Sarah Kim sis give it a rest, it's 99% live. If you try to isolate the mic feed, this will be very clear. Only Chaeyoung relied on her MR at some point. Stop hating if you can't handle the facts.
Sarah Kim This is sketchbook. Everything on here is live. Haters just get out of here. You’re not even an expert and talk like you know everything. Kinda stupid
xianli liem just admit that you cant deal with them singing live, even deaf person will hear that they are singing live, listen in headphones, yall are annoying
Some people seem confused so let me help you out. Sketchbook is a live show no lip syncing is allowed. Some backtrack is allowed to be played like how the "what is love" part is playing in the back since its very repetitive. In that case you just have to sing above the back track which is what twice did during those parts. The rest you can hear them singing on their own. Also sketchbook isn't a typical "music show" think of it along the lines of a jazz club. You come & listen to the music since their singing live so you can hear them so there are no fanchants.
are you kirring mi irrriya?? That wasnt their choice I think that their manager was scared to let them sing live since only thr vocal line were able to sing while dancing in a stable manner before even though they did have lots of live stages with knock knock sketchbook uses less playback which is why they were chosen to lip sync still that isnt an Excuse for lip syncing, lets be happy that they improved now
she didn't sing it, there's still a backtrack playing & in the mr removed of other " what is love " performances, dahyun & chaeyoung didn't sing the high note. it's reasonable though, considering that they're rappers. but chaeyoung's vocals in touchdown!!!
Wei Ren Gan its not even high tbh. This show is known for not using backtrack or just a minute amount. But you can hear everyone else breathing and sounding good os xd
They did sing live, but come on, the backtrack was louder than their voices. You can only hear 20% of their live vocals because it’s concealed by the backtrack heavily.
Whoever says they aren’t singing live, this show always had who ever came sing live as far as I know. I think the backingtrack was just too loud that you can’t hear them sing live. I can hear Nayeon and Jeongyeon mostly because they have loud voices.
I think they did sing live, but also with CD played together too. Is true they did sing live cause u can hear those members with a louder voice, like Jihyo, Nayeon and jeongyeon have louder voice so actually we can hear them. Idk why the sketchbook make the backup music/vocal so loud that it covers the live singing though... but anyway .... is really hard to set a bias in Twice .... Initially my bias - Sana, then bias wrecker came in like wrecking ball - Dahyun and another bias wrecker - Nayeon .... endless bias wrecker ....
nope the vocals in the backtrack are just the hidden vocals (like the "what is love!" part & some harmonising at their singing part) . while all the singing are from TWICE own Voices & vocals. The backtrack is loud but all the singing is from their own voices..
the backup music/vocal are already there. i already did karaoke on this song, and there are backup vocals. idk why maybe because their dance if you could see its not that extreme but its actually hard. so jyp know best 😂
but actually JYP need to train twice more because some of them have a weak vocal they are famous because we all know that they are from jyp and their cute song but JYP need to train more some of the members.
When Nayeon adjusted her mic, you can hear her voice got louder. That's a proof that they're singing live. The backtrack's just too loud and mostly covering their voices. And yeah, agree with others that they're eating CDs these past few days. They improved a lot. P.S I just realized that these past few comebacks, their dance keeps on getting harder. I can't wait for the 2x. Lol.
I saw this somewhere but I really gotta say, YHS's camerawork is by far the best as compared with the promotional stages they went so far. Views are nicely panned to the relevant members without giving headaches or focusing on the wrong part during their dances.
Yu Huiyeol’s Sketchbook is easily the best music based show and no one can convince me otherwise. There’s no competition, they pretty much have to sing live nowadays. And besides, I swear every group/solo artists beat stage is the best here
@@annabelleliu7417 When another idol perform in Yu Huiyeol's, no one ask to MR.Removed or kind of that thing. But when twice perform even on a Music Station where there is 100% Live Perf, there is a lot of people not believe if that is not 100% Live.
I honestly felt their nervousness in this performance, especially Dubu. But they did not have to worry. I honestly think they did great especially Tzuyu and Mina. I mean Nabongs and Jihyo did too but it was expected. Same with Jeong and Chaeng.
Ahh I wanted them to perform in these outfits and they did! God Jihyo slaying us with her visuals and vocals! I absolutely adore her new hair and how happy she is in every performance. ❤️🌙
They are NOT lipsyncing!!! Unfortunately the backtrack is just really loud! If you listen closely you can differentiate the live singing and the backing track. Stop hating on Twice, they are very talented and most of the members are stable! You also need to remember that being able to sing and dance well at the same time does not mean they’re good or bad singers, it only determines stamina! If you want to be fair, listen to them when they’re not moving as much.
Oh they cannot lipsynch in this program. Btw the backtrack is quite loud but they are trying to sing louder. You can here some lines that are totally different from the backtracks :)))
NAYEON AND JIHYO DESERVES THEIR LINES. JEONGYEON NEED MORE LINES BECAUSE SHE DESERVES THEM TOO. CHAEYOUNG AND DAHYUN DID GREAT SANA NEEDS TO SING LOUDER MINA SLAYS AS ALWAYS TZUYU'S DESERVES MOMO NEEDS PROPER SINGING TECHNIQUE THO, OR MAYBE USE HER ORIGINAL AND NATURAL VOICE : ( SHE'S STABLE WITH IT.
They did sing it live.. I can hear Nayeon, Mina, Jungyeon, Tzuyu, and Dahyun voices. For the others maybe it's because the backtrack was loud or their voices weren't loud enough compared the backtrack. but I enjoy their performance in here. They keep improving. Fighting Twice!
Their mbc performance was live. I saw it, the performance wasn’t perfect, but it was still better than what I expected. I wonder why they would choose to cover their voices with loud backtrack when they are capable of really performing it live?
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Jihyo my heart is beating for you stop being a the cutest person alive
Always With B i'm not a fan for these group and i don't like it but i agree with you jihyo is the cutest person
kyuma Same here. I'm not ONCE, but she always catch my eyes.
Always With B I started love her i month before, i'm not once but when i saw her i found that i'm falling in love.
Yes tell her!!!
Dahyun improved soooo much. Her rap is amazing and stable 😍
Mateus De Carvalho I think she has been that good since Likey
i love her so much!
YESSS!!! IM IN LOVE💖😍
Ikr!😍 she's getting stable im so proud that she's improving😍😍
And her singing is good too aw my gawddd
I swear Jihyo never disappoints me. 💓
LADY trueee
LADY the all never disappoint once 😘😍😍
Nayeon slayed this. Her voice is so stable. Jihyo's and Jeongyeon's as well.
Twedookpop all of them do. 😍😍
Nayeon is a queen 👑
i'm not sure jihyo is singing for real during chorus?
Twedookpop No Jihyo slayed this❤
the chorus is not her part tho. it is sana and tzuyu's. or do you mean the bridge part where she sang?
*Dahyun is literally perfect and I can't even explain how stunning is Jihyo*
Jihyo body goals
Dahyun our cutiepie 💖
They really did a great job with that live singing, especially Nayeon and Jihyo almost killing it. very loud and powerful
DNA they didn't sing it live..
Sarah Kim sis give it a rest, it's 99% live. If you try to isolate the mic feed, this will be very clear. Only Chaeyoung relied on her MR at some point. Stop hating if you can't handle the facts.
It's on sketchbook. Everything on sketchbook is live (except for adlibs sometimes).
Sarah Kim This is sketchbook. Everything on here is live. Haters just get out of here. You’re not even an expert and talk like you know everything. Kinda stupid
Kristian Jaafar i thought they ALL sing 100% live? no hate
Nayeon and jihyo singing those high notes plus they are smiling. Daebakk!
xianli liem yep, they are singing live
houda razol Ikr
Sana in pigtails need another comeback after this its adorable asf. 😍
ikr her pigtails plus bangs here looks SO ADORABLE
I've never seen something more adorable and pure than this
Jihyo’s such a bias wrecker 🙃❤️
I’m in love with Jihyo!! Omg she’s sooo pretty🍭❤️
Jihyo makes my heart flutter 😍
kathyphONCE which one is Jihyo?
^ The member shaking her shoulders at the ending scene and closest to the stage.
+Hasya Nursyakirin its jihyo
maryam haq Jihyo is the godess of Twice
I can hear Mina and Dahyun voice and others-> best live.
*Jihyo still slays it*
this show requires the idols to sing live. that's why and i love
*Seriously i'm in love with jihyo here, she looks so pretty especially with that clothes 😍😭💘💘💘*
Jihyo and Nayeon are very very very stable now!
They can hit high note easily!
jihyo is so cute. and whoever says she didn't sing live is annoying. you can literally during the bridge hear her harmonize at the end of her line!
yeah you can hear her sing. her voice sticks out from the back track. she doesn't sing the "what is love" part thats everyone
it doesn't sound autotuned to me
xianli liem just admit that you cant deal with them singing live, even deaf person will hear that they are singing live, listen in headphones, yall are annoying
@jamienyx oof They lipsynced when they preformed Knock Knock
@jamienyx oof but some of them have the backtrack with their voices, but they sing louder
srry, english is not my first language
I am seriously inlove with Nayeon...but Jeongyeon!!!stop wrecking my bias😩😩
CiiJayy Just take 2YEON as your bias 🤣
CiiJayy Don't resist
Some people seem confused so let me help you out. Sketchbook is a live show no lip syncing is allowed. Some backtrack is allowed to be played like how the "what is love" part is playing in the back since its very repetitive. In that case you just have to sing above the back track which is what twice did during those parts. The rest you can hear them singing on their own. Also sketchbook isn't a typical "music show" think of it along the lines of a jazz club. You come & listen to the music since their singing live so you can hear them so there are no fanchants.
Shawol Get_It they did lipsync with knock knock tho
are you kirring mi irrriya?? That wasnt their choice I think that their manager was scared to let them sing live since only thr vocal line were able to sing while dancing in a stable manner before even though they did have lots of live stages with knock knock sketchbook uses less playback which is why they were chosen to lip sync still that isnt an Excuse for lip syncing, lets be happy that they improved now
i watch their mr removed in this performance. they are not stable tho. TWICE HAS A LONG WAY TO IMPROVE!
@@brylleelloso5278 you are late bruh they already improved a lot you are oit of date yeah twice has a long way to go that's why they improved
@@brylleelloso5278 MR Removes aren't accurate. When removing the backing track, the live vocals get distorted.
_MINA_ 😍
JEON JUNGKOOK WIFEU me too
mina's so pretty
i like mina's voice it is so humble
I have to say that they really sound good. Even Chaeyoung, a rapper, can sing a high-note.
Chaeyoung is casted into JYP becuz of her vocal Listen to her melody project Alone cover and you will know how talented she is
She is notinto twice if she can't do everything. JYP debuted all of them becausenthey can do everything (Rap, Sing, Dance and Acting)
she didn't sing it, there's still a backtrack playing & in the mr removed of other " what is love " performances, dahyun & chaeyoung didn't sing the high note. it's reasonable though, considering that they're rappers.
but chaeyoung's vocals in touchdown!!!
Of course they sound good. The backtrack is playing throughout the whole performance to cover their vocal flaws.
Wei Ren Gan its not even high tbh. This show is known for not using backtrack or just a minute amount. But you can hear everyone else breathing and sounding good os xd
I'M IN LOVE WITH JIHYO'S TOP
Sanayeon so beautiful........ Sana with her ponytail and Nayeon with her baret.. my heart
chaeyoung looks SO GOOD!!! shes so eyecatching here
yessss ikr
I LOVE their outfits on this performance!!!!😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Jihyo and Chaen are getting more pretty with every comeback 😍😍😍
I think they sing live in this stage
CILLAWIBOWO yep they are singing live. You can clearly hear their stable loud voices.
The show didnt allow ever artist lypsinc. So twice isn't lypsinc. But the backtrack still loud. But they are hreat
Randy Ghalieb Really? Well then it's REALLY loud then.
They did sing live, but come on, the backtrack was louder than their voices. You can only hear 20% of their live vocals because it’s concealed by the backtrack heavily.
WAKE UP GURL! THEY ARE NOT SINGING IT LIVE!
That clothes were very expensive, that why they are using It again. 💖
the budget
These are from the teaser photos right? Which shirt is the most expensive?!
Alex Perez all lol! Moschino, balenciaga, LV, and other
Lol, JYP has money, they're just wearing their figurine
For sure most Once like to see them wear their photoshoot outfits. Doesn't make them less of a girl group. I love them all so much!
지효는 진짜 무대가 행복하다는게 느껴질 정도로 잘 웃어줌!!
Nayeon & Jihyo slay with your vocals !!!!
B2UTY/LIGHT&ONCE 4EVER Ikr
Love Momo's pants! And Nayeon is a star, she shines bright like a diamond. 🐰💕💎
Jihyo❤️
Jihyo's part always gets me! I think I'm gonna cry for weeks!!!
they improved so much but the fact is the backtrack is louder than their voice. I just can hear Nayeon and Jihyo live in this stage
jihyo 😍😘 😙😚 !!!
Jihyo so beautiful >
JIHYO UGH
Dahyun😭
Jihyo so pretty!!😍
So many comments talking about Jihyo! I'm happy, she deserves love!
Whoever says they aren’t singing live, this show always had who ever came sing live as far as I know. I think the backingtrack was just too loud that you can’t hear them sing live. I can hear Nayeon and Jeongyeon mostly because they have loud voices.
Seokmin Take my Soul Everyone knows Twice is the first group do not sing live in this show😂
This video's camera movement is the best version of all performance of "what is love" I wached
サスガイ super agree! In others stage , i feel like the cameraman dont know which part is important
Jihyo is so pretty!
They sing live and live again. it's so difficult with a busy group like TWICE. So Fighting!!!
Jihyo so beautiful
My fastest record watching video, and it's because of Twice
Rahma Nur Islami same 😂
Jihyo voice so stable,her cuteness is evrything,her smile is brightest,and she's in thumbnail is very beautiful😍😍
TWICE's ever-improving live stage vocals, proud to be a ONCE!
I love this show because this is the only show where artist can show they're signing live!
TWICE FAN they aren't even live are you deaf ??
Once a again their stylist did a great job.. their outfit seems to be simple but when you look at it every pieces are signature ones..
JIHYO OWNS MY HEART ❤️
Jihyo my beautiful princes 😍😍😍😍😍😍
I think they did sing live, but also with CD played together too. Is true they did sing live cause u can hear those members with a louder voice, like Jihyo, Nayeon and jeongyeon have louder voice so actually we can hear them. Idk why the sketchbook make the backup music/vocal so loud that it covers the live singing though...
but anyway .... is really hard to set a bias in Twice ....
Initially my bias - Sana,
then bias wrecker came in like wrecking ball - Dahyun
and another bias wrecker - Nayeon ....
endless bias wrecker ....
nope the vocals in the backtrack are just the hidden vocals (like the "what is love!" part & some harmonising at their singing part) . while all the singing are from TWICE own Voices & vocals. The backtrack is loud but all the singing is from their own voices..
TT Rookie then make twice your bias😂😂
the backup music/vocal are already there. i already did karaoke on this song, and there are backup vocals. idk why maybe because their dance if you could see its not that extreme but its actually hard. so jyp know best 😂
It's called MR
but actually JYP need to train twice more because some of them have a weak vocal they are famous because we all know that they are from jyp and their cute song but JYP need to train more some of the members.
jihyo is getting prettier😍😍😍
라이브를 떠나서 이날 코디 메이크업 헤어 셋 다 너무 내 취향이라 종종 보러 오게 되는 듯
Nayeon look cute, Mina too. But Jihyo look Beauty
When Nayeon adjusted her mic, you can hear her voice got louder. That's a proof that they're singing live. The backtrack's just too loud and mostly covering their voices. And yeah, agree with others that they're eating CDs these past few days. They improved a lot.
P.S I just realized that these past few comebacks, their dance keeps on getting harder. I can't wait for the 2x. Lol.
I want jihyo t-shirt 😁😁
Plus she is sooo pretty
Tzuyu is really cute😍😍😍 she got an angelic face.
MINAAAAAA
Baekhyun & Seulgi stan I love mina
Baekhyun & Seulgi stan - with bangs
Baekhyun & Seulgi stan 미나!!!😂😂😂
Baekhyun & Seulgi stan i see u everywhere
Jiyhooooo I love your eyes ❤.❤
I saw this somewhere but I really gotta say, YHS's camerawork is by far the best as compared with the promotional stages they went so far. Views are nicely panned to the relevant members without giving headaches or focusing on the wrong part during their dances.
My fave Nayeon's outfit so far for this era 💕😭
Jihyo's part ...❤❤❤❤ she is very beautiful ... Im gonna cry now... 😢😢😢😁😁
Yu Huiyeol’s Sketchbook is easily the best music based show and no one can convince me otherwise. There’s no competition, they pretty much have to sing live nowadays. And besides, I swear every group/solo artists beat stage is the best here
They sang live guys... can hear jihyo breathe and dahyun also
LAR ver. recorded their breathing. please googling
@@annabelleliu7417 girl idols have to sing live in this show so that's not possible
@@annabelleliu7417 When another idol perform in Yu Huiyeol's, no one ask to MR.Removed or kind of that thing. But when twice perform even on a Music Station where there is 100% Live Perf, there is a lot of people not believe if that is not 100% Live.
They still have back track specially the high notes
@@asakurayoh5339 their voices are higher than the backtrack
jihyo stop bias wrecking meee oh my god
Nayeon ,, Pretty as usual
Jihyo, I'm so glad you are more comfortable showing off who you are despite what people say about your figure/body
I honestly felt their nervousness in this performance, especially Dubu. But they did not have to worry. I honestly think they did great especially Tzuyu and Mina. I mean Nabongs and Jihyo did too but it was expected. Same with Jeong and Chaeng.
Dahyun so pretty 💕
Jihyo visual queen
NAYEON ARE SO GORGEOUS
i love mina with bangs
As expected yu huiyeol's sketchbook. All singer in this show, show their true talent. Proud of you twice, y'all improved and killed it so well
JIHYOOOOOOOO!
Sandra Marini yes
Her voice is soooo annoying!
Sandra Marini omggg
Chicken Nugget You’re so annoying
JIHYO indeed my friend
Good guy cameraman proved that Twice not only have fanboys but also fangirls lol
JIHYO CUTIE😝❤️
my fitspiration jihyo😍😍😍
You can say what you want about Momo but she does what she loves (dance) with style and she usually sings live.
Jihyo~~
Jihyo is so beautiful❤
QUEENS SLAYED AS USUAL 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Kotorin The SG ONCE lol.
Vitória Pellegrino lol right back at you.
Chaeyoung, Jeongyeon, Tzuyu, Jihyo and Momo look gorgerous. Love this song and everyone killed it.
My bias Jihyo trying to kill me with her cuteness 😭❤️💕
Ahh I wanted them to perform in these outfits and they did! God Jihyo slaying us with her visuals and vocals! I absolutely adore her new hair and how happy she is in every performance. ❤️🌙
They are NOT lipsyncing!!! Unfortunately the backtrack is just really loud! If you listen closely you can differentiate the live singing and the backing track. Stop hating on Twice, they are very talented and most of the members are stable! You also need to remember that being able to sing and dance well at the same time does not mean they’re good or bad singers, it only determines stamina! If you want to be fair, listen to them when they’re not moving as much.
Exactly 👏
Exactly
I can hear nayeon's voice tho, her voice is like shaking?
I agree with you
Oh they cannot lipsynch in this program. Btw the backtrack is quite loud but they are trying to sing louder. You can here some lines that are totally different from the backtracks :)))
Dahyunn is so cuteeee❤❤❤
才能と努力と可愛さと美しさと明るさと、
誠実さと謙虚さと、
国境を超えた信頼関係と。。。すべてを満たす
TWICEは地球人の誇り。
NAYEON AND JIHYO DESERVES THEIR LINES.
JEONGYEON NEED MORE LINES BECAUSE SHE DESERVES THEM TOO.
CHAEYOUNG AND DAHYUN DID GREAT
SANA NEEDS TO SING LOUDER
MINA SLAYS AS ALWAYS
TZUYU'S DESERVES
MOMO NEEDS PROPER SINGING TECHNIQUE THO, OR MAYBE USE HER ORIGINAL AND NATURAL VOICE : ( SHE'S STABLE WITH IT.
i waitinh for tzuyu wear $10 tshirt .. dream come true
Jihyo 💙💙💙
Love you jihyo
ML cover ok I wanna see it
i gotta say chaeyoung ,nayeon and jihyo killed it
My top style
1.Jihyo
2.Jwongyeon
3.Nayeon
4.Chayeong
5.Tzuyu
6.Momo
7.Mina
8.Dahyun
9.Sana
OMG!! Nayeon never fails to amaze me😍😍. How I wish to meet her in person😔😔😭😭 NAYEON SLAYED🔥❤🔥❤
They did sing it live.. I can hear Nayeon, Mina, Jungyeon, Tzuyu, and Dahyun voices. For the others maybe it's because the backtrack was loud or their voices weren't loud enough compared the backtrack. but I enjoy their performance in here. They keep improving. Fighting Twice!
Fannyya Devianti Jihyo’s voice was also quite loud imo. Probably the loudest with Nayeon
all of them sang live.
Tzuyu is so pretty~~😍😍
Their mbc performance was live. I saw it, the performance wasn’t perfect, but it was still better than what I expected. I wonder why they would choose to cover their voices with loud backtrack when they are capable of really performing it live?
kyungsoo's stick that he hides under the bed Well they dont have that choice their company gives the show the track to play
Shawol Get_It by they, i meant jyp lol
kyungsoo's stick that he hides under the bed Oh lol my bad
I think bcoz they sang 4-5 (?) songs here, more than on MC so they used loud backtrack to avoid flaws, mistakes.
My jihyo 😘😘😘 daebak