How do you propose to pay for your roads and schools with so many benefits being given out. Can you explain where you would get the money from? Unless you are congress party supporters, you would want your own country to go bankerupt as has bern happening in congress party ruled states
@dharam1718 Bro not a supporter of any party just a common man and being a common man I said what I feel is right. No more debaits if you didn't agree fine I respect your decision or thoughts.
@@dharam1718 all services r of poor quality. Roads r almost non existent and schools don't joke who even uses that?? 8std students r not able to answer 3rd std questions a recent study ws conducted on this. Better to give money in hands of middle class the only class running this country. This will increase consumption , better natural way of wealth distribution to lower class. Either way economy runs or consumption only in Indian. Our exports r more pathetic than our schools.
@@dharam1718Government charges GST on all items that is purchased by 1.45 billion people in India. Every month the government is exceeding its own GST collection targets. Moreover the GSY was introduced since the government wanted to removed TDS on the miniscule 1.16% of 1.45 billion that is paying income tax which means more than 98% of the population does not pay any income tax even if they are rich enough to pay. This is the issue. If we earn, we pay tax. If we spend fron the already taxed amount, we pay tax again. If we save from the previously taxed amount, government deducts tax from the saved amount as well.
Yes . If TDS is not deducted we will get interest on that amount till the time we have to pay our tax. Also we can invest that money somewhere till the time we have to pay tax.
Not only TDS, the employers are also doing bonded labour job for EPF ESIS etc. Why should they deposit it on behalf of employees? Employers can pay their share to employees and let them deposit it in their respective account.
जय हो अश्वनी उपाध्याय जी की अश्वनी उपाध्याय जी देश में सर्वाधिक PIL file करने वाले व्यक्ति हैं। उनके सारे PIL राष्ट्रहित के लिए समर्पित रहता है। जय हिंद
सभी राष्ट्रवादी चाहते हैं कि अश्विनी उपाध्याय जी को भारत का कानून मंत्री बनाया जाए। मैं भी अश्विनी जी को कानून मंत्री बनाया जाए, ये बार बार उनके वीडियोस में लिखता हूँ।
Farmers should definitely pay tds. And this system should not exist for income tax payers. Or farmers should start paying taxes. Govt should take 2-3% income tax from farmers earning more than 12 lpa
Why? When a farmer invest more than 50k+--1 lakh indian rupees in rainy days he losts all his assets then where are u ? You or government paying any help to the farmers..the government hasn't implemented msp also ...so Ghar mein Beth kr gyaan mt pelo bhai ...baap ko puchna kitna mehent krke tujhe ye life diya h ..isliye to ye sb baat krta h
@@AdityaRanjan-u8f what nonsense are u speaking ?. I paid tax for many years suddenly I lost the job what benefits am I getting from government for paying the tax for till now ?. Or in case of trader who paid tax and his trade in end losse !. What's the point to giving a high income farmer an excuse from income tax !.
बिल्कुल सही PIL है👌👌👌👌👌 इसके petitioner को दिल से धन्यवाद🙏🙏🙏🙏 सरकार टैक्स लेगा, उसमें फिर टैक्स देने के लिए बन्दा पैसा भी खर्चा करेगा......ये कहां का न्याय है........!!!!!!! टैक्स पे टैक्स हो गया ये तो........... टैक्स का पैसा जनता के लिए खर्चा कम नेता और सरकारी अफसरोंके जेब भरती के लिए है।
Very good 👍👍 initiative 😂❤😂 TDS on interest earned at banking sector is disgusting. Specially for senior citizens and to all others. Once the RBI/bank😢 & government fixes the interest then why on it again TDS charges????
Ma'am insufficient explanation of TDS. This is a method to pay income tax where tax amount is deducted directly from the salary during recieving the salary from employer. So, it's tax deduction at source.
Tds agar na bhi kate..still we need to file IT return as per our salary and the slab where it falls.That time we have to pay the entire amount.Agar kuch refund hona hai to hoga.....kindly point me if iam wrong...
Ma'am new tax regime me kya kaam ca ka? Shayad 1-2 clause hi ho usme tax saving ke otherwise it's like u r paying the full tax without any hack to save.
Good topic and could have context . Thanks for bringing it in firm if video madam. However write ur script of video first and find how many statements are repeating . This will help reduce ur video by more than 50% and shall have much better impact .
Once M.P govt abolished sales tax but introduced commercial tax with the same rates. If supreme court declares TDS is unconstitutional, govt will introduce with different name.
Thank you Mr Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay. You are a saviour for all honest tax payers who are terrorised by the current FM and government. This FM takes great pride in taxing just 1.16 % while she conveniently looks the other way when her politician collegues in parliament, state assemblies are looting the citizens of India and are doubling and triping in wealth every year. She has a problem if the average citizen earns honestly while those dishonest people just because they join BJP are allowed to keep swindling people. She should be sacked..she is the worst FM and a blood sucker
I really appreciate your efforts! A bit off-topic, but I wanted to ask: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How can I transfer them to Binance?
1. 🎯🎯[First time Ever] FLAT 55% Off on all UPSC Subs with Assured Success(CSE Assure) unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=CSELIVE CSE Assure: Unlock a Free 12-Month Extension! Crack UPSC CSE 2026 or Get a 12-month subscription extension for free when you purchase an 18-month or 24-month UPSC CSE subscription! (Terms & Conditions apply, as detailed on platform) 2. 🚨UCSC is on 29th Dec: 👉 Register Now: unacademy.onelink.me/nWi1/gtywrub4 (Unacademy Civil Services Championship Scholarship Test) Start 2025 With a Big Rewards & massive scholarship in Hand! Take the Scholarship Test and win exciting rewards, scholarships, and more! 🏆 Test Date & Time:29 December, 11AM & 5PM. Let’s Crack It!
Our govt is a very shameLess over tax system on its people this is a looting system they should resign or sacked from their post good job done by aswini upadya
Very good, myself retired from private sector. My money invested in one of the scheme and am getting interest which is more than 3 lakhs ie 3.18 lakhs for which it deducting about 30000+, because it is interest income. Why should I block this 30k+ for a year and ask for refund and for which I will have to pay ca fees.
GoI please keep one tax either GST or Income Tax. The Tax payer is a Golden duck, take the golden egg when the duck lays the egg. You are butchering the duck to collect few developing eggs.
It's just a stunt to come in limelight because Ashwani ji is BJP guy and too much tilted towards far right-wing. He will definitely collude with the government for that no other person can file this petition.
Pl note our total tax system is against the fundamental right given to people of INDIA .As all these taxes are imposed without giving consideration to the income of tax payer .So this is against the fundamental right given by our constitution .Which is --- RIGHT AGAINST EXPLOITATION SO WE MUST lodge a pition in suprem court against these all taxes .And ask to abolish all taxes and start only Bank transation tax 1 or 2% on credit deposited in account .V.V.BHOSALE MIRAJ
Collection of TDS is a failure of Govt machinery. Incometax officer harasses on TDS matters. One day delay in depositing TDS is punishment to Businessman. One day late cost 3% of additional Tax. Interest Tax which is abolished now, doe not permit to charge more than 12% and also for number of days delay. TDS should be discontinued. Presently the Business community is made to remain silent the day Modiji took power. It is worse than Mrs Gandhi's emergency.
I don’t think this will fly in Supreme Court. Even if they take it up, it won’t even work in the upcoming finance session. Simplying means they need to change the system, 😂
Tds is advance payment of tax this is not revenue of government the assesse can claim in their income tax return if you think 1% is burden so, I think you need to leave this country
We should support this lawyer in fighting against the govt so that middle class can be saved.. i used to be a stern supporter of BJP but i no longer support this party since they have been looting the middle class left right n center in the same way Congress did.. so we need a diff party to power who understands the pain of the oppressed middle class
PIL tax abolish ke liye karna tha. TDS abolish karney ka koi matlab nahin hai. Yeh logoon ko kuch incine chupaney main help karega. Court should reject it and instead force govt to raise the income limit to 15 lac above which the tax should be started. 15 lac income should be tax fras.
Very good salute to this lawyer. I thik abhi eak nahi more than lakhs of PIL hona chaye is khoon choos tax ke khilaf.
How do you propose to pay for your roads and schools with so many benefits being given out.
Can you explain where you would get the money from? Unless you are congress party supporters, you would want your own country to go bankerupt as has bern happening in congress party ruled states
@dharam1718 Bro not a supporter of any party just a common man and being a common man I said what I feel is right. No more debaits if you didn't agree fine I respect your decision or thoughts.
@@dharam1718 all services r of poor quality. Roads r almost non existent
and schools don't joke who even uses that??
8std students r not able to answer 3rd std questions a recent study ws conducted on this.
Better to give money in hands of middle class the only class running this country. This will increase consumption , better natural way of wealth distribution to lower class.
Either way economy runs or consumption only in Indian. Our exports r more pathetic than our schools.
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
@@dharam1718Government charges GST on all items that is purchased by 1.45 billion people in India. Every month the government is exceeding its own GST collection targets.
Moreover the GSY was introduced since the government wanted to removed TDS on the miniscule 1.16% of 1.45 billion that is paying income tax which means more than 98% of the population does not pay any income tax even if they are rich enough to pay.
This is the issue.
If we earn, we pay tax.
If we spend fron the already taxed amount, we pay tax again.
If we save from the previously taxed amount, government deducts tax from the saved amount as well.
Finally a middle class person is helping middle class against pathetic and illogical tax collection by govt.
I support this PIL, Salute this Lawyer....................
Every people of india should file case on government regarding TDS .
Yes . If TDS is not deducted we will get interest on that amount till the time we have to pay our tax. Also we can invest that money somewhere till the time we have to pay tax.
Not only TDS, the employers are also doing bonded labour job for EPF ESIS etc. Why should they deposit it on behalf of employees? Employers can pay their share to employees and let them deposit it in their respective account.
जय हो अश्वनी उपाध्याय जी की
अश्वनी उपाध्याय जी देश में सर्वाधिक PIL file करने वाले व्यक्ति हैं। उनके सारे PIL राष्ट्रहित के लिए समर्पित रहता है। जय हिंद
👍
सभी राष्ट्रवादी चाहते हैं कि अश्विनी उपाध्याय जी को भारत का कानून मंत्री बनाया जाए। मैं भी अश्विनी जी को कानून मंत्री बनाया जाए, ये बार बार उनके वीडियोस में लिखता हूँ।
Farmers should definitely pay tds. And this system should not exist for income tax payers. Or farmers should start paying taxes. Govt should take 2-3% income tax from farmers earning more than 12 lpa
Why? When a farmer invest more than 50k+--1 lakh indian rupees in rainy days he losts all his assets then where are u ? You or government paying any help to the farmers..the government hasn't implemented msp also ...so Ghar mein Beth kr gyaan mt pelo bhai ...baap ko puchna kitna mehent krke tujhe ye life diya h ..isliye to ye sb baat krta h
They will not do what you can do
@@AdityaRanjan-u8f in that case where will be the government if I loose my job !. Answer that !.
@@karthikm7063 if u don't have a job mean u don't have enough money to pat taxes...so there is nothing to answer your question
@@AdityaRanjan-u8f what nonsense are u speaking ?. I paid tax for many years suddenly I lost the job what benefits am I getting from government for paying the tax for till now ?. Or in case of trader who paid tax and his trade in end losse !. What's the point to giving a high income farmer an excuse from income tax !.
Yes, it begins, finally it begins. That's what I was waiting for.
One day this government will install meters in toilets too😂😂
😂Woh bhi 10 gunna lagan
Humlog vishwaguru banege bhai kya baat kar raaha hai
Payment of TDS is easy... But filing TDS returns is very Complicated / tedious process.....
Bhagwan us admi ka bhala kare ❤❤
A PIL needs to be filed to GST act as well. It is a big scam to loot public & benefit corporations & scamsters!
बिल्कुल सही PIL है👌👌👌👌👌
इसके petitioner को दिल से धन्यवाद🙏🙏🙏🙏
सरकार टैक्स लेगा, उसमें फिर टैक्स देने के लिए बन्दा पैसा भी खर्चा करेगा......ये कहां का न्याय है........!!!!!!! टैक्स पे टैक्स हो गया ये तो........... टैक्स का पैसा जनता के लिए खर्चा कम नेता और सरकारी अफसरोंके जेब भरती के लिए है।
Govt is busy in finding ways to tax, like popcorn tax
Normal people not paid tax only salary person pay majority amount of tax ...
Perfectly right. Who are these people to Tax on income. . What is the account for their political expenses. Of public money. Keep usage taxes instead.
AGRICULTURE TAX IS A MUST
very good.....saver for middle class
I support the cause, salute the lawyer & urge all concerned to support this lawyer financially.
Very good 👍👍 initiative 😂❤😂 TDS on interest earned at banking sector is disgusting. Specially for senior citizens and to all others. Once the RBI/bank😢 & government fixes the interest then why on it again TDS charges????
बात तो सही है । Tax में क्या advance tax और क्या tds । यह बस सरकारी स्कैम है । पहले पूरे साल की इनकम हो उसके बाद उस पर tax होना चाहिए ।
Shame. Not expected from unacadamy. TDS is tax deducted at source means tax deducted before payment is made..
TDS Ko khatam karna chahiye
Ma'am insufficient explanation of TDS. This is a method to pay income tax where tax amount is deducted directly from the salary during recieving the salary from employer. So, it's tax deduction at source.
Tds agar na bhi kate..still we need to file IT return as per our salary and the slab where it falls.That time we have to pay the entire amount.Agar kuch refund hona hai to hoga.....kindly point me if iam wrong...
Tax should be paid on interest paid and not on interest accrued but not paid.Please file PIL
Support this from the bottom of the heart . Thanks
TDS is problem for us...
Ma'am new tax regime me kya kaam ca ka? Shayad 1-2 clause hi ho usme tax saving ke otherwise it's like u r paying the full tax without any hack to save.
निर्मला को जज ने पुछना चाहिए unko भारत सरकार से मिलानेवाली सॅलरी पर वह क्या टॅक्स या TDS देती है?
Agricultural income se tax rebate hatao...
Good topic and could have context . Thanks for bringing it in firm if video madam. However write ur script of video first and find how many statements are repeating . This will help reduce ur video by more than 50% and shall have much better impact .
Once M.P govt abolished sales tax but introduced commercial tax with the same rates.
If supreme court declares TDS is unconstitutional, govt will introduce with different name.
Nirmala ji ko hatao BJP ko bachao...
I think Tds is better than income tax abolish this income tax
TDS = Time Delay System
TDS = Tax Deduction System
This step was must very good
Thank you Mr Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay. You are a saviour for all honest tax payers who are terrorised by the current FM and government.
This FM takes great pride in taxing just 1.16 % while she conveniently looks the other way when her politician collegues in parliament, state assemblies are looting the citizens of India and are doubling and triping in wealth every year.
She has a problem if the average citizen earns honestly while those dishonest people just because they join BJP are allowed to keep swindling people.
She should be sacked..she is the worst FM and a blood sucker
Super.i agree with him. Middle class dying
Topic accha hein.. ek request hein..aap ekhi sentence bar bar repeat karna Kam kariye .
Can you update or share contact or information about this advocate who filed PIL. Want to contribute with some more add ons.
Both Tds and GST is Pre Revenue Tax collection
अब सीनियर सिटीजन को छोड़ दो न अब बूढ़ों को जिंदगी जीने दो enjoy करने दो न l
I really appreciate your efforts! A bit off-topic, but I wanted to ask: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How can I transfer them to Binance?
Ashwini sir ko mere naman 🙏🙏🙏
1. 🎯🎯[First time Ever] FLAT 55% Off on all UPSC Subs with Assured Success(CSE Assure)
unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=CSELIVE
CSE Assure: Unlock a Free 12-Month Extension!
Crack UPSC CSE 2026 or Get a 12-month subscription extension for free when you purchase an 18-month or 24-month UPSC CSE subscription!
(Terms & Conditions apply, as detailed on platform)
2. 🚨UCSC is on 29th Dec: 👉 Register Now: unacademy.onelink.me/nWi1/gtywrub4
(Unacademy Civil Services Championship Scholarship Test)
Start 2025 With a Big Rewards & massive scholarship in Hand!
Take the Scholarship Test and win exciting rewards, scholarships, and more! 🏆
Test Date & Time:29 December, 11AM & 5PM.
Let’s Crack It!
Case no. Share kijiye
Our govt is a very shameLess over tax system on its people this is a looting system they should resign or sacked from their post good job done by aswini upadya
When Income Tax penalises late tax payments with interest, it should pay interest on refunds.
Our present government is seeking more tax imposed on the common man.
Why politicians are not paying income tax
Very good, myself retired from private sector. My money invested in one of the scheme and am getting interest which is more than 3 lakhs ie 3.18 lakhs for which it deducting about 30000+, because it is interest income. Why should I block this 30k+ for a year and ask for refund and for which I will have to pay ca fees.
That's why I call it tax draconian system.
Mam ur definition of tds is not proper. TDS is Tax Deducted at aource
We will support this lawyer
Additional payment pay for CA for filing middle class people face so many problems
I request the channel to understand the matter and let a professional explain
The TDS is not tax paying but tax deducted on behalf of the payee
I think this is high time to review tds. They include chores of ration card holders for vote banks and tax payer has to bear all these.
Correct case
This petition will not be heard by SC in next 10 years
Supreme court will always go with the government 😂😂😂 they will not help common man
What is the use. Ultimately whole tax is to be paid even if tds is not deducted.
Do cricket IPL people pay any sort of tax/GST?
GoI please keep one tax either GST or Income Tax. The Tax payer is a Golden duck, take the golden egg when the duck lays the egg. You are butchering the duck to collect few developing eggs.
Ab high time hai ki crore pati farmers ke upar tax lage
Now all tax player need to creat one nation level union, to raise tax player concerns, in era of social media it is possible
Bacchon ke padhne ke liye jio 399 ka postpaid recharge karte the usmein bhi GST ghused Di.
Are bhai Health Insurance bhi luxury item hai apne liye
I was waiting for this day
It's just a stunt to come in limelight because Ashwani ji is BJP guy and too much tilted towards far right-wing. He will definitely collude with the government for that no other person can file this petition.
Pl note our total tax system is against the fundamental right given to people of INDIA .As all these taxes are imposed without giving consideration to the income of tax payer .So this is against the fundamental right given by our constitution .Which is --- RIGHT AGAINST EXPLOITATION SO WE MUST lodge a pition in suprem court against these all taxes .And ask to abolish all taxes and start only Bank transation tax 1 or 2% on credit deposited in account .V.V.BHOSALE MIRAJ
Pil against gst
There should not be tds on any income
Good decision
Problem kya h tds me, agar tax achase de rha h to, tds se dene se to aur easy go jaega.
It's high time bjp abolished it and let the citizens breathe freely.
Collection of TDS is a failure of Govt machinery.
Incometax officer harasses on TDS matters.
One day delay in depositing TDS is punishment to Businessman. One day late cost 3% of additional Tax. Interest Tax which is abolished now, doe not permit to charge more than 12% and also for number of days delay.
TDS should be discontinued.
Presently the Business community is made to remain silent the day Modiji took power. It is worse than Mrs Gandhi's emergency.
I don’t think this will fly in Supreme Court.
Even if they take it up, it won’t even work in the upcoming finance session.
Simplying means they need to change the system, 😂
Use economic mindset in election's and give vote . Trump ji is reducing taxes in US.
Dear ,
Please learn more about TDS system ... You need to learn it
Adhura gyan ghaatak hota hai
Please explain
I support PIL .
Scrap income tax for salaried employees
Tds is advance payment of tax this is not revenue of government the assesse can claim in their income tax return if you think 1% is burden so, I think you need to leave this country
20 guunnaa lagan chukaanaa pharega 😂😂😂
No right of Supreme Court
I support this new TDS system
No use we still have to pay heavy tax, Nirmala please do middle class a favour and quit, that would be releif for middle class.
I support. TDS is nonsense.
Jo bhi kiya, bhagwaan hai
India tax system is disaster I hate Nirmal she is not qualified for FM
PIL to abolish this current GST system.
more taxes needed
अब और टैक्स देना होगा😂😂😂
We should support this lawyer in fighting against the govt so that middle class can be saved.. i used to be a stern supporter of BJP but i no longer support this party since they have been looting the middle class left right n center in the same way Congress did.. so we need a diff party to power who understands the pain of the oppressed middle class
There will be no result on this issue.
In BJP govt elections Bhastachar hogai!
Courts are also Bhastachar hogai!!
PIL tax abolish ke liye karna tha. TDS abolish karney ka koi matlab nahin hai. Yeh logoon ko kuch incine chupaney main help karega. Court should reject it and instead force govt to raise the income limit to 15 lac above which the tax should be started. 15 lac income should be tax fras.
Very good move.. every one should support this
🙏🙏🙏
Good but don't get your hopes high.😅
Nothing will happen
Illiterate PM and arrogant FM.