I know this is just a joke, but logically, the operator would not close the doors. He would just get out of his cab, and walk to the end of the train and turn the rear cab on so now it's the front of the train. THEN he would close the doors. (Because it's the 42nd Street shuttle)
CGI so real I actually thought this was real lmao.1st not even possible to fill that train with that many apples.2nd how can you fill them with the top covered and are you can't walk through that 😂😂😂😂
Not many people realise that when folks go apple picking in New York, they don't mean going upstate. Instead, they travel the subway looking for the apple trains, that appear occasionally at subway stations across the city to let out all the apples that have grown inside them
Reminds me of stories from when I lived in Florida for a short time. I guess poor people or just bored people would follow the trucks hauling oranges because they'd constantly spill out over bumps and whatnot. So, there'd literally be orange truck chasers. Being behind an orange truck once there was indeed a good amount that ended up bouncing out (the backs of the trucks don't have covers. Think of it as a kind of dump truck).
Yes, Brian. As a New Yorker, I am impressed that you know of this. One major reason why the city is called the "Big Apple." The nefarious side to all of this is when people eat these types of apples, that grow inside of subway cars, they get apple mesomothelis, a fatal affliction in which an apple tree will grow inside of the intestines and grow to fourteen feet in six days, all inside the human body. Death is slow and painful. The apple subway growers association knows of this, but will not make it public. Best to stick with store bought Honey Kissed brand.
"I just want to express how impressed I am with the efforts put forth by this organization. From the exceptional customer service to the quality of their products, I have nothing but positive things to say. Keep up the great work!"
RUclips algorithm 2010: no one will see it 2012: still nothing 2014: better wait 2016: nothing yet 2018: we are almost there *2021: the moment has come, let's put it in the recommended*
*Have you realized that the same train they used in advertising still exists to this day and people ride on it* They'll never know that it was full of apples unless they see that ad
There are 3 theories on how they made this advertisement. 1st Theory: The metro was actually filled but with plastic apples instead of real ones. 2nd Theory: The scene was digitally remodelled and the apples are physic simulations that have been seemlessly overlayed onto the video using trackers. (Remember this was 11 years ago) Or they actually used real apples in the metro which defeats the entire purpose of the advertisement.
Looks only like 2 cars were simulated or filled... even if it was plastic that would be hella wasteful, but maybe resold as toys or smthn. Also the cleanup.
That was a project by City Harvest to first convert humans to apples so more can fit in the train, re-convert to humans at their destinations. Carry more people. 😆😂🤣😁
If everyone on earth blinked at the same moment it would be an amazing coincidence but nobody would ever notice because when it happened we’d all have our eyes closed.
Well first of all all of the apples that rolled out of the train and rolled onto the floor are fake. It's CGI. Second of all, the lady might have had a real apple that was already washed and they just had it on a table or something that was not visible.
@@jaydottt_transitfanner The ENTIRE video was a joke... Even this comment was a form of sarcasm. I think you should go read a grammar book to learn how that stuff works, ok?
Not only the graphics. The biggest give a way is the constant fast moving of the camera so you can never get good focus on whats going. Oldest cgi trick in the book, thats how they cover up terrible graphics.
Now my mouth is watering 🤤for Apple 🍏 pie but it’s 6.25 am. I woke up too early and it’s my day off 🥱. Maybe I should I just start making one. Yum😋 🥧🥧🥧🥧
Apples and Subway are just more than enough to make applesauce and caramel apple pies....... especially on the 42 Street /Midtown Shuttle Train Service. TOTALLY INCREDIBLE ⚠️🍏
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
The guy from the math problems coming home with the groceries:
lmao
Tru
Wait you coment 1days ago
But the video 10years ago
Lmao
Bro the guy from the math problems is taking it too far right now.
🤣🤣🤣
"Every day 475,000 pounds of food is wasted..."
So to prove a point they waste that much food in 1 second... O_o
Lmao that doesn't mean they have to waste another 475k pounds of food again
Also isn't that another waste of food...
Its cgi
Its cgi
Its 470,000 pounds not 475,000 pounds
Eat those dam apples. Have a nice day. *Closes doors*
Shamari Kinsey Railfanner - Munipals and Trains I am sub to you
And btw that is a funny saying
I know this is just a joke, but logically, the operator would not close the doors. He would just get out of his cab, and walk to the end of the train and turn the rear cab on so now it's the front of the train. THEN he would close the doors.
(Because it's the 42nd Street shuttle)
rip the apples that were in the way of the door
They predicted Descendants 2 with Apples.
I couldn't tell this was CGI until the apples started moving lol. That's insane! Awesome job
you think this many apples would be wasted for something like this? ofc its cgi
@@soulofartorias9928 You never know with those people. They stopped an "oil" truck to protest against pollution, and it was a cooking oil load.
and its from 2010! unbelievable
Thing is the video was uploaded 14 yrs ago 😮
The upload year is CGI
2010: You're not going to watch this
2021: Ok, I'll take a look at this
Accurate!
सही।
Right 👍
..
No one fucking cares.
It's hard to believe this is CGI it's so good
Combined with the CGI: Indeed.
the CGI is to the point where is give that uncanny valley effect, but for fruit.
@@lor3nz42s2 I cant tell what it is can u tell?
CGI so real I actually thought this was real lmao.1st not even possible to fill that train with that many apples.2nd how can you fill them with the top covered and are you can't walk through that 😂😂😂😂
I actually thought they got enough granny apples to fill the train up for just this video. Looks pretty impressive for 2010 standards.
Every rat in the subway: *_"Is this heaven???"_*
The Gods hath Spokenth
Clean up crew: *no it's not*
@@lyonidus3073 yes it is
This is why I hate atheists
@@no_one_333 bruh let them be...
Not many people realise that when folks go apple picking in New York, they don't mean going upstate. Instead, they travel the subway looking for the apple trains, that appear occasionally at subway stations across the city to let out all the apples that have grown inside them
Reminds me of stories from when I lived in Florida for a short time. I guess poor people or just bored people would follow the trucks hauling oranges because they'd constantly spill out over bumps and whatnot. So, there'd literally be orange truck chasers. Being behind an orange truck once there was indeed a good amount that ended up bouncing out (the backs of the trucks don't have covers. Think of it as a kind of dump truck).
Yes, Brian. As a New Yorker, I am impressed that you know of this. One major reason why the city is called the "Big Apple." The nefarious side to all of this is when people eat these types of apples, that grow inside of subway cars, they get apple mesomothelis, a fatal affliction in which an apple tree will grow inside of the intestines and grow to fourteen feet in six days, all inside the human body. Death is slow and painful. The apple subway growers association knows of this, but will not make it public. Best to stick with store bought Honey Kissed brand.
@goglowdaddy1686 you just created a shitpist SCP
That sound like an SCP.
(From the SCP Foundation, which deals with anomolise objects and creatures)
I love that!
Can confirm. Source: I'm an operator for one of the apple trains.
They took "An apple a day keeps the doctor away" to a whole new level.
The train prob has more apples inside than most of us have eaten apples
*🥁🔔*
That much amount is going to keep hospitals in that city closed for a week
Those apples destroyed the whole damn medical industry
a doctor a day keeps the apple away
I think I'm skipping maths class today, the new teacher is scary.
_o k_
@@onionring010 good babe
Uh. Ok? I HAVE NO IDEA!
Big ol bunny big ol bunny buckle up bunny
Finally got Raju who buys 1billion fruits for nothing🙄
😂 ..HE PLAYED MATHS WITH THE SHOPKEEPER....
Lol
ㅤ
@@therajugaming3954 damn chill with the apples
There is no money 🤑 man 🤣
Math quiz be like
Sam buy 1 trillion apple
and sell 345,123,123,987
How many apple did sam have now
🍎
"did sam left" ?
654,876,876,013 apples
You just copied that older comment and made it worse.
Ugh not sam
RIP the janitor
RIP the train tracks
RIP the people who drowned inside the apples
RIP to everything who got affected
Its a cgi
@@fansloverz it was a joke bro
@@georgiatrainz4517 okay
There's nothing everything
@@nojeansv she doesn't? she just has one she probably got out of her pocket
"Every day, 270,000 pounds of food is wasted in NYC."
* wastes 270,000 pounds of apples in 7 seconds *
That's the real reason why.
@@testing_oscar i know that
AMERICA IS WAST CONTRY
@@tandeljk4068 wast country, nice
Exactly
Yes 👍 👍 in world 🌎 very man are dieing
I wanted to See how the Doors Will Close...😂
CUT THE APPLES
APPLE JUICE
Fruit ninja
@@mightypurplelicious3209 😂😂
The teacher supposes that Juanito bought 200.000 apples my mind 0:14
Man, that’s a lotta apples
If there are 2 trains traveling twords each other full of apples and one is traveling at 100mph & the other is traveling at 70mph....
Normal days on new york
Sup null
Lol
Everywhere i go i see you.
normal days *on* New York
Hong Kong: those are rookie numbers
"150,000 people die everyday"
**Opens train to show 150,000 dead bodies**
Lmao hahaha
People did that back in time... in Germany.
@@Rabiscuz Poland*
@@slavicnonatho8062 Oh, that's true. My mistake.
@Trey Kumar mankind are really dark back in the day.
“270000 tons of food is wasted everyday”
* wastes 270000 Tons of apples *
Exactly
It's fake... 🤦🏻♂️
It’s cgi if you didn’t already know
@@milon470 its cgi apples its all fake even the voice on the speaker
470*
If anyone watching this from 14 years ago , you have a great life
Something you don’t see every day.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
No I see it at WTC Sometimes.
@@tapetay5859 fair enough
LOL
except in nyc
Now the question is, who the hell snuck all those apples onboard to begin with! They deserve a reward!
There are hatches on the top of the carriages that can be opened... i guess they just dropped the apples in through those hatches lol
It's CGI lol
It was probably the guy from our elementary school math problems.
ruclips.net/video/UxXlsA367vQ/видео.html
Have you seen jurassic park? 1993 and had the most groundbreaking CGI
A minute of silence for those who thought this was real!😁😁😁😁
😂😂😂😂fr I fooled so many people they all thought it was real
@Niko Peludo no it's CGI apples🤣🤣
@Niko Peludo 😁😁
@JELLYBEAN it looks so real
@@danjofromnyc4256 IKR work of art
"I just want to express how impressed I am with the efforts put forth by this organization. From the exceptional customer service to the quality of their products, I have nothing but positive things to say. Keep up the great work!"
10 years later on my recommended, epic.
Mine too! It'll actually be 11 years tomorrow!
なんじゃこれはwww今アメリカで起きてる事もこんな感じにいきなりサプライズな予感がする、、、w
そもそもどうやったらこんなに車両に入れられるんだよw
窓から放り込むw
アメリカはほんとに何をしたかったんだ？
アフリカに渡しに行こう
これが本当の貨物電車
RUclips algorithm
2010: no one will see it
2012: still nothing
2014: better wait
2016: nothing yet
2018: we are almost there
*2021: the moment has come, let's put it in the recommended*
Overused meme
Well at this point I will watch anything youtube recommends me. I've watched so many random videos that the recommendations have become similar.
@@billyanimation9757 in Russia we call it as “bayan”
2019 and 2020: ARE WE A JOKE 2 U?
Leo from the Math Question unloading his purchase:
11 years later and those apples are probably still getting cleaned up by people, rats and roaches.😆
It's not real it's 3d model and tracked by a PC lol
@@blenderts prolly they meant it as a joke ...even if it was real there's no way they would still picking up the apples lol
its cgi bro
@@svenskatag5989 he is literally joking
@@PmerjYT yes, because he thinks it's real
0:15 this make me laugh so hard😂😂🥰
i dont know why i put the love emoji😂
@@yohannabarandiaran9383 who cares?
@@RumanujjamanOntu Your MoM
@@RumanujjamanOntu You replied to them, so you do
😐
This is a masterpiece of a million free apples!!
This was way ahead of its time.
I remember watching this on RUclips 10 to 11 yrs ago on a computer cafe, time flies tf
@isleepnow8066 but do you remember commenting that 6 months ago?
@@GoodFuude But do you still remember your reply after 12 days?
0:14 perfect aim of the cameraman
Lol 😂
Sldbfjsbdkdbfjdbdjdbfkdbfjdbdjf
Men 🚽
This comment is from 3yrs ago, has anyone got nostalgia from this?
@Bruh404-i4e dbfbfbf
*Have you realized that the same train they used in advertising still exists to this day and people ride on it*
They'll never know that it was full of apples unless they see that ad
Well actually, people wouldn't know unless they look at the car number
They're too busy looking down at their smartphones and laptops.
@CringeHub I looked up the car number and yep! It’s a real R62A. Looks like it ran on the shuttle.
One car number would be 1930
@@jaydottt_transitfanner it’s called a fleet number
This is the best thing I’ve seen all day
日本の方どれくらい見てますか？🙋
見てます
✋('ω')ｽｯ...
理解できぬ
何が起きてるのかわからん
の
Very good рекомендации!
О привет, fellow brony
Very good английский
Это все for real?
@@vmusatov Neт
@adhithya English язык
How is no one talking about how this is a really good ad?
There are 3 theories on how they made this advertisement.
1st Theory: The metro was actually filled but with plastic apples instead of real ones.
2nd Theory: The scene was digitally remodelled and the apples are physic simulations that have been seemlessly overlayed onto the video using trackers. (Remember this was 11 years ago)
Or they actually used real apples in the metro which defeats the entire purpose of the advertisement.
Looks only like 2 cars were simulated or filled... even if it was plastic that would be hella wasteful, but maybe resold as toys or smthn. Also the cleanup.
secondavenuesagas.com/2009/12/05/weekend-video-a-subway-full-of-apples/ no evidence though, but they say CGI.
its cg for sure, looks better because its in 360p, but its obvious
首先要裝這些蘋果已經不可能達到，車輛必須傾斜而鐵路公司通常不會有這種設備，而且注意片尾的蘋果流動很不正常。
very clear simulation
That was a project by City Harvest to first convert humans to apples so more can fit in the train, re-convert to humans at their destinations. Carry more people. 😆😂🤣😁
nice
ngl this render still holds up pretty decently
Yeah I was genuinely surprised to see that
A. The video quality hasn't been compressed to hell by RUclips yet
B. The render is actually convincing
Imagine how good it would look if done now
@@PrestonFrankel convincing enough that i believed it was real lol
Imagine if City Harvest happened 13 years later; and MTA would recreate this scene this time with an R211 full of apples! o-0
In another 11 years I would come again to here
That's some pretty convincing effects for 2010
If everyone on earth blinked at the same moment it would be an amazing
coincidence but nobody would ever notice because when it happened we’d
all have our eyes closed.
At any given time, millions of people are asleep. They won't blink.
Wow
@@mrinalraj499 Oh yeah, that's totally what the issue is, if not for that, it would be totally possible for everyone to blink at the same time.
It makes it completely impossible as opposed to very unlikely
🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏
this should be a 2008 commercial for city harvest
2010: Apples riding the subway train.
2021: iPhones riding the subway train.
Lol
This video never gets old 😂
Also an apple
急におすすめ出てきた人おる？
Xing xong bakuretsu yametekudasai
Boku no pico
Boku to misaki sensei
Dubai Subway: 😌
China Subway: 😌
New York Subway: 💀
☠️☠️☠️
Lady, don't you know there are a lot of bacteries in subway, and you take apple from a floor?
WELL SHE MIGHT WASH THEM
Well first of all all of the apples that rolled out of the train and rolled onto the floor are fake. It's CGI. Second of all, the lady might have had a real apple that was already washed and they just had it on a table or something that was not visible.
@@jaydottt_transitfanner DAMN you got a good brain and whats up with these hub names
@@Sunlightcee LOL
@@jaydottt_transitfanner The ENTIRE video was a joke... Even this comment was a form of sarcasm. I think you should go read a grammar book to learn how that stuff works, ok?
To whoever is worried about the apples being wasted: Look at it closely, it's obviously fake and CGI. It's not real so don't get upset
I never thought you would be here
It's funny though
But if NYC subbway really did this I would be like we eating good gonight
👌🏼😏👌🏼
Not only the graphics. The biggest give a way is the constant fast moving of the camera so you can never get good focus on whats going. Oldest cgi trick in the book, thats how they cover up terrible graphics.
Train: 1,0000 apples keeps
1,0000 doctors away
Doctors: *disintegrate *
XD
You don't know how to use commas
@@builditwecan2082 You're not a gammar teacher.
@@builditwecan2082 common, baby
@@OOXXOXOXX did u mean common or C'mon?😂
A message we need to be seeing hearing everywhere!!!
急にオススメに出てきた日本人の方います？
いないっす。
いません
なう(2021/05/03 03:58:45)
はい！
(^_^)/同じくー
Teacher: the math question isn’t hard
The math question:
Huh? Ur not funny and it made no sense
what a well made ad.
really good for the time.
Be honest
You watched this video in ur childhood
No 😅
Yes
最近のCGはすげーな！！！（すっとぼけ）
ほんとすげえよなぁ(すっとぼけ)
11年前のCGすげえなぁ
現代の技術にも勝るとも劣らない(すっとぼけ)
Let’s pour one out for the unfortunate souls who don’t realize that this is CGI and not actually real apples.
I would honestly be shocked if they actually filled that train with apples.
@@JGProductions6581 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆🍪
man this render was glorious back in the day
“John bought 100 apples. Dick bought 27462853 apples, how many apples do they have in total”
City harvest: stop wasting food!
Also city harvest:
Wastes apples by leaving them on the ground
It's obviously fake apples or CGI
@@jaydottt_transitfanner was gonna say that, because why would they waste all those apples while saying don’t waste food
It’s CGI dummy.
Yeah they hipocrite
**slow clapping** accompanied by 🤦♂️
Man I remember when this was cutting edge... still looks good... if very blurry
now probably random person will render it in blender
Бабушка: возьми пару яблок с собой
Я: не хочу
Бабушка: ВОЗЬМИ
Я дома:
😂😂😂😂 prend quelque pomme 🍏🍏
аххахх
Поезд от бабушки с брайтон бича
школьник, БРЫСЬ!
I guess the train driver thought what they said”An Apple A Day Makes A Great Day.
What an abundance of apples! Incredible!🍏🍏🍏🤔
😮
@@warunggrevand678 😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏 🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏
overapple of apples a@@luca_playz_stuff
"it's cgi" 🧐🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓
Such a New York way to make such a simple point. Ruthlessly ingenious.
It Ohio
@@lucijan96Plays 🥺🥺🥺
Iam seeing After 12 years
This video never get the oldnest
only you got old
13年前にこのCGが作れるのがすごい
bangladesh is better, I live in bangladesh, I love in bangladesh
@@rajbiswas1606 うざい子黙れ
@@rajbiswas1606 Allahuakbar 💣
Iron Man came out in 2008, dumb
@@Derek-b9cアンパンマン？！
*A P P L E L I V E S M A T T E R*
No apples were harmed during the making of this video
No apples were harmed lol, the apple society will be okay with that
Who watch this for 1st time 2024🙋♂
The student who got answer as 17 million apple in maths exam
God damn, this is great CGI.
somebody explain how the hell this is done so good
so how many apples you want?
city harvest: y e s
How tf i smelling the apple thru the screen💀💀💀
Good to know 14 million people got this on their recommendation list
this is the funniest video in my life i laughed so hard lol
“Everyday millions of food is wasted” proceeds to waste around a billion apples.
Now my mouth is watering 🤤for Apple 🍏 pie but it’s 6.25 am. I woke up too early and it’s my day off 🥱. Maybe I should I just start making one. Yum😋 🥧🥧🥧🥧
John is fr gonna feed his family of 5 for 2470 days with those 475000 apples
Hmm, suddenly in everyone's recommendation 😄🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏
駅員｢どうぞ、この青リンゴすべて食べてください｣ww
草www
日本人いて安心した
むしろ食べないと入れないze⭐
I don't speak yamete kudasai
それなww
日本人いて安心しましたw
i can imagine the apples getting crushed when the door closes-
Derrick:How to show we’re wasting food Jim?
Jim: waste more food!
Derrick: Jim, you gotta gift!
It's actually CGI.
The early 2000s was something else 😂gotta luv it
11 years ago was 2010. The 2000s technically just ended.
1 Apple:😁
10 Apples:☺️
10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Apples:😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫
1 minute silence for people who thought this was real
Fr
@@timeshare1444 F
When life gives you apples you make a apple juice
Dang! wish it was a train full of apple crisp! ❤
Subway door: Finally,a worthy opponent
I remember seeing this as a kid and thinking I could've fed all of africa with those apples.
@@craiglittleton2006 You misunderstood the comment
The train driver was very sick but he's afraid of doctors.
You're a legend if you get it
the joke is that an apple a day keeps the doctor away
and 270,000 apples a day keeps 270,000 doctors away
@@ayoutubechannel8925 I think 270.000 apples keeps the doctor away for 270.000 days
which keeps them away for 739.72 years
e
a
They say we waste food but when the doors open apples fall onto the tracks
typical day in subway, but suddenly... apples...
Eating a burger with no honey mustard
@@jaydottt_transitfanner YOU CAN’T DO THAT, YOU MADMAN!
Apples and Subway are just more than enough to make applesauce and caramel apple pies....... especially on the 42 Street /Midtown Shuttle Train Service.
TOTALLY INCREDIBLE ⚠️🍏
Alternative title: How to waste good apples with subway
It’s cgi
WOW this video is so good, 👍👍👏👏😎😎
0:14
*We’ll Be Right Back*
Maybe 2 years later u regret commenting this or not since I've told you.