tha to iski tahqeeq honi chahiye, hamare yahan sabzifarosh imaam aur qari rah chuke hain. Kisi KO koi problem nahi Hui. Aap KO Jo bataya gaya usper tahqeeq kijye.
Sir agar ya baat ha to sex ka adhar pr jo muslim woman ka satth discrimination ho rha ha us pr bhi baat kro ji jo 1 mard ko 4 shadi krna ki promision data ha or father ki property ma bhi muslim woman to equal right nhi milta. Or phir is pr bhi baat kra jo pura dash ma to educational instute ma to s.c obc reservation ha pr minority institutions ma nhi ha agar in ma bhi jaat paat ha to in instute s ma bhi s.c or obc reserveation ho is pr bhi apne rai degea tab to hma aap ka equality ka bhashan ka such pta chala ki aap kitna equility ka parkar ha ya vha pr kuter muslim ho jata ho
You are the best
In Muslim no one dalit all are equal.
KHUDAAVAN YESHUPITAA SABKO ACHCHHE SAMAANATAA MILE UPARVAALE JIVIT ISVAR PRABHU YESHUPITAA SATGURUDEV
Only 2 child policy and Human Resource Development can change the Destiny of.this Old Nation
Why ? the bestest , greatest, last and final religion of peace claims that it has this wonderful effect of removing all human discrimination and binding all its followers under the holy universal blanket of ummah. Why would one so elevated by this bestest religion be discriminated against? If a dalit muslim claims he converted due to discrimination he faced as a Hindu and still faces discrimination as a Muslim isnt it proof that the best religion is no better than religion of old pagan idolaters and disbelievers? All these people want is to get benefits of reservation and still run their conversion shops. There is no way reservation would be given to converts. This would only incentivise conversion factories.
But that's exactly what Indian politicians, including Modi, are desperately trying to do. Provide incentives to Dalits to convert to C'ianity and I slam
@@mlg1279 I don't think so. Please listen to Abhijit Mitra Iyer's episode on Hinduism and a lot of your doubts will clear. Making a committee is a sure way and readymade aswer for not acting on something for years. Reservation is an incentive for Dalits to not join homogenizing cults and remain under the fold of Hinduism. There's a lot out there that we regular people don't understand and there's a lot propaganda artists like FM are actively trying to push. This is all about monopoly and control. The second Muslim majority or enough numbers to effect substantial changes are achieved, FM's love for constitution will disappear under the holy word of the final messanger. All this speak of constitution and its values is to fool and trap gullible idiots, especially upper caste Hindus. Reality and actual agenda are faaar more sinister and insidious.
Sir! Aapne aisa kyu kaha ki govt. ne process ko delay karne ke liye ye panel banaya hai? Please thoda samjhaiye. Kya maine kuch galat samajh liya?😶😶😬
अगर दलित क्रिस्चियन और दलित मुस्लिम को अगर अनुसूचित जाति में शामिल कर आरक्षण दिया जाएगा , तो क्या आपको नहीं लगता कि आरक्षण की जो प्रतिशत है उसको फिर जनसंख्या के अनुसार बढ़ाना चाहिए
आपका इसमे क्या विचार है ?
क्या सरकार ऐसा कर सकेगी ?
जातिगत जनगणना करवा कर प्राप्त आँकड़ो के आधार पर आरक्षण बढाना चाहिए !
SC category me jub pasmanda muslim shamil honge to loss SC ke logo ko hi hoga ....
@@saurabhsingh5263 हमारे प्रोफिट और लोस की बात तू छोड़
अगर हिन्दुओ की तरह मुसलिमो धर्म मे जाति आधार पर स्पृश्यता पाई जाती है तो ही उन्हे भी अनुसूचित जाति मे श्रेणी मे डाला जा सकता आखिर मुसलिम धर्म मे भी जाति आधार पर छुआछूत है लगता है यह केन्द्र सरकार कमिटी बनाकर साबित करेगी ।
O you who have believed, do not take your fathers or your brothers as friends if they have preferred disbelief over belief. And whoever does so among you - then it is those who are the wrongdoers. Quran 9:23
achcha nehi sahab Ghar wapsi karne me subidha hoga isliye e sab kiya ja raha hai constitution me minority ke jo subidha hai ohi manle to thik se desh chalega
सर हम महाराष्ट्र मै मुस्लिम महेतर/ भंगी /हलालखोर समाज से ताल्लुक रखते है
जो कि मुस्लिम/ इस्लाम धर्म मै साब से ज्यादा पसमांदा/ पिछड़ा समाज है
आज हमारा समाज हर तरह से पिछड़ा हुआ है हर एक फील्ड में पीछे है मेरी केंद्रों सरकार से और राज्य सरकार से गुजारिश है कि हमारे समाज को विकसित और विकास करने में हमारी मदद करें
हमारा समाज आज भी भेदभाव वह एंड टच एबिलिटी का शिकार है समाज में आज भी हमें निश्चित स्थान प्राप्त नहीं है
Why muslim are not in Sc/St
Ashraf vakil saheb aapne mana to sahi ke muslmano main jatiwad hai . Ashraf unche jati ke log Khule Aam jatiwad ka samarthan karte hain ! Ashraf log islam ka istemal apne fhyede ke liye karte hain ?
Sabsey Pahley To Reservation Band hona Chahiye ...
Shadi byah me zaat paat sirf better compatibility ke wajah se dekhi jati hai, iska dharm se koi lena dena nahi hai, shadi me zaat, dharm, gora Kala, mota patla, ameer ghareeb, padha likha anpadh, naukri wala, dhande pani wala sab kuch dekhte hain.
sir.... in Telangana almost all the converted Christians are availing benefits of Scheduled Caste by grabbing their reservations and upon that these converted people are showing lots of discrimination and humiliation towards original SC s... .. pathetically it's happening since many years...
Good for those who r really need of this reservation benifit.. This is meant for all Religions.. But kya minorities mai nahi aatey yeh log.. Like sikhs & others..
Tumhari q jalli
Odish pe agar ek sc christian ban goya to unko jati v christian aur dharm v christian RI likh deta hei aur sc benefit zero, aur sab log unko wohi sc hi mante hei
Islaam me discrimination nhi h,
Or aap ne jo telangana wali baat kahi h
Ayse loog pakke-sacche musalmaan nhi h
अगर तुझे मालुम नहीं,तो एक पुस्तक पढ़ तू "मसावात की जंग" अली अनवर साहब का लिखा हुआ है
Jay Bheem, Jay Meem slogan is nullified by this video, scheduled cast will oppose such step, bcaz they will not share their right with new comers, more then 50 % reservation is prohibited l.
Why don't you advocate for Economic background ......
The simplest way to a prosperous India is... to provide all economically weaker citizens of the country with the benefit of education and skill learning at all levels and that too at Government subsidised cost... not only at government but private institutions as well... and for this purpose sufficient quota should be allocated based on biannual economic survey of the locality within a radius of 20 kilometres for non boarding schools and 50 kilometres for boarding institutions whether public or private...
🙏
Prosperity comes with innovation and improvement in efficiency, not just education
Bandhu... the first step to innovation is learning of skills... and to learn skills you need to be literate... it is as simple as that... kya samjhe ❓ nahin samjhe ❓
🙏
@@aniltuli5860 Education will not automatically bring prosperity. Why do you think we have an army of unemployed engineers in India?? So, your "simplest way" is not going to make India prosperous. It will only produce more educated unemployed.
Kya samjhe??
Ever given a thought to... exporting (deployment) of human resources ( skilled experts) to improve the economy❓... this is one easy way when our country is not able to attract much foreign investments due to the prevent mass scale corruption even after the Chief Manager trying since the last 7+ years...
Kya samjhe ❓
Agar ab bhi nahin samjhe... tou samjho ge bhi nahin...
Thanks...
Tropic closed... no further explanation required from your side or need to given from this side...
🙏
@@aniltuli5860 Tropic? 😂😂
Exporting of human resources is not a sustainable solution, u f00l.
Go back to school, kid
where is the question of caste in abrahamic religion ; then probably they must called hindu - dalit christian / muslim. Further it defeats the whole belief system of the religion ;
Dr ambedkat ne sc st ka labh hindu sikh boudh ko diya tha
जातियां मुसलमानों में है लेकिन इस्लाम इसकी इजाजत नहीं देता। ठीक वैसे ही जातियां क्रिश्चियन समाज में है लेकिन इसाई धर्म में नहीं है
Allah ke nazdik zaat paat ki koi value nahi hai, sirf nek amal aur taqwe ke wajah se he badai ho sakti hai.
Shame
It will harm deeply after long time.
The ratio of school/st reservation should be increase as, per the recommendations regarding including of few other religious converted Dalits.
Nobody else should have education ?
I think this is a new Play card. divide and rule and get votes.
On really . So delete your surname and add Indian as your second name .....try it.
Mushlim aur christian ko reservation nehin dena chaiye....ye dono hamare desh ke religion nehin hai...bahari aur AKRAANTA hai....
The Muslims ruled India for eight hundred years. How the rulers can be given Scheduled caste status?
Yeh toh musalmano ke saath bahut beinsaafi hogi.
Islam mein Economic backwardness, handicapped aur mahila k aadhar par reservation hota hai. Masjid mein mahilaon k liye alag jagah hoti hai, handicapped persons k liye kursiyan hoti hai.
MATLAB caste system bilkul exist nai krta
@@maaz87 In Islam there is no castism. Please read Qur'an with translation jis language mein aapko suvidha ho.
@@roshanara4800 Khala Ji Islam mein nai India k Musalmanu mein hai
@@maaz87 India ka Islam aur baaki Islam Alag hai. Are bhai duniyavi lalach mein apni akhirat na bigado, deen seekho, samjho aur Amal karo. Allah hidayat de ya Mita de.
@@roshanara4800 ap ki marzi Mohtrama