for me minjae is 2nd place in the episode..minjae can give me surprise for her performance but unfortunately she cant get better result.. i dont even know minjae before girl spirit,but now i really supporting her, never mind i believe she can get recognize by her performance but not result 민재이야 최고이야~
for people who think she deserved higher, check out the original song : my friend by cho pd & insooni. you'd notice minjae lacks the powerful vocals of insooni in the original song. kei undoubtedly was #1 and seunghee was still better vocally.. seunghee's performance mixed 2 different songs together which would naturally make the whole song not as pleasing to hear as 1 good song (which is probably why you fans are whining about how minjae lost), but they're scored mainly on their vocals and not performance. I love the original song but i'd have to agree with seo in young said that minjae didn't do the original justice.
Can all fans read this? ^ this show is actually quite fair because it isn't the fandom that is voting. I do like her voice and the performance overall, but something was lacking.
Ok so I didn't watch this broadcast live but just from watching the stages, I'll say that the best were Kei's and Minjae's. I did feel like something was lacking from this stage, the hype/excitement wasn't really there, and it could have been arranged better, but I liked the vocals/rap here.
she got 90 points while the two others got 100+ and 91 respectively. minjae deserved 3rd place but omg's seunghee got 2nd place all of a sudden despite getting 88 points. just wtf?
Because for the second round the audience are only allowed one vote. Some audiences that voted for Minjae may have voted in the second round for other performances that they prefer over hers.
reeve ng Do you watch Girl Spirit? Even before it was aired, it was confirmed that the audience is composed of students from music universities. All of them are musically-inclined (except for the Military special episode) but yes, I'm pretty sure there still is a bias.
what the hell to why minjae in the 1st vote get 90 be 3rd the good result and 2nd vote seunghee become top 3? and get 2nd in final vote??????? what the shady/ unfair vote? minjae u should be in top 3 after 2nd vote!
yup, the 2nd vote to make seunghee point more damn higher. is not fair. is very shady. and seungyeon is 91 point 2nd in 1st vote. after that finish the 2nd vote then become to 3rd in top 3 .
Ooh i kn sonamo I listen to some songs of them and i liked their last comeback it's just that I don't kn them individualy. Anyhow she rocks support her wish the voting was more honest. I love seunghee but still minjae was waaaaayyy better
![[Review] Girl Spirit Ep.5: Jin-sol from April sings 'Woo-ah(You are so gorgeous)'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IlKDNnLP4wk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Review] Girl Spirit Ep.5: Jin-sol from April sings 'Woo-ah(You are so gorgeous)'](/img/tr.png)
for me minjae is 2nd place in the episode..minjae can give me surprise for her performance but unfortunately she cant get better result..
i dont even know minjae before girl spirit,but now i really supporting her, never mind i believe she can get recognize by her performance but not result
민재이야 최고이야~
stupid show. stupid production team.
조피디 가사전달력 탑급이네
귀에 다 들림
minjae did well ♡♡♡
A girl who can sing and play the piano well with a guy who showed all the other rappers on the show how it's done, how can they not get in top 3?
She deserve be among the top 3, this was unfair as hell!
She has so much talent!
minjae did very well this week, she deserve to be top 3
i feel bad for Minjae with the result :( this program is still based on popularity i guess
always. not the 1st time already.
yeah, she did great tho :(
She's won once though :O
The vote.. its not about vocal, its all about perfomance. but i can say its about how seo in young react(?)
I disagree with your last sentence. If it is based on popularity kei would have won many times cause she is really popular
저게모야 인순이선생님 델구와!!!!
Wow! Minjae, you did great
for people who think she deserved higher, check out the original song : my friend by cho pd & insooni.
you'd notice minjae lacks the powerful vocals of insooni in the original song.
kei undoubtedly was #1 and seunghee was still better vocally.. seunghee's performance mixed 2 different songs together which would naturally make the whole song not as pleasing to hear as 1 good song (which is probably why you fans are whining about how minjae lost), but they're scored mainly on their vocals and not performance. I love the original song but i'd have to agree with seo in young said that minjae didn't do the original justice.
Can all fans read this? ^ this show is actually quite fair because it isn't the fandom that is voting. I do like her voice and the performance overall, but something was lacking.
if she didn't at least place 3rd this time around, there has to be something wrong with this show. I mean this performance deserves top 3
딕션 참 좋아
조피디는 뭐 최고네❤
MINJAEEE
Ok so I didn't watch this broadcast live but just from watching the stages, I'll say that the best were Kei's and Minjae's. I did feel like something was lacking from this stage, the hype/excitement wasn't really there, and it could have been arranged better, but I liked the vocals/rap here.
파이팅! 사랑해 민재야!
I still Think this is the best song in this team.. her voice so in point
her voice matches this song really well
Go Minjae Go Minjae!!! Hope she can get more spotlight after attending this show!!
fighting minjae!!!!~
~Fighting Minjae~
fighting minjae! love you ☺ ❤
talent
Minjae you did well I'm proud of you
I like her voice 💕
She should've been at the top 3! I know Seunghee is competitive but I guess Minjae is better on this episode. Ugh.
I love you minjae..
fighting Minjaeng♡
she got 90 points while the two others got 100+ and 91 respectively. minjae deserved 3rd place but omg's seunghee got 2nd place all of a sudden despite getting 88 points. just wtf?
Because for the second round the audience are only allowed one vote. Some audiences that voted for Minjae may have voted in the second round for other performances that they prefer over hers.
as we all know the 100 voter is not a real future singer student.
90% is a fandom. that the point.
Wow!!! How you know that they are in a fandom not students? Are you there?
reeve ng
Do you watch Girl Spirit? Even before it was aired, it was confirmed that the audience is composed of students from music universities. All of them are musically-inclined (except for the Military special episode) but yes, I'm pretty sure there still is a bias.
cool!👍👍💓
what the hell to why minjae in the 1st vote get 90 be 3rd the good result
and 2nd vote seunghee become top 3?
and get 2nd in final vote???????
what the shady/ unfair vote?
minjae u should be in top 3 after 2nd vote!
Seunghee didn't deserve be in top2 because she gets 88 meanwhile Minjae 90 points.
yup, the 2nd vote to make seunghee point more damn higher.
is not fair. is very shady. and seungyeon is 91 point 2nd in 1st vote.
after that finish the 2nd vote then become to 3rd in top 3 .
+reeve ng Yeah.
I think GS loves Seunghee too much.
q
can't blame her, because they have more fandom voting. voting system is never fair.
and production team can change any point what they want.
what they like.
what is the first song she sang? i have heard a HK song that my mother always played when i was a child, its the same beautiful tune.
friend by cho yong pil. theres also a remake version by alan tam
First comment:) well done minjae all us Pinecones are proud....
kei biased but for me she is #1
plus the song is so familar but i cant remember its name
i remembered it it was a remix by toppdogg and another singer i think friends is the name of the song or not i dont remeber really
Friends - Insooni
OMG Tooo strong
음질이 약간 떨어진게 아쉽네 ㅜㅜ
답장은 필수
what song that minjae sing ?
조피디 아직 살아있네
She sounds too old for me . Just my opinion non the less this is great performance
In which group is she??
SONAMOO aka the most underrated group.
SONAMOO ( TS ENT.)
Ooh i kn sonamo I listen to some songs of them and i liked their last comeback it's just that I don't kn them individualy. Anyhow she rocks support her wish the voting was more honest. I love seunghee but still minjae was waaaaayyy better
이 맛이 아니야
i hate cho pd... -_-
Minjae you did great 💕
노래부르는 여자분 누군지 모르지만 평범하네요~ 일반인인가