First of all I don’t believe the international community on their idea. This is your home. Again what I find strange in his description or evidence that the area belongs to the Jews is that most of the biblical names as we are thought as Christians are totally different from what he narrated. I don’t know why those who translated the bible refused to call these names by their “Jewish names instead decided to name them in English”. Again I discovered that most of the incidents that he explained happened over 2000 years again happened very close and not far away from each other. That looks very strange to me. I am from the 12 tribe of Isreal and hopefully we will be discovered before the messiah comes. Keep up the good work and I hope to visit one day to see in person all these places. Again I believe when he said “that the Jews were colonised stage by stage for 2000 years and in all these years, these criminals have settled and try to wipe-out the history of the original people being the Jews. God be with you all.
What an awesome video. You and the Israeli gentleman did a great job explaining aspects of the Jewish historical experience. I would love to explore Beit-El now.
As a Muslim I strongly believe that there should be a Jewish homeland and country for them to avoid any future potential persecutions of the Jewish people therefore I support Israel
@@TheOman968Absolutely. And people liked you should be allowed to own land and govern but of course only in Antarctica. The most beneficent One commands it thus.
@@jaialaiwarrior what is the wrong in my comment Yes we do support to have a homeland to Israeli people but not in our land You do support to have a home for homeless people but of course not your house its the same
@@TheOman968 these "homeless" people number about ten million, have an advanced economy worth almost $500 billion and are at peace with most of the functional nearby countries. The land consists of several layers of history and archaeology all built on their own foundations as a people. They govern a pluralistic society in which rights are guaranteed to all citizens, including Bedouin, Druze, and other non-Jews who enlist to serve in the IDF to defend a country that they won't give up just so you can have Mahmoud Abbas, expatriated Doha billionaires from Hamas or an Iranian ayatollah running it. The problem with your comment is that it lives in the 7th century, as do the Islamic supremacist "values" that inform it. Work on improving your own society and government before daring to tell other people what to do and where to go. Those "homeless" people have made a good country out of a place that you want to do nothing but ruin out of envy.
This is an amazing video. I’m so happy that I got to see this presentation. I felt the love, the dream, and the hope for all those who love this land, call it. Israel, Canaan, Palestine. This explanation of Judaism really gave me hope. It really diffuses the current narrative to a humane State. When Israel can reconcile its view of not being a Jewish state we will all see how loving both people actually can be. In this sense Jews are the “chosen” to encapsulate what peace means. And glory to our creator, to ourselves we can all aspire to live with greater morality.
I really enjoyed this video; hearing this man speak is a true treat for me. I could listen to him for hours on end. Currently I'm on my path in Judaism in N.Y. as I wasn't raised a Jew. I'm working now to change my life around so I can once again be living within walking distance of a Shul. I truly wish I took advantage of living on the same street as a Shul, in fact the first Shul I had ever been too. I'm glad I got my studies up to date as my "old testament" was in the past and now I have a complete Jewish text, Torah, the prophets, and the writings which I think is called the Tanakh even though it's in English. I've also been exploring the Babylonian Talmud all I need is a Rabbi to study under for I have many questions. Any advice would be greatly appreciated from any NYC Jews. Shalom.
Find an orthodox beit din that is recognized in israel for Aliyah and start your conversion process. I’m a convert. It’s not easy, but so worthwhile. Best decision I ever made! Wishing you success
imagine if the native americans has that attitude. Imagine if they started a war with the americans, claiming that they've been there for 10,000 yrs and so it's there land. They don't do that because they understand that today's laws are to be respected and obeyed. Ppl living in that land push the world around by not obeying the laws of the land, claiming that there god gave them that land, so they don't have to obey the laws of the land. This is why the world is turning against those ppl who have migrated there with the beliefs that they can do take whatever land they please because their god gives them the right. Can you see how rediculous such twisted thinking is???
@@RJ456-w6fHoly text says the land belongs to ALMIGHTY GOD , He gave it to Abraham, Isaac , Jacob= Israel. Moses and Joshua. Was called the Promised Land . Enough evidence and proof. So where do you and Islam come from .😂 Not for human discussion. It's GOD'S PROPERTY ❤
@RJ456-w6f is that a fancy way of saying you are ignorant? The city Of Gina in Yehuda and Samaria (west bank) modern name Jenin.... original city name Gina (garden in hebrew). Established in 1400 BCE (nearly 2500 years ago by jews) Jews lived in Gina for 1800 years (longer than 99% of all countries on earth today). Byzantine colonize it, in the year 350, in the year 628 Arab from Arabia colonize it from the Byzantine and change the name to Jenin.. The town of Schem (hebrew word) modern day Nablus. Established 3000+ years ago by jews who lived there for 1000+ years. Roman/Byzantine colonize it in the year 70 and rename it Neapolis. 550 years later arabs from Arabia colonize the land from the Byzantine and rename the town Nablus... Bethlehem, Hebron, all the major cities in the Juda and Sameria (west bank) exact same history.... these towns have jewish cemetery dating 500, 1000, 2000, 3000 years ago.. do you think jews/Israelis invented time machine and went back in time burry jews in these town before the Arab caliphite (5th largest colonizing empire in HUMAN HISTORY - 11.5 million sq km colonized by force. Just FYI all of Europe is 10.5 million sq km) there are literally none biblical, non jewish records that jews lived here before the Arab colonization in the year 638. Egyptian records, Jordanian stone tablets from 1800 years ago. How ignorant are you to blanket statement "none sense" when you don't even know basic history.
trying to understand the life of the jews, the journey of finding meaning and nationhood despite the toughest adversity... i'm following this conflict everyday, and liked seeing the genuine heartfelt instances of hope and light in your life... great content man
This is a very good video explaining the Jewish history. I knew this all along and this is confirming it. The Jewish guide has shown the evidence of past such as the holy Mountain, Macabee cave to prove it. All of Israel was the land of Jews as natives until they were ruled by Greeks, Romans and then displaced into exile. The name West Bank is a misnomer only came in 1967. I support only one State of Israel not two state partition. Today Israel is strong and should take back all their ancient land area which includes Gaza, West Bank, Gollan Heights and Lebanon, Damascus. Shalom to you all. You are now on the right path of Jaweh as he wanted for Israelis.
Well, guess what? today it's internationally recognized as the west bank. Why keep living in the past? Scientists have determined that the semitic ppl, which are the arabs, can be traced back to the levant for 10,000 yrs. Europeans just started migrating there in the past century. This is the kind of thinking that is responsible for the Israeli's war on gaza and the west bank today. You don't see the native americans stirring up trouble for america because they go back 10,000 yrs, do you?
Wonderful content! You are so unbiased and open to all, yet you are also proud of your identity. The internet and world need more people like you. Kol hakavod l'cha!
Definitely agree though meditation and consciousness can we come closer to good and behave more meaningful and deeper and softer to ourselves and one another. Interesting how he used divorce as a great example as the relationship between two sides trying to come to reconciliation.
«Principled resistance to Even understanding The identity and narrative of The other. We Are not fighting eachother, But The fantasies of eachother» I believe this is really important to understand. As an outsider looking in I try to see both sides, Even though I do acknowledge that The imbalance in Power is a big influence for me.
So, he thinks Jews should be allowed to live in Judea and Samaria, you should've also asked him if he thinks Palestinians should be allowed to live in Israel proper. The west bank isn't sovereign Israeli territory either.
Palestinians are living in Israel.they're getting citizenship voting rights and benefits. Can you show one muslim country in middle East which provides citizenship and equal rights to their non Muslims counterparts?
@@syhuhjk Um yes. The Egyptians don't have any policies put in place to discriminate against other races or religions. Same goes with the UAE, you can be free to be anyone you want there and still be a citizen. These are just examples off the top of my head.
So called "Palestinians" of today are not native to the land, they are mostly Egyptian and Jordanian exiles forced to migraine there and lay false claims to the land as a form of warfare... Israel was a very desolate land before jews returned, and when they returned they turned deserts into farms and cities; bought not stole land from a few Arab ppl who moved in after jews were forced out... All that land belongs to the Jewish ppl; only reason why there are "contested" areas is because Isreal made agreements with these foreigners that if they stop attacking and killing jews then they can settle but these ppl broke that agreement and continue to break it to this day thus Israel has every right to reclaim All of its land and send these foreigners back to their homelands outside of Israel... "palistinians" are called refugees by the west and in part that is true and the only way to solve it is to send every "Palestinian" who doesn't want to live peacefully with jews back to where they came from... In past Israel has reclaimed its land but foolishly again in attempts at peace allowed these violent foreigners to stay; would've been better if Israel just kept its own lands from the start and vetted ppl its willing to allow to stay... J and S is 100% Jewish lands and jews have legal rights to settle there where "palistinians" do not but they still illegal do so; Israel should expel them per the violation of the law but Israel is allowing some of it per the west keeps telling Israel what to do with its own land so to not spark an all out war... Just study actual history for yourself and you'll find these foreigners admit they are taking Jewish lands and that jews didn't steal it, also that mass imitation is their war tactic... If you go on vacation and squatters move in while you are away, when you return is ot your house or is it theirs? To solve the dilemma should you split your house in two giving them half? Or is it still your hose and the illegal invaders should be thrown out? Obviously the latter, this is story of Israel in a nut shell
@@jaybelle1909 🤣🤣🤣 So much BS in your comment. First of all, so you think when Arabs came, they replaced the whole population that was already in the Levant? This isn't true at all. If this was so, Muslims would have become the majority in all the places they conquered rather quickly, instead they would be minorities for many centuries in their conquered lands. Which indicates relgious tolerance and gradual increase of Muslims (conversions). I personally know Palestinians who descend from Jewish families, and these people have the strongest roots in the land as they have been directly inhabiting it for thousands of years, unlike modern day Jewish settlers. More BS claims that Palestine was a desolate land. Ironic that you are telling me to read history... why don't you read the book "A Question That Outweighs All Others: Yitzhak Epstein and Zionist Recognition of the Arab issue" This is by one of the first Jewish settlers who made Aliyah to Palestine in 1880. He describes the land NOT empty and with NATIVE people living on it. Ofc Israeli and Israeli sympathizers whitewash history.
Yehuda is amazing. He is creating a new paradigm that unites the Hebrew and Arab peoples, but I hope his vision is doable and not unwittingly a trojan horse. I say this because it is not just about Jews and Palestinians. It is about Islam and the conditioning of Muslims. Are they actually capable of changing their attitudes? I know some are, but how about the vast majority? Will we fool ourselves that things have changed and then find that our Muslim partners have become our oppressors? It's happened everywhere Islam has managed to embed itself. I counsel extreme caution.
those settlers are soooo not hebrew. They're americans and europeans. Do you really think they're hebrew? Hebrews were dark skinned, more like the palestinians are in gaza today.
Having said.... this portion of your vlogs really catched my interests and somehow able to understand the tribes of Israel particularly Juda and Yousef... this is the kind of topics that separates you from other expats vloggers from Philippines. Mabuhay and Salamat.🙏🏼
He explained in interviews that he changed his name to HaCohen, and his hebrew name is most probably Yehuda, as we mostly all have English and separate Hebrew names.
@@shainazion4073 I didn't think just anyone could take the cohen name. Can he do the priestly blessing or does he not count as a Cohen as far all the extra rules are concerned?
@@TikvaJane He told you -- he is a cohen. He is entitled to the name HaCohen. Jews have both an "outside" name and a Hebrew name, unless they are assimilated.
Fascinating video ty. Interesting how he calls Tel Aviv basically an outpost of the West...so I take it to mean his community's identity is more complex. He says they're not "super religious" but to this Westerner it looks that way. Finally, really interesting to learn he's not in favor of the so called "Two State Solution" and his version includes both peoples. Complicated and demographicislly speaking, don't the Palestinians aspire to "return" to this area as well? Wouldn't it be great if this man's vision could prevail over all the extremists' agendas? Great job on this interview 👍
Actually, I prefer to call it what it is, Eastern Judea as it actually was during the second temple period. After all, to call it a bank is not reality, it is neither a financial institution, nor the sandy slope of a river. The Jewish history of the land does come alive when one travels to these areas, denying reality will not address the real issues. The issues are not mistaken perceptions, but the real missile attacks from Gaza and the attacks against Israelis whether the weapons are rocks, explosives, knifes, guns, automatic weapons, etc. While the state of Israel is really just defending itself. This is the reality that somehow was lost in all of the philosophy. But yes, it is the ancient homeland of the Jewish people and of cause the evidence is overwhelming and much more than what this video covers.
It seems like people think this place was heavily populated before the establishment of Israel and Palestine. It really wasn’t it was very barren with small settlement. This land has switched hands many times but ultimately all of Earth belongs to G-d. He determines who lives where OUR part is what we do while we are here on earth. Do we promote peace ? Overcome our negative aspects into positive ones ? Hopefully as a collective we will shed the layers of hate and wear robes of love and holy spirit
It must be nice, that in the middle of working day, grown men do not need to work and can afford to spend time on prayer. Or better yet, some never work and just pray. Yet enjoy fairly high living standard. Where the money and resources come from? Who finances and supports it long term?
So they want us to believe the lady with the perfect American accent making cream cheese sandwiches is the indigenous person on the land and was colonized by the Palestinians? Okie.
So people who lived in a land for more than 1500yrs maintained their distinct customs and identity after being forced to leave have no right to say they are indigenously connected?
@@kableguy-ur3peif you are going to displace and govern people who were already there, you would have to prove the lady making cream cheese sandwiches (authentic middle eastern dish?) has direct ancestry in the land. Perhaps a family tree.
@@19Pulsar there are many Jews with family trees that go back as you suggest. We don't seek to displace or govern our arab cousins and with many groups like the Druzim, Samaritans, Christian Arabs there is very little friction.
Good video. I almost didn't watch it because I was offended by the clickbait title of "Jewish Extremists - Israeli Settlers on Palestine". I wouldn't call that guy an extremists he has good relations with the Palestinians as do manyJews living in Judea & Samaria - especially area C under Israeli control. People tend to forget it's Arabs who build the roads & houses here. They work in Jewish communities whether it's on farms, in factories , in stores or as bus drivers, garbage collectors. They benefit from Jews living here whether it's creating jobs or keeping the area safe. There is peaceful coexistence & it needs to be expanded. Handing the roughly 60,000 Palestinians over in area C to be ruled by terrorists will not do them any favors.
In Israel, there are 60% of the doctors, nurses, pharmacists, dentists and other professionals that are Palestinian Arabs. They are not all bus drivers and garbage collectors, making it sound like they are the working class, while Jews are an elite class.There are Palestinian lawyers, judges, army generals and other such positions also.
Isaiah 61:1-11 [1]The Spirit of the Lord God is upon me, Because the Lord has anointed me To bring good news to the afflicted; He has sent me to bind up the brokenhearted, To proclaim liberty to captives And freedom to prisoners; [2]To proclaim the favorable year of the Lord And the day of vengeance of our God; To comfort all who mourn, [3]To grant those who mourn in Zion, Giving them a garland instead of ashes, The oil of gladness instead of mourning, The mantle of praise instead of a spirit of fainting. So they will be called oaks of righteousness, The planting of the Lord, that He may be glorified. [4]Then they will rebuild the ancient ruins, They will raise up the former devastations; And they will repair the ruined cities, The desolations of many generations. [5]Strangers will stand and pasture your flocks, And foreigners will be your farmers and your vinedressers. [6]But you will be called the priests of the Lord; You will be spoken of as ministers of our God. You will eat the wealth of nations, And in their riches you will boast. [7]Instead of your shame you will have a double portion, And instead of humiliation they will shout for joy over their portion. Therefore they will possess a double portion in their land, Everlasting joy will be theirs. [8]For I, the Lord, love justice, I hate robbery in the burnt offering; And I will faithfully give them their recompense And make an everlasting covenant with them. [9]Then their offspring will be known among the nations, And their descendants in the midst of the peoples. All who see them will recognize them Because they are the offspring whom the Lord has blessed. [10]I will rejoice greatly in the Lord, My soul will exult in my God; For He has clothed me with garments of salvation, He has wrapped me with a robe of righteousness, As a bridegroom decks himself with a garland, And as a bride adorns herself with her jewels. [11]For as the earth brings forth its sprouts, And as a garden causes the things sown in it to spring up, So the Lord God will cause righteousness and praise To spring up before all the nations.
This is what Palestinians and Israeli jews need to come together and understand each other. Their will be less violence killings terror etc. I deep down believe you two nation of people can live together cmon guys make peace paleeeeeeez not nice seeing hatred can't we love one another for being unique in our own ways and diverse. Anyway wish peace upon everyone and pray you can understand one another
Thanks for showing and explaining all of Israel . It is very interesting. Being a Christian it is all I read in the Bible. I love all your videos. Thank you so much. I would like to see more.
@@TheTravelingClatt I get it, though - this "religious" thing is hard to take unto yourself. because your actions aren't, at their heart, religious. Religion is a Western construct, as Yehuda HaCohen alludes to in this video. What you are doing when you daven shacharis in the glorious Judean morning is not religion. It's tradition. So, yes, you are right to laugh nervously when someone refers to your actions as "religious".
@@gcolwill But isn't tradition culture? The manner in which a group of people do things in a certain way that is different from other groups of people? Being religious simply mean the repetition of rituals unique to a group of people handed down from the past? Tradition?
@@uriahthehittite2309 you can follow tradition without even believing in God. My family are doing a kiddush every Friday night, with yarmulkes and everything.. non of us are believers. Traditions can also be Octoberfest in Germany, or painting eggs in Easter. This guy definitely believes in God, but saying he's not very religious means he doesn't observe all the traditions of a religious Jew.. just some of them.
@@Abilliph Yeah, the cultural Jew. I don't see the relevance of festivals for the sake of "tradition" because belief in our Gd and our way of life are supposed to be inseparable. The ritual is not really the point.
The tragedy of the people of Palestine is that their country was “given” by a foreign power to another people for the creation of a new state. The result was that many hundreds of thousands of innocent people were made permanently homeless. With every new conflict their numbers increased. How much longer is the world willing to endure this spectacle of wanton cruelty?
There was NO country, the land was all Ottoman land, the people were all Ottoman subjects. The Ottomans had NOTHING called Palestine for 400 years. The Ottomans divided the land into 3 to 5 Sanjaks (provinces), none called Palestine. The Mamluks before the Ottomans, had NOTHING called Palestine. The Crusaders before the Mamluks, had NOTHING called Palestine. That is over 1000 years with NOTHING called Palestine. The Christian West called the Holy Land as Palestine, the people there did not.
The British illegally gave 77% of the Mandate of Palestine lands to the Arabs to become transJordan, leaving only 23% to become the future Jewish state.
Whether the Jews lived there during the times of the maccabees is immaterial, if they had taken the land from the Romans there would be no problem, the problem is that in 2000 intervening years other people made their home there and your claim doesn’t supersede theirs.
The Jews have turned away from God=Lord Jesus Christ before and have been scattered as a nation due to it. It has happened before during the captivity in Babylon like with the Romans afterwards. But one thing for sure God=Lord Jesus Christ always kept His promise to Abraham that he and his descendants the Jews will have the land of Israel and will keep His covenant for all time with Abraham , his son Issac and his grandson Jacob called Israel. Israel is all of Canaan, all of the Sinai peninsula, part of Egypt where the Nile is at, all of Jordan, all of Lebanon, part of Syria where Damascus is at, part of Iraq where Eden was and where the tree of eternal tree will be present and if God=Lord Jesus Christ allows us to eat from its fruit on judgement day the next prophesy of the last remaining two prophesies as stated in Revelation in the Holy Bible, and part of Northern Saudi Arabia. All of that is the Holy land of Israel. God=Lord Jesus Christ will rule Israel and all of the other nations on earth like He does in Heaven and His kingdom will never end. No one can change His will. God=Lord Jesus Christ doesn't want it to be Palestine. He wants it to be Israel and Israel is His like the whole earth as is heaven. Everything and everyone is His. We all will see to God=Lord Jesus Christ on judgement day. It is written.
They did not take anything from any people or land of Palestine. The land was former Ottoman land, the people were Ottoman subjects. The League of Nations created Mandates out of the Ottoman lands to create new countries. There were 3 Mandates created, the Mandate of Mesopotamia (Iraq), the Mandate of Syria and Lebanon, and the Mandate of Palestine. The Mandate of Palestine had one mission only, to reconstitute the Jewish homeland in the Area of Palestine. The British were made Administrators over the Mandate. They illegally gave 77% of the land to the Hashemites to become trans-Jordan. The 23% left was to become the Jewish state. In 1937, the British (against the Mandate Charter) offered the Arabs 80% of the land. The Arabs turned it down because the Jews were offered the other 20%. The Jews appealed to the Arabs to stay in their houses and help them create a country together, they were answered by 5 Arab armies that attacked the one day old country Israel. There were only 350,000 people in the land in 1860, and 30,000 were Jews. The rest were fellahins (tenant farmers) and bedouins. There were no Palestinians. Most of the people calling themselves as Palestinians came into the land in the 1900s as laborers. They were not living here for generations.
Shaina Zion .... the Jews are the original people of the Holy Land. All earth is owned by G-D but the Land of Israel is particular to the Jews. Despite exile, thousands of years of being out of the Land, they have returned. The true people of the Land are Jews.
Israel belongs to God=Lord Jesus Christ as all of the nations on earth. As does heaven. Everyone and everything belongs to God=Lord Jesus Christ. He is true original man. He is the Good Shepherd. We all will know who is His sheep on judgement day, the next prophesy of the last remaining two prophesies as mentioned in Revelation in the Holy Bible, His book.
Thank you so much, this man was fantastic. The way he explained the land and the nation, the Tribe of people, hopefully those who are outside will gain a better perspective.
I think there is no case of oppressed people that were attacked but never fought back and ditched their land for 3000 years, came back after 3000 years to make homeless the inhabitants. Even the nation that expelled you, are dead. Yes Isreal as nation are unique in that respects... It took 3000yrs to pluck up the courage to return and fight a ghost????.
@@rinan4058 Yes, they supported the muslims and were not zionist. The majority fleed. Similarly when joshua (AS) wanted to obey the orders of Musa AS to fight the rest disobeyed and were banished for 40yrs. Also zionist do not consider them jews are still loyal to muslims and loyal to the Torah. Moshaich in torah is meant to save them not the zionists. The average muslim is more devote then an average jew. Also remember that muslims took jerusalem and lifted the ban by christians of jewish return. Umer RA great disciple of Prophet (saw) lifted the ban. He was the most friendly with jews of medina out of companions (disciples). And cleaned the trashed whailing wall and temple mount with his own hands. The reason why jews can now pray at the wall is because of muslims and their help and support. But instead of taking mercy on them when they are in power, they are merciless. Muslims took mercy and the Isrealis did not. I know their are anti zionist jews out there loyal to their torah, may be small batch but descent. My teacher was one Dr Lichman,poor guys son died of cancer. Soo personally I do not hate jewish people or their book but zionism I am against because prequisite of zionism is focusing on expelling muslims rather then the return of jews. Zionists helped Ataturk of now turkey, do uprising inside the ottoman empire under the Banner of Youngs Turk who infiltrated the Caliphs and also targeted arabs. So arabs got upset and did uprising sk there is modern day Saudia Arabia, the palestinians who were loyal to ottomans now suffer.
I think there are a few flaws in your statement if you don't mind me being blunt Number one is you assume that the Palestinians were there before the Jewish settlers that is incorrect for hundreds of years already there have been Jews in the holy Land Number two is during the establishment of the state of Israel the Arabs chose to attack us not the other way around and when they lost the war they started running it was the Jews who invited them back but now they wanted everything on their terms so it's not as simple as you're putting it nor is it a true depiction of what took place so please don't take a complex situation which is veiled in propaganda and misinformation and force it into a narrow narrative It's simply not intellectually honest
I'm watching this after October 7th 2023, and now it seems there is more reason than ever to understand the "Settlers" POV. Why shouldn't Jews live among the Palestinian Arabs? In Israel we have a nearly 20% Arab population, so exclusivity is not a viable argument.
I personally think, regardless if Jewish or not, that the existence of some ruins of ancient times is no proof of ownership. Just imagine the Italiens would run around in the world and claim that every place with a roman monument belongs to Italy? Worse even, imagine some Pakistani Family converts to Catholicism and claims Alexandria in Egypt belongs to them because it has Roman monuments. The logic just doesn't make sense. Regardless of that, I believe that if the Palestinians could forgive and the Israelis could repent about this whole occupation, then some peace can take place.
It’s an inaccurate comparison. Jews are indigenous to that land. And Judaism is not a religion, it’s a civilization and people, closer to an ethno religion but more than that. And they were born on that land. They never colonized.
The Israelite people developed as a nation. In that land. The Italians are not the Romans, and even if they were should Rome 've tsken from them? Should Vatican City be taken from Christians? Should Japan be taken from the Japanese? Or Alaska he taken fron the Inuit? Or Australia or New Zealand from the Maori, this is where the people developed.
Italians would not say that because for the most part they don't care about having colonies anymore and can barely control themselves. Their monuments are relics in various parts of the world because they invaded those parts of the world and colonized them. The "Palestinians" did not even exist until the 1960s. None of them called themselves that and it was NEVER a country called Palestine. It was a region under the control of people that were in what is now Turkey. They called it the Ottomans. They controlled all of that territory. The only reason "Palestine" has ever been a term in use is because of the Romans, who took over and named it after the Philistines, who were their distant Mediterranean cousins that had settled in Gaza. Where are the Philistines now? COMPLETELY WIPED OUT. They vanished over the course of time. The ARAB people there now, are a salad of people from all corners of the region and the majority of them had ancestors who had flocked there in the years just preceding the 20th century due to economic activity that was beginning to stir up because of returning JEWS that returned to the land and joined Jews that had already been there, in spite of the izlomic taxes and the degradation to have foreigners in your own land. There is no nation of Palestine. It suddenly became important to have this identity, when "Palestinian" had been the name for Jews for decades while the British controlled the area. The "Palestinians" are an INVENTED PEOPLE. Israel - and when I say that I mean the entire area, including the places occupied by violent Arabs - is a Jewish land. The invented people are just there.
That's not a valid analogy. You can't compare Jews in Israel with Romans in parts of Africa or the Middle East that they colonized. We're indigenous to the land of Israel. It's where we emerged as a tribe. Romans, on the other hand, emerged in Italy. Not in North Africa, the Middle East or even in Central and Western Europe. Get it? We're not claiming ownership over a land we could have colonized in the past through military conquest. We're claiming ownership only over the land we're indigenous to.
The rest of your argument is even more absurd. Most Jews (Ashkenazim, Sefaradim and Mizrahim) today descend from the ancient Jews that lived in Israel 3,000 years despite having some admixture with other people (mostly female converts). We're a tribe with our own ancient language, values, literature, music and ancient bloodlines that can be traced back to the ancient Jews of this land 3,000 years - not a community of people of different ethnic origins that just happen to share ancient theological beliefs and rituals that are rooted in Israel. This is well known to most experts in Jewish History and it has also been proven through most the majority of genetic studies conducted on the main Jewish communities of today (Ashekanazim, Sefaradim and Mizrahim). Again, your analogy with Persian or Afghan converts to Catholicism has no validity whatsoever.
What a peaceful settler. Totally not the colonialism type of settlers! He has to endure Palestinian checkpoints (only for Israeli citizens), discrimination (streets that only Palestinians are allowed to use), and hatred. Here is an example of the discrimination against Israeli citizens in Hebron: ruclips.net/video/aEdGcej-6D0/видео.html&ab_channel=AJ%2B
All Bullshit propaganda!! In Hebron the Palestinian Authority rules over 80% of the village. The Jews have one street only they are allowed to live in. The Jews were massacred by the "Palestinian" Arabs in 1929. All those Jews that survived were transported out by the British. There was more killing of Jews in the 1980s in Hebron. Unless you know the complete story, I suggest you remain quiet!
That would be the jews ppl as they are the true Palestinians and called themselves such; when Israel became a state again jews dropped the palistinian name at which point Egyptian and Jordanian invaders adopted the term and made up false claims to the lands...
There's even a location where the West Bank (as the international diplomatic community recognizes it) and "Israel proper" (the country of Israel, as Israel recognizes itself under Israeli law) overlap - East Jerusalem and the Old City. Someone could argue with justification that the Old City is in both Israel and the West Bank.
@seeyouseemee3863 yes.. even if they are European Jews. They still keeps their traditions, language, and heritage, and pass it down to their children.. that's the definition of ethnicity.
Yes, Jews have the DNA proof as well as an unbroken chain of ancestry, practice and tradition for over 3000 years. We don't follow a drunk preacher who one night outside a bar in the American south had a vision that the African Americans were the true Israelites of the bible, with absolutely Not one piece of evidence to back it up.
"Jewish settler in Palestine", what a biased choice of words. Wonder why did you stop chronologically in Palestine and did not use the name it had before, Israel.
I have noticed that Judea and Samaria, the rightful and biblical name for that are in Israel, has been changed to the West Bank. Is it not the same story of Israel, that in the eyes of many, changing the name Palestine, when wanting to give the impression that the Jewish people have ‘stolen’ the Land, God has given to them as inheritance? I’m surprised the question, where did the name Palestine originated from, has not come up, in this documentary. Ask a Palestinian, what is the meaning of the word, Palestinian, and I assure you the answer will be, I don’t know… The Palestine/Palestina, was first given to Judea and Samaria (and not to all of the land), by Hadrian the Roman ruler in that areas of Israel, at the time of the Roman Empire. He gave the name Palestina, out of hate for the Jewish people; he chose the name of the worst enemy of Israel in biblical times, the Philistines. This word, philistines, is not a name of the people, but a name describing what they did. They were from the Greek islands and spoke Greek, not Arabic. The name given to the philistines, is a Hebrew word, meaning, invaders, because they have invaded places not belong to them. So, in away, the Arabs who call themselves Palestinians, and rightly so, by their own admission, are saying, that they are invaders. So when looking into the truth, lives are saved and people are set free…so many lives of loved ones, over a long period of time, have been sacrificed for absolute lies. So sad…
@mad catter Palestinians are a blend of ethnicities, including Arab, Jewish, etc. They're culturally Arab, but nonetheless have been living there for generations.
@mad catter Arabs have been living in the area since they first occupied it during the Rashidun Caliphate's invasion of it. There was an influx of more Arabs from Jordan and other places, but there were always Arabs living there for centuries. They did, in fact, make up the majority of the population until their mass expulsion by the Zionists in 1948. It doesn't matter if Jews have roots that stretch back further; you don't get to claim a piece of real estate forever, especially after having been removed from it for millennia. Having said that, I don't have a problem with Jews returning there to live. The issue is returning, then claiming exclusive ownership of the land, while ejecting its non-Jewish inhabitants to create a Jewish-majority apartheid state that has come to violate every international law there is. There is no excuse for that, save for racism, which many Israelis seem to have adopted as their default outlook on the Palestinian issue.
@madcatter6751 Why does it matter what the reasons for when and why Palestinian identity came into existence are? All cultural identities start somewhere, for a variety of reasons, and then become their own distinct group as their history unfolds. It doesn't matter whether Palestine has been around for a 1000 years old or just a year; it exists as a collective identity of a disenfranchised people who share a common struggle against an oppressor. Claims to land over seniority are moot, at best.
@madcatter6751 1. The difference between the two expulsions is that one occurred millennia ago and the other is recent, with those who witnessed the expulsion still alive. What gives someone the right to return after centuries of absenteeism and violently take it from people who already established themselves there? As I said, there is no eternal claim to real estate. If the Jews insisted on returning that badly, they should've insisted on making greater efforts to live side by side with the Arabs instead of saying "it's all ours". 2. You're arguing another moot point regarding ownership and occupation. What is the difference between the two when it comes to settling claims between different groups who have lived there at some point or another? What are the qualifications for rightful ownership of land? 3. I've heard that bogus argument so many times. You think some token Arab minorities in certain occupations in Israeli society detract from the racism they experience overall? They may be equal on paper, but not in reality: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Arabism#Anti-Arabism_in_Israel 4. What kind of point are you making here? People should be allowed to live anywhere they want. No one should be expelled from any place.
@@madcatter1 So many lies in your post. Israel brought all the refugees back?! Is that why there's so many refugee camps in the area? And is that why there's no named Arab village in what is now Israel? Because said country wiped all of them off the map? You extremist fanatics are unbelievable.
@@madcatter1 that's daft. By your understanding Maoris have no claim to New Zealand and Koris have no claim to Australia because they didn't have an 'official' nation.
@@madcatter1 your whole comment is a lie 😒. You can use Google and try to find a map that says Israel before 1930s. There's none maps from 1800s clearly states the place as Philistine. You need to use your common sense instead of your feelings 😒. There's still video evidence of the Jewish migration with the British to the middle east stop lying to yourself child. If these people came from the middle east they would have brown skin like the Palestinians not blonde with blue eyes like European's. You are claiming a history that is not yours. The whole idea behind the creation of Israel is online for everyone to see these people have been chased out of other nations for a reason. Israelis are thieves at this point they was offered a place to stay and now they want to take it all. And the current people living in Israel says there grandparents are Europeans. You are just choosing to believe whatever comforts your feelings not the truth.
@@madcatter1 do you realize the area we are talking about was referred to as North Africa not the middle east the term middle east is modern. There's more African Jews than the population of Israel. Israel itself is full of Africans you won't see them in the media though because they want to hide this but how long can you hide the obvious.
@@sandall100 So called "Palestinians" of today are not native to the land, they are mostly Egyptian and Jordanian exiles forced to migraine there and lay false claims to the land as a form of warfare... Israel was a very desolate land before jews returned, and when they returned they turned deserts into farms and cities; bought not stole land from a few Arab ppl who moved in after jews were forced out... All that land belongs to the Jewish ppl; only reason why there are "contested" areas is because Isreal made agreements with these foreigners that if they stop attacking and killing jews then they can settle but these ppl broke that agreement and continue to break it to this day thus Israel has every right to reclaim All of its land and send these foreigners back to their homelands outside of Israel... "palistinians" are called refugees by the west and in part that is true and the only way to solve it is to send every "Palestinian" who doesn't want to live peacefully with jews back to where they came from... In past Israel has reclaimed its land but foolishly again in attempts at peace allowed these violent foreigners to stay; would've been better if Israel just kept its own lands from the start and vetted ppl its willing to allow to stay... The vast majority of conflicts and violence in the region is caused by these foreigners not Israel and this too is blatantly obvious to anyone who actually studies whats really going on... J and S is 100% Jewish lands and jews have legal rights to settle there where "palistinians" do not but they still illegal do so; Israel should expel them per the violation of the law but Israel is allowing some of it per the west keeps telling Israel what to do with its own land so to not spark an all out war... Just study actual history for yourself and you'll find these foreigners admit they are taking Jewish lands and that jews didn't steal it, also that mass imitation is their war tactic... If you go on vacation and squatters move in while you are away, when you return is ot your house or is it theirs? To solve the dilemma should you split your house in two giving them half? Or is it still your hose and the illegal invaders should be thrown out? Obviously the latter, this is story of Israel in a nut shell
@@jaybelle1909 “Palestinian history doesn’t begin with Arab conquest. Jericho is 10,000 years old, Arab conquest is 1400 years old, no negating 9000 years of history and more.” - Mahmoud Darwish “Archaeology alone reveals nothing about the origins of “Ancient Israel” but provides information on settlement patterns & cultural traits of the population of PALESTINE during the period in which “Israel” appeared in Palestinian history.” - Keith W Whitelam “The invention of ancient Israel - the silencing of Palestinian history" By your logic Palestinians deserve the same right to return to their homes now in the hands of immigrants from America, Europe and Russia. By your logic, The only way to solve the conflict and gain peace is to send every foreigner who is a threat to Palestine and it's population back to where they came from. Foreign settlers do not have ANY right to steal land and homes in territory designated as Palestine. The name illegal settlements should give you a clue. The land given to Zionists in Palestine was given under defined conditions To uphold its founding promise, Israel must treat its Arab citizens as truly equal I suggest you study history and read some books on this topic. Your view is totally flawed. Here is a starter www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/threshold-crossed/israeli-authorities-and-crimes-apartheid-and-persecution
@@sandall100 because it is, it’s the Jewish homeland. Has been forever. Land of milk and honey. Arabs are welcome as long as they’re peaceful and identify as Israeli. There is not Palestinian state, no infrastructure, no government, hospitals, or work. Everyone travels from (West Bank) to the cities (all industrialized, Israeli)to work because the Arabs in the area cannot stabilize their own economy. They don’t even have an airport you can fly to if you wanted to, you’d have to travel through the Israeli state. There is no Palestine only the Roman semantics of what was Judea & Samaria. There is only one land and 2 people Jews and Arabs, but only one state, Israel. This is why settlement like this is completely fine and in fact advocated for. To return to the only homeland they have.
The thing is, this history is shared with the Palestinians, if you look at their DNA they have been there since the Natufian culture, 15 000 years ago. Loads have last names dirived from both Samaritan and Jewish names. They are part of the population that never left the holy land. Its literally siezing the land of your own family and keeping them under military law. Israel cant keep it up much longer.
That is so stupid. How come today that nilitic or African features are south of the Sahara and Israel, Egypt, Morocco, Jordan, Syria are all north of the Sahara and most of the people don't have those features? Was it so different then?
This is not an Israelite speaking. This is the Sulamite Slave girl who says that the daughters of Jerusalem ( Istaelite women) looked down on her because she was dark. If they were dark. They would not look down on other women for them being dark. And she became dark from the Sun, that means she was light actually.
Song of Solomon 1:5 is not an Israelite speaking, it is the Sulamite slave girl. She explains that the Sun made her dark, she wasn't born that way. She also says the daughters of Jerusalem looked down on her because she appeared dark. As the Israelites were not dark.
Sad part is that these people believe their own hype! Tribe of Judah!? Get serious. Who apart from you guys believe this sort of thing. Just say you're a sttler colonialist from America and be done with it. At least people won't accuse you of dishonesty.
@@rachelsamuel3328 Israelite history? You think the old testament is a historical document? No one knows any of the authors and it's a translation from Greek for God's sake! It's fiction! Besides, you really believe God is doing real estate? And what's so special about this tribe to the exclusion of all others!?
These people are so full of shit. They steal and justify it. It's absolutely sick. I care for neither side, but they can't help pissing on your leg and telling you it's raining.
@@mslayous1 Most of the history in the Torah has been confirmed by other sources. They have found cities mentioned in the Torah, they have found Bullae of the kings and prophets. They have found many proofs of the history in the Torah.
Why is there so much land left uncultivated and unoccupied in Israel? Is this a deliberate policy by the government? I visited Israel in January 2019, it was a very unforgettable experience....l love the country., the topography, the historical and biblical sites and the food too .❤❤🎉. Pity about the ongoing war. I pray for peace and prosperity to return to the land.
All of the region belong to Arabs. Isreal was created by UN. Jewish refugees of Europe have no rights to Palestine. There ancient homeland is Khazaria - which is eastern Ukraine and southern Russia. If a jewish refugee from Europe have right to Isreal ...then Arab and African refugees have right to turn Europe into their own nation and claim it.
Your best vlog to date: informative, thought-provoking & transformative to many of us who wish to see beyond the stalled peace process. There is now an alternative to the moribund two-state solution, one that I'm going to give much thought to in the coming weeks and months.
@@denigorelov9909 I mean, Geographically speaking, as in on a Map, Israel, the Indigenous homeland of the Israelis is literally located in West Asia. So, Jews are West asian by definition. The reason this sounds weird to you is because you have a narrow western conception of Asians which probably only include Chinese, Japanese, etc, which is really not the reality on the ground.
kindly reminder, there is no such thing as palestiniens. they are all ishmaeli arabs who came here as refuges from all the arab countries around us for all these years. palestine was the name the british gave to this land and it comes from the word "Plishtim" that is mentioned in the bible (the story of Shimshon). those "plishtim" were NOT arabs. so there's no connection between them and the arabs claimed to be palestiniens. how can they say we took the land from them when they never ruled here? they just lived here. well, news flash: there were jewish living here the whole time too. even after the roman exile, there were still jewish left here. there was never a time when israel was empty of jewish. we just didnt rule here for years. israel was a desert. if the arabs were here living good as they claim, why didnt they build anything? why was it all desert? nothing of a function society! it was only after the jews came here in and built this country from zero, cleaned the area from Malaria, farming, building... only then, suddenly, arabs has the audacity to claim this as their own. but even after knowing this fact, we jews were ready to live with them and let them enjoy our beautiful country and system, and some of them, mostly israeli arabs, live great, they are doctors and lawyers and they get to live freely in a democratic country. but the rest of them dont want to co-exist with us. they want us dead. they dont accept living under a jewish nation so how can we do peace with them? the problem is their religion. they believe jews should not exist anywhere. even if we gave them israel as a present they'd still hate us. thats the sad truth people around the world dont know. they think we are the bad ones who dont want to live with them when the truth is they are the ones who hate us for being jews. its not a political war, its a religious war and thats why it can never end. this conflict is claimed to be complicated when its really not. there's a simple answer which is - its the land of god. he gave it to us, he took it from us and gave it back to us. we were here first. end of story. and if u dont believe in the bible theres another answer: there was a war, we won. end of story. stop complaining. i dont see anyone shaming other countries who fought a war and won their territory. thats how the world works. want it "back"? fight us. we dare u. thats it.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Click here to watch our whole playlist. 🇮🇱 🇵🇸
ruclips.net/p/PLzHRSHS9p7Sumsv1YTdfT42y_FBJTXEWm
These people stole our land we we built alot of the cities 5 to 10 thousand years ago
The bit eil settlement was built 1977 stealing my family's land and towns land
@@anasshuaib5436 There was nothing there beforehand, just empty barren land.
First of all I don’t believe the international community on their idea. This is your home.
Again what I find strange in his description or evidence that the area belongs to the Jews is that most of the biblical names as we are thought as Christians are totally different from what he narrated.
I don’t know why those who translated the bible refused to call these names by their “Jewish names instead decided to name them in English”.
Again I discovered that most of the incidents that he explained happened over 2000 years again happened very close and not far away from each other. That looks very strange to me.
I am from the 12 tribe of Isreal and hopefully we will be discovered before the messiah comes.
Keep up the good work and I hope to visit one day to see in person all these places.
Again I believe when he said “that the Jews were colonised stage by stage for 2000 years and in all these years, these criminals have settled and try to wipe-out the history of the original people being the Jews.
God be with you all.
@@anasshuaib5436 if your Arab, your land is in Arabia. Go make a Hajj to Mecca and stay there forever
What an awesome video. You and the Israeli gentleman did a great job explaining aspects of the Jewish historical experience. I would love to explore Beit-El now.
As a Muslim I strongly believe that there should be a Jewish homeland and country for them to avoid any future potential persecutions of the Jewish people therefore I support Israel
Hey, appreciate your comment. Do you still support Israel?
We all support a home land for jew but not in Palestine, USA or Germany should give them the land but not our land
@@TheOman968Absolutely. And people liked you should be allowed to own land and govern but of course only in Antarctica. The most beneficent One commands it thus.
@@jaialaiwarrior what is the wrong in my comment
Yes we do support to have a homeland to Israeli people but not in our land
You do support to have a home for homeless people but of course not your house its the same
@@TheOman968 these "homeless" people number about ten million, have an advanced economy worth almost $500 billion and are at peace with most of the functional nearby countries. The land consists of several layers of history and archaeology all built on their own foundations as a people. They govern a pluralistic society in which rights are guaranteed to all citizens, including Bedouin, Druze, and other non-Jews who enlist to serve in the IDF to defend a country that they won't give up just so you can have Mahmoud Abbas, expatriated Doha billionaires from Hamas or an Iranian ayatollah running it.
The problem with your comment is that it lives in the 7th century, as do the Islamic supremacist "values" that inform it.
Work on improving your own society and government before daring to tell other people what to do and where to go. Those "homeless" people have made a good country out of a place that you want to do nothing but ruin out of envy.
So much information. Thank you to the guide and yourself of course
This is an amazing video. I’m so happy that I got to see this presentation. I felt the love, the dream, and the hope for all those who love this land, call it. Israel, Canaan, Palestine. This explanation of Judaism really gave me hope. It really diffuses the current narrative to a humane State. When Israel can reconcile its view of not being a Jewish state we will all see how loving both people actually can be. In this sense Jews are the “chosen” to encapsulate what peace means. And glory to our creator, to ourselves we can all aspire to live with greater morality.
I really enjoyed this video; hearing this man speak is a true treat for me. I could listen to him for hours on end. Currently I'm on my path in Judaism in N.Y. as I wasn't raised a Jew. I'm working now to change my life around so I can once again be living within walking distance of a Shul. I truly wish I took advantage of living on the same street as a Shul, in fact the first Shul I had ever been too. I'm glad I got my studies up to date as my "old testament" was in the past and now I have a complete Jewish text, Torah, the prophets, and the writings which I think is called the Tanakh even though it's in English. I've also been exploring the Babylonian Talmud all I need is a Rabbi to study under for I have many questions. Any advice would be greatly appreciated from any NYC Jews. Shalom.
שלום אחי
Hey man I'm a NYC Jew from Brooklyn. Feel free to reach out. Would def love to be a resource.
Ask him about Babylonian Talmud b12❓ is it ok to molest small children..are black people Hamites❓are Jews superior to all non Jews❓
@@yosefgreen3130 Ha
Find an orthodox beit din that is recognized in israel for Aliyah and start your conversion process. I’m a convert. It’s not easy, but so worthwhile. Best decision I ever made! Wishing you success
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
Wa Alaikum As Salaam Wa Rahamatullahi wa Barkatahu.
(May the peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be with you too).
Shalom back to you ☮️🕊️😍
It’s called Judea And Samarea.
It’s all Jewish land since 3,000 years ago.
imagine if the native americans has that attitude. Imagine if they started a war with the americans, claiming that they've been there for 10,000 yrs and so it's there land. They don't do that because they understand that today's laws are to be respected and obeyed. Ppl living in that land push the world around by not obeying the laws of the land, claiming that there god gave them that land, so they don't have to obey the laws of the land. This is why the world is turning against those ppl who have migrated there with the beliefs that they can do take whatever land they please because their god gives them the right. Can you see how rediculous such twisted thinking is???
Lol. Nonsense
@@RJ456-w6fHoly text says the land belongs to ALMIGHTY GOD , He gave it to Abraham, Isaac , Jacob= Israel. Moses and Joshua. Was called the Promised Land . Enough evidence and proof. So where do you and Islam come from .😂 Not for human discussion. It's GOD'S PROPERTY ❤
@@Sonny-ko2zk 😂 Nonsense argument yaar. I’ll come to your house and say god promised me it thousands of years ago
@RJ456-w6f is that a fancy way of saying you are ignorant?
The city Of Gina in Yehuda and Samaria (west bank) modern name Jenin.... original city name Gina (garden in hebrew).
Established in 1400 BCE (nearly 2500 years ago by jews)
Jews lived in Gina for 1800 years (longer than 99% of all countries on earth today).
Byzantine colonize it, in the year 350, in the year 628 Arab from Arabia colonize it from the Byzantine and change the name to Jenin..
The town of Schem (hebrew word) modern day Nablus.
Established 3000+ years ago by jews who lived there for 1000+ years.
Roman/Byzantine colonize it in the year 70 and rename it Neapolis.
550 years later arabs from Arabia colonize the land from the Byzantine and rename the town Nablus...
Bethlehem, Hebron, all the major cities in the Juda and Sameria (west bank) exact same history.... these towns have jewish cemetery dating 500, 1000, 2000, 3000 years ago.. do you think jews/Israelis invented time machine and went back in time burry jews in these town before the Arab caliphite (5th largest colonizing empire in HUMAN HISTORY - 11.5 million sq km colonized by force. Just FYI all of Europe is 10.5 million sq km) there are literally none biblical, non jewish records that jews lived here before the Arab colonization in the year 638. Egyptian records, Jordanian stone tablets from 1800 years ago. How ignorant are you to blanket statement "none sense" when you don't even know basic history.
Excellent. Thanks for this. Sharing far and wide!♥
trying to understand the life of the jews, the journey of finding meaning and nationhood despite the toughest adversity... i'm following this conflict everyday, and liked seeing the genuine heartfelt instances of hope and light in your life... great content man
Hh
Hg
This is a very good video explaining the Jewish history. I knew this all along and this is confirming it. The Jewish guide has shown the evidence of past such as the holy Mountain, Macabee cave to prove it. All of Israel was the land of Jews as natives until they were ruled by Greeks, Romans and then displaced into exile. The name West Bank is a misnomer only came in 1967. I support only one State of Israel not two state partition. Today Israel is strong and should take back all their ancient land area which includes Gaza, West Bank, Gollan Heights and Lebanon, Damascus. Shalom to you all. You are now on the right path of Jaweh as he wanted for Israelis.
Well, guess what? today it's internationally recognized as the west bank. Why keep living in the past? Scientists have determined that the semitic ppl, which are the arabs, can be traced back to the levant for 10,000 yrs. Europeans just started migrating there in the past century. This is the kind of thinking that is responsible for the Israeli's war on gaza and the west bank today. You don't see the native americans stirring up trouble for america because they go back 10,000 yrs, do you?
I'm watching one after another! Thanks.
This is great.I love his perspective and how honest he is.
❤❤ This was Very Interesting and even got some knowledge on The Time of The Maccabees
Extraordinarily valuable filmmaking.
Thank you for the nice words my friend
Wonderful content! You are so unbiased and open to all, yet you are also proud of your identity. The internet and world need more people like you. Kol hakavod l'cha!
Unbiased 😂
@@nadianurun6259 I think he wants to change the meaning of the word
This man really had a lot of knowledge.
I liked his description of the tribes.
Exceptional content bro! Respect 21:00 📍
Fantastic teaching video. Thank you for the enlightenment.
Definitely agree though meditation and consciousness can we come closer to good and behave more meaningful and deeper and softer to ourselves and one another.
Interesting how he used divorce as a great example as the relationship between two sides trying to come to reconciliation.
That's why Buddhism is #1
Wow. What a gem this video is ❤
Im proud the benjaminites got mentioned and remembered.
«Principled resistance to Even understanding The identity and narrative of The other. We Are not fighting eachother, But The fantasies of eachother»
I believe this is really important to understand. As an outsider looking in I try to see both sides, Even though I do acknowledge that The imbalance in Power is a big influence for me.
Better perspective. This is great video!
Nice video my brother ❤
Now it’s time to hear a peaceful Palestinian that doesn’t want us to be erased. Are you planning on doing that?
Goodluck
Nope 😯
Tt
Zionists have been erasing Palestinian for decades. Jewish supremacy must end for peace to be fulfilled.
@@RobPires thankyou
How can you reconcile, if you deny identity by statehood that you see as so important for yourself?
the rest of the ME is their statehood, you pos
So, he thinks Jews should be allowed to live in Judea and Samaria, you should've also asked him if he thinks Palestinians should be allowed to live in Israel proper. The west bank isn't sovereign Israeli territory either.
Palestinians are living in Israel.they're getting citizenship voting rights and benefits. Can you show one muslim country in middle East which provides citizenship and equal rights to their non Muslims counterparts?
@@syhuhjk Um yes. The Egyptians don't have any policies put in place to discriminate against other races or religions. Same goes with the UAE, you can be free to be anyone you want there and still be a citizen. These are just examples off the top of my head.
He does believe they should, I know him.but no one in mainstream Israeli society agrees with right of return
So called "Palestinians" of today are not native to the land, they are mostly Egyptian and Jordanian exiles forced to migraine there and lay false claims to the land as a form of warfare... Israel was a very desolate land before jews returned, and when they returned they turned deserts into farms and cities; bought not stole land from a few Arab ppl who moved in after jews were forced out... All that land belongs to the Jewish ppl; only reason why there are "contested" areas is because Isreal made agreements with these foreigners that if they stop attacking and killing jews then they can settle but these ppl broke that agreement and continue to break it to this day thus Israel has every right to reclaim All of its land and send these foreigners back to their homelands outside of Israel... "palistinians" are called refugees by the west and in part that is true and the only way to solve it is to send every "Palestinian" who doesn't want to live peacefully with jews back to where they came from... In past Israel has reclaimed its land but foolishly again in attempts at peace allowed these violent foreigners to stay; would've been better if Israel just kept its own lands from the start and vetted ppl its willing to allow to stay... J and S is 100% Jewish lands and jews have legal rights to settle there where "palistinians" do not but they still illegal do so; Israel should expel them per the violation of the law but Israel is allowing some of it per the west keeps telling Israel what to do with its own land so to not spark an all out war... Just study actual history for yourself and you'll find these foreigners admit they are taking Jewish lands and that jews didn't steal it, also that mass imitation is their war tactic... If you go on vacation and squatters move in while you are away, when you return is ot your house or is it theirs? To solve the dilemma should you split your house in two giving them half? Or is it still your hose and the illegal invaders should be thrown out? Obviously the latter, this is story of Israel in a nut shell
@@jaybelle1909 🤣🤣🤣 So much BS in your comment. First of all, so you think when Arabs came, they replaced the whole population that was already in the Levant? This isn't true at all. If this was so, Muslims would have become the majority in all the places they conquered rather quickly, instead they would be minorities for many centuries in their conquered lands. Which indicates relgious tolerance and gradual increase of Muslims (conversions).
I personally know Palestinians who descend from Jewish families, and these people have the strongest roots in the land as they have been directly inhabiting it for thousands of years, unlike modern day Jewish settlers.
More BS claims that Palestine was a desolate land. Ironic that you are telling me to read history... why don't you read the book "A Question That Outweighs All Others: Yitzhak Epstein and Zionist Recognition of the Arab issue" This is by one of the first Jewish settlers who made Aliyah to Palestine in 1880. He describes the land NOT empty and with NATIVE people living on it. Ofc Israeli and Israeli sympathizers whitewash history.
Yehuda is amazing. He is creating a new paradigm that unites the Hebrew and Arab peoples, but I hope his vision is doable and not unwittingly a trojan horse. I say this because it is not just about Jews and Palestinians. It is about Islam and the conditioning of Muslims. Are they actually capable of changing their attitudes? I know some are, but how about the vast majority? Will we fool ourselves that things have changed and then find that our Muslim partners have become our oppressors? It's happened everywhere Islam has managed to embed itself. I counsel extreme caution.
those settlers are soooo not hebrew. They're americans and europeans. Do you really think they're hebrew? Hebrews were dark skinned, more like the palestinians are in gaza today.
Having said.... this portion of your vlogs really catched my interests and somehow able to understand the tribes of Israel particularly Juda and Yousef... this is the kind of topics that separates you from other expats vloggers from Philippines. Mabuhay and Salamat.🙏🏼
Thanks!
sure man im gona come to your home and take it now becos my fam owed it 2000 years ago
LOLLL FRRRR
I see that this was filmed one year ago, BEFORE October 7, 2023.
I wonder what he would say now.
Subscribe to my channel! I'm doing a follow up with him soon!
@@TheTravelingClatt Great. Will do.
On the internet it states that Yehuda Hakohen, rabbi and former JDL member, was born Jason Weisbrod.
He explained in interviews that he changed his name to HaCohen, and his hebrew name is most probably Yehuda, as we mostly all have English and separate Hebrew names.
@@shainazion4073 I didn't think just anyone could take the cohen name. Can he do the priestly blessing or does he not count as a Cohen as far all the extra rules are concerned?
@@TikvaJane He told you -- he is a cohen. He is entitled to the name HaCohen. Jews have both an "outside" name and a Hebrew name, unless they are assimilated.
Weisbrod means white bread. He is a Cohen through his Father, and his father, and his father......
Jews in europe never had family names until 1740s after the Austrian emperor Josephs grand ducal decree.. look it up
Fascinating video ty. Interesting how he calls Tel Aviv basically an outpost of the West...so I take it to mean his community's identity is more complex. He says they're not "super religious" but to this Westerner it looks that way.
Finally, really interesting to learn he's not in favor of the so called "Two State Solution" and his version includes both peoples. Complicated and demographicislly speaking, don't the Palestinians aspire to "return" to this area as well?
Wouldn't it be great if this man's vision could prevail over all the extremists' agendas?
Great job on this interview 👍
Actually, I prefer to call it what it is, Eastern Judea as it actually was during the second temple period. After all, to call it a bank is not reality, it is neither a financial institution, nor the sandy slope of a river. The Jewish history of the land does come alive when one travels to these areas, denying reality will not address the real issues. The issues are not mistaken perceptions, but the real missile attacks from Gaza and the attacks against Israelis whether the weapons are rocks, explosives, knifes, guns, automatic weapons, etc. While the state of Israel is really just defending itself. This is the reality that somehow was lost in all of the philosophy. But yes, it is the ancient homeland of the Jewish people and of cause the evidence is overwhelming and much more than what this video covers.
It seems like people think this place was heavily populated before the establishment of Israel and Palestine. It really wasn’t it was very barren with small settlement. This land has switched hands many times but ultimately all of Earth belongs to G-d. He determines who lives where OUR part is what we do while we are here on earth. Do we promote peace ? Overcome our negative aspects into positive ones ? Hopefully as a collective we will shed the layers of hate and wear robes of love and holy spirit
💯💯💯
Look at camera footage in 1897 of jerusalem
ruclips.net/user/shortsNDZBsW8yLqg?feature=share
Its populated brother
Delusional hypocrite
It must be nice, that in the middle of working day, grown men do not need to work and can afford to spend time on prayer. Or better yet, some never work and just pray. Yet enjoy fairly high living standard. Where the money and resources come from? Who finances and supports it long term?
when he mentions the golden calf at 29:00 and the israelites praying to it reminds me of the meccans praying to the idols before Prophet Muhammed.
The critical perspective rings loud and true.
So they want us to believe the lady with the perfect American accent making cream cheese sandwiches is the indigenous person on the land and was colonized by the Palestinians? Okie.
So people who lived in a land for more than 1500yrs maintained their distinct customs and identity after being forced to leave have no right to say they are indigenously connected?
@@kableguy-ur3peif you are going to displace and govern people who were already there, you would have to prove the lady making cream cheese sandwiches (authentic middle eastern dish?) has direct ancestry in the land. Perhaps a family tree.
@@19Pulsar there are many Jews with family trees that go back as you suggest.
We don't seek to displace or govern our arab cousins and with many groups like the Druzim, Samaritans, Christian Arabs there is very little friction.
No one said in the video that anyone was colonised by the Palestinians.
@@happydillpickle 0:35
The man who you feature speaks perfectly
Good video. I almost didn't watch it because I was offended by the clickbait title of "Jewish Extremists - Israeli Settlers on Palestine". I wouldn't call that guy an extremists he has good relations with the Palestinians as do manyJews living in Judea & Samaria - especially area C under Israeli control. People tend to forget it's Arabs who build the roads & houses here. They work in Jewish communities whether it's on farms, in factories , in stores or as bus drivers, garbage collectors. They benefit from Jews living here whether it's creating jobs or keeping the area safe. There is peaceful coexistence & it needs to be expanded. Handing the roughly 60,000 Palestinians over in area C to be ruled by terrorists will not do them any favors.
In Israel, there are 60% of the doctors, nurses, pharmacists, dentists and other professionals that are Palestinian Arabs. They are not all bus drivers and garbage collectors, making it sound like they are the working class, while Jews are an elite class.There are Palestinian lawyers, judges, army generals and other such positions also.
Interesting, I keep wondering what Israeli settlers in Bet El are like. My both parents are from Birzeit, a Christian town.
Isaiah 61:1-11
[1]The Spirit of the Lord God is upon me, Because the Lord has anointed me To bring good news to the afflicted; He has sent me to bind up the brokenhearted, To proclaim liberty to captives And freedom to prisoners;
[2]To proclaim the favorable year of the Lord And the day of vengeance of our God; To comfort all who mourn,
[3]To grant those who mourn in Zion, Giving them a garland instead of ashes, The oil of gladness instead of mourning, The mantle of praise instead of a spirit of fainting. So they will be called oaks of righteousness, The planting of the Lord, that He may be glorified.
[4]Then they will rebuild the ancient ruins, They will raise up the former devastations; And they will repair the ruined cities, The desolations of many generations.
[5]Strangers will stand and pasture your flocks, And foreigners will be your farmers and your vinedressers.
[6]But you will be called the priests of the Lord; You will be spoken of as ministers of our God. You will eat the wealth of nations, And in their riches you will boast.
[7]Instead of your shame you will have a double portion, And instead of humiliation they will shout for joy over their portion. Therefore they will possess a double portion in their land, Everlasting joy will be theirs.
[8]For I, the Lord, love justice, I hate robbery in the burnt offering; And I will faithfully give them their recompense And make an everlasting covenant with them.
[9]Then their offspring will be known among the nations, And their descendants in the midst of the peoples. All who see them will recognize them Because they are the offspring whom the Lord has blessed.
[10]I will rejoice greatly in the Lord, My soul will exult in my God; For He has clothed me with garments of salvation, He has wrapped me with a robe of righteousness, As a bridegroom decks himself with a garland, And as a bride adorns herself with her jewels.
[11]For as the earth brings forth its sprouts, And as a garden causes the things sown in it to spring up, So the Lord God will cause righteousness and praise To spring up before all the nations.
This is what Palestinians and Israeli jews need to come together and understand each other. Their will be less violence killings terror etc. I deep down believe you two nation of people can live together cmon guys make peace paleeeeeeez not nice seeing hatred can't we love one another for being unique in our own ways and diverse. Anyway wish peace upon everyone and pray you can understand one another
Thanks for showing and explaining all of Israel . It is very interesting. Being a Christian it is all I read in the Bible. I love all your videos. Thank you so much. I would like to see more.
Ha
Sharona Eshet-Kohen and her husband Yehuda HaKohen are authors at Vision web magazine.
3:36 "I'm not the most religious Jew..." as he grabs a siddur, pulls out his tallit gadol, lays his tefilin and gets busy on Shacharit...lol - noice!
Ahahhaha
@@TheTravelingClatt I get it, though - this "religious" thing is hard to take unto yourself. because your actions aren't, at their heart, religious. Religion is a Western construct, as Yehuda HaCohen alludes to in this video. What you are doing when you daven shacharis in the glorious Judean morning is not religion. It's tradition. So, yes, you are right to laugh nervously when someone refers to your actions as "religious".
@@gcolwill But isn't tradition culture? The manner in which a group of people do things in a certain way that is different from other groups of people? Being religious simply mean the repetition of rituals unique to a group of people handed down from the past? Tradition?
@@uriahthehittite2309 you can follow tradition without even believing in God. My family are doing a kiddush every Friday night, with yarmulkes and everything.. non of us are believers.
Traditions can also be Octoberfest in Germany, or painting eggs in Easter.
This guy definitely believes in God, but saying he's not very religious means he doesn't observe all the traditions of a religious Jew.. just some of them.
@@Abilliph Yeah, the cultural Jew. I don't see the relevance of festivals for the sake of "tradition" because belief in our Gd and our way of life are supposed to be inseparable. The ritual is not really the point.
Very important voice to hear.
The tragedy of the people of Palestine is that their country was “given” by a foreign power to another people for the creation of a new state. The result was that many hundreds of thousands of innocent people were made permanently homeless. With every new conflict their numbers increased. How much longer is the world willing to endure this spectacle of wanton cruelty?
hmmm, and who started all those conflicts? Who was the aggressor?
There was NO country, the land was all Ottoman land, the people were all Ottoman subjects. The Ottomans had NOTHING called Palestine for 400 years. The Ottomans divided the land into 3 to 5 Sanjaks (provinces), none called Palestine. The Mamluks before the Ottomans, had NOTHING called Palestine. The Crusaders before the Mamluks, had NOTHING called Palestine. That is over 1000 years with NOTHING called Palestine. The Christian West called the Holy Land as Palestine, the people there did not.
The British illegally gave 77% of the Mandate of Palestine lands to the Arabs to become transJordan, leaving only 23% to become the future Jewish state.
Start looking up, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem. What he did and asked of the Arabs around 1948, then ask yourself why did he ask.
@@ali-rikabrands8637 False, Hajj Amin al Hussaini asked his people in the 1920s, not 1948!
Great contextualisation of the psychological enslavement and liberation movement.
Whether the Jews lived there during the times of the maccabees is immaterial, if they had taken the land from the Romans there would be no problem, the problem is that in 2000 intervening years other people made their home there and your claim doesn’t supersede theirs.
The Jews have turned away from God=Lord Jesus Christ before and have been scattered as a nation due to it. It has happened before during the captivity in Babylon like with the Romans afterwards. But one thing for sure God=Lord Jesus Christ always kept His promise to Abraham that he and his descendants the Jews will have the land of Israel and will keep His covenant for all time with Abraham , his son Issac and his grandson Jacob called Israel. Israel is all of Canaan, all of the Sinai peninsula, part of Egypt where the Nile is at, all of Jordan, all of Lebanon, part of Syria where Damascus is at, part of Iraq where Eden was and where the tree of eternal tree will be present and if God=Lord Jesus Christ allows us to eat from its fruit on judgement day the next prophesy of the last remaining two prophesies as stated in Revelation in the Holy Bible, and part of Northern Saudi Arabia. All of that is the Holy land of Israel. God=Lord Jesus Christ will rule Israel and all of the other nations on earth like He does in Heaven and His kingdom will never end. No one can change His will. God=Lord Jesus Christ doesn't want it to be Palestine. He wants it to be Israel and Israel is His like the whole earth as is heaven. Everything and everyone is His. We all will see to God=Lord Jesus Christ on judgement day. It is written.
They did not take anything from any people or land of Palestine. The land was former Ottoman land, the people were Ottoman subjects. The League of Nations created Mandates out of the Ottoman lands to create new countries. There were 3 Mandates created, the Mandate of Mesopotamia (Iraq), the Mandate of Syria and Lebanon, and the Mandate of Palestine.
The Mandate of Palestine had one mission only, to reconstitute the Jewish homeland in the Area of Palestine. The British were made Administrators over the Mandate. They illegally gave 77% of the land to the Hashemites to become trans-Jordan. The 23% left was to become the Jewish state.
In 1937, the British (against the Mandate Charter) offered the Arabs 80% of the land. The Arabs turned it down because the Jews were offered the other 20%.
The Jews appealed to the Arabs to stay in their houses and help them create a country together, they were answered by 5 Arab armies that attacked the one day old country Israel.
There were only 350,000 people in the land in 1860, and 30,000 were Jews. The rest were fellahins (tenant farmers) and bedouins. There were no Palestinians. Most of the people calling themselves as Palestinians came into the land in the 1900s as laborers. They were not living here for generations.
Shaina Zion .... the Jews are the original people of the Holy Land. All earth is owned by G-D but the Land of Israel is particular to the Jews. Despite exile, thousands of years of being out of the Land, they have returned. The true people of the Land are Jews.
@@adelmomarietta3964 And you are telling Me this, why?
Israel belongs to God=Lord Jesus Christ as all of the nations on earth. As does heaven. Everyone and everything belongs to God=Lord Jesus Christ. He is true original man. He is the Good Shepherd. We all will know who is His sheep on judgement day, the next prophesy of the last remaining two prophesies as mentioned in Revelation in the Holy Bible, His book.
It's really cool and tastes good is very different. Ha you always make me laugh
Thank you so much, this man was fantastic. The way he explained the land and the nation, the Tribe of people, hopefully those who are outside will gain a better perspective.
I am an American Jewish person of Eastern European Jewish ancestry. Where am I supposed to be native to? Israel? Ukraine? Manhattan ( my birthplace)?
Judah is your only true homeland. It's literally in the name of your people.
Herby Dan, a lawyer by education from Memphis Tennessee, owns and operates Herby's Bake Shop in Beit El.
מאפיית הרבי
Whats the significance of wearing blue/white clothing?
Well it's the colors of Israel.. idk google it
I think there is no case of oppressed people that were attacked but never fought back and ditched their land for 3000 years, came back after 3000 years to make homeless the inhabitants. Even the nation that expelled you, are dead. Yes Isreal as nation are unique in that respects...
It took 3000yrs to pluck up the courage to return and fight a ghost????.
Less than 2000 years and there have always been Jews in Israel,
there have been jews in israel for 3000 years straight dont forget them
@@rinan4058
Yes, they supported the muslims and were not zionist. The majority fleed. Similarly when joshua (AS) wanted to obey the orders of Musa AS to fight the rest disobeyed and were banished for 40yrs.
Also zionist do not consider them jews are still loyal to muslims and loyal to the Torah. Moshaich in torah is meant to save them not the zionists.
The average muslim is more devote then an average jew.
Also remember that muslims took jerusalem and lifted the ban by christians of jewish return. Umer RA great disciple of Prophet (saw) lifted the ban. He was the most friendly with jews of medina out of companions (disciples). And cleaned the trashed whailing wall and temple mount with his own hands.
The reason why jews can now pray at the wall is because of muslims and their help and support. But instead of taking mercy on them when they are in power, they are merciless. Muslims took mercy and the Isrealis did not.
I know their are anti zionist jews out there loyal to their torah, may be small batch but descent. My teacher was one Dr Lichman,poor guys son died of cancer. Soo personally I do not hate jewish people or their book but zionism I am against because prequisite of zionism is focusing on expelling muslims rather then the return of jews.
Zionists helped Ataturk of now turkey, do uprising inside the ottoman empire under the Banner of Youngs Turk who infiltrated the Caliphs and also targeted arabs. So arabs got upset and did uprising sk there is modern day Saudia Arabia, the palestinians who were loyal to ottomans now suffer.
@@salampakistan3691 totally false. local Jews are some of the most zionist element of society, then and now. i know many
@@salampakistan3691 and no, they were never treated equally
I love you guys. I am Ashkenazi but Mizrahi food for me is the best..
Settlers who displaced a settled population - is this not same as apartheid
I think there are a few flaws in your statement if you don't mind me being blunt Number one is you assume that the Palestinians were there before the Jewish settlers that is incorrect for hundreds of years already there have been Jews in the holy Land Number two is during the establishment of the state of Israel the Arabs chose to attack us not the other way around and when they lost the war they started running it was the Jews who invited them back but now they wanted everything on their terms so it's not as simple as you're putting it nor is it a true depiction of what took place so please don't take a complex situation which is veiled in propaganda and misinformation and force it into a narrow narrative It's simply not intellectually honest
They are not settlers, so....
Who is displaced
@@ali-rikabrands8637The ppl who lived there.
Hopefully people will learn from this. I sure have. Peace.
Thank you Brother you and your family!!! GOD BLESS ISRAEL!!!
They are from the devil
all good doers will be rewarded. all bad doers will be punished.
AWESOME - VISUAL HISTORY LESSON - THANK ---YOU ! ❤
@Paslms 122:6. Pray for the peace of
Jerusalem, they will prosper that love
you. God bless you on your journey!!!
Is it possible to do a follow up video in light of the current war?
It’s Judea and Samaria
Not the “West Bank”
There are actual names of all these regions and cities.
I'm watching this after October 7th 2023, and now it seems there is more reason than ever to understand the "Settlers" POV. Why shouldn't Jews live among the Palestinian Arabs? In Israel we have a nearly 20% Arab population, so exclusivity is not a viable argument.
I personally think, regardless if Jewish or not, that the existence of some ruins of ancient times is no proof of ownership. Just imagine the Italiens would run around in the world and claim that every place with a roman monument belongs to Italy? Worse even, imagine some Pakistani Family converts to Catholicism and claims Alexandria in Egypt belongs to them because it has Roman monuments. The logic just doesn't make sense. Regardless of that, I believe that if the Palestinians could forgive and the Israelis could repent about this whole occupation, then some peace can take place.
It’s an inaccurate comparison. Jews are indigenous to that land. And Judaism is not a religion, it’s a civilization and people, closer to an ethno religion but more than that. And they were born on that land. They never colonized.
The Israelite people developed as a nation. In that land. The Italians are not the Romans, and even if they were should Rome 've tsken from them? Should Vatican City be taken from Christians? Should Japan be taken from the Japanese? Or Alaska he taken fron the Inuit? Or Australia or New Zealand from the Maori, this is where the people developed.
Italians would not say that because for the most part they don't care about having colonies anymore and can barely control themselves. Their monuments are relics in various parts of the world because they invaded those parts of the world and colonized them. The "Palestinians" did not even exist until the 1960s. None of them called themselves that and it was NEVER a country called Palestine. It was a region under the control of people that were in what is now Turkey. They called it the Ottomans. They controlled all of that territory. The only reason "Palestine" has ever been a term in use is because of the Romans, who took over and named it after the Philistines, who were their distant Mediterranean cousins that had settled in Gaza. Where are the Philistines now? COMPLETELY WIPED OUT. They vanished over the course of time. The ARAB people there now, are a salad of people from all corners of the region and the majority of them had ancestors who had flocked there in the years just preceding the 20th century due to economic activity that was beginning to stir up because of returning JEWS that returned to the land and joined Jews that had already been there, in spite of the izlomic taxes and the degradation to have foreigners in your own land. There is no nation of Palestine. It suddenly became important to have this identity, when "Palestinian" had been the name for Jews for decades while the British controlled the area. The "Palestinians" are an INVENTED PEOPLE. Israel - and when I say that I mean the entire area, including the places occupied by violent Arabs - is a Jewish land. The invented people are just there.
That's not a valid analogy. You can't compare Jews in Israel with Romans in parts of Africa or the Middle East that they colonized.
We're indigenous to the land of Israel. It's where we emerged as a tribe.
Romans, on the other hand, emerged in Italy. Not in North Africa, the Middle East or even in Central and Western Europe.
Get it?
We're not claiming ownership over a land we could have colonized in the past through military conquest. We're claiming ownership only over the land we're indigenous to.
The rest of your argument is even more absurd.
Most Jews (Ashkenazim, Sefaradim and Mizrahim) today descend from the ancient Jews that lived in Israel 3,000 years despite having some admixture with other people (mostly female converts).
We're a tribe with our own ancient language, values, literature, music and ancient bloodlines that can be traced back to the ancient Jews of this land 3,000 years - not a community of people of different ethnic origins that just happen to share ancient theological beliefs and rituals that are rooted in Israel.
This is well known to most experts in Jewish History and it has also been proven through most the majority of genetic studies conducted on the main Jewish communities of today (Ashekanazim, Sefaradim and Mizrahim).
Again, your analogy with Persian or Afghan converts to Catholicism has no validity whatsoever.
What a peaceful settler. Totally not the colonialism type of settlers!
He has to endure Palestinian checkpoints (only for Israeli citizens), discrimination (streets that only Palestinians are allowed to use), and hatred.
Here is an example of the discrimination against Israeli citizens in Hebron: ruclips.net/video/aEdGcej-6D0/видео.html&ab_channel=AJ%2B
All Bullshit propaganda!! In Hebron the Palestinian Authority rules over 80% of the village. The Jews have one street only they are allowed to live in. The Jews were massacred by the "Palestinian" Arabs in 1929. All those Jews that survived were transported out by the British. There was more killing of Jews in the 1980s in Hebron. Unless you know the complete story, I suggest you remain quiet!
God bless the Palestinians
That would be the jews ppl as they are the true Palestinians and called themselves such; when Israel became a state again jews dropped the palistinian name at which point Egyptian and Jordanian invaders adopted the term and made up false claims to the lands...
😂😂😂😂😂 sooo smart, you are
There's even a location where the West Bank (as the international diplomatic community recognizes it) and "Israel proper" (the country of Israel, as Israel recognizes itself under Israeli law) overlap - East Jerusalem and the Old City. Someone could argue with justification that the Old City is in both Israel and the West Bank.
Ask them where they born
Out of Palestine
“It’s actually very, very complicated” this is so embarrassing 😭 racismcore to the max
Sensacional, e agradecido pelas legendas em portugues brasil
Judaism is an Indigenous ethno-Religion, that's the correct definition of what we are.
It is not a religion, it was only considered as a religion since the 1860s, from America first.
Yes.. and I would define the Jewish people as an ethnic or national community.
@seeyouseemee3863 yes.. even if they are European Jews.
They still keeps their traditions, language, and heritage, and pass it down to their children.. that's the definition of ethnicity.
Dude, 1995yuda, you're a troll. You even think nazis are jews. You think Louis Farrakhan is a jew. Lol.
Please start asking the Palestinians why they dont want Jordan which is 78% of Palestine???
Its a valid question no one is asking
I know but exactly you don’t have dna proof you only got words but no proof we got proof we are Abraham kids and you stole Israel
Yes, Jews have the DNA proof as well as an unbroken chain of ancestry, practice and tradition for over 3000 years. We don't follow a drunk preacher who one night outside a bar in the American south had a vision that the African Americans were the true Israelites of the bible, with absolutely Not one piece of evidence to back it up.
The Land Belongs to 🇮🇱🌷🕊️🕎💕,God Himself will fight for His Promised Land,God said it we believed it, Amen and Hallelujah 🇮🇱🕎🌿🕊️💞🌹
"Jewish settler in Palestine", what a biased choice of words. Wonder why did you stop chronologically in Palestine and did not use the name it had before, Israel.
Yehuda HaCohen - one of my favorite RUclips personalities, and one of my favorite zionists. Very erudite, very articulate individual.
I have noticed that Judea and Samaria, the rightful and biblical name for that are in Israel, has been changed to the West Bank. Is it not the same story of Israel, that in the eyes of many, changing the name Palestine, when wanting to give the impression that the Jewish people have ‘stolen’ the Land, God has given to them as inheritance? I’m surprised the question, where did the name Palestine originated from, has not come up, in this documentary. Ask a Palestinian, what is the meaning of the word, Palestinian, and I assure you the answer will be, I don’t know…
The Palestine/Palestina, was first given to Judea and Samaria (and not to all of the land), by Hadrian the Roman ruler in that areas of Israel, at the time of the Roman Empire.
He gave the name Palestina, out of hate for the Jewish people; he chose the name of the worst enemy of Israel in biblical times, the Philistines. This word, philistines, is not a name of the people, but a name describing what they did. They were from the Greek islands and spoke Greek, not Arabic. The name given to the philistines, is a Hebrew word, meaning, invaders, because they have invaded places not belong to them. So, in away, the Arabs who call themselves Palestinians, and rightly so, by their own admission, are saying, that they are invaders. So when looking into the truth, lives are saved and people are set free…so many lives of loved ones, over a long period of time, have been sacrificed for absolute lies. So sad…
@mad catter Palestinians are a blend of ethnicities, including Arab, Jewish, etc. They're culturally Arab, but nonetheless have been living there for generations.
@mad catter Arabs have been living in the area since they first occupied it during the Rashidun Caliphate's invasion of it. There was an influx of more Arabs from Jordan and other places, but there were always Arabs living there for centuries. They did, in fact, make up the majority of the population until their mass expulsion by the Zionists in 1948. It doesn't matter if Jews have roots that stretch back further; you don't get to claim a piece of real estate forever, especially after having been removed from it for millennia.
Having said that, I don't have a problem with Jews returning there to live. The issue is returning, then claiming exclusive ownership of the land, while ejecting its non-Jewish inhabitants to create a Jewish-majority apartheid state that has come to violate every international law there is. There is no excuse for that, save for racism, which many Israelis seem to have adopted as their default outlook on the Palestinian issue.
@madcatter6751 Why does it matter what the reasons for when and why Palestinian identity came into existence are? All cultural identities start somewhere, for a variety of reasons, and then become their own distinct group as their history unfolds. It doesn't matter whether Palestine has been around for a 1000 years old or just a year; it exists as a collective identity of a disenfranchised people who share a common struggle against an oppressor. Claims to land over seniority are moot, at best.
@madcatter6751 1. The difference between the two expulsions is that one occurred millennia ago and the other is recent, with those who witnessed the expulsion still alive. What gives someone the right to return after centuries of absenteeism and violently take it from people who already established themselves there? As I said, there is no eternal claim to real estate. If the Jews insisted on returning that badly, they should've insisted on making greater efforts to live side by side with the Arabs instead of saying "it's all ours".
2. You're arguing another moot point regarding ownership and occupation. What is the difference between the two when it comes to settling claims between different groups who have lived there at some point or another? What are the qualifications for rightful ownership of land?
3. I've heard that bogus argument so many times. You think some token Arab minorities in certain occupations in Israeli society detract from the racism they experience overall? They may be equal on paper, but not in reality:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Arabism#Anti-Arabism_in_Israel
4. What kind of point are you making here? People should be allowed to live anywhere they want. No one should be expelled from any place.
An accurate account of how, when & why the word Palestine came about plus a reminder of the far-off-island origins of the Palestinian people.
You need to go to Palestine and talk to the people that lives there. Because this sounds more like propaganda
@@madcatter1 Do you think it was right to kick out a people that had been living on that land for centuries? Yes or no.
@@madcatter1 So many lies in your post. Israel brought all the refugees back?! Is that why there's so many refugee camps in the area? And is that why there's no named Arab village in what is now Israel? Because said country wiped all of them off the map? You extremist fanatics are unbelievable.
@@madcatter1 that's daft. By your understanding Maoris have no claim to New Zealand and Koris have no claim to Australia because they didn't have an 'official' nation.
@@madcatter1 your whole comment is a lie 😒. You can use Google and try to find a map that says Israel before 1930s. There's none maps from 1800s clearly states the place as Philistine. You need to use your common sense instead of your feelings 😒. There's still video evidence of the Jewish migration with the British to the middle east stop lying to yourself child. If these people came from the middle east they would have brown skin like the Palestinians not blonde with blue eyes like European's. You are claiming a history that is not yours. The whole idea behind the creation of Israel is online for everyone to see these people have been chased out of other nations for a reason. Israelis are thieves at this point they was offered a place to stay and now they want to take it all. And the current people living in Israel says there grandparents are Europeans. You are just choosing to believe whatever comforts your feelings not the truth.
@@madcatter1 do you realize the area we are talking about was referred to as North Africa not the middle east the term middle east is modern. There's more African Jews than the population of Israel. Israel itself is full of Africans you won't see them in the media though because they want to hide this but how long can you hide the obvious.
No you speak yittish not Hebrew Hebrew isn’t yittish that’s germen not Hebrew you lied you don’t understand Aramaic do you see the game stops here
This is undisputedly Jewish land in my eyes, god bless this beautiful nation and it people.
Typical Zionist opinion. Do not forget the Palestinians.
Why? Give one reason why.
@@sandall100 So called "Palestinians" of today are not native to the land, they are mostly Egyptian and Jordanian exiles forced to migraine there and lay false claims to the land as a form of warfare... Israel was a very desolate land before jews returned, and when they returned they turned deserts into farms and cities; bought not stole land from a few Arab ppl who moved in after jews were forced out... All that land belongs to the Jewish ppl; only reason why there are "contested" areas is because Isreal made agreements with these foreigners that if they stop attacking and killing jews then they can settle but these ppl broke that agreement and continue to break it to this day thus Israel has every right to reclaim All of its land and send these foreigners back to their homelands outside of Israel... "palistinians" are called refugees by the west and in part that is true and the only way to solve it is to send every "Palestinian" who doesn't want to live peacefully with jews back to where they came from... In past Israel has reclaimed its land but foolishly again in attempts at peace allowed these violent foreigners to stay; would've been better if Israel just kept its own lands from the start and vetted ppl its willing to allow to stay... The vast majority of conflicts and violence in the region is caused by these foreigners not Israel and this too is blatantly obvious to anyone who actually studies whats really going on... J and S is 100% Jewish lands and jews have legal rights to settle there where "palistinians" do not but they still illegal do so; Israel should expel them per the violation of the law but Israel is allowing some of it per the west keeps telling Israel what to do with its own land so to not spark an all out war... Just study actual history for yourself and you'll find these foreigners admit they are taking Jewish lands and that jews didn't steal it, also that mass imitation is their war tactic... If you go on vacation and squatters move in while you are away, when you return is ot your house or is it theirs? To solve the dilemma should you split your house in two giving them half? Or is it still your hose and the illegal invaders should be thrown out? Obviously the latter, this is story of Israel in a nut shell
@@jaybelle1909 “Palestinian history doesn’t begin with Arab conquest. Jericho is 10,000 years old, Arab conquest is 1400 years old, no negating 9000 years of history and more.” - Mahmoud Darwish
“Archaeology alone reveals nothing about the origins of “Ancient Israel” but provides information on settlement patterns & cultural traits of the population of PALESTINE during the period in which “Israel” appeared in Palestinian history.” - Keith W Whitelam “The invention of ancient Israel - the silencing of Palestinian history"
By your logic Palestinians deserve the same right to return to their homes now in the hands of immigrants from America, Europe and Russia.
By your logic, The only way to solve the conflict and gain peace is to send every foreigner who is a threat to Palestine and it's population back to where they came from.
Foreign settlers do not have ANY right to steal land and homes in territory designated as Palestine. The name illegal settlements should give you a clue.
The land given to Zionists in Palestine was given under defined conditions To uphold its founding promise, Israel must treat its Arab citizens as truly equal
I suggest you study history and read some books on this topic. Your view is totally flawed.
Here is a starter www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/threshold-crossed/israeli-authorities-and-crimes-apartheid-and-persecution
@@sandall100 because it is, it’s the Jewish homeland. Has been forever. Land of milk and honey. Arabs are welcome as long as they’re peaceful and identify as Israeli. There is not Palestinian state, no infrastructure, no government, hospitals, or work. Everyone travels from (West Bank) to the cities (all industrialized, Israeli)to work because the Arabs in the area cannot stabilize their own economy. They don’t even have an airport you can fly to if you wanted to, you’d have to travel through the Israeli state. There is no Palestine only the Roman semantics of what was Judea & Samaria. There is only one land and 2 people Jews and Arabs, but only one state, Israel.
This is why settlement like this is completely fine and in fact advocated for. To return to the only homeland they have.
The thing is, this history is shared with the Palestinians, if you look at their DNA they have been there since the Natufian culture, 15 000 years ago. Loads have last names dirived from both Samaritan and Jewish names. They are part of the population that never left the holy land. Its literally siezing the land of your own family and keeping them under military law. Israel cant keep it up much longer.
😂😂😂
You really expect me to believe these people are "natives"
Song of Solomon 1:1 Verse 5
They are natives. The Syrians, Lebanese and other natives look similar to the Yidden of Bet El.
That is so stupid. How come today that nilitic or African features are south of the Sahara and Israel, Egypt, Morocco, Jordan, Syria are all north of the Sahara and most of the people don't have those features? Was it so different then?
Yasuke, what has this verse to do with being indigenous to Israel? Explain? Who is the speaker in verse 5?
This is not an Israelite speaking. This is the Sulamite Slave girl who says that the daughters of Jerusalem ( Istaelite women) looked down on her because she was dark. If they were dark. They would not look down on other women for them being dark. And she became dark from the Sun, that means she was light actually.
Song of Solomon 1:5 is not an Israelite speaking, it is the Sulamite slave girl. She explains that the Sun made her dark, she wasn't born that way. She also says the daughters of Jerusalem looked down on her because she appeared dark. As the Israelites were not dark.
39:00 looks like food storage
Sad part is that these people believe their own hype! Tribe of Judah!? Get serious. Who apart from you guys believe this sort of thing. Just say you're a sttler colonialist from America and be done with it. At least people won't accuse you of dishonesty.
Did you miss all the history of the Israelites?
@@rachelsamuel3328 dont try even to explaain this man is lost
@@rachelsamuel3328 Israelite history? You think the old testament is a historical document? No one knows any of the authors and it's a translation from Greek for God's sake! It's fiction! Besides, you really believe God is doing real estate? And what's so special about this tribe to the exclusion of all others!?
These people are so full of shit. They steal and justify it. It's absolutely sick. I care for neither side, but they can't help pissing on your leg and telling you it's raining.
@@mslayous1 Most of the history in the Torah has been confirmed by other sources. They have found cities mentioned in the Torah, they have found Bullae of the kings and prophets. They have found many proofs of the history in the Torah.
Why is there so much land left uncultivated and unoccupied in Israel? Is this a deliberate policy by the government? I visited Israel in January 2019, it was a very unforgettable experience....l love the country., the topography, the historical and biblical sites and the food too .❤❤🎉. Pity about the ongoing war. I pray for peace and prosperity to return to the land.
Nonsense...lies. thete is no palestine for arabs. Thete is no such thing as jewish settlers in the land of israel. Read and research your history.
All of the region belong to Arabs. Isreal was created by UN. Jewish refugees of Europe have no rights to Palestine. There ancient homeland is Khazaria - which is eastern Ukraine and southern Russia.
If a jewish refugee from Europe have right to Isreal ...then Arab and African refugees have right to turn Europe into their own nation and claim it.
@@farhiyaa4880 more lies...only the ignorant and uneducated fall for your lies...your madeup history! Btw....i am arab israeli. Your lies hurt us!
Shalom achi, are you a Yemenite Jew? Just wondering.
Iraqi
@@TheTravelingClatt cool. I'm partially Iraqi, too, with the rest being Persian and Turkish (Jewish).
That was Palestine.
you gotta show your new videos on the home tab. Its still showing old ones.
This what you get after colonization..
Your best vlog to date: informative, thought-provoking & transformative to many of us who wish to see beyond the stalled peace process. There is now an alternative to the moribund two-state solution, one that I'm going to give much thought to in the coming weeks and months.
Bro what is your ethnicity? You look like east Asian.
He is an Iraqi Jew.
@@rachelsamuel3328 iraqi wow that's amazing
@@wicomms Technically, Jews are West Asian, so.
@@1995yuda what ? lol please explain
@@denigorelov9909 I mean, Geographically speaking, as in on a Map, Israel, the Indigenous homeland of the Israelis is literally located in West Asia. So, Jews are West asian by definition. The reason this sounds weird to you is because you have a narrow western conception of Asians which probably only include Chinese, Japanese, etc, which is really not the reality on the ground.
Why are settler homes so filthy? Does anyone know. Palestinian houses are so clean….
Really? Go look at Corey Gil Shuster's Ask Project, The Palestinians themselves speak about how dirty the Palestinians keep the streets and land.
kindly reminder, there is no such thing as palestiniens. they are all ishmaeli arabs who came here as refuges from all the arab countries around us for all these years. palestine was the name the british gave to this land and it comes from the word "Plishtim" that is mentioned in the bible (the story of Shimshon). those "plishtim" were NOT arabs. so there's no connection between them and the arabs claimed to be palestiniens. how can they say we took the land from them when they never ruled here? they just lived here. well, news flash: there were jewish living here the whole time too. even after the roman exile, there were still jewish left here. there was never a time when israel was empty of jewish. we just didnt rule here for years. israel was a desert. if the arabs were here living good as they claim, why didnt they build anything? why was it all desert? nothing of a function society! it was only after the jews came here in and built this country from zero, cleaned the area from Malaria, farming, building... only then, suddenly, arabs has the audacity to claim this as their own. but even after knowing this fact, we jews were ready to live with them and let them enjoy our beautiful country and system, and some of them, mostly israeli arabs, live great, they are doctors and lawyers and they get to live freely in a democratic country. but the rest of them dont want to co-exist with us. they want us dead. they dont accept living under a jewish nation so how can we do peace with them? the problem is their religion. they believe jews should not exist anywhere. even if we gave them israel as a present they'd still hate us. thats the sad truth people around the world dont know. they think we are the bad ones who dont want to live with them when the truth is they are the ones who hate us for being jews. its not a political war, its a religious war and thats why it can never end. this conflict is claimed to be complicated when its really not. there's a simple answer which is - its the land of god. he gave it to us, he took it from us and gave it back to us. we were here first. end of story. and if u dont believe in the bible theres another answer: there was a war, we won. end of story. stop complaining. i dont see anyone shaming other countries who fought a war and won their territory. thats how the world works. want it "back"? fight us. we dare u. thats it.
Very interesting ❤