One honest person among the dishonest politicians who practice double standards. This man must be given obsolute power as he desires to bring back all the black money.... His vision has already contributed much to the progress of our country.. If our country can use remaining few years of his wisely then definitely we would progress tremendously...
Dr Subramanian Swamy is not only a brilliant visionary but a living legend that we all should be proud of. All Indians should run a nation-wide campaign to call upon the Modi government to give Swamy a portfolio that empowers him to deal with high level corruption, blackmoney and related practices.
How can Modi keep him away from cabinet post. He has so much of clarity of work in his mind. More then he is a great economist + nationalist. This combination is almost impossible in today's time.
WE THE PUBLIC OF INDIA CAN ONLY CLAP, LIKE A MOVIE DIALOGUE... VERY SAD. Dear DR. SWAMY YOU ARE A GENIUS AND INDIA NEEDS YOU IN AN EFFECTIVE POSITION. As you said, give you 2 months and the POWER, Put ED under you and RAW & IB under you and the results will come out in good time.
Dr Swamy needs to be made the Prime Minister of India. The post of FM is too less challenge for such a great soul of India. The salaried class should be on the forefront to push for this initiative. Only clapping and positive remarks won't do.
Single Dimensional materialistic society is the reason for the current situation of the society at large globally and India specially. What we need to cultivate is "Simple living and high thinking".
I am a common man but you Are my role model sir l love you for taking on the Holy cow of Congress party who for 70years looted India and thieves staking loot in other country well swarmy Ji go ahead and recover looted India hard earned money notthing is impossible if will is there how this article 370go
It seems mr. Swami may surpass the other ministers if he is made finance minister or some important one and this is an unwanted fear. no doubt,he has a good vision to handle the economical affairs.
Dr . Swami leave 2 months , Modi - Jaitely won't give u power for 2 minutes to do Ur work of bringing back Indian black money . It only proves that hamam mein sab nange Hain !
I could not able to find out fairness in our Union finance minister and also getting doubt about our honourable prime minister because he continuing Jetly as minister.Mr. Narendra Mody may become a specimen as loud speaker and a good actor .But l deserve from him only.God help us to act him accordingly.
I heartly appreciate DrSwamy for his genius knowledge But belittling a great patriot like like N Modi publicly is a sad aspect. Sincerely i feel it may weaken our nation because Modiji a. warrior,,a lion
Let there be a law to hamg those people who have stashed money in foreign accounts and get that money back to India so there would be nobody who could do that!
Why should my legitimate money be handed over to the govt. of India under the fourth method? That will put the onus of showing the money's source on me, for which as an NRI, I will have to unnecessarily deal with the Indian tax authorities, which I am sure will not be a smooth experience.
Why the Indian Government is still supporting Participatory Notes despite their corrupting influence o the Indian economy , and Dr Swamy publicising their negative role in generating foreign investments?
The only way to bring back black money is to let them surrender voluntarily under utmost secrecy. Make them pay flat 30% tax on the money they bring back and they must keep that money into Indian banks from there on, that way it will help Indian banks to lend that amount to startups and also boost housing market. Congress BJP both has crooks...accept it and give them best solution.
modi n co have never been serious abt black money... did de-mon fiasco but dont even consider any of the options undertaken by other nations which swamy highlighted
He is a brilliant guy, no doubt, well educated and well informed. But he is just a lot of talk no action and hence "no use". He has never taken anything he commented on, complained on, and/or taken to the court all the way to the end. Do not tell me that he does not have enough support to get this done. Like the Senior Officers he has mentioned, how much was offered to him and how much he took to keep mouth shut? Is he saying that getting information from the 70 countries will be easy and he is mentioning that the fourth method like the American method is a preferred one? In America, recently New York issued $15,600 worth of cheques to illegal immigrants who lost their jobs due to COVID. This is when many legal tax payers are still looking for their tax refunds to hit their accounts. America cannot get the names of the individuals who got the cheques from New York as New York can withhold this information (Federal Government cannot force the State Government to do it, and if they want to do it some Constitutional changes need to happen for which each of the State Government has to agree (at least 38 out of the 50 States have to agree to such a change). Please note that there are more than 38 Red (Republican) states in the USA but just because these are Red states it does not mean they will now go against the Democratic Government to vote for the Constitutional changes thus making it a cumbersome process). Do not follow anything from USA is my advice. Also, all these four methods he is mentioning all have a loophole that the criminals can escape (laws are generally written with holes to be circumvented by the rich and the powerful). Wasn't he the Minister or Commerce and Industry and then Minister of Law and Justice and is he saying that when he was the minister there was no black money invested outside India? Now he wants the power for two months to bring all the information out? What is it? One Day Chief Minister like movie attempt? He wants to get things done taking them to the Supreme Court? Ask him to take something against Hindus to the Supreme Court and they will act immediately otherwise Supreme Court of India is totally useless as it is in the hands of the wealthy who run the Government.
the average indian makes only about 2 to 3 dollars a day. when is india going to come up with a national living wage legislation ? it is almost 70 years since india got independence. even today india can not provide its population with 24 hour clean water or electricity. we call ourself the largest democracy in the world. is there rule of law in india ? think about it. go to mumbai and see how many people sleep on the side walk or live in the slums. what is the govt doing about it ? i can write so many other things.think about it.
People after a tiresome and misrule by congress gave BJP a big mandate which it has belied and precious time lost and it missed the bus!instead of resorting to foolish steps like demonetisation, a chaotic GST and dabbling with constitutional bodies like RBI,CBI,Planning commission UGC, ....!it could have instituted 1) lokpal to bring down corruption and on the plank it has been.voted to.power! 2) brought judicial reforms 3) electoral reforms 4) police reforms 5) implement DR.swaminathan report for farmers!....why& how do people remember PV now after 25 years only because of the economic reforms he boldly brought about!BJP could have learnt a lesson from recent history .Instead it's leaders were busy in mudslinging , clearing skeletons from their cupboards of their past political career! .
His Bernie Madoff vs Satyam Raju is not entirely correct. It is true Madoff is still in prison but many of his relatives are enjoying his wealth. He ran a Ponzi Scheme worth $60B and if you want to know, there are several senators and congressmen involved in that scheme benefiting from that. What is the use of giving a 150 years jail sentence to a person who was then 78 years old (are they going to find him in his next birth and continue the jail sentence?). I am not saying what they did with Satyam Raju is correct, but please do not create an impression that everything is happening properly in the USA. With Madoff what happened to the $60B and how many of the affected (when you look at it all the greedy investors deserve to lose which is something of a different issue)? Is anyone in the USA talking about Madoff any more? No. Do you know why? Look at the year 2008 and what happened!!!! Economic collapse, a bigger line drawn by the US Government to make the $60B line smaller, the typical USA way of making people forget some issues. US people have very small window of remembering things. Once the economic collapse happened affecting so many innocent, law abiding, clean individuals, they totally forgot about Madoff. Corruption in the US is worse than India but it happens only at the top level and since the people get all the basic necessities delivered without stoppage, they generally do not complain, a situation totally opposite of what happens in India. During this economic collapse, companies like GM (whose executives came to Washington DC in Private jets to ask for bailout, it is like a beggar coming in a Mercedes), Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan etc. and a company called State Street Bank (custodian for several trillion dollars of investments), a company very small compared to the Goldman Sachs or Morgan Stanley or a JP Morgan or a CItigroup or Bank Of America, tool $2B bailout just to be looked at the same level as the other biggies. So many $400M or $300M money were given to green starters. Most of the companies do not exist any more. They all filed for Chapter 11 (so that they can re-emerge in a different name) while investing all this money borrowed in mansions in Florida and other places (please notice that your primary residence will not be taken away when you file for Bankruptcy and hence they all kept their big water view Mansions) and many of them are re-emerging asking for more stimulus money. Folks, USA is not any better than India when it comes to Corruption. At least in India who ever you are, you can get things done if you have money as Corruption is formalized in India, but in the USA, you have to be a lobbyist or someone very close to a Senator or a Congressman to get things done.
Thank god, India has a politician and academician of this calibre. God Bless Swami ji and India.
WhiteTiger1969 /
He is correct with certain things but many of his comparisons and examples are not acceptable.
How many are you waiting to meet him once in a life time? Show your likes
Dr. Swami, a ''Gem of India''
Even out of all the lectures of Dr. Swamy that I have watched, this one was the best.
Country needs this man to become pm
i need this man to become pm for next term.
pledge to support dr swamy
A great Deshbhakt politician , academician etc, we want him to support Pm Modiji for the next many years. God bless him
I always love to listen to his speech.
He excel a lot in all the subject.
Fearless person
He doesn't care for any one
Just brilliant. Courageous, outspoken, delightful person .
One honest person among the dishonest politicians who practice double standards. This man must be given obsolute power as he desires to bring back all the black money.... His vision has already contributed much to the progress of our country..
If our country can use remaining few years of his wisely then definitely we would progress tremendously...
🙏🙏🙏 Hats off to calibre, fighting spirit of Dr.Swamy ji!
Dr Subramanian Swamy is not only a brilliant visionary but a living legend that we all should be proud of. All Indians should run a nation-wide campaign to call upon the Modi government to give Swamy a portfolio that empowers him to deal with high level corruption, blackmoney and related practices.
May God bless such a leader.
Thanks for the great speech Mr. Swamy.
I think He should be Next President Of India.
Great leader and extraordinary knowledge. Deserves to be the Prime Minister
Wow...great speech !
Saluting you Swamiji. May lord Ram bless you with everlasting peace, happiness and knowledge.
TRULY a RAREST of the RARE politician. Wish you live forever sir !
He is genius.
Swami the bestbig fan of him
thank u sir, i promise tht our project will not stop. i as a lawyer will b on ur line of guidance accordingly act upon
This is pure gold
How can Modi keep him away from cabinet post. He has so much of clarity of work in his mind. More then he is a great economist + nationalist. This combination is almost impossible in today's time.
gyanendras 'coz somebody big like Pranab Mukerrji our president may be on the list of black money acct. holders :) :)
HIGHLY TALENTED, EXTREME NATIONALIST, ABSOLUTE HONESTY. AT LEAST SW SHOULD BE MADE THE FINMIN.
WE THE PUBLIC OF INDIA CAN ONLY CLAP, LIKE A MOVIE DIALOGUE... VERY SAD. Dear DR. SWAMY YOU ARE A GENIUS AND INDIA NEEDS YOU IN AN EFFECTIVE POSITION. As you said, give you 2 months and the POWER, Put ED under you and RAW & IB under you and the results will come out in good time.
Great Lecture , brilliantly summed up.
Glad you liked it . please subscribe to the channel
Dr Swamy needs to be made the Prime Minister of India. The post of FM is too less challenge for such a great soul of India. The salaried class should be on the forefront to push for this initiative.
Only clapping and positive remarks won't do.
Abolish participatory notes and income tax! Subramanyam Swamy for next finance minister!!
God bless you
He should be made Finance Minister and with all the rights, power and freedom to achieve the goal
he's a savvy economist.
Modi should give Dr. Swamy 2 Portfolios - (1) Finance Minister and (2) Head of CBI; I really hope Modiji does this!
Single Dimensional materialistic society is the reason for the current situation of the society at large globally and India specially. What we need to cultivate is "Simple living and high thinking".
Swami sir is a Great leader and he should be the finance minister of India.
swamy u r great
As of 2020, top list of countries for foreign investment in India are Singapore ($15.72B), USA ($12.83B), UAE ($3.92B), Mauritius ($3.48B) ....
Brilliant direct speech with concrete suggestions. You cannot but conclude that BJP is dragging its feet only because some of their own are involved.
This man should at least get Nobel prize for economics.
I am a common man but you Are my role model sir l love you for taking on the Holy cow of Congress party who for 70years looted India and thieves staking loot in other country well swarmy Ji go ahead and recover looted India hard earned money notthing is impossible if will is there how this article 370go
If Dr. Swamy becomes P.M imagine how much reforms he can bring to India
I Suggest all 4 methods for India... :)
black money can come, only problem is current fm
Shri sway is brilliant why a BJP govt does not use him beats me are they scared of him?
It seems mr. Swami may surpass the other ministers if he is made finance minister or some important one and this is an unwanted fear.
no doubt,he has a good vision to handle the economical affairs.
Dr . Swami leave 2 months , Modi - Jaitely won't give u power for 2 minutes to do Ur work of bringing back Indian black money . It only proves that hamam mein sab nange Hain !
Ojha sir se padhe ho kya bhai?
Wow a true nationalist
great sage Swamy ji as ever...
Live long swami ! He is a future of India !
I have seen Swamy messing many politicians but I don't see those in return are giving any counter to Swamy
Indirectly swamiji says Modiji incourage corruption if not please appoint swamiji and result is come out
Dr sir Please do something about surplus ( excess) money, Black money, surplus money, fack money are different types
Great job of people holding funds !!!!?????
Rs 120,00,000 crores of black money stashed abroad??!!! Did I hear right!!!! $2 trillion!!!
Will we get the black money ever? Or is the BJP as "GOOD" as UPA in this regard? Let the Supreme court intervene strongly....
I could not able to find out fairness in our Union finance minister and also getting doubt about our honourable prime minister because he continuing Jetly as minister.Mr. Narendra Mody may become a specimen as loud speaker and a good actor .But l deserve from him only.God help us to act him accordingly.
Swamy Please help me... to get my own money
Is there any progress in bringing back black money?
Will it ever happen?
sir,
please bring stay from supreme court to jayalaitha`s case,where judgment given by karnataka high court on 11/05/2015
Sir you said empowerment..RG will say you copied him
Swamy explain in lay man's language how this country is being looted by Chidambaram and Nehru Gandi clan.....
No man have all knoledge,,Ideply
I heartly appreciate DrSwamy for his genius knowledge But belittling a great patriot like
like N Modi publicly is a sad aspect. Sincerely i feel it may weaken our nation because Modiji a. warrior,,a lion
Let there be a law to hamg those people who have stashed money in foreign accounts and get that money back to India so there would be nobody who could do that!
Swamiji I am tired on listening to your speeches , but no black money yet !!!! Launch a agitation and put pressure to bring the black money now !!!
also shown how much i have to receive..... fromSobha Ltd.......
Why should my legitimate money be handed over to the govt. of India under the fourth method? That will put the onus of showing the money's source on me, for which as an NRI, I will have to unnecessarily deal with the Indian tax authorities, which I am sure will not be a smooth experience.
One more misfortune of Indians is not able to see this DemiGod Dr.Swamy as PM.
swamy please help me to see there is law in India.....
Why the Indian Government is still supporting Participatory Notes despite their corrupting influence o the Indian economy , and Dr Swamy publicising their negative role in generating foreign investments?
India is not poor, corruption said we are poor.
Just a big fast gaspot
dear swamy. i will send all my documents..... you show me how a judge of a court... can dismiss the case without seeing any papers of a complement?
Britain will exit the EU and wants a trade deal with India .......Could Mr Swamy make a deal to allow all relevant details in Btitish Tax havens?
Now u know why swamy can never become fm
WHAT'S IS HIS NATIONALITY OF PAPPUUUUUUU❓❓❓❓❓
HOW COME AUTHORITIES ARE UNABLE TO ANSWER THIS ❓❓
I paid as per Income as per government law....
I am able to leave my margin Amount also....
Bring ordinance in parliament to bring back money abroad who is opposing is a chor
The only way to bring back black money is to let them surrender voluntarily under utmost secrecy. Make them pay flat 30% tax on the money they bring back and they must keep that money into Indian banks from there on, that way it will help Indian banks to lend that amount to startups and also boost housing market. Congress BJP both has crooks...accept it and give them best solution.
modi n co have never been serious abt black money... did de-mon fiasco but dont even consider any of the options undertaken by other nations which swamy highlighted
He is a brilliant guy, no doubt, well educated and well informed. But he is just a lot of talk no action and hence "no use". He has never taken anything he commented on, complained on, and/or taken to the court all the way to the end. Do not tell me that he does not have enough support to get this done. Like the Senior Officers he has mentioned, how much was offered to him and how much he took to keep mouth shut? Is he saying that getting information from the 70 countries will be easy and he is mentioning that the fourth method like the American method is a preferred one? In America, recently New York issued $15,600 worth of cheques to illegal immigrants who lost their jobs due to COVID. This is when many legal tax payers are still looking for their tax refunds to hit their accounts. America cannot get the names of the individuals who got the cheques from New York as New York can withhold this information (Federal Government cannot force the State Government to do it, and if they want to do it some Constitutional changes need to happen for which each of the State Government has to agree (at least 38 out of the 50 States have to agree to such a change). Please note that there are more than 38 Red (Republican) states in the USA but just because these are Red states it does not mean they will now go against the Democratic Government to vote for the Constitutional changes thus making it a cumbersome process). Do not follow anything from USA is my advice. Also, all these four methods he is mentioning all have a loophole that the criminals can escape (laws are generally written with holes to be circumvented by the rich and the powerful). Wasn't he the Minister or Commerce and Industry and then Minister of Law and Justice and is he saying that when he was the minister there was no black money invested outside India? Now he wants the power for two months to bring all the information out? What is it? One Day Chief Minister like movie attempt? He wants to get things done taking them to the Supreme Court? Ask him to take something against Hindus to the Supreme Court and they will act immediately otherwise Supreme Court of India is totally useless as it is in the hands of the wealthy who run the Government.
the average indian makes only about 2 to 3 dollars a day. when is india going to come up with a national living wage legislation ? it is almost 70 years since india got independence. even today india can not provide its population with 24 hour clean water or electricity. we call ourself the largest democracy in the world. is there rule of law in india ? think about it. go to mumbai and see how many people sleep on the side walk or live in the slums. what is the govt doing about it ? i can write so many other things.think about it.
People after a tiresome and misrule by congress gave BJP a big mandate which it has belied and precious time lost and it missed the bus!instead of resorting to foolish steps like demonetisation, a chaotic GST and dabbling with constitutional bodies like RBI,CBI,Planning commission UGC, ....!it could have instituted 1) lokpal to bring down corruption and on the plank it has been.voted to.power! 2) brought judicial reforms 3) electoral reforms 4) police reforms 5) implement DR.swaminathan report for farmers!....why& how do people remember PV now after 25 years only because of the economic reforms he boldly brought about!BJP could have learnt a lesson from recent history .Instead it's leaders were busy in mudslinging , clearing skeletons from their cupboards of their past political career!
.
His Bernie Madoff vs Satyam Raju is not entirely correct. It is true Madoff is still in prison but many of his relatives are enjoying his wealth. He ran a Ponzi Scheme worth $60B and if you want to know, there are several senators and congressmen involved in that scheme benefiting from that. What is the use of giving a 150 years jail sentence to a person who was then 78 years old (are they going to find him in his next birth and continue the jail sentence?). I am not saying what they did with Satyam Raju is correct, but please do not create an impression that everything is happening properly in the USA. With Madoff what happened to the $60B and how many of the affected (when you look at it all the greedy investors deserve to lose which is something of a different issue)? Is anyone in the USA talking about Madoff any more? No. Do you know why? Look at the year 2008 and what happened!!!! Economic collapse, a bigger line drawn by the US Government to make the $60B line smaller, the typical USA way of making people forget some issues. US people have very small window of remembering things. Once the economic collapse happened affecting so many innocent, law abiding, clean individuals, they totally forgot about Madoff. Corruption in the US is worse than India but it happens only at the top level and since the people get all the basic necessities delivered without stoppage, they generally do not complain, a situation totally opposite of what happens in India. During this economic collapse, companies like GM (whose executives came to Washington DC in Private jets to ask for bailout, it is like a beggar coming in a Mercedes), Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan etc. and a company called State Street Bank (custodian for several trillion dollars of investments), a company very small compared to the Goldman Sachs or Morgan Stanley or a JP Morgan or a CItigroup or Bank Of America, tool $2B bailout just to be looked at the same level as the other biggies. So many $400M or $300M money were given to green starters. Most of the companies do not exist any more. They all filed for Chapter 11 (so that they can re-emerge in a different name) while investing all this money borrowed in mansions in Florida and other places (please notice that your primary residence will not be taken away when you file for Bankruptcy and hence they all kept their big water view Mansions) and many of them are re-emerging asking for more stimulus money. Folks, USA is not any better than India when it comes to Corruption. At least in India who ever you are, you can get things done if you have money as Corruption is formalized in India, but in the USA, you have to be a lobbyist or someone very close to a Senator or a Congressman to get things done.