I like them both, I cant pick just one. The Stanley is easier to drink from the SM straw has a odd suction imo. Both leak if tipped on the side. Maybe my SM has a bad lid but it leaks just as much when tipped but like you said it doesn’t bother me but they keep marketing it as spill proof and it is not.
I think both of them will leak when tipped. I also don't like that either of them try to claim to be spill proof because that's impossible with an uncovered straw. Not sure what they are thinking because we have eyes ha ha.
I love my simple modern and they don’t leak. The only leak I have would be if I tipped it on its side it’ll come out of the straw but not the cup. I have multiple simple, modern. I love them because they stay cold forever. And I have the large tumblers I don’t wanna carry around something that big with a handle and they come with both tops, a straw and a drink spout they give you two and then it comes with two straws. I love the colors I give them as gifts people love them, and they agree that they stay cold so long, I have two in the fridge at all times one with water and one with tea
most people online who have tried a Stanley cup (2.0) for the first time say almost the same thing. they dont perticually like the top and its not very leak proof.
Does the Stanley have a powder coating? I've had Yeti mugs for years and their powder coating has held up so well. I bought a Stanley tumbler (from Dicks) the other day and it looks like the color is just painted on. It this the way all of their tumblers are?
@@marypadron6186 thanks! I really like the look of the one I bought but I don't want the paint to chip off. I guess I'll have to exchange it for another one. I've had such good luck with the coating that the yetis have. I've had some tumblers for 6+ years and only now do I see the faintest scratch.
If you're looking for something that doesn't leak, I would recommend neither. They both will leak. And I don't know that it's feasible to drink from the Simply Modern without the straw very easily.
I have a Stanley. im always on the go with my kids in sports i hate my Stanley now it leaks so much. not only from the straw area which u would expect but the rim part the most. I need a good cup with straw with minor leak if tip over.
The simply modern seems like the better of the two but when looking more into them 2 features that arent there on SM is you cant drink hot drinks with the straw and theres no extra hole to drink out of so its really only good for cold drinks
It seems Simple Modern beats Stanley in the "cold" tests but no one has done the "hot" test. It appears the lid is better insulated on the Simple Modern vs the Stanley. The real test should have been done without a straw in each. If keeping liquids cold then Simple Modern wins, but if you also need to consider the drop test, does it rust?, spill test, warranty, and clean test.
Good attempt at trying to be scientific. LOL!! Glad you measured the ice but you didn't measure the water in the container. Should have been the same as more water means more melting. Then you need to open the lid only once at 24+ hours and not a seconder sooner as that lets in heat which will skew the results... Just my humble opinion to get an accurate result.
They are all supposed to be 40 oz so in theory they "should" be pretty close to the same amount of water. That doesn't mean that they actually are in reality lol. I def did not adhere to the scientific method with this one so take everything with a grain of salt. They are both great at keeping water cold so I don't think it really makes much difference either way.
@@SamisSweetLife You’re right, it basically doesn’t matter one little bit. It’s just 1 titre of water, so as long as the cup holds ice well for 6-12 hours, that’s more than enough time to finish drinking the contents and refill, considering people need 2-3 litres of water a day.
Wow! The review I’ve been looking for! Thank you for weighing the ice properly! This helped me make my decision. 👍 👏
Thank you so much for stopping by! So glad you enjoyed it.
Loved the way you compared the cups! Great video!
Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Nice ordered diffrent brand in barath
I like them both, I cant pick just one. The Stanley is easier to drink from the SM straw has a odd suction imo. Both leak if tipped on the side. Maybe my SM has a bad lid but it leaks just as much when tipped but like you said it doesn’t bother me but they keep marketing it as spill proof and it is not.
I think both of them will leak when tipped. I also don't like that either of them try to claim to be spill proof because that's impossible with an uncovered straw. Not sure what they are thinking because we have eyes ha ha.
Try inserting the straw from under the lid instead of through the top to help with the suction on the SM one. If that makes sense.
I love my simple modern and they don’t leak. The only leak I have would be if I tipped it on its side it’ll come out of the straw but not the cup. I have multiple simple, modern. I love them because they stay cold forever. And I have the large tumblers I don’t wanna carry around something that big with a handle and they come with both tops, a straw and a drink spout they give you two and then it comes with two straws. I love the colors I give them as gifts people love them, and they agree that they stay cold so long, I have two in the fridge at all times one with water and one with tea
Great review! Thank you for sharing. 😁
They are both really great! Glad you enjoyed it.
simple modern has a better lid
most people online who have tried a Stanley cup (2.0)
for the first time say almost the same thing. they dont
perticually like the top and its not very leak proof.
Yeah, all great points. I don't find it an improvement at all.
Thanks for your video !
Glad you enjoyed it! I appreciate you stopping by.
Does the Stanley have a powder coating? I've had Yeti mugs for years and their powder coating has held up so well. I bought a Stanley tumbler (from Dicks) the other day and it looks like the color is just painted on. It this the way all of their tumblers are?
There’s both types available
@@marypadron6186 thanks! I really like the look of the one I bought but I don't want the paint to chip off. I guess I'll have to exchange it for another one. I've had such good luck with the coating that the yetis have. I've had some tumblers for 6+ years and only now do I see the faintest scratch.
great video, really helpful
Thank you so much! Glad you found it helpful.
Great review but which one leaks more because it looks like the simply has suction if taken straw out
If you're looking for something that doesn't leak, I would recommend neither. They both will leak. And I don't know that it's feasible to drink from the Simply Modern without the straw very easily.
I have a Stanley. im always on the go with my kids in sports i hate my Stanley now it leaks so much. not only from the straw area which u would expect but the rim part the most. I need a good cup with straw with minor leak if tip over.
The simply modern seems like the better of the two but when looking more into them 2 features that arent there on SM is you cant drink hot drinks with the straw and theres no extra hole to drink out of so its really only good for cold drinks
Great point! I didn't really think about that.
Metal straws can be used
Simple Modern comes with two lids
Does the SM lid fit on the Stanley cup? I have a Stanley cup and was going to order the SM lid from Amazon.
No they don''t fit each other unfortunately.
Giiiiirl!!! The simple modern pink with blue is my dream! Would you sell your extra to me? Haha 🥺
Amazing review! ❤
I'm sorry I am not selling them for now.
simple modern leaks less
It seems Simple Modern beats Stanley in the "cold" tests but no one has done the "hot" test.
It appears the lid is better insulated on the Simple Modern vs the Stanley. The real test should have been done without a straw in each.
If keeping liquids cold then Simple Modern wins, but if you also need to consider the drop test, does it rust?, spill test, warranty, and clean test.
Good attempt at trying to be scientific. LOL!!
Glad you measured the ice but you didn't measure the water in the container. Should have been the same as more water means more melting.
Then you need to open the lid only once at 24+ hours and not a seconder sooner as that lets in heat which will skew the results...
Just my humble opinion to get an accurate result.
They are all supposed to be 40 oz so in theory they "should" be pretty close to the same amount of water. That doesn't mean that they actually are in reality lol. I def did not adhere to the scientific method with this one so take everything with a grain of salt. They are both great at keeping water cold so I don't think it really makes much difference either way.
@@SamisSweetLife You’re right, it basically doesn’t matter one little bit. It’s just 1 titre of water, so as long as the cup holds ice well for 6-12 hours, that’s more than enough time to finish drinking the contents and refill, considering people need 2-3 litres of water a day.