Happy late birthday Edie! You’re such a special and loved princess ❤ Edit: omg stop ranting on in the replies, is this the backlash I get for wishing a young girl happy birthday? I really have no faith in humanity anymore..and how do you know that the father is exploiting her? Do you know them? No, therefore you have no right to give out to her and her father, people are terrible on the internet…
Now here's the kind of content we should be getting. No changing gender shit, no making the audience wonder if the boy is okay, just pure happiness altogether. Late, but happy birthday Edie!! - responses to the people supporting this: i completely get what youre trying to say, however once again edie is/was of too young an age to decide life-changing matters, at just 4 years old. thus my point about the father's parenting. at what point did he decide to sit down and have a chat with edie about sex and who he'd like to have sex with later on in life? if you've ever had normal, non-grooming parents you'll realise that you've never, EVER thought of that as a child. to make this ordeal worse, the father is placing this all on social media, i daresay he's promoting toddlers changing genders. he's milking views out of edie, taking advantage of his already horrible childhood to plaster him all over social media. now tell me, is this behaviour in a parent normal? it's not fine to hide behind beliefs that we should be fully supportive of ANYONE who is trans, and call anyone who disagrees a transphobe.
This comment makes me sad, but oh well, not everyone can have the same opinion. Just please, learn how to be respectful, you seem like you need a bit of it.
Can’t believe she did the rock climbing wall! I could never 😂 Sounds like she had fun! Edit: They are a “she” not a “he” y’all it ain’t that hard to understand. You must be low in life to misgender a *child* on purpose.
Such a beautiful girl isn’t she? It’s unfortunate she wasn’t born in the right body, that would have made it so much easier, but I’m glad she’s showing her true self
@@Swiftie13life5 I was once a hater, but then I realized, some people are just born in the wrong body, I don’t know if sounds wrong or not, but Edie is a much better girl than boy, and the reason is because she was born in the wrong body, she should’ve been born in a girl’s body but something happened and it somehow changed her biological gender, but she always was a girl, even before she transitioned
as you get older you no longer have parties, I’m turning 11 and stopped having parties when I was 9. Now I just have a day out with 2 friends and sleepover
That sounds like the best birthday ever!! ❤❤❤ I'm so happy Edie has a friend like libby. It takes an amazing friend to except the change that has happened to Edie. Send them both my love 💓 ❤️ 😍 💖 ❣️ 💕 💓
Happy late Birthday edie! and side note to others don't h!te you can tell shes not being forced shes happy she has a good life and even though her dads in every video, hes not a bad dad,hes nice he cares about his daughters happiness and thats all that matters.
It's not just Libby it's the random people aswel. It's against the law for him to show random people's face's and some people don't want to be seen on the internet. I'm sorry to say this but he must be the biggest idiot if he hasn't looked at the British laws.
@@keiracurto9702 eh no it isn't the same actually and the fact he is using random people's faces on RUclips suggests that he is breaking the English law's it's fine if he has consent but some people like to not have there face's pictured on social media
I'm really starting to think that the dad had something to do with it because I mean he seems a little fruity as well, and they get caught up in lies all the time, a child at 3 and 4 years old can't even make up their mind of what is their favorite color, if you were to a skate 3 or 4 year old what they want to be when they grow up there are more than likely going to say fire truck and a princess so why would you guys change HIS Sex because he probably said he loved the color pink and that was it no talking no trying to correct nothing, my son says the same thing about the color but I'm sure to let him know that pink is for girls / women he wanted to wear his cousins little princess shoes and guess what didn't let him told him they do look nice but again they are for girls and guess what I went and got his shoes and boom never again
@@jeremybaxter1676 I refer to the child as Eduardo as it’s likely that “Edie” isn’t really transgender. It’s not out of disrespect, I’m saying the child’s real name because it’s true that he’s being abused. There’s a difference between being genuinely transgender (where I always use someone’s preferred name no matter what) and cross-dressing.
Happy birthday Edie! U are getting so big. Also don’t mind the haters their insecure about themselves. Ur a beautiful *princess* I can’t BELIVE ur already 10 years old sweet *girl*
Doing this to a child is only depressing and is absolutely abuse. Poor boy, a father is supposed to lead his son to manhood and both physical and emotional strength. Don't try to shape him into what he's not. This is just irresponsible and you must -not only should- be ashamed of yourself.
So I watched this on shorts and when I scrolled down the first thing I heard was someone saying “my mom always thought me to go all out for birthdays “lol😂😂
Happy birthday!!!! I hope you have a lovely day. I need to go to gravity. That looks so fun. I've been to clip n climb witch was super excilerating. Best wishes!
@@boredburger okay since you think that child is a boy in what ways would you encourage the child to be more boy like since you are saying this out of compassion i assume
@@laurenrideout1584some things, you can't change or choose in life, like, gender, age, ethnicity... etc. If im white., And i tell you: from now on im a black guy. Would you also agree with me that im black? because that's what i told you?
@@laufey_luvver again... some things, you can't change or choose in life, like, gender, age, ethnicity... etc. If im white., And i tell you: from now on im a black guy. Would you also agree with me that im black? because that's what i told you?
All of these haters need to stop. My wife came out as transgender in October, just before her 42nd birthday. She has been feeling transgender since she was 8 years old but didn't feel safe enough until just now. She went almost 40 years hiding and being afraid of her authentic self because of society like you who don't understand and who hate. She had severe gender dysphoria and has scars all over her body because she is completely disgusted by her male body. She would have given everything to have been open as a little kid and been on hormone blockers before she went through puberty. Just because you are comfortable in what your chromosomes say you are, doesn't mean that everyone is. It's extremely difficult being transgender, especially because of how society treats them. Nobody would willing choose to be transgender. People are transgender because their brain tells them they are in the wrong body AND THAT'S OK!!!! They should be allowed to live the way that they feel is right for them. We live in Missouri and because of the ban on all gender affirming care, we have to move out of the state. Missouri has been my wife's home for her entire life and has been mine for the past 10 years. We LOVED it here and wanted to spend the rest of our lives within Missouri's borders but because of the hatred of politicians, we have to flee our home. Who would willingly choose to claim being transgender and be kicked out of their home, if there really wasn't a difference between their chromosomes and what their brain says. Look up the enormous amount of scientific research that proves transgender is real. Stop spreading lies that children are having surgery and irreversible hormones. NOTHING is done on children that is permanent.
@@VibecatThetrilogy ????? What about empathy?? You do realize that this little boy is being fed all this nonsense on a silver plate? If he reaches puberty and adulthood he could regret all of this terribly, and even hate his parents for not protecting him, helping him, and raising him correctly. If surgery is done for this oblivious little boy, he'll lose the ability to reproduce forever, and if he's given hormone through puberty, changes will occur in his body that he may absolutely regret. This child may die to medical complications concerning gender changing, and if not, he may commit suicide, even if he seems happy that he's "become a girl". Right now his brain and thoughts are being muddled with. I don't want his body, hormones, and biological functions to be muddled with as well. You can't leave a child this young alone without supervision... Just because he seems happy doing it, doesn't mean it's good for him or safe at all for that matter. Children depend on us adults for protection, safety, and guidance, we can't let them down in such a nonsensical way. I don't think you realize how phsycolohically and physically dangerous this is for all humans and especially children.
Happy late birthday Edie! You’re such a special and loved princess ❤
Edit: omg stop ranting on in the replies, is this the backlash I get for wishing a young girl happy birthday? I really have no faith in humanity anymore..and how do you know that the father is exploiting her? Do you know them? No, therefore you have no right to give out to her and her father, people are terrible on the internet…
He is a boy
She has stated many times she is a girl, if you listen you would know this xx
@@GromitInAbottleacting like a woman does not make you one
@@GromitInAbottlebro his dad exploited him and forced him to be a girl for clout TF U on abt
Bro she’s trying to be nice and everyone’s just talking about how she’s trans?
Now here's the kind of content we should be getting. No changing gender shit, no making the audience wonder if the boy is okay, just pure happiness altogether. Late, but happy birthday Edie!!
-
responses to the people supporting this:
i completely get what youre trying to say, however once again edie is/was of too young an age to decide life-changing matters, at just 4 years old.
thus my point about the father's parenting. at what point did he decide to sit down and have a chat with edie about sex and who he'd like to have sex with later on in life? if you've ever had normal, non-grooming parents you'll realise that you've never, EVER thought of that as a child.
to make this ordeal worse, the father is placing this all on social media, i daresay he's promoting toddlers changing genders. he's milking views out of edie, taking advantage of his already horrible childhood to plaster him all over social media.
now tell me, is this behaviour in a parent normal?
it's not fine to hide behind beliefs that we should be fully supportive of ANYONE who is trans, and call anyone who disagrees a transphobe.
Fax
I wish the world is happier
This comment makes me sad, but oh well, not everyone can have the same opinion. Just please, learn how to be respectful, you seem like you need a bit of it.
@@christian.jay2011 ikr
STOP hating, let them be them, ok?
Can’t believe she did the rock climbing wall! I could never 😂
Sounds like she had fun!
Edit: They are a “she” not a “he” y’all it ain’t that hard to understand. You must be low in life to misgender a *child* on purpose.
I tried to do rock climbing when I was her age and I got all the way to the top and started sobbing because I was deadly afraid of heights
Sameeee❤😂
Same
He*
@@Jamiraquai- she*
Happy birthday Edie! :D Hope you had an awesome birthday!
Happy late birthday Edie! Hope you had the best bday ever ❤
Awwww your kids are soooo adorable and cute 🥰 together I love them so much they deserve to have a great family and home 🏠
We should get this kind of content. Happy birthday Edie! Sorry I am sooo late
did any notice that their dad has some peloton swag 😨😨😨
HAPPY BIRTHDAY GIRLY! SENDING ALL THE LOVE ❤❤
Happy Birthday !!! Hope you have a great birthday!!!!
Such a beautiful girl isn’t she? It’s unfortunate she wasn’t born in the right body, that would have made it so much easier, but I’m glad she’s showing her true self
@@MTNShortsOfficial ya I agree 👍
@@Swiftie13life5 I was once a hater, but then I realized, some people are just born in the wrong body, I don’t know if sounds wrong or not, but Edie is a much better girl than boy, and the reason is because she was born in the wrong body, she should’ve been born in a girl’s body but something happened and it somehow changed her biological gender, but she always was a girl, even before she transitioned
@@MTNShortsOfficial it's sad when some was born in the wrong body
My birthday was 2 days before anyways happy birthday Edie❤🎉
@ingabraske695 Happy Birthday To You
Tysm:)
Happy birthday Edie! You are so beautiful!
Happy birthday Eddie!! 🤗
Happy birthday edie!!❤*omg 41 LIKES TYSM*
It’s Edie btw 😊
@@Editsofchannels oh im so sorry
How o.d is she
Old
@@samaustin2441 9
Happy Birthday, Edie! You're so precious, and I hope you have a great life!
Happy birthday 🎈🎂
Grown ass man being a creep
Hope she had a great birthday
as you get older you no longer have parties, I’m turning 11 and stopped having parties when I was 9. Now I just have a day out with 2 friends and sleepover
@croissantslay Happy Birthday To You
Happy birthday edie!! You are a blessed little girl to have such amazing supportive parents and family and friends! ❤❤🎉🎉
Boy* can’t change the fact
@@bundx no* can't change your stupid intolerance
@@bundx you can legally change that fact
@@alexzacuber 💀
@@bundx oh it sounds like someone is being an dumba$$
🎉Happy Birthday Edie!🎉
Happy Birthday To You Edie
Happy Birthday, Eddie.🎉🎉
happy birthday! i don’t usually support ur channel but still birthday wishes to him/her
This Channel is just parents forcing their agenda on their kid
Delete her and never look back
@@achillcapybara W the rapist
@@Emmandt😂💀
Agreed, I feel like you shouldn’t introduce things like genders, sexuality and legally changing your name until you are at least 13
That sounds like the best birthday ever!! ❤❤❤ I'm so happy Edie has a friend like libby. It takes an amazing friend to except the change that has happened to Edie. Send them both my love 💓 ❤️ 😍 💖 ❣️ 💕 💓
im uber late but this is adorable! happy Birthday Edie!!!!
Hope you had great fun Edie and fam ❤
Sorry and Livi ❤
Happy Birthday Edie!! Hope you had a good one dear, and Jonathon, I'm happy that all of you are doing well! ^^
Happy birthday! Ik I am probably late but happy B-day Edie!
ALSO HAPPY BDAY WISH U THE BEST😭💖
Awww I love u guys
Happy late Birthday edie! and side note to others don't h!te you can tell shes not being forced shes happy she has a good life and even though her dads in every video, hes not a bad dad,hes nice he cares about his daughters happiness and thats all that matters.
Ikr!
His dad that seems a little fruity as well.
Happy birthday Edie!!
And just when I thought the dad might not be in every video for once!!!
Happy birthday sweet girl!! Looks like a great time 🎉
He's a boy.
He’s a boy, get it right
@Duolingo im not gonna argue with dumb people
@Duolingo They are talking about his first gender
@Duolingo he is a child he can't know if he is a trans at that age
Happy birthday- just please don’t show Libby’s face without a parents consent!
It's not just Libby it's the random people aswel. It's against the law for him to show random people's face's and some people don't want to be seen on the internet. I'm sorry to say this but he must be the biggest idiot if he hasn't looked at the British laws.
They probably did get consent
@@Littleozzybear oh really some random person gives consent just for walking past and doing what they do in everyday life
@@ZombieGaming-su5jw but the parents might have given consent and also why is ur comment the same as the other one😂
@@keiracurto9702 eh no it isn't the same actually and the fact he is using random people's faces on RUclips suggests that he is breaking the English law's it's fine if he has consent but some people like to not have there face's pictured on social media
Happy belated birthday edie 😊
This little boy deserves a good childhood with good parents. Unfortunately he isn't going to have that.
Use correct pronouns
FR tho
it’s sad you don’t realize your comments will not change anything and you are not her parent 😂
the little GIRL has a good child hood and great parents, I’m 14 and my parents don’t except me as a boy. I wish my parents were as amazing as Edie’s
I'm really starting to think that the dad had something to do with it because I mean he seems a little fruity as well, and they get caught up in lies all the time, a child at 3 and 4 years old can't even make up their mind of what is their favorite color, if you were to a skate 3 or 4 year old what they want to be when they grow up there are more than likely going to say fire truck and a princess so why would you guys change HIS Sex because he probably said he loved the color pink and that was it no talking no trying to correct nothing, my son says the same thing about the color but I'm sure to let him know that pink is for girls / women he wanted to wear his cousins little princess shoes and guess what didn't let him told him they do look nice but again they are for girls and guess what I went and got his shoes and boom never again
OF COURSE HE HAD TO BE IN THE BIFEO
Happy birthday edie!! I swear you was at blue water 😂😂
Comment if you think Jonathan has a favorite child
Yeah k
Yeah, fair enough I can agree with this. But also having a favorite child is loki messed up
I think it’s Edie❤
We all know at this point 😅
"Edie decided to through all the socks at me" as you should queen!!!!!
Happy Bday Edie!!❤❤❤❤😊
Happy bday Edie!💖💖💖
*Un
@@Rehsials69420 ?
@@Rehsials69420 what?
@@meganthursby2002 he means unhappy
@@Rehsials69420 W
Happy birthday Edie god bless her soul
HIS soul
HIS soul
@@GgFC_zsc1911transphobe
@@GgFC_zsc1911transphobe
omg i love graVity! hope you had a lovely day! 🩷🩵🤍❤️
Happy birthday 🎈🎂 ( this is the content I like )
HAPPY BIRTHDAY GIRL IGNORE ALL THE HATERS ITS YOUR DAY!🎉🥳🪩
YES! HAPPY BIRTHDAY!
@@jeremybaxter1676 You’re right. We have nothing against the kid. The way Jonathan treats Eduardo is grooming. How can nobody see that? It’s obvious.
@@jeremybaxter1676 I refer to the child as Eduardo as it’s likely that “Edie” isn’t really transgender. It’s not out of disrespect, I’m saying the child’s real name because it’s true that he’s being abused. There’s a difference between being genuinely transgender (where I always use someone’s preferred name no matter what) and cross-dressing.
@@jeremybaxter1676 Jonathan was visited by Stacey Dooley on TV. How did she not ring the police?
@@jeremybaxter1676 And for a man who’s given his kids cold showers, I’m shocked Dooley did nothing.
For me, that would‘ve been a perfect birthday. Hope she had lots of fun!❤
'Boy'
@@Juicewrldfanpage1235oh so what it's HER birthday and u can't ruin it
@@tombarnes3718 nah it's a boy if your a boy u can't become a girl ☠️💀
@@tombarnes3718 he
@@tombarnes3718 he
I’m kinda late but HAPPY BIRTHDAY EDIE!!!❤️
Me:is this the first video that the dad isn’t in
The two clips of him at the end
Me:👁👄👁
OH MY-
Happybirthday Edie! Hope you have a wonderful time!
HAPPY BIRTHDAY EDDIE ❤ LOVE YOU!!! I HOPE YOU HAVE A GREAT LIFE!
Happy birthday I hope you had a great day🥳🥳
How is edie so pretty!? 😭❤
Hope edie had a very happy birthday alot of birthday wishes from me and my trans wife who show your family support whenever it'd needed
Happy Birthday Edie! I hope for your birthday you get better parents
Amen for that
fr
Um....
Fr
Agreed
Make all your kids a series they deserve it
Happy birthday Edie! U are getting so big. Also don’t mind the haters their insecure about themselves. Ur a beautiful *princess* I can’t BELIVE ur already 10 years old sweet *girl*
Aww 🥰 I hope Edie had lots of fun ❤
Happy Birthday Edie! I hope she had tons of fun 🎉
He
@@Africanmonkey89 She*
@@slaygurl196 He.
I will paste the entire book of Genesis if you dare deny me and the truth.
HEEEEE
LISTEN UP RESPECT HER PRONOUNS OR SIMPLY SCROLL
happy late birthday also glad she has a friend i hope they will be friends forever until they finish primary
Aw she is so happy❤❤❤ hope your b-day was amazing 🎉🎉🎉
#SaveEduardo
Happy b-day! It looked fun!
Yeeeeeessss
I was there i saw you guys you were having so much fun 🤩 ❤
✨️HAPPY B-DAY EDIE✨️
Happy birthday Edie!!! Have a great day
All of these comments are so robotic just repeating the same thing
Happy Birthday Edie
Thats the same gravity i went to for church lmao
Doing this to a child is only depressing and is absolutely abuse.
Poor boy, a father is supposed to lead his son to manhood and both physical and emotional strength.
Don't try to shape him into what he's not. This is just irresponsible and you must -not only should- be ashamed of yourself.
It will not take long before they turn the little guy in a girl😢
They're trying to shape him into what he's not.
This is just depressing.
I wish the little boy all the best.
Happy happy Chappy birthday ❤
Happy bday
I thought his name was Eddie
Yes but HER name is Edie
She changed her name she is Edie now
Happy late birthday I hope you had a great day🎉🎉🥳🥳
The way she says Livy as a baby is sooooo cute and happy bday Edie
bro what is wrong with you
Wow the dad makes it into every single video 💀💀
Happy late birthday I hope you had a amazing birthday your so brave for that climb I almost fainted having to do it once😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉
So I watched this on shorts and when I scrolled down the first thing I heard was someone saying “my mom always thought me to go all out for birthdays “lol😂😂
Happy birthday!!!! I hope you have a lovely day. I need to go to gravity. That looks so fun. I've been to clip n climb witch was super excilerating. Best wishes!
Happy birthday big boy!
Yeah boy not girl
@@skellybones9 ikr
Girl*
@@2-stepverification624 boy actually biological
@@boredburger okay since you think that child is a boy in what ways would you encourage the child to be more boy like since you are saying this out of compassion i assume
Omg gravity is an amazing place and I love the slushy x
Happy birthday!
THE WAY HE SAID Libby is so cute😢
Happy birthday Edie! May god bless you and your family. God he is such a beautiful child 💗🥰
Happy birthday… BUT WHY ARE YOU FILMING THE KID ON THERE BIRTHDAY i would want just a day to hang out with my friends but the dad HAS to get more subs
Awww happy late birthday edie!
P.s ik I’m very late 😢😅
Happy birthday, birthday boy 😊
OMg yes I love u for saying boy
Girl
@@laurenrideout1584some things, you can't change or choose in life, like, gender, age, ethnicity... etc. If im white., And i tell you: from now on im a black guy. Would you also agree with me that im black? because that's what i told you?
*GIRL
@@laufey_luvver again... some things, you can't change or choose in life, like, gender, age, ethnicity... etc. If im white., And i tell you: from now on im a black guy. Would you also agree with me that im black? because that's what i told you?
happy birthday edie make sure to wish for better parents
Happy Birthday 🎉 Edie hope you had a great day
I love that song calm down
All of these haters need to stop. My wife came out as transgender in October, just before her 42nd birthday. She has been feeling transgender since she was 8 years old but didn't feel safe enough until just now. She went almost 40 years hiding and being afraid of her authentic self because of society like you who don't understand and who hate. She had severe gender dysphoria and has scars all over her body because she is completely disgusted by her male body. She would have given everything to have been open as a little kid and been on hormone blockers before she went through puberty.
Just because you are comfortable in what your chromosomes say you are, doesn't mean that everyone is. It's extremely difficult being transgender, especially because of how society treats them. Nobody would willing choose to be transgender. People are transgender because their brain tells them they are in the wrong body AND THAT'S OK!!!! They should be allowed to live the way that they feel is right for them. We live in Missouri and because of the ban on all gender affirming care, we have to move out of the state. Missouri has been my wife's home for her entire life and has been mine for the past 10 years. We LOVED it here and wanted to spend the rest of our lives within Missouri's borders but because of the hatred of politicians, we have to flee our home. Who would willingly choose to claim being transgender and be kicked out of their home, if there really wasn't a difference between their chromosomes and what their brain says.
Look up the enormous amount of scientific research that proves transgender is real. Stop spreading lies that children are having surgery and irreversible hormones. NOTHING is done on children that is permanent.
Is it fine if I came out of bi at 10? Pls no hate
Was your wife a girl originally and turned to a boy? Orthe other way around?
@@TotallyxMadilynn You are 10. You don’t need to worry about your preferences that young.
@@everyhandleiwantedwastaken I’m 11 now
@@TotallyxMadilynn Well then, you are 11. You don’t need to worry about your preferences that young.
HAPPY BIRTHDAY EDDIE HAVE A GREAT DAY BIRTHDAY GIRL. OMG I WAS THE 11th PERSON WHO LIKED YOU ONLY POSTED 2 MINS AGO AHHH❤❤
I hope u tell her shes actually a boy and she should appreciating her gender and not understanding what trans is.
Thank you for using correct pronouns but she is a girl
Kids understand what being trans means lol
Not that Gravity being 8 minutes from where I live 💀
Hope she had the best birthday of her life ❤🎉
Very sad to see a father pushing his own mental confusion onto his own son. Hope this is stopped before its too late.😢
JUST STOP ALL READY HE DID NOTHING RONG
@@laurenrideout1584Learn to spell first and then maybe we can discuss this 😂
@@banditobella not really anything to discuss except why you feel so pressed about someone that has no association with you
@@VibecatThetrilogy ?????
What about empathy??
You do realize that this little boy is being fed all this nonsense on a silver plate? If he reaches puberty and adulthood he could regret all of this terribly, and even hate his parents for not protecting him, helping him, and raising him correctly.
If surgery is done for this oblivious little boy, he'll lose the ability to reproduce forever, and if he's given hormone through puberty, changes will occur in his body that he may absolutely regret.
This child may die to medical complications concerning gender changing, and if not, he may commit suicide, even if he seems happy that he's "become a girl".
Right now his brain and thoughts are being muddled with.
I don't want his body, hormones, and biological functions to be muddled with as well.
You can't leave a child this young alone without supervision...
Just because he seems happy doing it, doesn't mean it's good for him or safe at all for that matter.
Children depend on us adults for protection, safety, and guidance, we can't let them down in such a nonsensical way.
I don't think you realize how phsycolohically and physically dangerous this is for all humans and especially children.
@@SA-GE25 I don’t really give a shit
Happy birthday Edie hope you have a great time and make a big wish hope you enjoy every second of ot
Happy birthday I hope you had a great birthday
Y'all haters. Be respectful. Just let them exist without hate. Let them be who they wanna be. If shewant to be a girl. She can be a girl.