I feel like it should be second chances 2. We already had winners at war and most of the cast you picked are people from that cast. With second chances 2, people from the 30’s seasons get a chance to return, while so do the new era seasons (while also bringing back older players).
I like the idea of a "Best to never win" theme. Probst recently did an interview with Rob C. and stated they definitely want to do something big for the 50th season but claims they aren't sure yet. I think that will be Jeff's final season as he'll be in mid 60s by then.
Here's a hypothetical (without winners) Seasons 1-10: Sue (Borneo), Colby (Australia), Kathy (Marquesas), Ian (Palau) Seasons 11-20: Cirie (Panama), Ozzy (Cook Islands), Amanda (China), Russell (Samoa) Seasons 21-30: Andrea (Redemption Island), Malcolm (Phillipines), Spencer (Cagayan), Shirin (World's Apart) Seasons 31-40: Dominick (Ghost Island), Angelina (David vs Goliath), Devens (Edge of Extinction), Lauren (Island of the Idols) Seasons 41-45: Shan (41), Jesse (43), Carolyn (44), Caleb (45) Of course this isn't perfect, for example, 1 contestant off meeting the diversity mandate, but it provides a good range of players from all eras of Survivor's history
I loved Dom but watching him play with returnees that won’t just suck his dick until the finish would be interesting, he definitely has the potential to become a legend
Some people I'd love to see on a Legends seasons not included in the video: - Fairplay - Hatch - Elisabeth (Filarski, or more popularly known as Hasselbeck) - Venus - Brenda - Cesternino
Considering what Jeff said on RHAP recently about not wanting villains is aggrovating. Villains like Russell Hantz made the show so fun and exciting. I hope he cones back again as well.
Angelina winning Survivor: Legends I fear. She will climb a 250 foot ladder this time and negotiate even better than she did before to be to play the first perfect game of the post WAW era
Why? The only person who quit everything faster while being completely oblivious as to how he was coming across to everyone else was Colton. But I suppose it's to his credit that he didn't actually quit the show, just the challenges. At least we don't have to listen to his annoying voice anymore.
Aubry n Jenna Lewis n Jerri Manthey n Tai n Yao Man n Natalie n Rupert n Colby n Coach n Colleen Haskell n Kelly Wigglesworth n Jenna Morasca n Heidi Strobel
My dream cast using the "4 per era" rule - 1-10: Boston Rob Cesternino Sandra Stephenie 11-20: Cirie Parvati Coach Russell 21-30: Malcolm Ciera Tony Wentworth 31-40: Aubry Dom Angelina Rick 41-45: Jonathan Jesse Carolyn Emiily
legends from 1st ten seasons boston rob/rupert sue/sandra maybe jerri and sandra or sue and jerri. but i think sue is perhaps one of the most iconic moments of survivor history, to this day.
31-40 aubry/chrissy zeke/dom i have subs for rick devens o mike white, i think dom has to be there. Zeke I think is more cemented in the history of survivor than both of those. Dom forced the first ever tie.
@@celadonblue6250 can we get actual great players and fun personalities like kellie, Lauren, Angelina, Cassidy, Carolyn, cydney, Gavin, Victoria, Chrissy. Like why tf do we need Jake back? So he can cry and whine and fail a blindside again? Why do we need Emily? So she can bootlick the majority alliance? Why do we need Kaleb? So he can, well do nothing again? Why do we need Devens? So we can have an annoying nerd running around the island making terrible reads and just generally being bad at the game?
I actually did a Brant Steel for this type of cast a couple of months back. My cast consisted of Rob Cesternino, Jerri Manthley, Parvati Shallow, Amanda Kimmel, Cirie Fields, Earl Cole, Sandra Diaz, Tai Trang, Christian Hubikki, Angelina Keeley, Rick Devons, Chrissy Hofbeck, Domenick Abbate, Carolyn Wiger, Yamyam Archo, Dee Vallerase, Maryanne Oketch, Kaleb Gaberwold, Omar Zeheer, and Mike Holloway. The funny thing about that brant steel was that the final 3 ended up being Dee, Amanda, and Tai (one winner and 2 runners up from their first seasons) and Dee ended up being the winner again lol
I made a hypothetical “non-winners only” legendary cast Tribe 1: James (15) Jerry (2) Russell (19) Cirie (12) Malcolm (25) Brenda (21) Spencer (28) Wentworth (29) Joe (30) Drea (42) Tribe 2: Rupert (7) Amanda (15) Terry (12) Corrine (17) Ozzy (13) Andrea (22) Christian (37) Tasha (28) Jonathan (42) Carolyn (44)
I had a concept that’d be interesting but probably extremely difficult to cast for called Winners vs. Warriors. One tribe of 10 Winners vs. one tribe of Warriors (one of the runners-up from each season that the competing Winners were from - basically being they fought their way to the top but couldn’t bring home the win).
Decided to make this cast but also limit it to a maximum of 5 players per previous season. So WaW has 5 and then Game Changers and HvV have 4: **Borneo-Palau** - Vecepia - Sandra - Rob C - Rupert **Guatemala-HvV** - Cirie - Courtney - Earl - Yul **Nicaragua-Worlds Apart** - Malcolm - Tony - Wentworth - Natalie A. **Second Chance-Winners at War** - Domenick - Christian - Michele - Angelina **41-45** - Maryanne - Carolyn - Jesse - Omar
Jelinsky is an obvious shoe in, it was genius to give up the challenges and the only reason he lost was because of luck, everybody voted at random CLEARLY because they would otherwise never vote out a Survivor Legend such as him.
I actually like your cast but here are some of my changes: Stpehanie LaGrossa over V. Nothing against V but I think Stephanie is the most iconic female player of the 10s. I wonder how she will do after Snake in the Grass and Traitors S1. Malcolm over Jeremy. Jeremy is great, but I think after Malcolm's last vote in GC, I really think he deserves another shot. Plus he is one of the most likeable player ever AND a genuine triple threat. Wentworth over Natalie. As much as I love Natalie, Wentworth is a name that keeps coming up as much as Parvati and I think she cemented herself as a legend. Janet over Michelle. I know it's hard casting anyone from 39, but I think Janet went through so much in that season and she may be one of the biggest heroes in the show's history. Shan over Dee. I think Shan is the biggest star of 41 even if her game was cut short halfway. Cody over Yam Yam. If only so I can have a rematch of Cody vs Jesse.
Alright I figured I’ll give a crack at this with your same rules because why not. Boston Rob Hatch Queen Sandra Tina Russell Coach Parv Cirie Jeremy Tony Wentworth Chaos Kass Christian Devon Pinto (maybe not truly a legend, but it’s my season lol) Angelina Winchele Yam Yam Jesse Maryanne Carolyn
To pick Dee over Maryanne is astounding. Also, is that shade, dear Peridiam, when you used Dee's audiobyte of "real world morals" in this video??? 😂😂😂 Sneaky sneaky, Kelley Wentworth! 😂
I would limit the cast to players who played only once or twice, so we can freshen up the crop of all stars. Up to 5 winners (8 had 4, 20 had 5, 27 had 2, 34 had 3)
Calling Sandra “the first two-timer” is funny to me because she’s still the only actual two-timer. Barring Sandra winning a third time, WAW was a guaranteed second win for everyone else, so while being the winner of the winner’s season is impressive, becoming a “two-time winner” isn’t quite as impressive on a season where the winner is always going to be a two-timer no matter who wins. When everyone on the season is a winner, the playing field is a lot more even, and you don’t have to worry about being judged as a threat because of it, which is what makes Sandra’s two-time win far more impressive. On WAW, being a one-time winner didn’t make you a threat. Sandra won her second season without that benefit, and came on WAW with the disadvantage of being a two-timer when no one else was. She was basically playing the same game as a winner on a season of non-winners. Tony's win was very impressive. He's the King of Survivor and the Winner of all Winners, but being a "two-timer" is more of something he is by default, not really comparable to what Sandra accomplished.
This is exactly what I've been thinking! Tony can't be the best player, because he never achieved what Sandra did. People wanted her to win for the second time against someone who had never won. Tony won a season where no matter who was there in the end, it would be a two time winner (unless he lost to Sandra, if course).
Of course I’d love to see a majority of these legends again, I think 50 could be a good point to do “Survivor: Finalists at War”. Can be composed of players who have played more than once, but have either made it to the FTC or the Finale Episode of their season.
I ran this season on BrantSteele simulation: Christian, Yam Yam, and Sandra were medevac'd in the premerge. Rupert, Rick, Angelina, and Parvati were voted out in the premerge. Rupert was first voted out although after Christian's medevac. Russel idol'd out Vepecia and Natalie idol'd out Rob (who also had an unplayed idol). The final 3 votes were all ties. Kim won 6 challenges in a row (3 immunity). Jesse gets third place with 1 vote, Cirie gets second with 3 votes, and Michele wins with 5 votes.
Love this cast so much, but I’d put Coach over Russell. Coach is much more likely to play again and I’d rather see Coach play again, although I love both
In honor of the "ultimate vote" advantage Raymond got in Australian Survivor last night, does a top 10 "DISADVANTAGEOUS ADVANTAGES" sound interesting to you? It feels like there's already enough lot to choose from if you include survivor AU. Thanks Peridiam and love your videos as always.
Surprised Shan is not included in the new era names, she's easily the first name that comes to my mind when I think about 41+ legends (she's the only one who has her own soundtrack! lol)
Honestly the Final 6 Rock Draw was entirely because Hayden didn't want to be voted out. "Hey Ciera, if you make a big move you'll win the game" "Hey Ciera, they just told you that you're fourth out of their alliance of three so you'll be voted out next" "Oh look, I'm the vote target and so I become immune from the rock draw and have bought myself an extra round in the game". He knew who to put pressure on and how and it paid off.
I appreciate the Vecepia pick because she deserved a second shot (and this would be fixing that) but in terms of a Legends theme, I'd give her spot to Jerri. Jerri is more of "legendary" player in terms of archetype and history, imo. For the modern era, I think Dee is the better overall player, but I would prefer Maryanne. Maryanne is a bigger personality and it would be fun to see her mix it up with people like Tony. Great picks overall, can't really argue with many.
Carolyn being from the same area I’m from and also I’m so similar to her seeing her on this list actually made my day because the moment you said one more spot I was like this best be Caroline
If I have a say who gets in, the Legends season will be a Second Chance-Final Shot theme, and only players who have not returned yet, no winners, and each will be the sole returnee from their OG season: 1-10: Greg Buis/T-Bird Cooper/Ian Rosenberger/Christa Hastie 11-20: Shane Powers/Brett Clouser/Natalie Bolton/Crystal Cox 21-30: Eddie Fox/Jay Byers/Ashley Underwood/Carolyn Rivera 31-40: Daniel Rendering/Gavin Whitson/Cydney Gillon/Lauren Ashley Beck 41-present: Xander Hastings/Austin Li Coon/Drea Wheeler/Carolyn Wiger since its like a Final Shot season, nobody is allowed back again in the future.
Hey Peridiam, I think it’d be cool if you made a hypothetical cast for a Second Chance 2 season, I’d love to see your picks! I also think they should be players from season 32- present.
dont think it’ll ever happen but its always fun to hang on to what could’ve been, also who saw that jeff doesn’t want to cast anymore villains as long as he’s part of the show…?
Survivor 50 - Legends vs. New Era All Stars. Played under new era rules. Two tribes of 8-10. That way you'd only need to find 8 worthy legends that would want to play (well 7 because Sandra would definitely be a yes lol). A very small percentage of your former winners or even Cirie's, Rupert's etc. are going to want to play again. And you could build a pretty solid 8 person tribe our of new era all stars. Erika, Ricard, Shan, Maryanne, Omar, Jesse, Yam Yam, Carson, Carolyn, Dee, Austin (take your pick of 8 of the and that's with four seasons left before 50) and I'm sure a lot more of them would play again
I always thought that "Greatest To Never Win" would be a good one. Great players throughout the show's history that never clinched the title of Sole Survivor get one final opportunity to get there, and one of them would end up finally winning. Bring together Cirie, Rupert, Russell, Malcolm, etc., and give them one last shot.
My legends using the same rules, but no winners that were on WaW and not repeating original seasons: S1-S10: Jonny Fairplay Lex Van Den Berghe Shii Ann Huang Heidi Strobel S11-S20: Earl Cole Todd Herzog Cirie Fields Natalie Bolton S21-S30: Malcolm Freberg Mike Holloway Ciera Eastin Sabrina Thompson S31-S40: Davie Rickenbacker Tai Trang Janet Carbin Victoria Baamonde S41-S45: Jesse Lopez Kaleb Gebrewold Carolyn Wiger Shan Smith
Here's an idea for a fan cast: Survivor: Wild Cards. Basically just Cambodia: Second Chance 2, but with people who are NEVER considered for a returnee season, but probably should be. Stacy from Fiji, Matty from Gabon, Taj from Tocantins, RC from Phillipines, Trish from Cagayan, Nadiya from SJDS why not, etc. Really subjective but could be fun to consider.
Cochran has to be on this list (I know he said he was done) Id also go Kelley W in the 30s over Angelina if thats allowed since I think her first was 29 but she made her mark in the 30s.
I still want a Rivals season. They squandered the concept with Rob vs. Russell in Redemption Island. Two tribes made up on on screen rivals opposite each other.
Nice vid, but I think you’ve done yourself a disservice. By sticking to 2M/2W from each decade and not excluding winners, you’ve got a cast that just isn’t as interesting to watch play ~yet another time~ as it could be, in my opinion. So here’s my attempt (even gender split, 50% BIPOC, no season double-ups): Gervase (S1) Alicia (S2) Kathy (S4) Shii Ann (S5) Cirie (S12) Yau-Man (S14) Fishbach (S18) Phillip (S22) Malcolm (S25) Woo (S28) Kelley (S29) Aubry (S32) David (S33) Chrissy (S35) Dom (S36) Angelina (S37) Devens (S38) Shan (S41) Jesse (S43) Carolyn (S44) Is it Legends? I don’t know. Maybe Survivor: Icons
i would replace nat with wentworth only to have less WAW players, and dee with maryanne. maybe todd instead of russell (less HvV players also). hatch could replace boston rob and tina could take sandra's spot. amanda could take parvati's spot and malcolm could take tony's.
I feel like it should be second chances 2.
We already had winners at war and most of the cast you picked are people from that cast. With second chances 2, people from the 30’s seasons get a chance to return, while so do the new era seasons (while also bringing back older players).
I totally agree!
I agree (J1 for 2nd chances)
@@eryspink LMAOO HI ERYS
To be fair, 8 out of 20 isn’t “most” but I understand what you’re getting at.
I would make 49 2nd chance to with 4 people being added to the legends cast.
I like the idea of a "Best to never win" theme. Probst recently did an interview with Rob C. and stated they definitely want to do something big for the 50th season but claims they aren't sure yet. I think that will be Jeff's final season as he'll be in mid 60s by then.
dude has aged like wine I didn't realize he was already 62
@@ajnewhouse6217yeah I thought he was in his 50's
im just imagining Rob trying to Robfather and Carolyn just openly going against him
I'm here for it!
I’d do this without having any winners- think it’d be harder to come with people initially but could make dynamics more interesting!
Agree with this. I want legends that never won. There are plenty to choose from that played great games
Here's a hypothetical (without winners)
Seasons 1-10:
Sue (Borneo), Colby (Australia), Kathy (Marquesas), Ian (Palau)
Seasons 11-20:
Cirie (Panama), Ozzy (Cook Islands), Amanda (China), Russell (Samoa)
Seasons 21-30:
Andrea (Redemption Island), Malcolm (Phillipines), Spencer (Cagayan), Shirin (World's Apart)
Seasons 31-40:
Dominick (Ghost Island), Angelina (David vs Goliath), Devens (Edge of Extinction), Lauren (Island of the Idols)
Seasons 41-45:
Shan (41), Jesse (43), Carolyn (44), Caleb (45)
Of course this isn't perfect, for example, 1 contestant off meeting the diversity mandate, but it provides a good range of players from all eras of Survivor's history
Then that would just be Second Chance 2.
@@jiro110 Sounds good to me.
@@jiro110 no bc it’ll not be everyone’s second chance some it’ll be their third etc
Let’s put Jelinsky in it because Jelinsky is a master, Jelinsky is a legend
literally came here just to make that joke hahahah well played.
Honestly surprised that Dom from Ghost Island isn’t on this list. He’s on the top of my list of players I want to return from that era
Agreed I love Christian but I think Dom deserves it wayyyy more
@@chrisfacchini7285 I think Christian deserves it but Rick Devens, not so much
Same it’s a solid list though. I would hope they would expand the cast for a Legends season to fit a handful more key players in.
I loved Dom but watching him play with returnees that won’t just suck his dick until the finish would be interesting, he definitely has the potential to become a legend
Malcolm snubbed
Malcom’s a flop there I said it
I'd like if winners weren't included in this, and it was non-winner legends. The cast does seem to almost be WaW 2.0!
Jonathan from 42 should be a legend for his sheer beast mode carrying his tribe in challenges
Just put Him and Natalie on a tribe and watch those two dominate and carry their tribe to the merge without going to tribal
I standby that if it weren't for him, Maryanne would not have won.
Some people I'd love to see on a Legends seasons not included in the video:
- Fairplay
- Hatch
- Elisabeth (Filarski, or more popularly known as Hasselbeck)
- Venus
- Brenda
- Cesternino
It’s not a Legends season without Jalinski
Yes!
Rip to Wentworth and Malcolm both got pushed to the way side😂😂😂
Considering what Jeff said on RHAP recently about not wanting villains is aggrovating. Villains like Russell Hantz made the show so fun and exciting. I hope he cones back again as well.
This aged well considering Parvati just said she won't play again
i would guess most of these people won’t play again, or be given the opportunity for that matter
It's a hypothetical game buddy
Please....she would play again. Reality tv is her life.
@@btreese7 she literally only played survivor 3 times in 4 years, then 1 more time 10 years later, and now traitors, id hardly call it her life
This is probably the only thing that would get her to come back.
I'd love to see Rob Cesternino back on a season like this
Angelina winning Survivor: Legends I fear. She will climb a 250 foot ladder this time and negotiate even better than she did before to be to play the first perfect game of the post WAW era
Jelinsky from 46 better be on here after that legendary premiere
Jalinski should be at the top of this list as a “legendary” player
Why? The only person who quit everything faster while being completely oblivious as to how he was coming across to everyone else was Colton. But I suppose it's to his credit that he didn't actually quit the show, just the challenges.
At least we don't have to listen to his annoying voice anymore.
Aubry n Jenna Lewis n Jerri Manthey n Tai n Yao Man n Natalie n Rupert n Colby n Coach n Colleen Haskell n Kelly Wigglesworth n Jenna Morasca n Heidi Strobel
Love that you included Vecepia. She’s definitely an underrated winner!
Blood versus water III should bring back Nick Wilson and his cousin wife.
LMFAO 😭😭
uhm nty
My dream cast using the "4 per era" rule -
1-10:
Boston Rob
Cesternino
Sandra
Stephenie
11-20:
Cirie
Parvati
Coach
Russell
21-30:
Malcolm
Ciera
Tony
Wentworth
31-40:
Aubry
Dom
Angelina
Rick
41-45:
Jonathan
Jesse
Carolyn
Emiily
legends from 1st ten seasons
boston rob/rupert
sue/sandra
maybe jerri and sandra or sue and jerri. but i think sue is perhaps one of the most iconic moments of survivor history, to this day.
11-20
parvati/cirie
russell (cant deny it)/ ozzy
omg peridiam completely agreed on this one lol
21-30
Tony/Cochran
Cierra/Sarah
I didnt want it to be so winner heavy but this is the best I could do
lol i did better than peridiam who casted ALL winners.
31-40
aubry/chrissy
zeke/dom
i have subs for rick devens o mike white, i think dom has to be there. Zeke I think is more cemented in the history of survivor than both of those. Dom forced the first ever tie.
I think the new era should be called the “numbered” era
Not including Jellinsky is rude.
He's Legend Material.
If you say it enough it becomes true. If you say it enough it becomes true. If you say it becomes true.
survivor content on a random wednesday is always elite
You know 46 premieres tn right?
Do a second chances 2 with players like Jake, Kaleb, Emily, Carolyn, Devens, Christian, Chrissy, Angelina etc.
That would be an awful season. Jake??? Kaleb??? Emily??? Devens??? Christian??? Yikes
@@Uniquanators47who pissed in your coffee 😭 all of those people are great
@@celadonblue6250 these people are awful
@@celadonblue6250 can we get actual great players and fun personalities like kellie, Lauren, Angelina, Cassidy, Carolyn, cydney, Gavin, Victoria, Chrissy. Like why tf do we need Jake back? So he can cry and whine and fail a blindside again? Why do we need Emily? So she can bootlick the majority alliance? Why do we need Kaleb? So he can, well do nothing again? Why do we need Devens? So we can have an annoying nerd running around the island making terrible reads and just generally being bad at the game?
@@Uniquanators47 Gavin has the charisma of a wet paper towel
Could you put together a Survivor: Goobers Edition, I just wanna see who would win a $1M from a pool of the worst players in the game 😂
I actually did a Brant Steel for this type of cast a couple of months back. My cast consisted of Rob Cesternino, Jerri Manthley, Parvati Shallow, Amanda Kimmel, Cirie Fields, Earl Cole, Sandra Diaz, Tai Trang, Christian Hubikki, Angelina Keeley, Rick Devons, Chrissy Hofbeck, Domenick Abbate, Carolyn Wiger, Yamyam Archo, Dee Vallerase, Maryanne Oketch, Kaleb Gaberwold, Omar Zeheer, and Mike Holloway.
The funny thing about that brant steel was that the final 3 ended up being Dee, Amanda, and Tai (one winner and 2 runners up from their first seasons) and Dee ended up being the winner again lol
I made a hypothetical “non-winners only” legendary cast
Tribe 1:
James (15) Jerry (2)
Russell (19) Cirie (12)
Malcolm (25) Brenda (21)
Spencer (28) Wentworth (29)
Joe (30) Drea (42)
Tribe 2:
Rupert (7) Amanda (15)
Terry (12) Corrine (17)
Ozzy (13) Andrea (22)
Christian (37) Tasha (28)
Jonathan (42) Carolyn (44)
Jelinsky snubbed
I had a concept that’d be interesting but probably extremely difficult to cast for called Winners vs. Warriors. One tribe of 10 Winners vs. one tribe of Warriors (one of the runners-up from each season that the competing Winners were from - basically being they fought their way to the top but couldn’t bring home the win).
This is an interesting concept.
Winners:
Tina (2)
Vecepia (4)
Chris (9)
Yul (13)
JT (18)
Kim (24)
Michele (32)
Wendell (36)
Erika (41)
YamYam (44)
Warriors:
Colby (2)
Neleh (4)
Twila (9)
Ozzy (13)
Stephen (18)
Sabrina (24)
Aubry (32)
Dom (36)
Xander (41)
Heidi (44)
Must Have Pairs:
Tina/Colby (2)
Chris/Twila (9)
Yul/Ozzy (13)
Kim/Sabrina (24)
Michele/Aubry (32)
Wendell/Dom (36)
Strong Contender Pairs:
Vee/Neleh (4)
JT/Stephen (18)
Erika/Xander (41)
YamYam/Heidi (44)
Alternate Pairs:
Danni/Steph (11)
Todd/Courtney (15)
Parvati/Amanda (16)
Natalie/Russell (19)
Mike/Carolyn (30)
Ben/Chrissy (35)
Chris/Gavin (38)
Tommy/Dean (39)
Maryanne/Mike (42)
Dee/Jake (45)
Alternate Warriors:
Amanda (15 - replaces Courtney)
Deshawn (41 - replaces Xander)
Romeo (42 - replaces Mike)
Carolyn (44 - replaces Heidi)
Austin (45 - replaces Jake)
Decided to make this cast but also limit it to a maximum of 5 players per previous season. So WaW has 5 and then Game Changers and HvV have 4:
**Borneo-Palau**
- Vecepia
- Sandra
- Rob C
- Rupert
**Guatemala-HvV**
- Cirie
- Courtney
- Earl
- Yul
**Nicaragua-Worlds Apart**
- Malcolm
- Tony
- Wentworth
- Natalie A.
**Second Chance-Winners at War**
- Domenick
- Christian
- Michele
- Angelina
**41-45**
- Maryanne
- Carolyn
- Jesse
- Omar
for the new era i thing it should be either shan or emily and carolyn
Courtney, Wentworth, and Omar are all great picks that I didn’t think of at first!!
Jelinsky is an obvious shoe in, it was genius to give up the challenges and the only reason he lost was because of luck, everybody voted at random CLEARLY because they would otherwise never vote out a Survivor Legend such as him.
I actually like your cast but here are some of my changes:
Stpehanie LaGrossa over V. Nothing against V but I think Stephanie is the most iconic female player of the 10s. I wonder how she will do after Snake in the Grass and Traitors S1.
Malcolm over Jeremy. Jeremy is great, but I think after Malcolm's last vote in GC, I really think he deserves another shot. Plus he is one of the most likeable player ever AND a genuine triple threat.
Wentworth over Natalie. As much as I love Natalie, Wentworth is a name that keeps coming up as much as Parvati and I think she cemented herself as a legend.
Janet over Michelle. I know it's hard casting anyone from 39, but I think Janet went through so much in that season and she may be one of the biggest heroes in the show's history.
Shan over Dee. I think Shan is the biggest star of 41 even if her game was cut short halfway.
Cody over Yam Yam. If only so I can have a rematch of Cody vs Jesse.
I’ve been calling this new era the “Numbered Era”
I've been calling it 'Survivor Lite'
Me too!!
Where is Survivor Legend Jelinsky
Can’t have survivor legends without Jelinsky
Aubry Needs 2 Come Back As Well
Audio for the Devens highlight clip is messed up. Amazing video idea!
Natalie track record being First boot, Runner up AND Winner is actually insane.
Alright I figured I’ll give a crack at this with your same rules because why not.
Boston Rob
Hatch
Queen Sandra
Tina
Russell
Coach
Parv
Cirie
Jeremy
Tony
Wentworth
Chaos Kass
Christian
Devon Pinto (maybe not truly a legend, but it’s my season lol)
Angelina
Winchele
Yam Yam
Jesse
Maryanne
Carolyn
To pick Dee over Maryanne is astounding.
Also, is that shade, dear Peridiam, when you used Dee's audiobyte of "real world morals" in this video???
😂😂😂
Sneaky sneaky, Kelley Wentworth! 😂
The fact that Spencer, Malcom, and Dom weren’t on this cast is wild! I would also love to see Jay and Makayla from MvGX return
Dom has to be one of the guys from the 30s he needs a another chance
well now you gotta re-edit this and put jelinsky from 46 on here after that LEGENDARY performance he had in that premiere
DO NOT BRING BACK SANDRA OR RUSSELL EVER
Maybe Survivor 50 will be the WORLDS COLLIDE season?
US Survivor vs Survivor SA vs AU Survivor ???
I would limit the cast to players who played only once or twice, so we can freshen up the crop of all stars. Up to 5 winners (8 had 4, 20 had 5, 27 had 2, 34 had 3)
Should’ve casted the Natalie Napalm
How can you cast a legends season without Cao Boi?
Malcolm and wentworth are needed
Where’s Jelinski?
Jonathan from 42 has be there
i want to see Micheala play again and shan too
Calling Sandra “the first two-timer” is funny to me because she’s still the only actual two-timer. Barring Sandra winning a third time, WAW was a guaranteed second win for everyone else, so while being the winner of the winner’s season is impressive, becoming a “two-time winner” isn’t quite as impressive on a season where the winner is always going to be a two-timer no matter who wins. When everyone on the season is a winner, the playing field is a lot more even, and you don’t have to worry about being judged as a threat because of it, which is what makes Sandra’s two-time win far more impressive. On WAW, being a one-time winner didn’t make you a threat. Sandra won her second season without that benefit, and came on WAW with the disadvantage of being a two-timer when no one else was. She was basically playing the same game as a winner on a season of non-winners. Tony's win was very impressive. He's the King of Survivor and the Winner of all Winners, but being a "two-timer" is more of something he is by default, not really comparable to what Sandra accomplished.
Bro thinking outside the box🤯
This is exactly what I've been thinking! Tony can't be the best player, because he never achieved what Sandra did. People wanted her to win for the second time against someone who had never won. Tony won a season where no matter who was there in the end, it would be a two time winner (unless he lost to Sandra, if course).
Of course I’d love to see a majority of these legends again, I think 50 could be a good point to do “Survivor: Finalists at War”. Can be composed of players who have played more than once, but have either made it to the FTC or the Finale Episode of their season.
Dee talking about her morals in the real world 😂
I think it would have to be larger than 20 people.
Carolyn I think would REALLY struggle in a game with these level of players. Would love to see Carson though.
THANK YOU FOR SAYING VECEPIA. Her win was historic and so, so deserved. She’s, what I consider, the first UTR winner.
I ran this season on BrantSteele simulation:
Christian, Yam Yam, and Sandra were medevac'd in the premerge. Rupert, Rick, Angelina, and Parvati were voted out in the premerge. Rupert was first voted out although after Christian's medevac.
Russel idol'd out Vepecia and Natalie idol'd out Rob (who also had an unplayed idol). The final 3 votes were all ties. Kim won 6 challenges in a row (3 immunity). Jesse gets third place with 1 vote, Cirie gets second with 3 votes, and Michele wins with 5 votes.
If this was real it would be the best season
Love this cast so much, but I’d put Coach over Russell. Coach is much more likely to play again and I’d rather see Coach play again, although I love both
Biggest snubs: Rob C, Shan, Maryanne, Omer, Hatch, Carson, Dom, Tyson, Tina, Sue, Big Tom, Stephen, Coach, Ethan, Colby, Johnny Fairplay, Emily.
I think it should be ‘ legends-unhinged’ all the people on the edge of unhinged and crazy put together !!
No Kaleb? I thought for sure he was a lock
Dee giving a confession about “morals” outside the game and then helping Wendell cheat on his wife yikes 😭
PumpSmash is an awesome person, so cool to see her doing these logos for you 🙌🙌
In honor of the "ultimate vote" advantage Raymond got in Australian Survivor last night, does a top 10 "DISADVANTAGEOUS ADVANTAGES" sound interesting to you? It feels like there's already enough lot to choose from if you include survivor AU. Thanks Peridiam and love your videos as always.
Surprised Shan is not included in the new era names, she's easily the first name that comes to my mind when I think about 41+ legends (she's the only one who has her own soundtrack! lol)
Hayden Moss from 27 proved he had the strategic chops to have potential and id just love for there to be someone who won survivor and big brother
Honestly the Final 6 Rock Draw was entirely because Hayden didn't want to be voted out.
"Hey Ciera, if you make a big move you'll win the game"
"Hey Ciera, they just told you that you're fourth out of their alliance of three so you'll be voted out next"
"Oh look, I'm the vote target and so I become immune from the rock draw and have bought myself an extra round in the game".
He knew who to put pressure on and how and it paid off.
No Kaleb? No Emily? I mean recency bias but they were some of the best characters from the new era for sure
Id swap out Dee for Maryanne
Okay so with this cast and your way of casting it I would say my cast would be similar with a few changes.
1. Boston Rob (Seasons 4, 8, 20, 22, 40)
2. Sandra (Seasons 7, 20, 34, 40)
3. Rupert (Seasons 7, 8, 20, 27)
4. Ami (Seasons 9, 16)
5. Parvati (Seasons 13, 16, 20, 40)
6. Russell (Seasons 19, 20, 22)
7. Cirie (Seasons 12, 16, 20, 34)
8. Todd (Season 15)
9. Natalie A (Seasons 29, 40)
10. Tony (Seasons 28, 34, 40)
11. Sophie (Seasons 23, 40)
12. Malcolm (Seasons 25, 26, 34)
13. Michele (Seasons 32, 40)
14. Dominic (Season 36)
15. Devens (Season 38)
16. Jay (Season 33)
17. Shan (Season 41)
18. Maryanne (Season 42)
19. Jesse (Season 43
20. Carolyn (Season 44)
I appreciate the Vecepia pick because she deserved a second shot (and this would be fixing that) but in terms of a Legends theme, I'd give her spot to Jerri. Jerri is more of "legendary" player in terms of archetype and history, imo.
For the modern era, I think Dee is the better overall player, but I would prefer Maryanne. Maryanne is a bigger personality and it would be fun to see her mix it up with people like Tony.
Great picks overall, can't really argue with many.
when you got to the last pick, I was like "Carolyn? :D" you did not disappoint.
Is anybody else thinking that Malcolm should replace Jeremy or am I just weird?
Angelina pick is the only 1 I disagree w, and I’d replace Carolyn with Shan
Carolyn being from the same area I’m from and also I’m so similar to her seeing her on this list actually made my day because the moment you said one more spot I was like this best be Caroline
I need Malcom and Fabio, those two are both true legends.
Is it just me, or are there a couple of audio sync issues in this video? On the Devens clip, and another one towards the end
If I have a say who gets in, the Legends season will be a Second Chance-Final Shot theme, and only players who have not returned yet, no winners, and each will be the sole returnee from their OG season:
1-10: Greg Buis/T-Bird Cooper/Ian Rosenberger/Christa Hastie
11-20: Shane Powers/Brett Clouser/Natalie Bolton/Crystal Cox
21-30: Eddie Fox/Jay Byers/Ashley Underwood/Carolyn Rivera
31-40: Daniel Rendering/Gavin Whitson/Cydney Gillon/Lauren Ashley Beck
41-present: Xander Hastings/Austin Li Coon/Drea Wheeler/Carolyn Wiger
since its like a Final Shot season, nobody is allowed back again in the future.
I would love to see Greg and Colleen come back.
Hey Peridiam, I think it’d be cool if you made a hypothetical cast for a Second Chance 2 season, I’d love to see your picks! I also think they should be players from season 32- present.
dont think it’ll ever happen but its always fun to hang on to what could’ve been, also who saw that jeff doesn’t want to cast anymore villains as long as he’s part of the show…?
Okay PumpSmash mother!! they're iconic!!
Survivor 50 - Legends vs. New Era All Stars. Played under new era rules.
Two tribes of 8-10. That way you'd only need to find 8 worthy legends that would want to play (well 7 because Sandra would definitely be a yes lol). A very small percentage of your former winners or even Cirie's, Rupert's etc. are going to want to play again.
And you could build a pretty solid 8 person tribe our of new era all stars. Erika, Ricard, Shan, Maryanne, Omar, Jesse, Yam Yam, Carson, Carolyn, Dee, Austin (take your pick of 8 of the and that's with four seasons left before 50) and I'm sure a lot more of them would play again
Not the Wentworth snub hahaha Nah i get it
What a cast Peridiam!!!
I think Dom is an obvious snub.
But my favorite villian of all time.. my guy TYSON!
I always thought that "Greatest To Never Win" would be a good one. Great players throughout the show's history that never clinched the title of Sole Survivor get one final opportunity to get there, and one of them would end up finally winning. Bring together Cirie, Rupert, Russell, Malcolm, etc., and give them one last shot.
My legends using the same rules, but no winners that were on WaW and not repeating original seasons:
S1-S10:
Jonny Fairplay
Lex Van Den Berghe
Shii Ann Huang
Heidi Strobel
S11-S20:
Earl Cole
Todd Herzog
Cirie Fields
Natalie Bolton
S21-S30:
Malcolm Freberg
Mike Holloway
Ciera Eastin
Sabrina Thompson
S31-S40:
Davie Rickenbacker
Tai Trang
Janet Carbin
Victoria Baamonde
S41-S45:
Jesse Lopez
Kaleb Gebrewold
Carolyn Wiger
Shan Smith
Jelinskiiiii the real legend
You got a like from me when you mentioned V. Absolutely, she is a legend, and we need more seasons where the contestants bring their personal items.
Here's an idea for a fan cast: Survivor: Wild Cards. Basically just Cambodia: Second Chance 2, but with people who are NEVER considered for a returnee season, but probably should be. Stacy from Fiji, Matty from Gabon, Taj from Tocantins, RC from Phillipines, Trish from Cagayan, Nadiya from SJDS why not, etc. Really subjective but could be fun to consider.
Cochran has to be on this list (I know he said he was done) Id also go Kelley W in the 30s over Angelina if thats allowed since I think her first was 29 but she made her mark in the 30s.
I still want a Rivals season. They squandered the concept with Rob vs. Russell in Redemption Island. Two tribes made up on on screen rivals opposite each other.
Nice vid, but I think you’ve done yourself a disservice.
By sticking to 2M/2W from each decade and not excluding winners, you’ve got a cast that just isn’t as interesting to watch play ~yet another time~ as it could be, in my opinion.
So here’s my attempt (even gender split, 50% BIPOC, no season double-ups):
Gervase (S1)
Alicia (S2)
Kathy (S4)
Shii Ann (S5)
Cirie (S12)
Yau-Man (S14)
Fishbach (S18)
Phillip (S22)
Malcolm (S25)
Woo (S28)
Kelley (S29)
Aubry (S32)
David (S33)
Chrissy (S35)
Dom (S36)
Angelina (S37)
Devens (S38)
Shan (S41)
Jesse (S43)
Carolyn (S44)
Is it Legends? I don’t know.
Maybe Survivor: Icons
I reckon either a second chances season or an America v Australia season (top players from each series)… would make an epic season 50!
i would replace nat with wentworth only to have less WAW players, and dee with maryanne.
maybe todd instead of russell (less HvV players also).
hatch could replace boston rob and tina could take sandra's spot.
amanda could take parvati's spot and malcolm could take tony's.