확실히 사람마다 보는게 다르군요. 전 개인적으로 '나 우는거 안보여? 울어!울어!'하는 오바스러운 감정보다 뭔가 참는데 참는거 같지않는 그런 감정이 더 세련되고 와닿더라구요. 그리고 가창액션도 3:13 이걸보면 아래서 위로 갑자기 확 치고 올라오는 저런 절제된 듯하면서도 절제되지않은 저런 손 동작이 더 매력적이라고 생각 합니다. 마틸다 분도 노래 무지 잘하시는 분인건 확실한데 보여지는 기교에서의 세련된 디테일이 다소 아쉬웠습니다. 그거만 아녔어도 진짜 어마무시한 루키인데 감정선이 너무 오바스러워서 보기 좀 불편하더군요. 마치 한국식 심파를 보는 느낌이었어요.
It's such a difficult register to keep up with and then add distortion to it? Get the fuck otta there. Lil girl my ass, striped girl has a special tone that is either there or it isn't. A smokey voice in a fully eastern Asian person is very very rare and they really fucked up because the other person was a young girl.
I am used to koreans sing hight notes like that 14 yrs old girl.. but then the striped shirt girl has that emotion.. make her became my personal choice 2:12-2:16 3:51-3:53
이노래를 들으니.작년에 오랜.투병끝에 돌아가신 엄마가 왜 자뀨 생각나는지...지금 율고 있네요. 그저 엄마가 보고 싶어집니다. 연인의 노래지만 이 애절함... 돌아와주길...다시ㅜ보고픈 그 맘이 저는 엄마가 생각나....마음을 부여 잡고 웁니다. ㅠㅠ 고맙습니다. 울수있게 도와주셔서....늘 참고 있었는데....이 노래 들으며 엄마를 부르며 솔직하게 윱니다.
The girl on the left has the emotion/stage presence, the girl in the middle has a lot of control over her voice, and the girl on the right has a lot of range. All great singers and unable to compare and say who’s better. One of the hardest decisions on this show in my opinion
@@Xxmohammed150xX well that is not the industry's fault. People in general are attracted by the visuals and industry just knows people's preference very well. It is actually the audience who shapes the industries like that.
this is my 15th time watching this video, (not including listening it on my music app) each and everytime it got me on the edge of my seat not to mention the intense emotion, tears on my tear duct and a lump on my throat :')
I hated Ailee's trio, the girl that won got way more parts, the other's were so much better too. This one is absolutely amazing, they couldn't have gone wrong with their decision
K-pop requires for the idols to sing,dance,entertain and look good.These girls are phenomenal singers yes,but to be a Kpop idol they would have to be able to dance well,be good entertainers and look beyond beautiful.In Korea,being a Kpop idol and a singer is different and separate.There are the singers and then there are the idols.It's not the same profession.
Idols and singers are different in Korea. There are many artists and singers but “you” only know the idol industry. Normal Koreans listen to singers and only teen girls follow their idols like most of you guys
the 14-year-old girl win 'cause strong voice and technique at this age. but i really love the perform of the mathilda girl, especially 3:50 !!!!! cried when watching this :ooooo after that they have individual solo also, i wanna find youtube clip of mathilda solo one but can't find... :(
she won because she had a really really clear voice, which is what vibe was looking for to balance their husky voices. otherwise, the matilda girl would've probably won!!
lpdwon4 yea if I was vibe I would also choose the little girl. Her style is much more match with Vibe voice. I just feel pity for the mathilda girl... She should join other competitions XD
Back in 2024..that little girl still makes me have goosebumps..her vlice has anatural echo..and she sang like that without knowing that kind of love..imagine the power of the feelings once she falls in love.❤
Is so sad to know that the world is filled with people with this kind of talend and most of the "artist" we have today selling CD's can't even sing ㅠㅠTo me these girls are true artist even though they are not famous😣
If you watched the whole segment and the whole episode you would see how amazing these three girls are, you truly get a good feel of how well all three girls expressed their emotions. They all did really well.
Words can't describe how much I loved this performance. All three ladies were great, the fact a 14-year-old can sing like this (ad-lib and high note) truly blows my mind! On top of all, Lee Hi's expressions (love her!)......
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2024 MBC 방송연예대상] 박정현의 축하공연! ＜꿈에＞♬, MBC 250128 방송](/img/1.gif)
2025년에두듣는분.
다들 미쳤나봐 진짜
와 나 똑같이 이 말 하면서 봤는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ소름
이병훈 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
하여튼 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
14살이 저런 감정 감성을 제대로 표현해내는게 소름포인트
한글이 반갑네요 ㅋㅋㅋ
엌ㅋㅋㅆㅇㅈ
@@KimSO1977 9⁰0999⁹9⁹9⁰⁹9⁹⁹⁹999⁹99⁹⁹⁹9⁹99⁹999999⁹999⁹9⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹990999⁹99⁹9⁹9⁹99⁹⁰9⁹999⁰⁹909909990999999999999⁰9990⁹9⁹999⁹9⁹9⁹⁹999⁹9999ⁿ⁹⁹⁹9⁹9⁹0⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹990⁹99⁹9⁹⁰99⁹9⁹9⁹⁹⁹0⁹9999⁹999⁹999999099⁹9⁹⁹9⁹⁹99⁹9999999999⁹⁹⁹99⁹9999990ⁿ9⁹⁹⁹9⁹9⁹09⁹⁹9⁹⁹9⁹⁹999⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹999⁹⁹9⁹9⁹99⁹⁹⁹99 ⁹99vv9⁹999990
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
ㅂ
3:23
마틸다도 아쉬웠는데 저 14살짜리 소녀가 너무 잘했다 어린나이라고 믿을수 없을 만큼 감정 감성이 너무 좋았어
제 개인 등수를 매겨본다면
1. 고음대장
2. 도넛
3. 마틸다
@@Miles_Link 도넛?ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
1.도넛 2.마틸다 3. 고음대장
누가 뽑히느냐보다..
이 무대 자체가 레전드
誰も傷つけないこのコメントが好きです👍
진짜 가끔씩 보러옴 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
셋 조합이 최고임 ㅋㅋㅋ
감정 마틸다, 밸런스 도넛, 스킬/나이 고음대장
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 도랐음 ㄹㅇ
근황이 궁금하네여...
마틸다가 더 나아보이는데
저두 가끔 보러와요ㅋㅋㅋ
와 내 기준 이 편 레전드...
저두요.생각날때마다 들으러 와요ㅎㅎ
개인적으로 14살 애가 제일 지렸다...
마틸다님은 감정이 레전드고 도넛님은 진짜 너무 깔끔하심 고음대장님은 ㄹㅇ 탈 14살 아님? 진짜 세명다 좋음;
확실히 사람마다 보는게 다르군요. 전 개인적으로 '나 우는거 안보여? 울어!울어!'하는 오바스러운 감정보다 뭔가 참는데 참는거 같지않는 그런 감정이 더 세련되고 와닿더라구요.
그리고 가창액션도 3:13 이걸보면 아래서 위로 갑자기 확 치고 올라오는 저런 절제된 듯하면서도 절제되지않은 저런 손 동작이 더 매력적이라고 생각 합니다. 마틸다 분도 노래 무지 잘하시는 분인건 확실한데 보여지는 기교에서의 세련된 디테일이 다소 아쉬웠습니다. 그거만 아녔어도 진짜 어마무시한 루키인데 감정선이 너무 오바스러워서 보기 좀 불편하더군요. 마치 한국식 심파를 보는 느낌이었어요.
진심 세분 다 훌륭하시다. 존대가 절로 나온다는
그렇냐능?ㅋㅋ
이 무대가 미친 거 아님?... 듣고 들어도 질리지가 않내...
What’s the song called
@@kaylajones2546 vibe-미친거니(crazy)
3:22 진짜 미쳣
오홍 잘하네 하다가 쭉 올리는거 보고 지림..
호흡이 아주
저 14살 친구는 진짜 미쳤나봐 소름 쫙쫙돋게만드네...3:30 애드립에서 애기같은 얼굴로 저렇게부르니까 진짜 너무소름끼침 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
3:23 와 14살 고음대장.. 진짜 봐도봐도 또봐도 소름 너무잘해
3:50
마틸다님 진짜 미쳤나봐.. 헣허헣ㅎㅎ진짜 완전 취향저격 당함..
와.... 경쟁을 떠나서 미친무대. 세사람 모두를 사랑하게 되었음. 쩐다.
Can we just have all three!?!!
right !!
또 들으러 온사람?
04:11 도넛 가성애드립 너무 좋다...
맞아요. 도넛 이분도 매력적 입니다. 창법이나 여러 기교들이 참하다고 해야하나? 암튼 뭔가 참한 느낌.
역대 다시 보고 싶은 당시 일반인 무대.
세 명이 다시 모인 무대도 보고 싶네요.
I think this was probably the hardest performance to choose only one
2020년에도 보는사람? 전 맨날 듣고 있..
어제캡틴보는데 윤민서양이 나오네요😃😃
2021년에도 보고있어여 ㅋㅋ 봐도봐도 소오름~~~
The girl on the left with the striped shirt has so much emotion in her voice it tears you up
Ikr
Sooo trueeeeeeee 😭
she looks like Go Ara
It's such a difficult register to keep up with and then add distortion to it? Get the fuck otta there. Lil girl my ass, striped girl has a special tone that is either there or it isn't. A smokey voice in a fully eastern Asian person is very very rare and they really fucked up because the other person was a young girl.
I am used to koreans sing hight notes like that 14 yrs old girl.. but then the striped shirt girl has that emotion.. make her became my personal choice 2:12-2:16 3:51-3:53
난 이걸 아직까지 보는데 끊을수가 없음.ㅠ❤
어머 저 꼬맹이땜에 잠다깻네 ㅠㅠㅠ오모모모모 너무잘해 오모모머머
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ오모모머머ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
2024년에서도 또 들으러 왔다 갑니다.
1:34 when she sang " Wae ..." I felt like my heart broke a little ...😢😢
Thu Koyo me too.
진짜 판듀 최고 무대임… 언제봐도 소름돋음ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 다 너무 잘함…
미친정도가 아니라...이건 돌았다!! 14살 고음대장 지금은 뭐할까??
와드박아요
서공예가셨어요
엠넷 캡틴 오디션 나왔어요
현재 캡틴 오디션 경연중이십니다. 윤민서님.
이노래를 들으니.작년에 오랜.투병끝에 돌아가신 엄마가 왜 자뀨 생각나는지...지금 율고 있네요. 그저 엄마가 보고 싶어집니다. 연인의 노래지만 이 애절함...
돌아와주길...다시ㅜ보고픈 그 맘이 저는 엄마가 생각나....마음을 부여 잡고 웁니다. ㅠㅠ
고맙습니다. 울수있게 도와주셔서....늘 참고 있었는데....이 노래 들으며 엄마를 부르며 솔직하게 윱니다.
2024년에도 듣는분!
Are you crazy!? Ofcoursee
매년 몇번씩 듣는곡~~~~~
3:23 진짜 레전드다
3명 전부 다 진짜 잘 부른다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
한국인 특징: 다른나라말이 많으면 댓을 안담
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아
ㅇㅈㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아씨 혼자 조낸 웃었어
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅇㅈ
인즈엉ㅋㅋ
솔직히 셋이 한팀으로 음반내도 대박날듯 목소리들이 너무잘맞음
韓国語わかんないから何言ってるかはわかんないんだけどすごく感動した
にー にー それね
Someone sign them up quick as a trio idol group. They will slay all on singing ability alone.
I became their fan 😍
イヤホンで聞いてこんなに鳥肌立つのはすごい、、。
リアルで聞いたら鳥になってまうやろこれ…。
번역
이어폰으로 듣고 이렇게 소름 돋는건 대단해.. 실재로 들으면 새가 되어버릴거야.. 이거..
(아마도 닭살돋아서 새가 되는거 같음)
외국인놈들아 댓글좀 달자!
개쩜!!!ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 다 미쳤나봐 ㄷㄷㄷ
마틸다님 귀염상에 매력적이시네!!
가운데분도 못하는건 아닌데 옆에서 너무
잘해버리니까 묻히시네
10번 이상 들으신분?
The girl on the left has the emotion/stage presence, the girl in the middle has a lot of control over her voice, and the girl on the right has a lot of range. All great singers and unable to compare and say who’s better. One of the hardest decisions on this show in my opinion
진짜 니네가 미친거니 ......
No wonder music industries in Korea is really competitive... They are abundant with talents...
but unfortunately they debut basic on visual
@@Xxmohammed150xXyesss so sad
It's Korean soul : )
@@Xxmohammed150xX well that is not the industry's fault. People in general are attracted by the visuals and industry just knows people's preference very well. It is actually the audience who shapes the industries like that.
실제론..저렇게 실력있는사람들이 설무대는 없음..
아이돌은 가창력보단 비주얼을 중시하고
소속사에선 솔로가수는 안키우고..
자기파트도 못하는 아이돌세상..
미친거니 계속 듣다가 내가 미친줄..
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
3:29 that ad-lib of the 14-year-old singer is truly crazy omg >"
아직 보고있는분….?
dude..that is a child....14 years old and she can sing like that?????
Somebody needs to recruit her..she can sing .
alice givens i feel you
that's 13 in korea....so she's still in middle school...
+seoulstice85 No.... She's 14 in Korea, 13 in the U.S.
see LeeHi's reaction LOL
やっぱり韓国の歌は
いい曲が多い。
好きすぎて曲ダウンロードして
しまった。
The girl with the short hair have a beautiful voice woaaaw
와...개인적으로 판듀에서 제일 최강이다...
I love the lefr girl's voice. She sings with real emotion. It makes me move to tears ㅠ.ㅠ
bạn ơi, bài hát tên gì của ca sĩ gốc nào vậy??
+Trang Huyền 미친거니 are you crazy nhóm Vibe. bạn có thể tìm bằng tiếng Hàn trong zing mp3
+Nguyen Duc Toan cám ơn bạn :3
this is my 15th time watching this video, (not including listening it on my music app) each and everytime it got me on the edge of my seat not
to mention the intense emotion, tears on my tear duct and a lump on my throat :')
i agree, i loved her emotional style
난 도넛이 가장 잘하는듯 톤이 안정감있고 모든노래 다 잘어울리는 목소리인듯
that was goosebump inducing...soo beautiful. I dont understand anything but I felt something. The 14yrs old girl...holy!!!!!! her voice is wow!!!
the heck one of them's 14??? what am i doing with my life...
it's the girl at the far right
13, 14 is their korean age.
omg she´s 14???? 😨 that info just blew me away
@@bisporoxannekylad.6614 lol...
They need to bring this show back
진짜미쳤다 미친 재능이다...
이 노래 가사, 감성을 저 나이에 저만큼 표현한거면
나이먹고서, 겪어보고서, 우러나와서 노래할 땐
듣는사람들 눈물콧물 다 빼겠다ㅠㅠ
3:28 Best High Note
Fun fact: There was only a Piano in the background and you didn't realized it
I can't stop watching this daily. They're all so good. I even prefer this over Ailee's trio.
same! this gives me so many chills and doesn't get old
I hated Ailee's trio, the girl that won got way more parts, the other's were so much better too. This one is absolutely amazing, they couldn't have gone wrong with their decision
Me too. This version did make me cry..
What the title song??
마틸다 진짜 듣기 좋다
The vibrato on all three on them, jeeeeeeez
백반집 마틸다 소녀 너무 좋다 진짜
3:50 omg I replied this like thousand times !
1감성적 표현력 2기본기탄탄함3기교 가창력 바이브레이션 짱 결론 셋다 대단함
i mean if korea have these amazing singers, where the hell did all these monotones kpop singers came from?!!! thumbs up for these girls
K-pop requires for the idols to sing,dance,entertain and look good.These girls are phenomenal singers yes,but to be a Kpop idol they would have to be able to dance well,be good entertainers and look beyond beautiful.In Korea,being a Kpop idol and a singer is different and separate.There are the singers and then there are the idols.It's not the same profession.
they can sing great. but do you think all of these non-professional singers can perform like idols? no.
Idols and singers are different in Korea. There are many artists and singers but “you” only know the idol industry. Normal Koreans listen to singers and only teen girls follow their idols like most of you guys
@@tannedpotato5375 This is very true. Most adult koreans dont follow the idol industry as much as the singers.
@@tannedpotato5375 wow I learn a lot from your statement. It's a relieve because I thought Korean always listened to idol. It make sense now.. Thanks
아니 진짜 미쳤나봐 4년전영상인데 추천영상에 떠서 봤어... 유튜브 알고리즘 ㅋㅋㅋ 근데 진짜.... 나 14살 때는 놀기 바빴는데.ㅋㅋㅋㅋ다들 너무 잘한다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
the 14-year-old girl win 'cause strong voice and technique at this age. but i really love the perform of the mathilda girl, especially 3:50 !!!!! cried when watching this :ooooo after that they have individual solo also, i wanna find youtube clip of mathilda solo one but can't find... :(
You can find her audition video on the app itself.
not audition video. Vibe asked them to sing individually after this song.
she won because she had a really really clear voice, which is what vibe was looking for to balance their husky voices. otherwise, the matilda girl would've probably won!!
lpdwon4 yea if I was vibe I would also choose the little girl. Her style is much more match with Vibe voice. I just feel pity for the mathilda girl... She should join other competitions XD
I found some videos with the entire episodes and English subs, maybe they have this
すごい！
聴いてて鳥肌がたつ！
こんなに若くて可愛くて歌上手いのは本当に尊敬する！
これは、何ていう歌ですか？
윤민서님 노래 듣고 진짜 레알 소름 쫙 돋았다.. 하..너무 멋있어요
도넛누님 노래 부르시는 거 제 취향이십니다 듣기 너무 좋아요
세 소녀들 다 미쳤어요.
와. 이 영상을 이제 처음 봤는데
보면서 나도 모르게 눈물이 나는데
입에선 욕이 나오네요.
다들 미쳤나봐요.
14살 저분은 정말 미친분이네요
14살에 저정도면 진짜 대단하다 ㅋㅋ
Back in 2024..that little girl still makes me have goosebumps..her vlice has anatural echo..and she sang like that without knowing that kind of love..imagine the power of the feelings once she falls in love.❤
고음대장 진짜 멋있어요
목소리도 감정도 고음도
판타에서 가장 최고였어요 ~^^
歌詞が解らないのに、すごく泣ける歌だ
Is so sad to know that the world is filled with people with this kind of talend and most of the "artist" we have today selling CD's can't even sing ㅠㅠTo me these girls are true artist even though they are not famous😣
+Jackson c so true 😔
True!! 💔😭
lol you are so stupid
why the insult?
Edmon Lacsa wow your insecurity over 9000
미친거니 진짜좋네 맘이 미쳐버리겠다
3:51-3:54 IS WHAT REALLY MAKING ME CRAZY... DAMN MATILDA YOU'RE MAKING ME SCREAM hahahahaha
i would have picked her on those 3 seconds alone...
@@guitarislife983 Same, she is the best one
MATILDA 😂😂😂
MORE LIKE DORE THE EXPLORER
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
걍 이세분이 미친것같은데.,.,.
If you watched the whole segment and the whole episode you would see how amazing these three girls are, you truly get a good feel of how well all three girls expressed their emotions. They all did really well.
the 14 years old girl give me goosebumps
and makes me cry
your voice is amazing!
3:50 IM DONEEEE
1:30
14살한테 나오는 감정임 이게?
들을때마다 울면서말하는거같아서 울컥함
이조합이 미친거니다 넘잘함
저런 감성은 20년 6월에도 봐야지 ㅋㅋㅋ
なぜか涙出る
진짜 대한민국의 가요계는 점점 겁나 밝다
3:36 진짜 도넛고음깔끔한거너무좋음..
주기적으로 봐줘야되는 힐링영상
와.....14살짜리 호흡쓰는거봐 대박이네.
또 보고, 또보고 여러번을 봤는 데 할 말을 잃었다~~ 특히 14세 학생, 지금은 대학생 1~2학년이 됬을거고.... 하늘에서 내려온......
고딩이예요 아직
3:51 min 😵😵😵😵💎
全員すごいけど特に14歳の子すごすぎる
번역
모두 대단하지만 특히 14살 짜리 애는 너무 좋아
still crazy for this version in 2024
きれいなハーモニー、心地よいな～
윤민수 끝에 화음넣을때 죽인당~♡
수년이 지났는데도, 저런 가녀린 몸으로 저런 파워풀한 목소리를 내는 3명이 여전히 대단함
Words can't describe how much I loved this performance. All three ladies were great, the fact a 14-year-old can sing like this (ad-lib and high note) truly blows my mind! On top of all, Lee Hi's expressions (love her!)......
이 때도 너무 잘했는데 이 친구가 캡틴에 나와서 더 잘할지 누가 알았겠어 .. 민서 최고 ㅜㅜ 어디서 많이 봤다했다
Understand nothing but can't stop crying . Especially the girl in left side touches me the most .