Thank you for training this issue on your podcast, as an Indian Hindu I am concerned about this. In fact about 12 years ago one of my colleagues in the US who is a Hindu from Bangladesh was telling me the seriousness of the situation and that he wanted to bring his parents to the US. And it has come to this adversity.
Why was there such opposition to Sheikh Hasina by the UK Labour party, PM Starmer, European intelligentsia and US state department? What about strong powerful woman offends them so much?
@@AnAn___ I don't think any global power cares a whit about it being a man or woman. Apparently they wanted the Islands near Bangladesh though I'm not sure why. I don't think any global power interfered that much but just backed different horses. Most of the issue is with the jamaat-i-islami
@@Seevawonderloaf Jamaat has long had varying levels of support from the British establishment and academia. The de facto headquarters of Jamaat are Pakistan and the UK.
There is also since the fall of Sheikh Hasina growing violence against good liberal muslims, feminists, lbgtq+, agnostics, atheists. Of course, Bangladesh remains one of the best muslim majority countries in the world for nonmuslims, feminists, lbgtq+, agnostics, atheists. Why is there so much anti Sheikh Hasina hostility in Europe, North America and outside of Bangladesh?
The rapes in india are not religiously motivated. while the rapes in bangladesh are. the iranian girl is more concerned about india than bangladesh when the topic is about bangladeshi hindus.
pls understand, Iranian common people mostly are completely against Islamism. The difference of opinion between the regime and its people in Iran is probably unlike anything we see elsewhere. So it completely makes sense when she said that it is expected in Bangladesh from Islamists. And she rightfully said that when it comes to woman’s safety, a hell lot more is expected from India.
@@adityabhattacharyya600 if she dsnt have anything to add and is desensitized by the violence then why is she on the podcast?? she can go to another one to talk about rape/ women safety. she is diverting the topic. All indian podcasters have raised the issue of kolkata rape-muder. tbh it is not politically motivated, the guy was drunk looking for a prey and Abhaya happened to be there unfortunately. what we need is educating men to respect women. no amount of laws can solve this issue. Protest all u want. and no i m not a mamata supporter.
@@adityabhattacharyya600 but this is not the platform to discuss about india. i hope u get my point Mr over-educated woke Bengali. THIS IS NOT THE PLATFORM.
India was a harmonized country before the Muslim religion arrives, very sad that the same brothers and sisters were killing and the name of hate or God.
Can't say I agree so much. While I think we should have done a total population exchange, let's not forget we do have a history of caste-discrimination and untouchability and though it's been outlawed, people still practice in remote areas. We need to get rid of that entirely. STILL Hindus have ben active in reform...same can't be said of all groups unfortunately. And yet still, Indian Muslims are far more tolerant than the ones in Pakistan probably owing to the dilution of extremism with Indian pluralism
@@Seevawonderloaf caste. And untouchability had existed sll over the world. Not just india. ..what we need is hardcore industrialization ... And demography is destiny of a country today
Thank you for raising this issue Yasmine. Bangladesh is a tinderbox. They want to ‘finish the project’ that started centuries ago in the subcontinent. It will be worse than Pakistan in my opinion. Edit: Also I hope your Iranian guest reads the comments and understands that there is a time and place for every conversation. This was supposed to be a conversation to raise awareness about the ongoing crimes against the Hindus of Bangladesh. She totally derailed the conversation from this topic. Yes, we need to discuss SA, but we also need to talk about this topic.
I had no idea that Bangladesh had a Hindu minority. Before the Arab-Muslim spread into the Subcontinent it must have all been India. It's hard to understand why the Bangladeshi muslim had a problem with the Pakistani muslim, except the typically, muslims fight (in sadistic ways) everywhere, before they find another target to scapegoat and blame (for their own flaws).
That was ethnic (language and culture) difference between Pakistan and Bangladesh (erstwhile East Pakistan). Now the jihadi ecosystem of Bangladesh is warming up to Pakistani culture because, Ummah. They are also openly approving of the mass rapes committed by Pakistani soldiers when Bangladesh was trying to separate in 1971. There’s no cure for this ☪️an☪️er.
Short answer to your question - Bangladeshis speak Bangla language and have a different culture while Pakistan standardized Urdu language and is dominated by Punjabi culture.
Deep Halder is correct about India's diversity. India's internal diversity is comparable to the diversity of the rest of the world combined. India has a thousand languages. And perhaps 5 million different ethnic groups with different distinct cultures. Many of these cultures are very different from each other. And are more similar to Silicon Valley, California, than they are to many other cultures inside India. I think this might make dealing with rape difficult, because it comes across as demonizing a specific subgroup or ethnicity or culture. And then the Indian woke make a huge fuss. The USA has similar problems, which has led to a large increase in per capita rape in recent decades. It is difficult to discuss because Americans who oppose prisons and police don't like discussions of rape.
I would agree with you but I genuinely haven't seen any stats related to ra•es being tied to any particular group. Actually contrary, most of the time when it is a gang of men and you see their names, so often the names are a mix of Hindu+Muslim which is an interesting thing because it means that when it comes to the assault on women, even some taken place within a vacant temple, the assailants have nothing to do truly with religion
I took classes at the University at north east state this year with Blangadesh people and I was shocked how much hate the have against USA, Jews people, as well Indus, and they really did not hiding to not body, including females.
This is taught to them by jihadis.Opposition Politicians . Easiest way to become to power in islamic country. Especially in subcontinent. Abuse US, hindus, india, Israel. This unites muslims. With Muslims, they are bengalis. With Pakistanis, they are bangla first. Strange mindset. Bangladesh has to refine itself as part of india and bengal. Not Pakistan. They are bengalis for centuries. Pakistanis for 20 years ,and Bangladeshis only for 50 years
450 police stations set fired across the country There was a time when single police man wasn't there in station. Even whole police force fled from work place. It was just a hell after Hasina leaving 😢
This is islam. This is the face of islam on the subcontinent. Native bharatwasi converted into islam and want to wipe our their own brothers because he didn't convert. No Arabs there. No turks. No Persian,afghan
one guy cares about democracy, the iranian women is more concerned about rapes in india and yasmine is going on different tangents. nobody talked about or asked questions about bangladeshi hindus
All people her should know- that - what is ISLAM ? ISLAM is MAZHAB/DEEN/IDEOLOGY - must be followed in /with every word written in QURAN/Hadees. ISLAM is not RELIGION (RELIGION is Greek/latin word applied to Christianity only.) ISLAM is not DHARMA based Philosophy. ( LIke SANATANA (HINDU) dharma, Buddhist, jain - all dharmic philosophy based spiritual PATHS of life .
Not complex at all .they were forced secularism in 71. My 38 yrs as minority in BD in short majority belive in Pakistani anti India politics and they simply can not get rid of Hindus . Hypocrisy in every statge of life.
I thought this was about the plight of the Bangladeshi Hinuds but somehow the recent rape incident in Kolkata got the priority here. Why can’t the Western liberals stop this whatabouttery and keep the focus. Deep along with other journalists from India could have been invited for a separate discussion on the rape issues in India
Political unrest, communal oppression, attacks on different ideologies are going on in Bangladesh today. The situation may get worse in the coming days.
I like how people are asking silly questions about rapes in India as if there are no rapes in the so-called developed countries. Rape in India happens exactly for the same reasons rape happens in America or Japan. Rape is a primal instinct and can happen anywhere anytime just like murder or burglary no matter how many rules and laws are in place. It is exacerbated by drugs and porn industry and sustained by toxic masculinity and social conditions.
I agree that the culture of rape in India is "sustained by toxic masculinity and social conditions". I've been travelling in India for decades and experienced a big change when BJP's Narendra Modi was elected.
@@sandytatham3592 Nibhaya was raped when Congress was in power. The doctor in Bengal was raped by Mamata Banerjee's goons. Your mental gymnastics won't work here. Find a nastier platform to lie.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi Thankfully Nirbhaya’s tragic rape-murder resulted in NEW rape laws being created, though there was disappointment that marital rape was still not included. The perpetrators of the crime against Nirbhaya were fast-tracked through the courts, and the adult rapists given the death penalty. Hopefully the Kolkata doctor rape-murder case will also see speedy justice, as it has received much media attention. It’s good to see nationwide agitation, and calls for Prime Minister Narendra Modi to give support. Hopefully he will, as it is the central government which can ‘set the tone’ for India’s treatment of females.
Rapes per capita in India are below levels in the USA and UK. Suspect rapes per capita are higher among some subgroups. But because of wokeness and political correctness, studying this phenomenon is difficult. And we don't fully know which subgroups are engaging in rape in many countries. In India rape has been one of the top 5 political issue continually since at least the 1970s. And it is a dominant issue in every Indian election since the 1970s that I am familiar with. This massive emphasis on reducing rape is a positive sign. There was a recent rape of a female in Calcutta India that has been dominating Indian news for a month.
But the West and Islamists love to paint India as the rape capital of the world by amplifying few rape incidents when those would simply go down as a statistic in the West.
Yasmine - I really commend your dedication against religious obscurantism and fight for the cause of freedom of thought and conscience. However, in this interview the term "massacre" is an exaggerated term used. There was a massacre of Hindus in Bangladesh (then part of undivided India) in October 1946 Noalkhali as there was a massacre of Muslims in the Gujrat riots in 2002. There had been attacks on Hindus in Bangladesh, quite widespread, in 2001. Currently, following Hasina's fall, there have been attacks on Hindu property, and at times on Hindu lives but branding this situation as a "massacre" is stretching the definition of massacre.
48:00 It's simple... we are still a largely agrarian-feudal society, with the mores of a pre-industrial culture and all the related identity-based discrimination that comes with it. Now take that and mix it with veneer of modern urban life, you get a gross reaction more often than in other places. Combine that with shockingly poor policing.
Many of the agrarian societies are also matriarchies. I don't think they are the problem when it comes to rape. Isn't rape primarily in urban phenomenon of young men who want to free themselves of the shackles of the community matriarchs and matriarchy? Perhaps influenced by modern culture (rap) etc.? Which ethnic groups in India do you think commit disproportionate rape? Which regions? My observation is that rape varies greatly by ethnic group and region. In the UK, a lot of rapes are performed by conservative sunni punjabi mirpuris. What are the equivalents in India committing rape? I have heard a lot of speculation. But the Indian government refuses to publish this data--perhaps in the interests of "social harmony."
The rapes in india are not religiously motivated. while the rapes in bangladesh are. the iranian girl is more concerned about india than bangladesh when the topic is about bangladeshi hindus.
@@AnAn___ no in india the societies are patriarchal. india is not a monolith. some groups get protection from police and politicians and they kn they wont be reprimanded. its not like parents teach their kids to rape and not respect women. bad people do bad thing everywhere. just bcz rapes happen in india dsnt diminish the religiously motivated crimes in bdesh
u dont need to be a cat to speak on a cat , do u? the guy has written enough and researched much, i think that's enough . also what did he say that was wrong?
@@nahidmiah7234 pew survey is available for india Please read it! Also if u r from any other country then please compare yours with India. U can wish minorities in your country had the same condition as in India!
We are traditional Bangladeshis, we don't have to remember the date of Durga Puja! Hearing the news of Murthy Bhaanga, we understand that Durga Puja is coming.🙂💔
Woah, that was some rambling mental gymnastics from Deep Halder regarding sexual violence in India. I’m Australian, female, and have been travelling in India for over 30 years. Since taking early retirement I’ve been staying for six months every year in many different states. The big change in India happened around the time that the BJP government under Narendra Modi was elected. He gave impetus to young Hindu men to be forceful and superior. India is also horribly corrupt. For example, if a wealthy politician’s son rapes and even kills a foreign or local girl (to stop her talking and identifying him), the police will be paid a hefty bribe and then pin the crime on some man from a lower caste who can’t defend himself under the law. It’s disgusting. About nine years ago I reported a sexual assault, when a young Hindu man forced his way into my hotel room in Mysore. He locked the door, and tried to tear my clothes off in preparation for rape. An elderly Australian-Slovakian man witnessed what was happening to me through the open window to my room, but it was an American girl, who had watched the young Hindu guy tracking foreign girls as they went through hotel reception to their rooms, who was the only person brave enough to rescue me. Hotel security people were very good and they called the police who took me, the American girl, and the young Hindu man to the police station. There was even what seemed like a confession and an apology from the young man, but it went nowhere. The male police officer made me sign a blank statement, then said the young man would be held overnight and prosecuted in court. But the next day I enquired and he seemed to have been released so I suspect a bribe was paid by his family. There are very few female police officers, and the ratio of police to public is still extremely low in India, so this journalist seems to be an apologist for Hinduism. Gang rape and mob intimidation by Hindus is now very prevalent in India, however I never experienced it under Manmohan Singh’s presidency. When I ask Hindus what their ideology teaches them about honesty and attitudes to women, they say it’s all about karma. You do what you can get away with but you face your karma in the next life. Indians used to quote this lovely phrase to me, “guest is God”, but that’s now meaningless. Indians are hugely racist against other Indian groups, especially those of a darker skin colour or of less education or ‘culture’, and if they are from the ‘wrong’ religious group. They are also caste-ist and misogynistic. The rape laws have changed for the better, but neither Hindu nor Muslim personal law considers rape in marriage a crime. Until marital rape becomes a crime, I doubt that females will be treated better. I hope that one day a more balanced government will be returned to power. India is the one country I travel in where I don’t fear anything bad from Muslim men. The Muslims in India that I know well have a much stronger code of honour and honesty compared with the Hindu men, though I’m still very critical of Islam as an ideology.
I was gang πaped by Muslims in India and they said it was written in the Quran to do that. This happened in 2013 when Manmohan Singh was in power. Luckily a Hindu boy came to my rescue. Seems like Iran or Afghanistan would be a better choice for you to travel. Considering those are the safest countries for women.
@@sandytatham3592 I did and the convict didn't get punished because he was a juvenile and a Muslim his friend however was caught with little consequences. The Manmohan Singh government used to pander to muslims so he was also given a bail with a bailbond of Rs. 16001 which was paid by the government. So, basically I have a completely different expression to yours. A few years ago I visited Bengal and was assaulted in the metro by a Bangladeshi Muslim immigrant which I reported but to no avail. The Mamata Banerjee government there protect πapist when they are his party workers and Muslim. Now listening to the doctor being gang πaped and murdered by political goons of Mamata Banerjee in reputed state government hospital in Kolkata. Dr golam Azam and Shahnaz Khan and Yasmin Khatoon are the main accused in this case all faliciated by Sandip Ghosh the principal who is associated withTMC. No wonder the state machinery is protecting Muslim πapists.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi I’m sorry you didn’t achieve any justice. It’s not surprising that we have quite different experiences though because we are from very different backgrounds. Unfortunately vote-bank politics is now increasing in Western democracies too, such as in UK, US, Australia and Canada. It’s not easy to get accurate statistics but rape per capita is still quite low in India, however when it does happen it’s often violent and frequently involves gangs. And the legal process is quite corrupt and not transparent. If the Prime Minister could step in and set a strong example of prosecuting ALL men who commit sexual violence against females I think it would help a lot.
My comment as a Bangladeshi,, Please come to Bangladesh and collect the evidence and prove it ,, all journalist in the world are welcome in Bangladesh,,, But the social media comment and showing up is not the correct evidence,, Thank you
Everybody watching this video should visit Bangladesh and see for themselves how Hindus are living here instead of just believing what this liar is breeding
Please do not mix everything and say that all RELIGIONS !! - Juda, christianity, Islam, HINDU, Buddhist, jain etc. ISLAM is not RELIGION. ISLAM is called MAZHAB/DEEN/Ideology. christianity is RELIGION. sanatana/hindu/Buddhist/jain are DHARMIC philosophy based spiritual paths. All people should make this distinction. they are different. evrything is not a RELIGION.
Do you even raise your voice againist china goverment for attacking muslim.I have onething to say you that i am bangladeshi i personally donot see any violence against hindu brothers.If you see violence against hindus in recent time i can Guarantee you that such incidents took place because political reason.I have one example that come in my head that in syhlet an bnp party activist attacked to an awami league and destroy his house which is almost look like a temple and oviously the awami league layman was a hindu .And your india media sir reported that muslim destroyed hindus temple,which is false news.thanks.i am not good at english.
as far as the statistics is concern , in every way muslims r getting safer and safer. could u elaborate. independent and credible research also back the claim eg - pew research paper
what is SANATANA DHARMA (HINDU - Hindu is a Geographical term ,not religion . There is no such thing as "HINDU" "RELIGION". Both these terms are given, imposed by foreign , outside rulers. what is SANATANA DHARMA ( HINDU)?- IS A dharmic PHILOSOPHY based spiritual path, search for truth , which raises human conscience & consciousness to a higher level leading to self realization and seeing God in all - the creation.
DEEP & YASMINE - please note. Bangladesh is an ISLAMIC theocracy - officially ISLAMIC . so, unwritten understanding is that Bdesh should follow ISLAMIC tenets, sharia rules. So, everything you talk should be explained , seen in light of QURAN/HADEES/SIRA. Otherwise you will not make much sense.
My comment as a Bangladeshi,, Please come to Bangladesh and collect the evidence and prove it ,, all journalist in the world are welcome in Bangladesh,,, But the social media comment and showing up is not the correct evidence,, Thank you
@@djboss9732 well and thank you for advice of searching his name,, I know his name and I know I saw his video before,, but now I don't like his video or any post, because I think and my guess is that,,, He has a lot of lack of knowledge a lot of ignorance and a lot of pre planned trained dog and a false propaganda pig,,, I saw his video before and I supported him a lot even 5 months ago,,, But when I see he is a trained dog and a propaganda pig,, What should you say if you see his kind of Identity ???? I have a lot of evidence why I told him.. And listen , what I say to you about him is true,,,, Thank you,,,,
Thank you for training this issue on your podcast, as an Indian Hindu I am concerned about this. In fact about 12 years ago one of my colleagues in the US who is a Hindu from Bangladesh was telling me the seriousness of the situation and that he wanted to bring his parents to the US. And it has come to this adversity.
Why was there such opposition to Sheikh Hasina by the UK Labour party, PM Starmer, European intelligentsia and US state department?
What about strong powerful woman offends them so much?
@@AnAn___ I don't think any global power cares a whit about it being a man or woman. Apparently they wanted the Islands near Bangladesh though I'm not sure why. I don't think any global power interfered that much but just backed different horses. Most of the issue is with the jamaat-i-islami
@@Seevawonderloaf Jamaat has long had varying levels of support from the British establishment and academia. The de facto headquarters of Jamaat are Pakistan and the UK.
dont believe him he is just showing you his narrative to shame our country these most hendus are liars and evil people
OMG Yas! Thanks! There's so much silence regarding the persecution going on in Bangladesh against Hindus. Thank you for bringing attention to it.
Against all nonmuslims. Christians and Buddhists included.
There is also since the fall of Sheikh Hasina growing violence against good liberal muslims, feminists, lbgtq+, agnostics, atheists.
Of course, Bangladesh remains one of the best muslim majority countries in the world for nonmuslims, feminists, lbgtq+, agnostics, atheists.
Why is there so much anti Sheikh Hasina hostility in Europe, North America and outside of Bangladesh?
@@AnAn___secular Muslims, LGBTQ Liberals have the privilege of hiding behind their Muslim identity. That's not the case with Hindus.
@@AnAn___Liberals and LGBTQ will still be spared for their Islamic identity. That privilege is not available to Hindus.
@@AnAn___ Jamaat Lobby. Also Liberals have privilege of being Muslim, Hindus don't have that privilege.
The rapes in india are not religiously motivated.
while the rapes in bangladesh are.
the iranian girl is more concerned about india than bangladesh when the topic is about bangladeshi hindus.
pls understand, Iranian common people mostly are completely against Islamism. The difference of opinion between the regime and its people in Iran is probably unlike anything we see elsewhere. So it completely makes sense when she said that it is expected in Bangladesh from Islamists.
And she rightfully said that when it comes to woman’s safety, a hell lot more is expected from India.
@@adityabhattacharyya600 if she dsnt have anything to add and is desensitized by the violence then why is she on the podcast??
she can go to another one to talk about rape/ women safety. she is diverting the topic.
All indian podcasters have raised the issue of kolkata rape-muder.
tbh it is not politically motivated, the guy was drunk looking for a prey and Abhaya happened to be there unfortunately.
what we need is educating men to respect women. no amount of laws can solve this issue. Protest all u want. and no i m not a mamata supporter.
@@AA13494 thereby further proving that a lot of is expected from India compared to religious theocracies.
@@adityabhattacharyya600 but this is not the platform to discuss about india.
i hope u get my point Mr over-educated woke Bengali.
THIS IS NOT THE PLATFORM.
Stop spreading lies there are no rapes what are you talking about dont accuse us of doing evil things we are not like you and never will be.
Peace and love to our Hindu brothers and Sisters
Thank you
Thank you! I know a lot of people watch this show and you’re educating them too!
Thank you Yasmine. You are a true champion of humanity
India was a harmonized country before the Muslim religion arrives, very sad that the same brothers and sisters were killing and the name of hate or God.
Muslims are violent because of hadiths
Muslims of same family, kill hindus of same family. Shame
Can't say I agree so much. While I think we should have done a total population exchange, let's not forget we do have a history of caste-discrimination and untouchability and though it's been outlawed, people still practice in remote areas. We need to get rid of that entirely. STILL Hindus have ben active in reform...same can't be said of all groups unfortunately.
And yet still, Indian Muslims are far more tolerant than the ones in Pakistan probably owing to the dilution of extremism with Indian pluralism
@@Seevawonderloaf no they are not . Check out what's going on.
@@Seevawonderloaf caste. And untouchability had existed sll over the world. Not just india. ..what we need is hardcore industrialization ... And demography is destiny of a country today
Thank you for raising this issue Yasmine. Bangladesh is a tinderbox. They want to ‘finish the project’ that started centuries ago in the subcontinent. It will be worse than Pakistan in my opinion.
Edit: Also I hope your Iranian guest reads the comments and understands that there is a time and place for every conversation. This was supposed to be a conversation to raise awareness about the ongoing crimes against the Hindus of Bangladesh. She totally derailed the conversation from this topic. Yes, we need to discuss SA, but we also need to talk about this topic.
I had no idea that Bangladesh had a Hindu minority. Before the Arab-Muslim spread into the Subcontinent it must have all been India. It's hard to understand why the Bangladeshi muslim had a problem with the Pakistani muslim, except the typically, muslims fight (in sadistic ways) everywhere, before they find another target to scapegoat and blame (for their own flaws).
That was ethnic (language and culture) difference between Pakistan and Bangladesh (erstwhile East Pakistan). Now the jihadi
ecosystem of Bangladesh is warming up to Pakistani culture because, Ummah. They are also openly approving of the mass rapes committed by Pakistani soldiers when Bangladesh was trying to separate in 1971. There’s no cure for this ☪️an☪️er.
I responded to you in great detail and guess what, the comment was deleted!
Short answer to your question - Bangladeshis speak Bangla language and have a different culture while Pakistan standardized Urdu language and is dominated by Punjabi culture.
Unsurprisingly, the j1h@d1 ecosystem of Bangladesh is now warming up to Pak because, Ummah. There’s no cure for this ☪️an☪️er.
That is the most disgusting as a hummans. Even India helped Bangladesh people to escape to India when Pakistan killed them.
Deep Halder is correct about India's diversity. India's internal diversity is comparable to the diversity of the rest of the world combined. India has a thousand languages. And perhaps 5 million different ethnic groups with different distinct cultures. Many of these cultures are very different from each other. And are more similar to Silicon Valley, California, than they are to many other cultures inside India.
I think this might make dealing with rape difficult, because it comes across as demonizing a specific subgroup or ethnicity or culture. And then the Indian woke make a huge fuss.
The USA has similar problems, which has led to a large increase in per capita rape in recent decades. It is difficult to discuss because Americans who oppose prisons and police don't like discussions of rape.
I would agree with you but I genuinely haven't seen any stats related to ra•es being tied to any particular group. Actually contrary, most of the time when it is a gang of men and you see their names, so often the names are a mix of Hindu+Muslim which is an interesting thing because it means that when it comes to the assault on women, even some taken place within a vacant temple, the assailants have nothing to do truly with religion
At 43 min , refer to Karl Popper’s ‘Paradox of Tolerance’. Intolerance can’t be tolerated under the guise of democratic values .
I took classes at the University at north east state this year with Blangadesh people and I was shocked how much hate the have against USA, Jews people, as well Indus, and they really did not hiding to not body, including females.
This is taught to them by jihadis.Opposition Politicians . Easiest way to become to power in islamic country. Especially in subcontinent. Abuse US, hindus, india, Israel. This unites muslims. With Muslims, they are bengalis. With Pakistanis, they are bangla first. Strange mindset. Bangladesh has to refine itself as part of india and bengal. Not Pakistan. They are bengalis for centuries. Pakistanis for 20 years ,and Bangladeshis only for 50 years
450 police stations set fired across the country There was a time when single police man wasn't there in station. Even whole police force fled from work place. It was just a hell after Hasina leaving 😢
Yes because those police fired bullets to students. They are Hasina’s puppets. Hasina was a fascist and played minority card.
This is islam. This is the face of islam on the subcontinent. Native bharatwasi converted into islam and want to wipe our their own brothers because he didn't convert. No Arabs there. No turks. No Persian,afghan
Wonderful interview! Thank you both!
Thank you Yasmine Mohammed for inviting deep Halder
Thanks for raising our voice 🙏 to the world.🙏🕉️🇧🇩
Why are there no demonstrations, protests, and encampments on Western college campuses to protest this tragedy and travesty??
one guy cares about democracy, the iranian women is more concerned about rapes in india and yasmine is going on different tangents.
nobody talked about or asked questions about bangladeshi hindus
She is muslim. Partial and wants to hide things
All people her should know- that - what is ISLAM ? ISLAM is MAZHAB/DEEN/IDEOLOGY - must be followed in /with every word written in QURAN/Hadees.
ISLAM is not RELIGION (RELIGION is Greek/latin word applied to Christianity only.)
ISLAM is not DHARMA based Philosophy. ( LIke SANATANA (HINDU) dharma, Buddhist, jain - all dharmic philosophy based spiritual PATHS of life .
ok pagan
The comments about protected democracy is a great analysis.
Not complex at all .they were forced secularism in 71. My 38 yrs as minority in BD in short majority belive in Pakistani anti India politics and they simply can not get rid of Hindus . Hypocrisy in every statge of life.
A very good thing to think. What do we really know?
I thought this was about the plight of the Bangladeshi Hinuds but somehow the recent rape incident in Kolkata got the priority here. Why can’t the Western liberals stop this whatabouttery and keep the focus.
Deep along with other journalists from India could have been invited for a separate discussion on the rape issues in India
Political unrest, communal oppression, attacks on different ideologies are going on in Bangladesh today. The situation may get worse in the coming days.
I like how people are asking silly questions about rapes in India as if there are no rapes in the so-called developed countries. Rape in India happens exactly for the same reasons rape happens in America or Japan. Rape is a primal instinct and can happen anywhere anytime just like murder or burglary no matter how many rules and laws are in place. It is exacerbated by drugs and porn industry and sustained by toxic masculinity and social conditions.
I agree that the culture of rape in India is "sustained by toxic masculinity and social conditions". I've been travelling in India for decades and experienced a big change when BJP's Narendra Modi was elected.
@@sandytatham3592 Nibhaya was raped when Congress was in power. The doctor in Bengal was raped by Mamata Banerjee's goons. Your mental gymnastics won't work here. Find a nastier platform to lie.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi
Thankfully Nirbhaya’s tragic rape-murder resulted in NEW rape laws being created, though there was disappointment that marital rape was still not included. The perpetrators of the crime against Nirbhaya were fast-tracked through the courts, and the adult rapists given the death penalty. Hopefully the Kolkata doctor rape-murder case will also see speedy justice, as it has received much media attention. It’s good to see nationwide agitation, and calls for Prime Minister Narendra Modi to give support. Hopefully he will, as it is the central government which can ‘set the tone’ for India’s treatment of females.
Rapes per capita in India are below levels in the USA and UK.
Suspect rapes per capita are higher among some subgroups. But because of wokeness and political correctness, studying this phenomenon is difficult. And we don't fully know which subgroups are engaging in rape in many countries.
In India rape has been one of the top 5 political issue continually since at least the 1970s. And it is a dominant issue in every Indian election since the 1970s that I am familiar with. This massive emphasis on reducing rape is a positive sign.
There was a recent rape of a female in Calcutta India that has been dominating Indian news for a month.
But the West and Islamists love to paint India as the rape capital of the world by amplifying few rape incidents when those would simply go down as a statistic in the West.
I need a help how can i contact with u?
Religious intolerance has poisoned the world. Very sad.
Yasmine - I really commend your dedication against religious obscurantism and fight for the cause of freedom of thought and conscience. However, in this interview the term "massacre" is an exaggerated term used. There was a massacre of Hindus in Bangladesh (then part of undivided India) in October 1946 Noalkhali as there was a massacre of Muslims in the Gujrat riots in 2002. There had been attacks on Hindus in Bangladesh, quite widespread, in 2001. Currently, following Hasina's fall, there have been attacks on Hindu property, and at times on Hindu lives but branding this situation as a "massacre" is stretching the definition of massacre.
71 was not a targeted hindu massacre? chuknagar?
Dear Yasmine Mohammed, Do you think Bangladesh is a state of India??
48:00 It's simple... we are still a largely agrarian-feudal society, with the mores of a pre-industrial culture and all the related identity-based discrimination that comes with it. Now take that and mix it with veneer of modern urban life, you get a gross reaction more often than in other places. Combine that with shockingly poor policing.
Many of the agrarian societies are also matriarchies. I don't think they are the problem when it comes to rape.
Isn't rape primarily in urban phenomenon of young men who want to free themselves of the shackles of the community matriarchs and matriarchy? Perhaps influenced by modern culture (rap) etc.?
Which ethnic groups in India do you think commit disproportionate rape? Which regions? My observation is that rape varies greatly by ethnic group and region.
In the UK, a lot of rapes are performed by conservative sunni punjabi mirpuris. What are the equivalents in India committing rape?
I have heard a lot of speculation. But the Indian government refuses to publish this data--perhaps in the interests of "social harmony."
The rapes in india are not religiously motivated.
while the rapes in bangladesh are.
the iranian girl is more concerned about india than bangladesh when the topic is about bangladeshi hindus.
@@AnAn___ no in india the societies are patriarchal. india is not a monolith.
some groups get protection from police and politicians and they kn they wont be reprimanded.
its not like parents teach their kids to rape and not respect women.
bad people do bad thing everywhere. just bcz rapes happen in india dsnt diminish the religiously motivated crimes in bdesh
יסמין את מעולה! רק מגיב כדי להגביר חשיפה
🇮🇳❤️✌️
Why that irritating thumbnail ?
No happy faces plz
Abbhey durse desh ke log Hinglish nahi bolte. Stop using Indian words without explaining them.
Yasmeen the law it is a monster truck good job at your face what's what Audi key what time does that mean what's up Hollywood
What a great propaganda problem in Bangladesh but you bring one indian guy to talk about. You have to bring someone Bangladeshi hindu.
u dont need to be a cat to speak on a cat , do u?
the guy has written enough and researched much, i think that's enough . also what did he say that was wrong?
@@Shva927 he have to thik about his country minority fist than he can comment for another country
@@nahidmiah7234 pew survey is available for india
Please read it!
Also if u r from any other country then please compare yours with India.
U can wish minorities in your country had the same condition as in India!
We are traditional Bangladeshis, we don't have to remember the date of Durga Puja! Hearing the news of Murthy Bhaanga, we understand that Durga Puja is coming.🙂💔
Woah, that was some rambling mental gymnastics from Deep Halder regarding sexual violence in India. I’m Australian, female, and have been travelling in India for over 30 years. Since taking early retirement I’ve been staying for six months every year in many different states. The big change in India happened around the time that the BJP government under Narendra Modi was elected. He gave impetus to young Hindu men to be forceful and superior. India is also horribly corrupt. For example, if a wealthy politician’s son rapes and even kills a foreign or local girl (to stop her talking and identifying him), the police will be paid a hefty bribe and then pin the crime on some man from a lower caste who can’t defend himself under the law. It’s disgusting.
About nine years ago I reported a sexual assault, when a young Hindu man forced his way into my hotel room in Mysore. He locked the door, and tried to tear my clothes off in preparation for rape. An elderly Australian-Slovakian man witnessed what was happening to me through the open window to my room, but it was an American girl, who had watched the young Hindu guy tracking foreign girls as they went through hotel reception to their rooms, who was the only person brave enough to rescue me. Hotel security people were very good and they called the police who took me, the American girl, and the young Hindu man to the police station. There was even what seemed like a confession and an apology from the young man, but it went nowhere. The male police officer made me sign a blank statement, then said the young man would be held overnight and prosecuted in court. But the next day I enquired and he seemed to have been released so I suspect a bribe was paid by his family. There are very few female police officers, and the ratio of police to public is still extremely low in India, so this journalist seems to be an apologist for Hinduism.
Gang rape and mob intimidation by Hindus is now very prevalent in India, however I never experienced it under Manmohan Singh’s presidency. When I ask Hindus what their ideology teaches them about honesty and attitudes to women, they say it’s all about karma. You do what you can get away with but you face your karma in the next life. Indians used to quote this lovely phrase to me, “guest is God”, but that’s now meaningless. Indians are hugely racist against other Indian groups, especially those of a darker skin colour or of less education or ‘culture’, and if they are from the ‘wrong’ religious group. They are also caste-ist and misogynistic. The rape laws have changed for the better, but neither Hindu nor Muslim personal law considers rape in marriage a crime. Until marital rape becomes a crime, I doubt that females will be treated better.
I hope that one day a more balanced government will be returned to power. India is the one country I travel in where I don’t fear anything bad from Muslim men. The Muslims in India that I know well have a much stronger code of honour and honesty compared with the Hindu men, though I’m still very critical of Islam as an ideology.
😂😂Nice creative story .....
I was gang πaped by Muslims in India and they said it was written in the Quran to do that. This happened in 2013 when Manmohan Singh was in power. Luckily a Hindu boy came to my rescue. Seems like Iran or Afghanistan would be a better choice for you to travel. Considering those are the safest countries for women.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi
I’m very sorry that you were raped. Were you able to report it to the police? Were the perpetrators convicted and punished?
@@sandytatham3592 I did and the convict didn't get punished because he was a juvenile and a Muslim his friend however was caught with little consequences. The Manmohan Singh government used to pander to muslims so he was also given a bail with a bailbond of Rs. 16001 which was paid by the government. So, basically I have a completely different expression to yours. A few years ago I visited Bengal and was assaulted in the metro by a Bangladeshi Muslim immigrant which I reported but to no avail. The Mamata Banerjee government there protect πapist when they are his party workers and Muslim. Now listening to the doctor being gang πaped and murdered by political goons of Mamata Banerjee in reputed state government hospital in Kolkata.
Dr golam Azam and Shahnaz Khan and Yasmin Khatoon are the main accused in this case all faliciated by Sandip Ghosh the principal who is associated withTMC. No wonder the state machinery is protecting Muslim πapists.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi
I’m sorry you didn’t achieve any justice. It’s not surprising that we have quite different experiences though because we are from very different backgrounds. Unfortunately vote-bank politics is now increasing in Western democracies too, such as in UK, US, Australia and Canada. It’s not easy to get accurate statistics but rape per capita is still quite low in India, however when it does happen it’s often violent and frequently involves gangs. And the legal process is quite corrupt and not transparent. If the Prime Minister could step in and set a strong example of prosecuting ALL men who commit sexual violence against females I think it would help a lot.
My comment as a Bangladeshi,,
Please come to Bangladesh and collect the evidence and prove it ,, all journalist in the world are welcome in Bangladesh,,,
But the social media comment and showing up is not the correct evidence,,
Thank you
Madam & Sir, please don"t get worked up on such trivial incidents.
They asked for it.
Hindus killed opens the route of jannat for Gazis.
"They asked for it"! What do you mean?
Everybody watching this video should visit Bangladesh and see for themselves how Hindus are living here instead of just believing what this liar is breeding
Please do not mix everything and say that all RELIGIONS !! - Juda, christianity, Islam, HINDU, Buddhist, jain etc. ISLAM is not RELIGION. ISLAM is called MAZHAB/DEEN/Ideology. christianity is RELIGION. sanatana/hindu/Buddhist/jain are DHARMIC philosophy based spiritual paths. All people should make this distinction. they are different. evrything is not a RELIGION.
Do you even raise your voice againist china goverment for attacking muslim.I have onething to say you that i am bangladeshi i personally donot see any violence against hindu brothers.If you see violence against hindus in recent time i can Guarantee you that such incidents took place because political reason.I have one example that come in my head that in syhlet an bnp party activist attacked to an awami league and destroy his house which is almost look like a temple and oviously the awami league layman was a hindu .And your india media sir reported that muslim destroyed hindus temple,which is false news.thanks.i am not good at english.
Muslim are being attack in India. Please save them.😢😢😢
J1h@di ☠️
Are you serious? I am surprised and confused! Muslims are actually very good at playing victim!
then why muslim population incresing in india
There is no similaritie between your question and his anwer.s@@ulala9729
as far as the statistics is concern , in every way muslims r getting safer and safer.
could u elaborate.
independent and credible research also back the claim eg - pew research paper
what is SANATANA DHARMA (HINDU - Hindu is a Geographical term ,not religion . There is no such thing as "HINDU" "RELIGION". Both these terms are given, imposed by foreign , outside rulers.
what is SANATANA DHARMA ( HINDU)?- IS A dharmic PHILOSOPHY based spiritual path, search for truth , which raises human conscience & consciousness to a higher level leading to self realization and seeing God in all - the creation.
DEEP & YASMINE - please note. Bangladesh is an ISLAMIC theocracy - officially ISLAMIC . so, unwritten understanding is that Bdesh should follow ISLAMIC tenets, sharia rules. So, everything you talk should be explained , seen in light of QURAN/HADEES/SIRA. Otherwise you will not make much sense.
why r u two laughing ...nuts
To understand, know, think, ISLAM -- one must read, QURAN, HADEES, SIRA, see ISLAMIC culture, history of ISLAM.
My comment as a Bangladeshi,,
Please come to Bangladesh and collect the evidence and prove it ,, all journalist in the world are welcome in Bangladesh,,,
But the social media comment and showing up is not the correct evidence,,
Thank you
these pagans are anti muslims
search asad noor
@@djboss9732 well and thank you for advice of searching his name,,
I know his name and I know I saw his video before,, but now I don't like his video or any post, because I think and my guess is that,,,
He has a lot of lack of knowledge a lot of ignorance and a lot of pre planned trained dog and a false propaganda pig,,,
I saw his video before and I supported him a lot even 5 months ago,,,
But when I see he is a trained dog and a propaganda pig,,
What should you say if you see his kind of Identity ????
I have a lot of evidence why I told him..
And listen , what I say to you about him is true,,,,
Thank you,,,,
@@MD.NaimBokthair can you educate me why and how he is a trained dog