Even though quality cannot be defined, I know what quality is whenever I watch these great lectures from our GREAT HERO, J. K. ROBERGE. Thank you, sir!!
An excellent teacher, he could explain complex and unusual and counter-intuitive things with simplicity and clarity so that anyone could understand. I was luck I got a copy of his precious books. We are lucky we have these videos. I hope he didn't suffer, he will be in paradise now,. Thank you Professor Roberge, we learnt a lot and we are indebted to you.
They sure put in a lot more effort in creating opencourseware at MIT in 1985 than they do now... This is better than the average newer courseware lectures. This is indeed "produced" and a well thought-through production - clearly polished and edited to be delivered in video format-- this is not just a captured live lecture. MIT'ers were youtubers "avant la lettre"! Impressive man, by the way, he radiates dignity and authority. (In other words he looks more like a US president than most real US presidents!)
I struggled with control feedback systems, how prof Roberge shows comparison of circuit diagram with a block diagram gets me thinking how did I miss that. James will live forever.
Thank you MIT for making it possible to learn from the best for free. Will you be uploading the Modern Control Theory Course which Prof. Roberge mentions in this video?
Please fix the link to the complete course in the description, as it is not working. thank you MIT for your great effort in providing free excellent education to the world.
+ibrahim osamaa The version that we have on MIT OpenCourseWare was taught in Spring 2007. See the course on MIT OCW for more details: ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-computer-science/6-302-feedback-systems-spring-2007/
Scaling a circuit parameter (resistance) to get an open-loop system with the same voltage transfer function as a closed-loop system seems like a math hack.
Uh, what? This stuff is foundational and has not changed for about 8 decades now. Laws of physics haven’t changed, the systems being analyzed have not changed. The classical theory works quite well with a large group of everyday systems.
Still, it’s a solid foundation and a lot of analysis can be done using it. More advanced techniques also take more effrontery if you want to go pen and paper route.
Professor Roberge taught my father, and now thanks to RUclips, I get to learn from him as well. I love it!
Even though quality cannot be defined, I know what quality is whenever I watch these great lectures from our GREAT HERO, J. K. ROBERGE. Thank you, sir!!
Sadly, Professor James K. Roberge passed away on Friday, January 10 2014. RIP.
+smlbstcbr sad！ how brilliant he was
An excellent teacher, he could explain complex and unusual and counter-intuitive things with simplicity and clarity so that anyone could understand. I was luck I got a copy of his precious books.
We are lucky we have these videos.
I hope he didn't suffer, he will be in paradise now,.
Thank you Professor Roberge, we learnt a lot and we are indebted to you.
RIP
Great Respect to Prof. James from India !
Love you :(
If you really understand the concepts he are talking about you truly understand how good this lecture is
In love memory of such a great man.
They sure put in a lot more effort in creating opencourseware at MIT in 1985 than they do now... This is better than the average newer courseware lectures. This is indeed "produced" and a well thought-through production - clearly polished and edited to be delivered in video format-- this is not just a captured live lecture. MIT'ers were youtubers "avant la lettre"! Impressive man, by the way, he radiates dignity and authority. (In other words he looks more like a US president than most real US presidents!)
Great comment.
@@arnoldbr8418 Thanks, appreciated.
I struggled with control feedback systems, how prof Roberge shows comparison of circuit diagram with a block diagram gets me thinking how did I miss that. James will live forever.
A very good intro to the topic of classic control systems as it relates to operational amplifiers - nicely done!
R.I.P Professor James K. Roberge you were a very smart man
Thank you MIT for making it possible to learn from the best for free.
Will you be uploading the Modern Control Theory Course which Prof. Roberge mentions in this video?
Great! An inspiring lecture indeed with a strong grounding of the basic principles. Many thanks.
Note that the textbook to which Prof. Roberge refers is available online (see "View the complete course" just below the video)
rest in peace,
through these lectures he will always be with us guiding us
why should we got to uni and keep listening to bulshit every day while you can get high quality education thru youtube . you are a life saver
What if its a good uni?
Please fix the link to the complete course in the description, as it is not working.
thank you MIT for your great effort in providing free excellent education to the world.
Excellent lecturer. A great loss.
your lecture change my whole life!
+suneel arya why ?
why?
why?
why
He looks and sounds like mythical Americans from the 50s.
This is a great upload thank you.
I study Mechanical Engineering and I take this lecture included
If shunts and series feedback isn't a good approach to feedback, then how do you analyze a transistor feedback circuit?
Thank You Ashu Jangra Sir for suggesting him :)
in which semester is this content taught? thanks
+ibrahim osamaa The version that we have on MIT OpenCourseWare was taught in Spring 2007. See the course on MIT OCW for more details: ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-computer-science/6-302-feedback-systems-spring-2007/
@@mitocw Hi, could you publish "Modern control theory " lectures?
Scaling a circuit parameter (resistance) to get an open-loop system with the same voltage transfer function as a closed-loop system seems like a math hack.
Lots of such math hacks are necessary to ease analysis done without digital computers/SPICE. They are practical hacks.
Knowing almost nothing about the field, is this series still relevant?
Yeah
The principles discussed are certainly relevant
What has changed is matlab
I like this lecture
I have a better perspective on amplifiers, feedback loops, and desensitivity.
why does the intro go so hard
Don't know what he's saying but i have to try anyway.
But it won't get you a job unless you pay for it and get credit and a degree for it. That's what I did and I got jobs.
I don't know if this is helpful or not as it is heavily outdated.
Uh, what? This stuff is foundational and has not changed for about 8 decades now. Laws of physics haven’t changed, the systems being analyzed have not changed. The classical theory works quite well with a large group of everyday systems.
why should we got to uni while we can get high quality education thru youtube?
Tommy Lee Jones!!!!
Very basic by today’s standards.
Still, it’s a solid foundation and a lot of analysis can be done using it. More advanced techniques also take more effrontery if you want to go pen and paper route.
or just lie on your cv as longas you know the stuff ;)