The manderin one is like talking to Tao, Kris, and Luhan. But the Korean one is saying that they will keep moving forward for the fans even though it hurts
i strongly agree. im Korean. so i can understand what the lyric means well. but when i listen the k version, i feel they talk to exo l but the m version is talking about their mind to their ex members. it could be i cannot understand the m version though
+NCT Forever Lay composed the song, but for the Chinese version, Lay wrote ALL the lyrics, including the rap part. For the Korean version, Chen wrote the lyrics (Lay helped a little too) while Chanyeol wrote the rap.
Lay wrote this song for Tao (his only co-chinese member left during that time) but he's not dense and knows that exo-m's makne will also leave sooner or later, making him reminisce about their memories as ot12 and that even though everyone of them doesn't show it, he wants him to know that on the insde they are breaking and are also missing them (luhan and kris).. that's why if Tao really decides to leave.. he will promise that no matter what happen.. the will always be one (note: "we are one EXO") as for the korean version.. chen and chanyeol helped writing and translating this song.. the difference is that if the chinese version is for the ex-members then the korean one is for the EXO-Ls.. that even if 3 are gone, they would still stay as EXO for us which explains why Lay may hardly be without EXO most of the time but he's still not "leaving" EXO (note: there's an interview or something with EXO where Lay is on skype.. the girl said "you'll be coming back right?" to him and Lay said "I will come back.. I must come back).. another explanation is that EXO never is still not replacing the ex-members.. I mean the company can do that even with the trials going on that time but they didn't because in a group like this, there should an agreement with the original members.. also this song is connected to "miracles of december" (note: read the lyrics.. he mentioned the song)
Korean Ver. and Chinese Ver. are all for EXO-L,not for the left members(though a lot of fans still remind of them).2 versions of this song both talking about the hand-in-hand promise with EXO-L after pain and suffer. :) Lay said that at the end of a concert to fans telling them this is a song for EXO-L.
i think it was originally for Kris and Luhan at the time since he wanted Tao to write the chinese rap lyrics but then he left so he had to write it himself
Aveni Vicky nah, the korean ver. is for EXO-L whilst the mandarin ver. is for the ex-members. Lay said that Promise was for EXO-L at the end of a concert in Korea, where they only sang the korean version. When he wrote his book "standing firm at 24" in 2015, he wrote that the song was for the ex-members :)
It's 2016 but I will never get over this song. The chinese version is so much deeper since lay wrote ALL the lyrics and ALL his songs are SO SO SO sad ...
agree It's his feelings when he wrote these words )": or all his lyrics songs Even if it expresses sadness but you feel his emotion in his work that why he's Masterpiece 3>
this song is easily the one that holds the most meaning so I'm so proud of yixing for it. both his rap and singing was so good and I know the rest of exo felt it too, because they sang this with so much of themselves into despite not speaking mandarin. but yeah, lay carried this song.
Same it's sad that the fans are giving him hate I'm not the type of fan to like them for their bodies or looks I like the way they work hard and their talents
So I basically love all of them equally like family fans are saying that Lay should leave EXO and that he's selfish and stuff like that but really he works more than the boys due to working in China and practicing with EXO
PREACH! Lol, but yeah, that is really true. Like I'm not saying that he should deserve more love than the other members, nor am I saying that he should be everyone's bias or whatever. I just wish that the people who wants him to leave exo or say that he is selfish to acknowledge him for his hard work.
"Consolation can no longer console my heart because I know you'll leave one day" I broke down when he said please don't leave, next 😭😭😭 I'm crying fuck
Imagine if Luhan, Kris, and Tao sang this, too. I'm sorry for bringing them up again (I know many people don't like it when they are brought up)... Luhan's voice would've been so sweet, Kris and Tao would have perfect rap lines...
All those albums being produced after they left would have been perfect for their voices. But no they had to leave Overdose as their last album ._. ;-; And it's even the one I like the least xD .__.
Mia Sanders I know. This song want my favourite when I first started following exo. However, the more I know them and the things that they have been through, this song has touched my heart very very deeply ❤️❤️❤️
After reading Lay's book I had to come here to give this song another listen. I feel like I understand who he is just a little bit better now. Thank you Yixing ❤
+Noura M It's called "Standing Firm at 24" and if you type that in followed by English translation you'll find links to it (it's a Google drive document)
no no. i heard that the song was written by Lay but the lyric of song was written by chen. as u know chen is korean. he might write it in Korean. the rap was written by chanyeol. so the all the lyric is made in Korean first. then it might be translated to Chinese. give contribution to right person!!!
+Eunice But Lay is the only one fluent in Mandarin so he probably translated it for them, and edited the lyrics a bit so words fit better, etc. Personally I like the M ver better just because it seems more directed at the members who left and it's really touching~
HunHan feels. Lu Han was always smiling when with Sehun. Sehun looked so dower as his little deer left. Then Tao leaves as he losses is other closest friend. He looses that glow and that sunshine smile he had. Lay something I feel Lay looks lost with the other Chinese members. I can't help but think Sehun's lack of good performance after Tao's leaving is showing us that he's hurting. people lambasting him for being shit at everything. How would you feel if your Two closest friends left you? Don't you think that'd affect your performance if you were in a band? Be nice to your Maknae! That being said, I'm truly happy for Tao out of all the ex members he appears to be the happiest and you can tell it when you listen to his songs.
Luhan was very close with a lot of the members, not only Sehun. Hell, he was more close with Xiumin and the other Exo-M members than Sehun. Acting like he only smile with Sehun, you need to watch all his videos again. You shippers are too much!
I don't know anything about them other than they're a kpop group who lost members but I'm such a nerd when it comes to lyrics...I think I might tear up from words said by complete strangers. I swear I'm normal
Promise Koran & Chinese version makes me cry.. Makes me miss TAO, LuHan & Kris even more than I am already... And even if Lay is in EXO still, I miss him too, because he isnt with EXO so much anymore, since he is in China doing his stuff.. :(
I'm not usually a super emotional person, but I listened to this version of the song for the first time and I was crying. Lay did such a good job I'm so proud of him. 我爱你，宝贝！
I cried watching this. Seriously. This song contains what EXO members wanted to tell EXO-Ls. It's composed by ZHANG YIXING张艺兴/LAY, Lyrics by KIM JONG DAE/CHEN, and rap part by PARK CHAN YEOL/CHANYEOL. It's the best song ever. I mean it.
Uniunicorn xi You not appreciate lay work.. he trying hard to wrote and Composed this song.. Chanyeol and chen just help at korean lyrics.. In korean lyrics lay wrote too.. but he lost so chen and chanyeol come to help him..
woah woah woah no offense I googled it right before i sent this comment and GOOGLE SAID CHEN AND CHANYEOL DID THE KOREAN LYRICS sry if this is not the truth. Also, i DO appreciate his work, and lay is my UB forever, just to make clear. I understand his language and his experience since i also went to another country without knowing a word of that language...I DO APPRECIATE 张艺兴'S EXISTENCE.
Uniunicorn xi Yeah of course chen and chanyeol write the korean version. but in korean actually lay write too but chen help him because he korean not really good..
只有这首歌能每一次都弄哭我。只有这首歌告诉我继续坚持这个梦。为我爱的十二个少年，再累也无所谓，因为当我们放弃时，他们会更累。 This is the only song that makes me cry every sing time. Only this song tells me to hold onto this dream. For the twelve boys I love, it doesn't matter that I'm tired, because when we let go, it'll tire them out more.
Califfa Lowood Lay composed both versions and wrote the entire Chinese lyrics and rap. Chen wrote the Korean lyrics (in collab with Lay) and Chanyeol wrote the rap of the Korean version.
The Chinese Version reminds me of HunHan. When Luhan is still in EXO. Every moments, every angle, every time, every minute you look at Sehun he's smiling. But that smile fades away when Luhan left him. First Kris who is a father figure to him left him and then the least person he expect to leave. Already left him. And Tao his best friend leave him too. I want to see him smile again. Smile that he show us the bright side. I miss your Smile Sehunnie. I miss everything about you. I miss you.
at korean version im crying at kai and chanyeol's part, and here lay's line makes me cry alot... kai and chanyeol lines makes you think the promise they make to be ONE, coz WE ARE ONE always and lay makes you remembers those times when they are still 12, all the happy, sad, struggle, emotions they put it in these song...
After listening to this song,Lay became my bias (because he is so talented ,like god ) actually my first bias when I got into EXO is Luhan then he left
i love it!! i love how lay does the rap at beginning even though he is not the rapper and how chanyeol finishes it off strong, i'm guessing that chanyeol had some problem with the pronunciation and lay helped, i loved how s.m never changed the not giving sehun enough lines in songs even tho us fans hate it, i just love exo they r a perfection by god. saranghae EXO, exo-l 4 ever
We EXO-L are so lucky to have EXO in our life. We see our happiness in theirs and their sadness as ours. I'm very confident that i can't love anyone the way i love EXO. I'm so glad that they came into my life. Listening to them sing a sing for we EXO-L is the best thing in the world. It's been 2 years since I've been saving money to go to Korea. My life's ambition to just meet them and tell them how much i love them. 사랑해요 엑소❤❤❤❤ WE ARE ONE FOREVER😍 FIGHTING!!!!! Thank you EXO and all EXO-L
It's 2019 and I'm still crying over this, again and again. It's been years but this still strikes the heart differently. What a masterpiece yet such a bittersweet song.
This is a very painful song to listen to. About someone you held very dear to your heart leaving you forever. And even when people try to console you, you can never fully recover. You had a promise with that person but it was broken and unfortunately that person will never fully trust you again. You reminisce on the memories you had with that person and you Promise them that you will protect them from being hurt and that you will do anything to be back together with them. However it seems nothing is enough. So instead you reminisce on your past happy memories and eventually accept that as long as they are happy, even without you, you will in turn be happy for them and give them anything.
The whole time I thought about the other 3 Chinese members... Even though they're not promoting as OT12 anymore, but as they debuted, there was 12 members.
it's 2016 9 9 back and listen feel so emotion and cry )": a lot of the difficulties they went through but they keep the promise very proud of them !!! WE ARE ONE 12 FOREVER
i feel like there are so many hidden words and meanings *"Everything i do for you may not be enough"* _to convince you not to leave_ *"As long as your happy and blessed, I'm willing"* _to let you go_
“You and i, those beautiful days. You and I together (us together). Every drop of memories, you said with certainty “we will create miracles”. I know using my heart to feel, you’ll be by my side. I promise you (i promise you). I want us forever.” Man this part just-😩😩😭😭
Chanyeol's rap in the Korean ver and Lays rap in the Chinese ver just make me cry so hard coz I promise to BE AN EXO-L FOREVER AND SUPPORT EXO FOREVER even after they disband I will hold my second family close to my heart EXO-L FIGHTING EXO FIGHTING *God this is why I love rappers they can be such a turn on but kill me so fast like this 🖤🌹👑🔥 MY KINGS PLS CONTINUE TO SLAY MINE AND ALL OF THE EXO-L LIFE 🖤🌹👑🔥
It's already 2018 and I'm still crying while listening and reading those lyrics. I've heard this song a lot, listened to it a lot of times, but still can make me cry af😭
Today is EXO's 8th anniversary and the journey was not easy but we came this far, this song brings back so many memories which I will cherished forever, EXO LETS LOVE ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
I'm not an EXO-L but I really like EXO, and even though I'm not a declared fan, I really suffered from the departure of the members so I couldn't hold my tears here. I don't understand how there are 23 people disliking this song. It's absurd. Plus, this is even sadder than the korean version.
i never heard EXO's songs again after hear BTS's songs, but this song always makes me goosebumps, a song which sung with all their heart, i can feel their honesty and feeling
johnea michrace you know this owner forget mention Lay and Suho Name at description. make me feel sad.. This is song made by lay and She forget his name..
I feel the chinese version more. Maybe because I understand it and it's expressed well in both lyrics and vocals and also mu bae Channie. Credits to Lay who wrote the Chinese version and the tune all by himself.
It's so hurtful 😢😢😢😢 it's so meaning full.... It's much sadder than the Korean one since Lay wrote all the lyrics ❤️ I will never forget this song ❤️❤️ we are one EXO....... ❤️❤️❤️
As someone whose second language is chinese, I feel so ashamed that EXO (excluding yixing) can sing so well in chinese. I cant even speak it properly >
I can totally relate, my family speaks Chinese at home but I can't read (more words, anyways) or write much xD I can understand and speak it alright, I guess aha
Don't feel too bad...they're not THAT good XD This is one of the only Chinese versions where I can just barely understand everything the Korean members are saying Most of the other songs are just...muddled My mom's mother tongue is Chinese and she was SURPRISED when I told her they were singing in her first language lmao Excluding yixing of course
The manderin one is like talking to Tao, Kris, and Luhan. But the Korean one is saying that they will keep moving forward for the fans even though it hurts
i strongly agree. im Korean. so i can understand what the lyric means well. but when i listen the k version, i feel they talk to exo l but the m version is talking about their mind to their ex members. it could be i cannot understand the m version though
+Eunice well, maybe so. but also bc didn't lay compose some of the lyrics? he has broken down all of his raw emotions in this song...
+Katherineh885 ChanYeol and Lay Collab just to write the Lyrics and help compose some of the music :)
+NCT Forever Lay composed the song, but for the Chinese version, Lay wrote ALL the lyrics, including the rap part. For the Korean version, Chen wrote the lyrics (Lay helped a little too) while Chanyeol wrote the rap.
well the chinese lyrics were written by Lay so yeah maybe he gave a message to the former members.Who knows? ;)
Lay wrote this song for Tao (his only co-chinese member left during that time) but he's not dense and knows that exo-m's makne will also leave sooner or later, making him reminisce about their memories as ot12 and that even though everyone of them doesn't show it, he wants him to know that on the insde they are breaking and are also missing them (luhan and kris).. that's why if Tao really decides to leave.. he will promise that no matter what happen.. the will always be one (note: "we are one EXO")
as for the korean version.. chen and chanyeol helped writing and translating this song.. the difference is that if the chinese version is for the ex-members then the korean one is for the EXO-Ls.. that even if 3 are gone, they would still stay as EXO for us
which explains why Lay may hardly be without EXO most of the time but he's still not "leaving" EXO (note: there's an interview or something with EXO where Lay is on skype.. the girl said "you'll be coming back right?" to him and Lay said "I will come back.. I must come back)..
another explanation is that EXO never is still not replacing the ex-members.. I mean the company can do that even with the trials going on that time but they didn't because in a group like this, there should an agreement with the original members..
also this song is connected to "miracles of december" (note: read the lyrics.. he mentioned the song)
Korean Ver. and Chinese Ver. are all for EXO-L,not for the left members(though a lot of fans still remind of them).2 versions of this song both talking about the hand-in-hand promise with EXO-L after pain and suffer. :) Lay said that at the end of a concert to fans telling them this is a song for EXO-L.
Gennie Aquino I saw that skype too but I forgot was it the one with EXO or the one still about EXO comeback days
it is also about members leaving, lay wrote that himself
i think it was originally for Kris and Luhan at the time since he wanted Tao to write the chinese rap lyrics but then he left so he had to write it himself
Aveni Vicky
nah, the korean ver. is for EXO-L whilst the mandarin ver. is for the ex-members. Lay said that Promise was for EXO-L at the end of a concert in Korea, where they only sang the korean version. When he wrote his book "standing firm at 24" in 2015, he wrote that the song was for the ex-members :)
Well that hurt. The whole time I was trying so hard not to cry. And I almost made it. But Lay's rapping part did me in. The feels are real tonight.
It's 2016 but I will never get over this song. The chinese version is so much deeper since lay wrote ALL the lyrics and ALL his songs are SO SO SO sad ...
agree It's his feelings when he wrote these words )": or all his lyrics songs
Even if it expresses sadness but you feel his emotion in his work that why he's Masterpiece
3>
Ever listen to MYM by Lay???😏
2020
2020 and still can't get over 🤧
2021 🥺
this song is easily the one that holds the most meaning so I'm so proud of yixing for it. both his rap and singing was so good and I know the rest of exo felt it too, because they sang this with so much of themselves into despite not speaking mandarin. but yeah, lay carried this song.
Lay's rap! So proud of him
Same it's sad that the fans are giving him hate I'm not the type of fan to like them for their bodies or looks I like the way they work hard and their talents
So I basically love all of them equally like family fans are saying that Lay should leave EXO and that he's selfish and stuff like that but really he works more than the boys due to working in China and practicing with EXO
PREACH! Lol, but yeah, that is really true. Like I'm not saying that he should deserve more love than the other members, nor am I saying that he should be everyone's bias or whatever. I just wish that the people who wants him to leave exo or say that he is selfish to acknowledge him for his hard work.
EXO&BTS CAN FITE ME Lmao jk I'm too short No baby, Juat immature fans hate some exo member.. But all exo-l really love him so much
The saddest thing is that he rap as the rappers are gone
"Consolation can no longer console my heart because I know you'll leave one day" I broke down when he said please don't leave, next 😭😭😭 I'm crying fuck
same friend
Imagine if Luhan, Kris, and Tao sang this, too. I'm sorry for bringing them up again (I know many people don't like it when they are brought up)... Luhan's voice would've been so sweet, Kris and Tao would have perfect rap lines...
Omg YASS it would be perfect *crawls into the corner and cries*
All those albums being produced after they left would have been perfect for their voices. But no they had to leave Overdose as their last album ._. ;-; And it's even the one I like the least xD .__.
I do think it would've been amazing, although the song may never have surfaced if it wasn't for their departure.
Leigh Riddick Ahhh that's quite true... The feels only come when we think of the three that left.
If they are still in the group, I dont even think there will be this song.
*We Are One, Right?*
yes, we are one! :')
Forever 💙
Yes we are one.Forever and ever.
Yeeeees we are one ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Ofcourse
Omg i tear up every time i hear lay rapping.I wish sm will treat him and their idols better!!
When I first got into Exo I didn't like the calmer and sadder songs that much yet here I am, a sobbing mess under my covers in the middle of the night
Mia Sanders I know. This song want my favourite when I first started following exo. However, the more I know them and the things that they have been through, this song has touched my heart very very deeply ❤️❤️❤️
Same
After reading Lay's book I had to come here to give this song another listen. I feel like I understand who he is just a little bit better now. Thank you Yixing ❤
where i can read it (engsub) ?
+Noura M It's called "Standing Firm at 24" and if you type that in followed by English translation you'll find links to it (it's a Google drive document)
thank you ❤
ot5 trash Thank you
reading his book...? WHAT BOOK TELL ME
chinese lyrics are just beautifull, maybe because it's the original version
no no. i heard that the song was written by Lay but the lyric of song was written by chen. as u know chen is korean. he might write it in Korean. the rap was written by chanyeol. so the all the lyric is made in Korean first. then it might be translated to Chinese. give contribution to right person!!!
+Eunice whoa chill babe
+Eunice But Lay is the only one fluent in Mandarin so he probably translated it for them, and edited the lyrics a bit so words fit better, etc. Personally I like the M ver better just because it seems more directed at the members who left and it's really touching~
+Eunice That's two different lyrics, they did try to translate it. But it's lay's song, that's why Chinese ver. sounds better.
+June forever agreed
D.O.'s Chinese is super good!
Do english and spanish as well.. :3
Well that’s why he’s called king-of-singing-in-different-languages 😍
HunHan feels. Lu Han was always smiling when with Sehun. Sehun looked so dower as his little deer left. Then Tao leaves as he losses is other closest friend. He looses that glow and that sunshine smile he had.
Lay something I feel Lay looks lost with the other Chinese members.
I can't help but think Sehun's lack of good performance after Tao's leaving is showing us that he's hurting. people lambasting him for being shit at everything. How would you feel if your Two closest friends left you? Don't you think that'd affect your performance if you were in a band?
Be nice to your Maknae!
That being said, I'm truly happy for Tao out of all the ex members he appears to be the happiest and you can tell it when you listen to his songs.
I know it still hurts and hate how it is SM's fault. otherwise they would still be together
I miss HunHan so much 😔❤️
MISS XIUHAN SO MUCH
SleepyDoodle my hunhan feels were literally so triggered when listening to this song
Luhan was very close with a lot of the members, not only Sehun. Hell, he was more close with Xiumin and the other Exo-M members than Sehun. Acting like he only smile with Sehun, you need to watch all his videos again. You shippers are too much!
Lay and Chanyeol's rap got me crying and screaming
So proud of Lay! Seriously, he can do anything!
Everytime I listen to Promise ver M , I'm deeply pain and cry. I miss them!
#LoveEXO-M
EXO kai
EXO 😭😭😭
I don't know anything about them other than they're a kpop group who lost members but I'm such a nerd when it comes to lyrics...I think I might tear up from words said by complete strangers. I swear I'm normal
如果Lay写了这些歌词，他真的很感激。尝试更难的孩子
Promise Koran & Chinese version makes me cry..
Makes me miss TAO, LuHan & Kris even more than I am already...
And even if Lay is in EXO still, I miss him too, because he isnt with EXO so much anymore, since he is in China doing his stuff.. :(
I'm not usually a super emotional person, but I listened to this version of the song for the first time and I was crying. Lay did such a good job I'm so proud of him. 我爱你，宝贝！
Lay is amazing! All their vocals are on point here! CHEN is bae❤️❤️❤️👏🏽😭
I cried watching this. Seriously. This song contains what EXO members wanted to tell EXO-Ls. It's composed by ZHANG YIXING张艺兴/LAY, Lyrics by KIM JONG DAE/CHEN, and rap part by PARK CHAN YEOL/CHANYEOL. It's the best song ever. I mean it.
Uniunicorn xi No. you know this lyrics by Lay. not chen.. chen just help lyrics korean..
Uniunicorn xi You not appreciate lay work.. he trying hard to wrote and Composed this song.. Chanyeol and chen just help at korean lyrics.. In korean lyrics lay wrote too.. but he lost so chen and chanyeol come to help him..
woah woah woah no offense I googled it right before i sent this comment and GOOGLE SAID CHEN AND CHANYEOL DID THE KOREAN LYRICS sry if this is not the truth. Also, i DO appreciate his work, and lay is my UB forever, just to make clear. I understand his language and his experience since i also went to another country without knowing a word of that language...I DO APPRECIATE 张艺兴'S EXISTENCE.
Uniunicorn xi Yeah of course chen and chanyeol write the korean version. but in korean actually lay write too but chen help him because he korean not really good..
只有这首歌能每一次都弄哭我。只有这首歌告诉我继续坚持这个梦。为我爱的十二个少年，再累也无所谓，因为当我们放弃时，他们会更累。
This is the only song that makes me cry every sing time. Only this song tells me to hold onto this dream. For the twelve boys I love, it doesn't matter that I'm tired, because when we let go, it'll tire them out more.
This song means so much to exo because Lay composed it himself (Chinese Ver.). the Korean version is a collab of Lay, Chen and Chanyeol.
Califfa Lowood Lay composed both versions and wrote the entire Chinese lyrics and rap. Chen wrote the Korean lyrics (in collab with Lay) and Chanyeol wrote the rap of the Korean version.
The Chinese Version reminds me of HunHan. When Luhan is still in EXO. Every moments, every angle, every time, every minute you look at Sehun he's smiling. But that smile fades away when Luhan left him. First Kris who is a father figure to him left him and then the least person he expect to leave. Already left him. And Tao his best friend leave him too. I want to see him smile again. Smile that he show us the bright side. I miss your Smile Sehunnie. I miss everything about you. I miss you.
Who's listening this in 2017 and still crying?
here!! :"(
Exo Ot12 Forever me
Exo Ot12 Forever me😭😭😭
i look so ugly right now 😢😭
me 😢😢
excuse me ... the guy who start the song is LAY
Baekhyuni Exo Yes
Baekhyuni Exo he wrote the Chinese vr
Ivy Li And wrote korean version too.. But in korean chen and cy help him.. In chinese just himself
at korean version im crying at kai and chanyeol's part, and here lay's line makes me cry alot...
kai and chanyeol lines makes you think the promise they make to be ONE, coz WE ARE ONE always
and lay makes you remembers those times when they are still 12, all the happy, sad, struggle, emotions they put it in these song...
After listening to this song,Lay became my bias (because he is so talented ,like god ) actually my first bias when I got into EXO is Luhan then he left
Like the tiny Jimin floating in the air same
we all have someone we think about when we hear this song...
Yeah. Tao, Lu and Kris
+Leigh Riddick yep
i wish tao is rapping the part TT
o yeah, all of EXO's members
莫忘初衷
永遠支持12隻小狼
只希望你們都能幸福快樂
享受舞台
不管未來發生什麼
我只知道這段故事永遠不會消失
只要你開心幸福我願意
這段歌詞送給你們
不管做什麼決定
只要記得粉絲一直是你們最堅強的後盾
We are one!!!!
EXO相愛吧
i love it!! i love how lay does the rap at beginning even though he is not the rapper and how chanyeol finishes it off strong, i'm guessing that chanyeol had some problem with the pronunciation and lay helped, i loved how s.m never changed the not giving sehun enough lines in songs even tho us fans hate it, i just love exo they r a perfection by god. saranghae EXO, exo-l 4 ever
We EXO-L are so lucky to have EXO in our life. We see our happiness in theirs and their sadness as ours. I'm very confident that i can't love anyone the way i love EXO. I'm so glad that they came into my life. Listening to them sing a sing for we EXO-L is the best thing in the world. It's been 2 years since I've been saving money to go to Korea. My life's ambition to just meet them and tell them how much i love them.
사랑해요 엑소❤❤❤❤
WE ARE ONE FOREVER😍
FIGHTING!!!!!
Thank you EXO and all EXO-L
Fighting. Let's love 💙
Im in love with this song...like seriously lay is amaizing and all exo member but this is beautifuul....!!!
Lay's rap fuckingg slay me why did I find this now?
LAY'S RAPPING PART OH MY LORD THE TEARS
the original exo-m members getting the most lines in this version is what tears me up the most.....
It's 2019 and I'm still crying over this, again and again. It's been years but this still strikes the heart differently. What a masterpiece yet such a bittersweet song.
My UB is D.O but omg! Lay and Chanyeol rapping gave me so much feels!!!!!!!
+xoxSamIsLuvablexox OMG I LOV UR NAME XD ,
+Sugar Kookie Kpoprgdyvrhx😍😍😍
kAl😙😙😙😙😙
This is a very painful song to listen to. About someone you held very dear to your heart leaving you forever. And even when people try to console you, you can never fully recover. You had a promise with that person but it was broken and unfortunately that person will never fully trust you again. You reminisce on the memories you had with that person and you Promise them that you will protect them from being hurt and that you will do anything to be back together with them. However it seems nothing is enough. So instead you reminisce on your past happy memories and eventually accept that as long as they are happy, even without you, you will in turn be happy for them and give them anything.
😭😭😭😭😭Ot12💔
The whole time I thought about the other 3 Chinese members...
Even though they're not promoting as OT12 anymore, but as they debuted, there was 12 members.
Lay raps part😍
Suho voice is so good. Support you as always xx Suho oppa 😘🎈👏🏼🎉💕💋❤️💙
Don't SM blocks the videos anymore?
KPOP Lyrics~ {REQUESTS CLOSED} they still do ==" I expect they to block this one in one or two days :(
Lynn Eksonyeondan ouuu. okay :(( poor yoU AND everyone else ;((
KPOP Lyrics~ {REQUESTS CLOSED} do they block your videos?
Lynn Eksonyeondan yeah they did.. a long time ago ;((
yea they just blocked mine :)) I'm sad =="
1:18 KIM MINSEOK FUCKED ME UP SO HARDSHFFIJKHNET
saAmE
it's 2016 9 9 back and listen
feel so emotion and cry )":
a lot of the difficulties they went through but they keep the promise
very proud of them !!!
WE ARE ONE 12 FOREVER
exo m has something else..the feeling?❤
i feel like there are so many hidden words and meanings
*"Everything i do for you may not be enough"* _to convince you not to leave_
*"As long as your happy and blessed, I'm willing"* _to let you go_
The chinese version is more sad :(
Thank you Lay
the K and M lyrics are so different. 5 years had passed and here I am, crying. I miss KrisTaoHan and OT12 so much.
how could you forget to mention lay and suho in the description???
Lily Tran yeah..i thought suho has no lines because he was not in the description
12人EXO以經是過去了，愛麗的願望只有一個，希望12人能在一次一起表演就好。只有這首歌可以讓我哭的面目全非。
好想念12只小狼在一起的时光！听完后我哭了！
源王 我也好想念他们 :(
嗯
Iris Lim 我希望luhan,kris和tao能回来!
我也很想EXO12小狼在一起，我真的很希望EXO可以在變成12只小狼，我很想鹿晗，吳亦凡，黃子韜，張藝興，以前我只喜歡藝興可是我發現12只小狼在一起比較好
真想原本12個人的EXO，聽完這首約定不知不覺留下眼淚
“You and i, those beautiful days. You and I together (us together). Every drop of memories, you said with certainty “we will create miracles”. I know using my heart to feel, you’ll be by my side. I promise you (i promise you). I want us forever.”
Man this part just-😩😩😭😭
Chanyeol's rap in the Korean ver and Lays rap in the Chinese ver just make me cry so hard coz I promise to BE AN EXO-L FOREVER AND SUPPORT EXO FOREVER even after they disband I will hold my second family close to my heart EXO-L FIGHTING EXO FIGHTING
*God this is why I love rappers they can be such a turn on but kill me so fast like this 🖤🌹👑🔥 MY KINGS PLS CONTINUE TO SLAY MINE AND ALL OF THE EXO-L LIFE 🖤🌹👑🔥
That empty spot..
Rapmon is Jins sugar daddy i think you mean three of them 😔
😭😭😭 yixing really loved krislutao... ot12 was beautiful. I'm waiting for the reunion
okay why is no one talking about minseok’s vocal here??? he slayed his parts!
minseok singing in mandarin is my kink
这首歌真的超级好听，百听不厌。无论看歌词或不看歌词都能打动人心。词、曲及编曲都很喜欢。听了很多遍都还是会让人泪目的一首歌，看着词再想着EXO一路走来的不易，真的很催泪。
永远忘不了钟熊哭的那一个画面，我多想抱抱他呀！EXO-L永远在呀！加油，我的骄傲！
It's already 2018 and I'm still crying while listening and reading those lyrics. I've heard this song a lot, listened to it a lot of times, but still can make me cry af😭
Today is EXO's 8th anniversary and the journey was not easy but we came this far, this song brings back so many memories which I will cherished forever, EXO LETS LOVE ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
i can't believe that yixing do the rap with chanyeol. argghhh i cry like an idiot T_T that's right, we even can't return to past
How did I just find this? THIS IS GOLD
I'm not an EXO-L but I really like EXO, and even though I'm not a declared fan, I really suffered from the departure of the members so I couldn't hold my tears here. I don't understand how there are 23 people disliking this song. It's absurd. Plus, this is even sadder than the korean version.
It's 2020 and I'm sitting here crying like a river. I miss OT12 so much that it hurts.
Bridge part really is for Su Lay... Suho the leader... and his and Lay's voice are soft... gahd... i'm being emotional again 😭😭😭😭❤
I want kris luhan & tao listen to this.
Same.
they probably did. i kind of want to see how they reacted to it to be honest.
Tao performed it with the rest for his last stage
Ke Xin Li I want after all this time, that he listen to this
My first time listening to this had my eyes crying a river non-stop. Now it's my I don't even know but it still gets me. EXO fighting💋❤️
藝興：黑暗裡我關上門安靜略帶無助
物是人非的舞台卻是遺憾倒影
CHEN:你默默為我付出一切卻從來不提起
我鼓起勇氣再次睜開我的眼睛
DO:時間在一點一點慢慢地流走
我為你做的一切可能還不夠
伯賢：我依然掙扎要抱緊你
不可能有人可以去代替
就像我們的約定oh~
合唱：在流走的時間我用淚水祭奠懷念那過往的一切
（懷念那過往一切）
想說聲對不起可是我好愛你
請你再次給予我相信
SUHO：抱在我懷裡雙手抓緊你
只要你開心幸福我願意
秀敏：把所有的全給你
KAI:yeah想不顧一切守護你微笑的眼睛
世勳：（你微笑的眼睛）
伯賢：只為你
藝興：不知什麼時候起
微笑著你的樣子不是你
若你的心不能再給我那樣的愛
我還是會想起那些記憶
模糊的讓我覺得可惜
一切會好的都會過去的
安慰已經不能夠安慰我的心
因為我知道你有天會要離開
請不要離開我想握你的手
燦烈：正已經逃避誓言裡的畫面
沒有你知道那能不能讓我永遠停留在你的左右圍繞
呼吸一樣我們再次回憶
謝謝你對不起我愛你
這些都已經不足表達我的一切
我的愛就讓我守護你
yeah還有那破裂的誓言
秀敏：時間在一點一點慢慢地流走
我為你做的一切可能還不夠
CHEN :我依然掙扎要抱緊你
不可能有人可以去代替
就像我們的約定
合唱：回頭看著一路眼淚卻止不住
我把一切藏在心中
帶著我的夢和你給予的愛
所有汗水揮灑在舞台
KAI：抱在我懷裡雙手抓緊你
秀敏：只要你開心幸福我願意
DO：把所有的全給你~~
SUHO：那些美好時光裡
我和你在一起一點一滴的記憶
DO:你用肯定話語說我們來創造奇蹟
伯賢：用心感覺知道你會在我身邊
向你約定我要我們永遠
CHEN：我不會讓任何人傷你的心
這是我唯一的堅定
合唱：在流走的時間我用淚水祭奠懷念那過往的一切
想說聲對不起可是我好愛你
就讓時間來為我證明
藝興：抱在我懷裡雙手抓緊你
只要你開心幸福我願意
DO:我會兌現這一切
CHEN :oh~y eah
世勳：I promise you
This song is soo beautiful :') Those lyrics like really touch me... This song always makes me cry
i never heard EXO's songs again after hear BTS's songs, but this song always makes me goosebumps, a song which sung with all their heart, i can feel their honesty and feeling
Promise 約定
RAP：찬열(CHANYEOL) 韓文
作詞：첸(CHEN)
作詞：레이(LAY) 中文
作曲：레이(LAY)/디즈(Deez)
編曲：레이(LAY)/디즈(Deez)
黑暗裡我關上門 安靜略帶無助
物是人非的舞台 卻是遺憾倒影
你默默為我付出一切 卻從來不提起
我鼓起勇氣再次睜開我的眼睛
時間在一點一點 慢慢地流走
我為你做的一切可能還不夠
我依然掙扎要抱緊你
不可能有人可以去代替
就像我們的約定
在流走的時間 我用淚水祭奠
懷念那過往的一切(懷念那過往的一切)
想說聲對不起 可是我好愛你
請你再次給予我相信
抱在我懷裡 雙手抓緊你
只要你開心幸福 我願意
把所有的全給你
想不顧一切守護
你微笑的眼睛 (你微笑的眼睛)
只為你
不知什麼時候起 微笑著你的樣子不是你
若你的心 不能再給我那樣的愛
我還是會想起那些記憶
模糊得讓我覺得可惜
一切會好的都會過去的 安慰已經不能夠
安慰我的心 因為我知道你有天會要離開
請不要離開 我想握你的手
反正已經逃避誓言裡的畫面
沒有你知道 那能不能讓
我永遠停留在你的 左右圍繞
呼吸一樣 我們再次回憶
謝謝你 對不起 我愛你
這些都已經不足 表達我的一切
我的愛就讓我守護你
還有那破裂的誓言
更多更詳盡歌詞 在 ※ Mojim.com 魔鏡歌詞網
時間在一點一點 慢慢地流走
我為你做的一切可能還不夠
我依然掙扎要抱緊你
不可能有人可以去代替
就像我們的約定
回頭看這一路 眼淚卻止不住
我把一切藏在心中 (把一切藏在心中)
帶著我的夢 和你給予的愛
所有汗水揮灑在舞台
抱在我懷裡 雙手抓緊你
只要你開心幸福 我願意
把所有的全給你
那些美好時光裡
我和你在一起 一點一滴的記憶
你用肯定話語說 我們來創造奇跡
I know
用心感覺 知道你會在身邊
(深呼吸 用心感覺 知道你會在身邊)
向你約定 我要我們永遠
(別嘆息 向你約定 我要我們永遠)
我不會讓任何人傷你的心
這是我唯一的堅定
在流走的時間 我用淚水祭奠
懷念那過往的一切(懷念那過往的一切)
想說聲對不起 可是我好愛你
就讓時間來為我證明
抱在我懷裡 雙手抓緊你
只要你 開心幸福 我願意
我會兌現這一切
Oh- Yeah
god this is very sad... lay and chanyeol's rap...and the lyrics im crying
The Korean version definitely makes me cry, but the Mandarin version tears my heart into a million tiny pieces.
1:45 - 2:02 my bae unicorn is rapping.. huhu nice song!
And he also wrote the lyrics, and maybe compose the music too?
+NCT Forever He wrote the Chinese lyrics and composed both versions
johnea michrace you know this owner forget mention Lay and Suho Name at description. make me feel sad.. This is song made by lay and She forget his name..
Vvv kfccneveviebeysbdoyensoy. Jhwbijwgwkwgevwu. Wkhwb
Rruehuldnudhyrnroyebyuebudhtendk
Lay's rap! still fucking me up!
艺兴哥哥真棒,哥哥exo-l 和兴迷知道你想他们了
I feel the chinese version more. Maybe because I understand it and it's expressed well in both lyrics and vocals and also mu bae Channie. Credits to Lay who wrote the Chinese version and the tune all by himself.
聽了想哭想念他們12個miss them 12 together lot of memory 😢😢😢
my all time favorite songs from exo. nothing can beat this song. the lyrics are written so well as well. 😊😊😊
LAY IS AMAZING ♥️
Lol it took me forever to realise this was Exo 2014 on iTunes and Spotify
世勳 鹿晗 伯賢 我♥你們
😍😍😍😍😍😍
😍😍😍😍😍😍
This breaks my heart😭😭😭💔💔💔 I love them so much!! There is no words to describe this😍😍😭
EXO為EXO寫的歌😿🤧😭😫
In my opinion I think the Chinese ver is mostly about the members that left, and the Korean ver is mostly about they apologizing to us Ls
It's so hurtful 😢😢😢😢 it's so meaning full.... It's much sadder than the Korean one since Lay wrote all the lyrics ❤️ I will never forget this song ❤️❤️ we are one EXO....... ❤️❤️❤️
That moment when you tried hard not to cry, but in the end a tear went out to burst.
真的真的超好聽der(感動
我愛EXO
As someone whose second language is chinese, I feel so ashamed that EXO (excluding yixing) can sing so well in chinese. I cant even speak it properly >
I can totally relate, my family speaks Chinese at home but I can't read (more words, anyways) or write much xD I can understand and speak it alright, I guess aha
+Rayz I meant most* not more lol
Don't feel too bad...they're not THAT good XD
This is one of the only Chinese versions where I can just barely understand everything the Korean members are saying
Most of the other songs are just...muddled
My mom's mother tongue is Chinese and she was SURPRISED when I told her they were singing in her first language lmao
Excluding yixing of course
every time i listen to this the tears just start flowing.
The chinese version has more views. Finally, they noticed it.
I feel like crying but there's no tears coming out
This Is My Most Favorite Song and the Saddest too I cry everytime this song plays with a matching flashback video damn it
when you miss XIUHAN AND TAOHUN SO MUCH. I CAN'T.😭😭😭😭
This song always make me cry no matter when and where