Thank you Jeff - Hello Jeff I am Prabachan just a casual wannabe a singer kid and i had started to work on my vocals about a year ago not exatcly a year but i can seee massive massive like heaven to hell difference in my vocals im a tenor and i used to do this video of yours called tenor vocal warm ups comprehensive which is for 40 whole minutes and i do other exercises too but this one helped me soooooooo much so i jst wanted to say thank you and i appreciate u taking ur time in youtube❤️and to All THE NEW PEOPLE THAT WANT TO LEARN HOW TO SING: This actually works 😂 at first i thought of this as nonsense aswell but this is just ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ and by this i mean vocal exercises not particularly this video🌝I do these exercises for 2 to 3 hours daily and it improved me,really 🙈
This has been a great tool; thank you for introducing us to it! Odd, but the 5th has been the hardest to learn. The others all kind of 'lead' my ear somewhere, but that 'sol' is a big blank, to the point that I can reliably identify it by what it doesn't do.
Hello Jeff, I love your videos big time but these ear training videos well, sorry I just do not find them useful. I support you and subscribed to your channel but these are not good enough for beginners at all. What you're showing means that the singer has already engraved the major scale to both directions. Also you show up and down in the first video it's very confusing. This approach is exactly what causes problems for many. It jumps right into the middle from the beginning causing stress and frustration. I would recommend renaming these videos like ear training for intermediate student. For beginners they really need to even engrave half step and whole step. You're excellent and I honor you but it's a very advanced approach for advance students. Sorry just my feelings. Have a great day!
Thanks for your input, but I must respectfully disagree. In the first video, I start off with just a few notes taken from the major scale in a limited range with quite detailed instructions on how to sing and find 'do' in order to get a sense of the construction of the scale. In that video, I also mention taking one's time and slowly adding one scale degree at a time. What we're developing is an aural concept of the major scale, slowly over time. In this video, I very clearly mention that one would have to have done all the notes in the major scale, in other words, completed what had begun in the first video. I thank you for your input, and will consider it in moving forward. All the best! Jeff
@@JeffRolka thanks and I highly appreciate your answer! True but being able to sing from a note back to the tonic (ascending or descending in video 1) as you showed in the example requires quite advanced aural skills already which for someone who is a music study graduate as you seems trivial but for someone with basic skills is hard or impossible. I do apologise I am not questioning your method I just find that saying it’s stage one for beginners is not entirely appropriate. Either way you rock and your singing videos are one of a kind and I love you and your work!
I love love LOVE all of your lessons, teaching and advice! Thank you so much for posting regularly. You ROCK 🪨👏!
Thank you Jeff - Hello Jeff I am Prabachan just a casual wannabe a singer kid and i had started to work on my vocals about a year ago not exatcly a year but i can seee massive massive like heaven to hell difference in my vocals im a tenor and i used to do this video of yours called tenor vocal warm ups comprehensive which is for 40 whole minutes and i do other exercises too but this one helped me soooooooo much so i jst wanted to say thank you and i appreciate u taking ur time in youtube❤️and to
All THE NEW PEOPLE THAT WANT TO LEARN HOW TO SING:
This actually works 😂 at first i thought of this as nonsense aswell but this is just ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ and by this i mean vocal exercises not particularly this video🌝I do these exercises for 2 to 3 hours daily and it improved me,really 🙈
Thank you so much for watching and thank you for your kind words! Keep up the awesome work!!!
Best,
Jeff
There is a second part! Awesome, thank you.
This has been a great tool; thank you for introducing us to it! Odd, but the 5th has been the hardest to learn. The others all kind of 'lead' my ear somewhere, but that 'sol' is a big blank, to the point that I can reliably identify it by what it doesn't do.
:-) Bravo.
Hello Jeff, I love your videos big time but these ear training videos well, sorry I just do not find them useful. I support you and subscribed to your channel but these are not good enough for beginners at all. What you're showing means that the singer has already engraved the major scale to both directions. Also you show up and down in the first video it's very confusing. This approach is exactly what causes problems for many. It jumps right into the middle from the beginning causing stress and frustration. I would recommend renaming these videos like ear training for intermediate student. For beginners they really need to even engrave half step and whole step. You're excellent and I honor you but it's a very advanced approach for advance students. Sorry just my feelings. Have a great day!
Thanks for your input, but I must respectfully disagree. In the first video, I start off with just a few notes taken from the major scale in a limited range with quite detailed instructions on how to sing and find 'do' in order to get a sense of the construction of the scale. In that video, I also mention taking one's time and slowly adding one scale degree at a time. What we're developing is an aural concept of the major scale, slowly over time.
In this video, I very clearly mention that one would have to have done all the notes in the major scale, in other words, completed what had begun in the first video.
I thank you for your input, and will consider it in moving forward.
All the best!
Jeff
@@JeffRolka thanks and I highly appreciate your answer! True but being able to sing from a note back to the tonic (ascending or descending in video 1) as you showed in the example requires quite advanced aural skills already which for someone who is a music study graduate as you seems trivial but for someone with basic skills is hard or impossible. I do apologise I am not questioning your method I just find that saying it’s stage one for beginners is not entirely appropriate. Either way you rock and your singing videos are one of a kind and I love you and your work!