US criticism of S Africa's genocide case is meritless, counterproductive & baseless: Marwan Bishara
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 янв 2024
- The lawsuit filed by South Africa against Israel at the International Court of Justice in The Hague drew criticism from the United States on Wednesday. White House National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby dismissed the submission, labelling it as meritless, counterproductive, and lacking any factual basis.
Al Jazeera’s senior political analyst Marwan Bishara criticizes John Kirby's brief dismissal of South Africa's genocide case against Israel, emphasizing the thoroughness of the 84-page document. Marwan perceives Kirby's response as disrespectful and lacking diplomatic courtesy, asserting that South Africa and the academic community deserve more acknowledgement. Marwan also questions the US stance on the Gaza death toll, expressing concerns about the intent behind Israeli actions targeting civilians and infrastructure.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#UnitedStates #JohnKirby #ICJ #UnitedNations #WarCrimes #IsraelWarCrimes #GazaGenocide #Genocide #Israel #Palestine #Gaza #SouthAfrica #Genocide #GazaWar #IsraelWarOnGaza #WarOnGaza
The same John Kirby that was crying crocodile tears for Ukraine. The hypocrisy is unreal.
Well said man!
Surprisingly South Africa rejected genocide case against Russia in Ukraine and even opposed decision by ICC to arrest Putin. They never show Gaza case coming.
He is despicable .
Their empire is rapidly coming to an end. That's when u become more desperate
It's absolutely embarrassing. They are going to jail and they know it.
The US should be implicated as well for backing them at the UN and for supplying weapons to murdering civilians (countless 2000lb bombs).
E os civis Israelense que foram mortos por esses bicho, EUA tá certo 🇺🇸🇮🇱
US is 100% complicit
If the case is won, the US will be accountable under law for aiding and abetting.
Only US has the right to call genocide. They have experience along with Foster child Israel 😮
@@IdunilBandara-rj9uf it appears to be like that
Only people who have fought against oppression foreign rule for generations understand other people's pain and sufferings.
That's the irony, isn't it?
But the isrealis didnt understand the pain og others, why?
.Although I've not lived under foreign oppression, my sense of justice is profoundly offended by what Israel is doing and has done to the Palestinians. I weep for them, I do feel pain. I think anyone with human decency would.
@garysmith6049 I guess history and freedom to search for the truth is illegal where you live. Or you just intentionally want to be dumb
@@AWAYWITHEVILThe European Zionist foreigners.
I am super Proud of my country South Africa.
Oh yes of course...a country that does nothing against farm murders along with staying silent on xenophobic attacks against foreign nationals...a country that is so corrupt itself that literally can't keep the lights on should not be lecturing to the rest of the world
As you should be. 💛
Typical White House arrogance.
Sionistas
delusions of grandeur, coming to an end
Well what to expect of a country putting Kirby behind the podium... I love the games, but Kirby is far from a master diplomat, he's better off defending dream land and swallowing... Ohh i forgot that is exactly what he's doing. 🙄
US is complicit in the genocide
Typical White House Lie 😊
Wow!!! This US regime never stop to amaze the world. Criminals in power supports criminals to commit crimes...
Exactly.
Absolutely right
Sadly true.
At this point, even if Trump is guilty of things he is accused of.... he is still the least criminal of the lot! Imagine that!
Trust me I'm a south african..there are plenty more criminals here in government than in the US ! They are a disgusting bunch of inept fools that can't even keep the lights on in their own country !
I'm proud of South Africa for stepping out. Kudos!
Well done SA. You're certainly on the right side of history. Evils of the world are exposed
South Africa did itself proud by holding Israel accountable for its many crimes.
South Africa can not do anything. it's just theatrical
What did South Africa do when UN voted on condemning the invasion of Ukraine? That's right nothing... they abstained when even countries like Egypt condemned it. South Africa lost every right to play a moral party regarding Gaza with this double standard.
South Africa also did Putin proud by going to bed with Russia, a war criminal nation.
@@PP-cz5hi And so they should say nothing?
@@fckYTcensorship. Ukraine isn't innocent. Just remember that. Trouble with people like you, you don't look at the whole picture
America is so arrogant. A country with so little respect for other countries is doomed.
Much better than 💩 called 🇵🇸
☪️ 🕋 breeds terrorism !
The winner olympic for the arrogancy would be !$rael. No army would mock and take pride while inflicting harm to women and children like i-d f. I really applaud them for their shamelessness.
The days of evil triumphing is over, this is what they can't comprehend. That's baseless 🤷🏿♀️
Well, the good book says, those who Bless Israel will be Blessed and those who curse her will be cursed.
The reality is crystal clear no matter what other flawed narrative is presented 🇮🇱
God bless South Africa for standing for human rights
😂😂😂I think they are bootlicking Israel.
Thank you Al Jazeera for exposing the truth and Marwan is someone really worth listening to always
Every nation must support South Africa in this case and prove that humanity still exists.....
But judges won't find Israel guilty ... Because of holocaust and antisemitism ..... Zitler origin is a Jew and the holocaust seems suspicious to let sion-ists rule the world and get away with jenousides .......
Yes, lets line up South Africa's their condemnation of Russia, who invaded an innocent country two years ago. Oh, they did not condemn Russia? They are partners with Russia? Sad.
Not onearth SA cannot fix South Africa. Crimes looting undocumented peopleflooding SA. No electricity no water no service delivery. The USAis correct. Your analysis just big talk. Obvious because aljazeera supports isis talibans hamas muslim jihad. His ballah. 😂😂😂
Ireland 🙏🏻💯
Todos países tem que denunciar o genocidio no tribunal Penal Internacional
I Live in the US and I am disgusted with my governments actions
I think usa would save a lot of taxpayers money by bringing the zionists over there. They have very aggressive habits thou killing, bulldozing bullying
Then leave and go live ur life in Iran or come to South Africa where we have over 69% unemployment for the youths
You should be man, stop U.S genocidal action, period.
Not only now, but also in the future.
He is not going to be told by you, he has a right to disagree with his government @@koloni2862
@@koloni2862 America is a 3rd world country wearing a Gucci belt. The grass ain't greener over here
South Africa as a country is standing alone in this battle against the genocide of people of Palestine. Thank you all for your brave comments, may God hear all your prayers and help us win court case🙏🇵🇸🇿🇦
IT IS NOT GONNA HAPPEN
Hamas caused this all
@@pedro5591The only way I see it, is to invade Isreal..then push towards England and US.
Wait.. you're going to say.. It is not going to happen..right?
Africa is not alone. The majority of people around the world support them. We don't need a kangaroo court to tell us that
Yes, the majarity of the world Nazis and ignorants @@susanzhong1988
As a South African I actually agree with this academic like we didn't research what are you trying to say we are stupid and we have thought this through Mr Kriby give us more credit than that
If US was asked if Russia and Hamas have committed genocide they would definitely support the claim
Who takes what the US says with any degree of integrity or lack of bias anymore lol.
Russia has certainly intended to, going by their rhetoric. Hamas less so.
@@spaceman9599 Hamas would definitely want to too, judging by their actions, not just rethoric. Just because they are not capable of doing it, because Israel is stronger, doesn't mean they wouldn't want to.
In any case, what Russia does to Ukraine is despicable, what Hamas did on the 7th of October was also, and so is Israel's response (as well as the US' unconditional support for Israel's ethnic cleansing/genocide in Gaza).
@@flopoz2575 you need to widen your scope in the case of Palestinians, Gaza is not the place that they suffer, where is Hamas in the West Bank ?
South Africa cannot feed its own citizens. Once they figure out their own problems then they can contribute to the international community. Their case is not helpful and they are not credible.
The US should be hand to hand with Israel when the verdict of Genocide is announced. Neither of them is innocent. One provides weapons while other uses it.
Partners in crime
Couldn’t agree more. Really, Criminals supporting Criminals.
Add tories and liebour to that
And the united kingdom too
@user-fm5xp1tl4qEspecially Germany, which has been locking up Palestine peace supporters and has a well known affinity for genocide.
Every nation must support South Africa
God save the innocent,God be with South Africa
Case must be filed against USA too because all weapons they have provided including UK and EU.
As a Brit I agree 100%. The UK has tagged along with big daddy America every step of the way in facillitating this genocide.
Maybe that’s because Palestine is full of terrorists that want to destroy the west and have no respect for even their own citizens
😅
One step at the time. But the future will judge and those that are on the wrong side of History will wish they were not blind and deaf.
From America, I am proud of the actions of South Africa!! Someone needs to take action against the inhumane treatment of the Palestinians. I am just sorry it has taken 75 years to even file a case. This geno*ide and stealing of the Palestinian lives and land needs to stop now!!! Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤
let me guess, your heritage isn't american? 😂
@@mex3729kid what has that got to do, with what he said.
@@warkaahmed8035 easy to understand. He turns off his brain and follow the path of the ummah! Like every muslim!
@@mex3729 If you are not a native American, a red Indian, then your heritage is also not American. You are a settler, and illegal immigrant. Your forefathers committed genocide against the red Indian, do not forget that when you make these statements.
@@mex3729my heritage is American going back 200+ years and I am also proud of south africa. History will look upon them kindly.
Human beings don't have to go through this no matter their ethnicity, race or religion. It is completely unacceptable.
We Salute South Africa
The only thing meritless is John Kirby!
John Kirby deserves an Oscar. He flip-flops all the time. As Nelson Mandela said, "a man who changes principles all the time can never be considered a leader." That's John Kirby; a true hypocrite.
Well said and thought!
He's an amazing liar...
His intellectual capacity reminds me of methadone addiction. He is mindless. We do not need the US to help anyone see the truth. They are complicit in aiding and abetting.
this guy looks exactly like a street thief
We are proud of South Africa 🇿🇦 from Sierra Leone 🇸🇱. Standing for the right cause is always the right thing to do. "Our freedom is incomplete without the freedom of Palestine 🇵🇸"
What's about nigeria
No we re not..Are u African?please shut up
I'M proud to be an AFRICAN AMERICAN.
@@teenahweenah2608 no the black people home is Africa not America
@@teenahweenah2608 America only white
God bless this republic 🇿🇦🇿🇦..as we stand against the weaked rules of this world 😢😢
My two cents ? Admiral Kirby hadn’t even read South Africa’s 70- page submission to the ICJ...nor will he.
To dismissively answer the question I find disappointing but not surprising. But what can one expect from a retired military officer of the War Department.
Respect to the South African people for standing against oppression💪💪💪Shame on the american hypocrite politicians 👎👎👎
We understand USA democracy is a sham.
That is we slways seperate the politicians and ordinary citizens
Not the SAn people . The sickly corrupt pathetic ANC govt.
@@MichaelVumile-jb3lbDon't they teach English in Iran?
Where the rest of the comments go , and what they say ???
Omg bro i will never go america in my life after this
The American government can not allow the charges because they know they are supporting genocide.
Way to go South Africa.
You have my full respect.
🇨🇦
The American government does not control the world court, it doesn't get to veto like it did with the vote at the United Nations.
What, dont say south africa say the ANC,they are doing exactly the same in our country the problem is you just dont hear about it,you see this is the problem you are also supporting a communist party that also do genocide in south africa,the state enterpises that they rule here is all failing and is on a downhill drift,talk about the ANC not south africa,you no nothing that is happening here you dont hear it because its been wiped under the mat,if you want to accuse other countries of genocide then you hands must also be clean and trust me it isnt clean they also has blood on their hands but you shout go south africa
Because our country government has only cared about Military power and control in the Middle East, since 1948. Biden's speech to congress was disgusting in the 50s. But he's made it clear in the past, the near 9000 children dead is worth the price for military power.
We need to get the rest of Americans to wake up from the propaganda and their bubbles, but that is incredubly difficult, especially with the Trumpers. The only way to fix this long term is to vote 3rd party and weed out almost all the Democrats in Congress and all Republicans, and get new systems in place to ban corporate and foreign donations to campaigns, and lobbying.
Washington backed Israel regime has been and is committing unprecedented genocide in gaza flaunting international law, humanitarian law and basic human values. Its appalling that the so called civilised world in the west is defending these heinous crimes despite spending the last two years calling Russians all kinds of names. I think the double standard of western sponsored institutions is clear and the global rest must build it own systems.
As if we ever expected them to support the case!
When a wicked man smiles at you, RUN AWAY!
If USA was to support South Africa in this case, wouldn't every get shocked to death?
Bravo South Africa 🇿🇦 👏 👏👏👏
We do not need the respect of America. We have enough self respect to identify and call out genocide when we see it. 🇿🇦🇿🇦🇵🇸🇵🇸
❤
South Africa is one country that cares little about what Americans think or say
Exactly.
They sure care about their handouts and money though.. make no mistake the SA government are the most useless bunch of racist freeloading parasites ever his days are numbered.. half their members are rapists and murderers so it makes sense they called Hamas while South Africans were killed and kidnapped.. birds of a feather
The rest of the world is fast arriving to the same point.
Stop lying, no hand outs the US gives to South Africa, you are confusing South Africa to Libya or Somalia or Nigeria. You are too stupid to know that Africa is a continent and countries within Africa are totally different from each other. Like he said, South Africa doesn’t care what the US says, we have always been like that hence we can challenge the US on the international stage, they don’t scare us. Israel is a small useless apartheid state good enough to fight rebels in Gaza who are fighting with AK47s
Source?@@AWAYWITHEVIL
The separate file must be submitted to the ICC on the USA, as direct sponsor and direct participant of Genocide.
USA is not part of the ICC
From Indonesia, i'm very proud of South Africa.We stand with PALESTINE
That was incredibly concise and so well put
we do not ask someone accused of murder if they would like to go to court. we ask them to defend themselves in court.
Yes, indeed. With evidence that has/can be independently verified by qualified assessors with no conflict of interest in the matter!
These 3 words are at least serious. An Israeli representative recently stated: "It's a joke". Of course the US waves away this very just South African indictment, they are complicit. I am hopeful that the 11th will prove to be a step towards the end of apartheid and a peaceful future in Palestine/Israel.
Ruling by January 12th, Im wondering who will step up to enforce it.
@@Vbluevital Indeed, that's a very good question. Israel already has quite a track record in not caring about any resolutions and all that. Still, the international outcry has never been so loud, so I allow myself to hope for the moment, rather than already be cynical about the outcome. The deeper I dig, the more I see that the entire concept of the state of Israel has failed miserably. But the question of intervention other than more countries getting involved in that war… It seems bad enough as it is. Something more diplomatic would be very welcome.
@@findingfreedom-definingtru4818 The diplomatic giving up of power white South Africans did as they held elections and allowed a non-white government to take power and re-write the constitution is one solution.
Though they would need to allow all the Palestinians both in Gaza/the West Bank and the millions displaced that could want to return but are being denied the right to to vote.
All I know is that the world must be LOUD around the 11th, to ensure they know how important that judgment is. We need to protest and speak up more than ever before that day to get a hastened favourable judgement.@@findingfreedom-definingtru4818
AND TO END ALL GENOCIDES, ETHMIC CLEANSUNG. ETC. WE ALL HAVE A GID GIVEN RIGHT TO LIVE ON THIS EARTH WITHOUT FEAR.
The JEWISH UPRISING against their oppressors was a RIGHT TO DEFEND THEMSELVES. Are they the only privileged ones to have that right. Many genocides have occured and the WORKS remains silent. If the shoe was in the other foot and the Palistinians were the OPPRESSOR against Israeli's, they would have been STOPPED BY THE INTERNATIONAL COURTS OF JUSTICE. This law should not be for just the priveledge of one Country but to all countries and people. The treatment of the Palistinians started long before the 7th October and nothing was said or done. These are 22,000 defenseless unarmed men, woman, children and babies murdered by targeted bombs and journalists...only an inhumane country targets hospitals, schools (with children) sacred places of worship, refuge centres etc, cutting off water, fuel, electricity, food supplies and medicines. If this was happening to the Jews ACTION WOULD HAVE BEEN TAKEN SWIFTLY. One CANNOT be blamed for the culture language if color they are born into. If they were born a Jew they would not be killing them off. The PAKISTINIAN PEOPLE have a RIGHT to have JUSTICE and a country that most the people there today have been BORN IN. 75 years on and the 22,000 and 11,000 children with thousands maimed, crippled suffering PTS (just like soldiers to in times of war) living in fear that you may not live tomorrow or STARVE and watch your children STARVE. FHIS EVIL HAS TO STOP. This figure does NOT INCLUDE those still under the rubble, where WHOLE FAMILISS HAVE DIED. Thousands of ORPHANS. SHAME IN YOU as then still continue blatently ignoring the International LAWS out in place to NEVER HAPPEN AGAIN to any people of different ethnicity.
South Africa 🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦stand for the truth I'm proud of my country we cannot turn blind eye while people are dying
"What is meritless, counterproductive and baseless is the American response to the South African case". Bang!
The whole world is laughing at the Banana Republic of America.
I live there. They really think they are better than people outside America.
Always remember, today, most Americans have no culture or education; they have only entertainment, violent unabated Hollywood entertainment.
What is wrong in the head of this U.S.A government,their own population are not on teir side!
Only on AJ channel! The majority of the US(west) stands behind Israel! The rally's all over the world are 99% muslim immigrants, not native west people!!
Just puppets , citizens are mostly unable to do anything
millions of americans are trumptards that support the genocide because they believe joos need to inhabit the holy land in order for geezuz to return. the other voting half hate biden so much they won't vote for him again. so the trumptards will soon be victorious.
Majority of congress paid off by AIPAC that is why they keep spouting Israel's propaganda and the mainstream media also controlled. They depend on their public being apathetic and ill informed. How they sleep it night. Boils down to greed. And Kirby is like somone out of a Howdy Doody cartoon.
True
the TRUE COLORS OF the US and the WESTERN Nations governments will now be revealed! As a South African , I am SO proud of my Country right now !
US has not yet produce an official definition of what "Genocide" is. So how can they state the case does not fit?
The US must say frankly that Netanyahu governs it
If there's any guy you have to convince to stop of the war, it would be Benjamin Netanyahu, not the US, not Biden. It is clear that Netanyahu is calling the shots in Gaza.
It appears so.
Whitewashing US guilt
Time to fix that
@sayedibrahimameermeea3537...That`s exactly what John Kirby is saying!
Millions of Americans are in shock at what’s happening and disgusted. These a government officials are insane!
Millions of Americans also support Israel. These are the Democrats, who usually weakly support Israel. If you want to see real support, wait until the Republicans win this year. So you are caught between a rock and a hard place - good luck.
Yup and as an American, I can safely say we need regime change. There is nothing democratic about the way our government has behaved in the last 40 plus years.
Yes, only making the situation worse, no possible military solution only diplomatic, and after 75 years it appears Palestinians were I intentionally put in a trick box while lsrael runs occupation and ethnic cleansing, lsrael always disingenuous
The stench of corruption between Washington DC, the manufacturers of death, and Israel ...
@@fernandomendez9467The only positive is that the GOP is not leading the country as then Israel will be given even more carte Blanche to destroy Gaza.
Supplying weapons to murder
Also crime
As a current double levels grad/ undergrad, first gen Senior. So inspired to become an attorney after watching South Africa’s Brief.
Meritless? For them maybe, thousands of lives saved would beg to differ, counter productive? Against their interests. Baseless? Are they blind deaf and dumb?
From un organization in NY to south Africa thait's plan b is bound to fail to get
You forgot duplicitous
As a South African Muslim - I love my government for standing unapologetically and unequivocally with Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤️ 🇿🇦 ❤ 🇵🇸 ❤
You can be proud...❤❤❤
Would your country take itself to court for it Xenophobic acts on innocent immigrants who have died in your country's hands? What a shame. Pure hypocrisy.
200% Agree
Shukran Akhi, Free Palestine ❤
Jy is 'n regte Hamas spokesman.
Maran Bashar is so accurate! Why would The US speak for Palestinians? If they wanted to support Palestine, they would do so centuries ago and they wouldn't have been supplying deadly weapons to Israel to commit the genocide. If Israel is in trouble, fingers would also be raised on the US for being its ally.
The whole world knows the truth but only South Africa had the audacity to drag them to the court. Massive respect to South Africa 🇿🇦
Justice will be served, Ameen!!!
Love and prayers from Europe.
Is it my imagination or does John Kirby resemble a ventriloquists dummy? Well, if not he certainly plays the role well.
The US is should be a co-defendant in this case. It's complicit in Israel's actions and intentions. It's with US support that Israel has been getting away with this.
And the UK.
Mind Begs the Question:
- If USA Govt block/veto
- UN Resolution to end
- Starvation,Death Camps,Pogroms,Gas Chambers/White Phosphorus,Ethnic Cleansing,etc
- Not akin to puppet masters of Nazis?
The United States government is stocked with dual-citizen Israelis in high positions of influence. America has a completely Zionist-Occupied government.
@ForUForAlloFusWell, some nations do have the moral decency of remembering which countries stood by them, in their hour of need. Russia did that for SA, but Israel contributed to their misery, by supporting the Apartheid.
God bless South Africa 🇿🇦
God bless Africa.
It for the court to decide based on law . As with any other case brought to court .
No genocide? He should go live there then
Besides being an insult to South Africa and the excellent work they have done to document Is..ael's atrocities I think that what criminal Kirby said is an offence to everyone with a bit of intelligence and humanity. I applaud South Africa and I hope that more countries will support and follow.
It shows America is not made up of intelligent, thoughtful leaders, but of media personalities and sensationalist liers.
Very well said!
Every American Zionist needs to be held accountable for Israel's war crimes, for backing them up and financing their atrocities. And for committing war crimes for them as well, in Iraq, Syriaand Afghanistan.
They put the jew's evil money stained with innocent blood, over Human lives
It was the Zionist allies (US and UK) who stole Palestine land, and established the occupation govermnent in 1948. Every years stealing more land and expanding the segregation and killing Palestinians
Israel military and government, and US zionists, need to be trialed for war crimes
Kirby is an offense to everyone with a bit of intelligence!
Its no insult as what Kirby say is totally BS and its a well put together document and he KNOWS IT.
Love , hope and prayers from South Africa to the people of Gaza ❤
They scared cause this would put them in the same boat they supplied the weapons. They would be held accountable for it as they should, but they will try and separate them self from getting any replication in the act. They are really good at shifting the blame. They also good at making up rumors for the way they acted in this genocide war.
Lack of morals and a severe lack of humanity seems to be a must-have attribute for US Politicians and government officials.
The us knows exactly what is going on, however just like the owner of a savage dog that has just ripped someones arm off. The us cannot admit the savagery of its dog, which it has fed for decades now.
Because the dog is in control now and feasting on our innards.
83 pages of detailed proof and incidents “baseless” 🤣🤦🏽♀️the way these people lie with a straight face is sickening
Reading the 84 pages right now. And I have to say Kirby is about as wrong as wrong can be.
Kirby didn't read the document. Not sure he can read at all.
Well and perfectly said Mr Marwaan Bishara. That spokesperson has no moral or any standing whatsoever. they are complicit and their weapons were used in the bombing and massacres of the Palestinians. them and the UK government supporting this massacre and all others complicit , and all those that have benefitted financially from the bombing and massacre of the Palestinians must also be brought before the ICJ . Well Done SA for a well and meticulous and comprehensive factual prepared legal document presented to ICJ. It is full of Base and Merit.
My goodness, John Kirby and his boss must be smoking their socks.
Still what bases they need ?
Typical hypocrisy at its best...
I doubt Kirby read it, he just followed orders like a good dog. Besides, why does he look so guilty, almost scared?
He is a good dog.
well said!
and a constipated one!
Not only Israel, US & UK also held responsible for this genocide.
Hundred percent 💯
European Union,particularly Germany.
Dont forget Canada
@@do7696what do you mean by European Union? The EU is divided. And in the EU you have some countries that have a cleary oppose Israel, and some of them do more than simply talking, they take action (I'm thinking, for instance, of Irland, Spain and Belgium)
War is assuming that both sides have an army????
I don't think anyone can go lower than that
Kirby is a dual passport citizen. Let this sink in
Irony is dead.
Remember who was running the show on 9/11?
We need to be truly human regarding the situation of Gaza, move away from political circles and accurately scrutinize the following: What if, these were North American women and children, would that qualify as genocide?
Would you be speaking and maintaining that hypocritical rhetoric Mr. John Kirby, if the deceased children under the rubble were AMERICAN?
Yeah the double standard is mindblowing. And they have the audacity to claim to be the defender of human right? 🤦♀️ these people need to get a grip because nobody believe their lies anymore.
If he's on Israel's dole he very well may be. We currently have a government more loyal to Israel than to its own people. He's likely still find excuses if that's who's paying for it in the imaginary scenario. These people are corrupt through and through.
4.450.000, four and a half MILLIONS : that's the number of American citizens, 95% or more civilians, who would already have been killed at this date with the same ratio.
(Approx. 30.000 dead and missing on a population of 2.200.000)
You don't assume things during period of or in wartime.these killing happened on 7 Oct to the Jewish state not to the American must be clear about it.thank you
@Vilitati. Over 21,000 civilians, including over 8,000 children, died on October 7 during the Palestinian uprising? That's total bullcrap.
Any actions taken against its country is always baseless,
Only what they say have weight in that
A case of a narcissist being angry for being found out. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
He's saying Baseless.... with out doing any investigation🤔
My blood is boiling 🤢
It's right under his nose. He's financing the murder of kids and still-he can sleep at night. True psychopath.
Thank you South Africa the history and the world will remember that you did great work to protect innocent people
yes, add that to hte innocent Ukrainians that South Africa supports. Sorry, Russia they support.
The Russo-Ukranian conflict, how horrible it is, is nowhere near as a clear cut case of savagery and trampling of human rights as this latest Israeli agression against the Palestian people.@@rb239rtr
@@rb239rtr yes sorry we love Russia
@@thaabitmartin3743 so, being hypocritical?
@@to_mins_2_midnight-de5lj the renewal of the Soviet empire has been a Putin dream for two decades. Now it is Putin's bad dream and a disaster for Russia and Ukraine.
South Africa is upholding the intrinsic worth of all of human life, an outstanding calling. I am even vegetarian as to me all of life is precious each person and other species. War, killing people good grief how is this even vaguely acceptable, diplomacy conversations based on mutual respect and care for one another from our hearts creates more happiness and prosperity but aggression/war just promotes the trauma/violence cycle.
proud of my country, we fully support you, we have live through this oppression before, salute 🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦❤❤
I’m glad South Africa speaks for all moral people in bringing this case of genocide before the court.
If only other governments would support South Africa.
@@har3036Malaysia, Turkey and now Jordan support the claim.
The genocide is no muslim nation helps the palestinians ,Israel gets attack on Oct 7,there is a war between israel and Hamas and the arab world leaves them!That is genocide!
I salute South Africa's courage for making this big move.
It's the US government that are baseless and meritless or just a muck using the proper word...
What comes out of John Kirby what you do in your toilet every day
The evidence against Israel in both scope and scale is so obvious and overwhelming that it is unconscionable for Kirby to make such claims!
He's sold his soul decades ago
John Kirby lies without bounds. He plucks things from the air and throws them into the argument.
Let me see...Biden tells Iran that he's unfreezing the six billion dollars America was going to give Iran...Iran borrows money against that six billion and finances a three pronged terror attack co-ordinated between Hamas, Hezbollah and Houthis in Yemen. The goal is to overwhelm Israeli defences and wipe them out. But Hamas jumped the gun, and negated the effectiveness of a three pronged attack. Israel, having realized that this was an attempt at the genocide of it's nation, goes on the offence to wipe Hamas out and prevent such a co-ordinated attack in the future. And YOU and many other people accuse Israel of genocide??? Are you NUTS?
Well done South Africa!🇵🇸🤝🇿🇦
Couldn't be bothered about the inevitable negative repercussions imposed on SA by Israel via their western allies as a result of this court case, because unlike the rest of the world, we aren't afraid to take action & speak up for the oppressed while the rest of the world watches a genocide occur before our very eyes & stay silent!
Yes we do not care what the world thinks, even take away you chain stores and we will create our own. US only have a big mouth, they cannot even take on Russia alone.
As a South African - I am so proud of my government. Viva South Africa Viva. Viva ANC Viva ❤❤❤
Salute South Africa🫡
They need South Africa more than South Africa needs them. Western companies stole mines and farm lands from SA that they stand to lose. Russia, Iran, Venezuela, Zimbabwe are still here
Public opinion side with Africa. ❤
AIPAC writes those speeches for John Kirby
If you think logically the US is the involved party in all these atrocities against innocent Palestinian, consequently the US has to defend the all predators.
So proud of my country!!! 🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Well you accept what's going on in the country.
75 people are murdered daily in South Africa.
No jobs, no electricity, corruption, Etc etc and you are a proud of the government that destroyed the country after 30 years.
And they still blame apartheid after 30 years because of their failure.
@tonythebomb4147 shame you Isreal supporters will say anything to distract your conscience and the world from the fact that isreal has literally slaughtered over 20 000 civilians, almost half of them all being children. Over 8000 children killed. Every country has its own domestic issues and SA is no exception, but that doesn’t mean our government must stay silent while the world sits back and watches a preventable genocide. But please tell yourself whatever you need to to sleep well at night! You’re gonna need those lies to comfort you when you finally face the fact that you traded your humanity to support a genocidal regime. All the best!
Am in South Africa and there is electricity, load shedding is just to cut electricity supply for two hours a day sometimes 4 hours depending on the place and area. As for unemployment, there is unemployment in your country too. Stop lying, the infrastructure you see in South Africa today, the stadiums, airports huge roads etc were built by this Black government, you are simply a jealous fool. Israeli satanic Zionists will be brought to justice.
@@tonythebomb4147i do applaud our government for taking a stand as the deaths in Gaza must stop but you right. We are the biggest hypocrites when you consider how we allow African dictators to murder hundreds of thousands to take power and also take them in when they deposed. Nevermind siding with Russia when we should condemn them.
@@tonythebomb4147 You are so evil. You don't know South Africa. Stop your highest level of stupidity talking about SA yet you don't know.
Of course because according to article 3 of geneva convention USA will be charged of complicity.
Oh my God, it's crazy disgusting how the avenger is responding
We are proud of South Africa for standing up against the synagogue of satan. Revelations 2 verse 9.
South Africa should talk about Genocide. 75 people are murdered daily in South Africa.
They should focus what they have destroyed in 30 years.
And they still blame apartheid.
Like Hamas corruption and the people continue to suffer.
Revelation 2:9 is Jesus talking to the church of Smyrna. Israel was cut off when they rejected Jesus and scattered but as Paul and Revelation says they will be saved. Romans 11:26. May Christ be with you brother
Stop the war, stop the genocide, stop the hatred,,, spread love and justice in free Palestine,,,,🕊🤲🙌✌💯❤
Agreed
😘
lots of respect for guest and host as well.
u.s from day one is not only bias crossing every limit of decency.
John Kirby - straight talking voice of reason
Well said
Stop the genocide in Gaza.
Tell Hamas to surrender.
@@tonythebomb4147so u can be the occ u pior
South Africa is our hero.
You have my respect, South Africa!!!!!!
What would John Kirby say if Israel was attacking the US in the same way?
Proud of you @South Africa. You're a true face of humanity.