Grant Morrison Vs. Alan Moore
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 июн 2013
- It's the battle to decide the fate of the universe. Grant Morrison and Alan Moore, arguably the two greatest comic book writers of all time, in a supremely epic battle of comic creators with vastly different amounts of hair on their heads.
Makeup artist: Kelsey Jancisin
Help us make these videos: / patrickhwillems
MY VIDEO GEAR tinyurl.com/z9kb5ow
TWITTER: / patrickhwillems
FACEBOOK: / patrickhwillems
TUMBLR: / patrickhwillems
INSTAGRAM: / patrickhwillems
FEATURING
Grant Morrison - Matt Torpey / matthewtorpey
Alan Moore - Mike Curran / mikel_curran
Scott Snyder - Jake Torpey / jrtorpey
______________________________________
SEND ME SOME MAIL:
Patrick Willems
P.O. Box 380333
Brooklyn, NY 11238 
Развлечения
Grant Morrison Vs. Alan Moore? The winner: Neil Gaiman.
I mean... You're not wrong
"Oh no Jim Lee!"
using Short Round from temple of doom was awesome
I almost died when Scott SNyder appeared D: Congrats my friend! It was awesome.
Yeah I lost it at that part too.
Scott's great. I read absolutely everything he writes. He's also a super nice guy.
Wish I could meet him. Love his work
More comic creator fights? Did you do Warren Ellis vs. Garth Ennis yet? They could both say "Everyone confuses you for me and I hate you for it!"
This is amazing and Scott Snyder at the end was perfect.
The sigil part had me in tears. X'D
Me too!!! That was the best!
If it wasn't for Covid 19, I would have never found this hidden gem
How about: Rob Liefeld vs Accurate Perspective?
Warren Ellis vs. Garth Ennis. There will (and should be) BLOOD!
Nice touch with the rings on Alan Moore. I always envisioned a bit of the old Dr Strange hand signs.
"They're *really* abrasive". lol
Nix Uotan already beat Mandrakk though.
you win with this comment
You’re so right, and that’s not even the only time Grant Morrison wrote himself vs Alan Moore into a comic book, he also did it with No-Beard vs All-Beard in Seven Soldiers:
tractorforklift.wordpress.com/2019/03/23/grant-morrison-writes-spoofs-about-alan-moore-and-says-nice-things/
Thanks! We've been really trying to raise the quality of the videos.
Also, that is an awesome idea. I'd love to make it happen.
My eternal respect. And a high-five if we ever meet in person.
Really Beautiful Video
0:48-0:51
This has to be the best use of the Kirby Krackle effect I've ever seen in a live action film, I really never thought it could be brought to life convincingly outside of the printed page or an animated cartoon.
Again great job.
This is bloody brilliant.
After reading the last issue of Death Metal, I think this is more relevant than ever.
Haha this is great! 😂 After going on a Alan Moore and Grant Morrison binge last week, so glad I saw this
Ha! As I was watching this I was thinking "It'd be cool if they'd do something with Scott Snyder in the end.." And you have, you beautiful bastards!
I love this video by the way, always puts a smile on my face.
This is hands-down brilliant.
Moore might win, but in an alternate reality Morrison wins...so DRAW
+marc80s In a multiverse story written by Grant Morrison.
Madhav Krishna Yes, a story Moore would claim is based off his own ideas and refuse to read.
Only to find out 20 years later, they'd both stolen it off Michael friggin' Moorcock. You couldn't make this shit up . . . .If you could, Moore would claim to have written it first, and that Morrison had built his whole career from clumsily plagarising his work. While on the other hand, vehemently claiming never to have actually read any of Morrison's stuff.
Choose your character:
1. Alan Moore the traditional occult wizard with Lovecraftian theme.
2. Grant Morrison the Chaos Magician with Sci-fi theme.
3. Neil Gaiman, a guy who loves mythology and folklore, especially North mythology.
You have to be a special kind of nerd to get these jokes. 👍
Everything about this was amazing.
Speechless. Just speechless.
This is quite possibly the greatest thing I've ever seen.
Space and time are Grant Morrison's play tings since he wrote Doctor Who's The World Shapers and Changes starring the Sixth Doctor and Culture Shock starring the Seventh Doctor
Alan Moore is more like a traditional occult, Lovecraftian wizard.
Grant Morrison is likely a Chaos Magician with the love of sci-fi genre.
Neil Gaiman is a guy who loves mythology and folklore, especially North mythology.
This is so fucking great!
this is just fucking awesome
that was Moore using his "channel zapping" from DC's Crisis rigth? hahah and Morrison using Kirby dots, this is great. congrats!
Thanks, Jimmy! I'm sure we could make up a feud between you and Justin Gray easily enough. Or do a NY comic creator gang war between the boroughs with you and Frank Tieri leading the Brooklyn gang. We've got some options.
The ending was amazing
Surely next is Neil 'Scary Trousers' Gaiman versus Todd MacFarlane? Hell, that'd be awesome.
This summarizes my exact feelings about Snyder. ;) Great work!
oh man I laugh really good. awesome video
Well... I like them both, but this is really funny, especially the voices.
Very cool!
Thanks, David! NYC comic creator underground fight club?
they need to just merge body and soul and be one super chaote comic writer
Their fusion would actually have a reasonable amount of hair
More!!!!
I was going to suggest Peter David vs. Mark Waid, but reality gave that one to us already.
We are the ultimate entertainers. We can read your mind to deliver what you want before you have time to ask for it.
Jack Kirby vs Bill Finger for recognition.
Genius, just genius !
Kirby would be great. Also, have you seen Steranko's twitter feed? You could do him vs Bob Kane, or the knife fight he had with gang members, or or or....
Great job! I suggest George Perez vs. Phil Jimenez or Gail Simone vs. Dave Sim.
This was better than the Dragonball movie
do millar vs miller
Superior Red the edgiest battle of shitlords
Or Millar vs. Morrison.
Or Millar vs Ennis.
Grant Morrison wins this fight!
It's kinda said that these two seem to hate each other so much (or at least Moore seems to hate Morrison).
They're both fantastic comics writers and helped breath new life into the medium.
I guess they both just have fundamentally divergent worldviews and sensibilities which makes them clash as people. Moore deconstructed superheroes (by his own admission) in an effort to destroy them, while Morrison deconstructs superheroes in order to reanimate them for a new era. For Morrison, heroes are a source of inspiration, while Moore can't see them as anything but immature power-fantasies of little boys.
Eoin O'Connor If you haven't, read 'Last Alan Moore interview'. Here's a quote:
" admirers of Grant Morrison’s work would please stop reading mine, as I don’t think it fair that my respect and affection for my own readership should be compromised in any way by people that I largely believe to be shallow and undiscriminating.”
They have a similar philosophy and view the written word as being powerful. They both view their work as magic. They are so fckn similar... except Morrison has only used rape once in a story (wonder woman earth one).
Voltairine - Your remarks are plainly false.
If you think Moore sees "superhoes as immature power-fantasies of little boys", you've clearly never read _Miracleman_ or _Supreme_ .
"I guess they both just have fundamentally divergent worldviews and sensibilities which makes them clash as people."
Also incorrect. Moore dislikes Morrison because of Morrison's decades of alternately idolizing and condemning Moore in print, both in his own writing and in interviews. He went on about Moore, voluminously, for years and years - dozens of times, out of a frustrated sense of seething professional and artistic envy, embittered that he was neither as successful, as talented, nor as famous as Moore and could only produce crude facsimiles of Moore's work . Meanwhile, Moore only discussed Morrison three times - and only when DIRECTLY asked.
The printed record - Morrison's own words - are unequivocally damning and prove once and for all that there was never anything resembling a "feud", only a third-rate chihuahua of a Moore impersonator named Grant Morrison snapping at Moore's heels.
Here is part six of a seven-part, assiduously researched examination of Morrison's obsession with Moore and provides point-by-point research for each of Morrison's (indefensible) claims. This is the final word on the matter. Morrison hasn't got a leg to stand on and is a hack with no artistic integrity (but then one need only read his work to know that).
tractorforklift.wordpress.com/2019/03/31/alan-moore-says-what-he-thinks-about-grant-morrison-and-morrison-issues-a-fierce-rebuttal/
They seem to be forgetting Alan moore's shit-your-pants-scary factor and the fact that he's a full head taller than most other people in the business.
I knew the battle was done the minute Alan Moore called upon the Kirby Krackle Punch.
Next battle: Stan Lee vs Steve Ditko.
Google that history. There;s a deep battle brewing there.
Neil gaiman just sitting in the corner eating popcorn
YES! Lee vs. Kirby! FIGHT!!
EXCELSIOR!!
Do a Scott Snyder/Rob Liefeld one. Based on their Twitter meltdown, obviously.
Billy Corgan vs Cat Stevens
Congrats on being the first person to point out the Kirby Krackle!
The sigil thing was comedic gold!
Absolutely. Moore may be successful, but he could never get his fanbase to have a synchronised w̶a̶n̶k̶-̶a̶-̶t̶h̶o̶n̶ sigil charging session to boost his sales.
what about capullo vs. lee? artist vs artist?
Frank miller better be in the sequel
slackjaw awesome! I could pretend to be angry at Jimmy if you need oldschool NYC flava, but we'll have to make up and get a slice at the end.
It's in the unrated director's cut.
Damn that was so long ago that Patrick has gone bald since and I even forgot that he had hair
I can assure you they both watched this
If Stan Lee vs Jack Kirby doesn't end with Stan eating Kirby's soul, I will disappointed
Fantastic. Next: Stan Lee Vs. Jack Kirby. The people want it!.
hahaha this is the perfect metaphor for who's the best writer debates. Although my two cents. Alan moore is the better metaphorically deep writer. While Morrison is the better adventure story writer, making stories flow in ways and making us think in differnt ways.Although to poke fun at moore he'd probably demand you remove his name from this video as it bastardizes his work. (Like if you get my joke)
Bendis vs Johns as Avengers vs Justice League.
A Marvel Bullpen version of Blackest Night or whatever the hell the DC Zombie-thing was?
Now all we need is Alan Moore vs Neil Gaiman.
You can't realistically beat Gaiman on any kind of Theological level or magical duel, because he's a Scientologist, and therefore too top tier to get involved on anything other than a legal level. And his writing style, although very different to my Khaos bois, is every bit as good. In fact, you could argue that its better, because his creative characters and Worlds now have their own Universe. I know GM restructured the DC Multiverse, but he didn't create the component parts of it himself.
@ Morrison is not near Gaiman's level, I agree.
@ I feel Gaiman can dabble with same Grand concepts that Morrison does and he has done so frequently, but what sets him and Moore apart from Morrison is that, more often than not, Morrison variably fumbles in his execution. His script is not as tight as either, his writing flow is not as smooth and clean, this, sometimes, makes his work feel jarring which is really the only criticism he gets since he always has great ideas for stories. I agree that a literary work should be demanding to make most out of it but I feel that with Morrison, half of that is because of his subpar transitions from panel to panel and occasionally, dialogues which feel out of context. Also, I don't think flawed, dysfunctional characters are exclusive to Morrison, Sandman is as much about it's human characters as it is about mythological figures.
@@alphonseelric5722 I have noticed this with Morrison. He'll take on a huge project, like "Invisibles" and although it's brilliant, there are certainly some flat bits. And although he writes some stunning stuff, he seems to have trouble when it comes to wrapping it up. Compare "Invisibles" with Warren Ellis's "Transmetropolitan". Both comparable in length, both stand-alones, and completely original, but Transmetropolitan is tight. It has a well defined pace right from the get go.It's got a proper middle, a proper ending. And Warren Ellis never asked me to participate in a synchronised masturbatathon so that his sales would pick up.
Next round...Terry Prachett VS Robert Jordan
A key component of sigil magic is missing from this video
Moore should be fighting with his LEFT hand only.
Art Spiegelmann(Maus) vs David Small (Stiches).
Let's see ... Gaiman against Ellis?
I would love to see Stan Lee vs Jack Kirby
We made it. It's called "Stan Lee's Final Battle."
Oh please this!!! xD
As much as I love American Vampire and Severed (as well as his pre-N52 Detective Comics) I think Snyder is not as great as Moore and Morrison as some people claim. Maybe by the time...
Warren Ellis vs Garth Ennis!
HELLL YEAHHHH !!! ..... And look at that Superman shirt, am on Morrison's side.
Alan Moore would start banging on for twenty minutes about . . . . God only knows what, like a slow motion angry Badger. Before stating that he's never watched it, and never intends to watch it. Grant Morrison would find a fourth wall, and subvert everyone's expectations by not breaking it.
Brian Michael Bendis vs. Jeph Loeb. Kick his ass BMB!! lol
Stan Lee vs Bob Kane plz!!!
No-Beard Voldemort vs. All-Beard Dumbledore
very good, what about a figth with Neil Gaiman and Todd Mcfarland
Do Geoff johns v Brian Michael bendis
Lao Che Air Freight. Nobody's flying the plane
Yeah, the thought briefly crossed my mind, but I'm pretty sure no one would want to see that.
Chris Claremont VS Walt Simonson
Wait, that's not Danimal Cannon!
Scott Snyder vs Geoff Johns
I want to see Tom King vs Brian Michael Bendis lol
battle of who can ignore continuity more
The Beard vs. The Bald.
this is pure genius and i’m sad i just discovered this now
Stan Lee vs Steve Ditko!
This is about right....
To be honest it's Grant I'm mad at; just sayin'
He only went and only entered me into a majick contest without informing me first. Whuuuuut?
I won and didn't even realize I was in the blasted thing.
I made a whole new system of majick to boot; didn't even realize ( as I didn't know I was entered in the damn thing) that I had completed one of the main priorities. Woaaaaah. Miiiind Blown.
So Alan; ummm; what do you make of the whole Majick competition farce (stealing your system of electric majick no less). A total disgrace I am guessing. Anyways; this is why I, the Illustrious Joopmeister III General Excepionallo; a long with Thomas Sheridan and Alan Moore kicked SET AKA Mozza, out of the 3 (then 4) wise Magi.
1:43 Now Grant you know he's a better one :)
Todd McFarlane vs Rob Liefeld!
Jajaa