Holo Audio Spring 3 DAC Review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 июл 2024
- There are two brands of R2R ladder DACs that seem to be all the rage at the moment. One is Denafrips and the other, Holo Audio. I check out the, recently launched, Holo Audio Spring 3 DAC. Does it live up to the hype of being one of the finest sounding DACs for under £2,500?
Link to manufacturer's webpage
magnahifi.com/holo-audio-spri...
Link to my Patreon
/ abritishaudiophile
Link my Denafrips Ares II review
• Denafrips Ares II DAC ...
Link to my Denafrips Iris review
• Denafrips Iris DDC Review
Link to my Denafrips Pontus II review
• Denafrips Pontus II DA...
Time stamps
Intro 0:00
Design & features 2:23
Technical insights 4:23
Sound quality 11:50
Setup & partnering equipment 15:24
Conclusion 17:35
A wonderfully comprehensive review on a high quality product. Thanks Tarun, as ever your videos are a "must see" for someone interested in audio.
Thank you Richard. Very kind 👍😊👍
Greetings from sunny Malta, many thanks for your comprehensive and detailed reviews. This is very much appreciated for audiophiles like me who do not have the luxury of visiting and listen to audio equipment at their local Hifi store. Keep up the good work,
Thank you Daniel. That is great feedback 😊👍👍
Excellent review, thank you. I like that you showed the internals as well, and seeing it has optical decoupling is interesting.
Thank you Christian. Much appreciated 😊👍
Once again a superb review, excellent explanations and clarity. Thanks Tarun.
Thank you Caroline. I appreciate you watching and your kind words of support 👍😊👍
Thanks for your review that has been very helpful in choosing Pontas II or Spring 2 Dac. Started using Spring 2 and have been enjoying music.
Thank you for sharing Jonathan 😊
Nice review, Tarun. I especially liked the tour of the inside.
Thank you Eric 😊👍
Very Nice Review , very thorough & easy to understand & follow. I went with the Pontus2 , really nice solid piece. Sounds great, just a very clean, clear, detailed DAC with an amazing Sound Stage... Really looking forward to some serious listening sessions.. A+ for the Pontus2 .
Thank you for watching and sharing your experiences GT 😊👍
Methodology:
1. Watch a superb DAC review by Tarun,
2. Sit down in front of my system,
3. Choose music I most enjoy and that is likely to emphasise the tonality issues raised by Tarun,
4. Read about the concept of a DAC, the physics, and the manufacturer's notes and pedigree, and
5. Thoroughly enjoy myself.
Many thanks as always Tarun.
Thank you Michael. I am very flattered. I hope you have a great evening listening to your favourite music on your system 👍😊👍
Another excellent review Tarun. Thank you!!
Thank you Sandeep 😊👍
Good evening tarun, I've been very interested and impressed with the new R2 R dacs on the market, some very nice build quality and measurements as well, your review was very well informed and explained well to non audiophiles. I'm hoping to get to listen to said dacs soon if my local hifi retailers have them available, looking forward to seeing another review soon tarun keep up the good work.
Thank you for watching Paul. Please let me know how you get on with them, once you get a chance to audition. As always, I appreciate your support 😊👍
Fantastic review as always Tarun
Thank you Atri 😊👍
This is the level of construction I expect and desire to see. There’s something to be said of having options of excellence to choose from. This is the level of quality I have seen in Spectral Audio and Sutherland product lines. Well thought out layouts are not something new to this company. I’m not easily impressed, but this piece is well worthy of praise. This is what separates true craftsmanship from wannabes. Love to hear it. That is the true test. Listening for yourself in your system. It is where legends and decisions are made. Well done Tarun, bravo! Stay safe my mates!😊👍🏻😷
Thank you Mark. It is a very impressively built unit. A lot of pride of ownership with this one 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314, from the pictures and your review, this is clear. Listening in each person’s system is what will sell or fail this piece. Based on your analogy, it is based on perception and what you want as a listener. It will have to be tried in each person’s system to truly yield an answer for the perspective customer. Based on construction alone, I repeat my comments comparing it to Spectral Audio and Sutherland Engineering products. If you’ve heard either, you need not ask. You know what you like! Cheers!
Yes! Finally, but I still watch the others. Also just learned what linear actually means.
Excellent review. Out of my price range but I do appreciate how you describe these high end products. Keep up the good work.
Thank you Scott. Much appreciated 😊👍
No, this review is promoting a overprized product! Technics, maranz and Yamaha make superior products that include all sorts of streaming using superior DAC s! For the same price these products also include agood amp! The DAC industy is the new overprized snakeoil!
Your reviews are superb, thank you. I am very tempted to buy the Spring DAC now.
Thank you Jim. Much appreciated 😊👍
Great review. I recently purchased a May KTE. when connected to the source via coax the sound was good. As soon as I connected it via USB the sound was jaw dropping. This is an amazing DAC the measures well and sounds even better. Using it with HQ Player takes it up to another level
Thank you for sharing 😊
You shouldn't have to use HQ Player. Isn't NOS good enough?
@@johnratcliffe6438 NOS is very good, but I did find that upsampling did help on some recordings
Another great objective review Tarun. Thank you
Thank you Phil 😊👍
Great point about how good audio is today, especially at the lower-priced part of the market. Value for money is off the charts for everything audio. It wasn't always that way. I got into the avocation in the late 1970s. First, Dad's Dynaco, Acoustic Research, Rek-O-Kut/Shure system (which is still around, and to note, the ST-70 can still to this day be a lovely amplifier). Really good stuff was rare and mainly pricey. I got rid of all my large/heavy/complex/multi- chassis electronics and big floorstanding speakers largely due to a lack of space, but with how good all audio is today, I haven't lost anything, but gained even better performance at much lower cost, reduced footprint, and plug 'n play ease. We are in the best time of audio ever.
Thank you for watching and sharing your experiences Steven. Your dad had some great gear 😊👍
Another terrific review. It seems DACs are getting better every month!!
Thank you Richard. I really enjoyed my time with this one 😊👍
No, DAC s are not getting better at all! They are just snakeoil!
Hi Taran, I'm a bit late to the party but there is a reason. As always an excellent and informative review. I’ve a bit more cash available so was looking at the next level from these companies i.e Spring 3 KTE and Denafrips Venus II. Both are impossible to demo in the UK so we punters are totally reliant on reviews and forums of which there are quite a few but of variable quality and usefulness. Your site is one of the best I've come across and your equally instructive responses to comments also help. I couldn't choose between these 2 makes and I'm sure either would be highly satisfactory, but today I ordered the Venus II mainly because there was a UK dealer and the OS/NOS facility. I'm hoping your comments scale up, I'll let you know when I receive my new DAC. Thanks again and keep up the good work.
Thank you Andrew. Very much appreciated. I suspect the Venus II will be a great choice. Please let me know how you get on 👍😊👍
Denafrips NOS is not real. It’s marketing fluff.
Great explanation of this technology. I use an inexpensive r2r DAC from Schiit Audio using my Onkyo CD player as a transport and I wouldn't go back to using the onboard DAC. Thanks for a great vid.
Thank you Nick. Much appreciated 👍😊👍
Schiit makes multibit dacs though and not r2r no? Which schiit dac do u have?
True, it's not r2r dac, it's the Modi multibit. Very different sound than the Onkyo DAC.
Hey Tarun, thanks for a great review, always really helpful. I would love you to review the Denafrips Thallo amp, there aren't many reviews on this amp but it has been given high praise.
Thank you Anthony. Funny enough, I have that amp in to review at the moment 😊👍
Good review, liking the technical details section. R2R really stopped me disliking what I was hearing from the delta sigma technology.
BTW, I still have exactly the same E39 you featured.
Thank you John. Much appreciated. There was a lot to cover in this review. I have fond memories of that 5 Series E39 and the 3 Series E46. Great cars 🚗😊👍
Thanks Tarun this one is to rich for my blood but loved your review. Had seen a couple reviews now al good ones. Right now using a Bifrost but had looked into the Aries love it for my speed.
Thank you Robert. I appreciate you watching. The Ares II is the best bang for the buck out of all the DACs I have reviewed 😊👍
Great review, again. For me, ignorance is bliss - I really don’t notice all the finer qualities you mention, when listening to my music - so I’m happy, with a significantly smaller hole in my pocket 😀 But I did notice better dynamics when using the pre-amp of the Audiolab instead of the volume control on the RME ADI-2 DAC.
Thank you Jeremy. Great to hear from you 😊👍
Thanks Tarun, another excellent video. I have been eagerly anticipating this review as the Holo Spring 3 is joint top of my wish list with the Denafrips Pontus 2. It's going to be a tricky decision, but I'm tempted to push the boat out and go for a Spring 3 KTE version!
Thank you Ian. Much appreciated. That is a tough decision but either way you will have an excellent DAC. Just to add to your decision woes, the Denafrips Venus has the clocking mechanism of the Iris that I reviewed, plus other design enhancements. I wouldn’t overlook that option either 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Tarun, Not sure how to word it but isn’t the effectiveness of the better clock in the VenusII(USB input) as compared to the Iris-I2S-PontusII combination “lessened” by timing being a transport function? Learned this from you in the review of the Iris (around 9 minute mark) Not imagining that the better clock in the Venus doesn’t matter, just doing a different thing in the Iris.
Your reviews are among the most informative I’ve read. Thank you.
@@michaelperry3578 thank you for your kind words of support Michael 😊👍
The Iris takes a USB signal, cleans it up and, if using the I2S output, takes responsibility for the timing of information to the DAC. It reduces jitter compared to using the USB input direct to the Pontus II. The Iris’s clocking mechanism is identical to that of the Venus II ( from what Alvin at Vinshine informed me). By my reasoning that would make the Iris redundant when using the Venus II as it does the same job internally. I hope that makes sense 😊
@@abritishaudiophile7314 The Venus may be a bit overkill for me as I do already use a USB reclocker (SOtM tX-USBultra) between the streamer and the DAC
@@abritishaudiophile7314 This is news to me, thanks for explaining!
Excellent review as usual
Thanks Tim 🙂
Thank you for another intelligent review
Thank you my friend 😊👍
Nice review Tarun…and nice GMT master as well 😉
Thank you 😊
The Spring looks very well sorted inside and very pretty outside, I like the copper.
I agree. Thank you for watching Billy 😊👍
I ordered Spring 3 DAC after watching this review !
Thank you for the feedback Maaruks. I hope you enjoy it. Give it about 30 hours of use to run in and please let me know how you get on 👍😊👍
Brilliant review... detailed, paced, balanced. 👏🏻
Thank you Nuno. Very kind of you to say 👍😊👍
By the way Senhor T...KTE+pre spring 3...ordered.
@@nunoferraz5426 cool 😎 please let me know how you get on 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 will do
Thanks for another great review. Would love to see Holo Audio do smaller R2R DAC that you can use on a desktop (Ares II or Musician Pegasus sized).
Thank you GG. Much appreciated 😊👍
They do or did the Cyan DAC. Not sure if it is still available? 🤔
@@abritishaudiophile7314 I'd like a mini-holo may - newer design shrunken down :). The format of your reviews are great. You give inform from a variety of angles to satisfy different types of audio enthusiasts.
@@User_not_found_403 thank you GG. Very kind 😊👍
Great review. I wish I could hear these different dacs. I can only comment on what I have, a Questyle CMA400i and I think it sounds very natural. I hope you get to review a Questyle Dac sometime, would like to hear your comments on it.
Thank you for watching and your suggestion Jay 😊👍
Great review!
Thank you Mike 😊👍
I bought a Pontus 2 mainly because of this review. Wanted a Spring 3 but can't afford one yet, this review made me think that the Pontus was worth a try first.
Thanks, and excellent review!
Wow. That is great feedback. I hope you enjoy your Pontus II 😊👍
I know Jeff Zhu before the release of Spring 1. I was one of the users of the Holo Audio T.Rex 1704 DAC. This Spring 3 looks like an upgrade in the signal processing part like what he always pursue for years. I look forward to listen to it soon.
Very cool 😎 thank you for sharing 😊👍
Great reviews! Thanks
Thank you 👍
Thank you for the Holo vs Pontus 2 comparison. That was information I was very curious about. Perhaps next you can find an R2R DAC
which uses tubes & of the same $2k-$3k price range?
Thank you Jeff. I would love to do just that 😊👍
Thanks , that was an amazing review I
Thank you Trey. Very much appreciated 😊👍
Thanks! This does sound like a outstanding DAC and maybe one day. This year my disposable is going into a 77" OLED with the new EVO screen.
Thank you for watching Lonnie 😊👍
you always make me hungry when you describe things have to call you the audio chef lol
Sorry about that. Thank you for watching 😊👍
I respect your work sir!Next please review Gustard R26 if you have a chance!
Thank you. I will look into it 👍
Hello Tarun, first I would like to congratulate and give you may thanks for your transparent and fair reviews. Could you give a review about a technical interesting DAC. I’m talking about SONNET MORPHEUS DAC. cheers!!!
Thank you Luis. I appreciate the suggestion. I will look it up 😊👍
saw the holo on the back in previous videos, looking forward to watch this video. Denafrips still king? who knows!!
I hope you enjoy it EV 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 yes, great review!! I stay on ares2 for the long term, but looking forward to see a cheap holo in the future, or the next chord thing. Magna hifi are around the corner from here, bought from them my Singxer preamp, very nice people to deal with, you can trust them. Even via whatsapp they give direct support to customers Joris and company. They also carry hifiman headphones and I think audio GD, and more... Hifi is real!!! LOL
God bless the queen.
How is the importing stuff now from EU there? different price for each incoming country or not really or... ? Such a shame really...
@@exodusvelo thank you for sharing EV. The Ares II is a fabulous DAC. Distributors in the U.K. have faced all kind of supply issues due to Covid and Brexit. Hopefully, the worst is behind us 😊👍
Nice review again :)!! Guess what is driving my Kinki B7 mono blocks and S400s since two weeks. This thing rocks, especially with the preamp module it is one of the best value products on the market today. End game DAC / preamp for me. The combo with the B7 mono blocks is a match made in heaven to my ears :)! Final upgrade will be the S400 Mk2.
Hi Gerard what other DACs / preamps have you used in the past? I am also in the same upgrade journey and really looking at the Spring 3, L2 with Preamp module. I'm just skeptical if it'll make a noticeable enough difference. Also, what sources (USB), streamer, streaming subscription services have you used with it?
@@coolassloser One very important feature is the PLL, which removes jitter very effectively . I use it in living room environment, so for both music and tv/movies. This dac rewards good sources, but also sounds great with relatively noisy sources. It significantly cleaned up my tv sources (RUclips, cables, Netflix, ps5, etc) over optical. Streamer is Primare NP5. The difference with delta sigma dacs is night and day. I tried topping D90, Buchardt I150 with 9028 pro, Burson conductor (also sabre), RME adi 2. All sound lifeless and digital in comparisons. Also soundstage is completely different experience. With DS dacs it is more a wall of sound, whereas with R2R there is much more depth, layering, etc. Its sounds 3D and much more natural and real. Sometimes R2R in NOS mode can become too smooth, but the spring 3 strikes the right balance. All genres work well with it. It is also by far the most natural/musical experience I had. This is the first DAC with which I don’t get bothered by something in its presentation. It is also free of sibilance and sharpness. Decay structures, separation and timbre/tonality all are great. The preamp is also very clean and doesn’t add or subtract anything from the sound. Volume control is great and no loss in dynamics at all. You will love it if you already like the sound of your poweramp and speakers. The upgrade from 1k DS dacs is not small, is is huge in my opion. It is very close to the May DAC, that says it all. I also have a Merason Frerot. That one also sounds much better than any DS dac I tried, but that one was not so well controlled in the low frequencies. The Buchardt S400 are particularly sensitive to that with their passive radiator. The Spring is controlled even better than any DS dac in the bass department. This thing measures good, but more importantly sounds very good. It does deserve the best amplification you can get, because that is not something a DAC can fix.
Thank you Gerard. I would like to check out those Kinki amps at some point 😊👍
@@gerard3797 Awesome explanation and thank you for the wonderful retailed response. This gives me a lot more confidence. I actually have the RME ADI 2 fs w/ the AKM 4493. I’ll keep it for my headphone / office and do comparisons (if I go with the Spring 3). Obviously with lots of burn in time. I probably won’t go monoblocks but am thinking of pairing it up with the NAD C298. Hopefully it’ll be a good combo. If not, I’ll try something else.
@@coolassloser 👍 Break in is very real with the Spring 3, it takes at least 200+ hours. Also use a decent power cable, because that has a huge impact as well. I use Furutech The Empire and Puritan PS106 power conditioner.
Love your review structure, the explanations and most importantly the existence of COMPARISONS. The R2R market looks hot now. Any idea how the Holo Spring and the Denafrips Pontus compare to a similarly priced european solution like the Metrum Onyx?
Thank you my friend. Very kind. Unfortunately, I haven’t heard the Metrum as yet 👍😊👍
Awesome Review! Love your Video's ! Can you do a Video on good Streamers to use with the spring3 or May?
Thank you Tom 😊👍
Hi Tarun, excellent review as usual. I particularly liked the comparison to the Denafrips and the SMSL. I currently have the Lampizator Big 7 mk2 R-2R DAC which i love and I keep wondering how the Holo Audio May might sound in comparison……..it never ends!
Thank you Sujay. Much appreciated. I would like to check out the Lampizator DAC when the schedule clears 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 that will be very interesting. Looking forward to that
You have been fooled by the industri!DAC s are the new snakeoil! If you buy a good technics, maranz or Yamaha amp, you will get all streaming devices and DAC s included!
Thank You for another excellent in depth review. I followed what you were saying but couldn't repeat any of it. It sounds like you might be in for a new DAC, one or the other? I think DACs make a great difference in musical enjoyment. I went through several before I found one that sounded right and didn't cause any smoke to rise from my visa card. I know it sounds like a Schiit Parade from me, but I enjoy the Gungnir Multbit. No remote and no filters. Just good. I noticed you have some country music in your favorites. You might want to try All The Roadrunning by Emmylou Harris and Mark Knopfler. Light country but an elegant musical experience. Also great fun is Neck and Neck with Knopfler and Chet Akins. Some guitar amazing there. Thanks again. Love the reviews.
Thank you Lee. Sounds like you got the right DAC in the end. I have enjoyed both of those albums. I am a bit of a Mark Knopfler fan boy 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 It is i interesting how many films he scored. Another favorite is Steely Dan. Beckers arrangements are wonderful.
You should invest your money on better speakers or a better amp! If you can hear a difference between your DACs,then they are colouring or polluting the data.if you like the sound you should be happy!
Tarun, the reviewer on this site, has devoted hours upon hours of testing and commenting on the differences in DACs. I noticed you responded to me and not him. Please refer all demonstrably ignorant inquiries to him in the future. If you don't believe him (me)then what are you doing here? If Tarun is wrong about the differences in DACs why would you rely on anything he would say about any other gear? Why are you spending time reading reviews of things you don't believe in? There is a saying that applies to your comment. "Don't get down in the mud and wrestle with a pig, because you're just going to get dirty and the pig is going to like it"@@GeirRssaak
Very thorough and helpful review Tarun (as always). I have a question regarding the preamp module of the Spring 3. There don't appear to be any line-level inputs on the rear panel. Is the preamp section restricted to use with the digital inputs?
Thank you Bruce. Yes, it can only be used with the digital input of the DAC. It isn’t a standalone preamp 😊👍
Thanks for the awesome review Tarun!! I have been debating getting the Pontus 2 or the Holo Spring 3, L2 with Preamp module. You're the first reviewer that goes into comparison between your existing preamp vs the preamp module in the Spring3. Had some questions for you :)
1- Would you recommend pairing the Spring 3 (exact config as your review unit) to a Purifi-based Class D amp? Like the NAD C298? Or would you opt to pair it with a Hegel class AB? My speakers measure quite flat so I am wondering what amp I should combine the Holo S3 with.
2- What sources did you use with the Holo / Denafrips? Would a BlueSound Node be good enough to notice the Spring 3's full capabilities? I plan to use it direct USB to PC/Mac and Coax to Node. As always, highly appreciate your reviews and review style.
Thank you my friend. The Spring 3 imparts very little character on the music so I am sure it will work well with a wide range of amps. I haven’t heard the C298. It works well with Hegel though. I used my Auralic Ares II as the main source. I am sure the Node will do fine also 😊👍
Hello! I run a Pontus 2 with a Hegel H190 and it works well! Already going to upgrade my Node 2 though.. ;)
still loving the Chanel Tarun, any chance of you reviewing the ProAc Response D20R ? and a great follow up to what has been achieved since your 1se this would be the next logical level up for many in the 1k bookshelf range , keep up the great work
I would to Neville but ProAc do not send out products to RUclips reviewers 😊
Another superb review. And such a great voice, you should consider doing Audible books Tarun. What would you pair it with when using headphones instead of speakers. Under say 1000 pounds? Headphones are HD8800s, ZMF VC, LCD3's. Cheers John
Thank you John. Great DAC but you will need to run it in to a headphone amp 😊👍
Hello Tarun! Thanks for your transparent and fair reviews. Could you consider a review about another interesting R2R DAC? Soekris dac2541
Thank you. I appreciate the suggestion 😊👍
Hi Tarun, thank you very much for this beautiful review, that had a negative impact for me... I was decided to go for the pontus II next week, and now there is a big dought ;-) As I am seeking for the best for symphonic and classical music, according to you, which one would fit the best for this music, specialy for the cello and doublebass breeth and structure in a complex piece ? Thanks a lot Tarun for you advice, I could find wonderful one SCs thanks to you ! bye
Thank you Miguel. Very much appreciated. I think it is a trade between presentation between these two excellent DACs rather than one being better than the other. The Denafrips Pontus II doesn’t have quite as much clarity as the Holo Audio Spring 3 L2 but it has more harmonic richness 😊👍
proper bloke. good review
Thank you buddy 😊👍
Oh wow, nice dacs. I was going to suggest the Audial Aya 5 before this went up. Also Sonnet Morpheus (mk2), which has a very interesting voltage based volume control.
Thank you for the heads up Will 😊
@@abritishaudiophile7314 another product that isn't out yet, Soncoz class H power amp. Looks v interesting
Volume should be controlled by the amp
@abritishaudiophile7314
Tarun, another amazing review as always. Grateful for all that you do and your content.
I am debating like many others, between the Pontus II + Iris DDC, spring 3 KTE, or the Venus II. You mentioned the Venus II makes the Iris a moot point. How would you stack up the Venus to the Spring KTE? I’m leaning towards the Venus because it gives the option of OS/NOS but curious about your thoughts here. Source is eversolo dmp-a6 master, feeding into Michi X3 integrated amp and Sonus Faber Sonetto V speakers. Thanks.
Excelent review, thanks for sharing your knoledge. Thinking on upgrading from Topping d50s to VmV d1 se, do you think it worth it? My other equipment is an old rotel rb 991 and a parasound pre z3 preamp that i thinks is the weaker link. My speakers are dali zensor 3. Thanks, Greetings from Argentina!!!
Thank you Marcial. You will hear an improvement but probably not worth the outlay. I would go speaker upgrade first 😊👍
Hi - firstly a great review that really gets into the details of what makes the DAC good but also doesn't get lost "in the weeds" of dac technical detail. I have become a big fan of R2R dacs and my testing journey started at the SMSL M500, onto the Denafrips Ares both of which I tested in my home for a while.
I then had to narrow my decision down to the Pontus 2 and the Audio GD R8MK2. I had to choose one without an audition as there were none available to me at the time.
Have you ever listened to any of the newer Audio GD products? I would love to hear your opnoin?
Thank you Mark. Much appreciated. I hope to get to review some Audio GD DACs at some point 😊👍
Thanks for an interesting review. Looks like some great kit. I worked at Altwood of Maidenhead many years back and loved the E39. On a separate note have you ever auditioned the Marlow CE loudspeakers (by EJ Jordan). There is also the MFA Baby Classic pre amplifier. Both British. Would be great to see your review of these. Btw am not in or have any links to the audio industry.
I worked at Altwood Maidenhead in 1999 and 2000. Jason Ouvaroff was the sales manager at the time. I have some great memories of that time 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Haha, yes I remember that name. I was there in 96-97 and loved it.
Ahh Saturday morning again and another excellent Tarun review, even if it is another digital one going over the head of this old analogue dinosaur. Thanks Tarun but you're still not convincing me to move away from my LPs.
Thank you Keith. I think it is more likely that you will convince me to buy a turntable 😂👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 My goodness Tarun, although I've never seen a turntable featured in your rack on the videos I didn't realise you don't own one at all, not even hidden away. *Shocked*.
Do you have any LPs? You do realise your life isn't complete without a turntable so I consider it my mission to now tempt you into getting one.
@@keithwood4031 thank you Keith. Unfortunately, I am that generation that grew up with CD. I had a turntable and a small record collection early on but got rid of it. Regrettably 😢 It is not so much getting a turntable but build a record collection from scratch that seems prohibitive 😊
@@abritishaudiophile7314 it arguably isn’t worth getting into LPs now. Both software and hardware costs bring me to despair. Many of us who somewhat kept the flag flying when cd was taking over and had the time of our lives getting what was then a far superior sounding format (much better than cds used to sound during cds’ first decade) are hard pressed to see the value in it at today’s prices. LPs and turntables were being given away back then, practically. The cost of three of my high end refurbished vintage turntables cost less than what i would pay for a single mid level Pro-Ject turntable today. Digital has gotten so much better. I will not give up on LPs so long as I am still healthy enough to handle them, and still prefer the sound they make, but boy am i glad cds came along or else i’d never have been able to afford the turntables and LP collection I now own! Other well heeled younger audiophiles might argue to the contrary, obviously.
@@timleelim9930 thank you Tim 😊👍
i just ordered one!!
Cool please let me know how you get on 😊👍
Another highly detailed and informative review. How would you compare the Holo Spring to Chords Qutest. Different technology and sound signature.
Thank you Michael. I had a short demo with the Qutest and i would say that it is more on the level of the Ares II rather than the Spring 3 or Pontus II DACs 😊👍
Oh Tarun.... Fantastic.... This Is very much my cup of tea..... Very insightful.... The value of a clean pre amp facility as well as a superb (performing and measuring) dac is appealing.. Though the depth texture and body that a great seperate preamp may lend overall... Hmmmm.. Tough decisions 😂..... Really top content here, thank you again.
It is a great product Marcus. Thank you for watching and your generous words of support 👍😊👍
Hi Tarun.. An excellent review.. thanks. May i know which one have more airy in presentation, Pontus or Spring3?as you mention spring 3 wider sound stage comparing to Pontus.. thanks☺️
Thank you. It has been a while since I compared them. Both excellent in the upper frequencies. The tonal balance of the Spring 3 draws more attention to the treble 🙂
New to your channel and finding it most useful and informative. I have just got some ProAc DB1's similar to yours and im looking for some stands . Can I ask what you have for your ProAc's Thanks again for the channel
Thank you David. I appreciate you watching. I use Target R4s 😊👍
Outstanding review! Having tried a few myself, I realize it’s not as easy as you make it look.
Question: Does the Spring allow for easy absolute phase inversion? It doesn’t appear to have a “phase” button like the Pontus and Ares. If so, can it be done via the remote?
Thank you my friend. Greatly appreciated. There is no way to invert the phase an the Holo Audio Spring 3 that I am aware of 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Thank you for letting me know. That's unfortunate because I think I'd really like this DAC and the May DAC. That's disappointing. Darnit!
Hi Tarun, I'd love to hear your thoughts on how the Chord Qutest and or the TT2 stack up against these R2R dacs if possible?
Thank you for the suggestion. I reached out to Chord but didn’t get very far 😊
They are weary.
Great review and like the sound of the Holo Spring 3. How does it compare with the Auralic Aries/Altair (excluding the streamer function)?
Thank you. They will be pretty close in performance. I would need to get them both in at the same time to tease out differences 👍
Any chance of a review of the Musetec LKS MH-DA005 DAC? Great video's otherwise, looking forward to what you come up with next.
Thank you my friend. I am not familiar with that company 😊👍
Hi Tarun, a seemingly excellent match the spacious soundstage of the Holo Spring (and even more, May) Dac are the QAcoustics Concept floorstanders: 500 and 50. Hifi Choice even recently ranked the QAcoustics Concept 500 ahead of the mighty 3-way ATC SCM 40s (!) Also the late Ken Ishiwata chose the 500s to demo his flagship 9,000 Euro Marantz PM-10 amplifiers on. The Concept 50 is also rather good at its price point. So one of these QAcoustics might be very interesting for you to review, it is by the way a British brand.
Thank you Connor. I reviewed the Concept 300 standmount 😊
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Great, I'll check it out!
Hi Tarun, great review thank you! I have a Hegel H590 and Im considering alternative DAC's - would you consider the holo spring as a suitable upgrade? also - what did you use as a streamer for the review please as Im assuming it is a DAC only?
The Holo Audio Spring 3 will be an upgrade to the internal H590 DAC. My steamer is an Auralic Ares Mini with MCRU linear power supply 😊
Thank you very much for this video. I have a Chord Qutest as DAC. Is the Holo Audio superior in sound quality ? I don't have speakers, I have 2 headphone systems instead, Stax with Stax preamp and Audeze with Feliks Elisia MKII tube preamp. Will there be in your opinion a drastic difference in my system with the Spring 3 ? Thank you very much
Hi Michael, I haven’t done an AB between the two but I think the Pontus II and Holo Spring 3 are better than the Qutest. Where you will find the extra outlay for improvement worthwhile is personal and hard to judge 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Thank you so much for the response. Have a nice day 🙂
Hi Tarun, I’m considering partnering the Spring 3 with the Buchardt A500s. Since you have reviewed both products, any advice on whether I’d get much mileage from the upgrade? The A500s have a tuning that is supposedly flat. I’m hoping that one allows the best of this DAC to shine through.
I wouldn’t do that Nitin. All analogue inputs are digitised by the A500’s internal DAC. It will be the character of that DAC that you will be hearing. If you have the A500s, I would stick with digital sources, be it CD transport or streamer 😊
I have a doubt between audio - gd R28 NOS and Holo Cyan 2 dac.
Please, if anyone can help with advice.
Thank you
Hi Tarun,
I have an H190 and was wondering which match more appropriately, the holo or. Pontus, I do understand it Is a matter of tastes but certainly both can sing better with the hegel commanding, but which one stood out with the hegel, if any. Also if you have heard the h390 and the h590,.How do they compare with the holo /pontus +h190 teamup. Thanks to you and your channel..
Very well thought and well picked content
Thank you Jose. I haven’t tried the H390 or H590. As for the Spring 3 or Pontus II , it really is a matter of taste 😊👍
Great review! I have a Chord Mojo 2 in my system but am looking for another DAC. Do you think the Holo Audio Spring would be better / a good complement? I only ask as I know you have a Chord Mojo. Thanks!
Thank you. The Spring 3 is a much more capable DAC in the right system 😊
As usual Tarun another outstanding review, I sound a bit like a broken record. I am very interested in this review because I have a luxman DA-06 DAC and l am considering an r2r ladder DAC. Would I be right in assuming that the Terminator 2 is the equivalent of the May?
I'm not sure if you have any experience with the May but if so I'd be interested in your opinion in regards to a comparison of the two.
Cheers Shane.😁👍🎧
Thank you Shane. Great to hear from you. I have no experience of the May and Terminator as yet but hope to review them at some point 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 I look forward to hearing your thoughts Tarun.
Love your reviews! I've been going back and forth between buying a Pontus 2 and Holo Spring 3 and am still torn. I'll be pairing it with a Mcintosh 6600 integrated, Cambridge 851N streamer, and Kef Model Two reference speakers. I'm thinking the Mcintosh integrated should preclude the need for a preamp, and would love your thoughts on which DAC might pair best with what I have, and improve on the sound from the built in DAC of my Cambridge streamer. Many Thanks!
Thank you. I am sure you would be happy with either. It will come down to which direction you want to move your system in the slightly more detailed and analytical Spring 3 Vs the warmer and tonally richer Pontus II 😊
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Thanks so much , Tarun! You're the tops!
That construction is beautiful! Your explanations are great and unique. I'm personally eyeing the Doge 7 Tube DAC, any chance to review one please?
Thank you Peter. I haven’t any plans as yet. It will be looking at new products to review next year 😊👍
If a DAC producer makes an aluminium frontplate,how can you believe it is a great product?
Thank you for another nice review.Still I am curious about spring 3 I2S input.Have you tried this .Is it compatible with I2S output from Denafrips Iris.And how does it sound compared to Pontus2 with Iris via I2S connection.
Thank you. Unfortunately, I didn’t have a transport with an I2S input to use at the time 😊👍
Thank you, sir.For your kind response.
Tarun, what CD transport or streamer did you use with this DAC? Also, when Herb Reichert reviewed the Holo Spring May he used the I2s input exclusively.
I used my Auralic Ares Mini powered by a MRSU linear power supply, mainly with the usb input. It’s asynchronous nature means the DAC’s clock is taking care of business. With the other inputs it is the source, including I2S. I tested the coax and optical but didn’t have an appropriate transport to test I2S 😊
Hi Tarun, fantastic channel! I'm a happy owner of a h160 and wondering how the reviewed dac compares with the dac integrated into the Hegel. In other words, what would be price range, where an external dac would bring significant sound improvement compared to the h160 integrated dac?
Thanks for your opinion!
Thank you Christian. There is a very good internal DAC in the H160. However, the amp does have a slightly lean or dry tonal character. Something that Hegel have addressed in the H190. The Pontus II and Holo Audio Spring 3 would be overkill for the H160 unless you are planing to upgrade the amp in the near future. The Denafrips Ares II will help to flesh out the sound a bit over the internal DAC but I think money would be better spent on upgrading the amp instead 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 so getting Hegel 190 would be as good as getting Pontus and H95 separately? Speakers being Dynaudio Contour 20 or Evoke 20?
thanks for this review...My question for you is...what did you choose to keep in your system?...
Pontus ll or this Holo Audio Spring?...and what makes you selct that particular one?...also have you ever tried either of the following two dac's Msb Discrete or Aqua La Scala MKII
Optologic? those are more expensive dac's but somtimes more expensive doesn't relate into better sound..✌️
Thx. I kept the Pontus II. In comparison to the Spring 3 /L2, it traded a little resolution for a more harmonically rich sound which I preferred 😊
Hi Tarun nice review on the spring 3 is this available in the US?
Yes, indeed. Link to US distributor www.kitsunehifi.com
How does this DAC compare to the one in an OPPO 205, which is now a few years old and a potential upgrade partner?
There are many of these out there with owners who may be interested, but unable to pull one in for a direct comparison.
Or is this more appropriate to pair with an older player used as transport?
The 205 was a good player but I can’t imagine the internal DAC competing with the Denafrips Pontus II or Holo Audio Spring 3 😊
Hi Tarun, when you used the Spring 3 with your Exposure pre-amp, what volume did you set the Spring to? Is it best to up the volume on your Exposure and lower the Spring’s volume or vice-versa?
Thank you for a fantastic channel, all the best, Jim
That will vary from system to system but, if I recall, I had the volume set to line level on the DAC and adjusted the volume using my preamp 😊
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Thank you.
Hi Tarun, thanks for great reviews, should be the Spring 3 significant upgrade to dac inside Cambridge 851n? the rest of my chain is Kinki ex1+ and Magnat Signature 909. I mean, can the difference be as night and day? many thanks, new sub hear..
Hi Peter, thank you. There should be a noticeable improvement. I don’t know about night and day. That depends on many factors 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Thanks Tarun, and have a nice day😀
Hi,
It would be cool if you could compare the new Laiv Harmony to the Denafrips and Holo; then recommend which one sounds best for female vocalists/jazz.
I have the Denafrips Pontus II 12th-1 + Denafrips Iris 12th
Apple Music lossless
Thx 😊
Just subscribed to your channel! Which had a blacker background and spatial queues within soundstage? The Spring or Pontus?
It is close but I would give the edge to the Spring 3 😊
@@abritishaudiophile7314 Thank you!🙂
Hello Tarun.
Hello from Bruce in Canada
Enjoy all your reviews. Saw your review of the HOLO Dacs and wanted to seek your opinion on the Spring 3 DAC. Some reviews
state that if your system is under a certain value (speakers/amp/transport) then you maybe wasting the funds and should consider spending the money on upgrading speakers or amp. Recently retired and this maybe the last update to my gear. Have purchased within my budget new speakers (Q Acoustics Concept 40 & new amp MOON 240i internal dac). Using my old ARCAM DV27 cd/dvd player and must admit the sound is very good. Do you think spending approx $3000.00 CDN is worth it or should I upgrade the amp/speakers? Any reply or comment would be appreciated.
Thank you Bruce. I would upgrade the speakers first 👍
Great review. Is this the level 1 version of the Holo spring 3 Dac?
Thank you. level 2 👍
I will be happy if you could review the Gustard R26 dac as well
I have sent an email to Shenzhen Audio about it. Let’s see if they respond 😊
Great review! If you want to connect to an external pre-amp, is there a way to bypass the included one?
Thank you. You can buy the Spring 3 as purely a DAC 😊👍
@@abritishaudiophile7314 in your review though, how did you connect the spring3 preamp output to the Exposure pre-amp input ? Did you set the holo audio preamp volume to maximum?
@@Petrakeas I connected to my Exposure preamp at full volume and also connected it to my Exposure power amps directly and adjusted the volume on the DAC 😊
Hi Taran, what are you thought on the phase button? I think I see you see it out of phase(light on accordance to Alvin). Thank you.
Light on is positive phase 😊
How long did you burn-in the Hollo Spring for? I heard some feedback that it takes well over >300 hours to break in…
I had it running continually for a good couple of weeks before critical listening.
I didn't realize that resistors switched on and off? Or is this shorthand for the speed at which the data is being decoded in the R2R ladder?
By the way the blue finned unit in front of the O-ring transformer - is another toroidal transformer, providing a second voltage supply for secondary section of the machine.
I am trying to remember if you have reviewed the Schiit Audio Bifrost 2 (opposite the Denafrips Ares II)? And the Schiit Gungnir and/or Yggdrasil would be an interesting comparison to the R2R units you speak about here. I have the Ares II and it is my reference at this point - but I miss the bass dynamics and power of the Bifrost 2, so a step up in my DAC may be a future upgrade.
You are right. Poor choice of words. Resistor was a passive device last time I checked 😂
@@abritishaudiophile7314 I appreciate the schematic of the R2R you included - it makes it easier to understand how they work.
I love how a string of simple resistors (*very* precisely matched - but simple) are such an elegant means to decoding a really sophisticated and complex stream of a digital signal.
Tarun could you please do an R2R vs chip DAC video. What’s different in the sound quality between two high end implementations of both approaches.
There are some generalisations that can be made but it all depends on the individual product 😊
Are r2r DACs better than ess or akm ? The schiit multibit sounds good
There is a lot more to a DAC than the topology. I have been very impressed with the R2R ladder DACs I have reviewed recently 😊