@@ricky_son_of_a_bish it's not pretty and it doesn't make sense plus using ai for more than half of an mv is so lazy and a way to spend less money which is why fans don't support it..don't even get me started on the powerpoint wipe presentations
just because Mashiro and Yeseo have more lines now doesn't mean that the other girls will always have less lines. think that Mashiro and Yeseo were in Kepler for two and a half years and always had few lines.
yes i was so sad when i listened to the song when it came out because i'm a huge fan of her and i love how she gave so good vibes to Limelight's songs with her voice, hope she gets more line for their comeback
And they've goned and smashed that opportunity with a terrible AI MV, then terrible camera work and sets as well as a terrible songs. Limelight had good songs so o don't get this...
i mean i am REALLY happy that mashiro is getting lines and not having to be last like in kep1er but damn i didn't expect their literal MAIN vocalist to be last
I see a lot of Limelight fans crying because Sohye didn't get most of the lines and it's understandable, but they just debuted under another name and they need to get attention, the strategy is to show Yeseo and Mashiro who come from Kepler. It's the debut strategy and maybe with a comeback WSO will change and distribute the lines better.
miu was not a finalist in gp999 she was one of the first contestants to get eliminated in gp999 aka got eliminated in episode 5 which was the first elimination episode
Its no one, its just a sped up vocal recording and its counted as an individual line because when there promoting lyrics say who is singing/lip syncing which line
@@bahihorse okay i can hear it now, but this is kinda like a magnetic distribution, like how BAE BAE BAE is just yunah but its counted as the member lip syncing it
yup. they didn’t use her tone at all! this goes for gaeun too imo but i think the new members should be showcased more i just don’t know their voices very well yet
I'm so glad they removed most of the AI in the video, it SUCKS there's still a bit but at least the company knows now how we feel about AI. That is, we hate it.
this song is such a BOP like its catchy, easy listening and memorable but the line distribution its too bad for me. i know this is their debut and first album but seeing the line distribution it's just dissapointed. like Suhye can at least having 1 chorus too, i knew 143 want to gain more attention with mashiro and yeseo but suhye deserve in chorus too. anyways stan MADEIN, cant wait for their comeback❤
it’s crazy how unfair it is but it plays directly into what netizens and kep1ians want. “i will support yeshiro forever, they slayed, did so well,…” but why do the other members have to suffer under this? Please remember most of the ot7 stans were limelight stans, and they got completely ignored. The company 143 clearly just cares about trying to go big and not the members, main vocal Suhye being left with 8 seconds and Gaeun barely with center time. They push for popularity and it really sucks to see. Wish there were more Madein ot7 stans who would pledge for fair treatment
i get the frustration but i think we should at least wait till 2nd comeback. If by then all 7 members, especially limelight members, are getting the same treatment then it will be worrying. But i think yeshiro are being pushed a lot for madein debut because they came from Kep1er who were bigger than limelight in the grand scheme of things. I think distribution was a little better in the bsides, let's hope next title track is more fair. I get some kep1ians were rude about the whole group thing but a lot of us have respect for the entire group, and mistreatment as a kap1ian is not something i want being played into. there was enough of that in kep1
Notice how the song is supposed to attract Kep1er fans? But the only few are here. This really magnifies how much of Kep1er fans really cared about the members.
The lines absolutely need to be evened out however as someone who kept up with Kep1er, Yeshiro have been getting the least amount of lines since the we fresh era. I feel like 143 is trying to do them justice and showcase the talent the wakeone was hiding. Hopefully other members talents won't be at expense in their future comebacks
giving mashiro and yeseo the spotlight would've been a good debut strategy but 143 had to completely screw up any chances madein had of being successful with that horrid excuse of a music video. the ai scenes were so unnecessary
Se esta desperdiciando la maravillosa voz de Suhye, espero que sea solo por el debut que quieren que resalten mas las Keplers pero no es lo correcto hundiarla asi.
I get that 143 is trying to bring as many kep1er fans as they can due to Yeshiro but man... the ex IZ*ONE girls who made it into IVE and Le sserafim didn't lead in their respective debuts
@@soyeonvsveggies oh? SSE and SouMu are not big companies - LSFM case could be arguable as SouMu was under Hybe at that time. And mind you, Liz, new to the public eye, got the most lines in IVE debut instead of Wonyoung or Yujin, ex-IZ*ONE members.
@@briancastillo6486 girl reread my comment. source is under hybe so yes it is a big company. and “starship isnt big”? theyre literally sistar and wjsn’s company, both which are fairly successful groups especially sistar
So quick to cry, they just debuted and barely have a discography yet. Did you expect every member to have the same amount of lines line a preschool teacher would do? Please.
Requested by Patreon Supporter: veeu, ClaireL, moowho
Support me/Make a Request: randomk.me
Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/random_k
THANK GOD u use the no ai version of the mv
What's wrong with the AI version? The AI scenes were great, very beautiful and unique.
I was worried at first
It’s a relief lol
@@ricky_son_of_a_bish it's not pretty and it doesn't make sense plus using ai for more than half of an mv is so lazy and a way to spend less money which is why fans don't support it..don't even get me started on the powerpoint wipe presentations
random k is an orbit, antibbc, antif*f* and now we know he’s antiai?!??!? IN RANDOM K WE TRUST!
@@xiaorina YESSSSSS
Suhye getting the Haseul treatment 😭
really right? why they waste the potential of crazy good vocalist?
But "eottokke" is iconic tho
@@Seungdragonseung TRUE IT IS
True! No wonder I thought she barely has any solo shots in the mv.
I hope this debut is just to bring back Kep1er's fans, and that afterwards the other members will be put forward
i hope so too because this was incredibly awful
i think that will be the case, they're probably just getting as much exposure they can using yeshiro for debut
Love the song dont like the line distribution
poor suhye man, she was limelights main vocal TT
No because whoever distributed lines for their debut album had a serious vendetta on her 😭. Homegirl is last in album distribution
Or ik its a foreign concept for you fans but maybe just maybe she didn't fit the song @@ancermet4754
shes still the main vocal in madein
yeah they don’t showcase her vocals AT ALL
They did her dirty
2:41 if this part was given to suhye the line distribution would be good enough
or even this one 2:21
@Charlienoseque that what I thought
1:06 or even this
just because Mashiro and Yeseo have more lines now doesn't mean that the other girls will always have less lines. think that Mashiro and Yeseo were in Kepler for two and a half years and always had few lines.
Suhye is Main Vocal in Limelight.
yes i was so sad when i listened to the song when it came out because i'm a huge fan of her and i love how she gave so good vibes to Limelight's songs with her voice, hope she gets more line for their comeback
It makes sense to give the two Kepler members the most lines. The group is just debuting and they need to gather as much attention as possible
And they've goned and smashed that opportunity with a terrible AI MV, then terrible camera work and sets as well as a terrible songs.
Limelight had good songs so o don't get this...
they tried to be starship with yujin and wonyoung but failed
but does it also make sense to give your main vocalist 2 lines in the whole song?
@@kipr4zno cus literally. i'm like so mad these girls deserve better
love this song,, I wonder if they'll balance out the lines for the next comeback after using yeseo & mashiro's kep1er hype
Suhye wish you will get more line future album
Thanks for using natural version mv.
This song is so weirdly addicting but also so weird
i mean i am REALLY happy that mashiro is getting lines and not having to be last like in kep1er but damn i didn't expect their literal MAIN vocalist to be last
Ngl this is one of the best 5th gen debut!
obsessed with this song
I see a lot of Limelight fans crying because Sohye didn't get most of the lines and it's understandable, but they just debuted under another name and they need to get attention, the strategy is to show Yeseo and Mashiro who come from Kepler. It's the debut strategy and maybe with a comeback WSO will change and distribute the lines better.
Keplian will always support Mashiro and Yeseo
and not the other mambers?
@@bloodredbl00m They will but talking about Mashiro and Yeseo cause they left
Yes Kep1ians Are Care About Maahiro And YESEO But Actually They Care Other Members Too
STAN MADEIN FRFR!
GP999 finalists top 3!
miu was eliminated in ep5
but she participated in gp999
miu was not a finalist in gp999 she was one of the first contestants to get eliminated in gp999 aka got eliminated in episode 5 which was the first elimination episode
Oh you decided to use in background the Natural MV and not the AI one
라임라잇때부터 선혜가 멱살캐리하듯 노래 보컬 퀄 올려줬는데 7인 재편하고 이렇게까지 수납하는 거 맞나 싶은
진짜 메이딘 데뷔는 하나부터 열까지 마음에 드는게 하나도 없다 이게 최선이였을까 진짜
I love yeshiro but I hope in future relases 143 isn't pushing them as much, it's not fair to the other girls and must be exhausting for them
Miu,Mashiro and Yeseo!🤍🩶🖤🤎💜🩵💙💚💛🧡🩷❤️❤️🩹❤️🔥❣️💟💕💞💓💗💖💝💘💌
i needed this bc half the time nagomi and mashiro sounds the same and serina and yeseo sounded really similar too 😅
yeshiro 🫶🫶
2:34 that part is Mashiro
Its no one, its just a sped up vocal recording and its counted as an individual line because when there promoting lyrics say who is singing/lip syncing which line
@@bahihorse okay i can hear it now, but this is kinda like a magnetic distribution, like how BAE BAE BAE is just yunah but its counted as the member lip syncing it
yea it’s mashiro not miu miu only lip syncs it
I love themmm
With this video, I noticed that Nagomi is the rapper of the group
suhye deserves more lines
Yeseo center position is confirmed finally 😍
the best vocalist having 8s is a joke
yup. they didn’t use her tone at all! this goes for gaeun too imo but i think the new members should be showcased more i just don’t know their voices very well yet
I'm so glad they removed most of the AI in the video, it SUCKS there's still a bit but at least the company knows now how we feel about AI. That is, we hate it.
Gaeun😢😢😢
1:56 she actually says Tres instead of Dos, just pointing that out
I love Nagomis voice sm. Yeseo and Suhyes too, I want to see just those two have a duet song together one day 💖
Vocês tem noção que a distribuição de linhas poderia ter sido bem melhor.
Nagomi is so cute
She’s like a baby Haseul
Maybe they gave Mashiro and Yeseo a lot of lines to bring more fans!
Espero y no les hagan un "Yujin-Wony" en IVE, las 7 merecen la misma repartición :((
Love you Madien ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
this song is such a BOP like its catchy, easy listening and memorable but the line distribution its too bad for me. i know this is their debut and first album but seeing the line distribution it's just dissapointed. like Suhye can at least having 1 chorus too, i knew 143 want to gain more attention with mashiro and yeseo but suhye deserve in chorus too. anyways stan MADEIN, cant wait for their comeback❤
The top3 was part my girls planet 999 line up
Nagomi ❤
it’s crazy how unfair it is but it plays directly into what netizens and kep1ians want. “i will support yeshiro forever, they slayed, did so well,…” but why do the other members have to suffer under this? Please remember most of the ot7 stans were limelight stans, and they got completely ignored. The company 143 clearly just cares about trying to go big and not the members, main vocal Suhye being left with 8 seconds and Gaeun barely with center time. They push for popularity and it really sucks to see. Wish there were more Madein ot7 stans who would pledge for fair treatment
pretty sure the company is just pushing the gp999 and pd101j contestants first for publicity then they might start promoting the other members too
i get the frustration but i think we should at least wait till 2nd comeback. If by then all 7 members, especially limelight members, are getting the same treatment then it will be worrying. But i think yeshiro are being pushed a lot for madein debut because they came from Kep1er who were bigger than limelight in the grand scheme of things. I think distribution was a little better in the bsides, let's hope next title track is more fair. I get some kep1ians were rude about the whole group thing but a lot of us have respect for the entire group, and mistreatment as a kap1ian is not something i want being played into. there was enough of that in kep1
@@angelsoobin true. i’m a kep1ian myself so i totally get that, i really hope everything gets better when they come back
@@bahihorse not gonna waste my time talking to someone with the user bahihorse, please get a life
could you please do "Starry Night" or "SOS" by FIFTY FIFTY? ❤
Kep1erから来たイェシロはセンター枠でパート多く貰ってる！
1番のサビとか全部イェシロやん(^^)
kep1erで、オールラウンダーだからこそパートが少なめだったマシロだったから、嬉しいー
でもメインボーカルはスヘちゃんのはずだから、イェシロを活かしつつ、スヘちゃんのハモリとかを入れたり、他のメンバーも目立てるようにしてほしいなー
今回もすごくいいんだけど
なごみのパート良すぎ！！
Gaeun😢
Lines likely distributed by: NiNE team
Notice how the song is supposed to attract Kep1er fans? But the only few are here. This really magnifies how much of Kep1er fans really cared about the members.
❤❤❤
Please dadarida madein
30 minutes ago ❤😊
2:33 is mashiro
La voz de Nagomi me recuerda a la de otra idol pero ahora no caigo
Omgg atee 🫶🫶🫶
The lines absolutely need to be evened out however as someone who kept up with Kep1er, Yeshiro have been getting the least amount of lines since the we fresh era. I feel like 143 is trying to do them justice and showcase the talent the wakeone was hiding. Hopefully other members talents won't be at expense in their future comebacks
Xodiac our days ,,,please
best vocalist 8 seconds 💀
Everglow + 1
i love this song so much ❤ yeshiro slayed
yeah they literally killed the others
SOS song line distribution please....❤😢
next "ATEEZ - Birthday" :))
Why don't you upload Fifty Fifty new released songs SoS-Gravity-StarryNight... I've been waiting so long from your channel....
Suhye having only 8 seconds MAKES NO SENSE
Yikes ! I was waiting for your video 🥰
Suhye tiene un gran vocal y solo le dan 8 segundos? Que es ese robo.
the likes were 666 😭😭
Sos of fiftyfifty pls
Did mashiro the center?
Boycott 143 ENT.!!
The lyrics make no sense and by watching the mv I can see that the lyrics were also made using AI because what is this?
BOYCOTT
😯😳💀
fifty fifty plisssss😢😢😢
Sadly it'll most likely not happen because of toxic boycotters
@@StudentABC123 "toxic"
@@angelsoobin Yes, toxic.
before yall comment about mashiro and yeseo getting “too much” just remember why madein is popular in the first place 😂
Ok why the hell the main vocalist have that less lines
Mashiro with many lines, I loved it! She was my Kepler Utt and didn't have many lines
fifty fifty sos please)
They don't take requests from RUclips
NOO SUHYE IS MAIN VOCAL 😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@WhatAreHumanRights666 She had a lot lines on Dopamine (the best song in Madein's debut album)
@@joshuhua Oh okkkk thx
@@joshuhua she didnt have a lot? she still had under 20 seconds
@@innerdances yep
giving mashiro and yeseo the spotlight would've been a good debut strategy but 143 had to completely screw up any chances madein had of being successful with that horrid excuse of a music video. the ai scenes were so unnecessary
Se esta desperdiciando la maravillosa voz de Suhye, espero que sea solo por el debut que quieren que resalten mas las Keplers pero no es lo correcto hundiarla asi.
The way that mashiro and yeseo got half of the circle line 😂 it literally Kep1er ft Madein
it’s yeshiro ft madein lol
wth is this distribution! (exaggerated). But srsly I hope this will only happen for the debut only
Nice promote,Agency really treat mashiro and yeseo
NOT MASHIRO GETTING LINES IN HERE
stop complaining
@@limjiho wdym
No way Yeseo and Mashiro left Kep1er to join this nugu group
Truu
People say this group was made for nothing 😒
usually nugu groups tend to give us real music so..
yes they did clown and they're happy
@auternionn_ what's nugu?
katseye Please
Suhye was the main vocal, why did they do this? Its so unfair😢
I might need to unstan 😬😬
Just deal with it stop complaining like a small kid will ya?
now they have 4 fans omg
Yeseo and Mashiro deserved better...
Honestly, all the girls deserved better. This song and comeback is a disgrace. To their names.
FLOPSEO & PIGSHIRO
What the fxxk is this line distribution? Main vocal got 8s is a joke. Say hi to early Haseul
I get that 143 is trying to bring as many kep1er fans as they can due to Yeshiro but man... the ex IZ*ONE girls who made it into IVE and Le sserafim didn't lead in their respective debuts
maybe thats because ive and le sserafim are from big companies so are basically guaranteed success while madein is not? use your brain
@@soyeonvsveggies oh? SSE and SouMu are not big companies - LSFM case could be arguable as SouMu was under Hybe at that time.
And mind you, Liz, new to the public eye, got the most lines in IVE debut instead of Wonyoung or Yujin, ex-IZ*ONE members.
@@briancastillo6486 girl reread my comment. source is under hybe so yes it is a big company. and “starship isnt big”? theyre literally sistar and wjsn’s company, both which are fairly successful groups especially sistar
Seriously... They ruined Mashiro, Yeseo's and all of these gilrs careers with this dumb song, Limelight had great songs bro what is this ☠️☠️☠️
The song is good, the problem is the MV.
As a former Mashiro-biased Kep1ian I'm so disappointed of this line distribution
Lmao
unbiasing mashiro because of a line distribution is crazy…
@@soyeonvsveggies Girl what no.. I didn't unbias her in Kep1er 😭 I said "former" because she literally left the group 🤦🏻♂️
@@LJPPKGGFS-C OH 😭😭 SORRY LMAO
So quick to cry, they just debuted and barely have a discography yet. Did you expect every member to have the same amount of lines line a preschool teacher would do? Please.
this debut is such a mess, i hope the comeback its better
Suhye after gets 8.0s : 🥲