I love Fr Murr - I'm a Latin Mass Catholic but my Lost daughter just completed the Divine Mercy Devotion and I'm praying she is Found - good fruit that I have long prayed for
This is Catholicism . So glad Fr Murr mentions that he rediscovered he priesthood and understood the Mass as a sacrifice . I felt like I didn’t understand the Mass as a sacrifice until ai started attending TLM. But no wonder bc so much taken out of Novus Ordo. And then trying to be a meal and talk of sacrifice . I used to wonder what is the sacrifice - the bread people are taking up to the altar?! People left the Chiurch bc they have no idea what is really going on at the Mass.
@@finallythere100 Poor catechesis, I’m afraid resulted when the Baltimore Catechism was dropped as modernists rejected rote learning and wanted free lance creativity. Rote is to religion as .memorizing basic math facts is to building s foundation for upper math
Fr. Ed O’Connor CSC wrote the book,, Listen to My Prophes: Divine Mercy, Divine Justice. He reminds us of the need for repentance and reparation for sin Cdl. McElroy proceeded to teach that there’s no need for repentance and that the priest never tress could give absolution, Bsp.. Paprocki called this out as heresy.
My son serves at the latin Mass Father. He is 16 and he has a lot of boys that serve with him. It took him a long time to train. There is hope! We are seeing a lot of young men thinking of the priesthood. God Bless Father and Emmanuel.
I have used this prayer for patients who were dying as indicated by Faustina, with excellent results. I saw light enter the room and peace seen on they’re faces just before they died.
By praying the Chaplet of Divine Mercy as the person was dying brought great blessings and indulgences to both of you. The Chaplet is a mini rosary seeking mercy. Dt. Faustina was mindful of the offense of even venial sin to Jesus which she makes clear in her diary.
Liberalism has always been a sinful force that Pope Pius X worked so hard to combat. He insisted on an annual oath against Modernism which Pope Paul Vi dropped. Although he wrote Humanae Vitae and warned that Contraception leads to abortion, he was so weak as he did nothing to defend it. He permitted Communion in the hand.. pope JPIi allowed girl servers and, surprisingly, pressed for the zneevIrder Mass and erred in his disregard for Absp. Marcel Kefebvre who warned that if you change the Liturgy, you change belief. Fr. Murr reveals all of them valuable traditions that were dropped and disregarded once the New Order Mass was introduced.
I think that you meant the Latin word protestant. I know Latin is not properly used in The Church nowadays, so I going to assume that you don’t know what protestant means. Because Fr. Murr quite literally was protesting against The Church, and if you knew what protestant meant you would understand that Fr. Murr is a protestant. However, and again I’m going to assume no fault of your own, modernism has influenced the world. Modernism changes definitions of words. So to say that Fr. Murr is not a protestant (at least in this video) is a modernist view.
Thank you Fr Murr for being a priest, not mincing words regarding a devotion that pulls people away from Our Lords Sacred Heart. I feel the same way about the repeated chant of the chapter. I’ve said it, but had suspicions about its real purpose. God bless you Father. God bless you Emmanuel for brining this discussion to us. It is a valuable lesson in traditional thinking and the solid truth of the traditional church teachings.
To me, the Divine Mercy chaplet is basically the same as the Jesus prayer - just asking for mercy on us (and the world). Jesus prayer is "Lord Jesus Christ have mercy on me, a sinner". No words about justice there either...
Excellent breakdown! Fr. Murr explains very understandably how the Sacred Heart devotion is fuller-how it must necessarily include repentance and justice.
The Devotion to His Most Sacred Heart and to His Divine Mercy are not at odds they are a compliment to one’s life of prayer. The tragedy in the life of the Church is a loss of devotion in the life of the family and the world. Families no longer have their homes enthroned to His Sacred Heart and display a statue or painting that is honored. The Divine Mercy image compliments the message of the Burning Heart of Gods Love that is the message of the Sacred Heart. St. Mary Alacoque was instructed to spread the message of His Love and St. Faustina was instructed to spread the message of His Mercy. God have Mercy on us.
Thank you Emmanuel for this wonderful video. As one who grew up in the 60s and 70s, I am very inspired by the deep probing of core questions and the clear answers from Father.
EXCELLENT VIDEO SO GLAD I FOUND THIS by chance well done THANK YIU and GOD BLESS and PROTECT YOU FATHER CHARLES AND WELL DONE TO A 19 YEAR OLD YOUNG MAN EMMANUEL GOD BLESS YOU
Thank you Fr Murr and for the host for the interview. It was very refreshing for me. Our priest had also told myself and my wife about his thoughts on the divine mercy prayer and Chaplet. He had guided us away from this as a practice for similar reasons mentioned in here. And as there are so many older traditional chapters and prayers it felt wiser for us to turn to something more traditional and felt correct for us at that time. Father in this video elaborated on it all more for me, especially it seems in line with the way the church has been moving where Mercy is focused on without the appropriate attention to Justness of our Lord. The simple example of the forgiving the $5 was perfect. It made me think of deeper forgivenesses we have in life too which are tough. Say, a parent who didn’t show up in a grievous manner, an ex partner who was abusive. We find these troubling to move past for the reasons aforementioned I think. Although we may be able to forgive the person it’s hard to fully move on until we feel that a justice which has matches our compassionate forgiveness has happened. It seems this can be made by the person who did harm to us making actions of repentance and just actions in regard to their relationship with us to a degree that appropriate justice has taken place and things will feel ordered. Otherwise, because this is beyond our control, we must then turn to the Almighty Gods justice. Trusting that although he is also infinitely compassionate with his divine mercy he is equally infinitely just in his judgement. In that case we must have faith in the knowledge of that just judgement and hand the worry’s or any bitterness or resentment over to Our Lord, knowing that we know not enough to action justice appropriately in this world, but He does.
Father, Thank you so much! I LOVE the Sacred Heart of Jesus, more than the Divine Mercy Devotion too, and so true, all that liberation and modernism during the Second Vatican Council.
Emmanuel may God bless you, you're have been deeply blessed. This interview with Fr. Charles Murr is brilliant and outstanding. I have come to admire and trust through video interviews and his book Fr.Charles Theodore Murr. I am very grateful having watch this video and subscribed to Faith & Tradition.
What I don’t like about Divine Mercy Sunday is that, to me, it causes a break or a shift in our mind from what occurred just one week prior -- Easter Sunday. It’s like the Church is saying “Okay everyone, Easter was last week, now let’s move on to do this other thing.”
L I V I N G [ day by day and for life ] the Divine Mercy message and devotion is already enacting God's Justice, insofar as it reverses the enactment of MORE unjust thoughts, words, and deeds.
Emmanuel, thank you for being a critically thinking young man with a moral compass. I did not have that at your age and fell into a life of mortal sin. I was so wretched a sinner, that when I tried to come back to Jesus, I would fall right back into sin. I found the homilies were devoid of “yes Jesus is merciful, but you must repent” (bc I believe the priest is speaking to me during the homily) I started going to a men’s group who promoted “accountability and men of faith” and praying the Devine Mercy Chaplet, and the men would get annoyed when I started asking questions about mercy without repentance. The church appealed to my emotional side initially, which is egocentric and humanistic. As I start to pray the rosary, acts of contrition multiple times daily, and strive for obedience to Mary’s pleas at Fatima, i fear offending God, don’t need a pat on the back. post V2 church is all about appealing to emotions. God bless you!
And pre V2 Church is the one that considered Saint Pio a fraud and forbid him to say Mass.. 🤦♂🤦♂ also Saint Faustina never said that you have not to confess and repent, asking to God for mercy is the extrema ratio.
The Divine Mercy reminds me of the prayer that Protestants say once in which you are saved permanently! BTW I agree with Fr. On the vocation thing! I will pray for you. You are so well formed at such a young age! God Bless you! !
@@Pawel_Jozwik It is the lack of justice from the devotion, the once saved always saved lacks justice also. As the good Father says the devotion does not say go away and sin no more. " Say unceasingly the Chaplet that I have taught you. Whoever will recite it, they will receive great mercy at the hour of death. Priests will recommend it to sinners as their last hope of salvation. Even if there were a sinner most hardened, if he were to recite this chaplet only once, he would receive grace from My infinite mercy." (Diary, 687) Whatever happened to confession? The last rites? Only this chaplet is a sinners last hope? This devotion is very Protestant to say the least.
@@Pawel_Jozwik....also the image she said she received was actually black and white and the artist who painted the image for her committed suicide after .....😮
@@margaretmary1139 You are spreading falsehood, you should go to confession and confess that you sinned against the 8th commandment. Sister Faustina in her diary often talks about Gods wrath for those who don't accept Gods mercy. Here are just few examples, there are many more. Read the diary b yourself, before talking nonsense about it. "39 + One day Jesus told me that He would cause a chastisement to fall upon the most beautiful city in our country [probably Warsaw], This chastisement would be that with which God had punished Sodom and Gomorrah 27 . I saw the great wrath of God and a shudder pierced my heart. I prayed in silence." === "474 In the evening, when I was in my cell, I saw an Angel, the executor of divine wrath. He was clothed in a dazzling robe, his face gloriously bright, a cloud beneath his feet. From the cloud, bolts of thunder and flashes of lightning were springing into his hands; and from his hand they were going forth, and only then were they striking the earth. When I saw this sign of divine wrath which was about to strike the earth, and in particular a certain place, which for good reasons I cannot name, I began to implore the Angel to hold off for a few moments, and the world would do penance. But my plea was a mere nothing in the face of the divine anger. === Then I saw the Mother of God, who said to me, Oh, how pleasing to God is the soul that follows faithfully the inspirations of His grace! I gave the Savior to the world; as for you, you have to speak to the world about His great mercy and prepare the world for the Second (91 ) Coming of Him who will come, not as a merciful Savior, but as a just Judge. Oh, how terrible is that day! Determined is the day of justice, the day of divine wrath. The angels tremble before it. Speak to souls about this great mercy while it is still the time for [granting] mercy. If you keep silent now, you will be answering for a great number of souls on that terrible day. Fear nothing. Be faithful to the end. I sympathize with you. "
@@loarnotoole36 That's nonsense. Maybe you talking about this, but that's clearly not a command to paint it in black and white. There is no other mention of black and white in the entire diary. : 313 +Once, when I was visiting the artist [Eugene Kazimirowski] who was painting the image, and saw that it was not as beautiful as Jesus is, I felt very sad about it, but I hid this deep in my heart. When we had left the artist’s house, Mother Superior [Irene] stayed in town to attend to some matters while I returned home alone. I went immediately to the chapel and wept a good deal. I said to the Lord, “Who will paint You as beautiful as You are?” Then I heard these words: Not in the beauty of the color, nor of the brush lies the greatness of this image, but in My grace. "
I really respect that Father Murr came to a channel that he wasn’t entirely familiar with and which isn’t huge and acted with such humility and service
A great talk. God bless you. One thing I’d like to correct you on. It was the devotion to Divine Mercy as recommended by s. Faustina that was banned & the use of the DM image in Churches in 1959. However, the Diary was never placed on the Index of Forbidden Books. This is a common error. The reason for this is that the Diary was not fully published back in the 1950’s but only parts of it were. The 1st time it was fully published was in 1981 after the Notification was removed in April 1978. Not that this changes the fact that the whole devotion was banned. Another less known fact was that one of the major reasons why the Holy Office placed the ban in 1959 was after the feedback they receive which they receive from the Polish bishops in 1957. Vast majority came back with negative opinions of it. It was not until Karol Wojtyla became a bishop & then a cardinal that & later pope that things progressed along with the change in the Church after V2. He made it his personal mission at any cost to bring back this devotion publicly & make s. Faustina a Saint. This devotion has sadly replaced in practice the Sacred Heart devotion which gives us the full understanding of God’s mercy & our duty to lead virtuous lives & make reparations for our sins.
@Sebastian... Well said! Especially your closing: >our duty to lead virtuous lives and make reparations for our sins.< Reparation IS key part of the Sacred Heart messages to St. Margaret Mary Alacoque, yet SO little spoken of nowadays. BTW, do you know what MOST greatly pained, offended Our Lord which He told to St. Margaret Mary Alacoque? (Can't imagine how much that's increased in our times!) It was the >indifference »»of Catholics«« to His Real Presence< in the BL. Sacrament in the Tabernacle. Archbp. Fulton Sheen encouraged a half hour daily spent before Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament for the laity, If at all possible (at least full hour for all Religious persons.) I recall that Mother Teresa of Calcutta said that time spent before Jesus in the BL. Sacrament had central importance her Religious Order >before< all the help given to the poor and sick.
Sr Faustina was barely literate & spoke a unique rare Polish dialect. The Diary is a forgery. Sr Faustina original idea was a bloody beaten scourged face of our Blessed Lord. The Prayer itself isn't bad but don't assume Sr Faustina was in anyway involved w the post 1978 replacement of Low Sunday,diary,new age image,etc Notice the rise of D.M. & devotion to St Joseph suddenly mysteriously falls off the cliff,along w Sacred Heart of Jesus novena/image.
DM is a modernist propaganda. Pope jp2 is a modernist pope just like all vatican 2 popes including pope john 23. The devil hates the rosary so he tries to replace it with the dm chaplet.
It seems to me that the writings show that God does not tolerate sin. During Eucharistic Adoration in the convent Jesus was looking very sternly at some of the sisters. Faustina said that if we understood how much we would have to pay for the slightest sin we would never commit a venial sin. God kept showing her His justice. Different times Faustina would say that this soul or that soul was falling into Hell. I did not get the impression that God's Mercy was not obtained without struggle.
Incl. perhaps BEST explanation of what was + why Index of Forbidden Books mattered that I've ever heard; AND a thoughtful overview of errors in the Church today. St. Padre Pio said the "Rosary is the weapon!" So... many more we need to pray. Our Lady Destroyer of All Heresies pray for us. St. Joseph Patron of the Universal Church pray for us. St. Michael Archangel defend us.
If you quote Padre Pio as a beacon of truth (which I do) you can't pick and choose his discernment. He was himself a mystic and victim soul. He fully supported the mysticism of Luisa Piccarreta who also appeared on the forbidden books. He supported Garabandal.
@@Fiat.Voluntas.Tua22 I don't see your follow up. Unless, I'm mistaken, Fr. Murr explained some issues with the Divine Mercy devotion (btw, NOT any critique on sanctity of St. Faustina). And the show wasn't on topic of Garabandal or Louisa Piccarretta. Also, as far as I know St. Pio had no words about Faustina or her new devotion. So I don't see his part in any of this discussion. The point about the index of forbidden books still holds. AND all the books on the list, incl. about the Divine Mercy >were Not removed< from the list: the list simply was taken down: in effect, the Church was informed that it's no longer in force >as a moral or canonical prohibition.< In other words, None of the reasons/causes which had flagged the books were altered, changed or disproved. It's just that you're Not committing a sin by reading any of those books. Honestly, I'm NOT here to say a person's going against Church teachings, etc. by following the Divine Mercy devotion (btw, the chaplet is 100% orthodox with Church prayers and practice). However, I agree with Fr. Murr that the devotion presents s different focus both in its written explanations and in the devotion's practices… THAN WAS given to and revealed by St. Margaret Mary Alacoque about devotion to the Sacred Heart. Hence, I don't dissuade others about it, unless I'm asked; yet, personally I focus on what Our Lord revealed to St. Margaret Mary Alacoque.
It’s helpful that Emmanuel brought the best from Fr. Murr’s by letting him reminisce like this. Fr. Murr as the oldest child in his family because he was educated I n Catholic schools before the Church lost 500,000 religiosity sifters post Vatican III. His siblings asked these wonderful devoted servants of God.
I believed the Divine Mercy, as I believed in Pope JP2. Later, after much research and reading exerpts from Sr. Faustina's diary, I began to question this devotion. She was wrong on predicted dates and I cannot believe that Jesus would tell her that He loved her more than anyone else. Even His own mother??? I think Sr. Faustina had some mental heath issues... anyone else.
The Divine Mercy image nickname is “heart-less Jesus.” It’s not hard to guess why. The whole devotion is not only missing the Divine Justice side of mercy, it’s devoid of any connection to Mary. Whenever the modernist church wants to make a Catholic devotion more palatable to Protestants, they discard the very things that make it Catholic (Sacred Heart of Jesus, True Face of Jesus, the Crucifix, the Immaculate Heart of Mary, the Rosary, all Marian devotions, the Latin Mass, any connection to Saints and Angels, any mention of Purgatory, the Sacraments, and more). What you’re left with is so devoid of any true spirituality, it’s not enough to sustain meaningful conversion and growth…which is, I suppose, the entire point. Think about it!
@@mementofidei You are creating a wonderful channel with great commentary and guests. Keep it up and I’ll keep watching. You might consider being a guest on other shows. Hearing from someone so young and yet so gifted and insightful is always interesting.
The problem with Confession is in 99% of parishes there is no anonymity. Many more people would go to Confession if it was still in a confessional box not in a room sitting on a chair next to a Priest. ❤
Remember that Our Lord Jesus is standing beside the Priest in Confession - he already knows your sins but do you have true Humility to repent of your sins - if not there is pride and trouble - go to Confession if you want to make Heaven and be with God for eternity.
Thank you, F&T, an excellent presentation with Father Murray. I suggest searching Lloyd De Jongh's channel for futher study of modernism and all the gnostic heresies - atheism, communism, socialism and Free Masonry. Lloyd does meticulous and ubelievably thorous research on all things atheism related. He goes back to pre-Christ and brings is all the way to the 21st century. It is similar to lifting a cover off the entry to hell!
I have *very* serious doubts about the Divine Mercy chaplet and, especially, the writings of Faustina Kowalska. I just can't subscribe to it! Thanks for making this video!
Reading St. Faustina's Diary before Eucharistic Adoration helped me be deeply aware of the gravity of my sins as never before. I realized that I would spend a long time in Purgatory as the state of my soul is so wretched. I confessed Many sins but became so aware of the impact my sins had on so many of God's children. This was leading me to discouragement but know that is the tool of the devil. I am totally dependent on God's Mercy.
I pray to the ear of God so my friendship with God is unbroken. The Holy Spirit would give me no peace at all if he wanted to correct me. None. No peace. But, I have peace.
Awesome channel. I hope many more subscribe. Great video lineup. Great Catholic content. Great interviews. Love your commentary and insights. No downside except one: a pulsating emoji where video of YOU should be. I’m so impressed with you, I can’t help feeling disappointed about not getting to see and connect with you on a more personal level.
I would do video. But I can't afford a camera and my house doesn't exactly have a good background. I decided to do it anyway. I thought it would help people if they knew.
Fr. Murr looks and sounds identically to my grandfather Wm. Joseph McMullen from Ireland via Liverpool. It's astounding. He was the son of Denis Patrick McMullen. I wonder if he's related. Fr. Murr is his twin.
) “He who refuses to pass through the door of My mercy must pass through the door of My justice ...” -Diary 1146 (5) “Souls perish in spite of My bitter Passion. I am giving them the last hope of salvation; that is, the Feast of My Mercy. If they will not adore My mercy, they will perish for all eternity.” -Diary 965
Jesus said to the dying criminal on the cross today you will be with me in Paradise. (Mercy) Then there is the prodigul son who spends all his Fathers money squandering it, and the Father is so happy on his return he throws a feast for him. God shows us many works of mercy throughout the Bible. God is the Creator, we can never comprehend with our intelligence what he as Creator chooses to do, as servants it is not our place. ❤
@@mementofidei Justice and Infinite Mercy can't even be in the same sentence. Or you are a judge or you have infinite Mercy and you just have to wish in His mercy over His justice, deal with that.
False just like med jug orgy...confusion for weak catholics who look for signs and wonders and when the world will end etc...etc..Our Lord and Saviour warned us about these times when people would look for outersigns etc...🥴🧐
@@CRUSNET Says who, you? A sede vacantist who would have probably agreed to call Saint Pio a fraud and forbid him to say Mass as before Vatican 2?? Because that was the Church that forbid Saint Faustina devotion, know that.
Won't this Justice be served in Purgatory?? The fact that God forgives you through His Mercy doesn't mean you're going straight to Heaven, it just means that you're not damned. I don't see any problem with Divine Mercy. We find the same Mercy of God in the writings of the Servant of God Luisa Picarreta.
Most Divine Mercy devotions on Divine Mercy Sunday have one or more Priests heairng COnfession at the same time. So there is Justice and repentance. in attendance.
God is Divine Mercy and any prayers is positive at least this has brought a lot of people close to the 3 pm hour where people worship the Son of God and his passion and death . So don’t condemn this prayer . It has worked and converted a lot of people .
IF I ever did pray this prayer, I keep Justice in mind and ensure that It has fidelity to Tradition? What is the Original Sacred Heart Devotion, I am very interested in this.
@hm... See words, writings, prayers of St.Margaret Mary Alacoque¹, and her spiritual director,:FrJohn Croiset, S.J.², on details of the Sacred Heart devotion. ¹ St. Margaret Mary Alacoque is THE saint of the Sacred Heart of Our Lord Jesus. GOD chose Margaret Mary to reveal the depths of His Sacred Heart to. Short books of her >Thoughts and Sayings of St. Margaret Mary: For Every DayThe Way of Divine Love< the journal of Sr. Josefa Menéndez, to whom Our Lord revealed His love and Sacred Heart in special ways. The future Pope Pius XII, then a cardinal, wrote a forward in a letter of recommendation for the original publication of her journal. (This is a deeply moving and thoughtful book, which helped bring me back to rediscover the Faith; together with >The Glories of Mary< by St. Alphonsus Ligouri (Doctor of the Church, no less-seriously, if Francis had real humility and love for Our Lady he would take to heart truths about Mary that he's dared publicly to demean and deny!) ² Fr. John Croiset, SJ., was the spiritual director of St. Margaret Mary Alacoque (a little different than her confessor, who was Saint Fr. Claude La Colombière, SJ.) for decades, became intimately familiar with Our Lord's messages to her, and wrote THE classic book on the subject: >The Devotion to the Sacred Heart< republished by TAN. It's filled with profound insights and heartfelt prayers also. † ❤️ † Prayer of Margaret Mary Alacoque taken from the book >Devotion To The Sacred Heart< by Fr. John Croiset, S.J.: Prayer: O Sacred Heart of Jesus, to Thee I consecrate and offer up my person and my life, my actions, trials, and sufferings, that my entire being may henceforth only be employed in loving, honoring and glorifying Thee. This is my irrevocable will, to belong entirely to Thee, and to do all for Thy love, renouncing with my whole heart all that can displease Thee. I take Thee, O Sacred Heart, for the sole object of my love, the protection of my life, the pledge of my salvation, the remedy of my frailty and inconstancy, the reparation for all the defects of my life, and my secure refuge at the hour of my death. Be Thou, O Most Merciful Heart, my justification before God Thy Father, and screen me from His anger which I have so justly merited. I fear all from my own weakness and malice, but placing my entire confidence in Thee, O Heart of Love, I hope all from Thine infinite Goodness. Annihilate in me all that can displease or resist Thee. Imprint Thy pure love so deeply in my heart that I may never forget Thee or be separated from Thee. I beseech Thee, through Thine infinite Goodness, grant that my name be engraved upon Thy Heart, for in this I place all my happiness and all my glory, to live and to die as one of Thy devoted servants. Amen. ps. This prayer-in all its depth, subtlety >and humility< blows me away (in a different dimension utterly than St. Faustyna, whose sanctity in all truth and justice was never questioned; yet the humility of St Margaret Mary Alacoque before GOD that's conveyed in this prayer is not found, in my humble opinion (and others' more knowledgeable), in her diary. I'm praying 🙏 and trying step by step to get to the point when I will be able myself to honestly pray Margaret Mary's words as my own. St. Margaret Mary Alacoque pray for us-that we love the Sacred Heart of Our Lord with a heart like yours.
A veces Dios mismo hace promesas para obligarse a si mismo a salvarnos. Si la Misericordia de Dios es grande es porque Su JUSTICIA también lo es. Si no hubiera Justicia no habría necesidad de Misericordia. No hablo inglés muy fluido, pero algo entiendo de lo que escucho. Tengo la obligación moral de decir lo "que hemos visto y oido" el dia de la fiesta de la Divina Misericordia de 2004 en la misa de las 3 de la tarde ,en el Santuario de la Divina Misericordia de Buenos Aires. Se podía ver el sol sin molestias en la vista, rayos danzantes rojos y azules girando alrededor del sol (como en forma circular, no radial) y la Santa Faz Perfectamente formada por nubes en un día totalmente despejado de nubes. Todo duró unos instantes y lo vimos todos , hasta el sacerdote párroco del Santuario, que dijo dejó la homilía para consagrar en ese momento. A partir de ese momento ya no puedo tener dudas, además lo vimos todos, todos, no yo solamente. Lo hago bajo juramento y con Dios como testigo, por una cuestión de conciencia y gratitud a Dios por ese signo que nos dio.
@Turi por ejemplo en el A.T. Dios rescata a los Israel después de haber caído gravemente y les aclara que lo hace en virtud de la promesa que le hizo a Abraham. O por la Santidad de Su Santo Nombre para que los paganos no digan ¿donde esta su Dios? O los mismos Israelitas piden perdón apelando a Dios a que lo haga por su promesa. La gente cree que tiene DERECHO a ser salvada y no es así (y hasta llegan a decir ¿por que no me salvaria si yo "no hice nada"?). Hasta el mas grande santo se salva por la misericordia de Dios y no por derecho propio, fundamentada en sus promesas. Lo que si Dios pide es conversión, arrepentimiento y amor, sin eso no hay Misericordia ni Promesa que valga (es necesario corresponder a la gracia)
Why not honor both devotions? One doesn’t take away from the other. Those who pray divine mercy realize that we must atone either here or in purgatory. You pray for mercy and forgiveness. I love all of it. Rosary, divine mercy chaplet, the sacred heart devotion. Listen to talks by Fr Alar on this devotion. He’s a Great faithful priest who understands this devotion.
I recommend the interviewer to contact the Marian Fathers in Stockbridge, MA. They have promoted the devotion to the Divine Mercy from the beginning. They are the authorities on this and they will clarify and eliminate all your confusion on this devotion. Go to the source when you're doing any kind of research.The Sacred Heart devotion and the Devine Mercy complement each other. As for Divine Justice the Divine Mercy devotion requires repentance and sacramental confession.
The image the nun said she recieved was Black and White with no sacred heart on Jesus body , the artist she got to paint her image committed suicide after , she said that the Blessed Eucharist flew into her hand 😮....there was no communion in the hand then , it would have been seen as an abomination , then the image appeared as Red and White , the polish colours 🤔....pope jp 2 andcthis nun were polish 🧐....now the image colours are Red and blue.. JESUS CHRIST our Lord and Saviour does NOT cause confusion....the demonic realm cause lies and confusion to those who look for signs and wonders...😒....the freemasonic modernist caused muvh confusion at v2
The absolving of sins by the priest in confession is not just for Catholics. It's for everyone because everyone is called to the True Church that Jesus Christ instituted. We, as Catholics, are called to bring people into the fold.
If you search Prayers to The Sacred Heart of Jesus by Catholic Crusade You will see what Fr Charles is talking about. You will understand. Your eyes will be opened
If Divine Mercy is a true devotion then it is from God, how could it not have the ‘energy’ from God? The diary calls for confession again and again. Without confession there is no Mercy without Mercy there is no Justice. I know I’ll get push back but those that know their theology know that God’s Mercy and Justice are one.
@@mementofidei To be in communion with Antipope Francis and the entity he leads is to be at war with the actual Catholic Church and thus at war with Christ. See my many videos on this. It’s time to get real; really real.
It’s not lacking the aspect of justice at all. Mercy and Justice go hand in hand. There’s no Mercy without Justice and Justice without Mercy. If you read the book on Devine Mercy, there’s a lot said about Justice in there. Also, when you say the Chaplet of Devine Mercy, you are supposed to be meditating on the Passion of Christ. Another point is that there are plenty of people who like Juda Iscariot have a huge problem forgiving themselves and/or release themselves of the guilt they feel (even after confession). And that’s when this devotion is crucial for bringing sinners back to the Church. How come you don’t see that Father? And yes! God’s Mercy is unconditional and His love is unconditional and the Chaplet of Mercy is for sinners who repented. Faustiana talks about the repentance all the time in her book and about sin. Father, you didn’t read the book I think.
I’ve read it four times Use rosary beads - but never says pray after rosary Our Lady (7 years earlier) Pray rosary daily Faustina mentions rosary a couple of times in 700 page diary
The statements from this supposed apparition present a number of problems. The first problem is the promotion of Communion in the hand, which is supposedly endorsed by Our Lord. The Host flies into her hand numerous times, and Our Lord supposedly says that He desires to rest in her hands. I believe this is a diabolical snare to get Communion in the hand accepted in advance of the Vatican II religion. Second, we see unnecessary praise heaped upon this sister. We see things allegedly said to her by Our Lord that wouldn’t foster humility, but vanity: that she is basically the greatest thing in the world. I don’t believe Our Lord would instruct her to tell her superior that she is the most faithful daughter in the Order. Our Lord could have told the superior such a thing if he wanted it known.
The original translations were faulty, weren't accurate. Cardinal Karol Wojtyla had the original Polish text retranslated. Once this was completed the initial problems were solved and those problematic issues were clarified. Contact the Marian Fathers to explain the history to you.
That’s the thesis the DM devotees push without knowledge of the background. Marian Fathers conveniently omit certain facts. A few things which are wrong with this thesis: 1. No official statement from Vatican or primary source that confirms this thesis. It’s a conclusion that people draw mainly from the introduction to the Diary which points out that there were errors in parts of the text. 2. In 1957 the Holy Office asked through the Primate of Poland Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski for feedback from all Polish bishops in their diocese on how the the DM devotion was being promoted & adhered to. The majority of bishops came back with negative opinions, which played a major role in DM devotion being banned. 3. It wasn’t the Diary that was banned or placed on Index of FB’s but the spreading of the devotion in public places of s worship. Images DM were also to be removed. As you can see from above the reason for ban of DM devotion as recommended by s. Faustina wasn’t due to a faulty translation, the Holy Office wouldn’t have been forthright if this was the only reason. Additionally the Archbishop Jałbrzykowski under whose diocese s. Faustina was also believed that what she disclosed was not supernatural in origin(after hearing her confession) This was also passed on the the commission. It was the wind of change in Church after V2 that allowed for this devotion to be promoted & elevated which as we can see wouldn’t have taken place under the traditional & orthodox Vatican.
It's the ploy of the devil to distract from the essentials of the faith, chasing instead false messages to make us feel better and think we're doing the right thing.
ALSO, there are extreme problems with Sr. Faustina's Diary on Divine Mercy. There are many shocking statement she made exsmples: that supposedly Jesus said to her, that she is the pearl of His Heart-- He told her thar He has united His Heart to her like no other creature ever... That makes her above the Blessed Virgin Mary!!! Also, puts her above any and all of Saints! Jesus supposedly told her she should not worry about judgement because she will not be judged. He supposedly told her that her love for Him is more pure than that of the Angels!!! There is many many more heretical statements in her diary. Those are a few. Please, research for your self.
God Bless Fr. Murr. He is a real Priest. God help us, he is a rarity
Most Sacred Heart of Jesus, have mercy on us 🙏🙏🙏🌹
Amen thank you for this! Immaculate Heart of Mary pray for us. Sacred Heart of Jesus we place all our trust in Thee. 🙏🏻❤️🕊
I love Fr Murr - I'm a Latin Mass Catholic but my Lost daughter just completed the Divine Mercy Devotion and I'm praying she is Found - good fruit that I have long prayed for
Such joy! My six children have strayed from the faith , as has my husband of 36 years. I never give up 🙏. Prayers welcome
I find Fr Charles murr like a true father who comforts his children thank you Fr for your knowledge,God bless you🙏
This is Catholicism . So glad Fr Murr mentions that he rediscovered he priesthood and understood the Mass as a sacrifice . I felt like I didn’t understand the Mass as a sacrifice until ai started attending TLM. But no wonder bc so much taken out of Novus Ordo. And then trying to be a meal and talk of sacrifice . I used to wonder what is the sacrifice - the bread people are taking up to the altar?! People left the Chiurch bc they have no idea what is really going on at the Mass.
@@finallythere100 Poor catechesis, I’m afraid resulted when the Baltimore Catechism was dropped as modernists rejected rote learning and wanted free lance creativity. Rote is to religion as .memorizing basic math facts is to building s foundation for upper math
Fr. Ed O’Connor CSC wrote the book,, Listen to My Prophes: Divine Mercy, Divine Justice. He reminds us of the need for repentance and reparation for sin Cdl. McElroy proceeded to teach that there’s no need for repentance and that the priest never tress could give absolution, Bsp.. Paprocki called this out as heresy.
He's my favorite Catholic period
My son serves at the latin Mass Father. He is 16 and he has a lot of boys that serve with him. It took him a long time to train. There is hope! We are seeing a lot of young men thinking of the priesthood. God Bless Father and Emmanuel.
Fr. Charles, Jesus made you a priest for these times and the desire for the TLM bearing such fruit in your soul, has truly come to fruition! TY
I have used this prayer for patients who were dying as indicated by Faustina, with excellent results. I saw light enter the room and peace seen on they’re faces just before they died.
By praying the Chaplet of Divine Mercy as the person was dying brought great blessings and indulgences to both of you. The Chaplet is a mini rosary seeking mercy. Dt. Faustina was mindful of the offense of even venial sin to Jesus which she makes clear in her diary.
Liberalism has always been a sinful force that Pope Pius X worked so hard to combat. He insisted on an annual oath against Modernism which Pope Paul Vi dropped. Although he wrote Humanae Vitae and warned that Contraception leads to abortion, he was so weak as he did nothing to defend it. He permitted Communion in the hand.. pope JPIi allowed girl servers and, surprisingly, pressed for the zneevIrder Mass and erred in his disregard for Absp. Marcel Kefebvre who warned that if you change the Liturgy, you change belief. Fr. Murr reveals all of them valuable traditions that were dropped and disregarded once the New Order Mass was introduced.
I believe Ft. Murr and Emmanuel would be enlightened by reading St. Faustina’s diary.
Though it’s true God loves us as we are, it’s also true that He loves us far too much to leave us as we are.
Thank God we have Priests like Father Murr coming out and speaking the truth with clarity.
Bc he is not a PROTESTABNT and doesn’t promote Protrstant error.
I think that you meant the Latin word protestant. I know Latin is not properly used in The Church nowadays, so I going to assume that you don’t know what protestant means. Because Fr. Murr quite literally was protesting against The Church, and if you knew what protestant meant you would understand that Fr. Murr is a protestant. However, and again I’m going to assume no fault of your own, modernism has influenced the world. Modernism changes definitions of words. So to say that Fr. Murr is not a protestant (at least in this video) is a modernist view.
Thank you Fr Murr for being a priest, not mincing words regarding a devotion that pulls people away from Our Lords Sacred Heart. I feel the same way about the repeated chant of the chapter. I’ve said it, but had suspicions about its real purpose. God bless you Father.
God bless you Emmanuel for brining this discussion to us. It is a valuable lesson in traditional thinking and the solid truth of the traditional church teachings.
Thank you Fr Murr for participating in an interview with this young man.
To me, the Divine Mercy chaplet is basically the same as the Jesus prayer - just asking for mercy on us (and the world). Jesus prayer is "Lord Jesus Christ have mercy on me, a sinner". No words about justice there either...
Excellent breakdown! Fr. Murr explains very understandably how the Sacred Heart devotion is fuller-how it must necessarily include repentance and justice.
Well done! Glad this came up in my feed.
The Devotion to His Most Sacred Heart and to His Divine Mercy are not at odds they are a compliment to one’s life of prayer. The tragedy in the life of the Church is a loss of devotion in the life of the family and the world. Families no longer have their homes enthroned to His Sacred Heart and display a statue or painting that is honored. The Divine Mercy image compliments the message of the Burning Heart of Gods Love that is the message of the Sacred Heart. St. Mary Alacoque was instructed to spread the message of His Love and St. Faustina was instructed to spread the message of His Mercy. God have Mercy on us.
Thank you for the reply!
I always have a 1st friday devotion to the Sacred Heart of Jesus. Yes Jesus is merciful but also Just. Thank you Fr. Murr. Well explained.
Bravo Fr. Murr for telling the truth. Your comment to the parishioners was priceless. That should be repeated by every Priest.
I always appreciate Fr Murr! Great job Emmanuel! You did great in the interview, too! Praying as you consider that vocation.
I'm really glad you think so. I had thought it had not gone as well as I had wanted. God bless you as you pray for me.
Thank you Emmanuel for this wonderful video. As one who grew up in the 60s and 70s, I am very inspired by the deep probing of core questions and the clear answers from Father.
EXCELLENT VIDEO SO GLAD I FOUND THIS by chance well done THANK YIU and GOD BLESS and PROTECT YOU FATHER CHARLES AND WELL DONE TO A 19 YEAR OLD YOUNG MAN EMMANUEL GOD BLESS YOU
Thank you Fr Murr and for the host for the interview. It was very refreshing for me. Our priest had also told myself and my wife about his thoughts on the divine mercy prayer and Chaplet. He had guided us away from this as a practice for similar reasons mentioned in here. And as there are so many older traditional chapters and prayers it felt wiser for us to turn to something more traditional and felt correct for us at that time. Father in this video elaborated on it all more for me, especially it seems in line with the way the church has been moving where Mercy is focused on without the appropriate attention to Justness of our Lord. The simple example of the forgiving the $5 was perfect.
It made me think of deeper forgivenesses we have in life too which are tough. Say, a parent who didn’t show up in a grievous manner, an ex partner who was abusive. We find these troubling to move past for the reasons aforementioned I think. Although we may be able to forgive the person it’s hard to fully move on until we feel that a justice which has matches our compassionate forgiveness has happened. It seems this can be made by the person who did harm to us making actions of repentance and just actions in regard to their relationship with us to a degree that appropriate justice has taken place and things will feel ordered. Otherwise, because this is beyond our control, we must then turn to the Almighty Gods justice. Trusting that although he is also infinitely compassionate with his divine mercy he is equally infinitely just in his judgement. In that case we must have faith in the knowledge of that just judgement and hand the worry’s or any bitterness or resentment over to Our Lord, knowing that we know not enough to action justice appropriately in this world, but He does.
Spot on, sir! God bless.
Thank you Father for helping us to understand the confusion in the Church.
Father, Thank you so much! I LOVE the Sacred Heart of Jesus, more than the Divine Mercy Devotion too, and so true, all that liberation and modernism during the Second Vatican Council.
Lumen Gentium 16 & Nostra Aetate.
These 2 documents aren't ever discussed by mainstream post 2020 so called "traditional Catholics."
And before V2 Church called Saint Pio a liar and a fraud and a forbid him to say Mass for long time. Sop what's exactly your point guys??
yes absolutely, Justice . You are making absolutely total sense. The world is full of people who make justice invisible
Emmanuel may God bless you, you're have been deeply blessed.
This interview with Fr. Charles Murr is brilliant and outstanding.
I have come to admire and trust through video interviews and his book Fr.Charles Theodore Murr.
I am very grateful having watch this video and subscribed to Faith & Tradition.
God bless you, Biserka! I appreciate those kind words.
Don't Die ... we need you 🙏😇
What I don’t like about Divine Mercy Sunday is that, to me, it causes a break or a shift in our mind from what occurred just one week prior -- Easter Sunday. It’s like the Church is saying “Okay everyone, Easter was last week, now let’s move on to do this other thing.”
L I V I N G [ day by day and for life ] the Divine Mercy message and devotion is already
enacting God's Justice, insofar as it reverses the enactment of MORE unjust thoughts,
words, and deeds.
Emmanuel, thank you for being a critically thinking young man with a moral compass. I did not have that at your age and fell into a life of mortal sin. I was so wretched a sinner, that when I tried to come back to Jesus, I would fall right back into sin. I found the homilies were devoid of “yes Jesus is merciful, but you must repent” (bc I believe the priest is speaking to me during the homily) I started going to a men’s group who promoted “accountability and men of faith” and praying the Devine Mercy Chaplet, and the men would get annoyed when I started asking questions about mercy without repentance. The church appealed to my emotional side initially, which is egocentric and humanistic. As I start to pray the rosary, acts of contrition multiple times daily, and strive for obedience to Mary’s pleas at Fatima, i fear offending God, don’t need a pat on the back. post V2 church is all about appealing to emotions. God bless you!
Thank you for your message, Mike. God bless
And pre V2 Church is the one that considered Saint Pio a fraud and forbid him to say Mass.. 🤦♂🤦♂ also Saint Faustina never said that you have not to confess and repent, asking to God for mercy is the extrema ratio.
The Divine Mercy reminds me of the prayer that Protestants say once in which you are saved permanently! BTW I agree with Fr. On the vocation thing! I will pray for you. You are so well formed at such a young age! God Bless you!
!
What do you mean? How did you come to this conclusion that the Devine Mercy Chaplet is "once saved always saved"?
@@Pawel_Jozwik It is the lack of justice from the devotion, the once saved always saved lacks justice also. As the good Father says the devotion does not say go away and sin no more. " Say unceasingly the Chaplet that I have taught you. Whoever will recite it, they will receive great mercy at the hour of death. Priests will recommend it to sinners as their last hope of salvation. Even if there were a sinner most hardened, if he were to recite this chaplet only once, he would receive grace from My infinite mercy." (Diary, 687) Whatever happened to confession? The last rites? Only this chaplet is a sinners last hope? This devotion is very Protestant to say the least.
@@Pawel_Jozwik....also the image she said she received was actually black and white and the artist who painted the image for her committed suicide after .....😮
@@margaretmary1139 You are spreading falsehood, you should go to confession and confess that you sinned against the 8th commandment. Sister Faustina in her diary often talks about Gods wrath for those who don't accept Gods mercy. Here are just few examples, there are many more. Read the diary b yourself, before talking nonsense about it.
"39 + One day Jesus told me that He would cause a chastisement to fall upon the most
beautiful city in our country [probably Warsaw], This chastisement would be that with
which God had punished Sodom and Gomorrah 27 . I saw the great wrath of God and a
shudder pierced my heart. I prayed in silence."
===
"474 In the evening, when I was in my cell, I saw an Angel, the executor of divine wrath.
He was clothed in a dazzling robe, his face gloriously bright, a cloud beneath his
feet. From the cloud, bolts of thunder and flashes of lightning were springing into
his hands; and from his hand they were going forth, and only then were they
striking the earth. When I saw this sign of divine wrath which was about to strike
the earth, and in particular a certain place, which for good reasons I cannot name, I
began to implore the Angel to hold off for a few moments, and the world would do
penance. But my plea was a mere nothing in the face of the divine anger.
===
Then I saw the Mother of God, who said to
me, Oh, how pleasing to God is the soul that follows faithfully the inspirations of
His grace! I gave the Savior to the world; as for you, you have to speak to the
world about His great mercy and prepare the world for the Second (91 ) Coming of
Him who will come, not as a merciful Savior, but as a just Judge. Oh, how terrible
is that day! Determined is the day of justice, the day of divine wrath. The angels
tremble before it. Speak to souls about this great mercy while it is still the time for
[granting] mercy. If you keep silent now, you will be answering for a great number
of souls on that terrible day. Fear nothing. Be faithful to the end. I sympathize
with you. "
@@loarnotoole36 That's nonsense.
Maybe you talking about this, but that's clearly not a command to paint it in black and white. There is no other mention of black and white in the entire diary. :
313 +Once, when I was visiting the artist [Eugene Kazimirowski] who was painting the image, and saw that it was not as beautiful as Jesus is, I felt very sad about it, but I hid this deep in my heart. When we had left the artist’s house, Mother Superior [Irene] stayed in town to attend to some matters while I returned home alone. I went
immediately to the chapel and wept a good deal. I said to the Lord, “Who will paint
You as beautiful as You are?” Then I heard these words: Not in the beauty of the
color, nor of the brush lies the greatness of this image, but in My grace. "
I really respect that Father Murr came to a channel that he wasn’t entirely familiar with and which isn’t huge and acted with such humility and service
Amen ! We’ll pray for Fr Emmanuel in the future. God bless you both. As always Fr. Murr it was a pleasure listening to your interview.
A great talk. God bless you. One thing I’d like to correct you on. It was the devotion to Divine Mercy as recommended by s. Faustina that was banned & the use of the DM image in Churches in 1959. However, the Diary was never placed on the Index of Forbidden Books. This is a common error. The reason for this is that the Diary was not fully published back in the 1950’s but only parts of it were. The 1st time it was fully published was in 1981 after the Notification was removed in April 1978. Not that this changes the fact that the whole devotion was banned. Another less known fact was that one of the major reasons why the Holy Office placed the ban in 1959 was after the feedback they receive which they receive from the Polish bishops in 1957. Vast majority came back with negative opinions of it. It was not until Karol Wojtyla became a bishop & then a cardinal that & later pope that things progressed along with the change in the Church after V2. He made it his personal mission at any cost to bring back this devotion publicly & make s. Faustina a Saint. This devotion has sadly replaced in practice the Sacred Heart devotion which gives us the full understanding of God’s mercy & our duty to lead virtuous lives & make reparations for our sins.
@Sebastian... Well said! Especially your closing: >our duty to lead virtuous lives and make reparations for our sins.< Reparation IS key part of the Sacred Heart messages to St. Margaret Mary Alacoque, yet SO little spoken of nowadays. BTW, do you know what MOST greatly pained, offended Our Lord which He told to St. Margaret Mary Alacoque? (Can't imagine how much that's increased in our times!) It was the >indifference »»of Catholics«« to His Real Presence< in the BL. Sacrament in the Tabernacle.
Archbp. Fulton Sheen encouraged a half hour daily spent before Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament for the laity, If at all possible (at least full hour for all Religious persons.) I recall that Mother Teresa of Calcutta said that time spent before Jesus in the BL. Sacrament had central importance her Religious Order >before< all the help given to the poor and sick.
Sr Faustina was barely literate & spoke a unique rare Polish dialect. The Diary is a forgery. Sr Faustina original idea was a bloody beaten scourged face of our Blessed Lord. The Prayer itself isn't bad but don't assume Sr Faustina was in anyway involved w the post 1978 replacement of Low Sunday,diary,new age image,etc Notice the rise of D.M. & devotion to St Joseph suddenly mysteriously falls off the cliff,along w Sacred Heart of Jesus novena/image.
DM is a modernist propaganda. Pope jp2 is a modernist pope just like all vatican 2 popes including pope john 23. The devil hates the rosary so he tries to replace it with the dm chaplet.
Thoroughly enjoyed this conversation! Thank you Emmanuel!
You're welcome!
It seems to me that the writings show that God does not tolerate sin. During Eucharistic Adoration in the convent Jesus was looking very sternly at some of the sisters. Faustina said that if we understood how much we would have to pay for the slightest sin we would never commit a venial sin. God kept showing her His justice. Different times Faustina would say that this soul or that soul was falling into Hell. I did not get the impression that God's Mercy was not obtained without struggle.
Perhaps Fr. Murr hasn’t read Dt. . Faustina:s Diary. She, like St. Catherine of Sienna , reminded that Jesus is hurt even by venues sins.
Cor Iesu Sacratissimum,
Miserere nobis.
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Incl. perhaps BEST explanation of what was + why Index of Forbidden Books mattered that I've ever heard; AND a thoughtful overview of errors in the Church today.
St. Padre Pio said the "Rosary is the weapon!" So... many more we need to pray.
Our Lady Destroyer of All Heresies pray for us.
St. Joseph Patron of the Universal Church pray for us.
St. Michael Archangel defend us.
If you quote Padre Pio as a beacon of truth (which I do) you can't pick and choose his discernment. He was himself a mystic and victim soul. He fully supported the mysticism of Luisa Piccarreta who also appeared on the forbidden books. He supported Garabandal.
@@Fiat.Voluntas.Tua22 I don't see your follow up. Unless, I'm mistaken, Fr. Murr explained some issues with the Divine Mercy devotion (btw, NOT any critique on sanctity of St. Faustina). And the show wasn't on topic of Garabandal or Louisa Piccarretta. Also, as far as I know St. Pio had no words about Faustina or her new devotion. So I don't see his part in any of this discussion.
The point about the index of forbidden books still holds. AND all the books on the list, incl. about the Divine Mercy >were Not removed< from the list: the list simply was taken down: in effect, the Church was informed that it's no longer in force >as a moral or canonical prohibition.< In other words, None of the reasons/causes which had flagged the books were altered, changed or disproved. It's just that you're Not committing a sin by reading any of those books.
Honestly, I'm NOT here to say a person's going against Church teachings, etc. by following the Divine Mercy devotion (btw, the chaplet is 100% orthodox with Church prayers and practice). However, I agree with Fr. Murr that the devotion presents s different focus both in its written explanations and in the devotion's practices… THAN WAS given to and revealed by St. Margaret Mary Alacoque about devotion to the Sacred Heart.
Hence, I don't dissuade others about it, unless I'm asked; yet, personally I focus on what Our Lord revealed to St. Margaret Mary Alacoque.
Great interview 👍
What a wonderful human being... 🙏💗
Thanks ma'am
I like this program very much I think the same
It’s helpful that Emmanuel brought the best from Fr. Murr’s by letting him reminisce like this. Fr. Murr as the oldest child in his family because he was educated I n Catholic schools before the Church lost 500,000 religiosity sifters post Vatican III. His siblings asked these wonderful devoted servants of God.
I believed the Divine Mercy, as I believed in Pope JP2. Later, after much research and reading exerpts from Sr. Faustina's diary, I began to
question this devotion. She was wrong on predicted dates and I cannot believe that Jesus would tell her that He loved her more than anyone else. Even His own mother??? I think Sr. Faustina had some mental heath issues...
anyone else.
A lot of people agree with you. Myself included.
Sister Josefa Menendez (1890-1923) author of The Way of Divine Life which is pretty similar to the diary of sister faustina?
ABSOLUTELY ... DEAD ON ...
Thank you father Murr. This is Mr. Noel Cordero of New York City.
Thank you fr, Murray’s we need more like you. God bless you thru Mary
Father please write more books. I enjoyed your books 📚
Have you read all? I'm surprised. He has quite a bit though
The Divine Mercy image nickname is “heart-less Jesus.” It’s not hard to guess why. The whole devotion is not only missing the Divine Justice side of mercy, it’s devoid of any connection to Mary.
Whenever the modernist church wants to make a Catholic devotion more palatable to Protestants, they discard the very things that make it Catholic (Sacred Heart of Jesus, True Face of Jesus, the Crucifix, the Immaculate Heart of Mary, the Rosary, all Marian devotions, the Latin Mass, any connection to Saints and Angels, any mention of Purgatory, the Sacraments, and more).
What you’re left with is so devoid of any true spirituality, it’s not enough to sustain meaningful conversion and growth…which is, I suppose, the entire point. Think about it!
God bless you, Dasan! That was very wonderful 😁
@@mementofidei You are creating a wonderful channel with great commentary and guests. Keep it up and I’ll keep watching. You might consider being a guest on other shows. Hearing from someone so young and yet so gifted and insightful is always interesting.
@@dasan9178 Thanks ma'am. I'm currently working on something new. I'll let you on this thread. God bless.
The dm picture is also missing the Sacred Wounds of Our LORD JESUS CHRIST.
This channel is AWESOME!
You are a true shepherd, Fr. Murr.
The problem with Confession is in 99% of parishes there is no anonymity. Many more people would go to Confession if it was still in a confessional box not in a room sitting on a chair next to a Priest. ❤
I quite agree with you there. When I was in the NO, that was definitely true.
The anonymity helps the priest in the keeping his vow of secrecy the sacrament of confession.
Remember that Our Lord Jesus is standing beside the Priest in Confession - he already knows your sins but do you have true Humility to repent of your sins - if not there is pride and trouble - go to Confession if you want to make Heaven and be with God for eternity.
@@eginjensen718 You totally missed the point, of removing obstacles for people who would otherwise go. I go frequently🙏❤
Bingo Father Murr! That was my thought too Emmanuel!
Thank you, F&T, an excellent presentation with Father Murray. I suggest searching Lloyd De Jongh's channel for futher study of modernism and all the gnostic heresies - atheism, communism, socialism and Free Masonry. Lloyd does meticulous and ubelievably thorous research on all things atheism related. He goes back to pre-Christ and brings is all the way to the 21st century. It is similar to lifting a cover off the entry to hell!
Sure thing. I will do well to check it out. Thanks!
Thank you for this very instructive video, I admire the intelligent questions and the inspirational and informative answers
Remember Gods ways are different from ours and his thoughts are above ours believe in Gods Mercy always
You are a God send brloved Emanuel. God with you. Very beautiful name. Chosen by your parents for a reason.
I appreciate your kind words. God bless you too.
I have *very* serious doubts about the Divine Mercy chaplet and, especially, the writings of Faustina Kowalska. I just can't subscribe to it! Thanks for making this video!
And thanks Father Murr!
Reading St. Faustina's Diary before Eucharistic Adoration helped me be deeply aware of the gravity of my sins as never before. I realized that I would spend a long time in Purgatory as the state of my soul is so wretched. I confessed Many sins but became so aware of the impact my sins had on so many of God's children. This was leading me to discouragement but know that is the tool of the devil. I am totally dependent on God's Mercy.
The Bible and the Catholic cathechism make us well aware of our sins , Gods mercy is bountiful when we repent of our sins 🙏🙏🙏
Please send Fr Murr to Australia!
I just love your little talking Sacred Heart.
I pray to the ear of God so my friendship with God is unbroken. The Holy Spirit would give me no peace at all if he wanted to correct me. None. No peace. But, I have peace.
I find him true as he ever was.
Awesome channel. I hope many more subscribe. Great video lineup. Great Catholic content. Great interviews. Love your commentary and insights. No downside except one: a pulsating emoji where video of YOU should be. I’m so impressed with you, I can’t help feeling disappointed about not getting to see and connect with you on a more personal level.
I would do video. But I can't afford a camera and my house doesn't exactly have a good background. I decided to do it anyway. I thought it would help people if they knew.
@@mementofidei Keep going anyway. You’re awesome, and so are your guests.
@@dasan9178 Thank you. God bless.
@@mementofidei Do more... as you're able, as best as you can. The Fr Murr interview was EXCELLENT- MUCH need these confusing times
I hope all the priests nowadays are like Fr Murr.
Great video! I liked and subscribed. I agree with Fr Murr concerning Divine Mercy.
Fr. Murr looks and sounds identically to my grandfather Wm. Joseph McMullen from Ireland via Liverpool. It's astounding. He was the son of Denis Patrick McMullen. I wonder if he's related. Fr. Murr is his twin.
Wow. That sounds nice
) “He who refuses to pass through the door of My mercy must pass through the door of My justice ...” -Diary 1146
(5) “Souls perish in spite of My bitter Passion. I am giving them the last hope of salvation; that is, the Feast of My Mercy. If they will not adore My mercy, they will perish for all eternity.” -Diary 965
Use rosary beads - but never says pray after rosary
Our Lady: Pray rosary daily
Rosary only mentioned a couple of times in 700 page diary
@@scootahscoot9389 I use both.
Jesus said to the dying criminal on the cross today you will be with me in Paradise. (Mercy) Then there is the prodigul son who spends all his Fathers money squandering it, and the Father is so happy on his return he throws a feast for him. God shows us many works of mercy throughout the Bible. God is the Creator, we can never comprehend with our intelligence what he as Creator chooses to do, as servants it is not our place. ❤
God will do as He pleases. As for us, we should fear His Justice, hope in His Mercy, and love His Goodness.
@@mementofidei Justice and Infinite Mercy can't even be in the same sentence. Or you are a judge or you have infinite Mercy and you just have to wish in His mercy over His justice, deal with that.
Devine mercy has a power of conversion regarding sinners, modern day pagans or reverts
nope... it's a false devotion.
False just like med jug orgy...confusion for weak catholics who look for signs and wonders and when the world will end etc...etc..Our Lord and Saviour warned us about these times when people would look for outersigns etc...🥴🧐
MO YOUR WRONG TOTALLY@@CRUSNET
@@marybaer4660 nope... Please take a look at the original divine mercy image... There is no wound in "Jesus" hands... It means it came from the devil.
@@CRUSNET Says who, you? A sede vacantist who would have probably agreed to call Saint Pio a fraud and forbid him to say Mass as before Vatican 2?? Because that was the Church that forbid Saint Faustina devotion, know that.
Won't this Justice be served in Purgatory?? The fact that God forgives you through His Mercy doesn't mean you're going straight to Heaven, it just means that you're not damned. I don't see any problem with Divine Mercy. We find the same Mercy of God in the writings of the Servant of God Luisa Picarreta.
Most Divine Mercy devotions on Divine Mercy Sunday have one or more Priests heairng COnfession at the same time. So there is Justice and repentance. in attendance.
How true it is that the corruption of the best is the worst
I have friends that have devotion to both.
You are right. Jesus spoke so simply because he was gathering his sheep- those who had ears to hear.
Love you Fr. MURR. What you say always appeal to me (thank you )i'm wondering about the name Murr whats your country of origin ?...
God is Divine Mercy and any prayers is positive at least this has brought a lot of people close to the 3 pm hour where people worship the Son of God and his passion and death . So don’t condemn this prayer . It has worked and converted a lot of people .
Nobody is condemning it. Pray to the Sacred Heart instead
Every action to make you closer to God, is not from the devil
Father Murr ... sounds a lot like my teachers in Catholic school in the early 60's. Clarity.
My own call is care and nurture of the sheep. My deepest concern is are these things bringing people to the table of Christ or driving them away?
IF I ever did pray this prayer, I keep Justice in mind and ensure that It has fidelity to Tradition?
What is the Original Sacred Heart Devotion, I am very interested in this.
@hm... See words, writings, prayers of St.Margaret Mary Alacoque¹, and her spiritual director,:FrJohn Croiset, S.J.², on details of the Sacred Heart devotion.
¹ St. Margaret Mary Alacoque is THE saint of the Sacred Heart of Our Lord Jesus. GOD chose Margaret Mary to reveal the depths of His Sacred Heart to. Short books of her >Thoughts and Sayings of St. Margaret Mary: For Every DayThe Way of Divine Love< the journal of Sr. Josefa Menéndez, to whom Our Lord revealed His love and Sacred Heart in special ways. The future Pope Pius XII, then a cardinal, wrote a forward in a letter of recommendation for the original publication of her journal. (This is a deeply moving and thoughtful book, which helped bring me back to rediscover the Faith; together with >The Glories of Mary< by St. Alphonsus Ligouri (Doctor of the Church, no less-seriously, if Francis had real humility and love for Our Lady he would take to heart truths about Mary that he's dared publicly to demean and deny!)
² Fr. John Croiset, SJ., was the spiritual director of St. Margaret Mary Alacoque (a little different than her confessor, who was Saint Fr. Claude La Colombière, SJ.) for decades, became intimately familiar with Our Lord's messages to her, and wrote THE classic book on the subject: >The Devotion to the Sacred Heart< republished by TAN. It's filled with profound insights and heartfelt prayers also.
† ❤️ †
Prayer of Margaret Mary Alacoque taken from the book >Devotion To The Sacred Heart< by Fr. John Croiset, S.J.:
Prayer:
O Sacred Heart of Jesus, to Thee I consecrate and offer up my person and my life, my actions, trials, and sufferings, that my entire being may henceforth only be employed in loving, honoring and glorifying Thee. This is my irrevocable will, to belong entirely to Thee, and to do all for Thy love, renouncing with my whole heart all that can displease Thee.
I take Thee, O Sacred Heart, for the sole object of my love, the protection of my life, the pledge of my salvation, the remedy of my frailty and inconstancy, the reparation for all the defects of my life, and my secure refuge at the hour of my death. Be Thou, O Most Merciful Heart, my justification before God Thy Father, and screen me from His anger which I have so justly merited. I fear all from my own weakness and malice, but placing my entire confidence in Thee, O Heart of Love, I hope all from Thine infinite Goodness. Annihilate in me all that can displease or resist Thee. Imprint Thy pure love so deeply in my heart that I may never forget Thee or be separated from Thee.
I beseech Thee, through Thine infinite Goodness, grant that my name be engraved upon Thy Heart, for in this I place all my happiness and all my glory, to live and to die as one of Thy devoted servants. Amen.
ps. This prayer-in all its depth, subtlety >and humility< blows me away (in a different dimension utterly than St. Faustyna, whose sanctity in all truth and justice was never questioned; yet the humility of St Margaret Mary Alacoque before GOD that's conveyed in this prayer is not found, in my humble opinion (and others' more knowledgeable), in her diary.
I'm praying 🙏 and trying step by step to get to the point when I will be able myself to honestly pray Margaret Mary's words as my own.
St. Margaret Mary Alacoque pray for us-that we love the Sacred Heart of Our Lord with a heart like yours.
To find out more about the Sacred Heart devotions look up First Friday Devotion.
A veces Dios mismo hace promesas para obligarse a si mismo a salvarnos. Si la Misericordia de Dios es grande es porque Su JUSTICIA también lo es. Si no hubiera Justicia no habría necesidad de Misericordia. No hablo inglés muy fluido, pero algo entiendo de lo que escucho. Tengo la obligación moral de decir lo "que hemos visto y oido" el dia de la fiesta de la Divina Misericordia de 2004 en la misa de las 3 de la tarde ,en el Santuario de la Divina Misericordia de Buenos Aires. Se podía ver el sol sin molestias en la vista, rayos danzantes rojos y azules girando alrededor del sol (como en forma circular, no radial) y la Santa Faz Perfectamente formada por nubes en un día totalmente despejado de nubes. Todo duró unos instantes y lo vimos todos , hasta el sacerdote párroco del Santuario, que dijo dejó la homilía para consagrar en ese momento. A partir de ese momento ya no puedo tener dudas, además lo vimos todos, todos, no yo solamente. Lo hago bajo juramento y con Dios como testigo, por una cuestión de conciencia y gratitud a Dios por ese signo que nos dio.
@Turi por ejemplo en el A.T. Dios rescata a los Israel después de haber caído gravemente y les aclara que lo hace en virtud de la promesa que le hizo a Abraham. O por la Santidad de Su Santo Nombre para que los paganos no digan ¿donde esta su Dios? O los mismos Israelitas piden perdón apelando a Dios a que lo haga por su promesa. La gente cree que tiene DERECHO a ser salvada y no es así (y hasta llegan a decir ¿por que no me salvaria si yo "no hice nada"?). Hasta el mas grande santo se salva por la misericordia de Dios y no por derecho propio, fundamentada en sus promesas. Lo que si Dios pide es conversión, arrepentimiento y amor, sin eso no hay Misericordia ni Promesa que valga (es necesario corresponder a la gracia)
Gid is justice and mercy. God has the authority to wave punishment like the good theif and martyrs. They go straight to the beatific vision.
He does. However, the good thief was baptized.
Why not honor both devotions? One doesn’t take away from the other.
Those who pray divine mercy realize that we must atone either here or in purgatory. You pray for mercy and forgiveness.
I love all of it. Rosary, divine mercy chaplet, the sacred heart devotion.
Listen to talks by Fr Alar on this devotion. He’s a Great faithful priest who understands this devotion.
Fr Alar is suspect. Don't follow him.
@@horizon-one I just started following Fr. Alar , is there something I should know about him before I follow him ?
The man who sr faustina got to draw the image committed suicide after and the original image she said she received was black and white....😮
@@loarnotoole36
Sr. Faustina's story is pretty sketchy to me.
@@horizon-one How so?
Is true no priests say anything about sin and Repentance or Confession
I recommend the interviewer to contact the Marian Fathers in Stockbridge, MA. They have promoted the devotion to the Divine Mercy from the beginning. They are the authorities on this and they will clarify and eliminate all your confusion on this devotion. Go to the source when you're doing any kind of research.The Sacred Heart devotion and the Devine Mercy complement each other. As for Divine Justice the Divine Mercy devotion requires repentance and sacramental confession.
The image the nun said she recieved was Black and White with no sacred heart on Jesus body , the artist she got to paint her image committed suicide after , she said that the Blessed Eucharist flew into her hand 😮....there was no communion in the hand then , it would have been seen as an abomination , then the image appeared as Red and White , the polish colours 🤔....pope jp 2 andcthis nun were polish 🧐....now the image colours are Red and blue.. JESUS CHRIST our Lord and Saviour does NOT cause confusion....the demonic realm cause lies and confusion to those who look for signs and wonders...😒....the freemasonic modernist caused muvh confusion at v2
I wonder about their unquestioned devotion and that huge church. Just very odd.
@@loarnotoole36 pope jp2 is a modernist, obviously promoting the protestantized novus ordo mass and communion on the hand?
Then why did I substitute Dm chaplet for rosary for over a decade
Huge mistake
Also, the abolition of Indulgences!
The absolving of sins by the priest in confession is not just for Catholics. It's for everyone because everyone is called to the True Church that Jesus Christ instituted. We, as Catholics, are called to bring people into the fold.
If you search Prayers to The Sacred Heart of Jesus by Catholic Crusade
You will see what Fr Charles is talking about. You will understand. Your eyes will be opened
What is this that St. Theresa told faustina she was a saint (in her diary)?
How many here have read the diary cover to cover.
I have four times
Glad I recently escaped DM cult vortex. Pray the rosary daily
If Divine Mercy is a true devotion then it is from God, how could it not have the ‘energy’ from God?
The diary calls for confession again and again. Without confession there is no Mercy without Mercy there is no Justice. I know I’ll get push back but those that know their theology know that God’s Mercy and Justice are one.
It's much more complicated than that. Admittedly we mostly glossed over the issue in this video.
Isn’t he of the Novus Ordo Antichurch founded during Vatican II and now led by Antipope Francis?
No he's not
@@mementofidei Is he not in communion with Francis and the entity he leads?
@@JeremiahAlphonsus He is in communion with the Pope. That is Francis.
@@mementofidei To be in communion with Antipope Francis and the entity he leads is to be at war with the actual Catholic Church and thus at war with Christ. See my many videos on this. It’s time to get real; really real.
@@JeremiahAlphonsus I condemn sedevacantism. It's logically false and incoherent
U should have asks Father if he read the complete diary????????
What does that matter? Sr. Faustina was a weirdo.
@@karentarnell3366 And you carry devil's water.
@@Gianluca- At least, she didn't blaspheme. You're a sick man.
It’s not lacking the aspect of justice at all. Mercy and Justice go hand in hand. There’s no Mercy without Justice and Justice without Mercy. If you read the book on Devine Mercy, there’s a lot said about Justice in there. Also, when you say the Chaplet of Devine Mercy, you are supposed to be meditating on the Passion of Christ. Another point is that there are plenty of people who like Juda Iscariot have a huge problem forgiving themselves and/or release themselves of the guilt they feel (even after confession). And that’s when this devotion is crucial for bringing sinners back to the Church. How come you don’t see that Father? And yes! God’s Mercy is unconditional and His love is unconditional and the Chaplet of Mercy is for sinners who repented. Faustiana talks about the repentance all the time in her book and about sin. Father, you didn’t read the book I think.
I’ve read it four times
Use rosary beads - but never says pray after rosary
Our Lady (7 years earlier) Pray rosary daily
Faustina mentions rosary a couple of times in 700 page diary
The statements from this supposed apparition present a number of problems. The first problem is the promotion of Communion in the hand, which is supposedly endorsed by Our Lord. The Host flies into her hand numerous times, and Our Lord supposedly says that He desires to rest in her hands. I believe this is a diabolical snare to get Communion in the hand accepted in advance of the Vatican II religion.
Second, we see unnecessary praise heaped upon this sister. We see things allegedly said to her by Our Lord that wouldn’t foster humility, but vanity: that she is basically the greatest thing in the world. I don’t believe Our Lord would instruct her to tell her superior that she is the most faithful daughter in the Order. Our Lord could have told the superior such a thing if he wanted it known.
I saw this from the vaticancatholic website also. It's a needless corruption of the Sacred Heart.
Interesting.
@@mementofidei Vati-cath Is Sede though, If it is actually said in the original source and Diary that is a different story though.
The original translations were faulty, weren't accurate. Cardinal Karol Wojtyla had the original Polish text retranslated. Once this was completed the initial problems were solved and those problematic issues were clarified. Contact the Marian Fathers to explain the history to you.
That’s the thesis the DM devotees push without knowledge of the background. Marian Fathers conveniently omit certain facts. A few things which are wrong with this thesis:
1. No official statement from Vatican or primary source that confirms this thesis. It’s a conclusion that people draw mainly from the introduction to the Diary which points out that there were errors in parts of the text.
2. In 1957 the Holy Office asked through the Primate of Poland Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski for feedback from all Polish bishops in their diocese on how the the DM devotion was being promoted & adhered to. The majority of bishops came back with negative opinions, which played a major role in DM devotion being banned.
3. It wasn’t the Diary that was banned or placed on Index of FB’s but the spreading of the devotion in public places of s worship. Images DM were also to be removed.
As you can see from above the reason for ban of DM devotion as recommended by s. Faustina wasn’t due to a faulty translation, the Holy Office wouldn’t have been forthright if this was the only reason. Additionally the Archbishop Jałbrzykowski under whose diocese s. Faustina was also believed that what she disclosed was not supernatural in origin(after hearing her confession) This was also passed on the the commission.
It was the wind of change in Church after V2 that allowed for this devotion to be promoted & elevated which as we can see wouldn’t have taken place under the traditional & orthodox Vatican.
What about Easter
Does it override on for some
I think some souls get more excited over divine mercy rather than Easter?
I did on some occasions
It's the ploy of the devil to distract from the essentials of the faith, chasing instead false messages to make us feel better and think we're doing the right thing.
@@mementofidei a good possibility
Was very devoted for years and had major miracles happen but also it is the prayer and faith ♥️
ALSO, there are extreme problems with Sr. Faustina's Diary on Divine Mercy. There are many shocking statement she made exsmples: that supposedly Jesus said to her, that she is the pearl of His Heart-- He told her thar He has united His Heart to her like no other creature ever... That makes her above the Blessed Virgin Mary!!! Also, puts her above any and all of Saints! Jesus supposedly told her she should not worry about judgement because she will not be judged. He supposedly told her that her love for Him is more pure than that of the Angels!!! There is many many more heretical statements in her diary. Those are a few. Please, research for your self.
Mercy was misconstrued with the Divine Mercy.
Divine mercy chaplet replaced confession 😢
What an idiotic rant.
Did not Pope John Paul attribute the inconsistency to the translation which he himself corrected? That is Pope John Paul 11.
Original Translators included POLISH TRANSLATORS...