@@nickroosh9407 Other 4 to me are, in no particular order: Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Piano Concerto No. 26 in D major, K. 537, "Coronation" Prokofiev Piano Concerto No. 1 in D-flat Major, Op. 10 Rachmaninov's Piano Concerto 2 Beethoven: Piano Concerto No.4 in G, Op.58
Virile, clear, cut-glass definition; power, enthusiasm, familiarity with score. Superlative performance of Liszt's transformative genius. Schubert's Wanderer constantly strives against the bounds of solo piano, two hands. As heard by Liszt, it should have been piano concerto; and even then, the music can hardly be contained. Immense energy! Yet another Jando recording which is of absolute benchmark status. And as for Liszt, to him goes credit for realizing brilliantly 'Schubert - Piano Concerto'.
Très impressionnant, d'une très grande beauté. Liszt se fait discret et soutient le caractère expressif de ce chef-d'oeuvre magnifique de façon magistrale. Merci de ce partage. Very impressive, of great beauty. Liszt is discreet and supports the expressive nature of this magnificent masterpiece. He did it in a magistral way. Thank you for sharing.
Fabulous. I first learned of this with the Brendel version back in the 70's. Loved it ever since. For me it improves on the solo. Thanks much for going through the trouble to put the score with the music.
Farrel Permadi yes it did. Liszt used Schubert's one movement "sonata" like idea which is clearly seen in the sonata in b minor as it is one whole long movement
This fantasy influenced a lot of what Liszt does in general. The flat 3 over the 5 (altered dominant) to 3 over 1 (I) resolution. The two-whole-step modulation from C to E (Liszt would go on to complete the cycle with Ab, and used this modulation pattern all the time. The two-handed cadenza runs, etc, etc…
I heard that the original Wanderer Fantasie was too hard for Schubert him self to play, and he even said that "only devil can play such a difficult piece"🤔 (Liszt：And here I come~d(`>∀
T. Alexander E. A fact to note on, if you had a close analysis of Tchaikovsky piano concertos (both but the second for more), the piano parts are evolutions from liszts styles and techniques. And you can also see how they evolve as Liszt ➡️Tchaikovsky ➡️ Rachmaninoff.
@@tomswiftyphilo2504 No argument with liking the original. But some of his transcriptions of Schubert are, as I said, mightily effective in their own right-this giving orchestral scope to his idea's in this piece, and the song transcription's artistry and poetry without a voice necessary.
@@bloodgrss I like Erlkonig and Standchen. I literally couldn't listen to Der Winterreise. it felt like liszt took all of the beautiful simplicity of what may as well be my favorite songs in any genre... and crapped his virtuosic filagree all over it, with no regard for whether it would actually sound better.
Nah. Demidenko gives best solo version. Amazing, particularly the power of the finale. But... it's nothing, compared to this, massed ranks of orchestra and piano acting together! Jando's piano solo version is just good.
![[Sviatoslav Richter] Schubert: Wanderer Fantasy for Piano](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OJQQ0fPemaE/mqdefault.jpg)
Schubert's harmonic and melodic brilliance meets Liszt's skillful orchestration. Love it.
i feel Liszt spent less than a day on his orchestation. He had too much stuff on his hand...
This transcription is simply incredible. Ever since I first listened to it I get the intention that the original is a transcription of this.
i love it how liszt remained faithful to Schubert's style. I almost didn't hear liszt on this. So beautiful. :D
I think it is a Busoni arrangement.
@@jimcrawford5039 It´s Liszt
Yes, the orchestration is largely classical in style too.
One of the best 5 piano concertos ever!
Agree with you!)
What are the rest? (in your opinion, as always.)
@@nickroosh9407
Other 4 to me are, in no particular order:
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Piano Concerto No. 26 in D major, K. 537, "Coronation"
Prokofiev Piano Concerto No. 1 in D-flat Major, Op. 10
Rachmaninov's Piano Concerto 2
Beethoven: Piano Concerto No.4 in G, Op.58
I was looking for piano concertos by Franz Schubert and I guess this is what's going to be available. Splendid piece of music.
11:23 Schubert, one of the Greatest music figures of all time!
yeah. i like that place as well
Brillante transposition du chef d’œuvre de Schubert par un Liszt virtuose
Virile, clear, cut-glass definition; power, enthusiasm, familiarity with score. Superlative performance of Liszt's transformative genius. Schubert's Wanderer constantly strives against the bounds of solo piano, two hands. As heard by Liszt, it should have been piano concerto; and even then, the music can hardly be contained. Immense energy! Yet another Jando recording which is of absolute benchmark status. And as for Liszt, to him goes credit for realizing brilliantly 'Schubert - Piano Concerto'.
Très impressionnant, d'une très grande beauté. Liszt se fait discret et soutient le caractère expressif de ce chef-d'oeuvre magnifique de façon magistrale. Merci de ce partage.
Very impressive, of great beauty. Liszt is discreet and supports the expressive nature of this magnificent masterpiece. He did it in a magistral way. Thank you for sharing.
Didn't know existed a version for piano and orchestra!
Sadly, rarely performed. I have loved it for years.
Fabulous. I first learned of this with the Brendel version back in the 70's. Loved it ever since. For me it improves on the solo. Thanks much for going through the trouble to put the score with the music.
Liszt finished what Schubert started; no additions, no cadenzas; just amplification and improvement to what was already there.
@@tomowenpianochannel Agreed 1000%
Questa registrazione e.'meravigliosa!
That compression though... sounds like the audio was meant for radio, not CD.
J'aime bien Jando Jeno! Sa version des impromptus est magnifique, selon moi!
Fantastic, thank you for the post, best recording I've yet heard.
18:06 sounds very increible
I love this music! Too much!!
This fantasie must influence on his Sonate B minor motivation
No lah, he is transcribing Schubert's Fantasia in C Major (known as Wanderer Fantasia)
Farrel Permadi yes it did. Liszt used Schubert's one movement "sonata" like idea which is clearly seen in the sonata in b minor as it is one whole long movement
The Wanderer Fantasy not only influenced it, but he copied it for his Sonata.. lol
This fantasy influenced a lot of what Liszt does in general. The flat 3 over the 5 (altered dominant) to 3 over 1 (I) resolution. The two-whole-step modulation from C to E (Liszt would go on to complete the cycle with Ab, and used this modulation pattern all the time. The two-handed cadenza runs, etc, etc…
Que exelente combinación. Y también exelente. el pianista. ,
Suena como un concierto....
I heard that the original Wanderer Fantasie was too hard for Schubert him self to play, and he even said that "only devil can play such a difficult piece"🤔
(Liszt：And here I come~d(`>∀
Wonderful, thanks for the upload.
素晴らしい。元のバージョンへの理解がより深まる。
Wat 'n ontdekking, ben er blij mee !
3:18
The passage at 19:41 sounds like Rachmaninov
T. Alexander E. A fact to note on, if you had a close analysis of Tchaikovsky piano concertos (both but the second for more), the piano parts are evolutions from liszts styles and techniques. And you can also see how they evolve as Liszt ➡️Tchaikovsky ➡️ Rachmaninoff.
@@rakeshkrishna1795 they are MUCH higher in Tchaik. Let's not kid ourself. phahaha
Yes! I agree.
Klasse
21:25
19:23 exciting moment
even more intriguing than the original version~
Who's the pianist? Many thanks.
Name is in the title.
I just don't see the point. maybe someone could explain it to me.
Liszt wanted to know how it would like it was a concerto, so he did this. That's all.
Perhaps, also Tom, because it's mighty effective as music?
@@bloodgrss I suppose. I like some of Liszt's transcriptions but mostly I find myself thinking I would rather be listening to schubert.
@@tomswiftyphilo2504 No argument with liking the original. But some of his transcriptions of Schubert are, as I said, mightily effective in their own right-this giving orchestral scope to his idea's in this piece, and the song transcription's artistry and poetry without a voice necessary.
@@bloodgrss I like Erlkonig and Standchen. I literally couldn't listen to Der Winterreise. it felt like liszt took all of the beautiful simplicity of what may as well be my favorite songs in any genre... and crapped his virtuosic filagree all over it, with no regard for whether it would actually sound better.
lots of echo in this recording
La composicion es muy floja....pero surna bien...no habia tenido la oportunidad de escucharla....gracias....
Es un arreglo
Still preferred the original version for solo piano~! No offense!
Yes. More interesting than punchier like orchestrated f minor fantasie op.103/D940 from also Schubert (originally for piano four hands) by Kabalevsky
I think the original version is better.
Nah.
Demidenko gives best solo version. Amazing, particularly the power of the finale.
But... it's nothing, compared to this, massed ranks of orchestra and piano acting together!
Jando's piano solo version is just good.
Che cacata! XD XD
20:42