I just realized something about the ending of the sung version and the vocaloid version: They both play a piece of the song in the opposing songs key at the end. The two versions are a half-step apart. If put together, they sound dissonant, making a minor 2nd, the musical term for a really clashing pair of notes. What this means is while the songs lead to one another, they can never be heard together, or be together for that matter, like some of the meaning found in the music video. This is some simple yet amazing detail and storytelling to add onto the already beautiful song. This song is so wonderfully haunting and spine-tingling to listen to, and I really cannot express how much I appreciate this music. Here's some love from a sleepless English user
@@taringtajam Heya! I made a video where the two are in tune with each other. Their voices actually work really well together. Check it out if you want to!
this theory's supported by the fact that: - RUclips ver. has the coloured key on "G" - NND ver. has the coloured key on "F#" edit: timestamp for reference (around 3:11 or 3:12)
@@alka_llyod It's really awesome what you did there. When the two versions follow the same tune, it creates a good harmony between the voices. In the other hand, you just reunite the two girls and now the song sounds more complete than before. Good job!
Can we talk about how insane it is that he produces, composes, illustrates and animates all of his own videos? There are only two people in the world I know of that do that
not to mention also has the ability to sing them himself, something I wouldn't have guessed from a vocaloid producer. this guy is just...really multi-faceted apparently.
Harumaki Gohan is simply so talented. From the production of the song to the music video he does it all. What a legend. Definitely a new legend in the Vocaloid and J-Pop scene in general. Also, he has such a nice singing voice it honestly makes me jealous.
YT ver and NNd ver had different point of view(?) Yt from this pink girl And NND is from that yellow girl And BOTH ARE LOVABLE Miss each other And can't meet again orz thats depressing.. I love this concept..
if you play both versions at the same time, there is an obvious dissonance in the melody, further emphasizing the story behind the song, absolutely genius
holy crap, you guys should check the version where miku sings (if you haven't already). the MV is different, we see the other girl with yellow hair instead and it's really sad because even though the title is reunion, it's a reunion that'll never happen :(( I hope the two meet again though, somewhere, someday...
I find it super incredible that Harumaki Gohan self-produces his songs (though he did have help with the animation for this one). The music is a BOP and the animation is super detailed and smooth- Thanks for your hard work 🙏🙏
This was the very first Harumaki Gohan song I heard, almost a year ago, and I remember how it brought me to tears and sobbing. Now I listen to Harumaki Gohan almost every day--the music has become a part of my life in an unexpected way. I'm grateful I found this when I did.
Harumaki Gohan's music videos always evoke these emotions and have beautiful lyrics! It really makes me fall in in love his songs so easily. Also, I'm very greatfull for the English translations!
Super long theory: I think the meaning of this song might be quite straight forward. At least from my understanding this song is about not wanting to grow up. I think the protagonist and her friend (I'll call her Blue for now and her friend Yellow) made a promise about never growing up and staying children forever (0:48), but somehow Blue was left behind. When young, they decided that growing up wasn't the right way of living and that Grownups were just humans that forgot how to actually live and not just exist, unlike them ("So this is how to live a life right? Living is not just breathing, right?"). A representation of those Grownups that forgot how to live are the robots in this video. This is suggested by them holding onto train handles and them wearing suits at 0:40. In Japan most people use trains to get to/to leave work, so I think the robots are representing aldults going to/leaving work. The color Pink in this MV might represent "childishness", or the will to not "just exist", maybe even individuality. You can see one of the Robots looking to the side with pink eyes, while everyone else just looks straight ahead. In the end the robots gets forced to look straight ahead just like everyone else (2:04) which could represent him being pressured into acting and thinking like everyone else, again leading to just existing and not actually living. (This robot might be a child being pressured by their parents into acting the way society expects them to and being forced to "grow up", forgetting their "childishness" ("Eventually, we will forget we once were kids")). I think the airship in this MV is a representation of the act of "growing up", entering this ship officialy makes you an adult, maybe just like using the train to get to your first job for the first time. "The final Bell rings, the two will be left behind, the grownups are worried that they're not sane" probably means that the adults that knew Blue and Yellow were worried that something was wrong with them because they weren't acting like everyone else and didn't "grow up", like they were supposed to. The "final bell" probably represent the last bell/announcement before the airship to aduldthood leaves the station. I think Yellow took her own life a long time before this video took place (maybe because she noticed that there wasn't a chance of them winning this fight, at 2:17 you can see the airship of adulthood looming over them, maybe Yellow noticed that there wasnt a chance of running away from this) and that Blue is on her way to "join" Yellow by killing herself as well (hence the title "Reunion", they'll finally meet again after death, this is also suggested by Blue thinking this at the beginning of the video: "I wonder if you remember my voice, I wonder how we talked to each other, we've both grown", suggesting that she hasn't seen Yellow in a while and that she wonders if they'll even recognize each other when they finally meet again). You can see Blue looking at her watch multiple times, this might represents her thinking that her time has finally come to join Yellow. After falling from the cliff at 3:20 we can see her into a pink stream of color. Before this there was a yellow stream of color (2:43) which probably represents Yellow killing herself just like Blue at some point before this. Finally, at the end of the video you can see the two streams flying in the sky while the airship to adulthood leaves without Blue and Yellow. Well this is how I understood this MV at least, sorry for any grammar or spelling mistakes, english is not my first language :) Ah, can I also say, Harumaki Gohans voice is so pretty and soothing!
I think that's an excellent theory. I was thinking something along similar lines, but not quite the same - I kind of think the song is about a suicide pact between the two of them. My theory is the two girls grew up together and, like you said, agreed that adulthood wasn't for them if it meant losing themselves, and so they decided to both kill themselves at the moment they reached it (I think you're spot-on with the airship as a metaphor for adulthood). This is also because of lines around 3:04 where it's implied that the two girls have gone off to do something and the adults are worried about them but don't take them seriously enough to stop them. I think that they were separated a while ago, when their paths of growing up diverged, thus why they're on different towers going to different airships, if we're sticking with the airships-taking-off-is-adulthood-metaphor, but they both stuck to the decision they made back when they were together in the hopes that it would bring them together again. That's why their paths mirror one another; they're going through the same actions, but just mimicking each other can never truly bring them together again. Like, there's this poem by Andrew Marvell called The Definition of Love, and there's a bit in it where he writes 'as lines, so loves oblique may well / themselves in every angle greet; / but ours, so truly parallel, / though infinite, can never meet.' and this song strikes me as the absolute embodiment of that.
@@beiyuimpact4636 yeah, I can see that; apparently in Japan romantic relationships between girls is societally seen as “something you do when you’re younger as practice for a ‘real relationship’, something you grow out of” So I can see the “not wanting to grow up if it means losing ourselves” thing as something like that, where it’s like “if growing up means that we can’t love each other anymore, we don’t ever want to grow up”
the fact that these two both look strikingly similar to pink and blue from melty land nightmare makes me feel that these two ARE them and this takes place before that song edit: i still stand by my theory that this is melty land nightmare 2.0 or at least takes time somewhere between that song. these two (im gonna call reunion pink and yellow) look extremely similar, which im starting to think it was done deliberately, to melty pink and blue. the main thing i got from this song is that reunion pink and yellow are awaiting a reunion which will never come. in melty land nightmare, blue visits melty pink in her dreams because her real life isnt going well for her so pink comforts blue out of her sadness. eventually, however, blue leaves pink and she's eventually forgotten. my main theory here is that reunion pink and yellow were best friends growing up and started seeing less of other as time went past. They both felt the pressures of becoming an adult and leaving your childhood behind which leads to one of them committing suicide (which im going to say is reunion pink) we enter MLN territory as yellow starts to struggle more with her life and can only escape in her sleep and dreams where she (dressed as blue) meets melty pink. if reunion pink is the one that committed suicide, then its most likely she came back as melty pink and a spirit in yellow's dreams. this could also be why reunion and melty pink are the same color. i could also say that the reason why yellow is blue in her dreams is because in reality, shes unhappy with her situation. we all know how the story ends there through: blue eventually leaves melty land and melty pink is forgotten. i could interpret that as yellow waking up from her sleep into reality (as you can forget dreams after waking up) and came back to melty land when she went back to sleep (which is why the song mentions that blue has visited her thousands of times) i find it awfully sad because no matter how you see it, both girls in MLN and this song can never truly be together. blue can't remember melty pink every time she visits and reunion pink and yellow can't be together as they are, quite literally as yellow's POV is on niconico, in parallel worlds. it the end, ill probably say that its likely that yellow did end up committing suicide in the hopes that she would join reunion pink in death as well as pressure. i do know that there are some theories that yellow may of been the first to go or that she's the representation of a imaginary friend/childhood that reunion pink eventually has to let go. the NN MV does make it hard since it's from yellow's POV but thats what I got from this one and thats why harumaki gohan is a legend
Giovanni Fuego i personally think at least for now that MLN may take place maybe during this song? or at least somewhere in between because while the title is called reunion, its a reunion that wont come to pass. at least in my interpretation
so now that the full series is out, has this theory changed? i was actually just wondering if anyone thought this was a sequel to mln when this first came out lol
ok i know i already replied but i HAVE to say this. as much as i loveloveLOVE this theory, as someone who knows a lot about the harumaki gohan lore from reading the album artbooks... this theory is literally impossible. so in the harugo canon you've got the blue planet, which is where futari no takes place. but you've ALSO got dream planets, special planets that humans can visit in their sleep, which currently includes the melty land and seventina (although there's WAY more, they're jusy undiscovered). but here's the thing - *the blue planet and dream planets are in the same universe.* not only that, but melty is impled to have existed for a REALLY long time, while nana and lili were 21 when they heckin died. so there's actually a good chance that futari no and melty land nightmare are going at the same time. it's depressing to debunk this but the harugo lore is actually REALLY cool and the official meanings for a lot of his songs are better than the fan theories a lot of the time (just my opinion though) so i highly recommend reading up on it! you won't regret it (the artbooks are in japanese though so you can either check out the harumaki gohan wiki or read tick's translations which can be found on his twitter [harugo_eng])
![[스타레일] 로빈 노래 3곡 모음 / Honkai: Star Rail Robin's full album 'Inside'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qKHGfkEsmvs/mqdefault.jpg)
ふたりのシリーズのスタンプを作りました
store.line.me/stickershop/product/26945574
They're so cute!! I really like the Himitsu-themed designs!
4年前に偶然この曲と出会って
そのまま曲名忘れちゃって
｢いい曲だったからまた聴きたいな～｣って思ってたらいきなりオススメに出てきた
ホントに｢再会｣した
スゴ
「二度と来ない再会」って歌詞、
もう二度と会えないんじゃなくて、もう離れないから再会することも無いってことなのかな。
この考察好き
エモすぎる
頭良すぎ
思った
「手を繋いだままなら二度と来ない」再会ですもんね…！
生きることってこうだろう
息を吸うことじゃないだろう
ここの歌詞好き過ぎる
椛/Acer 100にしました
最初に聞いた時鳥肌立ちすぎてやばかった(語彙力)
響く歌詞ですよね
めっちゃくちゃ分かります
もっと深い意味があるってことか？
「生きることってこうだろう
息を吸うことじゃないだろう」
ロボットになってしまった大人たちは生きていない。息をしているだけ。
それに対して、約束を守って自分たち自身の決断で身体的な命を絶ったこの二人は、息をしていなくても「生きている」んだろうな
【歌詞】再会 /はるまきごはん
どんな声が覚えてるかな
どんな風に話してたかな
すっかり背が伸びたお互い
正義とか常識とかさ
疲れちゃうよね正直ね
秘密基地の中には
そんなものはない
約束しようふたりは
ずっとこどものままで居よう
誰も傷つかないなら
思い出のままにしよう
ふたりだけ花びらの散るように
幼気な春風に舞うように
どんな少女でも終わりは美しく
ふたりだけ飛ぶ鳥の落ちるように
手を繋いで星の裏側まで
飛んで往きたい
『再会 SAIKAI』
そういえば泣き虫だよね
必死こいて隠してるよね
立派になるもんだお互い
大人って面倒くさくて
疲れちゃうよね正直ね
みんなきっと忘れてくこどもだったこと
冒険しようふたりは
大人達とお別れさ
生きることってこうだろう
息を吸うことじゃないだろう
ふたりだけ当たり前を知らないで
徒然な後悔も言わないで
どんな言葉も無いほど麗しく
ふたりなら落ちる陽の寂寞も
藍がかった星の裏側まで
覚えておける
タイムリミットの鐘が鳴る
ふたりは置いていかれる
大人達が憂いてる
あいつは正気じゃない･･･と
タイムリミットの鐘が鳴る
ふたりは確かに生きている
ふたりだけ花びらの散るように
幼気な春風に舞うように
そんな最期ならふたりに相応しい
さんざめくこの世界にさよならを
手を繋いだままなら
二度と
こない
再会
最後の景色を、思い出す。
どんな声か ですね
あざまる水産
たすかる
開始二行目で誤字からの編集済みはかっこいいがすぎる
この機械化されたみたいな世界で紙の写真持ってるの好き
はるまきごはんさんのディストピア的世界の中でどこかもの哀しいような、鮮やかで儚いような生き様を見せる主人公達が大好きです
バッドエンドやディストピアな雰囲気なのに何故かハマってしまう…。おそろしや…
子供の頃の夢や信じてたこと、純粋な気持ちとか今では「馬鹿だな」って思うのにはるまきごはんさんはそれを「あぁ、忘れたくないな」「戻りたいな」って思わせてくれる作品ばっかりでほんとに大好き
最近自曲をセルフカバーするボカロPが多いけど、みんなその曲を誰よりも理解してるような歌い方してくれるから好き。
ご本人が愛を込めて作った曲を
ご本人が愛を込めて歌うとか
耳が宝くじに当選したような気分になる
耳が当選するとかいう
パワーワード好きだぞ
あと関ヶ原の戦いで負けた時の虚しさもあるね
良い例えww
すこ
@@とあ-o4j 関ヶ原の戦い参戦してたの？！
｢そういえば泣き虫だよね｣
｢必死こいて隠してるよね｣
｢立派になるもんだお互い｣
って歌詞、自分の素直な感情でさえも押さえつけてしまう事を世の中では｢立派｣だとされているって感じで辛い(語彙力)
この後にマカロンはナナが飛び降りた理由を探しに、「彗星になれたなら」の海岸に行って彗星を見て、リリと再会するために飛び降りたってことを理解して、ふたりが生きていたことを伝えるため、アルバム一曲目の「ふたりの」で語り手になったのかな
これはナナとリリにとってはハッピーエンドだけど、マカロンにとってはただナナが飛び降りただけだから不幸で、「ふたりの」の歌詞のようなことを言ったんだとしたら、納得がいく
なにそれ素敵😭✨
ほんとうに泣く、怖いくらいにエモい、エモいのに怖い、オレンジ色じゃなくて紫色で青色の夕暮れ
はるまきごはんさんの絵って、色使いがめっちゃ綺麗だよね。
前まで大人になったらそうなんだって思ってたのに、今聞いてすごく泣いてる、もう私大人なんだ。疲れちゃうよ、めんどくさいよ、意味わかんないよもう、子供だったあの頃に戻りたい、この歌を聴いて大人になるの嫌だなって思ってた頃に戻りたい
『手を繋いだまま』ならお別れがない
だから『再会』もない
そう考えたらまだ救いがある
大人の言うことばっかり聞いてただ息をしてるだけでは死んでることと同じでせっかく生まれたなら好きなように冒険して生きようって感じ好き。
周りはロボットとめんどくさい大人に囲まれて、2人ぼっちって感じ大好き。
少女が終わる前に二人とも死を選んだのか
"ずっとこどものままで居よう"って約束を果たすために
なるへそ
そうゆう考察すき
生きることは息を吸うことではないって言ってたしね
約束...
大人(機械)になるか、人間として生きる為に、大人になる前に人生を終えるか、2つの選択肢があってほとんどの人は、機械として生きることを選んだ。それが当たり前だった。だけど2人はずっと子供(人間)のままでいることを選んだ。だから、自殺した。最後まで人間である為に…………
どんな少女でもおわりは美しく っていう歌詞にずっと救われている
スタジオはるまきじゃなくてスタジオごはんってことははるまきごはんさんははるまきよりごはん派ってことですよね
私ははるまきとごはんじゃなくてはるとまきごはんの可能性も視野に入れてたんですけどね
おう、志布志市志布志町志布志みたいなコメントやめてくれや
目が回る
はるまきさんが春巻き派なのかご飯派なのかの考察じゃなくて、PVと曲の考察しなさいw
うらにわ ひらがな多い分余計分かりにくくなってるな笑
でも読んでくれてありがとう
へっぽこ大尉 呼び方がはるまきさんってことはあなたは春巻き派ですね(ドヤ顔)
あと、PVと曲を考察するほどの頭はない笑
笑った
アルバムで二人が一緒にいる曲は全部bpmが同じってことに気付いて鳥肌
3:10 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
まさかの歌！？！？？？？
Mvのクオリティ半端ねえです…どんどん上がってません！？
神ですか！？
ニコニコだとボカロバージョン聴けますよ！
Day Dream
みたいですね！！どっちも素敵ですよね～～...🍚
通知来た瞬間飛んできたので歌！？！ってなりました、笑
329むしゃ
わかります...わかります...はるまきごはんワールド最高ですよね...この世界観にのめり込みたい...
ニコニコverと同時再生すると不協和音になって聴けないの、二人は二度と会うことはできないっていうのを表してる感じがしてすき
まじだこええそこまで考えが至るのも素晴らしい
天才
私も聞いた。作り込まれてて鳥肌しか立たなかった
なんだそりゃ。
感動した。
はるまきごはん×初音ミク
合わせてみたってやつですか？
聞いてきましたが、
やばかったです。。
はるまきごはんさんの曲の夕方と夜の間みたいな雰囲気好き
ニコニコと同時に再生すると不協和音になるのすごすぎる。
もう二度と会うことができない2人を表してるのか。
Yes it is amazing
テスト中ずっとこれ流れてて、頭ん中藍で満たされて、なんも解けやんかった
3:29 血の表現がキレイ
どんな少女も終わりは美しくってこういうことか？
「ふたりは確かに生きている」のところでピンク色に光る弦がRUclips版とニコニコ版で違うけど位置的には隣り合った弦同士なの、良い………
I just realized something about the ending of the sung version and the vocaloid version:
They both play a piece of the song in the opposing songs key at the end.
The two versions are a half-step apart. If put together, they sound dissonant, making a minor 2nd, the musical term for a really clashing pair of notes.
What this means is while the songs lead to one another, they can never be heard together, or be together for that matter, like some of the meaning found in the music video.
This is some simple yet amazing detail and storytelling to add onto the already beautiful song.
This song is so wonderfully haunting and spine-tingling to listen to, and I really cannot express how much I appreciate this music.
Here's some love from a sleepless English user
Good theory, that's why when I put both version in one video it sounded really clashing.
Such a good song with a sad story.
Here, love from me too
@@taringtajam Heya! I made a video where the two are in tune with each other. Their voices actually work really well together. Check it out if you want to!
this theory's supported by the fact that:
- RUclips ver. has the coloured key on "G"
- NND ver. has the coloured key on "F#"
edit: timestamp for reference (around 3:11 or 3:12)
The fact that one is uploaded on RUclips and one is on niconico too...
@@alka_llyod It's really awesome what you did there. When the two versions follow the same tune, it creates a good harmony between the voices. In the other hand, you just reunite the two girls and now the song sounds more complete than before. Good job!
考察。※ニコニコ版についてガッツリ言及するので、まだ見てないよ、知りたくないよって人は【続きを読む】を押さないように！
結論から言うとピンクちゃんが死んだ話で、黄色ちゃんはもっと前に死んでます。(黄色ちゃんが先に死んでいることについては他の人も言っていました)
黄色ちゃんが先に死んでいたと考える理由は
理由①
0:54 ロボットの爆発にピンクちゃんは気づくが、黄色ちゃんは気づかない。(目を向けない)
理由②
0:30 写真では2人の身長は同じだが、0:57ではピンクちゃんの方が背が高い。
→黄色ちゃんは身長が低い時＝幼い時に既に死んだ
理由③
3:38 とエレベーターの中で、黄色ちゃんは座っている
→黄色ちゃんは再会を『待っていた』
対してピンクちゃんは立っているし、飛んでくる、つまり再会を『しに来た』
理由④
3:11 小魚(稚魚)と大きな魚
これは言うまでもなく黄色ちゃんとピンクちゃんのメタファーでしょう
理由⑤
3:04 歌詞で『ふたりは置いていかれる』と言っているのに対し、『大人達は憂いてる あいつは正気じゃないと』と、単数であること。
しかし『ふたりは確かに生きている』と言うように黄色ちゃんはピンクちゃんの心の中に生きていたのだと思います
理由⑥
2:06 子供と思われるロボットの目に映る色はRUclipsもニコ動もピンク。つまり、大人達とは反対に進む、即ち宇宙船に乗らないのはピンクちゃん一人。(そしてそれをまるで「見ちゃダメよ」と言うように子供の視線を変えさせる大人と思しきロボット。)
また、2人が同一人物である説、二重人格説も考えました。しかし、冒頭の2人の腕時計の形が異なること(0:17 ピンクちゃんは丸、黄色ちゃんは四角)、1:20 部屋の窓枠の形や家具の種類が違うことから、2人は別人であると考えました。
ではなぜ2人は死んだのか、考えていきます。
まず飛び降りているので自殺だと考えます。そして、自殺理由は結論から言うと『人として死ぬ為』だと考えます。この理由についてまず背景を考えました。
遠い、あるいはそう遠くない未来、人間(大人達)は住みづらくなった地球で生きるため、長生きするために身体をロボットにしていった。戦争もした。それでも限界はあるのでついに地球から出ていくことにした→3:50宇宙船が飛んでいく
2人はそんな人間の生き方に疑問を抱き、大人達が忘れてしまった(自然や生き物と寄り添ったりする)子供の心で、本来の人のあり方で最後を迎える。
→【生きることってこうだろう】
また、黄色ちゃんが死ぬ時の歌が【地球をあげる】なのかなぁと。【再会】と同じ斜めになった建物(曲がった世界でも真っ直ぐな2人を表していると思う)と黄色ちゃんみたいな髪型の女の子が立っているので。黄色ちゃんは大好きな地球を大好きなピンクちゃんに託したのだと思います。戦争をしていたと考える理由もこの歌です。
以上の理由より、人として生きたことの証明として、人の姿で死ぬことを決めたんだと思います。だから、1:25で位置は違えど、落ちてくる2色の線はどちらも地球儀＝本来の"人"にたどり着くのです。
そして【手を繋いだままなら二度と来ない再会】とは負の意味ではなく、『ずっと一緒にいられる』という意味だと思います。二度と離れないので最後の再会です。
おまけ
ピンクちゃんの足元にいつもいるマカロンみたいなロボットについて。
結論から言うと1:26(ニコ動)の写真の中の犬だと思います。犬は生物としての終わりを迎えますがロボットとして姿だけを変えて最期までピンクちゃんのそばにいました。ラストではマカロンは取り残されていますが、ピンクちゃんならその機能を停止させてあげていると思います。
かなり無理やりですし、
・ピンクちゃん、黄色ちゃんが落ちる時その前を黄色、ピンクの粉が先行して落ちていく
・1:23 RUclipsとニコ動では地球儀の光る位置が違う
・1:23 RUclipsの方の部屋は窓が割れていて、しかも補強されている
・ピンクちゃんが飛び降りたあとには黄色ちゃんの時のような涙のあとが残らない
これらの理由もわからないので不完全ですが、ここまで見てくださってありがとうございました。
ピンクちゃんが飛び降りた後、黄色ちゃんみたいにインクみたいな跡が残ってないのは犬みたいなやつがお掃除ロボットだからだと思います。はるまきごはんさんの twitterであれはお掃除ロボットだと言っていました。
塩分チャージ 取り敢えずお前凄いな
私は気づいてしまった( ﾟ∀ ﾟ)ﾊｯ！最後の4:00の所からは最初のシーンの黄色ちゃん版だっ！しかも時計は反転？させてあるっ！(みんな知ってるかもw)
理由②は普通に座ってたからだとおもう。
niconicoも見てきましたが
MVの主人公違うの好きです。。
2つ同時に…！流してみてください…！タイミング合わせて流すと、最後に二人同時に出会うのでなんかこう…良いんですよ（語彙力低下）
Day Dream
分かりました！流してみます〜！！
@@みなみ-m6c 最後の再開のシーン、画面が入れ替わるのでほんとに鳥肌たちましたww
あやぽん 比較動画みたいの欲しくなったw
動画に出てくるロボット、最初は感情のない随行支援ロボ程度にしか思ってなかったんだけど、関連動画を見るうちにロボットにもしっかり感情があることがわかってしまい、それを踏まえた上で再度 3:54 を見た時に胸が苦しくなった。
疲れちゃうよね正直ね、がほんとすき
ニコニコver.とRUclipsver.の違いまとめ。
(書き忘れ編集済)
・女の子
MVの視点となる女の子が違う。
niconico→カチューシャの女の子。
エフェクトカラーは黄色。以降☆。
RUclips→ツインテールの女の子。
エフェクトカラーはピンク。以降♡。
・服の文字 (編集した)
それぞれ以下のように書いてある。
☆→『リリ』(名前？)
♡→『七七七』(回想では『七』)
最初は名前(ななみ)と思っていたのですが、今では年齢(21、7才)では？と考えています。
・腕時計
☆→下から腕を上げる。
腕時計は四角。手首に直に付けている。
♡→上から腕を下げる。
腕時計は丸い。服の上から付けている。
・エレベーター
☆→座り込んでいる。
ピンクちゃんよりは幼くみえる。
♡→吊り革を持ち立っている。
黄色ちゃんよりも大人びてみえる。
・乗り込むロボット達。
☆→ロボット達の背が高くみえる
♡→ロボット達と背の差があまりない。
・爆発するロボット
☆→欠伸をして外を眺める。
気がついていない。
♡→ロボットの爆発に目を瞑る。
目を向けた時に光が映り込む。
・落ちていく
花びらのような光が一緒に落ちていく。
☆→ピンクの花びら。
♡→黄色の花びら。
・部屋
それぞれの自室。
ピンクちゃんの方がボロくなっている。
・部屋に飾られた写真
☆→二人の寝顔？の写真。
♡→手を繋ぐ写真。
・屋上
☆→床スレスレに座る。
♡→少し後ろに座る。
ピンクちゃんの後を掃除ロボが付いてくる。
・再び落ちていく
反転して映るのもう一つの落ちる光。
・部屋の中
互いを思い出している様子。
・ピアノの鍵盤
光の粒が落ちる鍵盤が
☆→「ファ♯」♡→「ソ」
この音を合わせると不協和音になる。
同じトリックなのか、両MVを同時に聞くと曲全体を通して不協和音になるように作られていることが分かる。
・再開
交互に映る部分で順番が入れ替わる。
・飛び降りた後
☆→涙の跡が残る。
♡→跡がない。ロボが涙を掃除したから。
・そして…
もう一つの再開を垣間見る。
どんな少女でも終わりは美しく
この歌詞好きすぎる…なんて素敵な歌詞なの…
0:19 エレベーターで上昇中シーン
この藍色と桃色の空をみると懐かしさと寂しさを感じる。締め付けられるなんだろう。
ナナちゃんに自分を重ねて聴いてる。心に沁みるね
*キャラの名前どこでわかりますか？*
@@ぴっけですっ
はるまきごはんさんがキャラクターをまとめたサイトを作っていらっしゃるので､よかったら調べてみてください！
はるまきごはんさんの曲とMVはいつもすてきすぎて、泣いてしまう。私もそんなふうに物語を広がりたいなあっと思ってくれる。本当に大インスピレーションです。
（日本人じゃないですから、日本語が悪かったらならすみません。)
3:11のはぁ→あぁ↓あぁぁぁぁ⤴︎ ⤴︎⤴︎っていう歌い方がすごく好き
Can we talk about how insane it is that he produces, composes, illustrates and animates all of his own videos? There are only two people in the world I know of that do that
not to mention also has the ability to sing them himself, something I wouldn't have guessed from a vocaloid producer. this guy is just...really multi-faceted apparently.
Can you tell me who are the other 2 people?
@@artyk6011 Kenshi Yonezu is one.
he has an assistant for this song's MV
a skilled one
@@Shyncase yeah I realized that after. But on many of his songs/videos he worked alone
はるまきごはんさんの儚すぎる歌声を聴いて鳥肌が止まらん……
やっぱりご本家さまって最強なんだ………、、
「手を繋いだままなら二度とこない再会」のところで最後2人が微笑んでいるのが素敵、
Harumaki Gohan is simply so talented. From the production of the song to the music video he does it all. What a legend. Definitely a new legend in the Vocaloid and J-Pop scene in general.
Also, he has such a nice singing voice it honestly makes me jealous.
Perfect 💓💓💓
夜中にふたりのシリーズ聴いて大号泣して寝るのすごくすき
最初のイントロのメロディと最後のメロディは同じはずなのに最後は何故かすごく鳥肌経ちました、すごくこう、何かがなくなってしまったかのような切なげな感じが綺麗で...
物語や世界観だけじゃない、もっとこの人の作家性に気付いてくれ。
自分が死んだ時、天国は、こういう世界観の場所であって欲しい。切なくもグッと綺麗な聡明な感じ。
2:47とかに出てくる、この女の子達と一緒にいたロボットが3:55で取り残されてるのも切ない
2年前のコメントで心苦しくなるとは思ってなかった
「約束しよう2人はずっと子どものままでいよう」の部分めっちゃ好き
この歌詞とメロディーがすごく安心する
いつも疲れた時聴きにきてる
すごく綺麗な曲で好き
うぽつです〜〜！！！！！
歌まで歌えるとかほんとに……尊敬です
落ち着く声してる
なんで居るんだ（恐怖）
落ち着く声してるの本当それ
3:11 から血の表現までがすごくいい
やっぱself coverがめちゃめちゃ好き
泣かせて来させる感じの切ない落ち着いた曲苦手なのにはるまきごはんさんの曲はなぜか死ぬほどすこ、、、
共感でしかないです🥲
@@ki_t7192結構共感者多くて意外！
"手を繋いだままなら二度とこない再会"
ていうところが好き
はるまきごはんさんを知っているという幸せ
何度も何度もこの曲を聴いては、何度も何度も涙を零している。
最愛のあの子たちに、もう二度と再会することができないことを思い出してしまう。この曲は、幼かった頃の自分の稚拙な理想を何年経っても記憶の忘却から守っている曲に思えてきて、切なく苦しい気持ちになるけれど、諦めさせないでいてくれるこの曲が、ずっとずっと大好きだ。
何か壮大な映画見終わった気分になるよねごはんさんの曲
曲が始まってから16秒間のなんとも言えない切ないイントロで泣きそうになる、、
MVで涙出るのなんて初めてで感想にしきれず歯がゆいばかりなんだけどもう、なんか……こう……この、すごいの……言葉にできない。どうしたら良い
大丈夫、私も言葉にできないから…
でもなんか不思議な何かがあるよね。
普通だったら映像ってみないんだけど、はるはんさんが、この曲の為のPVを自身でつくってるってのが尊すぎるし、可愛くて色遣いも綺麗なPVだから、どうしても映像を見たくなっちゃう。
祝5周年🎊
5年経っても色褪せずに胸が締め付けられるふたりのシリーズの第1作目、すてきな物語をありがとうございます
「ふたりだけ当たり前を知らないで」好きすぎる
毎回映像の中の景色がはるまきさんにしかない独特な色で美しい
自分が終わる時はこの曲を聞きながら終わりたいって思ってるくらい大好き
なんだこれ、、４分経ったことに気づかないくらい楽しくて何周もしちゃう
洒脱な歌声も、あっさりしてるのに光が伝わってくる色づかいも、カメラで撮ったみたいなアニメーションも洗練されてて聴き心地がいい
でもどこがとかじゃなくて、もとからあったものみたいにその世界が伝わってきて、これ一つに衝撃を受けた
はるまきごはん何者なんだ…
YT ver and NNd ver had different point of view(?)
Yt from this pink girl
And NND is from that yellow girl
And BOTH ARE LOVABLE
Miss each other
And can't meet again orz thats depressing..
I love this concept..
DUDE
IF YOU DIDN'T MENTION THAT THE NND VERSION WAS FROM THE YELLOW GIRL'S POV I WOULD HAVE NEVER FOUND OUT
HOLY SH- I LOVE THIS SONG EVEN MORE NOW
if you play both versions at the same time, there is an obvious dissonance in the melody, further emphasizing the story behind the song, absolutely genius
holy crap, you guys should check the version where miku sings (if you haven't already). the MV is different, we see the other girl with yellow hair instead
and it's really sad because even though the title is reunion, it's a reunion that'll never happen :(( I hope the two meet again though, somewhere, someday...
:0 is the miku version on niconico?
@@dalasquil2442 yep!! I think he uploaded them at the same time. btw, you can check the description for the link
@@dalasquil2442 for now yes, on Niconico only. I wonder if their voice will ever on the same channel or will be as seperated...
Could you give us a link? I tried to find it but I’m not having much luck
Here's the NND link: sp.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm35330510
めっっっっっちゃくちゃこのイントロが好き。
なんでかわからんけど。
胸が苦しくなって広くなる。
本当に一番大切な人とどっかへ飛んで生きたい
再会みるたび2人ともほんと大人になってて親みたいな気持ちになる；；；；；；
藍色とネオンピンクのMVが綺麗で、近未来な表現がうますぎる。。
どんな声か覚えてるかな
どんな風に話してたかな
すっかり背が伸びたお互い
正義とか常識とかさ
疲れちゃうよね正直ね
秘密基地の中にはそんなものはない
約束しようふたりは
ずっとこどものままで居よう
誰も傷つかないなら
思い出のままにしよう
ふたりだけ花びらの散るように
幼気な春風に舞うように
どんな少女でも終わりは美しく
ふたりだけ飛ぶ鳥の落ちるように
手を繋いで星の裏側まで
飛んで往きたい
そういえば泣き虫だよね
必死こいて隠してるよね
立派になるもんだお互い
大人って面倒くさくて
疲れちゃうよね正直ね
みんなきっと忘れてくこどもだったこと
冒険しようふたりは
大人達とお別れさ
生きることってこうだろう
息を吸うことじゃないだろう
ふたりだけ当たり前を知らないで
徒然な後悔も言わないで
どんな言葉も無いほど麗しく
ふたりなら落ちる陽の寂寞も
藍がかった星の裏側まで
覚えておける
タイムリミットの鐘が鳴る
ふたりは置いていかれる
大人達が憂いてる
あいつは正気じゃない･･･と
タイムリミットの鐘が鳴る
ふたりは確かに生きている
ふたりだけ花びらの散るように
幼気な春風に舞うように
そんな最期ならふたりに相応しい
さんざめくこの世界にさよならを
手を繋いだままなら
二度とこない再会
I find it super incredible that Harumaki Gohan self-produces his songs (though he did have help with the animation for this one). The music is a BOP and the animation is super detailed and smooth-
Thanks for your hard work 🙏🙏
3:34 何回見てもここで泣いてしまう
歌詞もメロディも大好きだし、MVも苦しくなるくらい好き。特に1:28あたりの「再会」のところ、まるで空に浮かんだ光の扉が開く瞬間みたいに見えた。
この曲を聴くと、とうの昔に忘れてしまった感性が蘇ったような気がして、世界が前よりも綺麗に見える
Looking back on this song after listening to the new one ("Promise") is so sad…
「幼気な春風」ってフレーズが本当に綺麗で大好き。
「二人」じゃなくて「ふたり」なのも「来ない」じゃなくて「こない」なのも好き。言葉の繊細な美しさにあてられて目も耳も最高に幸せ。
本人歌唱…！
曲は、はるまきごはんさんらしさもありながらとてもかっこよくて素敵です！！ストーリーの考察もしたい…！
アニメーションのクオリティがめちゃくちゃ高くて感動です👀
ミクver.とはるまきごはんver.で違うのもすごい……リピートします
This was the very first Harumaki Gohan song I heard, almost a year ago, and I remember how it brought me to tears and sobbing. Now I listen to Harumaki Gohan almost every day--the music has become a part of my life in an unexpected way. I'm grateful I found this when I did.
Harumaki Gohan's music videos always evoke these emotions and have beautiful lyrics! It really makes me fall in in love his songs so easily.
Also, I'm very greatfull for the English translations!
Super long theory:
I think the meaning of this song might be quite straight forward. At least from my understanding this song is about not wanting to grow up. I think the protagonist and her friend (I'll call her Blue for now and her friend Yellow) made a promise about never growing up and staying children forever (0:48), but somehow Blue was left behind.
When young, they decided that growing up wasn't the right way of living and that Grownups were just humans that forgot how to actually live and not just exist, unlike them ("So this is how to live a life right? Living is not just breathing, right?"). A representation of those Grownups that forgot how to live are the robots in this video. This is suggested by them holding onto train handles and them wearing suits at 0:40. In Japan most people use trains to get to/to leave work, so I think the robots are representing aldults going to/leaving work.
The color Pink in this MV might represent "childishness", or the will to not "just exist", maybe even individuality. You can see one of the Robots looking to the side with pink eyes, while everyone else just looks straight ahead. In the end the robots gets forced to look straight ahead just like everyone else (2:04) which could represent him being pressured into acting and thinking like everyone else, again leading to just existing and not actually living. (This robot might be a child being pressured by their parents into acting the way society expects them to and being forced to "grow up", forgetting their "childishness" ("Eventually, we will forget we once were kids")).
I think the airship in this MV is a representation of the act of "growing up", entering this ship officialy makes you an adult, maybe just like using the train to get to your first job for the first time. "The final Bell rings, the two will be left behind, the grownups are worried that they're not sane" probably means that the adults that knew Blue and Yellow were worried that something was wrong with them because they weren't acting like everyone else and didn't "grow up", like they were supposed to. The "final bell" probably represent the last bell/announcement before the airship to aduldthood leaves the station.
I think Yellow took her own life a long time before this video took place (maybe because she noticed that there wasn't a chance of them winning this fight, at 2:17 you can see the airship of adulthood looming over them, maybe Yellow noticed that there wasnt a chance of running away from this) and that Blue is on her way to "join" Yellow by killing herself as well (hence the title "Reunion", they'll finally meet again after death, this is also suggested by Blue thinking this at the beginning of the video: "I wonder if you remember my voice, I wonder how we talked to each other, we've both grown", suggesting that she hasn't seen Yellow in a while and that she wonders if they'll even recognize each other when they finally meet again). You can see Blue looking at her watch multiple times, this might represents her thinking that her time has finally come to join Yellow. After falling from the cliff at 3:20 we can see her into a pink stream of color. Before this there was a yellow stream of color (2:43) which probably represents Yellow killing herself just like Blue at some point before this. Finally, at the end of the video you can see the two streams flying in the sky while the airship to adulthood leaves without Blue and Yellow.
Well this is how I understood this MV at least, sorry for any grammar or spelling mistakes, english is not my first language :)
Ah, can I also say, Harumaki Gohans voice is so pretty and soothing!
You really did a great job at explaining the song :") 💜
I think that's an excellent theory. I was thinking something along similar lines, but not quite the same - I kind of think the song is about a suicide pact between the two of them. My theory is the two girls grew up together and, like you said, agreed that adulthood wasn't for them if it meant losing themselves, and so they decided to both kill themselves at the moment they reached it (I think you're spot-on with the airship as a metaphor for adulthood). This is also because of lines around 3:04 where it's implied that the two girls have gone off to do something and the adults are worried about them but don't take them seriously enough to stop them. I think that they were separated a while ago, when their paths of growing up diverged, thus why they're on different towers going to different airships, if we're sticking with the airships-taking-off-is-adulthood-metaphor, but they both stuck to the decision they made back when they were together in the hopes that it would bring them together again. That's why their paths mirror one another; they're going through the same actions, but just mimicking each other can never truly bring them together again. Like, there's this poem by Andrew Marvell called The Definition of Love, and there's a bit in it where he writes 'as lines, so loves oblique may well / themselves in every angle greet; / but ours, so truly parallel, / though infinite, can never meet.' and this song strikes me as the absolute embodiment of that.
Lore Update. They made a Promise.
According to the lyrics, they seem to be lovers, not just friends.
@@beiyuimpact4636 yeah, I can see that; apparently in Japan romantic relationships between girls is societally seen as “something you do when you’re younger as practice for a ‘real relationship’, something you grow out of”
So I can see the “not wanting to grow up if it means losing ourselves” thing as something like that, where it’s like “if growing up means that we can’t love each other anymore, we don’t ever want to grow up”
長いこと離れ離れになった
ふたりが、再会を望む曲のようだ。
私だったら、多分耐えられない。
どんな少女でも終わりは美しく
儚くて強くて可愛くて、まじで好きです
最後の再会のスッて切れるところがすごい好き
再会ほどふたりの最後を飾る曲に相応しいものは無いと思う
何度聴いても素晴らし過ぎて涙が出ます
この歌に誕生日おめでとう! / Happy Birthday to this song!🎉🎂💕
これ時間が5時前ってことは、黄昏時を表してるのかな、、
黄色ちゃんはもう既に亡くなってるから死者に会えるその時間にかけてピンクちゃんも自殺する、、？
サビの｢幼気な春風｣って所で幼気なぃってちょっといが聴こえる気がする。※幼気を強調する時に幼気ないって言うらしいです
みんなが忘れている子供の頃を強調したかったのかなと言う考察です。ミクver.も少しいが聴こえる気がするんですよね、、
ところどころ空を飛んでるリュウグウノツカイ？になにか意味があるのかとても気になります。
最後の3:35は飛び降りたあとの血を表しているのかなと思いました。
長々とすみません🙇♀️
黄色の女の子は紫色の女の子よりも先に亡くなってしまっていて紫色の女の子はその子に会いに逝ったのかな
でも歌詞の中に「二人は確かに生きている」ってあるから違う意味合いで作られた曲なのかなぁ。
椎名遊
ニコニコverはmvがここと違うので、見てみると考察が変わるかもしれませんぜ
ネタバレにならんようにあんまり言わんでおきますが笑
坂出アサ 今見てきましたが本当ですね💦「どちら」とは定まらず「どちらかが」の方がこの考察には当てはまるかなw
ぼくなりの解釈なのですが、子どものままでいよう、という約束してたことから、死の表現は子どもを忘れ大人になっていくことかな、と
だから二度と来ない「再会」ってことなんじゃないかなぁと
子どものままでの再会は叶わなくなってしまった
追加；大人、というのは、傷つくのを恐れて素直な心を隠して生きていく、そんな人のことをさしているんじゃないかな、と思ってます
ここのせたると
なるほど！そう考えるともっと切なくなってきてしまいますね...
「生きることってこうだろう 息を吸うことじゃないだろう」という歌詞から、身体が生きていなくても、一般的には「死んでいる」状態でも、「二人は確かに生きている」と言えるのではないでしょうか
10年くらい前によく聴いていた邦楽の音を感じるのに電子的で新しくて未来を感じもする、不思議だ、、
考察
既出ならごめんだけど、
思いっきりロボットの形をしてる大人達を無視することになるけど
これ、船は「ノアの方舟」かな?
地球温暖化かなんかで近い将来の話、世界が終わろうとしていて、大人達は逃げようとして（=ロボットとして永遠の命を手に入れて）方舟に乗るけど、この2人は「自分達がロボットになるなんて嫌」「それならいっそのことこの星と一緒に終わってやる」とか言って落ちてったのかなとも解釈出来て。星は滅んでしまって結果的には会えなくなるから「二度と来ない再会」。色んな解釈をさせる余地を残してくれるボカロPさんが私は好き。
「再会」のエモポイント
（ややネタバレ注意）
・はるまきごはんさんverとボカロverを合わせると不協和音になる
・PVがそれぞれ違う
・物語モノ
・1番最後はお互いとも、お互いのPVに繋がっている
はぁー、エモい（頭を抱えながら）
the fact that these two both look strikingly similar to pink and blue from melty land nightmare makes me feel that these two ARE them and this takes place before that song
edit: i still stand by my theory that this is melty land nightmare 2.0 or at least takes time somewhere between that song. these two (im gonna call reunion pink and yellow) look extremely similar, which im starting to think it was done deliberately, to melty pink and blue.
the main thing i got from this song is that reunion pink and yellow are awaiting a reunion which will never come. in melty land nightmare, blue visits melty pink in her dreams because her real life isnt going well for her so pink comforts blue out of her sadness. eventually, however, blue leaves pink and she's eventually forgotten.
my main theory here is that reunion pink and yellow were best friends growing up and started seeing less of other as time went past. They both felt the pressures of becoming an adult and leaving your childhood behind which leads to one of them committing suicide (which im going to say is reunion pink)
we enter MLN territory as yellow starts to struggle more with her life and can only escape in her sleep and dreams where she (dressed as blue) meets melty pink. if reunion pink is the one that committed suicide, then its most likely she came back as melty pink and a spirit in yellow's dreams. this could also be why reunion and melty pink are the same color. i could also say that the reason why yellow is blue in her dreams is because in reality, shes unhappy with her situation.
we all know how the story ends there through: blue eventually leaves melty land and melty pink is forgotten. i could interpret that as yellow waking up from her sleep into reality (as you can forget dreams after waking up) and came back to melty land when she went back to sleep (which is why the song mentions that blue has visited her thousands of times)
i find it awfully sad because no matter how you see it, both girls in MLN and this song can never truly be together. blue can't remember melty pink every time she visits and reunion pink and yellow can't be together as they are, quite literally as yellow's POV is on niconico, in parallel worlds. it the end, ill probably say that its likely that yellow did end up committing suicide in the hopes that she would join reunion pink in death as well as pressure.
i do know that there are some theories that yellow may of been the first to go or that she's the representation of a imaginary friend/childhood that reunion pink eventually has to let go. the NN MV does make it hard since it's from yellow's POV but thats what I got from this one
and thats why harumaki gohan is a legend
Giovanni Fuego i personally think at least for now that MLN may take place maybe during this song? or at least somewhere in between because while the title is called reunion, its a reunion that wont come to pass. at least in my interpretation
so now that the full series is out, has this theory changed? i was actually just wondering if anyone thought this was a sequel to mln when this first came out lol
ok i know i already replied but i HAVE to say this.
as much as i loveloveLOVE this theory, as someone who knows a lot about the harumaki gohan lore from reading the album artbooks... this theory is literally impossible.
so in the harugo canon you've got the blue planet, which is where futari no takes place. but you've ALSO got dream planets, special planets that humans can visit in their sleep, which currently includes the melty land and seventina (although there's WAY more, they're jusy undiscovered).
but here's the thing - *the blue planet and dream planets are in the same universe.*
not only that, but melty is impled to have existed for a REALLY long time, while nana and lili were 21 when they heckin died. so there's actually a good chance that futari no and melty land nightmare are going at the same time.
it's depressing to debunk this but the harugo lore is actually REALLY cool and the official meanings for a lot of his songs are better than the fan theories a lot of the time (just my opinion though) so i highly recommend reading up on it! you won't regret it (the artbooks are in japanese though so you can either check out the harumaki gohan wiki or read tick's translations which can be found on his twitter [harugo_eng])
なんか泣きそうになるくらい透明でエモい
夢を見ているような優しい色合い、
そして温かい印象を持たせるイラストと、
どこか寂しく、切なくなるような曲調が
相まってとても好きです。
…小説化とか映画化とかしないかな。
最後の｢二度とこない再開｣ってもうずっと一緒にいるから再会はないよ、なのか死んでしまったからもう出会えない、という意味なのか…
自分的には二度と離れない意味で再会はないよと意味だと勝手に思ってます笑
これ初見で聞いた時マジで泣いた
ボカロバージョンもこっちも登場人物が違って、重ね合わせると不協和音になったり、
PVも物凄く作りこまれてるしほんとに素晴らしい！！（なお語彙力
透明感のある曲で世界観に引きずりこまれていくようでとっても好きです！！
外国の方も多くコメントしてて世界共通にいい曲なんだなって。
寝る前に暗い部屋で目瞑って聞くのがすき…
聴き続けて1年……変わらず大好き