What is the Biggest Carnivore the World has Ever Seen?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 июн 2022
- In the newest Jurassic World film Dr. Allen Grant claims that the giganotosaurus is the largest carnivore that the world has ever seen. But is that actually true?
Music by Approaching Nirvana
/ approachingnirvana
Song: Jurassic Park Theme Remix
Listen to the song on Spotify: bit.ly/AN_Spotify
Totally didn’t forget Carcharodontosaurus hahahahahahah that would be so funny right…
To be fair, that dino does get overlooked a lot.
Mapusaurus is actually larger than carcharodontosaurus and giga
@@syedhussaini2207 longer but I think slightly lighter, correct?
No it’s the opposite,suprsingly mapusaurus outweighs them both
Mapusaurus actually outweighs the giga by around 200 kg.It’s possible giga is larger but due to the lack of specimens we have the answer is still inconclusive.
The spinosaurus in Camp Cretaceous is the same individual from JP3 and it’s fully grown, at around 15.2 metres long and 6-7 metres tall at the top of the sail. This makes it 50 feet long, one of the two largest carnivores of the franchise, tied with the Indominus Rex fully grown.
The Spinosaurus from camp Cretaceous is not the same, in canon JP3 it stated that the Spinosaurus died from the velociraptor pack on Isla Sorna. The Camp Cretaceous Spinosaurus is different.
@@aamirsgalaxy5123 the show makers confirmed it’s the same individual from Sorna, the JP3 ending where the raptors take down the Spinosaurus was scrapped.
@@aamirsgalaxy5123 no it didn’t that was a cut scene in the movie that never even saw light, Nice head canon bud
@@wyattbhoffman Then explain the difference in noises and roars, and also explain the change in patterns on its skin, the Spinosaurus would’ve had the same looks if it aged, they wouldn’t change the patterns on the skin if it wasn’t a different Spinosaurus. Also, Jurassic world evolution 2 (a canon Jurassic world game) shows the exact comment I said.
@@aamirsgalaxy5123 Bud, that was in a chaos theory gamemode a what if scenario, the only thing “Canon” about Jurassic Word evolution 2 is the campaign mode not chaos theory which is where that scene took place, ITS NOT CANON.
R.I.P. to all the Carcharodontosaurus fans.
fr F
My favorite dinosaur is easily the Spinosaurus, I grew up watching dinosaur documentaries and the jurassic park movies and the Spinosaurus was equally majestical in both of them, im just horribly sad that its not in the move
Same
Same
same
Same here. Disappointed😓😮💨
Same
i think now scientists say that despite not being the longest or tallest, T-Rex was actually the heaviest, because was bulkier and had more muscles than the Spino and Giga.
Actually spino weight is very under developed and is still in research but some estimates put it at 12 metric tons
I seen spino put on scale of 10 to 11 tons
Rex is 11 tons
@@stonefist8590 where are you getting your information? I haven't seen that anywhere... The consensus is that an average T-Rex was near 7-8 tons. Spino like someone said is under developed and you can find different scientific estimations.
It new but not new rex goes 10700 to 10900 kilograms all u do is convert it to metric tons which in range of 10-11 tons many was stated as by rex Skelton called Scotty I think 2 months ago maybe longer
Tyrannosaurus Rex will always be my favorite dinosaur. Ever since I saw Rexy in Jurassic Park I felt that the Rex was so majestic but intimidating at the same time. That feeling has only been confirmed to me more and more over the years. Not only in Jurassic content but in other paleo media like Prehistoric Planet, I’m reminded that I don’t only love Hollywood’s Rex but I also love the real Tyrannosaurus. It’s very cliche but there’s no other dinosaur like it and I don’t ever see myself choosing another dinosaur as more interesting and more awe inspiring as the Tyrant Lizard King itself.
I agree Tyrannosaurus Rex will also be my favorite dinosaur nothing will be my new favorite.
Same
@@PurussaurusEnjoyer1234 nice
T. Rex will always be the King.
@@classicgalactica5879 agree
Spino always looked biggest on screen to me with Indominus looking as heavy but not as long or as tall, but bulkier.
Dude I said the same thing about Spino being taller.
indominus is taller tho
wake up to the reality and touch grass Spino can't compete in height while it is length
@@macewindu4070 no i searched lol length Indominus 16.9 height 23.0 so u Better shush now
@@Taketheriskgetbandz google information is inaccurate, misleading, misinformation
Alan: *encounters Spinosaurus*
Alan a few decades later: *encounters Giga*
Alan: biGGesT cArnIvORe thE wOrlD hAs EvEr sEen
If the age of the spinosaurus is gonna be mentioned then the Giga’s has to be too. The Giga was made by Biosyn sometime *after* the events of Fallen Kingdom, which is only a few years before Dominion
@Spooky_GooseHD wasnt in the movie
Well if we go by camp Cretaceous it could’ve been made prior to fallen kingdom seeing the ceo of biosyn went to get dna from isla nublar dinos and already had dna from other Dino’s since he said he something about it would been easier to get dna this way instead of how he did it all these years
Jurassic franchise - Spino > Giga > T-Rex
Real life - T-Rex>Giga>Spino
There is no such thing as real life -they are all long dead
My disappointment is how inaccurate JP is in theropod size and build.
You shouldn’t be using the sail of Spino to begin with. Height estimates for theropods are determined at the hip height.
With the discovery of the Spino tail it may increase in weight. Maybe surpassing T Rex.
It is said that T Rex is said to have more fossils Specimens in Western paleo museums stating a weight 10-11 Tons. One more thing on T Rex. Scotty was around 43 feet long.
Giga was impressive but was more of a thinner build. It’s size keeps going down.
We may never know who the largest was. There may be a species that dwarfed them all that didn’t fossilize.
there is a very good in canon reason the animals in jurassic park are not accurate. They aren’t genuine dinosaurs, never were, they are all generic hybrids, through gene splicing and filling gaps in the genetic code that are missing, and thus genes from different animals cause the dinosaurs to differ from their paleontological counter parts.
Universal doesn't use hip height for their sizes. They use head height.
I think the discovery of the Spinosaurus A. tail actually lowered its weight, they were estimated to be close to 7.5-8 tons and are now at about 7ish with the new semi-theropod theory.
Only a few adult Tyrannosaurus specimens are Sue/Scotty-sized (10 tons); the remainder are in the 7-9 ton range mostly.
The Giganotosaurus holotype is around 9 tons, for reference.
@@bkjeong4302 It’s no longer 9-15 tons as estimated back in the 1990’s. Scott Hartman’s Skeletal reconstruction has brought Giga back down to 7-8 tons. I’ll take his research over 1990’s inflated headline grabbing estimates.
Scotty, Sue, Trixy, Tristan and Sampson are very close in size.
Thanks man. Great video. Cant wait to see more.
Scotty has entered the chat*
Within the JP universe, the ranking with regards to length and height looks to be:
1. Spinosaurus
2. Indominus Rex
3. Giganotosaurus
4. T-Rex
In real life, the ranking would likely be:
1. Spinosaurus
2. Giganotosaurus
3. Tyrannosaurus Rex
In real life, Tyrannosaurus would be taller than both Giganotosaurus and Spinosaurus, and it would be slightly longer than Giganotosaurus.
With official/canon stats, your first list would have to swap the first three with one another. Adult Indominus would undeniably be the biggest, followed by the Giganotosaurus, then the Spinosaurus.
@@windsorcollegealumni Tyrannosaurus goes above Spinosaurus though.
@@Xenosaurian Maybe Rexy could, but the others would be smaller.
I think the title should say “Walked the Earth” instead, as the way its phrased opens the door to sea-faring predators, which allows Megalodon and Levyatan to enter the group, and completely dominate in length and mass by a mile.
Edit: Should include the Blue Whale, but filter feeders are even more of a technicality, as they are predators, but aren’t really what we first think of as predators.
Yeah, exactly. The mega theropods are usually less than 10 tons but the meg and livy are around 50 tons
Don't forget about the Blue Whale
@@user-ga5fne3h yes I am aware, I was pointing out that the phrase in the film is inaccurate is all
blue whales exist you know
Also the Leviathan isn't real.
Indominus rex: am I a joke to you ?
Height or length doesn't mean it's bigger the T.Rex in real life was taller as it's total B.S counting the sail height, the T.Rex was built for power it's very likely stronger than both Giga and Spino based on muscle structures and definitely had a much harder bite, the T.Rex is massively underestimated in media and video games all the time as the 1st bite in JP3 would have severed the Spino's neck.
Nah its totally Overrated. It wasn't a.good hunter or fighter.
It was a bully and coward-used it's size and aggression to chase off smaller predators and steal their food.
It was a poor hunter and if their prey would fight back the trex would run a mile
@@user-uh4ub4ke3t hahahaha obvious troll very good but I'd be lying if I said you nearly had me.
Trex is overrated
@@theronoxstudios5735 it's underrated otherwise people would realise it'd dominate a Giganotosaurus or Spinosaurus in a fight.
@@JJ-yl2mi you have zero way to prove that-as you haven't studied them up close to know anything about them.
You are relying on people's theories and opinions who never saw these animals
I like this video, unlike most RUclipsrs who would say giga is the biggest, but you actually went deeper, and used actual evidence instead of other RUclipsrs who would probably just say something without evidence. Hats of to you 👏👏👏👏
I mean he got some things wrong 🗿especially Rexy and gigas sizes
Still even if he did get some things wrong he still did go deeper and used evidence instead of just saying something without evidence even tho he may have got stuff wrong but no one is perfect
@@grokidaalligatorloki1307 I mean the only thing he actually proved is that the spino is 46ft long
@@_ThermoGojiDesignFanatic I did not say he was right, I only said that he went deeper into it instead of just being lazy
He got barely anything right. This is just pandering.
8.8 metric tonnes for a Trex is actually the old estimate for Scotty. New estimates put him at 10.6 Metric tonnes. So he actually completely dominates Giga and Spino in terms of weight. And I thought Rexy was over 8 tons but I must of been wrong. And for her height every size I’ve seen for Rexy puts her at 17 feet tall. And I saw somewhere a article which Collin said that the Giga in dominion was 21 feet tall. That would make sense seeing as it is quite a bit taller than Rexy.
The last estimates that are published has Sue at 8400kg and Scotty at 8860kg and even then paleontologists expressed doubt because the difference between the two theropods are very minor.
A recent gravity study has upped the weight of all dinosaurs,I recommend you check it out.
m.ruclips.net/video/E58IQ_Fv8_8/видео.html
This RUclipsr explains the study very well.
@@syedhussaini2207 But nothing suggests Tyrannosaurus weighing over 10 tonnes. I can't find any sources
The study is in the description
In reality neither spino nor giga would pick a fight with rex.A fully grown T Rex has a very powerful bite force.
But they do not know that because they either have never faced one and their instincts do not exist because the species lived in different time periods
@@cadehardin2360 because the researchers believe so. T-Rex was the brawler of dino world. Having numerous injuries because they picked more fights. A rex will absolutely start a fight and giving it robustness and more weight, more intelligent, a crippling bite force. Yea, the others will stay away.
In real life none of them would have ever met and your logical makes zero sense
Considering the Spinosaurus (possibly the same one from JP3) in Jurassic World Camp Cretaceous has jaws that was able to bite the whole neck from Big Eatie, I think it's safe to say that the Spinosaurus is the biggest carnivore the world's ever seen, at least in the Jurassic universe.
The scientific consensus is that Spinosarus egyptiacus was a piscivore which some times ate small to medium sized land animals. Not T-Rex. But the jury is still out.
Nice beasty tough.
The new discovered of the Spinosaurus back legs were actually short and it never hunted other dinosaurs but only hunted fish and most of the time lived in rivers swamps and small lakes
He stated that in the video
Edit: It definitely hunted other dinosaurs, Proof of this is a spinosaurus tooth that was found in a skeleton of a Carchardontosaurus, they both shared territory or atleast similar areas, spinosaurus most definitely hunted other land dinosaurs
You know that's most likely not true it almost wouldn't make sense for the size of a spino it's almost saying the same thing if you said trex was a scavenger it's just a theory that at first glance might make sense but after you take time to look at and compare it to it's features it does not add up
@@skidmycrack7374 yeah funny thing is this new discovery he stated I’m pretty sure it’s out of date
I feel bad for its cousin irratator the dinosaur did not do anything
@@wyattbhoffman No I said Wake up to the reality, carchar was a nemesis of the spino
oh my gosh! Off topic but i love the background music. the jurassic park theme remix. 😍
Mosasaurus: hi
Spino Team for life
Just one detail. Rexy in Jurassic park was 20 ft tall, and 17 ft tall in Jurassic world. In JWFK she seems bigger than in previous movie, and she also got bigger in JWD. Also she was 7 tons in original, but 9 tons in Fallen Kingdom.
When Rexy was apex predator on isla nublar after the events of Jurassic world, she lived and thrived on the island not being held in a cage anymore. So she got bigger and heavier and stronger
Who knows how big and heavy rexy is this year.
My guess is that she is 21 feet tall 45.5 feet long and 9.7 tons but that my estimate
Excellent video!! I loved your explanation, more obseqious Rex fans need to listen to it.
Facts:
T-Rex/Giga/Spino
Length in m: 12.5-13.5/12.2-13.2/14-16
Weight in tons: 8.5-9.5/7.5-8/6-7.5
Bite force in pounds: 18,000/6,000/4,200
Tooth length in cm: 30/20/14
Brain in EQ (encephalization quotient) scale: 1.25-1.5/0.25-0.5/0.8-1.0--> in comparison dog 1.2/ fox 1.6/ chimpanzee 2.5 & human 7,4
In short, the Spino was the longer but at the same time the lighter while the T-Rex was the heavier and more intelligent and the Giga was neither the heavier nor the longer but the "dummiest" of the three...
Spinosaurus is obviously the biggest
With your logic of Spino not being fully grown that could be said with Giga, we don't know how old Giga is, if it got older than it could've grown too theoretically. So Giga still bigger
Cry?
@@ljobenieta1865 Cry that you can't accept the logic?
Ikr, people really underestimating giga, its kinda sad
Fr. Giga was no older than three years old in JWD and was stated in a article in regards to an interview with Colin himself and said it was 22ft tall. Which although wasn’t it’s in film size MORE than establishes it as a sub adult
spino prob has the least amount of fossil evidence out of the 3
Giganotosaurus might not have been fully grown in dominion as well. He was created in the 4 year gap between fallen kingdom and jw3 . Biosyn started creating their own dinosaurs after capturing most originating from nublar , which means it could be even less younger than that !
No. They have growth hormones remember? The ankylosaurus we saw named bumpy grew fully grown in a couple of months. Also in real life giganotosaurus is the largest land carnivore. Spinosaurus is an aquatic predator.
Gig had growth hormones from Biosyn. So pretty much it was fully grown. Spino on the other hand wasn’t fully grown. Now if you watched camp cretaceous. The Spinosaurus is fully grown and it’s the same Spinosaurus from JP3. He’s 50ft in length.
@@CashAdams___ bumpy was a special case. He grew faster and was completely different from the other ankys.
@@onlyadro5692 giga is no older than three years old. It would’ve taken them more than a year to build the facility+all the new technology+find the DNA for the giga. So it was likely even younger than four years old. And biosyn wanted more natural dinosaurs. They wouldn’t further modify them to have accelerated growth since that’s literally unnatural, the exact opposite of what they went for. As well as empire magazine stating the giga was 22ft tall based on an interview they did with Colin himself.
@M1NK You’re joking right??
T. rex was most likely the heaviest because it had far more fat and muscle. But recent studies have shown spinosaurus had extremely dense bones that could have made it easier for the spinosaurus to dive. Having compact dense bones would make the spined lizard a lot heavier than previously thought.
That’s real life, we’re talking about jurassic in here
One thing to remember here in real life is that they have never found a complete skeleton of spinosaurus. There is still a lot of debate about its proportions
I'd like to add that the Giganotosaurus has two conflicting measurements. DinoTracker's profile puts it at 50.8 feet long and 18 feet tall. However, Colin Trevorrow said it's actually 22 feet tall and weighs 11 tons, I posted it in a video.
none is factual correct tho
@@sferro0930 There's no indication in the exert that he was referring to the Giga animatronic. It isn't even brought up to my knowledge.
@@suricata1993 not in our universe but in the Jurassic Universe it is canon that the Giga is that
large
@@miragenights801 The excerpt doesn't mention Colin saying it either. That stuff is outside of quotations, so there's no proof that Colin himself came up with that information.
@@windsorcollegealumni They wouldn't have made such a specific and bold statement unless it was part of the interview, so it's more than likely an account of what they heard Colin say. Why would the interviewer specifically mention it's larger and more aggressive than "an" Indominus Rex? What gives them the authority and knowledge to make that comparison? They're recounting what was said during the interview.
The height, lengths and weight like to differ a lot in the Jurassic Park franchise. In Dino Tracker it says Giga is 4.5m tall while T-Rex is 5.3m tall, yet in the movie the Giga dwarfs the T-Rex, lets not start about the bullshit chart of JP3. Spino and T-Rex were much larger in the movie than shown in the chart.
They legit changed the size chart to make spino smaller in size to please trex fans bc they kept crying cuz spino clapped a rex that's why in the jurassic park game spino is 15m long bc in the movie it actually was yet on the charts it only says 13m long but they made it 13m long after they released film and got hate bc of salty trex fans crying all day like little kids also the anamatronic was 13m long and it was missing some part of its tail so it's impossible to be 13m long bc that means other half of tail is cut of
@@godlyphantom3255 that kinda sounds like a salty rant about T. rex fans?
@@godlyphantom3255 The truth is and this has nothing to do with t rex fans that in real the rex overcomes any known Land predator, Thats just a fact on actual studies. The known Giga skeleton is a bit smaller as the rex, also Spino got corrected in size again and there are No evidence for a 49 foot Animal as of today. Scottie is the biggest t rex yet with 13m and est. 10-11 tons. Giga is 12.3m with 6-7 Tons and spino is not 100% clear the best known specimen is around 11.9m and 4-6 tons. But over all they Never met so and they all where remarkable animals.
@@godlyphantom3255 source or just head canon?
@@godlyphantom3255 Do you wanna cry, Spinosaurus fanboy? Watch a short RUclips video called Jack Horner on Spinosaurus. The guy who started the whole T. Rex vs Spinosaurus thing puts it to rest, once and for all.
I think what alan meant was that giga was the biggest carnivore the WORLD has ever seen not people who went to sorna during it's rule of sorna
Deinosuchus hatcheri is the biggest land carnivore the world has ever seen. It's size is 14.12 meters & 14.8 tonnes
scotty the tyrannosaur was estimated at the heaviest to be 10.6 tons, not to mention that counting spinosaurus sails is a bad idea, its like saying dimetrodon was taller than a horse even though its head reaches its knees lol
Its still part of its body
@@user-ga5fne3h depends what horse but its bigger than a standard one
"What is the Largest Carnivore the World has Ever Seen?"
Pretty sure that's the Blue Whale.
The Blue Whale is a plankton-feeder
@@WhyTho525 it eats Krill which are shrimp. It is a Carnivore.
Land carnivore not water, water doesn’t count.
@@sham9505 lol of course water counts.
"Largest Carnivore the World has ever seen"
That statement includes the ones in the water.
@@TVJUNK85 Idk I don’t think anyone cares about whales tho
The trex was a super dino. With a jaw force so strong, he probably didn't even notice bones during a meal. Also, his eyesight was extremely superior. the same goes for smell.
The biggest treat for trex was probably a triceratops.
I like how as soon as dominion is out all the salty rex fans wanna talk realism 😹😹
They can’t cope
@@sylver1146 it still killed the Giga and is the face of JP series 😂. You peeps should cope because your dino isn't as famous as rex. Last time they tried, JP3 grossed half of JP2 😂.
@@gay_hatr5172 so ? Lmao rex got bodied by giga both times hell even theri did better than what rexy did yr the one who can't cope , rexy got clapped and was knocked out at the finale mah boi
@@gay_hatr5172 and no rexy didn't kill tf u on abt it was theri cuz without his claws giga would still be thriving
@@gay_hatr5172 bro really pulls up real life logic on jp verse a place where chicken to dog sized dinos lile pyroraptor , atrociraptor and velociraptor are size of Utah raptors
Dr. Grant is actually the only one in the series to meet the big 3. Since he said the Giga is the largest, the Giga is the largest. Always trust the dinosaur man. 🦖🦕
The t-Rex is the true king. Greatest mass, and by far the greatest bite force! They had it right all along.
Scotty the biggest T-Rex is 43 feet long
Only if this came out before Camp Cretaceous season 5 cause spino is bigger in that it is 48-50 ft long and 18-20 ft tall at the head and 23 ft tall at the head. And I did my research I found d a official CC render of the spino made by Netflix and in the words beside it it said the spino weighs 11 tons so he is bigger in CC season 5 which is in 2016 thanks to the growth accelerators
No size is mostly determined by weight, and height and length are just determining factors if they’re the same weight
I've been trying to figure out how the giga is considered the biggest and it doesn't even look close to the size of the Spino. That part confused me. 🤷🏽♂️
Because in reality nor spino or giga were larger than t rex the t rex was the largest
@@death-nm7hr longer and taller make them larger
@@death-nm7hr no spino was bigger and longer
@@indoraptoristhegoat6460 t rex weighed far more than spino it was also stronger a t rex has the strongest bite force of any land animal and Dino ever and if we measure carnivores like t rex giga and spino t rex is the largest based off weight and muscle and strength t rex would murder spino
@@death-nm7hr strength doesn’t mean size, and the weight difference isn’t merely large enough to put the trex in front of the spinosaurus, length and height matter the most, which the spino was dominating on by a great margin. Spinosaurus was the biggest, no debate.
It's said that in camp Cretaceous that the spino is 23 feet tall at the head (28 feet tall at sail) measures 50 feet long and weighs 11 tons
Ain’t that’s the same Spino from JP3?
Give me a source.
@@_ThermoGojiDesignFanatic idk some people say it somestimes
The whole 50 feet thing was started by Spinosaur the clown. This 50 feet thing has been disproven by universal, CC staff, Mathematician's, archeologist, and dozens of others.Spino was full grown and not that large.
@@John316_Acts2 we don't speak the forbidden name here
spinosaurus gonna change Again like it wouldn't be surprising at this point
Him: find out how you can get a shout out
Me: I don't even know who you are
(Endgame reference)
I love how Jurassic park fans constantly tries to downplay the tyrannosaurus by lying and insulting the animal.
Aww can’t cope with the fact that it’s not the biggest?
@@indominusfats2390 in real life it is the biggest. Movies don't count.
@@indominusfats2390 when a skinny 7 foot guy fights a body builder, well if you know you know.
I like the Rex but I feel like the fans are a bit over protective over it tbh.
it is being disrespect in movie, that's why
@@khuongnguyenduc7569 kinda both but agreed
@@MrLynamYT i dont like the way they treat spino and Giga anyway. they portray them as "monsters" more than just dinosaurs. And use the term "bigger than t-rex" to attract the audiences. t-rex already cool and king of therepod, why have to pull it down to make movies?
@@khuongnguyenduc7569 yeah, I don’t like the idea that the Giga was called the joker. I feel like it was under used and just felt like an animal trying to get food. I feel like the Indominus Rex is really the joker tbh.
Facts:
T-Rex/Giga/Spino
Length in m: 12.5-13.5/12.2-13.2/14-16
Weight in tons: 8.5-9.5/7.5-8/6-7.5
Bite force in pounds: 18,000/6,000/4,200
Tooth length in cm: 30/20/14
Brain in EQ (encephalization quotient) scale: 1.25-1.5/0.25-0.5/0.8-1.0--> in comparison dog 1.2/ fox 1.6/ chimpanzee 2.5 & human 7,4
In short, the Spino was the longer but at the same time the lighter while the T-Rex was the heavier and more intelligent and the Giga was neither the heavier nor the longer but the "dummiest" of the three...
Mosasaurus would like to know everyone's location.
This was actually a very good and detailed video regarding these theropods! I'm really happy someone is keen enough to mention the age of the Spinosaurus during the events of Jurassic Park 3. Compared to Rexy in which it took 5 years of Ingen growth hormones to be displayed as an attraction. It's such a crucial detail many gloss over for some reason.
Just a heads up, Spinosaurus is said to grow 15.2 - 16 meters long according to the 2020 paper by Nizar Ibrahim. The same paleontologist said it weighed 10 to 12 metric tonnes as you mentioned. A large specimen dubbed "NMC 41852" has been recreated as having proportions over 50% greater than the neotype. It potentially represents the largest known S. aegyptiacus specimen, scaling it up from the model given by Ibrahim et al. 2020 and using the densities provided by Larramendi et al. 2020 with the disparity in size SpinoInWonderland got with it and the neotype it would have been around ~16.65 meters long and weighed around ~14 340 kg. It possibly represents the largest known theropod and largest predatory animal capable of locomotion on land. Just food for thought.
As for Giganotosaurus, the most complete specimen and also the holotype, MUCPv-Ch1, is thought to be 12.4 meters in length and weigh more than 8320 kg. The referred dentary MUCPv-95 that appears to have been an animal 6.5 - 10% larger has been used to extrapolate a length of 13.2 - 13.7 meters and a weight of 9000kg - 11000kg. Ignore the 2.2% scaling which is way too conservative by some users referencing Dan Folkes or Franoys.
You may be interested in hearing that the Spinosaurus in Camp Cretaceous is scaled to be 52ft long and 23ft tall according to PuppeteerPaul from Reddit. On the official Jurassic World website, it also stated Spinosaurus to grow to such lengths and up to 11 metric tonnes. Colin Trevorrow recently also said in an interview with Colider that Spinosaurus is the strongest carnivore in the franchise dubbing it as a T.rex killer. Which makes sense seeing as how it was attracted to T.rex pee and is experienced in fighting so. Followed by Giganotosaurus outbesting the Tyrannosaurus everytime.
Yeah ?and you gotta realize,spinosaur fought a sub adult t rex,and all the other dinosaurs that fought rexy fought her when she is way out of her prime,she doesnt even look nearly as scary as she did in the first film..
Plus what gets me is Gigonosaurus had oversized teeth,t rex had much larger teeth in real life made for crushing,and it bothers me is a 7-9 ton bite force doesnt even phase these dinos in the movies when it should be crushing their bones..is a t-rex untouchable?No,it has lost agains triceritops in real life,but when it delivers its bone crushing bite,its the clear winner
The study has yet to come out yet so it’s a little to soon to declare Spino as the largest.
@@syedhussaini2207 True but we can get similar results by scaling the neotype and new density study
A spino wouldn't do shit to a trex irl lol simce spino is a fish eater and got a weak bite compared to the trex
@@hugo-pg5tv By that logic, an Anteater would get its ass handed to it by a Jaguar or a Grizzly Bear would get wrecked by a Tiger even though nature proved diets are a poor indicator of an animal's fighting capabilities.
Spino's bite was still estimated to be decently strong at 3 tons and remember, those are just estimates since we can't do a proper bite force test on Spinosaurus yet since an adult's skull has never been found.
Those are just average size as there could have been T-Rexes bigger than that
And there could have been bigger spinos and gigas too as well !
@@user-uh4ub4ke3t Giga weighed the least out of them, length doesn't really matter.
You got this all wrong the Blue whale is the biggest carnivore the world has ever seen.
This video is riddled with small inaccuracies
Hey I would like to add something if the spino isn’t fully grown how do you know the giga is fully grown by the events of dominion
Tha twas a pretty good analysis but spino was an adult.
TLW took place at isla sorna SITE A while JP3 took place at SITE B which means that spino didnt appear in TLW because his terretory is located at SITE B so he might be older then rexy since the plan was to open the park in sorna where they already had many the dinos clonned.
I.rex on the other hand had giga DNA as well and he was suppose to grow massive like or even bigger then a giga which for me puts giga or i.rex at 1st place, spino at second and by a massive dffrence t.rex at third place.
Actually its already kinda confirmes that Spino was made in 1999 and is canonically 2 years old
@@Sr_V2 I was about to say that but yeh, exactly
@@brokenjohnassexum0929 yeah and I think this guy forget that Spino was not on Ingen List.... even when the events of the Lost World happen so yeah
@@Sr_V2 its Fully matured in JWCC and seemed bigger and handling 2 trexs amongst other things
Spinosaurus is the biggest second is charco and third is the giga
I mean when it comes to the biggest land carnivore EVER to walk the earth we may never know cause maybe there is a much bigger carnivore yet to be found, and maybe it's not even a dinosaur
True
Spino at the head wasn't 6 meters (18 feet). Rex is now 10 tonnes, giga 8, spino 7, biggest means mass, so t rex is the biggest carnivore the world has ever seen
Weight is not the point
@@ljobenieta1865 well yes it is, biggest means mass
Every other category it get dominated so it’s not the biggest carnivore
Gets*
@@dashaunbaylor4965 mass means largest bruh.
From my understanding T-Rex's lived in family small pods like orcas do so they would be very formidable if theory is right.
Its not pods, its packs
@@amn2760 I thought that they were pods because supposedly hunt in family pods. Sorry if I was wrong.
@@elcajondavid1 A pod is only described for marine mammals living in groups
@@amn2760 Interesting, I thought they were "family" groups while like wolves are mixed with family and others like a lion pride. Thanks Alex, learn something new every day.
@@elcajondavid1 Thats not even what i meant
I would just assume they got the spino the wrong size on the graph, and the given size was the accurate one.
Also, sail tip isn't as good of a size comparison as hip or head height. It's like counting your hair to say you're taller.
And we don't know how old the giga is either
Biggest carnivore world ever seen: Spino, giga, and Indo at each other's throats.
Rex: constantly yells I'm the most powerful
.
.
.
Mososaurus: silently growling in the depths.
therizino and mosa: Rex got carried.... Twice
Cool and interesting video, wether I agree with most of this the Spinosaurus actually was fully grown in JP3, he was actually born the same year as Rexy, we just didn’t see him until JP3, and the Spino in Camp Cretaceous (which is the same Spino) is still the exact same size as the one in JP3 even director confirming it. Also fun fact Rexy is ever so slightly taller than Spino at head to head, but yeah Spino’s still longer than Rexy
Really? Jp3 spino is only like 43ft long while rexy has been put 44ft+ long.
The novel's also said it only takes the dinos 3 years max to reach adulthood.
Spino is confirmed to be make in 1999 making it 2 years old in JP3
Eve one person that made JP3 confirmed it was made in 1999
Hey man it says ‘no stream’ so I’m unable to view it, is this an issue on my end?
I got that too…
@@that1dudewhoplayz843 huh. this looks like an issue. gimme a sec
@@ThePrimalEarth Thank you for the quick fix
@@that1dudewhoplayz843 no problem! Happy to help!
@@ThePrimalEarth thank you brother I’m now enjoying the video. Cheers!
Technically, the biggest carnivore that ever existed on the planet still lives. It's the blue whale.
Where’d you find the 12 ton potential estimate for Spinosaurus do you have a paper or a link?
In Jurassic world Franchise.
Spinosaurus is the biggest & baddest predator.
Adult jp3 ( biosyn) Spinosaurus is 18.2 meters long & 16.2 tons & it's in the canon.
Biosyn Giganotosaurus is 15.5 meters long & 13 tons.
Rex the T.rex is 13.5 meters long & 10 tons
Already confirmed by jack Anthony ewins mentioned it was already fully grown the Spinosaurus was only 13,3 meters not 18 meters just more false information without no actual evidence and you saying it’s canon without no source
"Adult jp3 ( biosyn) Spinosaurus is 18.2 meters long & 16.2 tons & it's in the canon."
Proof, please. I'd like to know where exactly this was shown.
Size is determined by weight, in which case T-Rex wins in terms of largest carnivorous dinosaur
If we go in terms of the Jurassic Park/Jurassic World franchise, trex is a lot smaller due to it being designed like a starved african child. In terms of the franchise, giga likely wins
On a side note, trex’s speed does an inverse in this scenario. In real life giganotosaurus was by far the fastest, and trex was incredibly slow in terms of a terrestrial hunter
well there is a new document that spino might be 2 to 4 tons heavier then a trex. because of the bone density for being in water.
To some
I suppose the jurrassic park/world counterparts are hybrids.
That spino was an absolute unit. Gutted it didn't turn up in dominion
Um, I'm not sure we should measure height by the sail, but as we usually do we should measure it by the hip, in which case Tyrannosaurus dominates. Giganotosaurus is also NOT longer than Tyrannosaurus, but its length is actually a bit difficult to estimate and the safest we can say is that it's slightly shorter or as long as Tyrannosaurus. In terms of height (from the hip, not the sail), weight, volume, and mass (as well as length, in comparison to Giga and excluding Spino) the T-Rex reigns supreme as the biggest ever land carnivore. Also, the JP3 Spinosaurus was born in 1999, and was definitely fully grown by 2001, and there's no telling if it kept growing or not, and Indominus dominates them all.
@@TitanusTerror Oh I'm gonna whine all I want bud! This franchise is a mess, but if we're gonna go by officially released size estimates then T-Rex would be bigger than Spino.
@@TitanusTerror That's not what the official sixe charts say, but T-Rex is bigger than Spino, and Giga is bigger than T-Rex, and Indom is bigger than Giga, in this franchise. It's a mess either way.
I’m still partial to TRex, and loved it even more after seeing Prehistoric Planet, best representation of this majestic King yet. Don’t need to watch JW Dominion
It was only a debate for the uneducated. It's always been (biggest to smallest in real life)
1. Spinosaurus
2. Giganotosaurus
3. T-Rex
Actually, this list should be reversed, considering it goes from rex to giga to spino when it comes to mass (Which determines the largest, not length or height).
@@gloomyallo1830
First of the mass factor is 95% speculation by paleontologist. You can't determine how much something weighed just by looking at the skeletal structure...
Secondly, there are many studies pointing towards the Spinosaurus weighing the most.
Spino is biggest known carnivore the world has yet to see. Period.
@@gravityfallscanada Ftlog, here we go. We know spinosaurus factually weighed less than giga and rex because it had a high bone density that allowed it to be more adept to a subaqueous lifestyle, we factually know spinosaurus was in the 6-8 ton range (8 tons being near the highest possible weight based on current estimates), meanwhile T-Rex averaged out at over 8 to 9 tons (And 9 tons is factual based on the weight of the rex specimens Scotty and Sue, with Scotty nearly reaching 10 tons in weight), and giganotosaurus averages out in the same weight range as what would be the heaviest of spinosaurs (Around 8 tons). So yes, we can indeed determine a lot about weight based on the skeletal structure.
Here is a comparison of the most complete and sure estimates of three theropod dinosaurs and an unsure estimate of a larger Spinosaurus:
Tyrannosaurus rex (FHMN PR 2081 - Sue)
Length - 12.39 meters
Height (hip) - 3.8 meters
Total height - 4.32 metrs
Weight - 10 tonnes
Giganotosaurus carolinii (Mucpv-Ch1- holotype)
Length- 12.57 meters
Height (hip) - 3.5 meters
Total height - 3.76 meters
Weight - 7.8 tonnes
Spinosaurus aegyptiacus (IPHG 1912 VIII IK - holotype)
Length - 9.43 meters
Height (hip) - 1.85 meters
Total height - 2.74 meters
Weight - 3.7 tonnes
Spinosaurinae indet. (MSNM v4047)
Length - 14.43 meters
Height (hip) 2.35 meters
Weight - 7.3 tonnes
Tyrannosaurus rex is the biggest theropod and by extension the biggest fully terrestrial carnivore ever to walk the Earth.
Tyrannosaurus rex was also the smartest out of all large theropods, while having impeccable eyesight better than a hawk and incredible smell. Tyrannosaurus had the strongest bite of any fully terrestrial animal ever. The bulk of T. rex gives it strength and agility over S. aegyptiacus and G. carolinii.
T rex wins this one no questions asked.
Me when you say that spino might not be fully grown
Ima go real quick
The largest carnivore? Sure! The largest predator? Not in the slightest! That crown belongs to the gigantic Mosasaurus Maximus Dr.Wu created in his lab.
And yes Dr. Wu coined his moddified Mosasaurus Hoffmanni as a new species
Blue whale walking in.
@@NolongerUsedChannel35 The Blue Whale is always a bit of a cheap escape, as it is the largest animal on the planet
(Yes I know about this new whale fossils but rediculess weight of over 230 tonnes has already been called into question)
I'm only talking about the prehistoric animals from that franchise
In the latest season of camp Cretaceous the exact Spinosaurus from Jp3 makes an appearance. It doesn't look like it's changed much if at all since it's original appearance. So as for the assumption it may have grown since then I don't think that would work.
Spinosaurus couldn't reach any longer than 14 meters, and the maximum weight a Spinosaurus could actually get is 7.4 metric tons, this was confirmed by Paul Sereno in November 2022 in the article titled, " Spinosaurus is not an Aquatic Dinosaur" in the National Center of Biotechnology Information website.
One huge inaccuracy is that T-Rex is 41 feet long when Scotty the biggest T-Rex found so far is 42.6 feet long and weighs in at around 9.8 tons
21 years later, Im pretty sure Jp3 spino still want Alan and the Kirbys dead.
Colin confirmed it was Giga.
Grant: the biggest carnivore the world has ever seen. Spino:what am I a roach
Yes the spino is a roach. Goodbye spino, hello Giganotosaurus "The *BIGGEST CARNIVORE THE WORLD HAS EVER SEEN."*
Blue wahle be like.
but paleontologists don't actually count the sail for height. but the main part of the body without the sail, they only count head and hip height for animals, so Spinosaurus would be the shortest of the 3 in height, Spinosaurus still had to look upwards to see the heads of Giga and T Rex. and 2022 November the length of Spinosaurus has been fully confirmed to be no longer than 14 meters, and with a max weight of 7390kg, and this for the population of Spinosaurus at their average adult size and weight.
In terms of real life, tyrannosaurus rex was the heaviest of the apex therapods with such a bulky build that trumps giga and spino. In terms of the films, spinosaurus was cemented as biggest, even to the likes of indominus rex with its latest appearance in Camp Cretaceous.
I think JWD saw the Spino as a fish eater, therefore making the giga the biggest, idk tho
I'm so disappointed they didn't bring back the Spino for Dominion. Such a wasted opportunity. Not only could they have shown a fully grown spino, but what a last fight it would have been. The giganotosaurus was fine, I guess, but it had no real impact on the story, but the spino has history. I got way too excited when the dimetrodon showed up cause I thought it was the spino for a moment.
The world may never know 🫠 new species are always being discovered
In the movie: 1.Giganotosaurus (9 ton in wiki fandom and 11 ton in the novels)
2.Tyrannosaurus aka Rexy:8,4 ton
3.Spinosaurus:8 ton
In real life:1.Tyrannosaurus Rex:10 ton
2.Giganotosaurus Carolinii:8,3 ton
3.Spinosaurus Aegyptiacus:6,3 ton
In real life - Tyrannosaurus Rex 11 tons
Giganotosaurus: 9.63 tons
Spinosaurus: 7.84 tons
By Dan Folkes
So the definition of bigger is who is the bulkiest with more muscles, no matter the height. In that case, the Tyranno is the biggest, although the Spino and the Giga were taller and larger than it by some meters.
With estimates that widely different it's frankly not possible to say.
Theropd size comparison
(Max sizes)
1. Tyrannosaurus rex-11+ tonnes
2. Giganotosaurus carolinii-9.6 tonnes
3. Mapusaurus rosae-8.7 tonnes
4. Deinocheirus mirificus-8.5 tonnes
5. Spinosaurinae indet-8 tonnes
6. Tyrannotitan chubutensis-7.8 tonnes
7. Carcharodontosaurus saharicus-7.2 tonnes
8. Spinosaurus cf. "aegypticus"-6.8 tonnes
9. Acrocanthosaurus atokensis-6.6 tonnes
10. Epanterias amplexus-5.8 tonnes
(Average sizes)
1. Tyrannosaurus rex-9.2 tonnes
2. Giganotosaurus carolinii-7.8 tonnes
3. Mapusaurus rosae-7.6 tonnes
4. Deinocheirus mirificus-7.5 tonnes
5. Spinosaurinae indet-7.4 tonnes
6. Tyrannotitan chubutensis-7.2 tonnes
7. Carcharodontosaurus saharicus-6.8 tonnes
8. Acrocanthosaurus atokensis-6.2 tonnes
9. Epanterias amplexus-5.3 tonnes
10. Tarbosaurus bataar-5.2 tonnes
(Average Spinosaurus aegyptiacus is 3.9 tonnes)
Based on this, kinda.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/0/d/1GVpHchzogtjkTqQrP7PFM2BAWMGHYHABD-Xnk_6KPj0/htmlview
2:10 there is also Scotty who is 11 tons and Sue at 10 tons. T.Rex is the heaviest by a long shot. But yea the average T.Rex is about 8.8 tons.
Though the JP rex always looked very nice, I think today we know it would be a lot more heavier with a huge gut. And though it is questionable on what dinos grew larger, another factor is that Tyrannosaurs would have likely had a much shorter life span because it fought the most dangerous dinosaurs of all time (prey wise). I have not seen the new movie but the JP specs even put the original Rex (Rexy) at a larger size than Spino. I believe the T-rex is 17ft and 44ft long while Spino is 16ft and 43ft long. I have seen this before but the consistency of JP facts are all over the place sometimes.
You'd be correct. JW/JWFK Rexy was 17 feet tall, 44.3 feet long (in JWD she became 18 feet tall). The Spinosaurus was 16 feet tall, 43.8 feet long. If you counted the sail, that'd be the only thing bringing the Spinosaurus up to 19.7 feet.
@@windsorcollegealumni we talking abt Jp3 Spino or CC? Jp3 Spino was quite a bit shorter than Rexy and CC was around the same height
@@Zedumbass24 JP3, but the CC Spino is the same one, same size and all. Fans can pixel calc what they want, but officially there's no word on it being a different size, so I use the size that's available.
Spino and Rexy really aren't that different in size. They're practically the same length, and while Rexy has about two feet of head height advantage, the Spino's sail is still nearly two feet above that. To me, they're on the same level, unlike the Spino and the JP3 Bull.
2 years old spino was born 1999 and the events in jp3 takes in 2001
I think you may have gotten the height wrong for the T.Rex because I believe it was actually 15 feet tall but I could be wrong.
This means since 2004 spino has been fully grown
U should mention this to the trex vs spino poll posted by goji center
Now apparently Spinosaurus is 16.5 length and 6.61 meters in height and if that is true then wow that is big😂
There are conflicting size data for Biosyn Giganotosaurus, but there is that Biosyn dinosaur chart where Rexy and Giga are beside each other. There I measured Giga at around 18 feet tall on the tip of the neck spine and stretch at over 48 feet from nose to tail.
There is also the same, and now older and bigger, Spinosaurus in Camp Cretaceous S4 & upcoming S5. I'm not gonna make Spinosaur the King levels of overestimation, but the S5 trailer might be hinting that our Spiny boy is 20 feet tall at the head and up to 50 feet long
It's not.