Its a sad song. Poor Ed. "Beautiful mother, soft and sweet, once you were gone, we were not complete, back through the years we reached for you, a-last twus not ment to be." ~Vic singing
Vic has such a beautiful voice, and goes great with this song. I also like the japanese version with the child choir singing, but Funimation translated this song very well.
Those dislikes are all misclicks, because this is perhaps the most touching/chilling song ever, listening to it causes a mass of goosebumps to rise from my skin and I can't help but hum or sing along everytime I hear it... It's just such a beautiful song and Vic only makes so much greater because of his amazing voice.
whenever i listen to this song, i think of my little brother who died in a car accident 4 yours ago, and how i miss him so much. this song is beautiful and bring me to tears everytime.
I heard him sing quite a lot of different songs now.. but this one just fits him best.. because you know.. his voice has this very soft side, but it's still very meaningful..
i love this song so much theres so much energy. i can just imagine if fullmetal alchemist was a disney movie this would be like the lament song in every disney movie
He actually just did it because he liked the song, and he sent it to some friends who put it on the internet; something he wasn't going to do in the first place because he knew he could get in trouble. I'm kind of happy his friends put it online though=)
You know are an amazing voice actor when you take the place of a goddess like Romi Paku and no one complains. This guy is a legendary anime voice actor and he isnt asian, respect.
I love this song Vic sang this song at this year past MechaCon. I could tell just by the music notes in the air. I could recognize it right away form the Japaneses one quite easy.
My dog just passed away, so I've been listening to this song in Russian for the past hour or so. Mostly cause I'm Russian, and the language you grew up with just seems more powerful... especially with this track... I will miss my little puppydog... nobody to run out and meet me in the front yard anymore, waiting for me to pet him, with his ears down... wagging his tail... I'm gonna miss my doggy so much... :*(
I never understand how people can hate Vic's acting and voice. I can understand disagreeing with his stance on religious and...other issues, but as far as being a performer goes, he does great.
i met vic mignogna at his panel at fanexpo 2010 hes the nicest guy ever :D he took my breath away and signed my drawings of edward anybody who gets a chance go meet the dude
Aaaww I just love his voice *__* voice of an angel xP Seriously, I felt in love with Ed's voice the very first time I heard it. And he's (Vic) really, but really cute! (Though he's older than my parents...) He fits with his family name. In french, "Mignon" means "cute"... And finally, yah, the song is so beautiful, meantful. Seriously, every time I'm listening this song, I just wish I could have a strong relationship with someone, such as the Elric Brothers... =/
this is my like 54th time ive watched this exact video and i love this song it makes me want to cry and .sob. oh jeez .sob hic sob. i love this song so much
i read somewhere that it was supposed to be a duet between the voice actors of Ed and Al, but Al's voice actor couldn't do it so it was just Ed's voice actor .... i love this song though, it always makes me sad and DEFINATELY portrays Ed and Al's relationship
No matter how many times I listen to this song, it never stops being beautiful.
this song is so wonderful....and vic....this voice is incredible. I could listen to this song over and over again.
I love this song, I listen to it over and over again. The more you listen to it, more the it sounds like Ed!
He has such a wonderful voice.
This song seriously touches my heart... ~
so many of us SAY we'd give an arm and a leg for those we love. Edward Elric loved so much he literally did.
I've never seen Fullmetal Alchemist, but I am in awe of Vic's talent. He is an amazing singer. This song is absolutely beautiful and heartbreaking.
i love this song. its so beautiful and peacful. Vic had me close to tears when i first heard this
YAY! Vic's voice is soooo awesome, and he's so good to his fans. RISEMBOOL RANGERS! our goal is world domination!
It's so hard for me to listen to this without crying. Such an amazing voice. It's so sad and touching
i love vic so much, his voice is a gift from above, and i love this song too, so beautiful ^^
Wow, Vic nearly lulled me to sleep then! And I was close to tears! He has such a great voice, such a touching song too.
I can no longer count how many times I've heard this song... I still wanna give Ed a hug...
Thanks for sharing this - Vic has a great voice, especially on this song :)
Its a sad song. Poor Ed. "Beautiful mother, soft and sweet, once you were gone, we were not complete, back through the years we reached for you, a-last twus not ment to be." ~Vic singing
Vic has such a beautiful voice, and goes great with this song. I also like the japanese version with the child choir singing, but Funimation translated this song very well.
Those dislikes are all misclicks, because this is perhaps the most touching/chilling song ever, listening to it causes a mass of goosebumps to rise from my skin and I can't help but hum or sing along everytime I hear it...
It's just such a beautiful song and Vic only makes so much greater because of his amazing voice.
Oh my god ! It's actually Edward english voice actor !!!
That's even more amazing..! I'm ...speechless..
My favorite thing about him was that he had actually helped Edward and Alphonse with what they were doing
whenever i listen to this song, i think of my little brother who died in a car accident 4 yours ago, and how i miss him so much.
this song is beautiful and bring me to tears everytime.
I got to meet him this past weekend at Katsucon 16. He was awesome.He sung this and several others. It was amazing.
He looks like Hughes :)
Beautiful Song!
ikr
My brother, I was a fool. I love you, Al.
Vic is awesome, he is my favorite voice actor of anything i have ever seen
When I finished watching the movie and started reading FMA fanfiction I always listened to this song. It fits like a glove
All we saw full metal alchemist, know that this anime frame our lives and this song is perfect to summarize the story of the Elric brothers
He sang this live at his panel. It was amazing. I usually dont like things live but his voice was just beautiful.
it's such a touching song really i can't see how anyone can hate this song it's beautiful and Vic is AWESOME for doing a english translation of it ^_^
I heard him sing quite a lot of different songs now.. but this one just fits him best.. because you know.. his voice has this very soft side, but it's still very meaningful..
I know is by heart
i love this song so much theres so much energy. i can just imagine if fullmetal alchemist was a disney movie this would be like the lament song in every disney movie
quite possibly the best song ever, thank god for the replay button!
I literally cried.
I totally agree!! He's one of the VA"s I'm actually looking forward to seeing!
This song always brings tears to my eyes, but I see Edward every time I hear this so it makes it really and especially touching. =]
I love this song.
Vic has a beautiful voice.
I love his voice, he also gives the best hugs!
This song is so touching, I was almost in tears...
He actually just did it because he liked the song, and he sent it to some friends who put it on the internet; something he wasn't going to do in the first place because he knew he could get in trouble. I'm kind of happy his friends put it online though=)
You know are an amazing voice actor when you take the place of a goddess like Romi Paku and no one complains. This guy is a legendary anime voice actor and he isnt asian, respect.
i nearly cried ;~; he is so awesome :3
I love this song Vic sang this song at this year past MechaCon. I could tell just by the music notes in the air. I could recognize it right away form the Japaneses one quite easy.
Vic is so talented! And he's really sweet!
how could anyone dislike this? Its amazing! I'm almost crying which doesn't happen to often with me.
Omg I didn't know they made an English version of this!
This is awesome!
Vic Mignogna is awesome!
*sob sob sob* gosh I'm getting all choked up...wonderful series, beautiful song, made perfect by Vic...
when i first heard this song i cried simple has that VIc puts so much emotion in this song
He is my favorite voice actor
This is Vic voice Oh God he has an amazing voice
I actually cried. I'm talking ACTUAL tears. Poor Elrics. They may get their bodies back, one day, but the emotional scars will stay there forever.
OMG he doesn't only have a beautiful voice he also sings!!! this made my day :D :D :D
He has an amazing voice, and I agree this song is really sad, but he did an amazing job!
I love Vic Mignogna so much....
That's so awesome. It's great that some voice actors really care about their fans. ^^
I love this song. When I first heard it I cried! ;n;
wooo! I'm so happy I found this! His voice is awesome!
This song is sad...
My dog just passed away, so I've been listening to this song in Russian for the past hour or so. Mostly cause I'm Russian, and the language you grew up with just seems more powerful... especially with this track... I will miss my little puppydog... nobody to run out and meet me in the front yard anymore, waiting for me to pet him, with his ears down... wagging his tail... I'm gonna miss my doggy so much... :*(
I like it so much as well, and even after hearing the english version I am not disappointed with the lyrics.
wow he is good this is the firsat time i have ever heard him sing and damn he has a beutiful voice
omg i love his voice and it pretty much tells the whole story of them
Vic Mignogna is just...so awsome.
I love Vic's glasses, he looks HOT
This song makes me so sad. Damn Vic! That was amazing!
OMG Vic with glasses....*-*
He must be the handsomest and most talented grown up guy in the world!
He has such a beautiful voice..
Vic is the best voice actor ever -w-
Melted my heart
when i first heard this song i cried now i just love it and Vic
Favorite voice actor, sadness song of an anime
You have no idea how cool vic is!!!!!
Lol me too... i thought i would be over it by now... but now listening to it... I really want to cry
Oh my...his voice is so awesome!! =0
such a really nice song, I feel happy ^^
this is beautiful. an awesome song for an awesome anime.
I never understand how people can hate Vic's acting and voice. I can understand disagreeing with his stance on religious and...other issues, but as far as being a performer goes, he does great.
i met vic mignogna at his panel at fanexpo 2010 hes the nicest guy ever :D he took my breath away and signed my drawings of edward anybody who gets a chance go meet the dude
I start crying when I hear this. All I can think of is Ed. ;__;
And, of course, Vic's amazing singing voice.
He is such a great singer!!! Thanx 4 uploading!!!!! I luv you!^~^
Vic has such a beautiful voice :D
I'm in love with his voice :)
Brotherhood and Vic will equal awesome.
An angel just slapped me in the face with his voice. Im about to cry.. T-T
this song ...is soo...beautiful
omg he's really good at singing! this has mad me want to watch FMA now
Beautiful song! Beautiful voice!
This version should have been played at the ending credits of the FMA movie dub! Amazing for anyone who watched the show.
FMA, Best Show Ever Made!
Who the hell. Would dislike this? Gosh really it such a beautiful. Song
Aaaww I just love his voice *__* voice of an angel xP
Seriously, I felt in love with Ed's voice the very first time I heard it.
And he's (Vic) really, but really cute! (Though he's older than my parents...) He fits with his family name. In french, "Mignon" means "cute"...
And finally, yah, the song is so beautiful, meantful. Seriously, every time I'm listening this song, I just wish I could have a strong relationship with someone, such as the Elric Brothers... =/
Thats true. He mentioned it on his website that a fan sent him the english lyrics and asked him to sing them.
that's the part that makes me cry the most.
I saw him at an anime con. He's so awesome and nice and funny! He even dubbed yoda live.
Oh this just tears my heart out, but somehow in a good way
he has a nice voice and i love this song
:'(
i lost a friend 3 years back
i still miss him so much
:'(
shivers all over my body. beautiful.
this is my like 54th time ive watched this exact video and i love this song it makes me want to cry and .sob. oh jeez .sob hic sob. i love this song so much
I think it makes it is amazing is that it is basically Edward Elric that is singing this song; which is extremely appropriate.
i read somewhere that it was supposed to be a duet between the voice actors of Ed and Al, but Al's voice actor couldn't do it so it was just Ed's voice actor .... i love this song though, it always makes me sad and DEFINATELY portrays Ed and Al's relationship
When I listen to him.. I feel I'm listen to Edward.. best guy ever.. Edward Elric
This is Such a Beautiful Song xD
I love Full Metal Alchemist
Can't Wait to see Vic @ Ichibancon in Janurary
You just gave me a video idea! Thank you! :)
HE SINGS TOO!?!?
Mother of God...
He is an AMAZING voice actor, super funny, cute, and sings. FULL PACKAGE, BABY!
Vic Mignogna,
COMETOME!
Omg... So beautiful.