Throwing A Portal Into Another Portal (and other portal experiments)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 331

  • @UndeadJester1
    @UndeadJester1 Год назад +67

    Couple ideas - attaching the portals to either side of a suspension glitch that flings it around everywhere - and making an AI that follows you and tries to catch you with a portal attached to it that may or may not send you to your death.

  • @stevepittman3770
    @stevepittman3770 Год назад +32

    5:59 Multiplayer Monday idea! Each player builds a small castle and then you get a certain amount of time with one of those blocks with 2 portals on it and a hammer to destroy as much as you can. Last castle standing wins.
    Also, put the 2 portals on either side of a block on a bearing and spin it while pushing it into things, that might be interesting!

    • @Thagrynor
      @Thagrynor Год назад

      Or, instead of a hammer, a catapult that launches the block with the 2 portals on it. The guys have to build both the castle as well as the "ammo" and the catapult.

    • @RealPanzer999
      @RealPanzer999 Год назад

      @@Thagrynor One mistake & you could need another catapult. XD

    • @Thagrynor
      @Thagrynor Год назад

      @@RealPanzer999 You say that like it's a negative 🤣🤣

    • @RealPanzer999
      @RealPanzer999 Год назад

      @@Thagrynor Well didn't mean it to be negative... so ups XD

  • @kittyn5222
    @kittyn5222 Год назад +167

    Me who watched minute physics:

  • @Necromorph790
    @Necromorph790 Год назад +15

    Think of portals as nothing other than a door from one point to another, if the door-well frame I suppose comes flying at you, while you're standing still, you come out of the other side not moving as well. However if you were to say, bust through the door/run through the frame, you'd go flying out the other side. Same applies to the portal that comes at you in this case

    • @j.hawkins8779
      @j.hawkins8779 Год назад +8

      except that that is from your frame of reference. a portal moving at you and you moving at a portal are indistinguishable.

    • @DaysofKnight
      @DaysofKnight Год назад +3

      @@j.hawkins8779 But since you yourself are not carrying momentum, what reason within the laws of physics would you have to go flying out the other side with zero momentum going in?
      GladOS said it perfectly: "Speedy thing goes in. Speedy thing comes out."

    • @j.hawkins8779
      @j.hawkins8779 Год назад +4

      @@DaysofKnight it would violate relativity: *there is no "absolute frame of reference".* you dont have momentum compared to what? the portal? the ground? an outside observer? please watch minute physics' video on this exact discussion.

    • @DaysofKnight
      @DaysofKnight Год назад +2

      @@j.hawkins8779 Compared to yourself, and the world. The portal has momentum, not you.
      I feel like you're being aggressive for no reason on this, and trying to push something??
      The momentum you carry equals zero because you yourself are not moving relative to the ground. The portal moving doesn't impart momentum onto you.
      Again "Speedy thing goes in. Speedy thing comes out."
      I've seen plenty of MinutePhysics. I've seen his portal videos.
      It's all theoretical thought and assumptions. Since, Portals themselves aren't real. Though a good channel, it's not something you should refer to, to prove a point, or to prove fact.
      Yes, many of his videos are accurate, those on portals are not. Since again, Portals are not real.
      To me, what makes more sense, is that you wouldn't be shot out of the end Portal, just because the beginning Portal has it's own momentum.
      You can kind of test this in real life, to a degree. Cut a hole in something flat, then shove that flat thing into a ball. Does the ball come flying out of the other side? No, it wouldn't, because the ball itself has no initial momentum to carry it through, flying out the other side.
      Portal momentum wouldn't impart velocity or momentum onto the thing passing through it.
      The object passing through it, needs its own momentum to fly out the other side.
      You can't get something from nothing, in this case.
      Because by our basic understanding of a Portal, all it does is move something from Point A to Point B. It doesn't take Object 1 and add something to that object between Point A and Point B.
      Make sense now?

    • @j.hawkins8779
      @j.hawkins8779 Год назад +2

      @@DaysofKnight im not trying to be aggressive, nor do i have any agenda, im just trying to say that it wouldn't make sense in the real world. sure, portals may just be theoretical, but that doesn't mean they don't follow relativity. if the portal doesn't shoot out a static object, that means that that objects frame of reference is the "correct" one, and thus absolute, which we know for a fact physically can't exist. i get what you're saying, and it would make sense in a video game, im just saying it couldn't happen in real life (and, lets be honest here, this is a scrap mechanic video, scrap mechanic isn't exactly a game known for realistic physics).

  • @qritical743
    @qritical743 Год назад +26

    hey scrap man just wanna let you know your content right now is really good

    • @infinitescream
      @infinitescream Год назад

      It’s crazy how he hasn’t run out of ideas yet

  • @jacobgatton525
    @jacobgatton525 Год назад +12

    What about a multi-player race with portals? Where the track slowly gets eaten away throughout the race

  • @onuathecreator5775
    @onuathecreator5775 Год назад +4

    I think that momentum is not connected to the speed of the portal, but rather the speed of the object passing threw it. This is because a portal that moves simply changes in distance from the other portal, and if the object isn't moving there will be no momentum to to transfer.

  • @ComicDig2004
    @ComicDig2004 Год назад +1

    9:48 multiplayer Monday idea!
    You use this creation and play snake.

  • @colbywilson8790
    @colbywilson8790 Год назад +5

    Scrapman, I’m sure you are aware, but just in case you aren’t, Teardown has a new expansion that, I’m sure I speak for a lot of your audience when I say, we’d love to see you play it.

  • @morrow2869
    @morrow2869 Год назад +5

    Day 281 of asking for more workshop hunters, and day 282 of asking for more brick rigs
    For all of you that wants any of these you can help too

  • @pawlik1004
    @pawlik1004 Год назад +7

    Would be sick to see some escape rooms with this mod

  • @phoenixrising3538
    @phoenixrising3538 Год назад +1

    Physicists on Earth: how the hell do we gather enough negative energy and antimatter to satisfy the energy requirements to sustain a portal.
    Scrapman: what are you talking about even? Just put it on a block... Put it on wheels and drive on them.

  • @Skyblade12
    @Skyblade12 Год назад +1

    The multiplayer potential from these experiments is just amazing.

  • @sixfthree
    @sixfthree Год назад +4

    I think it would be like 2 cars driving at 60mph and hitting head on. They do not hit at 120mph of force but only at 60mph (thank you Mythbusters). So since you are not moving when the portal hits you, you have no momentum to transfer.

  • @gamerxdpro9112
    @gamerxdpro9112 Год назад +2

    physics on games are a little bit weird and i like this video keep it up scrapman

  • @Circle9ru
    @Circle9ru Год назад +1

    5:16 ScrapMan: **move the portal placed 90 degree to block and it makes a long hole exactly 1 block wide** Well, that was a surprising result
    Me: **looking at regular saw blade** I know how to upgrade you! **evil laungh**
    12:06 you're wrong. the mod portal works exactly as it would work in reality. portal is not "this part of reality moving towards me", its a curved space, curved enough to connect 2 places, if it moves towards you, it means the place behind portal become closer to you. its like open door. lets say you stand in the room with some wall with the door in the middle, the wall moves with door on it, it can simply pass you and you still stand on the same spot, but you're now behind the wall. that's exactly how the portal would work in realy.

    • @maratby4364
      @maratby4364 Год назад

      on a similar note, I think the portals on the ground don't work because the character hits the floor at the same time as entering the portal, they would probably conserve momentum if you didn't hit the ground before entering them. Probably because their collision is really flat and you hit the ground as you enter (or clip through the ground) which is shown in the top + bottom portal loop as the player enters the landing animation every time they loop through the portals. The bots also took damage when they went through the ground portals at high speeds, because they hit the ground at high speed and thus lost all their speed.
      i would put this in a regular comment, but youtube doesn't let me post comments for some reason.

  • @DigitalJedi
    @DigitalJedi Год назад

    That floor-eating car looks like it would be awesome for multiplayer spleef. Make the floor a couple layers deep so you can have fun getting stuck, but people can also cut out chunks and fall through. Or, just make it solid all the way down and play it as the last person able to move wins.

  • @DreadEnder
    @DreadEnder Год назад +1

    12:00 no the portal has a high velocity relative to you but you have a low velocity relative to it so all it’s like is if you were standing still and had a door thrown at you, the portal will retain momentum not the person

  • @OnyxBMW
    @OnyxBMW Год назад

    As a note, you wouldn't retain momentum if a portal ran through you. The portal is moving, you are not. It'd be more akin to a Doctor Strange portal where your environment changes around you (or disappears from around you in the case of getting dropped in the sky) but you wouldn't maintain any momentum, at least in a vacuum.
    Now here's the interesting question. If you place a portal on one gravitational body, and put its exit on another, they both are moving differently relative to each other. What would happen to the momentum you had when walking through? It'd be the coriolis effect, on steroids. Possibly.

  • @sethcushman5454
    @sethcushman5454 Год назад

    In the real world, I believe most scientists would agree a theoretical portal/wormhole would "spit" you out with speed if one of the portals was pushed into you with speed. Because you moving quickly through a portal is just a different frame of reference of the portal moving quickly into you.

  • @anthropillar
    @anthropillar Год назад

    PLEASE DO A MULTIPLAYER MONDAY WITH THIS!!! That would be SO COOL

  • @snelake
    @snelake Год назад

    Guys, you don’t have to have discussions about relativity because scrap mechanic portals don’t preserve momentum reliably.
    That’s a video game thing, not a real-life science thing.
    You probably hit the surface the portal is attached to and then get teleported through, meaning you have no momentum since you hit the wall.

  • @triangle8181
    @triangle8181 Год назад

    Multiplayer Monday idea:
    You play cat and mice
    Each persons must build a cat:
    A vehicle with a cage (with a portal) and a mechanism that can eat the mice with the portal.
    And a mice:
    A veicale that can avoid the cat.
    The cat that can catch them the quickest wins!

  • @B_Poort
    @B_Poort Год назад

    This could be fun for multiplayer Monday, a race where you can eat each others cars

  • @somedudenamedjuno1301
    @somedudenamedjuno1301 Год назад

    You could literally play spleef if you put a portal behind your car, low enough to delete blocks and have only a single layer of blocks to drive on. Grab a few friends and have fun

  • @4biel910
    @4biel910 Год назад +1

    Multiplayer monday idea: play catch but the catcher has portals on their car that they use to catch and eat the cars. winner is the person who can disable the cars in the least amount of time.

  • @c_death
    @c_death Год назад

    What about the (destructible) trees and rocks??? those could be fun to mess with. Drive into trees, drop whole trees into portal, do the big rocks work, small rocks? Etc! I watch you every video Scrapman and always fun and entertaining!

  • @bizzybeezs7208
    @bizzybeezs7208 Год назад

    Okokok I got a multiplayer Monday idea from this! Use the portal mod and make a sort of spleef! Make a car and have portals placed on the bottom while driving over layers of cardboard!

  • @crispylasagna
    @crispylasagna Год назад

    I feel like portals on cars could make an interesting Multiplayer Monday

  • @MrMattkid
    @MrMattkid Год назад

    I would say that being hit by a moving portal wouldn't impart any momentum, because it would be like moving the eye of a needle onto a thread. The thread just passes through, or better feeding a rope through a window it would just coil up on the ground in front of the window.

  • @danser_theplayer01
    @danser_theplayer01 Год назад +1

    Portal gun is now a portal canon judging by how loose portals can eat blocks.

    • @Poldovico
      @Poldovico Год назад

      Rick and Morty portals are just not as good as the Aperture OGs.

  • @kitty_foreststreamvods4116
    @kitty_foreststreamvods4116 Год назад

    10:00 that car with the diagonal portals could be a multiplayer monday idea... you race on a track made of a thick layer of blocks and anyone whos not in first would have a bad time, and then of course theres the 2nd lap

  • @caycelusinger3580
    @caycelusinger3580 Год назад

    For a multi-player Monday you guys should make an escape room that uses the portals

  • @phoenixrising3538
    @phoenixrising3538 Год назад

    The fact that the portals decided to only consume and transport certain types of matter and didnt mind being used as wheels is blowing my mind... Ooooh i have to show this to shoddycast

  • @Moon_Lord18
    @Moon_Lord18 Год назад

    If scrap man and the boys do a build off that is also a battle in the end, he could use the portals to fight

  • @travislapham3479
    @travislapham3479 Год назад

    That was interesting yet funny and scrapman I was thinking that maybe you could have a portal in one spot and another portal underground and then try to build underground using the portal system

  • @Brandon-LB
    @Brandon-LB Год назад +1

    Multiplayer Monday idea!
    player seeking Portal Olympics..... ill delete your build as you complete the challenges

  • @thesleepingone
    @thesleepingone Месяц назад

    I see it as my momentum and velocity not the portals. You end up pushing yourself out of the other side. Instead of flying out you might get some weird g-force damage from each piece of yourself pushing against the one in front. Might also create a strange phenomenon where you moving through at high speed is fine but the portal moving the same high speed might crush you out the other side.

  • @MrGoodman1998
    @MrGoodman1998 Год назад

    I wish this was a bit more recent so these would be seen but you need to move fast through the portal to retain any momentum

  • @Just_A_Panther_Tank
    @Just_A_Panther_Tank Год назад

    Idea: Make a multiplayer Monday challenge that’s pretty much tnt run from Minecraft so the floor disappears out from under you using those portals

  • @omgtntlol
    @omgtntlol Год назад +1

    day 47 of asking scrapman to do a multiplayer where everyone starts at the crashed ship with a craftbot already at the mechanic station and everyone has 30 minutes to build a vehicle from scratch, no glitches, thrusters allowed, after which everyone meets up and races along some road

  • @Chris-ok4zo
    @Chris-ok4zo Год назад

    I feel like Scraps accidentally made makeshift destruction/mud physics using the portals. And also I believe Cave Johnson might offer an internship to this man.

  • @Anti-Smart
    @Anti-Smart Год назад

    "Portal thrown at you"
    When this was said my brain went immediately to portal grenade.

  • @SneakyTogedemaru
    @SneakyTogedemaru Год назад

    Now we need mod that adds bloodborn pizza cutter, but with portals instead of sawblades

  • @DantheGif
    @DantheGif Год назад

    I can't wait to see how Portals effect Multiplayer Mondays

  • @lucaswakefield9237
    @lucaswakefield9237 Год назад

    Using multiple portal guns you can make infinite portals so you could do many more experiments

  • @straightasaspline
    @straightasaspline Год назад

    Multiplayer Monday idea, ur vehicle destroys the road your on as u drive and u have to cross a massive series of canyons

  • @deserted_1013
    @deserted_1013 Год назад

    scrapman is becoming more and more like gen z every episode

  • @seanfitzgerald9815
    @seanfitzgerald9815 Год назад

    Yep single block double portal needs to be mmm destruction game

  • @lowbatteryg4mer214
    @lowbatteryg4mer214 Год назад +1

    It's amazing how well your channel his doing. It seems like just yesterday you were at 200k. Keep up the great work.

  • @wizardbadger2728
    @wizardbadger2728 Год назад

    Multiplayer Monday, destruction Derby race with portals on the cars

  • @billywilliams8752
    @billywilliams8752 Год назад

    Using them as a mining car it gives you a more natural tunnel/cave like build

  • @jamesdomitrovich9681
    @jamesdomitrovich9681 Год назад

    Did you know that if you add 4 small curved pipe pieces on a small wheel facing inwards it will cause the wheel to drift

  • @ezrawilson7644
    @ezrawilson7644 Год назад

    Idea for Multiplayer Monday, you cold do portal spleef with the wedge portals on the car

  • @bobisha772
    @bobisha772 Год назад

    Multiplayer monday race with the angled portal cars where the track is made out of blocks so as you drive it makes the course more difficult for the other racers.

  • @Ryoneln
    @Ryoneln Год назад

    I would love to see for a multiplayer monday idea, portal jousting

    • @Ryoneln
      @Ryoneln Год назад

      like making jousting vehicles with a single block wide pole/beam and attach a portal at the end of it to attempt to eat each others vehicles in a jousting type idea

  • @RecycleBin26
    @RecycleBin26 Год назад

    What if you guys made a winter MM where you make snow plows and you use portals to pick up the snow and then blow it out another portal like irl.

  • @jewlyienboyd8776
    @jewlyienboyd8776 Год назад

    with those portals on slopes. (if the portals work on Multiplayer) you can make a sploof game or what ever it is drive around and it destroys the blocks below it so the other players fall through

  • @edenbwicey7250
    @edenbwicey7250 Год назад +1

    What about setting the portals together in a v shape with slopes on the piston then dropping them onto the block, surely then they wouldn't get stuck

  • @GammaG.O.D
    @GammaG.O.D Год назад +2

    What if you and kan did a digging competition with this mod

  • @LoveableLina
    @LoveableLina Год назад

    The portals velocity that you start from wouldn't matter in terms of how fast you would be moving in the end. It's the end portals movement that would determine how fast your moving. But again it's theoretical so even having a portal that can move would be more then likely disasters for your body. Lol think of it like this one part of you is on the still side and the other that is moving at any speed as both keeping your body still but moving your body at the same time. So imagine sticking your arm out the window while on the highway but the window is a portal transporting your atoms across space and one part of your body is completely still all the other part is moving lol I can't imagine it would be a good feeling

  • @toxicara
    @toxicara Год назад

    The portal on the stick is getting destroyed when the block it's attached to is destroyed, that's obvious enough. But the centre of the portal on the wall is off to the side. This is it's anchor point which is not getting got by the stick portal.

  • @link_is_here22
    @link_is_here22 Год назад

    On the topic of getting a portal thrown at you
    I was always under the impression you wouldn’t retain the velocity of the portal, but maintain whatever velocity you were moving at before? As the portal isn’t technically imparting any force on you, no acceleration should be applied, right? If you were to move at the speed of the portal, some amount of force would need to be applied in order to accelerate you, which just isn’t happening

  • @Honored_racist_one
    @Honored_racist_one Год назад

    Bering=o
    Block=b
    Portal=()
    () b b o
    b
    o b b o
    So its spinning circle while having a portal

  • @ewancoppens3193
    @ewancoppens3193 Год назад +1

    Mod devs: here is a portal mod
    Scrapman 10 minutes in the video: 10:12

  • @danyael777
    @danyael777 Год назад

    Imagine a racetrack with those sloped portal racers.

  • @ruanb2418
    @ruanb2418 Год назад

    Imagine survival with this mod

  • @fergusalano4388
    @fergusalano4388 Год назад

    10:24 you can play spleef with this vehicle (i think)

  • @steeljawX
    @steeljawX Год назад

    Can a portal warp stop an explosion/do trashed explosives still detonate if they've been triggered?
    Can resources be portalled and do they stay valid or are they rendered into garbage?
    Portal shield. Get a tape bot to shoot at you only to have a portal yeet its tape back at it. That being said, can you send the Farm Bot's chemical blobs back at it as well?

  • @jaxonheadrick6131
    @jaxonheadrick6131 Год назад

    Also with the portal question it’s like a door way and it slides your way and it goes over you you’ll still be at the same speed

  • @remi1959
    @remi1959 Год назад

    Multiplayer Monday idea a crazy portal that going around and you have to survive it eating your car.

  • @Fallout81
    @Fallout81 Год назад

    the portal car gave me an idea and a question, do drills break cardboard? and if they do can you make a drill car?

  • @BLKBRDSR71
    @BLKBRDSR71 Год назад

    7:34 at this point you made a boring machine. Now you can mine through anything (Almost).
    Also what effect would a portal have on trees? Like can you destroy an entire forest?

  • @elarbuztheprotogen7376
    @elarbuztheprotogen7376 Год назад

    Make a escape room that uses portals in the next multiplayer monday.
    Maybe make a rule that you only can put portals on white surfaces like in the original portal game.

  • @acdctrain
    @acdctrain Год назад

    This would be a fun addition to survival... make a car with a portal on front and have it teleport bots you hit into a bot crusher. 😂

  • @LeeBayliss98
    @LeeBayliss98 Год назад

    9:37 Multiplayer Monday idea?

  • @draysoncrook4898
    @draysoncrook4898 Год назад

    You can equip more that one portal gun for more Portals

  • @demonoverlord6385
    @demonoverlord6385 Год назад

    You should do a multi-player Monday portal car race with obstacles you can destroy with the portals

  • @VENOMBGAlexRasiyski
    @VENOMBGAlexRasiyski Год назад +1

    Scrapman can you recreate the Martin 262 Convoy Fighter ?

  • @The-knucklehead.
    @The-knucklehead. Год назад

    next episode should be workshop hunters on trailmakers. i may have made some vehicles for you to try out.

  • @caewing85
    @caewing85 Год назад

    Shoot a spud through two portals and see what happens…maybe an infinite spud loop? My son’s idea. :)

  • @victorrivera2655
    @victorrivera2655 Год назад

    I dont think having a portal thrown at you works that way because you dont have momentum so it makes sense if you we’re thrown at the portal then youd have momentum coming out the second portal but having a portal thrown at you while youre standing still is just the portal with all the momentum and velocity and all Youre really doing is getting moved from one point to another

  • @villekorhonen824
    @villekorhonen824 Год назад

    Do sensors still register the color or overall existence of block send through portal?

  • @kukackis5051
    @kukackis5051 Год назад

    Idea: froving some thing into two portals at once

  • @JohnJCB
    @JohnJCB Год назад

    6:57
    This is the PH
    7:10
    Let me reiterate the is the PH

  • @michalc1018
    @michalc1018 Год назад

    i want multiplayer monday with this

  • @Daymusik
    @Daymusik Год назад

    I don't know if you made this video after happening across the ASAP Science/5MinutePhysics video talking about portals and sending portals through each other; I also don't know if my follows suggest is possible if Scrap Mechanic, but if it is possible, you should try inserting a portal into the other one at an angle. Not directly perpendicular to each other.

  • @Im_Merobiba_
    @Im_Merobiba_ Год назад +1

    Portal spleef multiplayer monday

  • @leannelow5788
    @leannelow5788 Год назад

    Try making a vehicle narrow enough to be within the portals footprint, and then put one portal on each end of the car. The vehicle you used this video extended beyond the portal.

  • @dhoonzafar4486
    @dhoonzafar4486 Год назад

    Imagine the plasma saw behaves L
    like this 6:00

  • @nekowknight
    @nekowknight Год назад

    Portals have multiple possibilities because like the state you where in is the state you come out so even though the portal has energy you do not, or if you hit the portal as 100mph you exit so you can be right and wrong at the same time it's like schordingers cat theory

  • @NoNNNNN
    @NoNNNNN Год назад

    I mean if you are standing still as the portal comes towards you. You are not moving so you would just appear through the portal really fast. I think

  • @funpol-ice1247
    @funpol-ice1247 Год назад +1

    Make this into a saw blade machine

  • @carlosshavo3558
    @carlosshavo3558 Год назад

    Ironically since the last Sunday this vid became more and more referencial to Rick and Morty

  • @red-black8138
    @red-black8138 Год назад

    ~ 12:10 your getting negative velocity if im right out of it.

  • @spencerp_6067
    @spencerp_6067 Год назад

    6:14 did he say third things first 🤣

  • @gaminghub8108
    @gaminghub8108 Год назад

    Claim your prize of “Within 1 hour” here….:)
    Fun fact: Scrap Mechanic used to run on a different physics engine (Ogre, also used on Roblox) until they made their own from Axolot Games

  • @nionanoman4800
    @nionanoman4800 Год назад

    this gives me an idea..
    mole/drill multiplayer Monday. kinda imagine volcanoid game treasure hunt

  • @somerandomguy5120
    @somerandomguy5120 Год назад

    Video idea Workshop hunters vs portals

  • @catmanaz6975
    @catmanaz6975 Год назад

    portal spleef with the 'get stuck in the mud car'