I am currently extremely curious with aespa's standard right now becuz even koeun who trained since 2012 can't even make it for the debut line?! And even yiyang and lami who are one of the most recognised visuals can't even make it either?? This is very interesting
same here. i can't wait to see them perform because i've been rooting for the rookie girls way way back and been waiting for them to debut. especially lami, she's like top visual material for me. oh well.
Maybe because they want to make a group like nct, it's will focus on dance so maybe that's why. And they will focus on US market i think, because their visual tell all.
Yiyang chose to leave SM by herself. As for Koeun and Lami... they didn’t make one of the early cuts for the aespa lineup :( I think they left SM last year
@@SMAnthonyW I think the otherwise. It is said that Aespa's debut was confirmed just 6 months ago but Lami and Koeun left almost a year ago so maybe the got tired of waiting while Hina is cut out from the group because her and Giselle is fighting for that Japanese title. Obviously Giselle won because she'll "complete" the group more. They need a rapper while Hina and Karina will be both main dancer, plus the fact that Giselle can speak English that would help them enter Western Market.
What is sm rookie? Sm trainee that make this sort of generation group but not debuted yet?? I'm interested in this bcs of the shining school anime thing ( idk if it's anime since it's Korean ) but it's really interesting and it's soo smart to make those animation for advertising purposes , I kind of like kpop ( song ) now, used to hate them a lot.
SMROOKIES are SM trainees who are revealed by SM entertainment. The main reason is for them to gain popularity for their future group. They are very likely to debut in the future (unless they leave the company). Just like Red Velvet and NCT, most of the members were SMROOKIES.
Although, sm failed to utilize the smrookies system right after they debuted red velvet and nct. They only used it when they need to reveal new nct members again :(((
@@wenjaellay8609 i think sm became cautious about revealing their trainees in public since they kinda learned that not everyone will end up debuting anyway....... :'
they haven't debuted yet, but they've been revealed for varying amounts of time... lami - december 2013 koeun, hina - july 2015 jungyeon - december 2015 ningning - september 2016 and the former rookies herin - july 2015 yiyang - september 2016 yeri (graduated, in red velvet), jeesu, winny - august 2014
i dont know but im pretty sure, the person who singing this song are ningning, yiyang and jungyeon. without koeun/hina the voice from beginning of the song : 0:02 yiyang 0:12 jungyeon 0:20 ningning 0:30 yiyang 0:42 jungyeon 0:51 yiyang 01:19 jungyeon 01:28 jungyeon + ningning and the rest of adlibs at the end is ningning.
NINGNING DEBUT NOW😭
I hope that they debut this year or at least 2020.
John Patrick Juan Same
27th June 2020 ;(
They've already confirmed it, I think they'll make their debut this month or probably the other month.
Only ningning
she did, ningning i mean.
Almost all of the songs sang by the Idols of Shining Star are from SM Rookies! Can't wait for them to debut!
Ning ning ate that up
i love jungyeons voice so much u__u also i'm pretty sure that 0:39 through 0:48 is jungyeon with hina echo
Hina and Ningning 😍😍
Lami looks like Eugene from ses
I am currently extremely curious with aespa's standard right now becuz even koeun who trained since 2012 can't even make it for the debut line?! And even yiyang and lami who are one of the most recognised visuals can't even make it either?? This is very interesting
same here. i can't wait to see them perform because i've been rooting for the rookie girls way way back and been waiting for them to debut. especially lami, she's like top visual material for me. oh well.
Maybe because they want to make a group like nct, it's will focus on dance so maybe that's why. And they will focus on US market i think, because their visual tell all.
@@ciyoritana1740 oh I thot they are focusing on the asia market since 2 of its members are from china and japan
Yiyang chose to leave SM by herself. As for Koeun and Lami... they didn’t make one of the early cuts for the aespa lineup :( I think they left SM last year
@@SMAnthonyW I think the otherwise. It is said that Aespa's debut was confirmed just 6 months ago but Lami and Koeun left almost a year ago so maybe the got tired of waiting while Hina is cut out from the group because her and Giselle is fighting for that Japanese title. Obviously Giselle won because she'll "complete" the group more. They need a rapper while Hina and Karina will be both main dancer, plus the fact that Giselle can speak English that would help them enter Western Market.
NINGNING DEBUT IN AESPA
I miss these girls 😢😭😭😔
Ning Ning :) Hearing she was in SM Rookies, Thought maybe she trained with Yeri but no she was SR15G while Ning Ning was SR19G.
ningning was sr16g. and sadly no yeri debuted before ningning joined sm in early 2016 :')
jungyeon has such a cute voice
Hina gonna be my bias
Jungyeon❤
they're amazing i miss herin and i'm emo T_T
I hate sm for not debuting smrookies ..
i was waiting for hina in aespa T^T
:(
What is sm rookie? Sm trainee that make this sort of generation group but not debuted yet?? I'm interested in this bcs of the shining school anime thing ( idk if it's anime since it's Korean ) but it's really interesting and it's soo smart to make those animation for advertising purposes , I kind of like kpop ( song ) now, used to hate them a lot.
SMROOKIES are SM trainees who are revealed by SM entertainment. The main reason is for them to gain popularity for their future group. They are very likely to debut in the future (unless they leave the company). Just like Red Velvet and NCT, most of the members were SMROOKIES.
Me too
I used to hate kpop
Although, sm failed to utilize the smrookies system right after they debuted red velvet and nct. They only used it when they need to reveal new nct members again :(((
@@wenjaellay8609 i think sm became cautious about revealing their trainees in public since they kinda learned that not everyone will end up debuting anyway....... :'
Koeun sounds like Yoona omg lol
I think she more look like Taeyeon
Wait... it is official???
They are part of Smrookies??
I need to know their ages!!
jungyeon - 1997
Koeun - 1999
Hina - 2000
Ningning - 2003
Lami - 2003
@@stephaniemortel383 Ningnig is from 2003?!?!?!? Other sites say that shes from 2002 :O
my fault it was a typo
@@stephaniemortel383 ah ok, THANK YOU!!!
Welcomee😊
if you may know how many years they debuted... ?
they’re trainees. they haven’t debuted yet
they haven't debuted yet, but they've been revealed for varying amounts of time...
lami - december 2013
koeun, hina - july 2015
jungyeon - december 2015
ningning - september 2016
and the former rookies
herin - july 2015
yiyang - september 2016
yeri (graduated, in red velvet), jeesu, winny - august 2014
@@user-nd5lg2rj2j irene was also a rookie, but you know she already in red velvet
` yes, same for seulgi & wendy! but they were the first generation to graduate/debut, followed by yeri and then nct
thankyou... 💕💕
I think they are SR18G??
BM ENTERTAINMENT it's 2019 so it's sr19g
@BM ENTERTAINMENT SR18G stands for Sm Rookie 2018 Girls so it changes every year ^^
When will they debut?? There is no more heri and one other girl us her name is ying ying idk i dont remember
Maybe yixing?
Oh yiyang!
@@patriciametta3819 Yixing is in EXO 😂😂😂
Sm rookies girls suppose to be nct female version
lami didn't sing?
Yes, she doesn't have a line in this song only the vocal line (jungyeon, kowun, hina, ningning) participated in singing ost
i dont know but im pretty sure, the person who singing this song are ningning, yiyang and jungyeon. without koeun/hina
the voice from beginning of the song :
0:02 yiyang
0:12 jungyeon
0:20 ningning
0:30 yiyang
0:42 jungyeon
0:51 yiyang
01:19 jungyeon
01:28 jungyeon + ningning
and the rest of adlibs at the end is ningning.
ncity’s countries nope koeun and hina are clearly in this song cause shining star even give them credit
No. This color coded actually true. Try to listen to another song. In the first is jungyeon voice and there are hina and koeun sing this song too
lami doesnt sing?
Why Lalai are not singing?
Mengapa Lalai tidak bernyanyi?
ruclips.net/video/cSf8kd3O5Uw/видео.html teve uma conta que repostou seu vídeo
SM wasted them :((
Ningning will debut
Where lami part??
she doesn't have a line in this song only the vocal line (jungyeon, kowun, hina, ningning) participated in singing ost
@@kominingna what is lami position??
@@cnc3543 maybe i think she will be a rapper or maybe dancer it's just my opinion. But not sure
Crazy Rozz she was supposed to be the visual and Center but she left along with Koeun sadly