@@alfiecorbett1703 God damn calm down bro, the op commenter was just stating their opinion on the worst part about being betrayed, its not something to get furious about, now now maybe you should try some breathing exercises! Breathe in and out deeply for 30 seconds, take your time, you don’t have a train to catch.
Half his life? More like most of his life since Dutch and Horsea raised Arthur when he was 14 they taught him how to hunt, fish, read and write and alot of other things Micah is the whole reason why they are both gone Dutch wasn't thinking right
I think Micah mirrors Dutch's true nature to some degree. Violent, egoistic, greedy. Arthur but more so Horsea gave him moral hold for a long time but when he met Micah, he didn't had to hid it anymore. That's why Blackwater turned out to be such a mess - because both Arthur and Horsea were absent. Also Dutch suffered multible head injuries
In those few second’s Dutch realized he had been a fool and apart from Hosea, Arthur had been the best friend he ever had and he had let that go away just for Micah.
@@KT-tz3mwafter the train station robbery dutch start losing it. I just played that mission today and after that mission You go to largas with dutch and that is the first time I saw him in the Game screaming like a crazy then hosea dies and then he really loses it
When john asks what dutch is doing here he says “same as you, I suppose” and obviously john is here to kill micah. not a lot of people catch this but i think he reunited with micah with intentions to kill him the whole time
The fact the guy who played Dutch claimed that after the scene where author is dying when he ‘leaves the scene” he just started to cry. These actors put so much in it that they get connected to it in such a way.
My friend got a warning from God. He said "Tell my people I am coming back soon, and read your Word". Here are some verses I recommend reading~ Matthew 7:21-23 Matthew 4:17 Acts 2:17 Joel 2:28 James 2:17-26 Acts 16:31 I recommend writing them down and truly meditating on them. 22 But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves. 23 For if any be a hearer of the word, and not a doer, he is like unto a man beholding his natural face in a glass: 24 For he beholdeth himself, and goeth his way, and straightway forgetteth what manner of man he was. 25 But whoso looketh into the perfect law of liberty, and continueth therein, he being not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, this man shall be blessed in his deed. -James 1:22-25 Tomorrow isn't promised, BUT, God being a loving and forgiving Father is and always will be, don't wait until later or tomorrow. Gods kingdom is at hand! ❤️
É atuação, tipo estar fazendo teatro para uma plateia, você sabe da história, mas se entrega tanto no papel, que muitas vezes as emoções transmitidas são reais. @@mehshutup3041
That cutscene is a mod Dutch never looked at Micah like that but it would have been cool if they put this much detail into some of the cutscenes Edit:I replayed rdr2 it looks like he did look at him but not as of realization it was just a slight glance the mod made it look more dramatic
@@Ifounddoubtyeah I was thinking “I don’t remember Dutch looking at him like that” and then realized that’s not end game Dutch 😂 But I prefer this little look over, even if it’s a split second difference
No he didn’t, he did it for John. It’s John’s story, he always has been and always will be the main character. Arthur was a retcon to make a prequel work. That’s it
You can see the pain in his eyes as Micah said that. Arthur was his son and he went and betrayed him for a damn rat. He thought he could trust Micah and that he wasn’t the rat but then he goes and shit talks his son. Well John finished off but the Arthur comment made Dutch shot
Yeah but then in RDR 1 Dutch let his pride go to his head and decided to keep on going down that path even though he knew it was one paved with the blood of his family. Don't feel bad for him in the slightest.
@@gunslinginleftist it is more or less of a observation. You can still tell he felt bad about Arthur’s death but he still let everything go to his head in spite of everything. He is kind of a piece of shit still a good character with a nice storyline
@@GhostToastie Oh yeah. Dutch is so cool I want to name my next dog Dutch. He might’ve felt bad, but channeled that remorse into hate and weaponized it against innocents. For sure a well written bad guy.
The moment of realisation Dutch had is so sad. But what’s worse is that after killing Micah Dutch really just didn’t know what to do so he went off and that uncertainty in his life is what probably led him to become the monster that he is in rdr1
Horsea and Arthur were his voice of reason the ones that was there to always tell him that's a bad idea while Micah was always telling him to do crazy idea that's how the Blackwater massacre happened Arthur and Horsea were not there they were doing other stuff so they couldn't talk him out of killing all those people
I sobbed like it was the last time I didn't cry like that, when my best friend betrayed me like I did when Arthur died. Shit, I just realized that during those hours in the game, I've grown more attached to him than to my probably last friend in life 🤠
That’s what people don’t understand, Dutch didn’t kill micah to save John, he killed Micah because he wanted to avenge Arthur and leave Micah behind. I believe that Dutch truly loved Arthur and Hosea, even if people think he was bad from the starts
My headcannon is that Dutch went crazy because he couldn’t cope with the realization of his mistakes and how it destroyed the gang. That’s why he was how he was in rdr 1
I think he got PTSD after the fall of his gang. All his deeds after were done cause he didn't care. Because he (or everything good in him) died with his gang.
When micah shit-talked Arthur, Dutch finally realized he was wrong to Arthur, and john, and everyone else. He still went crazy,hence his final exit in red dead Redemption 1, but when he shot micah... He still had some good in him...😔
he wasnt a good man, thats what his whole arc is about. hes a bad guy (like nearly everyone else in the gang) trying to be better. as charles says in the mission where you rescue eagle fly from the army, knowing that you‘ll die was a gift, he has had the chance to be better and not die as the bad guy he was till he got TB. hosea, lenny, the callender brothers etc were bad people. but arthur had the chance to be more than that. even john says it in the epiloge when meeting mickey in valentine, he wasnt a good man, neither a bad man. its surely hard to tell, but his bad deed def overweigh his good ones
the way dutch looked at micah, he realized everything, he realized micah only wanted the money and nothing else, and that he should have never doubted arthur. Imo: if arthur didnt get tb and beat micahs ass dutch would prob shoot him since he still trusted micah so idk what to say to all the people saying no tb arthur and dutch would regroup or something
It depends on which theory on Dutch is true. If he really did go bad over time then yes, he probably did realize right then what a horrible series of mistakes he made that led to all the people he cared about dying or leaving and how he never should've trusted Micah. Alternatively if he was always just using the gang he would've had a similar realization but only cared that his plan was ruined.
@@TNASTY6688846993 nah, i dont believe he used the gang, if he did he wouldnt be so heartbroken over hosea or arthur. But he was a bad man that acted like an angel until everybody left him alone.
he takes his hand off though, Arthur has ample time to shoot Micah but decides not to in his final moments in life, either that or he was too weak at that point @@Shayan351
i still remember arthur and dutch's conversation in a mission. there the dutch was starting to get brainwashed by micah but wasn't completely. they were talking something about trust. then dutch said, "I'll walk into the hell itself if you're watching my back boy".
I replayed the ending recently. I still cry and feel just depressed and shaken. Red Dead Redemption 2 is not just a masterpiece, it's art! It makes you feel stuff! 😢
something i wish rockstar added was gang npcs reacting to john wearing Arthur's hat, i feel like micah definitely would have made a snarky comment when he saw john wearing that hat.
You can see the way he looked at Micah he was crying inside he was you can tell and that’s most likely why he shoot Micah and it’s sad to see in rdr he goes insane sure he was a bad guy but he’s still an amazing character
The fading to black of Arthur is like how he slowly fades away with his condition and how his memory fades from all who knew him. I respect that detail man. 😢
Arthur was so loyal that in the end that he knew even the owner of the gang (Dutch) was on the wrong side and even with this he wanted to safe the gang incredible character
Before Arthur: “I’m here ain’t I? Been by your side for 20 years!” Dutch: “I KNOW!!! I!…I… I’m sorry son..” After Arthur: “I gave you all I had…” Dutch: “I… I…..” Dutch new it was to late to say sorry at that point. He walks off with tears in his eyes eventually breaking down.
@@loyscgodlike that’s when he genuinely believed in Michas lies. He thought Arthur was the rat. In the end Dutch sees the truth and realizes he failed his sons. It drove him insane hence rdr1. Dutch isn’t someone who likes to admit when he’s wrong. But trust me he knows when he is. His ego, pride, ambition, intelligence and insanity drove him to the edge.
Man I always thought Micah was that one psychotic crazy guy of the gang but extremely loyal, Kind of like Trevor, But when It was revealed he was the rat all my respect disappeared in an instant
Micah never had my respect, a crazy and egotistical asshole who antagonizes everyone in the camp at every chance he gets, Arthur should've left in Strawberry.
He was not a good man bro and l love Arthur one of my favorite characters but he caught tuberculosis while beating a dying sick man in front of his family to death over money and he was in a violent gang for over 20 years and it took him to get sick to realize all the bad he’s done and the bad things outweighs the good things he did so he definitely went to hell just bc he tried to change towards the end after he got sick and saved a few people don’t mean nothing
@@Seven-or1lx no bro he wasn’t arthur was in a violent gang robbing and killing people for over 20 years and he wasn’t changing until he got sick bro after he got sick that’s when he tried to apologize to the family of the guy he beat up to death he didn’t do it before he did it after so it took him to get sick and knowing he was gonna die for all the bad things he did in the past 20 years being with Dutch? Yeah that wasn’t a good man at all and u gotta realize the game it’s trying to romanticize the criminal lifestyle of Arthur existed in real life and did all those things he did on the game everyone would look at him like a degenerate
@@robbymark972 he didn't,he doesn't see Arthur die. He said it in an interview. he just sees that Arthur is dying and that he's beaten up and exhausted,but he turns around. He thinks Arthur will escape
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Im first pin? Also COOL VIDEOOOO
Thank you bro! ❤️🤠
U have best rdr2 viedos i ever seen
@@reddeadcljpsKeep it up making videos that remind you of tear-jerking moments, which is good
Arthur will always be my favorite alongside Hosea.
@@reddeadcljps good edit bro👍
Red dead redemption 2 is just a masterpiece
i can already see the 5 yo that say “GTA is way better,” in the replies
@memeconsumer1000 no need for the GTA4 in this instance, it's not applicable.
@@TELJ.66yep
@@RaymationsGTA 4 is really good
@@Raymationsyes very true, GTA V’s story and map feel like a school project compared to RDR2
The way he looked at him shows that he knows he screwed up
Naw m8, Dutch is clearly a self serving wanker, your just seeing what you wish was true.
He knew he screwed up for a while, its just that he made the best of the situation after the gang fell to stay an outlaw
I think he just took it personnaly that he talked about arthur like that,he cared about arthur but the person he cared about the most was himself
@@Michael.Jordan_.69agreed
When he killed Arthur he knew he messed up thats why he started his own gang
Arthur, Lenny Kieran , Hosea, John, miss Grimshaw ,uncle, Sean,Molly, jack marston, Abigail marston, I will miss you
Sean
What abt Charles
@@ALIA-nq8gb Bruh💀 he is not death!
SEAN TOO
And Keiran
Arthur is the definition of loyalty
Bro its so fucking true
Indeed!
"be loyal to what matters."
thats Trevor
@KeyUploads Trevor is more loyal than Arthur
Dutch: You have my back Arthur?
Arthur: Always Dutch.
Also dutch:*stabbing sound*🤔😯😕🙁😔
This comment made me tear up! Next thing I thought about was: " I gave you everything I had Dutch!" - Arthur, moment before he passed. 😢
@@superheavyxd2684”I gave you all I had, Dutch… I did.” - Arthur Morgan’s last words to Dutch Van der Linde.
You are my SON
Sad to say it wasn’t the other way around😔
The worst part about being betrayed, it’s always by someone you know
Never from an enemy
No shit that's the definition
@@alfiecorbett1703 God damn calm down bro, the op commenter was just stating their opinion on the worst part about being betrayed, its not something to get furious about, now now maybe you should try some breathing exercises! Breathe in and out deeply for 30 seconds, take your time, you don’t have a train to catch.
The true saying i think is that the worst thing about betrayal is that it never comes from you r enemies
@@alfiecorbett1703 exactly😂
This man trusted an random outlaw he met in a bar for only six months than the person he is with for half of his life
Exactly Dutch is the worst POS ever. He literally raised an orphan as his own then threw him to the streets for a damn rat
Don't worry, he had a plan.
😂😂
Half his life? More like most of his life since Dutch and Horsea raised Arthur when he was 14 they taught him how to hunt, fish, read and write and alot of other things Micah is the whole reason why they are both gone Dutch wasn't thinking right
I think Micah mirrors Dutch's true nature to some degree. Violent, egoistic, greedy.
Arthur but more so Horsea gave him moral hold for a long time but when he met Micah, he didn't had to hid it anymore. That's why Blackwater turned out to be such a mess - because both Arthur and Horsea were absent.
Also Dutch suffered multible head injuries
In those few second’s Dutch realized he had been a fool and apart from Hosea, Arthur had been the best friend he ever had and he had let that go away just for Micah.
Honestly after Hosea’s death, everything went downhill from there
@@KT-tz3mwafter the train station robbery dutch start losing it. I just played that mission today and after that mission You go to largas with dutch and that is the first time I saw him in the Game screaming like a crazy then hosea dies and then he really loses it
When john asks what dutch is doing here he says “same as you, I suppose” and obviously john is here to kill micah. not a lot of people catch this but i think he reunited with micah with intentions to kill him the whole time
@@KT-tz3mwthe situation got out of control back in blackwater
@@tayrus2622blackwater was a mess…
Dutch in that moment, Realized Micah is the main reason Arthur is Gone
And John misses him just as Much as he does
Dutch didn’t shoot Micah for Arthur he shot him because he couldn’t accept the he had been fooled
The fact the guy who played Dutch claimed that after the scene where author is dying when he ‘leaves the scene” he just started to cry. These actors put so much in it that they get connected to it in such a way.
Interesting that Micah’s actor didn’t mind doing what he had too
Ahtur and micha are frensd to (irl)
My friend got a warning from God. He said "Tell my people I am coming back soon, and read your Word".
Here are some verses I recommend reading~
Matthew 7:21-23
Matthew 4:17
Acts 2:17
Joel 2:28
James 2:17-26
Acts 16:31
I recommend writing them down and truly meditating on them.
22 But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves.
23 For if any be a hearer of the word, and not a doer, he is like unto a man beholding his natural face in a glass:
24 For he beholdeth himself, and goeth his way, and straightway forgetteth what manner of man he was.
25 But whoso looketh into the perfect law of liberty, and continueth therein, he being not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, this man shall be blessed in his deed.
-James 1:22-25
Tomorrow isn't promised, BUT, God being a loving and forgiving Father is and always will be, don't wait until later or tomorrow. Gods kingdom is at hand! ❤️
Kinda funny imagining adults using bodysuit with motion capture sensor inside a big studio crying because of the scene that they cant actually see
É atuação, tipo estar fazendo teatro para uma plateia, você sabe da história, mas se entrega tanto no papel, que muitas vezes as emoções transmitidas são reais. @@mehshutup3041
Never paid attention on Dutch’s face during this line. What a masterpiece
That cutscene is a mod Dutch never looked at Micah like that but it would have been cool if they put this much detail into some of the cutscenes
Edit:I replayed rdr2 it looks like he did look at him but not as of realization it was just a slight glance the mod made it look more dramatic
Yeah Dutch has a wild man beard going on instead of the clean cut you see here
@@Ifounddoubtyeah I was thinking “I don’t remember Dutch looking at him like that” and then realized that’s not end game Dutch 😂 But I prefer this little look over, even if it’s a split second difference
@@IfounddoubtYeah, He did
If you remember dutch doesn't actually wear a hat in this scene and hes got a much heavier jacket on
When he looks at Micah feels so hard...
The depression Dutch all of a sudden felt
And the shock to the news
@@Flame-r6ibro he watched him die
@@Nachocheese-np6it I know
@@Nachocheese-np6itno Dutch left before Arthur could die
Not just dutch
Dutch didn't shoot Micah for John. Dutch shot Micah for Arthur
He didn't like John anyway
@@piotr3580He loved John, just as he loved Arthur. They were his sons. His friends. But, he felt like John turned his back on him after Blackwater
I think that’s what Dutch meant when he said “Same as you, I suppose” when John asked why he was there. They both wanted to kill Micah for Arthur.
No he didn’t, he did it for John. It’s John’s story, he always has been and always will be the main character. Arthur was a retcon to make a prequel work. That’s it
@frodoshaggins what?
Arthur is such a good protagonist man😕
But Micah is a good antagonist we all hate him
@@spencerpiesik1639yep that’s when you know he’s a great villain
John marston is better
@@John_Marston445…
@@spencerpiesik1639
you
hate to love him
and
love to hate him
You can see the pain in his eyes as Micah said that. Arthur was his son and he went and betrayed him for a damn rat. He thought he could trust Micah and that he wasn’t the rat but then he goes and shit talks his son. Well John finished off but the Arthur comment made Dutch shot
I think you're looking for things that ain't there? Dutch was a self serving prick, he cared only bout himself.
Yeah but then in RDR 1 Dutch let his pride go to his head and decided to keep on going down that path even though he knew it was one paved with the blood of his family. Don't feel bad for him in the slightest.
@@gunslinginleftist it is more or less of a observation. You can still tell he felt bad about Arthur’s death but he still let everything go to his head in spite of everything. He is kind of a piece of shit still a good character with a nice storyline
@@GhostToastie Oh yeah. Dutch is so cool I want to name my next dog Dutch. He might’ve felt bad, but channeled that remorse into hate and weaponized it against innocents. For sure a well written bad guy.
@@gunslinginleftist he is such a good character. What breed of dog do you ‘plan’ on getting maybe a ‘Dutch’ shepherd ;)
“I gave you all I had.”
In the end I tried I did
" But i tried and im the end i did"
@@BrunoGameplays20090 I... I...
You missed something "OH Dutch..."
@@gUzttavo “Dutch, we made it, come on! We can make it! Come on, Dutch! COME ON! AAAGH!”
Arthur was a SON to Dutch. Finished this game years ago. Not enough words, so I keep a maxxed out Chapter 2 save to revisit.
The moment of realisation Dutch had is so sad. But what’s worse is that after killing Micah Dutch really just didn’t know what to do so he went off and that uncertainty in his life is what probably led him to become the monster that he is in rdr1
In rdr1 you can tell he hates himself he regrets what he did and now doesn't care for anything
Dutch was already a monster. We just haven't seen it on the Blackwater DLC yet😂
@@sarcastickz6885 micah caused that
Horsea and Arthur were his voice of reason the ones that was there to always tell him that's a bad idea while Micah was always telling him to do crazy idea that's how the Blackwater massacre happened Arthur and Horsea were not there they were doing other stuff so they couldn't talk him out of killing all those people
"Monster" bro has -1 media literacy 😂
Anyone else cry when Arthur died?
I sobbed like it was the last time
I didn't cry like that, when my best friend betrayed me like I did when Arthur died. Shit, I just realized that during those hours in the game, I've grown more attached to him than to my probably last friend in life 🤠
@@СырАнча I know bro...
Never thought I would ever cry at a video game after aeriths death in ff7 but then rdr2 came
Between Arthur dying and him thanking the damn horse at the end I fuckin lost my shit 😂 my wife was just looking at me like “bro it’s just a game” lol
First time I played 4 years ago I cried, when I replayed it recently, I cried even harder 😢😓😂. He’s just the greatest protagonist you could ever play.
The way Dutch looked at Arthur said it all. Dutch realized his mistakes too late.
That’s what people don’t understand, Dutch didn’t kill micah to save John, he killed Micah because he wanted to avenge Arthur and leave Micah behind. I believe that Dutch truly loved Arthur and Hosea, even if people think he was bad from the starts
Ye i think it's both mostly to avenge arthur that John ask what are you doing here he says same as you i suppose
Yup I suppose
Duvido que ele fez isso pelo Arthur, acho que foi uma forma de se vingar por toda merda que o Micah fez a Gangue passar
@@tw3801bruh
Dutch just needed the right time to have Michah killed. John Marston provided him with that opportunity
“With you watching over us, I’d ride into hell itself.”
As would I
I just played that mission for the thousandth time 😂💪🏿
Who says this again?
@@Luffy-su1hoDutch says it about Arthur, and Micah agrees
@@Luffy-su1hodutch
My headcannon is that Dutch went crazy because he couldn’t cope with the realization of his mistakes and how it destroyed the gang. That’s why he was how he was in rdr 1
They way he looked at Micah has the expression of "you don't get do FUCKING say that"
Mfn' HELL YEAH
I think at that moment he realized fully that he let Micah damn them all
I personally think Dutch had some PTSD from Arthur’s death and when Micah said that it really hurt Dutch
He had brain trauma from crashing the trolly in saint denis
I think he got PTSD after the fall of his gang. All his deeds after were done cause he didn't care. Because he (or everything good in him) died with his gang.
@@apathy9603 the trolly was taking them to tahiti but it crashed unfortunately.
Because he went against everything he taught Arthur and the gang he crossed he’s own line
The way he wearing arthur's hat 🫡
never realised that dutch looked at micah like that after he said this
When micah shit-talked Arthur, Dutch finally realized he was wrong to Arthur, and john, and everyone else. He still went crazy,hence his final exit in red dead Redemption 1, but when he shot micah... He still had some good in him...😔
He never did. Its a mod
@@кчау-л6я i don’t get why someone would mod that but anyway
@@pluwgfx i dont get it either. But its modded 100%.
@@кчау-л6яnah it’s not modded
The way Dutch look at Micah he was like “the fu*k you say”
Its the animation he looks at him many times😂(sorry to ruin your moment)
@@_.-_.--it's not watch that version he don't look at him that much but deeply stars when Micah says that😂
@@_.-_.-- he stearrs at John alll the time only looks at Micah once and John talks to Dutch more so Dutch is staring at him more😂
When John says Arthur been dead for a long time John stares
Dutch stares at John I mean then Micah says it a few seconds he stares at micah
The way he looked at him showed everything about what he did
Arthur Morgan was a good man but sadly good men must go😢
he wasnt a good man, thats what his whole arc is about. hes a bad guy (like nearly everyone else in the gang) trying to be better. as charles says in the mission where you rescue eagle fly from the army, knowing that you‘ll die was a gift, he has had the chance to be better and not die as the bad guy he was till he got TB. hosea, lenny, the callender brothers etc were bad people. but arthur had the chance to be more than that. even john says it in the epiloge when meeting mickey in valentine, he wasnt a good man, neither a bad man. its surely hard to tell, but his bad deed def overweigh his good ones
@@zin3d1n5 Arthur was a good man that lived a bad life
@@Jaboi. more like he had a potential to be a good man but got raised in wrong hands.
@@zin3d1n5That depends.
My Arthur is definitely burning in hell for pretty much killing every npc wherever he went.
@@sultankebab1587 My Arthur was max honour and remorsed for all this sins, so he probably went to heaven, I'm glad😌
Jesus Christ, Arthur was a real one. Deserved the calm life for sure.
The way Micah said it tells it all. Dutch is a bad man but at this point he still had a guilty conscience.
Arthur deserved better 😢
At least he had his redemption 😔
Yup😔
@@hsh8913Arthur’s redemption was legendary..
Honestly l love Arthur but he had it coming for all the bad things he did
He shouldn't have gone to Thomas downs
Dutch looked so sad he probably regrets leaving Arthur for dead
But he was going to die anyways
@@Theflaminggunslingerso bc someone is gonna die anyways you support dutch for stopping him? You sounds slow ngl
@@kimiko2788 dude💀
@@kimiko2788 he had tuberculosis he was beaten up by Mika really bad you think he is going to survive that
@@kimiko2788 and what do you mean I sound slow bro look at yourself
He cared about arthur but he didn’t know what to do
That dumb ass betrayed Arthur where Arthur stayed loyal until the end even if he saw that Dutch became crazy
So fax!
Dutch: "I was gonna say you're like a son to me, but you're more than that."
Blessed are the peacemakers
the way dutch looked at micah, he realized everything, he realized micah only wanted the money and nothing else, and that he should have never doubted arthur.
Imo: if arthur didnt get tb and beat micahs ass dutch would prob shoot him since he still trusted micah so idk what to say to all the people saying no tb arthur and dutch would regroup or something
He should realized that before putting his foot on Arthur's hand
It depends on which theory on Dutch is true. If he really did go bad over time then yes, he probably did realize right then what a horrible series of mistakes he made that led to all the people he cared about dying or leaving and how he never should've trusted Micah. Alternatively if he was always just using the gang he would've had a similar realization but only cared that his plan was ruined.
Fr I think dutch got caught up with worrying about the Pinkerton
and stuff so then dutch feel into Micah's trap
@@TNASTY6688846993 nah, i dont believe he used the gang, if he did he wouldnt be so heartbroken over hosea or arthur. But he was a bad man that acted like an angel until everybody left him alone.
he takes his hand off though, Arthur has ample time to shoot Micah but decides not to in his final moments in life, either that or he was too weak at that point @@Shayan351
I like how in the clips, Arthur turns grey like he is just a memory now😢
"You better stick to them book's because, Mark my words revenge is fool's game"
Till this day it hits.
i love how it turns arthur grey and not anyone else
Underrated edit. 100%
@@tanweerazam5340What?
@@tanweerazam5340 what are you talking bout bro in the clips arthur fades to gray
@@mnemw Oh i thought he meant After Micah said arthurs been dead along time
i still remember arthur and dutch's conversation in a mission. there the dutch was starting to get brainwashed by micah but wasn't completely. they were talking something about trust. then dutch said, "I'll walk into the hell itself if you're watching my back boy".
Arthur didn’t deserve that 😢
Also john 😢
Arthur was a follower, friend and most of all a brother to Dutch or even a son to Dutch
No he was more than that
Arthur Morgan will alwys be a fkn Legend man R.I.P
At least Arthur, john and lenny are now in heaven drinking a lot of beers
Leny!@!1
Heaven? Nice joke 😂
None of them made to heaven
They all Rob and kill
Sean: “wut bout me-“
@@KingsD3adi meant high honor Arthur and low honor Arthur is in hell
They say grown men cant cry, couldn’t have been so far from the truth
"The same things make us laugh, make us cry."
You can see the anger and sadness in his eyes
the way dutch looks at him 😢 W edit 🐐
one of THE best edits i’ve seen
Song name?
We gave you everything we had Dutch, we did.... we loved you.😔💔
I replayed the ending recently. I still cry and feel just depressed and shaken. Red Dead Redemption 2 is not just a masterpiece, it's art! It makes you feel stuff! 😢
Dutch felt that when just looked at micah and realized how he killed the only people you trusted him and helped him the whole time
Arthur was the real hero, he didn't die, he just rested.
Enough to make a grown man cry.
That sudden Tilt and expression on Dutch's face 💀
Rdr is the only thing I live for❤
The way Dutch looked at the rat, he realised that Micah was just going for money….😢😢😢💔💔
something i wish rockstar added was gang npcs reacting to john wearing Arthur's hat, i feel like micah definitely would have made a snarky comment when he saw john wearing that hat.
When you have a gun pointed at you I doubt you’d look at what hat the other guy was wearing, nor has he seen that hat for years.
@@cashmoneycockburn9502 when john brings up arthur directly during the standoff he 100% would have remembered the hat, or at the very least dutch
the way he's gray'd out at the last frame kind of like a fading memory
In case you Were wondering;
The Song’s Name is
IDGAF By Black Bear
THANK YOU
@@goosebish8646 Ain’t no Problem
Thanks for the song. Name that is.
He has been poisoned by Micah and when he says Arthur, really wake him up
The way Dutch looks at Micah seems like he still always cared for arthur
Wow I can’t believe I didn’t notice that. You can tell so much went through Dutch’s head is such a split second. He knew he lost the better man.
Arthur deserved more
It took dutch too long but finally realized where he went wrong
You can see the way he looked at Micah he was crying inside he was you can tell and that’s most likely why he shoot Micah and it’s sad to see in rdr he goes insane sure he was a bad guy but he’s still an amazing character
I feel good to see that Dutch realised his mistake atleast for a short period of time😌
The fading to black of Arthur is like how he slowly fades away with his condition and how his memory fades from all who knew him. I respect that detail man. 😢
that’s the exact moment dutch had finally realized he messed the fuck up
Sort of, Dutch is a complicated villain who could easily just be evil completely or caring. He loved the gang for sure though
In rdr1 he is a psycho. I played both games and Dutch probably was always evil
I think he Just fucked up is life after lose Arthur because of him and the other like sadie John...
@@airshipgrain8904 what?
Dude, is so...sad and excellent
Arthur was so loyal that in the end that he knew even the owner of the gang (Dutch) was on the wrong side and even with this he wanted to safe the gang incredible character
Arthur💔 always the fav for me.
You should’ve ended the video with Dutch shooting Micah after the flashbacks. Then it would’ve been perfect 💯
💀💀💀💀💀
A clip of Dutch putting his hand on Arthur’s shoulder in the flashbacks.
“I was going to say you’re like a son to me, but you’re more than that…”😮💨
In the actual game when Micah says Arthur been dead a long time Dutch stopped talking right there so Dutch probably remembered what Micah did
Bro broke my hart. its just that look of Dutch😭
heart*
He love arthur even in the end but he know its to late
"All them years dutch" 😔
Just for this rat :(
This game changed my life🖤
This is one masterpiece of an edit. Definitely one of my favourites.
Pls someone like this so I can revisit this ❤
Trust it’s a really hard clip
To find
Come here bro
The way Dutch looked at Micah realising what he done and what to do, the pain in his eyes was pure pain.
I LOVE this scene purely because of how you see Dutch immediately look at micah while disrespecting aurther
Arthur looking drippy as hell in this video
Arthur had a cold yet open heart to those he loved.
Song name?
And after this, we felt happy once again!!
Dutch looking at Micah like that, hits diffrent.
The sudden wave of emotions washed all over Dutch's face, you can see his face completely drop. He didn't know.
Dutch may be a selfish narcissist but he genuinely did care about Arthur 😔
Before
Arthur: “I’m here ain’t I? Been by your side for 20 years!”
Dutch: “I KNOW!!! I!…I… I’m sorry son..”
After
Arthur: “I gave you all I had…”
Dutch: “I… I…..”
Dutch new it was to late to say sorry at that point. He walks off with tears in his eyes eventually breaking down.
No! If you recall Dutch ran away when he saw Authur get knocked down by the gas.. luckily Arthur safe by eagle flies..
@@loyscgodlike that’s when he genuinely believed in Michas lies. He thought Arthur was the rat.
In the end Dutch sees the truth and realizes he failed his sons. It drove him insane hence rdr1. Dutch isn’t someone who likes to admit when he’s wrong. But trust me he knows when he is. His ego, pride, ambition, intelligence and insanity drove him to the edge.
It would’ve been 8 years since Arthur’s death during this scene 😢
This scene takes place in 1907
@@ki_Cpyes which is 8 years after Arthur’s death
You could tell in Dutchs eyes there after Micha said "hes been dead a long time" he was sad and regretted everything
Man I always thought Micah was that one psychotic crazy guy of the gang but extremely loyal, Kind of like Trevor, But when It was revealed he was the rat all my respect disappeared in an instant
Micah never had my respect, a crazy and egotistical asshole who antagonizes everyone in the camp at every chance he gets, Arthur should've left in Strawberry.
If I remember correctly, he drops a couple of racist lines straight up in first chapter, so I never had any respect for him.
Arthur had Dutchs back. In the end, despite the value in loyalty, Dutch betrayed him.
I think he realized the full impact of this fact at this moment.
Dutch has always been my favorite character. Don’t really know why but he’s my favorite
Dutch:your like a brother to me author.Micha:brutally stabs author in the back.Dutch:and I was okay with that
Hits hard when he’s wearing Arthur’s hat 😢
You can tell Dutch cared and knew he screwed up
Arthur really was a Good Man.
He just wouldn't show it
He definitely did, every who knew him will say he was a kind, loyal man. He just didn't think he was one, so he out on a rough exterior
He was not a good man bro and l love Arthur one of my favorite characters but he caught tuberculosis while beating a dying sick man in front of his family to death over money and he was in a violent gang for over 20 years and it took him to get sick to realize all the bad he’s done and the bad things outweighs the good things he did so he definitely went to hell just bc he tried to change towards the end after he got sick and saved a few people don’t mean nothing
@@theunprofessional9837actually he tried to change . Everybody has bad deeds Arthur was a good man dawg he was changing even before getting sick
@@Seven-or1lx no bro he wasn’t arthur was in a violent gang robbing and killing people for over 20 years and he wasn’t changing until he got sick bro after he got sick that’s when he tried to apologize to the family of the guy he beat up to death he didn’t do it before he did it after so it took him to get sick and knowing he was gonna die for all the bad things he did in the past 20 years being with Dutch? Yeah that wasn’t a good man at all and u gotta realize the game it’s trying to romanticize the criminal lifestyle of Arthur existed in real life and did all those things he did on the game everyone would look at him like a degenerate
The way dutch looked at him after saying something so disrespectful proves that dutch still cared about arthur
He looked at him like that because he thought Arthur escaped and saved himself ☹️
Bro he saw him die wdym
@@robbymark972 he didn't,he turned around and left,he never knew Arthur died
@@263fr he did, he knew that Arthur died
@@robbymark972 he didn't,he doesn't see Arthur die. He said it in an interview. he just sees that Arthur is dying and that he's beaten up and exhausted,but he turns around. He thinks Arthur will escape
He knows Arthur is dead