Agree completely. Hollywood used to make such good movies! Now its just absolute garbage and filth. Braveheart, Shawshank Redemption, Blood Diamond etc.
@Sudden Arrival lmao. Because your interpretation of art is different than mine, you're right and I'm wrong?? Its a movie about faith. Not Christianity. Your reply is why people dont take Christians seriously anymore. Its about God. There are many Gods in religion. Your arrogance is why you see it as a Christian movie
@Sudden Arrival you're ignorant and insecure. Your comment was irrelevant drivel... I didnt report it because i dont give a shit about your opinion. Go be gay somewhere else
Unbelievable. You don't get scenes of this power in Hollywood anymore. Hollywood needs an artistically free Night back. However, i want Night to ditch Hollywood and go independent, so that we can get his art completely unfiltered.
There was a time when M Night was making gems. This is one. The music in this scene is fabulous. James Newton Howard is up there with the best of them.
This scene was lost on me as a kid but re-watching Signs the other day, it's easily now my favourite. The camera shots on the torches, the music, and then that monologue, just blew me away.
Makes me cry everytime): So sweet. Love how it goes from horrifying to a brief moment of comic relief, then horrifying again, then something sad and touching like this. Brilliant
I don't give a shit about what anybody says, Mel Gibson is an AMAZING fucking actor. This scene like so many others of his brought fucking tears to my eyes.
Anyone else love the morning after this. *checks baby monitor* 0.7 seconds of silence "That's good enough for me" "Me too" *proceeds to go open the door*
+Dillon ferko (Shamrock69) , the aliens in this movie are from a certain point of view demons, who threaten his family. It's about his religious battle how he loses God and through this experience he finds him again. But also HAHAHAH yes they should've waited a bit longer before going up.
Great performance in this movie. Very moving and intense, especially this scene. Just a note: if you're ever helping someone with an asthma attack, it's usually easier to breathe if they're leaning forward instead of lying back.
I cried wen I watched this. Both my parents died from asthma and I am now in care. My asthma is really bad sometimes and I hav been 2 hospital 20 times it is not fair. The doctors say I hav a 90%chance of dying by the time I am 15. I am 13.
That's actually Macaulay Culkin's (Home Alone) brother, Rory Culkin. They all come from a family of theatre actors so it's no surprise how talented he is even at this age.
Rory Culkin played Euronymous in Lords Of Chaos (the movie about the infamous Norwegian black metal band Mayhem), and he was also in Scream 4. I've honestly only ever seen him in darker "horror" films, but he's a great actor regardless, and he also happens to be the little brother of Macaulay (Kevin from Home Alone) and Kieran (Kevin's cousin on Home Alone)
Magnificent, stunning attention to detail in this scene, as in so many in the film. God acts through Graham, who uses spiritual words even as he expresses his outward hatred for God. Merrill prays but can't do anything else. The sister has already dreamed of this outcome. So much meaning - injected by the Holy Spirit into M. Night Shyamalan's amazing film-making. The film "Signs" offers signs to all of us out in the audience, and that is why there has rarely if ever been a movie like it.
But Merrill piles up the "special meal" made by the company Joy. Do you not see? He has his spiritual food, and even as his brother is struggling, cursing God and trying to save his son through humanist means, the brother is praying to God, while the girl Bo is still in her angel costume and is proven able to convert water in such a way that her pure goodness sanctifies it to burn the demon-aliens. And as the music changes imperceptibly we realise God is not far away at all... which He really isn't! Then Merrill (seemingly) refers to saving the Flashlight, but he is actually referencing the saving of the enlightenment they have received!
i have asthma but my parents don't believe it and i don't have an inhaler so I have to pray during mine in order for me to know that I will live. Anyone going through what I am.
You understand that there may be "signs" in this scene that even the genius makers may not realise? [the dog food for a start - cute name, wouldn't you say?] [The tear in Joaquin's eye at 01:30] Of course a movie about signs (made to restore some faith and hope after 9/11) would receive the active involvement of the Holy Spirit. Human genius is wondrous, but here it is raised beyond, as we are close to perfection. Human beings alone cannot do that, but with God nothing is impossible. And the Holy Spirit is indeed ACTIVE in promoting Discipleship. He's here with us in this world, and wants to be inside each of us if we give Him a chance. I did.
Riveting scene that moves anyone to tears if you analyze it closely. Another great scene from this film is when Joaquin's character calmly lashes out on Mel's character for this--not because he was being a responsible dad, but because he showed his weakness when he let his faith falter for a moment or so.
this is SO sad ): poor little boy... poor everyone with asthma! ): i dont have it but i feel REALLY bad for all of you who do x( it makes me really appreciate my health
Painful, back muscles are tight & locked up from the effort to get air. Airways are painfully constricted & you have to concentrate on getting little gasps in. Leaning forward or lying on your side is better positioning for opening airways. NOT having a grown mans big hand on your chest while you struggle is preferable!!
so no one is noticing the bruising on Mels neck and the alien grabbing the son in the same spot of his, then Mel says towards end of scene "We're the same".....hmmmm
What he meant by "we're the same" was that he and his son are one is the same as they took deep breaths to not worry his son about feeling negatively about him
It literally feels like that. You hold with the tightest grip ever to whatever is near. I dont know why but you do. You freak out so much and it doesn't help.
On previous viewings, when Graham is cradling Morgan and says, “I hate you”, I assumed he was talking to Morgan, to help Morgan stay alive by using Morgan’s own words against him. Now I realize that Graham is actually expressing his hatred for God in that moment, fearful that God will take another of his loved ones. Hence why he says, “Don’t do this to me again. Not again. I hate you.”
@@alifakhrzadeh1544the film is a sign about how the Holy Spirit uses signs to reveal God's love, care and mercy. On the basis of all divine things having meaning, value and purpose, and just "adding up". As any Born-Again like myself will tell you ... it ... is ... all ... true! I know, I see (at least a bit). With the Holy Spirit, things make sense. He is love and TRUTH. Jesus, whom He reveals, is the way, the truth and the life...
Well I stand by both my statements and Rob Jackson it’s like I said earlier there’s overdramatic elements that make it silly a little like Scream with satires however this movie’s humor is dry like scotch while Scream is whisky with more flavor. You may ask then what is the point about joking about God well some people find it silly because he can be a fictional character or some believe but hate his hypocritical views
I have bronchitis problem and I had crises often. I love this movie and I really identify with this scene, because it's almost the same thing ... I'm from Brazil!
I haven't watched this movie since it first came out about 20 years ago. At the time, it was just some average UFO/alien movie to me and nothing more. I just rewatched it again and I can honestly say this movie has hit me so much harder this time around. I have 2 children of my own now... as a parent, this scene was extremely heartbreaking to watch. It's amazing how our views on movies and how they make us feel can change so much over time. I need to rewatch some more classic M. Night Shyamalan movies now!
This time you get more of the Holy Spirit who is in the movie, with it, and emanating out of it. You find it when you need it. [We all need it] Probably you know that Shyamalan wanted the movie to act as some kind of balm for people after the evil of 9/11 - which happened at the very start of their filming. How could the Holy Spirit NOT get behind something like that, which is anyway a movie about lapsed faith, the return to faith, and the way in which the enigmatic Holy Spirit even achieves His purposes for Father and Son through things that seem trivial or awful or ridiculous? With Him things just add up, within the movie but also beyond it.
Me too. You understand that there may be "signs" in this scene that even the genius makers may not realise? [the dog food for a start - cute name, wouldn't you say?] [The tear in Joaquin's eye at 01:30] Of course a movie about signs (made to restore some faith and hope after 9/11) would receive the active involvement of the Holy Spirit. Human genius is wondrous, but here it is raised beyond, as we are close to perfection. Human beings alone cannot do that, but with God nothing is impossible. And the Holy Spirit is indeed ACTIVE. He's here with us in this world, and wants to be inside each of us if we give Him a chance. I did.
@MathyPure same here. i'm sixteen now tho. instead of using ventolin everyday tho, there is advir... it prevents attacks from happening thoughout the day...thou of course, sometimes u will still need the ventolin (rescue in haler)
@XxSteevo93xX He's talking to god, not to his son, when he says I hate you, and don't do this to me again, that sort of thing. He's talking about how his wife was killed already and he doesn't want to lose his son too.
Signs is one of the best but underrated movies ever
Agree completely. Hollywood used to make such good movies! Now its just absolute garbage and filth. Braveheart, Shawshank Redemption, Blood Diamond etc.
What is the name of the film
@@hajarmoussa8408 Signs
Mel Gibson’s acting was top notch in this movie. The way he tried to help his son cope with asthma it made you feel the fathers pain. Amazing movie!
The movie theater busted out laughing when he threw that can on top 😂😂😂😂
I wish I could have seen it in theaters. I was way too young to see it
@@jkm7983 I was 9 when I saw it in theatres. I actually think it's a good family movie. Even scary films can be good family films.
@@Ratchet299 I was like 3 when it was out. I wouldn't have remembered it
Every pound counts 😂
When I was 9 I was able to see this movie cause a friend took me payee me free watch in the drive thru theater.
"Don't do this to me again, not again. . . I hate you . . . I hate you!" I believe this is the moment where he regains his faith.
He never lost it. He merely tried to pretend otherwise. This scene made me realize the same exact thing. I dont think belief is a choice
@Sudden Arrival I'm not talking about that science fiction book called the bible.
@Sudden Arrival lmao. Because your interpretation of art is different than mine, you're right and I'm wrong?? Its a movie about faith. Not Christianity. Your reply is why people dont take Christians seriously anymore.
Its about God. There are many Gods in religion. Your arrogance is why you see it as a Christian movie
@Sudden Arrival lmao ive never reported anyone in my life. You're a dunce
@Sudden Arrival you're ignorant and insecure. Your comment was irrelevant drivel... I didnt report it because i dont give a shit about your opinion. Go be gay somewhere else
Unbelievable. You don't get scenes of this power in Hollywood anymore.
Hollywood needs an artistically free Night back. However, i want Night to ditch Hollywood and go independent, so that we can get his art completely unfiltered.
That’s what he does now - he basically self financed his movies.
There was a time when M Night was making gems. This is one. The music in this scene is fabulous. James Newton Howard is up there with the best of them.
Kevin Barton JNH's score on M Night films is always top notch. I can always count on loving the score
This scene was lost on me as a kid but re-watching Signs the other day, it's easily now my favourite. The camera shots on the torches, the music, and then that monologue, just blew me away.
Makes me cry everytime): So sweet. Love how it goes from horrifying to a brief moment of comic relief, then horrifying again, then something sad and touching like this. Brilliant
I just love his acting in this scene
I don't give a shit about what anybody says, Mel Gibson is an AMAZING fucking actor. This scene like so many others of his brought fucking tears to my eyes.
Amazing Actor And director!
Anyone else love the morning after this.
*checks baby monitor*
0.7 seconds of silence
"That's good enough for me"
"Me too"
*proceeds to go open the door*
Also might I add that Mel Gibson is deeply religious which kinda contradicts this movie
+Dillon ferko (Shamrock69) , the aliens in this movie are from a certain point of view demons, who threaten his family. It's about his religious battle how he loses God and through this experience he finds him again. But also HAHAHAH yes they should've waited a bit longer before going up.
Greatest film ever made. A man protecting his family from demons and returning to Christ. Mel Gibson is the greatest actor to ever live.
Great performance in this movie. Very moving and intense, especially this scene. Just a note: if you're ever helping someone with an asthma attack, it's usually easier to breathe if they're leaning forward instead of lying back.
The best scene in Signs. I cried. :'(
I love when he puts the can on top 😂 like it would help😂
Cor3y Curtis
hahahahahahahahahahaha I can't stop laughing at that moment
Seems legit lol
It's like the final thing
EVERY LITTLE BIT HELPS! Don’t judge!
I cried wen I watched this. Both my parents died from asthma and I am now in care. My asthma is really bad sometimes and I hav been 2 hospital 20 times it is not fair. The doctors say I hav a 90%chance of dying by the time I am 15. I am 13.
dead
As long as you are honest my friend.
Are u alive still :(
heidi h You still alive?! Don’t leave us...
RIP
I remember this scene it was so heartfelt a father holding his son get through an asthma attack 🙏
I cry my eyes out every time i see this scene - probably the best in the movie
Wow... this is really emotional. Great scene!
the kid is really great actor
That's actually Macaulay Culkin's (Home Alone) brother, Rory Culkin. They all come from a family of theatre actors so it's no surprise how talented he is even at this age.
That's McColley Corkin's bro
He is a adult now
Great actor. First movie I saw him in was “Mean Creek”.
Rory Culkin played Euronymous in Lords Of Chaos (the movie about the infamous Norwegian black metal band Mayhem), and he was also in Scream 4. I've honestly only ever seen him in darker "horror" films, but he's a great actor regardless, and he also happens to be the little brother of Macaulay (Kevin from Home Alone) and Kieran (Kevin's cousin on Home Alone)
This is such a moving scene, so well done.
Magnificent, stunning attention to detail in this scene, as in so many in the film. God acts through Graham, who uses spiritual words even as he expresses his outward hatred for God. Merrill prays but can't do anything else. The sister has already dreamed of this outcome. So much meaning - injected by the Holy Spirit into M. Night Shyamalan's amazing film-making. The film "Signs" offers signs to all of us out in the audience, and that is why there has rarely if ever been a movie like it.
Remember my dad watching this on the tv I’ve been looking for this movie for forever
I can relate to this scene. The helplessness of seeing your child go through this and you cannot do anything. Just wait for them to come out of it...
Im soorry
This to me, is the scariest scene in the movie. Locked in the basement, no medicine, asthma attack, hostile aliens in the house.
But Merrill piles up the "special meal" made by the company Joy. Do you not see? He has his spiritual food, and even as his brother is struggling, cursing God and trying to save his son through humanist means, the brother is praying to God, while the girl Bo is still in her angel costume and is proven able to convert water in such a way that her pure goodness sanctifies it to burn the demon-aliens. And as the music changes imperceptibly we realise God is not far away at all... which He really isn't! Then Merrill (seemingly) refers to saving the Flashlight, but he is actually referencing the saving of the enlightenment they have received!
Love this movie.
What is the name of the film?
@@hajarmoussa8408
Signs
@@kathleenc8 thanks😊😊
@@hajarmoussa8408
You're welcome!
Oddly powerful scene from a great underrated movie
Watched it again
My favorite movie
❤
Sept, 14, 2023
"I hate you!" oh so many feels.
Was he saying that to God?
@@VincentMalloyy no to joe biden
@@VincentMalloyy yes
hey it's Mel Gibson Brilliant Director Actor, :)
The scene is so inspiring I remember watching this movie and found tears in my eyes
i have asthma but my parents don't believe it and i don't have an inhaler so I have to pray during mine in order for me to know that I will live. Anyone going through what I am.
I wonder how many people click this video thinking it's an actual kid having an asthma attack and not knowing it's really a scene from a movie
What a scene!
You understand that there may be "signs" in this scene that even the genius makers may not realise?
[the dog food for a start - cute name, wouldn't you say?]
[The tear in Joaquin's eye at 01:30]
Of course a movie about signs (made to restore some faith and hope after 9/11) would receive the active involvement of the Holy Spirit.
Human genius is wondrous, but here it is raised beyond, as we are close to perfection.
Human beings alone cannot do that, but with God nothing is impossible.
And the Holy Spirit is indeed ACTIVE in promoting Discipleship. He's here with us in this world, and wants to be inside each of us if we give Him a chance.
I did.
@@sidpheasant7585that is what it was about
Riveting scene that moves anyone to tears if you analyze it closely. Another great scene from this film is when Joaquin's character calmly lashes out on Mel's character for this--not because he was being a responsible dad, but because he showed his weakness when he let his faith falter for a moment or so.
still tears today in this scene, I don't care what people think, superb, John Moore 2020.
the words of the Father to the son,
echo GOD's to us
Amen
I love the bout Mel is having with God. I can emphasize
That "I hate you" is the most honest, real moment of prayer ever depicted in a movie
@@familyphotoshoot2413 yeah I know that’s the beauty of it I think it’s meant to be a warp black comedy that you can either get or not
this is SO sad ): poor little boy... poor everyone with asthma! ): i dont have it but i feel REALLY bad for all of you who do x( it makes me really appreciate my health
Good film but fucking terrifying when I was 10
ɷ I Haveeee Watchedddd Thiss Movie Leakedddd Versionnn Heree : - t.co/EQMyZQlo5e
I can't even imagine what that feels like.
Bria Plsss really Oh my God
Painful, back muscles are tight & locked up from the effort to get air. Airways are painfully constricted & you have to concentrate on getting little gasps in. Leaning forward or lying on your side is better positioning for opening airways. NOT having a grown mans big hand on your chest while you struggle is preferable!!
I know what you mean. I've had 2 asthma attacks when I was younger. Haven't had one in years now.
so no one is noticing the bruising on Mels neck and the alien grabbing the son in the same spot of his, then Mel says towards end of scene "We're the same".....hmmmm
What he meant by "we're the same" was that he and his son are one is the same as they took deep breaths to not worry his son about feeling negatively about him
SUPERB , tears for me right now.
had an asthma attack today luckily my ventolin kicked in before going to the ER but i have absolutely no energy
this film is perfection
Love the movie signs
Best scene.
I love this movie....
i have asthma and i feel very " uncomfortable " watching asthma attacks becuase i know i could have one at any time
It literally feels like that. You hold with the tightest grip ever to whatever is near. I dont know why but you do. You freak out so much and it doesn't help.
On previous viewings, when Graham is cradling Morgan and says, “I hate you”, I assumed he was talking to Morgan, to help Morgan stay alive by using Morgan’s own words against him. Now I realize that Graham is actually expressing his hatred for God in that moment, fearful that God will take another of his loved ones. Hence why he says, “Don’t do this to me again. Not again. I hate you.”
Possibly yeah it’s either a really twisted black comedy or a real screw you to god for his injustice
@@alifakhrzadeh1544 It's clearly towards God.
@@alifakhrzadeh1544the film is a sign about how the Holy Spirit uses signs to reveal God's love, care and mercy. On the basis of all divine things having meaning, value and purpose, and just "adding up". As any Born-Again like myself will tell you ... it ... is ... all ... true! I know, I see (at least a bit). With the Holy Spirit, things make sense. He is love and TRUTH. Jesus, whom He reveals, is the way, the truth and the life...
Well I stand by both my statements and Rob Jackson it’s like I said earlier there’s overdramatic elements that make it silly a little like Scream with satires however this movie’s humor is dry like scotch while Scream is whisky with more flavor. You may ask then what is the point about joking about God well some people find it silly because he can be a fictional character or some believe but hate his hypocritical views
I have bronchitis problem and I had crises often. I love this movie and I really identify with this scene, because it's almost the same thing ...
I'm from Brazil!
I have asthma attacks my mom was crying when sor me lying in the floor not breathing but I finally recover
Oh my gose I hope yoyr still alive
Please be alive please
0:24 He Used Can, It's Super Effective!
I haven't watched this movie since it first came out about 20 years ago. At the time, it was just some average UFO/alien movie to me and nothing more.
I just rewatched it again and I can honestly say this movie has hit me so much harder this time around. I have 2 children of my own now... as a parent, this scene was extremely heartbreaking to watch. It's amazing how our views on movies and how they make us feel can change so much over time. I need to rewatch some more classic M. Night Shyamalan movies now!
This time you get more of the Holy Spirit who is in the movie, with it, and emanating out of it.
You find it when you need it.
[We all need it]
Probably you know that Shyamalan wanted the movie to act as some kind of balm for people after the evil of 9/11 - which happened at the very start of their filming.
How could the Holy Spirit NOT get behind something like that, which is anyway a movie about lapsed faith, the return to faith, and the way in which the enigmatic Holy Spirit even achieves His purposes for Father and Son through things that seem trivial or awful or ridiculous?
With Him things just add up, within the movie but also beyond it.
Beautiful!
scene reminds me of the movie signs
This is a scene from the movie of 'Sign' the story of the damn freaken alien that died because of water
It is the movie
Lol wow really
My little brony My ponies r/whooooosh
SIGNS
❤
GREAT MOVIE
He lost his faith when his wife died, and regained it when his son was spared Mauricio
XO
@Dollymayfrosty yeah i know she's in frickin' everything
i dreamed about this
Tears.
Me too.
You understand that there may be "signs" in this scene that even the genius makers may not realise?
[the dog food for a start - cute name, wouldn't you say?]
[The tear in Joaquin's eye at 01:30]
Of course a movie about signs (made to restore some faith and hope after 9/11) would receive the active involvement of the Holy Spirit.
Human genius is wondrous, but here it is raised beyond, as we are close to perfection.
Human beings alone cannot do that, but with God nothing is impossible.
And the Holy Spirit is indeed ACTIVE. He's here with us in this world, and wants to be inside each of us if we give Him a chance.
I did.
When the little girl said she dreamed this why do u think she said to the boy about to die I don't want u to die earlyer in the movie
Wow I never thought of that 😳
@@SilverQueen848same I did not think of that
I hate asthma and I had an asthma attack but survived
Have astms lachelle
4year ago 82 I 😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷😷
make you feel like your chest is tightning up and ur dying
Still have tears.
1:29 she played a girl (a blind girl) in an episode of NCIS
@MathyPure same here. i'm sixteen now tho. instead of using ventolin everyday tho, there is advir... it prevents attacks from happening thoughout the day...thou of course, sometimes u will still need the ventolin (rescue in haler)
I have asthma I'm in grade 12 it was quite every since grade 7 but now it's gotten worse
Sorry to hear that, I'm not an expert but when I had juvenile asthma I was told to eat lots of fish oil. So maybe try that it works for some people.
@XxSteevo93xX He's talking to god, not to his son, when he says I hate you, and don't do this to me again, that sort of thing. He's talking about how his wife was killed already and he doesn't want to lose his son too.
i have astham and i almost died but i survived
I can feel what the boy feels 😔
Thanksssss =D I wanted to see this ^^
@olanis97 Her real name? Abigail Breslin.
@Azeroak ohhh D: thanks for telling me ): i didnt know i could get it any time... ): ill make sure to be careful
Merril is praying
The way he says “I hate you”
He's really letting it all out towards God. That's what makes you cry. He's at his breaking point.
Tell Graham to see.
A master class on acting
What is the name of the film??plz
Signs
@@alifakhrzadeh1544 thank youu😊😊
It can be worse than you imagine it to be. Trust me. It can.
WHY DISEASES EXIST??? I HAVE ASTHMA....AND I SUFFER AND THERE ARE MANY ANOTHER PPL WHO SUFFER FROM ANOTHER DISEASE...
thanks! ya i got it like 7 years ago i was about 14 sucks.. thats life just gotta take the meds =)
I have asthma and it really sucks :(
ميل جيبسون ملك السينما الامريكيه 😘😘
"Signs"
what is the movie called?
Skull Risger signs
Don’t know if u need it anymore but...
Good lord, the vitriol in that 2nd “I hate you”
Is that Abigail Breslen at 1:13
Omg, she's so cute! :D
Glennjridge I didn't know who he was say he hated too lol I thought it was the little boy
alot of my friends have asthma
278,199, XO Bravo Christopher Dugan XO
Tears XO
Woah is that girl from my sisters keeper?
No, that girl is from Zombieland! Poor Little Rock can't catch a break...
WHO ELSE WATCHED THIS WHILE HAVING AN ASTHMA ATTACK! oh, just me huh?
@allisonacres Ah that makes sense thanks for the explanation.
@vioxshadow4swords I WAS HEALTH ALSO BUT NOW ITS TERRIBLE... YOU CAN GET ASTHMA OR ANOTHER DISEASE any time-( take care