For real. Younha's mixed voice is absolutely insane. Luna probably wins when it comes to head voice and Joohyun when it comes to lower register I think.
i dont really care for supported range they have from kpopvocalanalysis, something that i really care is Ock joohyun is solid singer. She has power, resonance, head voice and rich quality sound. For me Ock joohyun is better comparing two other.
I'm disappointed ,you're just watching my videos now? LoL ruclips.net/video/FpoNb5ytIXs/видео.html girl lost her confidence after her 5 years break, that open throat and brightness have left the chat
While I enjoy Younha's tone a lot more and she wins in this video, I have to admit that Luna is technically by far way ahead. Technique overall I mean.
Well yeah, Luna has a better developed lower register and a very well developed head voice. Younha never really used her head voice all that much and her lower register was incredibly weak unfortunately. :< I know that Younha used to support her mixed voice all the way up to E5/F5, which isn't the case anymore I believe. And Luna's all the way up to Eb5 with some incredible E5's.
nearly two years after ... edgar is commenting i honestly don't care they harmonizing on different notes i thought luna was with ailee but the purposes of the video was the Bb4 - Eb5 range honestly , i almost stopped there
SOme may don't agree with that but for Me OCK is more consistent on her mix than luna ; OCK struggles with vowels sometimes but she got more good moments on Eb5s and E5s than luna especially phrasing ... Luna lack resonance at times she also struggles with placement , I tend to Make extra LONG Videos Like u can see lol
@@benjaminsotocornejo3653 I mean the video speak for itself Ock/Yeonji can pretty much dominate Bb4-Eb5 and let no body breath with their depth and technique but Younha and Haeri take the cake above ....when it get to a certain point it about how how more brightness and ease to get above Eb5 ish
Younha won, she has more resonance , a better projection and her supported range is the highest.
For real. Younha's mixed voice is absolutely insane. Luna probably wins when it comes to head voice and Joohyun when it comes to lower register I think.
Thanks for including Younha
thank you for watching and commenting
no problem! You def put quite a lot of effort here >_
Honestly all tied for me they’re all amazing but Ock really impressed me she’s so underrated omg and her headvoice is godly!!!
루나 G3 ~ D5/Eb5 ~ Bb5
옥주현 F3/F#3 ~ D5/Eb5 ~ F#5
윤하 A3/Bb3 ~ E5/F5 ~ Eb5
정리하자면 루나는 헤드보이스, 옥주현은 저음, 윤하는 진성 고음이 제일 뛰어남
Some of these Luna clips.. Younha wins.
i dont really care for supported range they have from kpopvocalanalysis, something that i really care is Ock joohyun is solid singer. She has power, resonance, head voice and rich quality sound. For me Ock joohyun is better comparing two other.
윤하,루나 다 잘하지만 옥주현을 저기 끼워놓는건....이미 라이선스 뮤지컬할때마다 월드클래스 평가 받는분인데...
윤하 사랑합니다..
물론 윤하 루나도 꽤나 탑클래스지만 옥주현은 저 정도에 비교될 수준은 이미 넘고도 넘음 ㅋㅋ 엘리자베스 월드 컴필에 초대되고 대학교에서 교수생활까지 하면서 뮤지컬이 수입되면 무조건 옥주현이 1순위인데 저기 낄 급은 아닌듯
조성철 목청 정말 대단하죠. 근데 가요 부르면 밋밋하다는거랑 진성 음역에 비해서 두성 음역 좁은게 흠인거 같아요.
kevin good 소향만하겠어요 ㅋ 걘 ccm만 불러야댐
kevin good 그리고 옥주현 도샾까지 올라가는데 뭔 두성영역이 좁음 ㅋㅋ
Thank you for this
Esra Turgut thanks for watching , it nice to see some appreciation
BAZISSINO 94 ❤❤❤
옥주현이 고음만 잘 지르는 가수가 아니라 저음도 완벽하지
국내 여자가수중 저음은 짱일듯
박동녘 인정이여-^^ 옥주현은 저음이 진짜 타고났는데ㅡ사람들 잘 모르는거 같아요
마지막 윤하 3옥솔아니고 정확하게 3옥라(A5)입니다.ㅠ
아니, 내가 다른 G5를 필요로한다는 것을 알지 못한다. 나는 그 중 하나를 강조했다 .... 그녀는 A5 전에 하나를 쳤다.
그건 맞는데 그 전에 3옥솔도 냈어요
Younha 🤩
루나가 생각보다 더 잘하네 옥주현 성량은 정말 미쳤고 윤하는 음색이 너무 내스탈 이야 ㅋㅋ 다 좋아
마침내, 그들 중 3 분께 좋은 코멘트를 주셔서 감사합니다 🙏🙌
오리콘의 혜성 !!!
물론 다 노래는 잘 부르지만 옥주현이랑은 비교대상이 되는가 ......
윤하 완전팬인데 ㅋㅋ
다좋아욥~
보고 주셔서 감사합니다 ~
Also, Younha's been pretty inactive lately, but I found this "Shower" jewel! /watch?v=MQsGlJR1dQA
윤하💕
Ock Joo Hyun~
갠적으로 윤하가 제일 깔끔하고 듣기편해요
2:17 yes
3:43
4:14
4:24 wheww
6:11
8:39 slayage!
SO ock hasn't impressed you on a single note lol ?
love this! Sad that YounHa seems to have regressed lately :(
I'm disappointed ,you're just watching my videos now? LoL ruclips.net/video/FpoNb5ytIXs/видео.html girl lost her confidence after her 5 years break, that open throat and brightness have left the chat
@@jinji4609 no it actually tight
She didn't. It's fact that her vocal cords become tired easily
윤하 언니 사랑해요! (주현님이 조금 더 잘하시지만 윤하언니 최고에요)
mixed register ?
I prefer :
JooHyun>Luna/Younha
옥주현은 여기에 비교할 클래스는 아닌듯 한 3급은 높아보임
옥주현>>>넘사벽>>>윤하>>>>넘사벽>>루나
같은음이라도 옥주현은 이상하게 낮고 편하게들림 ㅋㅋㅋ
ᄇᄋᄋ 같은 소프라노인데 타입이 달라서 그래요
Yeah OcK is a full lyric soprano when younha and luna are light lyric
@@BAZVOCALS if u don't mind ,can you explain what could be distinted from 2 each type of soprano? i'm not good at english 😂 i am sorry
마지막 3옥 라 아닌가요? 제가 잘못알고 있는건가
역시 옥주현이지 ~ 가창력도 고음도 ~
고음은 잘 낼 수는 있는데 옥주현처럼 성량이 가득찬 고음은 본적이 없습니다
6:28 윤하가 부르는 노래 제목이 뭐죠..??
i dont care요
아니 옥주현을 어디다가 누구랑 비교하는거지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 비교자체가 안될텐데 ㅋㅋㅋ
비교하는 자체가 바보짓임 답은 나와있는데
각자 팬들 자기 가수가 잘한다고 난리. 그냥 취향차이임.
내가 윤하팬인데 옥주현은 넘사야..
넘사 까지는 아닌듯.. 잘하는 장르도 다르고.
윤하,루나는 3옥솔에서 두성 비율이 높은데 옥주현은 거의 흉성 비율이 높네요 ㅋ
옥주현이 여기 왜낀건지 이해가 전혀안됨 뮤지컬 원탑을 ㅋㅋㅋㄱㄱ
While I enjoy Younha's tone a lot more and she wins in this video, I have to admit that Luna is technically by far way ahead. Technique overall I mean.
@@qlimax95 when younha was at her peak ? U think luna is above her?How ?
Well yeah, Luna has a better developed lower register and a very well developed head voice. Younha never really used her head voice all that much and her lower register was incredibly weak unfortunately. :< I know that Younha used to support her mixed voice all the way up to E5/F5, which isn't the case anymore I believe. And Luna's all the way up to Eb5 with some incredible E5's.
Luna hit A5 in the Greatest Showman music video.
sensation won but it was throaty.
Luna's G5 is actually Ailee
nearly two years after ... edgar is commenting i honestly don't care they harmonizing on different notes i thought luna was with ailee but the purposes of the video was the Bb4 - Eb5 range honestly , i almost stopped there
옥주현은.....굳이 비교하자면 루나
Luna 💜
that G5 belongs to Ailee not Luna. lol
윤하 클립이 제일 긴 것 같다...
난윤하~한표 ㅎㅎ
8:47옥주현 고음 지려따
다들 노래 잘하긴하지만,, 옥주현이 이거보면 약간 빈정상할 거 같다..
여기서 루나가 명함을 내밀 수가 있나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
내밀 수 있죠
영상 너무 정신없게 편집해서 뭘보는지도 모르겠다
윤하 승임 가창력이라는 넓은 의미에서 제일 듣기 좋음 옥주현이 그동안 쌓아온 경력이나 위치 알겠으나 너무 신격화하네
갠적 생각이시네
옥주현이 신격화 라니 .....
This battle is not fair Ock Joo Hyun is Mezzo not Soprano
Gurl bye 💀
다 집어 치우고 젤 듣기 좋은건 윤하 노래가 제일 좋은것도 윤하 ㅂㅂㅂㄱ
다 잘하시지만... 옥주현씨는 비교에 어울리지 않은 것 같아용ㅠㅠ
갓루나ㅠ
년차 없이 같의 나이로 비교하는 것도 아니고.
Youhna>Ock Joohyun=Luna (Also i appreciate how you dont use the obvious notes used 100 times before which i see in many chanels)
SOme may don't agree with that but for Me OCK is more consistent on her mix than luna ; OCK struggles with vowels sometimes but she got more good moments on Eb5s and E5s than luna especially phrasing ... Luna lack resonance at times she also struggles with placement , I tend to Make extra LONG Videos Like u can see lol
BAZISSINO 94
I dont know lunas E5s in nu abo are some of my faves
Danger(Pinochio)**
u mean nu abo ... there"s only D5s F5 and sustained Eb5 ...NO E5 ?!
BAZISSINO 94
I confused "danger" with nu abo
ruclips.net/video/uOx0Leu8ajQ/видео.html 3:14
im stupid
IT OK :D
윤하오 옥주현 만큼은 아니지만 진짜 그에 비빌만한 가창력인데 댓글 뭔데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 개웃기네 무슨 숭배함?
화학충 존나웃김 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ무슨 숭배정도까지 하냐 ㄹㅇ 존나빨아재끼네
고음만 따지면 옥주현이라 할 수도 있겠으나 가창력을 본다면 윤하가 한수위지
솔까 윤하가 이긴거아니냐 영상만보면ㅋㅋㅋ
뭘 자꾸 옥주현이랑 비교할 클래스가 아니래 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 제목그대로 그냥 고음배틀이구만
루나랑 윤하말고 차라리 이영현 바다 넣지
셋이 제일 기량이 비슷해서 그래요 넣을 수 있다면 김연지도 가능
@@harrykim5391 ??????? 옥주현이랑 루나랑 윤하 기량이 제일 비슷하다고??????
Are you serious ? Ock Joo Huyn slays both of those girls
Technically, Younha is the best
@@benjaminsotocornejo3653 I mean the video speak for itself Ock/Yeonji can pretty much dominate Bb4-Eb5 and let no body breath with their depth and technique but Younha and Haeri take the cake above ....when it get to a certain point it about how how more brightness and ease to get above Eb5 ish
@@BAZVOCALS haeri is not here lol
@@benjaminsotocornejo3653 no bc I mentioned yeonji :3 so I had to mention haeri
@@BAZVOCALS oh got it lol sorry