@@pinkykamara3665 no, its so annoyong to see people calling soyeon an ace when the only ace is yuqi and possibly minnie. Soyeon cant do a vocal support meaning she isnt an ace
@@evertopia not being able to do vocal support doesn't make you a bad vocalist Minnie and soyeon is a good example of that as their vocals are beautiful even tho they don't have vocal support they know how to use their voices and what way is best to use it soyeon is the ace of gidle not only is she a better dancer and rapper she also have great stage presence the best in the group actually she also have a very unique voice very different from others she's also one of the best producer in kpop that's what you call an ace
@@pinkykamara3665 Still, of we talking multi abilities, minnie does a better job than soyeon. She doesnt have a good vocal meanwhile minnie is somewhat decent. She is able to do a little bit of everything, meanwhile soyeon is just focused on rap and dance. Altough no doubt she is greatly keeping the group going, and we all love her for that, but she doesnt have to be an all rounder to do that.
@@luhluhxraii Soyeon auditioned to be main vocalist though? Look at her solo stage in lion, she hit Minnie’s high notes. Sp is also soyeon, and soyeon has no issues with dancing. Rap is obviously soyeon. And it’s also who produces songs the most, it’s Soyeon. Soyeon literally made 97% of their discography… Ace means someone who can also compose, and produce music, not only what positions their good at. Get your facts right the next time you underestimate soyeon’s role in (g)-idle
In my opinion soyeon is more than ace, she did good at everything in this video, plus her producing music skills is no joke man, most idle songs is produced by her, her solo stuff since predebut, produce for other artists, when collaborating w other artists shes always take part in producing and make lyric too, and the most importan thing is she is the concept master of idle evwry comeback and performances, she did everythingg for her group since debut
That’s a good point, I feel like Yuqi is the better vocalist out of the 2. But they both have their strengths, but yeah I think this fact makes Soyeon the Ace.
Even if we take away all the other great things Soyeon does for the group, just singing, dancing, and rapping. She’s the ACE, of course the vocal line sings better but she’s a very proficient vocalist, after the departure of Soojin she’s first in stage presence and dancing. All that’s left is rapping, and she’s clearly number one there too. Yuqi is a great 2nd though, she’s actually really good at rapping, and she’s a monster performer. She just doesn’t trump Soyeon in dancing.
Idk, I think Shuhua's dancing is overall as good as Minnie. I'm not a professional dancer so I could be wrong. I also think Minnie's stage presence is usually as strong as Yuqi. It only gets a bit weak when the choreo gets more intense (like Tomboy and My Bag) but Gidle doesn't have a lot of hard choreos, so Minnie's stage presence is usually very strong. I also think Soyeon's singing is overall as good as Yuqi. They both have different strengths and weaknesses in singing. However, for some reasons, I often get bored listening to soyeon's solo singing, whereas I can repeat yuqi's solo songs a million times and never get bored. I'm not sure why. Yuqi's voice and the way she sings is just very captivating. Also, Yuqi's rap blew my mind. I would give her a 9.8 in rap, just because of that one verse in My Bag. She could be one of the best female rappers in kpop if she wants to, but she's probably still focusing on her singing and dancing.
I often get bored of yuqi Solo to be honest i have listened to it like three times and i just find it boring now I love her covers tho i don't really watch her fancams because i feel like she's not going to do anything exciting and am right most of the time but with soyeon i don't know what to expect and i love that she's sooo exciting to me so i guess we're opposite
Same tho, but i think even tho Yuqi have a good rapping tone and rapping skills, i still think that she won't really focus on rapping cause she's more into singing and Dancing
@@saeros9760 Nahh soyeon doesn’t have a vocal support which means all the notes she hits are either strained or just relaxed and tell me what soyeon can do that yuqi can’t do ?
@@Verowinday777 Lmao. So you want to compare each categories? When did Yuqi produced and wrote multiple chart topping songs? When did she came close to soyeon's rap? Or to Soyeon's stage presence? My dude, Soyeon is miles above everyone in anything but vocals.
Ridiculous, Soyeon's the best rapper (Gidle's only strong area) and dancer of the group by far, not to mention her stage presence. The fandom sadly hate her and call her ugly, so she'll never get the recognition she deserves
The main dancer is Yuqi, and I understood that not just "because". At first in lots of interview girls said that Yuqi the best one in remembering choreography, she even remember all other members chores and can mistakly start do fence them. The second, I know that there are lots of battles who is actually best dancer in technique. And it is Yuqi. Just watch their practise, Soyeon has very smooth movements, but they aren't strict and sharp, she always makes it a little bit inaccurate, then Yuqis movements always shurp and strict, but maybe not so smooth. So Soyeon is ACE, but her dancing isn't the best in group.
@@Solnyshko_652Yuqi is energetic, but she'd be the first one to point out that she's no dancer. Soyeon is definitely the only one with some proper training in that department.
the ace is definitely soyeon. this girl can sing, rap, dance, perform, write, compose and produce so well. she is literally carrying idle on her back at this point, she writes and produces most of their songs. stan soyeon!
no need to argue tho, this group is a powerhouse and realistic, they dont overuse highnotes that they cannot support, unlike other groups forcing highnotes and ended up lipsyncing, 😂
That's not what an Ace is in my opinion tho yuqi rapping is good i can't see my self watching her video that's like a Solo song and she's going to be rapping the whole time it wouldn't suit her yuqi is good vocalist that's the only thing i think she's better than soyeon in after soojin left soyeon is the best dancer in the group nothing is charging my mind i watched each of their fancams before coming to this decision even when soojin was there it was always soojin soyeon then yuqi now for the most important part stage presence you can love yuqi all you want just like me cause she's my bias wrecker but you cannot tell she has more stage presence then soyeon because you have to be either delusional or really bias towards yuqi am not angry or anything i just noticed that people always think that because soyeon get so many lines we should make her come no. 2 and that's ridiculous
@@pinkykamara3665 I don't think that "because Soyeon get so many lines we should make her come no.2". I like her too and I know she is the best rapper of the group and I'm agree with you that her dance is excellent. But I think that also Yuqi can rap very well, her stage presence is not bad and in my opinion her vocal is a little better than Soyeon. For the dance category, I think both are very good and both can be nominate as "main dancer" after Soojin left the group. But since I prefer Yuqi's dance style, I prefer her as a dancer. I am not saying that Soyeon is inferior or anything like that because for me both can easily be classified as an ACE, but just i said before, since I prefer Yuqi's dance and her vocal, in my opinion Yuqi is the ACE. This is nothing like official nomination, it's just what I think. I don't want to create hate and I respect your opinion.
first yuqi is a better vocalist,second she is a good rapper (at the same level with karina from aespa),third she is a good dancer,almost the same level as soyeon (the gap is minimal),fourth she can write and produce songs just like soyeon,while soyeon doesn’t really have vocal support so she can’t be considered as an ace,she has alot of control over her voice but her technique is not that good.
Gidle Vocal: 10/10 Rap :9/10( only soyeon can rap the fastest) Dance : 6/10 (sorry but their dance is weak ) Stage presence: 9/10 Overall : 34/40 They're so talented ❤
look being an ace doesn't mean that the can write song knows how to rap dance or whatever all of them are ace because according to what I said rap and so the all can do it the can write song and other stuff she has a reason y she made yuqi first u hv a reason why u made soyeon so pls respect her opinion for me is yuqi and for people is soyeon and her yuqi so respect it bto
have a good and low voice can make you good on rap...but not necessary make you a good rapper....that different thing... and have a power in dance not make you good dancer.... if you know...minnie was a best rapper among vocalist in her trainee era...
there are MANY things wrong with this video. first of all, the ratings arent fair at all. if yuqi is a 10 in dancing, then what is momo, a 1000? and the ranking isnt true at all imo. let me cook. 1) SOYEON - the ace vocal: 8/10 dance: 8,5/10 rap: 10/10 sp: 9,5/10 (here's the thing: soyeon is an ace because she is also a producer and songwriter. thats the difference between an all-rounder) 2) yuqi - all-rounder vocal: 8+/10 dance: 9/10 rap: 9/10 sp: 8/10 3) minnie vocal: 8,5/10 dance: 8/10 rap: 8,5/10 sp: 8,5/10 4) shuhua vocal: 6/10 (be fr rn. wdym 8.3 shu??) dance: 8-/10 rap: 8,5/10 sp: 9-/10 (imo!) 5) miyeon vocal: 9/10 dance: 7,5/10 rap: 8/10 sp: 8-/10 i'm a big neverland and i love every member equally. no hate to any of them and no hate to you.
People saying Soyeon is an ace because of her writing and producing but Yuqi also writes and produces. Obviously not as much as Soyeon. Her genre is different to the G(I)DLE vibe if I can even say so. Yuqi deserves her spot! Soyeon is the all-rounder.
@@Verowinday777 ik ik according to me she deserves more than 5, I like her singing I don't really care about tiers and all cuz only in k-pop I see it's use, no where else, so I just rank on control of voice cuz that's what I've been taught, so according to that she deserves more than 5 (my opinion)
![YUYEON being whipped to each other for 11 minutes #8 [Yuqi & Soyeon 2021 (G) i-DLE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AENrCTY3IKk/mqdefault.jpg)
![MISSING: SLIM SHADY [Expanded Mourner’s Edition Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xh8qgHrOO1g/mqdefault.jpg)
Yuqi and Soyeon are solid in everything, but I do think Soyeon is the Ace of the group cause she's also a songwriter and producer(really good one).
Soyeon is the Ace of the group people just find it hard to admit i mean she's good at everything
I agree
@@pinkykamara3665 no, its so annoyong to see people calling soyeon an ace when the only ace is yuqi and possibly minnie. Soyeon cant do a vocal support meaning she isnt an ace
@@evertopia not being able to do vocal support doesn't make you a bad vocalist Minnie and soyeon is a good example of that as their vocals are beautiful even tho they don't have vocal support they know how to use their voices and what way is best to use it soyeon is the ace of gidle not only is she a better dancer and rapper she also have great stage presence the best in the group actually she also have a very unique voice very different from others she's also one of the best producer in kpop that's what you call an ace
@@pinkykamara3665 Still, of we talking multi abilities, minnie does a better job than soyeon. She doesnt have a good vocal meanwhile minnie is somewhat decent. She is able to do a little bit of everything, meanwhile soyeon is just focused on rap and dance. Altough no doubt she is greatly keeping the group going, and we all love her for that, but she doesnt have to be an all rounder to do that.
Yuqi’s the all rounder, and soyeon is the ace:)
No yuqi is ace and soyeon is all rounder an all rounder is someone who can rap has good VOCals and sp and dance but is not to fluid with it
@@luhluhxraii Soyeon auditioned to be main vocalist though? Look at her solo stage in lion, she hit Minnie’s high notes. Sp is also soyeon, and soyeon has no issues with dancing. Rap is obviously soyeon. And it’s also who produces songs the most, it’s Soyeon. Soyeon literally made 97% of their discography… Ace means someone who can also compose, and produce music, not only what positions their good at. Get your facts right the next time you underestimate soyeon’s role in (g)-idle
no yuqi ace soyeon all rounder
@@bro_wh0-are-y bro, read my comment
Vice versa
The vocal of Soyeon is underrated😢
FR
Ikr😭😭
In my opinion soyeon is more than ace, she did good at everything in this video, plus her producing music skills is no joke man, most idle songs is produced by her, her solo stuff since predebut, produce for other artists, when collaborating w other artists shes always take part in producing and make lyric too, and the most importan thing is she is the concept master of idle evwry comeback and performances, she did everythingg for her group since debut
She loves calling "genius" by other people 😂😂 she is the mastermind tho.
Guys an ace is someone who can not only sing, dance and rap but someone who can write and produce their own music. That's soyeon.
But Yuqi Can Also Produce Songs
@@ReaverRBLX but soyeon has wrote 4 perfect all kills and many other hit songs
Even tho soyeon isn't my bias i Super Agree that she's the Ace Of Gidle Period.
in my opinion soyeon is the ace due to the fact that she wrote, produced, and arranged all of (G)-IDLE’s hits including “TOMBOY” and “MY BAG”
That’s a good point, I feel like Yuqi is the better vocalist out of the 2. But they both have their strengths, but yeah I think this fact makes Soyeon the Ace.
My opinion
1.So yeon
2.Yuqi
3.Minnie( shes also an actor which I love)
4.Shuhua
5.Mi yeon
Soyeon vocal is weak than others
@@Satt_AJSAt least she got the basics and vocal stability on stage
@@nate16254 I'm not saying she doesn't have vocal. I just said compared to others she is weak
☠️
@@user-xe6ys9xh3g ??
miyeon is full of vocal
Although I love Yuqi, I still think Soyeon is the ace of the group.
Even if we take away all the other great things Soyeon does for the group, just singing, dancing, and rapping. She’s the ACE, of course the vocal line sings better but she’s a very proficient vocalist, after the departure of Soojin she’s first in stage presence and dancing. All that’s left is rapping, and she’s clearly number one there too. Yuqi is a great 2nd though, she’s actually really good at rapping, and she’s a monster performer. She just doesn’t trump Soyeon in dancing.
All of them are Aces of the group💖
Soyeon's vocal is 9.9
The fact that they did this ranking on miyeon 10/19
Miyeon the vocal is 1000/10
Yuqi is my bias and I adore her but I couldn’t agree more that Soyeon is the Ace. She slays at everything and is a song writer.
They needed to add more points to miyeons vocals bc she broke the scale 😂
Miyeon vocal are 10/19😭😍🥰😇😊🙂🥲
Idk, I think Shuhua's dancing is overall as good as Minnie. I'm not a professional dancer so I could be wrong. I also think Minnie's stage presence is usually as strong as Yuqi. It only gets a bit weak when the choreo gets more intense (like Tomboy and My Bag) but Gidle doesn't have a lot of hard choreos, so Minnie's stage presence is usually very strong.
I also think Soyeon's singing is overall as good as Yuqi. They both have different strengths and weaknesses in singing. However, for some reasons, I often get bored listening to soyeon's solo singing, whereas I can repeat yuqi's solo songs a million times and never get bored. I'm not sure why. Yuqi's voice and the way she sings is just very captivating.
Also, Yuqi's rap blew my mind. I would give her a 9.8 in rap, just because of that one verse in My Bag. She could be one of the best female rappers in kpop if she wants to, but she's probably still focusing on her singing and dancing.
I often get bored of yuqi Solo to be honest i have listened to it like three times and i just find it boring now I love her covers tho i don't really watch her fancams because i feel like she's not going to do anything exciting and am right most of the time but with soyeon i don't know what to expect and i love that she's sooo exciting to me so i guess we're opposite
@@pinkykamara3665 well everyone has a different opinion and i think we should respect it
Same tho, but i think even tho Yuqi have a good rapping tone and rapping skills, i still think that she won't really focus on rapping cause she's more into singing and Dancing
@@o_o9220 i do respect their opinions am just sharing mine
Yea yuqi voice is good at rapping, and the way soyeon produced and wrote the lyric for my bag is really suited each member
Yuqi in that number one spot for a reason. Girl is the real ACE of G(I)DLE.
nope soyeon
Miyeon's vocal is 1000/10 . Her vocal color is so pleasing to the ears . She also has the widest vocal range in GIDLE .
Yuqi Have so Many Talents 😢 10/10
In my opinion soyeon is no.1 in everything yuqi coming no.2 Minnie no.3
Yuqi is probably no.1 because she can sing,rap,dance,produce and write
@@Verowinday777 You literally just described soyeon.
@@saeros9760 Nahh soyeon doesn’t have a vocal support which means all the notes she hits are either strained or just relaxed and tell me what soyeon can do that yuqi can’t do ?
@@Verowinday777 Lmao. So you want to compare each categories? When did Yuqi produced and wrote multiple chart topping songs? When did she came close to soyeon's rap? Or to Soyeon's stage presence? My dude, Soyeon is miles above everyone in anything but vocals.
@@Verowinday777 soyeon does all that as well
soyeon and yuqi are the aces of the group, miyeon and minnie are all rounders and shu is close to being an all rounder...
Soyeon is Ace❤
imo it's
1. Soyeon
2. Yuqi
3. Minnie
4. Miyeon
5. Shuhua
true
Yes it's true
Not true u r baised
@@redxcherry18 i said in my opinion 🤷🏻♂️ you can choose to agree or not to agree
@@redxcherry18 it's true why don't u think so
Yuqi(my bais❤)she is a all rounder and this is why she is the fotg
Soyeon should be first, she is a better rapper and dancer than yuqi (unbiased because yuqi is my bias)
Ridiculous, Soyeon's the best rapper (Gidle's only strong area) and dancer of the group by far, not to mention her stage presence. The fandom sadly hate her and call her ugly, so she'll never get the recognition she deserves
The main dancer is Yuqi, and I understood that not just "because". At first in lots of interview girls said that Yuqi the best one in remembering choreography, she even remember all other members chores and can mistakly start do fence them.
The second, I know that there are lots of battles who is actually best dancer in technique. And it is Yuqi. Just watch their practise, Soyeon has very smooth movements, but they aren't strict and sharp, she always makes it a little bit inaccurate, then Yuqis movements always shurp and strict, but maybe not so smooth. So Soyeon is ACE, but her dancing isn't the best in group.
@@Solnyshko_652Yuqi is energetic, but she'd be the first one to point out that she's no dancer. Soyeon is definitely the only one with some proper training in that department.
This is a group of all rounders ❤
the ace is definitely soyeon. this girl can sing, rap, dance, perform, write, compose and produce so well. she is literally carrying idle on her back at this point, she writes and produces most of their songs. stan soyeon!
I think that yuqi is slightly more well rounded however soyeon is still technically more ace because of her producing skills
And people still wonder why (G)I-dle are my ults😂❤
Soyeon is no.1 that was no doubt
For Soyeon in rap and Stage presence 11/10 let’s be real
Miyeon have a gold voice 🥇💗
MINNIE IS THE ACE
How you can put miyeon 10/19?! In vocals
Yugi is an all rounder and soyeon is an ace 😊
I like minnie
Every Member Is All Roundner
Ok but if soyeon’s vocals aren’t that good why did someone say to her that ”If rappers vocals are this good than what do the others do?”
Soyeon is the ace
theyre all so talented!!
Gurl soyeon should be the ace(no hate to yuqi I love her too)
Why is Miyeon rap so underrated
Yuqi and soyeon are best duo
Soyeon should higher than yuqi in vocals, she even always teach yuqi how to hit a note
Soyeon is the ace of idle and yuqi is an all-rounder
soyeon is the aceGET REALLLL
i think soyeon is no 1 and miyeon is definitely better than shuhua
no need to argue tho, this group is a powerhouse and realistic, they dont overuse highnotes that they cannot support, unlike other groups forcing highnotes and ended up lipsyncing, 😂
Shuhun is vocal 👏 and queen dance👑🔥✨
Vocal queen 😂😂😂
And Soojin:)
Vocal:8.5|10
Dance:10|10
Rap:9|10
Stage presence:9.6|10
Overal:9.4
so soojin would be 3rd?
Yuqi❤❤❤
Loooooooool
I agree with you. Yuqi is the ACE.
Soyeon deserve to be the ace too, but I prefer Yuqi for her amazing vocal, so In my opinion she's the ACE
That's not what an Ace is in my opinion tho yuqi rapping is good i can't see my self watching her video that's like a Solo song and she's going to be rapping the whole time it wouldn't suit her yuqi is good vocalist that's the only thing i think she's better than soyeon in after soojin left soyeon is the best dancer in the group nothing is charging my mind i watched each of their fancams before coming to this decision even when soojin was there it was always soojin soyeon then yuqi now for the most important part stage presence you can love yuqi all you want just like me cause she's my bias wrecker but you cannot tell she has more stage presence then soyeon because you have to be either delusional or really bias towards yuqi am not angry or anything i just noticed that people always think that because soyeon get so many lines we should make her come no. 2 and that's ridiculous
@@pinkykamara3665 I don't think that "because Soyeon get so many lines we should make her come no.2". I like her too and I know she is the best rapper of the group and I'm agree with you that her dance is excellent. But I think that also Yuqi can rap very well, her stage presence is not bad and in my opinion her vocal is a little better than Soyeon. For the dance category, I think both are very good and both can be nominate as "main dancer" after Soojin left the group. But since I prefer Yuqi's dance style, I prefer her as a dancer. I am not saying that Soyeon is inferior or anything like that because for me both can easily be classified as an ACE, but just i said before, since I prefer Yuqi's dance and her vocal, in my opinion Yuqi is the ACE.
This is nothing like official nomination, it's just what I think. I don't want to create hate and I respect your opinion.
@@rebe.v865 same
first yuqi is a better vocalist,second she is a good rapper (at the same level with karina from aespa),third she is a good dancer,almost the same level as soyeon (the gap is minimal),fourth she can write and produce songs just like soyeon,while soyeon doesn’t really have vocal support so she can’t be considered as an ace,she has alot of control over her voice but her technique is not that good.
Soyeon is ace and Yuqi is the all rounder
ranking
Vocal:
1. Miyeon (D)
2. Yuqi (E+)
3. Minnie (F+)
4. Soyeon/Shuhua (F)
Rap:
1. Soyeon
2. Yuqi
3. Minnie/Shuhua
4. Shuhua
5. Miyeon
Dance:
1. Soyeon (mid tier 6)
2. Yuqi (low tier 6)
3. Shuhua (high tier 7)
4. Minnie (mid tier 7)
5. Miyeon (mid tier 7)
Sp:
1. Soyeon
2. Yuqi
3. Minnie
4. Shuhua
5. Miyeon
In my opinion YUQI is no.1 in everything soyeon coming no.2 Minnie no.3
Miyeon ❤❤❤
Миен 10/19
Soyeons vocal are honestly a bit underrated. I mean have yall seen super lady??
This list is delusional……you all realised Miyeon is the MAIN vocalist right? She can’t be the last
Do a most liked.
1.Yuqi
2.So yeon
3.Miyeon
4.Shuhua
5.Minne
Miyeon is the bestt❤❤
Soyeon is lower than Yuqi when it comes to dance?? Lol she's the best dancer in (G)I-DLE even when Soojin was still there.
You did at vocal from miyeon 10/19 ?)
Gidle
Vocal: 10/10
Rap :9/10( only soyeon can rap the fastest)
Dance : 6/10 (sorry but their dance is weak )
Stage presence: 9/10
Overall : 34/40
They're so talented ❤
Idk why i read "g-idle RACE ranking"💀
Miyeon
Vocal: 10/10
Rap: 5/10
Dance: 7/10
Sp: 6/10
Overall: 28/40
Minnie
Vocal: 9/10
Rap: 7/10
Dance: 8/10
Sp: 8/10
Overall: 32/40
Soyeon
Vocal: 6/10
Rap: 10/10
Dance: 9/10
Sp: 9/10
Overall: 34/10
Yuqi
Vocal: 8/10
Rap: 8/10
Dance: 10/10
Sp: 9/10
Overall: 35/40
Shuhua
Vocal: 7/10
Rap: 6/10
Dance: 7/10
Sp: 7/10
Overall: 27/40
Ranking:
1. Yuqi
2. Soyeon
3. Minnie
4. Miyeon
5. Shuhua
Yuqi is my bias ❤❤❤❤❤
Minnie vocal 7/10
look being an ace doesn't mean that the can write song knows how to rap dance or whatever all of them are ace because according to what I said rap and so the all can do it the can write song and other stuff she has a reason y she made yuqi first u hv a reason why u made soyeon so pls respect her opinion for me is yuqi and for people is soyeon and her yuqi so respect it bto
Mine
Soyeon
Vocal:6/10
Rap:10/10
Dance:8/10
Stage presence:10/10
Overall:8,5/10
Soojin
Vocal:7/10
Rap:7/10
Dance:8,5/10
Stage presence:10/10
Overall:8,1/10
Yuqi
Vocal:8/10
Rap:7,5/10
Dance:7,5/10
Stage presence:9/10
Overall:8/10
Minnie
Vocal:7,5/10
Rap:6,5/10
Dance:7,5/10
Stage presence:9/10
Overall:7,6/10
Miyeon
Vocal:8,5/10
Rap:6/10
Dance:6,5/10
Stage presence:7,5/10
Overall:7,1/10
Shuhua
Vocal:4/10
Rap:4,5/10
Dance:6/10
Stage presence:8/10
Overall:5,6/10
totally agree👍
Agree, this video ranking too high 😑
Totally disagree
Pls guys i know she is kicked out but pls include soojin
have a good and low voice can make you good on rap...but not necessary make you a good rapper....that different thing...
and have a power in dance not make you good dancer....
if you know...minnie was a best rapper among vocalist in her trainee era...
Lmaooooo shuhua 8.3 vocals am I seeing this right
Shuhua 8.3 in vocals? Ummm...
She's my bias but i can't say that she pass the 6...
I agree with you, except Shuhua's ACE ranking
for me my minnie is 9/10 in rap!
there are MANY things wrong with this video.
first of all, the ratings arent fair at all. if yuqi is a 10 in dancing, then what is momo, a 1000?
and the ranking isnt true at all imo. let me cook.
1) SOYEON - the ace
vocal: 8/10
dance: 8,5/10
rap: 10/10
sp: 9,5/10
(here's the thing: soyeon is an ace because she is also a producer and songwriter. thats the difference between an all-rounder)
2) yuqi - all-rounder
vocal: 8+/10
dance: 9/10
rap: 9/10
sp: 8/10
3) minnie
vocal: 8,5/10
dance: 8/10
rap: 8,5/10
sp: 8,5/10
4) shuhua
vocal: 6/10 (be fr rn. wdym 8.3 shu??)
dance: 8-/10
rap: 8,5/10
sp: 9-/10 (imo!)
5) miyeon
vocal: 9/10
dance: 7,5/10
rap: 8/10
sp: 8-/10
i'm a big neverland and i love every member equally. no hate to any of them and no hate to you.
Yuqi my queen
People saying Soyeon is an ace because of her writing and producing but Yuqi also writes and produces. Obviously not as much as Soyeon. Her genre is different to the G(I)DLE vibe if I can even say so.
Yuqi deserves her spot!
Soyeon is the all-rounder.
Sorry but soyeon is no. 1
Soyeon is all rounder and yuqi is ace
Shuhua is last for sure. In vocals she deserves 2/10
Minnie's Vocal Should Be 9 She has Less Vocal Support Than Yuqi Thus She is The Third Best Vocal In The Group
i thinked we all knew Soyeon is G Idle´s Ace
my opinión
Soyeon
vocal: 6,5/10
rap: 10/10
dance: 8,5/10
stage presence: 10/10
Miyeon
vocal: 10/10
rap: 4/10
dance: 2,5/10
stage presence: 7/10
Minnie
vocal: 8,5
rap: 6,5/10
dance: 5/10
stage presence: 8/10
Soojin
vocal: 6,5/10
rap: 6/10
dance: 9/10
stage precense: 9,10
Yuqi
vocal: 8/10
rap: 8,5/10
dance: 8,5/10
stage presence: 9/10
Shuhua
vocal: 6/10
rap: 4,5/10
dance: 7,5/10
stage presence: 8/10
ovall:
soyeon 35
yuqi 34
Soojin 30,5
minnie 28
shuhua 26
miyeon 23,5
Soyeon vocal 2/10.
Soyeon vocal very weak only tier F/F+
@@Cecilioni261 super lady intro?
سوجين:
راب ١٠/١٠
رقص١٠/١٠٠٠٠
غناء١٠/١٠
جمال ١٠٠٠٠٠٠/١٠٠٠٠٠٠٠
حضور مسرحي احسن من وجهك
miyeon, vocal: 10/19
Wait what ? What are these notes ?! How Soyeon can have 8.7 in vocals for example?
Yeah she should have got 5
@@Verowinday777no no according to you soyeon should probably have 2 or smth
@@AshmitaPanja you are just being harsh 💀,she definitely deserves more than 2.
@@Verowinday777 ik ik according to me she deserves more than 5, I like her singing I don't really care about tiers and all cuz only in k-pop I see it's use, no where else, so I just rank on control of voice cuz that's what I've been taught, so according to that she deserves more than 5 (my opinion)
@@AshmitaPanja are you really arguing over this ? Bye lol I have better things to do.
1-soyeon
2-yuqi
3-minnie
4-miyeon
5-shuhus i think
Minnie getting 10/10 in vocals and yuqi not getting 10 is so funny, everyone knows Yuqi is a better vocalist than Minnie
now miyeon is at 3rd position with her wife rap
Miyeon😢
10/19😨
You hate Miyeon?
Soyeon is a better dancer than Yuqi. It's like a common knowledge
Minnie vocals 10/19?????wtf