@@goljompas beaucoup plus utile que de tenter de rabaisser les autres pour se sentir mieux avec toi-même et pourtant, ça t'empêche pas de faire ce genre de commentaire 🤡
@@almamater9566 C'est exactement ce que tu essaies de faire là, me rabaisser, tu veux parler de noblesse d'âme ? Je méprise le concept d'être Charlie, toi tu es mode en mode attaque personnelle, je comprends pas quelle leçon tu espères donner là.
@@goljom j'ai toujours trouvé très drôle les gens qui chouinent quand on les traité exactement comme ils trouvent normal de traiter les autres ... C'est peut-être l'occasion d'envisager une petite introspection du coup. Si ces problématique quand ça t'est adressé, ça l'est tout autant quand ça vient de toi. À peine egocentré et malhonnête cette réponse. Merci pour le fou rire champion. Pour le reste, libre à toi de penser ce que tu veux. Mais ton opinion n'est pas supérieure à celle de qui que fe soit d'autre et tu n'as aucun droit de dire aux gens ce qu'ils doivent penser. T'as un sérieux problème toi
@@almamater9566 Drôle, votre joute verbale... " tu n'as aucun droit de dire aux gens ce qu'ils doivent penser. " N'est-ce pas exactement ce que tu fais ?
2015 was horrible for our country! Charlie Hebdo, the Bataclan (a concert hall) the supermarket Hyper Casher, Montrouge, le Stade de France.... Hundreds of deads/injured people. A sad year indeed!
Sans vouloir être cynique, tes propos prouvent, à ton insu, que les "grandes" nations se contentent d'elles-mêmes... Je m'explique : 2015 fut une année terrible pour TOUTE L'EUROPE !!! Déjà en 2014, attentat au Musée Juif de Bruxelles ... puis en janvier Charlie Hebdo en connexion avec la Belgique ... février attentat au Danemark ... en Bosnie... puis encore en France, puis encore en France, puis encore en France certes.. mais avec des connexions partout en Europe... et ça continue en 2016 à Bruxelles, en Allemagne, ... Bref, 2015 année charnière pour l'Europe entière... pas seulement la France ! (Comme je disais, je ne le prends pas mal, ce n'est pas de ta faute, toutes les "grandes" nations ont se complexe ; exemple, les Etatsuniens ont le même problème de replis nationaliste et de ce fait, ils n'ont principalement que les infos des USA... "America first" !)
JE SUIS CHARLIE 🇫🇷✊🏻😔Charlie Hebdo is a satirical magazine. (Hebdo is an abbreviation of hebdomadaire, that means that the magazine is released every week) The reason why the terrorists attacked is that the magazine released a satirical drawing of Mahomet. In Islam, any representation of the prophet is banned. Those terrorists are not Muslims, they are horrible people.😢 "Je suis Charlie" is of course a reference to the name of the magazine. People were holding these signs to pay tribute to the victims. My English isn't really good, excuse me if there are mistakes.(I'm sure there are😅)
Those terrorists were totally Muslims, trying to change this fact will not help resolve these kind of problems. Luckily the great majority of Muslims in France don't apply their own horrendous texts...
@@oscur_destal No they aren't. In Islam you can't take a live only to protect yours. A draw is not a live threat. When you don't respect Islam, you're not considering as a muslim.
I am Charlie is a way to express our solidarity with the French victims that day and our pledge to protect freedom of speech, since that was a political magazine. The attack on Charlie Hebdo was one of the three terrorist attacks to occur in France that year (2015).
I don't know if you've noticed but at the end the man talks about other terrorist attacks that occured later this year, mentionning a "climax" being "Friday the 13th". I don't know if you've ever heard about it but you could react to a video explaining what this event was, because it is certainly the most horrifying attack that ever happened in France, the most lethal, and maybe what we could call the french 9/11 in a way
It will probably have a similar video from Lemonde in november. But yeah, as French same if i didn't live in Paris, i was very chocked by the terror attack in Paris. And i think i'm not alone.
answer to your questions: Charlie Hebdo is a satyric journal who caricatured the islam prophet mohamed, the french police can have guns, depends of the town, if it is in the countryside, they will have guns because it is the gendarmerie, a police which is part of the army, if they have gun, i think they carry them by their side. the shooter of the jogger is still unknow, maybe one of the terrorists, maybe someone else. yes, all these where simultanate. we use Charlie to show that what appened to Charlie Hebdo impacted us.
Yes, they have guns, but only pistols the large majority of the time (in the streets). A simple gun VS an army full automatic gun, I understand they don't shoot and just try to take cover.
French policemen also carry pistols on their belts, but they are strictly forbidden to take them out unless absolutely necessary (e.g. a potentially lethal threat).
@@federicacatapano3846 Almost every French cop or Gendarme carry at least a handgun; a Sigsauer SP2022 with a 15 9mm hollow point bullets magazine. Their guns are loaded and ready too shoot. They also wear bullet-proof jackets. You can sometime see them carry HK SMG’s or assault rifles, mostly the G36. The French police may not be brunch of trigger-happy dudes, but when things get serious, let’s just say you don’t wanna mess with them…
@@federicacatapano3846 Yeah but the National Policemen was not heavy arm at this period. Most of the time they doesn't wear any bullet proof vest and only have handgun. It's why we can see the police "flee" against the two terrorist when they shot the police car. Standard Police was not trained to respond at war weapon and terrorism
The guy on the bench who shot the jogger is still a John Doe but they said they were sure the gun was the same used by the third terrorist in the HyperKasher. Personal Anecdote from that day : I was in middle school at "Collège Henri Bergson" in the 19th, I used to live in Rue de Meaux where they crash their car just after the attentat. I remember that day when I came back from school around 1-2 pm I think, they blocked half of the street, it was the first time I saw policemen with assault rifle and big suits but especially the bomb-disposal suit, the black Mastodonte inspecting the car. The pressure was suffocating amoung the cops, they told everyone to leave so I run at home and turned on the TV to understand what's going on, my mom came from work 10min after me (specially, she's military nurse so not suposed to be home) and she explained what she knew, we were standing a meter of the TV listening and seeing everything on live, that day was frightening. (pardon my english)
j'habitais aussi au 35 de la rue de Meaux et ce jour là je devais prendre un vol le matin depuis l'Espagne qui aurait du me faire arriver à mon domicile plus ou moins à la même heure que les frères Kouachi plantaient leur véhicule dans cette rue (ils sont d'ailleurs venus par là car ils résidaient dans le quartier et faisaient partie de ce qu'on appelait le gang des Buttes Chaumont). Le vol au départ de l'Espagne a eu deux heures de retard au décollage et ne suis arrivé rue de Meaux que vers les 16h sans être au courant de quoi que ce soit de ce qui se déroulait dans l'est parisien depuis le matin. Il y avait encore une extrême agitation dans la rue lorsque je m'y suis engagé à pied mais aucun policier ne m'a empêché de passer ou prévenu de quoi que ce soit...je suis monté chez moi et c'est seulement quelques 30 mns plus tard en branchant la TV (mais sans le son) et que distraitement je vois toutes les chaines en boucle diffusant des images de la bagnole encastrée devant la pharmacie que je commence à me demander ce qu'est ce binz et prends petit à petit connaissance des événements...les jours qui ont suivi, dans le quartier ont juste été paranoïaques avec des alertes attentats presque quotidiens.
"Charlie Hebdo" is the heir to another French satirical magazine "Hara-Kiri" which often caused scandal and was censored by the French government in the 60s. There is no real equivalent of these magazines in the USA, because if social and somewhat political satire exists (with for example the magazine "Mad"), religious satire is taboo in this country. The closest thing to "Charlie Hebdo" would be the series "Southpark". (For information, the name Charlie comes from the Peanuts Charlie Brown) In 2005, a Danish (very conservative) newspaper "Jyllands-Posten" published a series of caricatures of the prophet Mohammed, partly following the murder of a Dutch Islamophobic far-right leader. This publication provoked hostile reactions in the Muslim world and death threats against the Danish cartoonists were publicly expressed in various Muslim countries and by Al-Qaeda. In response, several European newspapers in turn published caricatures of Muhammad, including "Charlie Hebdo" in France. Subsequently, "Charlie-Hebdo", previously mainly targeted by traditional Catholic circles, notably via complaints and legal proceedings, regularly caricatured Islamist movements (including an Islamist movement in Tunisia, which led to an arson attack on the newspaper's headquarters). In 2012, "Charlie Hebdo" published new caricatures of the prophet Muhammad, which earned it death threats from the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS), which emerged from the rubble of Bush Junior's war in Iraq. During the civil war in Syria, France intervened militarily against ISIS and became a priority target for ISIS terrorist threats. The attacks against "Charlie Hebdo" and the Hypercasher (Jewish grocery store) in January 2015 were followed by several others, the worst of which, in November 2015, left more than 100 dead at the Bataclan and in Parisian cafes and restaurants. The cartoonists murdered at "Charlie Hebdo" were very well-known and rather appreciated personalities in France, which contributed to the public's outrage. The reaction "Je suis Charlie" (i am Charlie) is a way for the French to say that if terrorists try to attack freedom of expression in France, they will not succeed because the French are too attached to this freedom.
Excellent I should add an element though on the origin of the name "Charlie". Charlie Hebdo was created after a previous satirical magazine was outlawed, following an article about the death of former president Charles de Gaulle « Bal tragique à Colombey - 1 mort ». So the name has both Charlie Brown and Charles de Gaulle as origins.
2015 was a sad year in France. I was in the stade de France to see the soccer game France/Allemagne in novembre the 13 when a brutal terrorist attack happened.
Le Monde kind of failed to explain anything with that video. But I guess they assumed the viewer already knew the overall story and motive and the purpose here was only to zoom-in at the chronology.
Yeah this video was not meant to be watched by someone who has no idea what Charlie Hebdo was and who these people were... A better choice of a video for today would have been a "from zero" explanation video. I'm sure there is. Poor guy wouldn't have been so confused all along.
@@luciep9741 Indeed, but I'm impress how he understands quickly a lot of things, and what's interesting is the way of he reacts to the situation, emotion... Thank you, Charlie Bonjour la France
This is a "what happened" video that present what happened that day minute by minute. It is obviously aimed to the french that know what we are talking about.
10:10 : At this moment, when the jogger was shot 5 times, the weapon used was the tokarev, we are still today not sure who shot the jogger. Still, the weapon used that time (precisely the same tokarev) was found in possession of the 3rd terrorist of that attack (Ahmedi COULIBALY)
French police officers only have handguns. Unlike in the US, patrol vehicles in France are not armored or reinforced. Faced with weapons of war, they could only retreat.
Only highly armed specialized police teams have special protection equipment and weapons to deal with armed gangs, hostage takers, hijacking’s and terrorists. They have very high level training similar to military special forces. Such teams are permanently located in the main cities and regions of France and can be deployed anywhere very fast. Bigger teams are based in the Paris area headquarters.
Another satirical magazine is "Le Canard Enchaîné", though it goes more in depth about many stories. In the US there were The Havard/National Lampoon and Mad. More recently, there is The Onion which is both in print and on RUclips.
merci pour tous, j'ai un amie d'enfance qui à vécu ça et il à survécu, mais dès que je l'ai appris, je me suis précipité chez lui il été tout pâle pendant 4 jours d'affilé. encore merci à vous ! ❤🩹
The guy who shot the jogger has not been identified. It was either: a) An accomplice to the other 3 who was never found nor identified. b) A totally unrelated guy who was never found nor identified, but whose gun conveniently ended up in the hands of the 3rd terrorist (so highly unlikely). c) Coulibaly himself, but no element can confirm it as there was seemingly no witnesses at the time and he didn't live to admit it. Considering Coulibaly had the gun used to shoot the jogger in his possession, the c) is the most likely one.
Hi french here. the 3 guys knew each other and together but they did their things almost at the same time but not in the same place. To answer your question, in France police can have weapons but not all of them (differences between police departments). Anyway, if you are curious about this event and want to know about an other episode of this "dark year", you can teach yourself what happened on 2015 november the 13th in Paris. Terrible days and events we never forget. Sorry for my english. Peace.
French policeman on the ground is Ahmed Merabet. The person who made the video just put it on facebook for 10 or 15 minutes then the whole network and medias used it as a symbol of this attack. While members of his family had no news about him and were in front of screens showing the scene, but with blur just like in this video. This is a crucial part of these events, the images traumatized tons of people, and a few things that were never explained also pushed for conspiracy theories about his fate and who he was. (I met a couple of members of his family a few months later and before November 13). These are really hard times for France, and I'm afraid islamists here managed to really shock the country and since we live like under collective PTSD). In November we'll have to talk about November 13 again and the scale of the attack will really amaze you... be ready... 2015 is such an infernal year for France.
Le Monde is a french newspaper ... gauchiste et n existant que grâce aux subventions de l'état donc des impôts des Français car sinon ça serait la clef sous la porte pour ce torchon..
@@Sophie-Ocean le Monde is a daily newspaper . Charlie hebdo is a satirical weekly magazine. The Charlie hebdo cartoonists who were killed 10 years ago were very famous . Their drawings disturbed the muslim community . All the demonstrations after their death were to support freedom of expression. 2015 was a terrifying year ending with the Bataclan shooting in November.
I love how the author subtitles subtly avoid every "Muhammad" or any islam relatedmotivation which led them to start it first. Charlie Hebdo is a magazine that caricaure everyting but one drawing of Muhammad led to all this shit
@@BonjourCharlie The multiple attacks of 2015 and 2016 highlight the weakness of the French government policy against the police, always frowned upon by politicians and the People, the intelligence services, which knew of the existence of more than 24,000 S ranked extremists and radicalists INSIDE the country, and the almost non-existent controls on immigrants.
you might have heard about the other traumatic event, the attack in Bataclan because it happened during the concert of an american band. there were few of these attacks in Paris at the time. it's ten years already but it's not forgotten.
this wave of terrorism was of islamic inspiration and the terrorists were loosely connected between them but there must have been connections to big criminality because of the guns they had, you can't just get hold of those freely in France.
Charlie Hebdo is a newspaper making satirical political cartoons making fun of all politicians, national and international, and of all geopolitical matters.
Hi, I don't know if you'll see this message, but I am French and I don't really speak English. I understood that you were asking about police engagement protocols in France. I don't claim to know everything, but I'm basing this on my own deductions. Basically, in France, the police usually operate in groups of at least 3 and are lightly armed: a handgun, a taser, or pepper spray. This is why, during the Charlie Hebdo attack, the police couldn't do much. However, since these attacks, their equipment has been reinforced. During major events or in big cities with a lot of people, one member of the patrol is now equipped with an assault rifle, like the G3 model.
No it doesn't happen a lot but it had a major impact. The November attack on Bataclan had an even greatet impact imo. You can see the story of the police reaction in the movie November by C. Jiménez
I remember, I was 6 when that happened but I still asked to go on the street with my family and neighbours to support the liberty of the press. At school a friend asked me if I wanted to make some flyers "Je Suis Charlie" and when I came back with 1 of them at home my mother cried. What's so important with this attack is that it came from a caricature of the Prophet Mahmood (who was criticizing the Islamists) published in the Charlie Hebdo magazine (along with caricatures of other religions and ohter stuff). Those acts of terror were (for the terrorist) a revenge but in France the liberty of the press is one of the thing we are the most proud off and when that happened we were all socked. I mean Charlie Hebdo already had a lot of controversies due to their politic and not that much people liked this magazine BUT these attacks were like attacks directly against the France itself (don't forget that our 3 words are: Liberty/Freedom, Equality, Fraternity ).
I didn't finish the video yet, but to answer a few questions you asked before I forget : Charlie Hebdo was a newspaper that was focused on comic cartoons that criticized a bit of everything, I lack the words to explain it in english but basically they made humor with goofy cartoons, they got victim of this attack after publishing a cartoon that was targeting the prophet Mahomet (note that they do this with everyone : religion, politics, as far as I know they were not sided but rather treating every subject the same) On the question : "Are french policemen armed ?" Yes, but it's mostly since those years of terrorism with Charlie Hebdo and Le Bataclan that you can see police officers with assault riffle in important events, usually they only carry a handgun and at this time I am pretty sure they were not trained to face people equiped with war weapons, we have specialized units for that but they are not patrolling the streets. Also note that french people are not used to see weapons, unlike us where it's legal, most of us never saw more than a hunting riffle in our life, and I wouldn't be surprised that a lot of people didn't even see one, so it's even more shocking for us to see an AK-47 being used in our streets
French police is armed but only handguns. the Kouachis had ak 47s I believe, may be another type of automatic riffle I'm not sure but it clearly outclassed the police guns. The only police units heavily equipped are the special intervention groups of RAID(national police special force) and GIGN(same thing for the gendarmerie nationale(countryside police that's legally part of the military)). these units are only used for situations with heavy danger (usually anything that includes armed people). That's why the normal police force had trouble fighting the terrorists since they were heavily outgunned.
Now, because of all the attentats in 2015 and since, but not back then. Only spécial forces were armed in 2015. Therefore the policewoman and men were killed. They had nothing to defend themselves against someone with a gun.
The possession of firearms in France by citizens was legal until 1939 when the Vichist government (the one which surrendered to Germany in 1940) banned it because it feared a revolution. Some people, however, preferred to hide their weapons rather than obey (which was risky because during WW2 being spotted could mean death), also some French people may have inherited undeclared weapons dating from before 1939. Even after the liberation of 1945, the law was never repealed and was even gradually strengthened. People here are used to it and are overwhelmingly against gun ownership. Nowadays while citizens the acquisition of firearms (legal because there are traffickers) is strictly limited. The most simple and common case involves hunting arms (there are a lot of hunters in France, so they weigh in the elections, so politicians are more careful with them than with other gun owners). Then there are the weapons for sport shooting. Then some exceptional cases for specific professions. All these cases require special procedures. The last possibility, where the purchase of weapons is free, is the acquisition of historical weapons (dating from before 1900) and considered not very dangerous. Despite all this, France would be the 2nd country in Europe in terms of the number of arms. At 2010 (France had 65 million inhabitants): 20 to 30 million weapons in total in the country. 10 million legal civilian weapons, including approximately 3 million declared-firearms, most for hunting. And an estimate of 30,000 criminal firearms resulting from trafficking (1% ratio but not same firepower).
I'm really not educated on the subject and I don't understand the Math here, could you give more details please? 1/ What is considered a "weapon" if there are 20 to 30 million weapons in total but only 3 million declared-firearms and an estimate of 30,000 criminal firearms? I guess a part of them are the legal but not civilian weapons? The ones used by the army (including gendarmes) and the police? 2/ What are the 7 million legal civilian weapons that are not firearms? I genuinely don't know, what one would need a permit for that is not a firearm?
@@neroli_0.0_ In France, weapons are spread across 4 categories. The details of what weapons fall into which category are a bit complex, but for short: A: anything you would see used in a war, from automatic weapons to explosives and such. You basically cannot own any of that as a civilian. B: rifles, pistols... your run of the mill firearms. Think america without the occasional spice. You can have these, but you need to be trained, provide proof you're trained to authorities, and get a permit. You will also keep up the training and renew the permit from time to time. C: Hunting rifles and such. You only need to register the weapon with authorities, no special permit required. You also need to declare any sale of a weapon you owned. The new owner doesn't need to do anything specific unless the previous owner couldn't manage to declare the change of ownership (inheritance cases for instance). D: anything else, like knives, old rifles that are more museum piece than weapons (from before 1900), that kind of thing. Freely owned and not subject The numbers given above are a bit outdated and come from studies made in the late 2000's. In 2015, the ministry of interior gave an estimate 10M illegal firearms circulating in the country, and 4M legal ones (owned by 1.4M hunters and 160k sports shooters). Note that these illegal arms include a vast majority of what is called "family weapons", hunting rifles or world war pieces and such for which the family didn't file the proper paperwork after inheriting it from a relative. Regarding overall weapon ownership per capita, ranked against other countries in the world, France fell down the ladder severely, being 23rd in 2017, bellow Germany(8th) and Switzerland(17th).
For Amedy Coulibaly, I think what they mean is that the joger said its wasnt him who shooted in that park. But they found the gun of the terorrist in his bag. Which means it's was a coordinated attcks
@@BonjourCharlie or a more likely possibility is that it’s simply Coulibaly. Since he had the gun why would it be someone else? They just can’t be sure at 100% since the runner could not identify the shooter and Coulibaly was shot before talking.
@@BonjourCharlieje suis déjà au courant de l'attentat de 2015 vu que je l'ai vu au informations et en plus j'avais pas besoin d'avoir recours à des sout titres vu que la vidéo que tu regardé était française
For the "Thalys" attack in august 2015, there was 3 american tourist in the train who stopped the terrorist. Clint Eastwood realised a movie about this history. You should know "The 15:17 to Paris".
@@LizzieJaneBennet or maybe it refers to the question the terrorist asked when he walked into the room : " who is Charlie ?" Because they wanted to shoot Charlie - they thought it was a real person.
Never forget who was armed, who was not, who died, who didn't, who got lucky to survive, who wasn't. Coulybali was lucky. When he shot the policewoman, she and her partner were not armed, not were the city employees there were talking to. If the partner was, Coulybali would have been shot on spot, wounded and maybe killed. In the shop, the man who grabbed one rifle from him... the rifle didn't jam : its safety was on and the young man didn't know how to switch it off. That's why the rifle didn't operate. What would have happened if HE was carrying a handgun (which is forbidden in France) ? What would have happened if one of the city employees was carrying a handgun ?
To answer to your question at 06:30, french police had 9mm pistols in 2015 and some unletal weapons (tear gas, taser, etc). Since this event and the Bataclan massacre, some task force (like BAC, PSIG) has assault rifle, balistic shields and heavy armors in their vehicules in case of mass murder. These events were so significant for the police that many intervention processes have been reviewed since then, even the even the legal framework for the use of weapons for the police. My brother was in the police north of Paris at this time and participated in the blockade of the capital. I remember spending hours watching the 24/7 news channels just in case something happened.
I watched this video out of curiosity but honestly, it really puts me in distress, I could barely stand it. How could human being reach that level of cruelty !
I guess you are not from France then. 2015 was an awful year for us, and sadly, this attack wasn't the worse one we got that year. I can still remember the fear of November 13, watching the info about everything that was happening, while knowing I had friends around there at that time (one of them was in the Stade de France at the time, I got especially scared for him). I think those events are still a wound for french people, even for those that were not there directly, and I still feel weird hearing and reading the name "Battaclan" even today.
@@oceki3592 At the time I was 12 years old (13 at the time of Bataclan) and lived all the way in French Guiana. All this was a bit distant by then. I have become much more permeable to news-induced stress now.
@@noefillon1749 Je vois, ça explique des choses. Effectivement pour les habitants des territoires d'outre mer ça a du être vécu différemment que pour ceux qui sont en métropole directement. Je ne sais pas comment vous avez reçu l'information en Guyane française (si c'était en direct ou pas principalement), y compris l'heure qu'il était pour vous quand c'est arrivé parce que ça influence aussi, en plus de la distance entre le lieu de l'attaque et vous. J'avais 14 ans quand c'est arrivé (presque 15 ans) donc visiblement nous sommes assez similaires en tranche d'âge. Pour ma part, j'ai vraiment vécu tout ça en direct avec les informations, bien que je n'étais pas à Paris à ce moment là. Et le fait que j'avais des amis là bas a contribué à la peur que je ressentais, et je me souviens leur avoir envoyé beaucoup de messages pour m'assurer qu'ils étaient en sécurité (c'est là que j'ai appris qu'un autre de mes amis était au Stade de France et que c'était plus ou moins le chaos).
''Charlie'' Général Charles de gaulle ww2 Créé en 1970 pour remplacer la version hebdomadaire du magazine Hara-Kiri, édité par la même équipe et venant d'être interdit à la suite d'un titre raillant la mort du général de Gaulle, il est publié régulièrement jusqu'en 1981
About the question if police officer have guns readily avaliable, yes they do. All national police officers carry a side arm(typically berettas and such), and can be seen patrolling sometimes with SMG/AR (rarely AR unless it's around a sensible place) Gendarmerie (another type of french police) also often patrols with ump-45 in addition of their side arm However, patrolling with shoulder weapons became way more often after the charlie hebdo and November 2015 attacks
Je suis Français, croyez-moi ! Ils nous ont rendus plus fort. J'ai une pensée particulière pour les victimes des attentats qui sont devenue les martyrs de la République. On est un peuple libre et fière. Quiconque essait de touché à nos libertés connaîtra le prix du sang et des larmes. Vive la liberté d'expression et vive la France ! Nous sommes tous Charlie.
Hebdo is a shortened for Hebdomadaire meaning Weekly (a weekly journal in that case). The journal was a satiric journal with lots of caricatures on their covers. Ironically, their edition adress had recently changed at the time of the terrorist attack. I used to live in the same building of their former location that was more in the center of Paris and my Godmother still lives there. There could have been trouble. Ironically, I'm glad they moved elsewhere months before the attack !
At the end, they say Charlie as "he", but it's a mistranslation. In French, there is no "it" for object etc... only he/she, so it got translated litteraly as "he" which it should've been "it was a marker"
J’étais à Paris entrain de fêter l’anniversaire d’un collègue le soir du bataclan vraiment je n’oublierai jamais… ainsi que les 2 tour à New York vraiment entre les deux tour Charlie et le bataclan j’en ai encore les larmes aux yeux. Merci point cette vidéo. Vive la France vive l’Amérique amis pour l’éternité ❤
I’m French and it was horrible because there had already been an attack before at the newspaper Charlie Hebdo and they were not protected as they should have. After there were so many attacks and so many deaths and when we see President François Hollande leading the procession in tribute to all these talented men, simple visitors, police... and that in 2024, This former president has allied himself with a political party that supports the Islamists of Hamas and others, it is disgusting. Today in France, it is worse because the people are not protected or so little and the politicians in power do not care or are complicit. At least in the United States, you can be and defend yourself while we French citizens do not even have the right to legitimate defense and if a man enters our house and we hurt him, he can file a complaint against us! A world of crazy, except that the crazy are all armed.
Un traumatisme qui va changer notre comportement à jamais. Plus rien ne sera pareil désormais surtout avec les horribles attentats qui suivront le 13 novembre 2015. Le peuple français s'est uni comme jamais pour faire face et défendre notre devise "Liberté-Égalité-Fraternité". Merci aux pays du monde entier qui ont été un soutien incomparable.
Every policeman in France is equiped with a had gun type 9mm but rarely with anything of a biger caliber, some unites have them but thay are not as much every where than in america because these tragical events append extremelly rarlly.
En France si quelqu'un s'introduit chez toi ,et que tu le frappes juste pour le neutraliser,l'individu peut porter plainte pour coups et blessures ! Welcome in France.
The "unidentified guy" is of course a terrorist and might be one of the 3 of this video the problem is, we don’t have any proof that one of the 3 really used this gun
The "insane reason" you are talking about is religion. They did all that because their imaginary friend told them to (or so they believe). That's why it is difficult to understand their behaviour. "Anyone who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities" (Voltaire). Je suis Charlie.
Ce n'est pas qu'une question d'islam. Al Qaeda et Daesh ont des idéologies inspirées à la fois du fascisme européen et du wahhabisme(et à l'inverse, des groupes identitaires américains s'inspirent de leur idéologie, comme la Atomwaffen division qui a quelques éléments en Europe)
@anaskournif9290 lisez les règles de l'islam sunnite. Ils n'ont dérogé à aucune. Ils sont en jihad, c'est malheureusement ce qui est écrit dans ces dogmes obscurantistes.
@@anaskournif9290 Bah c'est basé que une vision rigoriste de la religion,. C'est pas inspiré plus d'un fascisme que de l'autre. N'importe quelle idéologie incritiquable devient du fascisme. C'est comme un mormon aux Etats-Unis, sauf que le mormon ne tue pas. On va dire sinon comme un Klu k*ux k*an. D'où l'importance de maintenir chez nous la religion loin des institutions publiques pour qu'elle ne devienne pas une source de référence et s'impose à ceux qui ne la suivent pas.
Charlie Hebdo is the name of the satirical journal. Few days before, they posted satirical cartoons about prophet Mahomet . 10 years after we will not forget. It's very important for us that strangers know and react to this event. So, ty for your video. Je suis Charlie.
C'est vrai que ça n’arrive pas souvent en France ou en Belgique ce genre de chose. Quand ça se passe c’est très grave pour la France. J’espère que tu réagiras à une vidéo des attentats du 13 Novembre 2015 pour les 10 ans
The double hostage situation by 2 coordinating crews was an extremely critical situation for the special police forces because of live news channels (TV, radio, web) giving real time reporting of the detailed situation. Any police raid on one hostage location risked to trigger a revenge bloodbath on the other location. Both police teams had to be fully prepared before any intervention could be launched.
The reason of the attack against Charlie Hebdo is because they re-published a caricature of Mahomet as a terrorist. This was drawn by a Danish drawers and it created huge demonstrations in muslim countries with Danish flash burnt and ambassies attacked. To support their Danish colleagues and defend press freedom, Charlie Hebdo made their front page with it. They knew it was risky that's why they had a police protection. It was a big shock for everybody to hear that drawers like Cabu (who worked in a famous TV program for Kids when I was a child) or Wolinski (famous satyrical drawer in newspapers) were killed. Dark times
The "Charlie, he" was a translation mistake. The french language has no equivalent for the pronoun "it". We designate everything, including objects, by either "he" or "she". It should have been translated to "it" in english
btw #JESUISCHARLIE Charlie Hebdo is a satirical newspaper. It is full of caricatural drawings, and it has been attacked because of drawings depicting Mahommet, saying "it is hard to be loved by dumbasses" in reaction to 9/11.
At the end of the video they speak about the others acts of terrorism that we suffered during the year. If you want there is the film "Novembre" which retraces the events of the biggest attacks of this year (2015).
For the guy in the bench we don't know who it is but we think it's the third terrorist, Amedy Coulibaly, because we found the sane gun on him. But there are 'only' 3 terrorists that have been in contact after and during this 3 awful days.
At the end, the man doesn't talk about Charlie like a person. It's just a very common mistake in translation. French doesn't have a "it" to talk about animals or objects.
6:22 It's the basic "National Police", the situation was probably very confusing, everything is going very fast in only a few minutes. They probably had only SIG-Sauer handguns and weren't expecting to be confronted to two crazy men with assault rifles (AKs, Sa Vz 58, Skorpion VZ61...). Other units always have rifles, not them. GIPN, BRI, RAID, they are on another level... They are the ones fully equipped to neutralize anything. 17:40 Yes, not is such scale (and I guess your next video will be about November 2015, another attacks even more brutal and elaborated). 19:23 It was most likely Amedy Coulibaly but police/justice can't be *100% sure* it was him.
Hi i live in Fontenay aux roses a city in the suburbs of paris, this is were the jogger was shot by "John doe" . The terrorist Coulibaly was also from Fontenay aux Roses and since they found the gun uses for the shooting on him it's most likely Coulibaly was the one involved in the jogger shooting. They can't be 100% sure but we can say 90% that is him who did it
The 3 guys are in the same team, we suspected A.Coulibaly the third guy's, to be the guy's who's shooting 5 time with a tokarev a runner because he have the tokarev in his stuff when he attack the market.
In France, the national police (and the gendarmerie = carabinieri in Italy) routinely wear a loaded handgun. They may be fitted with long weapons on certain occasions or missions.
6:18 Yes the Police have gun in France. In France we have 3 different polices : municipale police ( they have tasers I think. It's a small neighborhood police force, you could say. Then there's the national police and they have pistols (but not with big calibers to compete with terrorists). Otherwise there's the Gendarmerie but it's a police force in principle more rural or outside urban areas in any case (and they are real soldiers much better trained and equipped). But on January 7, 2015, there was no gendarmerie (because there aren't any in urban areas). And so the people on bikes were municipal police officers (with tasers) and in the car they were national police officers (National Police). So it's impossible for them to respond to such caliber. Then we have very heavily armed special police forces, but it's the one we see later in the video (equivalent to SWAT) the GIGN
The municipal police can be equipped with handguns if the city council approves it, and the policemen have the appropriate training and qualification. It’s different in each city. Some cities have no city police at all, especially small villages obviously.
As said by many, french police is split across sections that will have varying degrees of equipment. On the whole, they are not equipped to deal with such situations. Most will have a sidearm. But even with heavier equipment, they are trained to be very cautious when firearms are involved, for everybody's safety, hence why the guys escaped for a while. It's considered better to avoid immediate confrontation in volatile situations, because you never know who will be caught in the crossfire in addition of the problem of you being outgunned. Since they were showing a willingness to flee, better to let them escape and track them down afterwards, giving you the ability to create the scenario for a clean sweep.
This is a great channel! Merci de témoigner de l amitié franco américaine sans faille ! Thx for publishing this , those events shaped french and European security against terrorist attacks. Basically a french version of 9/11 a pardon! 11/9.
Charlie Hebdo is a French satirical political weekly newspaper based on caricatural drawings. It was targeted by Islamist radical groups for reproducing satirical drawings of Muslim prophet Mahomet first published by a similar newspaper in the Netherlands if I recall. This happened somewhere around 2006, so 9 years before this slaughter terrorist attack.
charlie hebdo is a very well-known and widely bought newspaper in France where chronicles on current affairs and politics in France are written in the form of caricature illustrations sometimes very contested and questionable and a few weeks before an edition appeared depicting bin laden the cartoonists who were assassinated were very well known to the French and very popular, this created deep horror and fear and affected freedom of expression. This newspaper was extremely daring but they killed them in the worst possible way
C'est dommage qu'on ne puisse pas faire la traduction en français de tes commentaires, on aurait pu t'aider a comprendre se qui c'est passé exactement et répondre aux questions que tu te poses.
10 years have passed, but we don't forget those from charlie hebdo. Je suis Charlie.
Ca vous coute rien de dire je suis Charlie c'est sur... ça donne bonne conscience et ça fait joli.
@@goljompas beaucoup plus utile que de tenter de rabaisser les autres pour se sentir mieux avec toi-même et pourtant, ça t'empêche pas de faire ce genre de commentaire 🤡
@@almamater9566 C'est exactement ce que tu essaies de faire là, me rabaisser, tu veux parler de noblesse d'âme ?
Je méprise le concept d'être Charlie, toi tu es mode en mode attaque personnelle, je comprends pas quelle leçon tu espères donner là.
@@goljom j'ai toujours trouvé très drôle les gens qui chouinent quand on les traité exactement comme ils trouvent normal de traiter les autres ... C'est peut-être l'occasion d'envisager une petite introspection du coup. Si ces problématique quand ça t'est adressé, ça l'est tout autant quand ça vient de toi. À peine egocentré et malhonnête cette réponse. Merci pour le fou rire champion.
Pour le reste, libre à toi de penser ce que tu veux. Mais ton opinion n'est pas supérieure à celle de qui que fe soit d'autre et tu n'as aucun droit de dire aux gens ce qu'ils doivent penser.
T'as un sérieux problème toi
@@almamater9566 Drôle, votre joute verbale...
" tu n'as aucun droit de dire aux gens ce qu'ils doivent penser. "
N'est-ce pas exactement ce que tu fais ?
2015 was horrible for our country! Charlie Hebdo, the Bataclan (a concert hall) the supermarket Hyper Casher, Montrouge, le Stade de France.... Hundreds of deads/injured people. A sad year indeed!
And that's not all with the current weak policy. Zero tolerance for guys like that on death row or life in the worst prison in existence.
Sans vouloir être cynique, tes propos prouvent, à ton insu, que les "grandes" nations se contentent d'elles-mêmes... Je m'explique :
2015 fut une année terrible pour TOUTE L'EUROPE !!! Déjà en 2014, attentat au Musée Juif de Bruxelles ... puis en janvier Charlie Hebdo en connexion avec la Belgique ... février attentat au Danemark ... en Bosnie... puis encore en France, puis encore en France, puis encore en France certes.. mais avec des connexions partout en Europe... et ça continue en 2016 à Bruxelles, en Allemagne, ... Bref, 2015 année charnière pour l'Europe entière... pas seulement la France ! (Comme je disais, je ne le prends pas mal, ce n'est pas de ta faute, toutes les "grandes" nations ont se complexe ; exemple, les Etatsuniens ont le même problème de replis nationaliste et de ce fait, ils n'ont principalement que les infos des USA... "America first" !)
and Nice in 2016 :/ both 2015 and 2016 were sad years
JE SUIS CHARLIE 🇫🇷✊🏻😔Charlie Hebdo is a satirical magazine. (Hebdo is an abbreviation of hebdomadaire, that means that the magazine is released every week)
The reason why the terrorists attacked is that the magazine released a satirical drawing of Mahomet. In Islam, any representation of the prophet is banned. Those terrorists are not Muslims, they are horrible people.😢
"Je suis Charlie" is of course a reference to the name of the magazine. People were holding these signs to pay tribute to the victims.
My English isn't really good, excuse me if there are mistakes.(I'm sure there are😅)
They are indeed Sunni Muslims !
Without lies, Islam dies
Those terrorists were totally Muslims, trying to change this fact will not help resolve these kind of problems. Luckily the great majority of Muslims in France don't apply their own horrendous texts...
They are muslims.
@@oscur_destal No they aren't. In Islam you can't take a live only to protect yours. A draw is not a live threat.
When you don't respect Islam, you're not considering as a muslim.
@@cyclotronbxl Yeah sure so it's not the Christians who made the Crusades either, and actually the Muslim conquests are not Muslims.
I am Charlie is a way to express our solidarity with the French victims that day and our pledge to protect freedom of speech, since that was a political magazine. The attack on Charlie Hebdo was one of the three terrorist attacks to occur in France that year (2015).
Merci, oui et le bataclan...
I don't know if you've noticed but at the end the man talks about other terrorist attacks that occured later this year, mentionning a "climax" being "Friday the 13th". I don't know if you've ever heard about it but you could react to a video explaining what this event was, because it is certainly the most horrifying attack that ever happened in France, the most lethal, and maybe what we could call the french 9/11 in a way
It will probably have a similar video from Lemonde in november.
But yeah, as French same if i didn't live in Paris, i was very chocked by the terror attack in Paris. And i think i'm not alone.
Friday 13th is also referred as the Bataclan.
Which is a concert hall where terrorists shot many many people in the audience.
answer to your questions: Charlie Hebdo is a satyric journal who caricatured the islam prophet mohamed, the french police can have guns, depends of the town, if it is in the countryside, they will have guns because it is the gendarmerie, a police which is part of the army, if they have gun, i think they carry them by their side. the shooter of the jogger is still unknow, maybe one of the terrorists, maybe someone else. yes, all these where simultanate. we use Charlie to show that what appened to Charlie Hebdo impacted us.
Yes, they have guns, but only pistols the large majority of the time (in the streets). A simple gun VS an army full automatic gun, I understand they don't shoot and just try to take cover.
La police nationale est armée, pour les polices municipales, ce n'est pas vrai partout.
Journal en anglais ne veut pas dire journal mais journal intime (; Journal, c'est "newspaper"
At that time police officers of police nationale only had guns, now it's different, some units (like BAC) have HKUMP9 or HKG36.
French policemen also carry pistols on their belts, but they are strictly forbidden to take them out unless absolutely necessary (e.g. a potentially lethal threat).
Je suis Charlie ❤... To aswer to your question. Yes French policemen are armed.
Only municipal policeman were not armed at that time. Now I think they are armed too. Sorry for my bad english.
@@federicacatapano3846 Almost every French cop or Gendarme carry at least a handgun; a Sigsauer SP2022 with a 15 9mm hollow point bullets magazine. Their guns are loaded and ready too shoot. They also wear bullet-proof jackets. You can sometime see them carry HK SMG’s or assault rifles, mostly the G36. The French police may not be brunch of trigger-happy dudes, but when things get serious, let’s just say you don’t wanna mess with them…
@@federicacatapano3846 Yeah but the National Policemen was not heavy arm at this period. Most of the time they doesn't wear any bullet proof vest and only have handgun.
It's why we can see the police "flee" against the two terrorist when they shot the police car. Standard Police was not trained to respond at war weapon and terrorism
@@jda755wrong, we have bullet armor since 2009. However the daily gun is 9 mm.
mais ils ne peuvent pas les utiliser sinon ils sont poursuivis en justice
The guy on the bench who shot the jogger is still a John Doe but they said they were sure the gun was the same used by the third terrorist in the HyperKasher.
Personal Anecdote from that day :
I was in middle school at "Collège Henri Bergson" in the 19th, I used to live in Rue de Meaux where they crash their car just after the attentat. I remember that day when I came back from school around 1-2 pm I think, they blocked half of the street, it was the first time I saw policemen with assault rifle and big suits but especially the bomb-disposal suit, the black Mastodonte inspecting the car. The pressure was suffocating amoung the cops, they told everyone to leave so I run at home and turned on the TV to understand what's going on, my mom came from work 10min after me (specially, she's military nurse so not suposed to be home) and she explained what she knew, we were standing a meter of the TV listening and seeing everything on live, that day was frightening.
(pardon my english)
j'habitais aussi au 35 de la rue de Meaux et ce jour là je devais prendre un vol le matin depuis l'Espagne qui aurait du me faire arriver à mon domicile plus ou moins à la même heure que les frères Kouachi plantaient leur véhicule dans cette rue (ils sont d'ailleurs venus par là car ils résidaient dans le quartier et faisaient partie de ce qu'on appelait le gang des Buttes Chaumont). Le vol au départ de l'Espagne a eu deux heures de retard au décollage et ne suis arrivé rue de Meaux que vers les 16h sans être au courant de quoi que ce soit de ce qui se déroulait dans l'est parisien depuis le matin. Il y avait encore une extrême agitation dans la rue lorsque je m'y suis engagé à pied mais aucun policier ne m'a empêché de passer ou prévenu de quoi que ce soit...je suis monté chez moi et c'est seulement quelques 30 mns plus tard en branchant la TV (mais sans le son) et que distraitement je vois toutes les chaines en boucle diffusant des images de la bagnole encastrée devant la pharmacie que je commence à me demander ce qu'est ce binz et prends petit à petit connaissance des événements...les jours qui ont suivi, dans le quartier ont juste été paranoïaques avec des alertes attentats presque quotidiens.
"Charlie Hebdo" is the heir to another French satirical magazine "Hara-Kiri" which often caused scandal and was censored by the French government in the 60s. There is no real equivalent of these magazines in the USA, because if social and somewhat political satire exists (with for example the magazine "Mad"), religious satire is taboo in this country. The closest thing to "Charlie Hebdo" would be the series "Southpark". (For information, the name Charlie comes from the Peanuts Charlie Brown)
In 2005, a Danish (very conservative) newspaper "Jyllands-Posten" published a series of caricatures of the prophet Mohammed, partly following the murder of a Dutch Islamophobic far-right leader. This publication provoked hostile reactions in the Muslim world and death threats against the Danish cartoonists were publicly expressed in various Muslim countries and by Al-Qaeda. In response, several European newspapers in turn published caricatures of Muhammad, including "Charlie Hebdo" in France.
Subsequently, "Charlie-Hebdo", previously mainly targeted by traditional Catholic circles, notably via complaints and legal proceedings, regularly caricatured Islamist movements (including an Islamist movement in Tunisia, which led to an arson attack on the newspaper's headquarters). In 2012, "Charlie Hebdo" published new caricatures of the prophet Muhammad, which earned it death threats from the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS), which emerged from the rubble of Bush Junior's war in Iraq. During the civil war in Syria, France intervened militarily against ISIS and became a priority target for ISIS terrorist threats.
The attacks against "Charlie Hebdo" and the Hypercasher (Jewish grocery store) in January 2015 were followed by several others, the worst of which, in November 2015, left more than 100 dead at the Bataclan and in Parisian cafes and restaurants.
The cartoonists murdered at "Charlie Hebdo" were very well-known and rather appreciated personalities in France, which contributed to the public's outrage. The reaction "Je suis Charlie" (i am Charlie) is a way for the French to say that if terrorists try to attack freedom of expression in France, they will not succeed because the French are too attached to this freedom.
Excellent explanation 👏👏
Excellent
I should add an element though on the origin of the name "Charlie".
Charlie Hebdo was created after a previous satirical magazine was outlawed, following an article about the death of former president Charles de Gaulle « Bal tragique à Colombey - 1 mort ». So the name has both Charlie Brown and Charles de Gaulle as origins.
2015 was a sad year in France. I was in the stade de France to see the soccer game France/Allemagne in novembre the 13 when a brutal terrorist attack happened.
Le Monde kind of failed to explain anything with that video. But I guess they assumed the viewer already knew the overall story and motive and the purpose here was only to zoom-in at the chronology.
Yeah this video was not meant to be watched by someone who has no idea what Charlie Hebdo was and who these people were... A better choice of a video for today would have been a "from zero" explanation video. I'm sure there is. Poor guy wouldn't have been so confused all along.
@@luciep9741 Indeed, but I'm impress how he understands quickly a lot of things, and what's interesting is the way of he reacts to the situation, emotion... Thank you, Charlie Bonjour la France
nope it's pure propaganda with hidding of the real cause of the problem
This is a "what happened" video that present what happened that day minute by minute. It is obviously aimed to the french that know what we are talking about.
@@RemplacementTV Qu'est-ce que tu racontes gros ?
In France, the police usually have only handguns (9mm) just as the american police.
10:10 : At this moment, when the jogger was shot 5 times, the weapon used was the tokarev, we are still today not sure who shot the jogger.
Still, the weapon used that time (precisely the same tokarev) was found in possession of the 3rd terrorist of that attack (Ahmedi COULIBALY)
French police officers only have handguns. Unlike in the US, patrol vehicles in France are not armored or reinforced. Faced with weapons of war, they could only retreat.
Only highly armed specialized police teams have special protection equipment and weapons to deal with armed gangs, hostage takers, hijacking’s and terrorists. They have very high level training similar to military special forces. Such teams are permanently located in the main cities and regions of France and can be deployed anywhere very fast. Bigger teams are based in the Paris area headquarters.
@@joso5554nah police officers can carry guns like mp5, not only special forces
🇨🇵🇨🇵❤️Je Suis CHARLIE ❤️🇨🇵🇨🇵 NE JAMAIS OUBLIER 😢😢😢😢
Another satirical magazine is "Le Canard Enchaîné", though it goes more in depth about many stories. In the US there were The Havard/National Lampoon and Mad. More recently, there is The Onion which is both in print and on RUclips.
merci pour tous, j'ai un amie d'enfance qui à vécu ça et il à survécu, mais dès que je l'ai appris, je me suis précipité chez lui il été tout pâle pendant 4 jours d'affilé. encore merci à vous ! ❤🩹
The guy who shot the jogger has not been identified. It was either:
a) An accomplice to the other 3 who was never found nor identified.
b) A totally unrelated guy who was never found nor identified, but whose gun conveniently ended up in the hands of the 3rd terrorist (so highly unlikely).
c) Coulibaly himself, but no element can confirm it as there was seemingly no witnesses at the time and he didn't live to admit it.
Considering Coulibaly had the gun used to shoot the jogger in his possession, the c) is the most likely one.
Hi french here. the 3 guys knew each other and together but they did their things almost at the same time but not in the same place.
To answer your question, in France police can have weapons but not all of them (differences between police departments). Anyway, if you are curious about this event and want to know about an other episode of this "dark year", you can teach yourself what happened on 2015 november the 13th in Paris.
Terrible days and events we never forget.
Sorry for my english.
Peace.
French policeman on the ground is Ahmed Merabet. The person who made the video just put it on facebook for 10 or 15 minutes then the whole network and medias used it as a symbol of this attack. While members of his family had no news about him and were in front of screens showing the scene, but with blur just like in this video. This is a crucial part of these events, the images traumatized tons of people, and a few things that were never explained also pushed for conspiracy theories about his fate and who he was. (I met a couple of members of his family a few months later and before November 13). These are really hard times for France, and I'm afraid islamists here managed to really shock the country and since we live like under collective PTSD). In November we'll have to talk about November 13 again and the scale of the attack will really amaze you... be ready... 2015 is such an infernal year for France.
Hi,
What shocked me was the murder of the little girl in a school in Toulouse in 2012.
@@stf5876 I'm from Toulouse, and yeah that was pure horror
@@HatsuHaruEdit
Hi,
"Qui ne saute pas n'est pas Toulousain !"
I lived the AZF blow.
En France "les droits de l'homme" s'appliquent aux criminels et les policiers ne sont pas armés. ça fait partie de la disparition de la France.
Le monde is a French newspaper
Le Monde is a french newspaper ... gauchiste et n existant que grâce aux subventions de l'état donc des impôts des Français car sinon ça serait la clef sous la porte pour ce torchon..
No it's a french satirical political cartoon magazine
@@Sophie-Oceanits not political. They makes satire on everyone, all boards, all background, all origines, everyone.
@@Sophie-Ocean le Monde is a daily newspaper . Charlie hebdo is a satirical weekly magazine. The Charlie hebdo cartoonists who were killed 10 years ago were very famous . Their drawings disturbed the muslim community . All the demonstrations after their death were to support freedom of expression. 2015 was a terrifying year ending with the Bataclan shooting in November.
@@Sophie-Ocean I'm talking about the newspaper Le Monde that made this video. I'm not talking about Charlie Hebdo
I love how the author subtitles subtly avoid every "Muhammad" or any islam relatedmotivation which led them to start it first. Charlie Hebdo is a magazine that caricaure everyting but one drawing of Muhammad led to all this shit
that's crazy
pour le coup ca parle de la facon dont sa s'est passé pas des revendication ou autre chose. donc non il n'évite pas de parler de ca
@@colonelmoutard28 le contexte aurait été bien. mais je comprend que tué pour un dessin ne dépeigne pas la religion de paix et d'amour d'un bon ton.
@@BonjourCharlie The multiple attacks of 2015 and 2016 highlight the weakness of the French government policy against the police, always frowned upon by politicians and the People, the intelligence services, which knew of the existence of more than 24,000 S ranked extremists and radicalists INSIDE the country, and the almost non-existent controls on immigrants.
@@BonjourCharlie tout ça a été aussi commandité par daesh et Al-Qaïda. La France était engagé en Syrie 😭
Je suis Charlie forever ❤
you might have heard about the other traumatic event, the attack in Bataclan because it happened during the concert of an american band. there were few of these attacks in Paris at the time. it's ten years already but it's not forgotten.
this wave of terrorism was of islamic inspiration and the terrorists were loosely connected between them but there must have been connections to big criminality because of the guns they had, you can't just get hold of those freely in France.
Charlie Hebdo is a newspaper making satirical political cartoons making fun of all politicians, national and international, and of all geopolitical matters.
Hi, I don't know if you'll see this message, but I am French and I don't really speak English. I understood that you were asking about police engagement protocols in France. I don't claim to know everything, but I'm basing this on my own deductions. Basically, in France, the police usually operate in groups of at least 3 and are lightly armed: a handgun, a taser, or pepper spray. This is why, during the Charlie Hebdo attack, the police couldn't do much. However, since these attacks, their equipment has been reinforced. During major events or in big cities with a lot of people, one member of the patrol is now equipped with an assault rifle, like the G3 model.
No it doesn't happen a lot but it had a major impact. The November attack on Bataclan had an even greatet impact imo. You can see the story of the police reaction in the movie November by C. Jiménez
Je suis Charlie = Freedom of speech !
I remember, I was 6 when that happened but I still asked to go on the street with my family and neighbours to support the liberty of the press.
At school a friend asked me if I wanted to make some flyers "Je Suis Charlie" and when I came back with 1 of them at home my mother cried.
What's so important with this attack is that it came from a caricature of the Prophet Mahmood (who was criticizing the Islamists) published in the Charlie Hebdo magazine (along with caricatures of other religions and ohter stuff).
Those acts of terror were (for the terrorist) a revenge but in France the liberty of the press is one of the thing we are the most proud off and when that happened we were all socked. I mean Charlie Hebdo already had a lot of controversies due to their politic and not that much people liked this magazine BUT these attacks were like attacks directly against the France itself (don't forget that our 3 words are: Liberty/Freedom, Equality, Fraternity ).
Mark Moogalian, Alek Skarlatos, Spencer Stone, Anthony Sadler vous êtes des Héros. Attentat du train Thalys le 21 août 2015.
I didn't finish the video yet, but to answer a few questions you asked before I forget :
Charlie Hebdo was a newspaper that was focused on comic cartoons that criticized a bit of everything, I lack the words to explain it in english but basically they made humor with goofy cartoons, they got victim of this attack after publishing a cartoon that was targeting the prophet Mahomet (note that they do this with everyone : religion, politics, as far as I know they were not sided but rather treating every subject the same)
On the question : "Are french policemen armed ?" Yes, but it's mostly since those years of terrorism with Charlie Hebdo and Le Bataclan that you can see police officers with assault riffle in important events, usually they only carry a handgun and at this time I am pretty sure they were not trained to face people equiped with war weapons, we have specialized units for that but they are not patrolling the streets.
Also note that french people are not used to see weapons, unlike us where it's legal, most of us never saw more than a hunting riffle in our life, and I wouldn't be surprised that a lot of people didn't even see one, so it's even more shocking for us to see an AK-47 being used in our streets
French police is armed but only handguns. the Kouachis had ak 47s I believe, may be another type of automatic riffle I'm not sure but it clearly outclassed the police guns. The only police units heavily equipped are the special intervention groups of RAID(national police special force) and GIGN(same thing for the gendarmerie nationale(countryside police that's legally part of the military)). these units are only used for situations with heavy danger (usually anything that includes armed people). That's why the normal police force had trouble fighting the terrorists since they were heavily outgunned.
French police are very much armed especially in Paris
Now, because of those attentats, but not back then..
Yes but they can't use it because it's very limited to use the weapon
Ça a été une vraie peine et des "amis" dessinateurs qui nous manquent encore !!
YOU SHOULD READ THE STORY BEFORE WATCHING THIS VIDEO. Watching this vidéo 📹, you cant understand why , they did those crimes.
Ah parce qu'on peu justifier des crimes ?
Fou vous êtes
Do not forget.
Do not forgive.
They have handguns and some units like the BAC have G36s. But handguns vs kalashnikov...
Now, because of all the attentats in 2015 and since, but not back then. Only spécial forces were armed in 2015.
Therefore the policewoman and men were killed. They had nothing to defend themselves against someone with a gun.
The possession of firearms in France by citizens was legal until 1939 when the Vichist government (the one which surrendered to Germany in 1940) banned it because it feared a revolution. Some people, however, preferred to hide their weapons rather than obey (which was risky because during WW2 being spotted could mean death), also some French people may have inherited undeclared weapons dating from before 1939. Even after the liberation of 1945, the law was never repealed and was even gradually strengthened. People here are used to it and are overwhelmingly against gun ownership.
Nowadays while citizens the acquisition of firearms (legal because there are traffickers) is strictly limited. The most simple and common case involves hunting arms (there are a lot of hunters in France, so they weigh in the elections, so politicians are more careful with them than with other gun owners). Then there are the weapons for sport shooting. Then some exceptional cases for specific professions. All these cases require special procedures.
The last possibility, where the purchase of weapons is free, is the acquisition of historical weapons (dating from before 1900) and considered not very dangerous.
Despite all this, France would be the 2nd country in Europe in terms of the number of arms. At 2010 (France had 65 million inhabitants): 20 to 30 million weapons in total in the country. 10 million legal civilian weapons, including approximately 3 million declared-firearms, most for hunting. And an estimate of 30,000 criminal firearms resulting from trafficking (1% ratio but not same firepower).
I'm really not educated on the subject and I don't understand the Math here, could you give more details please?
1/ What is considered a "weapon" if there are 20 to 30 million weapons in total but only 3 million declared-firearms and an estimate of 30,000 criminal firearms?
I guess a part of them are the legal but not civilian weapons? The ones used by the army (including gendarmes) and the police?
2/ What are the 7 million legal civilian weapons that are not firearms? I genuinely don't know, what one would need a permit for that is not a firearm?
@@neroli_0.0_ In France, weapons are spread across 4 categories. The details of what weapons fall into which category are a bit complex, but for short:
A: anything you would see used in a war, from automatic weapons to explosives and such. You basically cannot own any of that as a civilian.
B: rifles, pistols... your run of the mill firearms. Think america without the occasional spice. You can have these, but you need to be trained, provide proof you're trained to authorities, and get a permit. You will also keep up the training and renew the permit from time to time.
C: Hunting rifles and such. You only need to register the weapon with authorities, no special permit required. You also need to declare any sale of a weapon you owned. The new owner doesn't need to do anything specific unless the previous owner couldn't manage to declare the change of ownership (inheritance cases for instance).
D: anything else, like knives, old rifles that are more museum piece than weapons (from before 1900), that kind of thing. Freely owned and not subject
The numbers given above are a bit outdated and come from studies made in the late 2000's. In 2015, the ministry of interior gave an estimate 10M illegal firearms circulating in the country, and 4M legal ones (owned by 1.4M hunters and 160k sports shooters). Note that these illegal arms include a vast majority of what is called "family weapons", hunting rifles or world war pieces and such for which the family didn't file the proper paperwork after inheriting it from a relative. Regarding overall weapon ownership per capita, ranked against other countries in the world, France fell down the ladder severely, being 23rd in 2017, bellow Germany(8th) and Switzerland(17th).
@@k.v.7681 Thank you for the details!
For Amedy Coulibaly, I think what they mean is that the joger said its wasnt him who shooted in that park. But they found the gun of the terorrist in his bag. Which means it's was a coordinated attcks
For the 3rd man part, they still don't know who shoot that runner guy but they did find the gun with Coulibaly.
so he could still be out there?
It was coulibally
@@BonjourCharlie or a more likely possibility is that it’s simply Coulibaly. Since he had the gun why would it be someone else? They just can’t be sure at 100% since the runner could not identify the shooter and Coulibaly was shot before talking.
@@Sophie-Ocean nobody knows that.
@@BonjourCharlieje suis déjà au courant de l'attentat de 2015 vu que je l'ai vu au informations et en plus j'avais pas besoin d'avoir recours à des sout titres vu que la vidéo que tu regardé était française
For the "Thalys" attack in august 2015, there was 3 american tourist in the train who stopped the terrorist. Clint Eastwood realised a movie about this history. You should know "The 15:17 to Paris".
Je suis Charlie, solidarity message, refers to JFK's "Ich bin ein Berliner !" in West-Berlin in 1963
YES ! Good remark.👍
@@LizzieJaneBennet or maybe it refers to the question the terrorist asked when he walked into the room : " who is Charlie ?"
Because they wanted to shoot Charlie - they thought it was a real person.
Never forget what they did to us. NEVER FORGIVE NEVER FORGET
Never forget who was armed, who was not, who died, who didn't, who got lucky to survive, who wasn't.
Coulybali was lucky. When he shot the policewoman, she and her partner were not armed, not were the city employees there were talking to. If the partner was, Coulybali would have been shot on spot, wounded and maybe killed.
In the shop, the man who grabbed one rifle from him... the rifle didn't jam : its safety was on and the young man didn't know how to switch it off. That's why the rifle didn't operate. What would have happened if HE was carrying a handgun (which is forbidden in France) ?
What would have happened if one of the city employees was carrying a handgun ?
To answer to your question at 06:30, french police had 9mm pistols in 2015 and some unletal weapons (tear gas, taser, etc).
Since this event and the Bataclan massacre, some task force (like BAC, PSIG) has assault rifle, balistic shields and heavy armors in their vehicules in case of mass murder.
These events were so significant for the police that many intervention processes have been reviewed since then, even the even the legal framework for the use of weapons for the police.
My brother was in the police north of Paris at this time and participated in the blockade of the capital.
I remember spending hours watching the 24/7 news channels just in case something happened.
At 5:51 they shout " we avenged prophet Muhammad " that's "forgotten" in the translation .
I watched this video out of curiosity but honestly, it really puts me in distress, I could barely stand it. How could human being reach that level of cruelty !
its sad that people do these things
I guess you are not from France then. 2015 was an awful year for us, and sadly, this attack wasn't the worse one we got that year. I can still remember the fear of November 13, watching the info about everything that was happening, while knowing I had friends around there at that time (one of them was in the Stade de France at the time, I got especially scared for him). I think those events are still a wound for french people, even for those that were not there directly, and I still feel weird hearing and reading the name "Battaclan" even today.
@@oceki3592 I am from France, and I knew what to expect, but still
@@oceki3592 At the time I was 12 years old (13 at the time of Bataclan) and lived all the way in French Guiana. All this was a bit distant by then. I have become much more permeable to news-induced stress now.
@@noefillon1749 Je vois, ça explique des choses. Effectivement pour les habitants des territoires d'outre mer ça a du être vécu différemment que pour ceux qui sont en métropole directement. Je ne sais pas comment vous avez reçu l'information en Guyane française (si c'était en direct ou pas principalement), y compris l'heure qu'il était pour vous quand c'est arrivé parce que ça influence aussi, en plus de la distance entre le lieu de l'attaque et vous.
J'avais 14 ans quand c'est arrivé (presque 15 ans) donc visiblement nous sommes assez similaires en tranche d'âge. Pour ma part, j'ai vraiment vécu tout ça en direct avec les informations, bien que je n'étais pas à Paris à ce moment là. Et le fait que j'avais des amis là bas a contribué à la peur que je ressentais, et je me souviens leur avoir envoyé beaucoup de messages pour m'assurer qu'ils étaient en sécurité (c'est là que j'ai appris qu'un autre de mes amis était au Stade de France et que c'était plus ou moins le chaos).
''Charlie'' Général Charles de gaulle ww2
Créé en 1970 pour remplacer la version hebdomadaire du magazine Hara-Kiri, édité par la même équipe et venant d'être interdit à la suite d'un titre raillant la mort du général de Gaulle, il est publié régulièrement jusqu'en 1981
This video give me goose bump. I'm french so... It's difficult to see these footages
About the question if police officer have guns readily avaliable, yes they do. All national police officers carry a side arm(typically berettas and such), and can be seen patrolling sometimes with SMG/AR (rarely AR unless it's around a sensible place)
Gendarmerie (another type of french police) also often patrols with ump-45 in addition of their side arm
However, patrolling with shoulder weapons became way more often after the charlie hebdo and November 2015 attacks
Des drames que nous n oublierons jamais !
2:20 Final 'e's are silent in French. Many letters are silent.
Je suis Français, croyez-moi ! Ils nous ont rendus plus fort. J'ai une pensée particulière pour les victimes des attentats qui sont devenue les martyrs de la République. On est un peuple libre et fière. Quiconque essait de touché à nos libertés connaîtra le prix du sang et des larmes. Vive la liberté d'expression et vive la France ! Nous sommes tous Charlie.
@BonjourCharlie There's a problem, your video is considered by youtube to be French. This means that the subtitles when you speak are in English.
The biggest scandal is an arms trafficker as soon as the French right is in contact with a policewoman who supplied the weapons to the terrorist
3:19 bro how can u say its a cartoon or a comic don’t u look the subtitles
Hebdo is a shortened for Hebdomadaire meaning Weekly (a weekly journal in that case).
The journal was a satiric journal with lots of caricatures on their covers.
Ironically, their edition adress had recently changed at the time of the terrorist attack. I used to live in the same building of their former location that was more in the center of Paris and my Godmother still lives there. There could have been trouble. Ironically, I'm glad they moved elsewhere months before the attack !
At the end, they say Charlie as "he", but it's a mistranslation. In French, there is no "it" for object etc... only he/she, so it got translated litteraly as "he" which it should've been "it was a marker"
The dude on the bench was actually a fourth person, Coulibaly and the Kouachi brothers weren't related to him
For us, the type of attacks are really rare, this is why the country as a whole is still devastated
J’étais à Paris entrain de fêter l’anniversaire d’un collègue le soir du bataclan vraiment je n’oublierai jamais… ainsi que les 2 tour à New York vraiment entre les deux tour Charlie et le bataclan j’en ai encore les larmes aux yeux. Merci point cette vidéo. Vive la France vive l’Amérique amis pour l’éternité ❤
I’m French and it was horrible because there had already been an attack before at the newspaper Charlie Hebdo and they were not protected as they should have. After there were so many attacks and so many deaths and when we see President François Hollande leading the procession in tribute to all these talented men, simple visitors, police... and that in 2024, This former president has allied himself with a political party that supports the Islamists of Hamas and others, it is disgusting. Today in France, it is worse because the people are not protected or so little and the politicians in power do not care or are complicit. At least in the United States, you can be and defend yourself while we French citizens do not even have the right to legitimate defense and if a man enters our house and we hurt him, he can file a complaint against us! A world of crazy, except that the crazy are all armed.
Every European police force is armed, but only a part of the British police is armed.
Deja 10 ans, damn
Un traumatisme qui va changer notre comportement à jamais. Plus rien ne sera pareil désormais surtout avec les horribles attentats qui suivront le 13 novembre 2015. Le peuple français s'est uni comme jamais pour faire face et défendre notre devise "Liberté-Égalité-Fraternité". Merci aux pays du monde entier qui ont été un soutien incomparable.
Every policeman in France is equiped with a had gun type 9mm but rarely with anything of a biger caliber, some unites have them but thay are not as much every where than in america because these tragical events append extremelly rarlly.
En France si quelqu'un s'introduit chez toi ,et que tu le frappes juste pour le neutraliser,l'individu peut porter plainte pour coups et blessures ! Welcome in France.
The Thalys train attack on August 21, 2015, was foiled by American Military on vacation, who neutralized the terrorist.
The "unidentified guy" is of course a terrorist and might be one of the 3 of this video the problem is, we don’t have any proof that one of the 3 really used this gun
In France, the use of police and gendarmerie weapon are really limited
C'est dramatique. Ils doivent être prêts à risquer leur vie, mais sans avoir trop trop le droit de la défendre non plus...
C'est juste insensé.
@@Bulle.Blanche je suis d'accord
The "insane reason" you are talking about is religion. They did all that because their imaginary friend told them to (or so they believe). That's why it is difficult to understand their behaviour. "Anyone who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities" (Voltaire). Je suis Charlie.
Ce n'est pas qu'une question d'islam.
Al Qaeda et Daesh ont des idéologies inspirées à la fois du fascisme européen et du wahhabisme(et à l'inverse, des groupes identitaires américains s'inspirent de leur idéologie, comme la Atomwaffen division qui a quelques éléments en Europe)
@anaskournif9290 lisez les règles de l'islam sunnite. Ils n'ont dérogé à aucune. Ils sont en jihad, c'est malheureusement ce qui est écrit dans ces dogmes obscurantistes.
@@anaskournif9290 Bah c'est basé que une vision rigoriste de la religion,. C'est pas inspiré plus d'un fascisme que de l'autre. N'importe quelle idéologie incritiquable devient du fascisme. C'est comme un mormon aux Etats-Unis, sauf que le mormon ne tue pas. On va dire sinon comme un Klu k*ux k*an. D'où l'importance de maintenir chez nous la religion loin des institutions publiques pour qu'elle ne devienne pas une source de référence et s'impose à ceux qui ne la suivent pas.
Charlie Hebdo is the name of the satirical journal. Few days before, they posted satirical cartoons about prophet Mahomet .
10 years after we will not forget. It's very important for us that strangers know and react to this event. So, ty for your video.
Je suis Charlie.
C'est vrai que ça n’arrive pas souvent en France ou en Belgique ce genre de chose. Quand ça se passe c’est très grave pour la France. J’espère que tu réagiras à une vidéo des attentats du 13 Novembre 2015 pour les 10 ans
6:13 Yeah, they do have guns. Regular units have small handguns but some brigades can have bigger rifles like the BAC and others.
Charlie Hebdo is an icon of freedom of speech , its a satiric journal . As a french its a real scar ...
I like that a foreign guy wants to learn about our French sad story. But that guy even with English subtitles really can't understand shit 😅
The double hostage situation by 2 coordinating crews was an extremely critical situation for the special police forces because of live news channels (TV, radio, web) giving real time reporting of the detailed situation. Any police raid on one hostage location risked to trigger a revenge bloodbath on the other location. Both police teams had to be fully prepared before any intervention could be launched.
The reason of the attack against Charlie Hebdo is because they re-published a caricature of Mahomet as a terrorist. This was drawn by a Danish drawers and it created huge demonstrations in muslim countries with Danish flash burnt and ambassies attacked. To support their Danish colleagues and defend press freedom, Charlie Hebdo made their front page with it. They knew it was risky that's why they had a police protection.
It was a big shock for everybody to hear that drawers like Cabu (who worked in a famous TV program for Kids when I was a child) or Wolinski (famous satyrical drawer in newspapers) were killed.
Dark times
The "Charlie, he" was a translation mistake. The french language has no equivalent for the pronoun "it". We designate everything, including objects, by either "he" or "she". It should have been translated to "it" in english
btw #JESUISCHARLIE
Charlie Hebdo is a satirical newspaper.
It is full of caricatural drawings, and it has been attacked because of drawings depicting Mahommet, saying "it is hard to be loved by dumbasses" in reaction to 9/11.
ruclips.net/video/hf0EG9KLDGY/видео.html
At the end of the video they speak about the others acts of terrorism that we suffered during the year. If you want there is the film "Novembre" which retraces the events of the biggest attacks of this year (2015).
I'm so glad to be bilingual (French/English) right now.
For the guy in the bench we don't know who it is but we think it's the third terrorist, Amedy Coulibaly, because we found the sane gun on him. But there are 'only' 3 terrorists that have been in contact after and during this 3 awful days.
At the end, the man doesn't talk about Charlie like a person. It's just a very common mistake in translation. French doesn't have a "it" to talk about animals or objects.
6:22 It's the basic "National Police", the situation was probably very confusing, everything is going very fast in only a few minutes. They probably had only SIG-Sauer handguns and weren't expecting to be confronted to two crazy men with assault rifles (AKs, Sa Vz 58, Skorpion VZ61...). Other units always have rifles, not them. GIPN, BRI, RAID, they are on another level... They are the ones fully equipped to neutralize anything. 17:40 Yes, not is such scale (and I guess your next video will be about November 2015, another attacks even more brutal and elaborated). 19:23 It was most likely Amedy Coulibaly but police/justice can't be *100% sure* it was him.
Hi i live in Fontenay aux roses a city in the suburbs of paris, this is were the jogger was shot by "John doe" . The terrorist Coulibaly was also from Fontenay aux Roses and since they found the gun uses for the shooting on him it's most likely Coulibaly was the one involved in the jogger shooting. They can't be 100% sure but we can say 90% that is him who did it
He also killed Clarissa Jean-Philippe in Châtillon wich is a city nearby Fontenay
The 3 guys are in the same team, we suspected A.Coulibaly the third guy's, to be the guy's who's shooting 5 time with a tokarev a runner because he have the tokarev in his stuff when he attack the market.
Grand respect à nos force de l'ordre ❤❤❤
In France, the national police (and the gendarmerie = carabinieri in Italy) routinely wear a loaded handgun. They may be fitted with long weapons on certain occasions or missions.
6:18 Yes the Police have gun in France. In France we have 3 different polices : municipale police ( they have tasers I think. It's a small neighborhood police force, you could say. Then there's the national police and they have pistols (but not with big calibers to compete with terrorists). Otherwise there's the Gendarmerie but it's a police force in principle more rural or outside urban areas in any case (and they are real soldiers much better trained and equipped). But on January 7, 2015, there was no gendarmerie (because there aren't any in urban areas). And so the people on bikes were municipal police officers (with tasers) and in the car they were national police officers (National Police). So it's impossible for them to respond to such caliber. Then we have very heavily armed special police forces, but it's the one we see later in the video (equivalent to SWAT) the GIGN
The municipal police can be equipped with handguns if the city council approves it, and the policemen have the appropriate training and qualification. It’s different in each city. Some cities have no city police at all, especially small villages obviously.
As said by many, french police is split across sections that will have varying degrees of equipment. On the whole, they are not equipped to deal with such situations. Most will have a sidearm. But even with heavier equipment, they are trained to be very cautious when firearms are involved, for everybody's safety, hence why the guys escaped for a while. It's considered better to avoid immediate confrontation in volatile situations, because you never know who will be caught in the crossfire in addition of the problem of you being outgunned. Since they were showing a willingness to flee, better to let them escape and track them down afterwards, giving you the ability to create the scenario for a clean sweep.
Je suis Charlie, et pour la vie …
This is a great channel! Merci de témoigner de l amitié franco américaine sans faille !
Thx for publishing this , those events shaped french and European security against terrorist attacks. Basically a french version of 9/11 a pardon! 11/9.
tu es était ok la première fois, le mois et le jour ;-) 9/11 sept-11
Charlie Hebdo is a French satirical political weekly newspaper based on caricatural drawings.
It was targeted by Islamist radical groups for reproducing satirical drawings of Muslim prophet Mahomet first published by a similar newspaper in the Netherlands if I recall. This happened somewhere around 2006, so 9 years before this slaughter terrorist attack.
charlie hebdo is a very well-known and widely bought newspaper in France where chronicles on current affairs and politics in France are written in the form of caricature illustrations sometimes very contested and questionable and a few weeks before an edition appeared depicting bin laden the cartoonists who were assassinated were very well known to the French and very popular, this created deep horror and fear and affected freedom of expression. This newspaper was extremely daring but they killed them in the worst possible way
in france, the police officers are allowed to wear guns when they are in service in case they need to do an intervention
yes they do have 9mm pistols
C'est dommage qu'on ne puisse pas faire la traduction en français de tes commentaires, on aurait pu t'aider a comprendre se qui c'est passé exactement et répondre aux questions que tu te poses.
🇲🇫 merci pour la video